-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH: quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:Why should I care about some dead Americans when Americans are incapable of caring about the living if they live outside America. Well by your definition I guess that would make you an American then. BTW - answers to such questions are often not so simple. First of all prove to me that your contention is true - that "Americans" care not for lives outside of America. In some ways I could esily argue the opposite - as compared to say...Scotland - I mean really now - what have the Scotts ever done for anyone...etc...and is that all Americans or just some? Please don't generalize and base your (resentful) views concern myself and others here only based on the record of US politicians, Hollywood or whatever other mass market/tabloid version of America(ns) you are consuming...What definition? I was asking a question - a question you did not answer. Might I add that it is a good thing for America that most of what the world sees about America is based on Hollywood's propaganda version. If the world knew the truth about the average American's views they would be sick. The only good thing to come out of "9/11" is that the world is now beginning to know the truth about America. And maybe even Americans are at last starting to know the truth about America. On a lighter note: have a listen to this :-) http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/comedy/rams/nowshow.ram Skip forward 24 minutes to the song about Bush and his daddy.
-
Why should I care about some dead Americans when Americans are incapable of caring about the living if they live outside America.
-
Decline of the American empire - hasn't Gore Vidal been saying this for decades! And isn't it ironic that some of Bush junior's speeches (such as the "you are either with us or against us" crap) are almost verbatim clips of things Vidal wrote in the screenplay for "Ben Hur". But Vidal isn't that bright - I was making the historical comparison between the destruction of the World Trade Center and the burning of the Reichstag in 1933 while the towers were still burning. 12 months later it should be clear to everyone that Bush IS another Hitler, and Blair is his little poodle Mussolini."The end of liberty" by Gore Vidal
-
quote:Originally posted by Azat:I am getting sick and tired of seeing everything revolve in the Press and TV and Radio around 9/11. Every paper you pick up this past week, every TV program and all I hear on NPR is 9/11 this and 9/11 that and the families who are suffering and all that crap. If you, as an American, are getting sick of it then think how sick of it the rest of the world must be!! And then there are all the movies in the pipeline.
-
quote:Originally posted by Sip:Actually, I agree. Both the first and last name are Persian. Mehrtash doesn't sound very Persian. "Tash" is Turkish for stone, and "Mehr" is Meher. Maybe he is Kurdish if not Armenian.
-
quote:Originally posted by Alla:IN my Art History class we're covering the Renaissance period through the Moder times. Armenian art or architecture isn't even mentioned in the text book, since it's we mostly cover the western european art. Well there wouldn't be, would there - there was no such thing as "Armenian Renaissance architecture"! During the Renaissance period little was being built in Armenia - and none of it was to do with Europe. Please please don't believe that "Haykakan Renessanci Tchartarapetutyun" book by Hrayr Isabekyan - there is NO CONNECTION BETWEEN ARMENIAN MEDIEVAL ARCHITECTURE AND EUROPEAN GOTHIC OR RENAISSANCE ARCHITECTURE. Steve
-
and for more than just worthy, try VirtualANI ! cilicia.com also has a lot of stuff on architecture. There are a large amount of architecture photos on this site, mostly uncatalogued though. http://www.virtualarmenia.am/
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi:What is the African American view on this? Do they need to have views? I thought they had "educators" and "activists" and "community leaders" that did away with the need for them to have views on anything. Although that "Oakland Resoluton on Ebonics" is the funniest thing I've read for some time, it is probably too serious a matter to dismiss as "only in America". The fascistic undertones in it are all to obvious: you are what we say you are and not what you want to be. How else can you account for concepts like "these studies have also demonstrated that African Language Systems are genetically-based". No language is genetically based!! Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:steve, 1. there are turkish stereotypes, o.k., but many strereotypes that you refer to, especially the "laz" stuff, are used by the laz themselves. we have an entire literature of laz jokes, just as there are frisian jokes in germany, breton jokes in france etc. i have a ton of karadenizli friends, quite a few of them laz, (all karadeniz is usually referred as laz whereas the real laz are concentrated in a few places) and i know most of my laz jokes from them. Thanks Ali. All I wanted was for you to admit that there WERE racial stereotypes in Turkey, since you initialy had said there were not. quote:2. the turkish word for negro is zenci. but here, i have never heard zenci used in a derogatory context.I never said it was - after all, "negro" is not a derogatory word. quote:i had heard one or two times "arap" used in that context, but that's about it.What I was trying to say was that "Arap" used in that context has the same meaning as "nigger" in English, because Turks thought of Arabs in the same way as Europeans thought of black Africans. quote:3. i take your word for your experience wit the mhp guys over there re the use of the word "armenian". i have heard precisely the same from an american racist guy when i was a student at oxford, who used the term "arabs" and "iranians" in precisely the same fashion. am i to deduce from that that "arab" and "iranian" are swearwords in american english?Those MHP guys were not conciously using "Armenian" as a racist term! I'll try to explain - I'm trying to think of a similar usage - let's say it is like thinking "well, everyone from Crete is stupid, so lets call anyone who is stupid a cretin". (That is not a true analogy because the word "cretin" has a different origin - but I hope you get my point! Maybe Lesbos/lesbian is a better example). So, they were calling the PKK "Armenians" because Turkish state propaganda said the PKK were just a bunch of traitorous murderers who deserved nothing but death, and the section of Turkish society which these MHP guys belonged to believed all Armenians to have been just a bunch of traitorous murderers who deserved nothing but death. So for them to call the PKK "Armenians" was (given their beliefs) a natural and logical link to make. I doubt whether in making it they even considered that there was a real county called Armenia, filled with real Armenians. Actually, of the 3 persons I heard using "Armenian" in this way, only two were MHP people: a Turkish taxi driver in Erzurum and a Turkish store keeper in Erzincan. The third person was a Kurdish man working in a carpet shop in Erzurum. quote:besides as a turk i would not agree that the mhp can be representative of my nation in any way. would you like the national front guys taken to be repesentatives of britain?Correct me if I'm wrong, Ali, but I don't think a member of the national front is deputy Prime Minister of Britain! The leader of the MHP is deputy Prime Minister of Turkey. If that is not representing Turkey then what is it? quote:besides, that story about the pkk that i told you about is true.Yes, I remember reading similar stories a few years ago - but I bet they originated as black propaganda produced by the Turkish state, similar to that well-known photo purporting to be an Armenian priest talking to PKK leaders. quote:4. "kırk arabın aklı bir incir çekirdeğini doldurmaz" i had first heard this in its entirety guess where: at oxford from my tutor! it is true that as a nation if we are racist about anyone, these are the arabs (i am not sure that here the word was used to mean "black" rather than "arab"). cheers,[/QB] I got it from a book of Turkish proverbs!
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza:what i'd like to know is...who are those two strange silhuete figures in the second picture? One sitiing and the other waving his hands over him Can't tell - it's way too blurry. But it's probably meant to be an inhabitant pointing out the city to a traveller.
-
quote:Originally posted by MosJan:it's St-Hripsime - St Echmiyatsin - St Gayane Sam way that are in city of Echmiyatis I know that! I was asking what is the place depicted in the other engraving!!
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:The bottom engraving shows Etchmiadzin, but where is the walled city on top of the mountain, shown on the middle engraving? Vanaberd.Vanaberd as in Van city and citadel? I thought it might be!! It looks nothing like Van, but it does look a little like some other engravings of Van that also look nothing like Van.
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa:You're right he is buying for a "museum". The buyer is Aram Arkun, director of the Krikor and Clara Zohrab Center of the diocese. Here is his e-address in case you want to call him and call him... arkun@uscom.com Thought so! He buys ANYTHING Armenian related, (browsing his feedback items is rather interesting, seems he needed a lot of lightbulbs as well, and did you know an Armenian ran for President in the 1960s - he has bought a campaign badge to prove it).
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:steve, go learn some turkish before you say something like that, especially to a native turkish speaker who has been trained as a historian of the turkish language! now your points: human sterotypes are the basis of much humour. after all, humour is cruel and uses sterotypes everywhere. However, British humour is mostly based on an ordinary person running into amusing situations. In Turkey it is an amusing (as a result of his/her stereotypical atitudes) person interacting with normal situations. I'm not saying one is better (or funnier!) than the other - merely pointing out that your statement that there are no stereotypes in Turkey is wrong. The racial origin of those stereotypes may not be openly stated (since everyone in Turkey is officially a "Turk") but everyone knows they are meant to be Kurds, or Laz, or Georgian, etc. quote:in turkish humuor, though, we don't have that sort of thing except the trash the the government pushes and even that is not at all taken on by the turks. there is a ton of anti-greek, anti-armenian and anti this and that literature, but a lot of it is state sponsored/financed, instigated etc., because turks left on their own just don't have the cultural baggage to produce that kind of stuff. besides, the public doesn't approve of it, and several journaliss were publicly criticised for that sort of thing in their own newspapers and were made to apologise (bedri koraman was one, for instance). I was referring to privately produced stuff, comic stips in newspapers, etc, and especially Turkish home-produced films from the 70s and 80s. Which reminds me, just a few weeks ago I was watching a Turkish music video in which the singer (sorry - I can't remember his name but he is very popular in Turkey) is dressed up as a caracature of a Byzantine emperor (complete with cross shaped jewelery made of sausages, etc, and containing many caracatures of Christian imagery that could be considered very insulting). I hope he was just sending up those amateurish Turkish films (there was a scene on some battlements when a jet fighter incongruously flew past). quote: the pkk supporters were called "armenian" not beacuse the term has abusive connotations in itself (but i get your point, to call the muslim kurds who had fought/killed armenians just nne decades ago armenians might offend them), but there were bodies of pkk members retrieved from the battlefield who had not been circumscised. as there are quite a few villages in the east who are turkish/kurdish on the surface now but are armenian in origin (and as the surrounding population knows all about it) and still speak armenian in private (and are widely believed to practice christianity), there may well be a very big grain of truth in some of it. plus do not forget that the pkk carried out joint operations against turkey with asala and other armenian groups outside turkey (and neither side denied it), and were on several occasions reported to have carried out such operations in eastern turkey (the authenticity of this i do not know, but it is of course possible). so there may very well be a grain of truth in calling at least some of these guys "armenians". i myself have seen quite a few kurdish - and turkish - pkk symphatisers who, when the conversation deepened and mutual trust established, confessed that their grandmother/grandfather was armenian. armenian grandparents are quite common in that part of turkey.You are ignorant of the truth here, maybe because you have not witnessed it at first hand. On several occasions (twice in Erzurum and once in Erzincan) I have come across Turkish fascists (they were MHP supporters who were happy to be called fascists, by the way) who refered to the PKK as Armenians for precisely the reason that I described. They were not (and they clearly explained that to me when I questioned their use of the word) refering to a real Armenian identity. The PKK are "Armenians" because they ACT like Armenians: Armenians (in MHP propaganda) killed defenseless women and children for no reason, lied all the time, were traitors to Turkey, and got what they deserved. quote:regarding the "arap" business: first of all, we call blacks arabs because we are a profoundly uneducated lot: your average turk cannot really tell the difference between an arab and an african, to him they are all darker even than us, they have a vague notion that there are also persians who are not arabs (to know that persians and arabs are not the same was a mark of education in my youth), and we do have as a nation the sort of prejudices that every imperial nation has: there was an irishman, a scotsman, a welshman, and an englishman type of thing. Again, this is simply not true - I cannot understand why you are denying that to call someone an Arab in Turkey can be intended as an insult and is the equivalent of "nigger". It may not be in general usage now (neither is "nigger", after all) but it was used in the recent past in that way. Didn't you say you liven in Antakya for a while - you must have seen there the racism some Turks display against Arabs. The Turkish word for negro is Zenci. quote:the term "arap" is never used in a derogatory context, in fact we had a very popular singer esmeray who recently passed away who was the masses' beloved "arap bacı". Would that be like "Kirk Arabın aklı bir incir çekirdeğini doldurmaz". quote:we have many things wrong with our nation, but racism european-style is not one of them, i am afraid. cheers, Hmm ....I have obviously touched a sensitive subject here!
-
The bottom engraving shows Etchmiadzin, but where is the walled city on top of the mountain, shown on the middle engraving? http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI...item=1545704934 PS: the book was worth a lot more than 50 dollars. But it is pointless bidding against that particular person, you always loose. To judge from the huge quantity and value of things he buys I think he is buying on behalf of a museum and has no spending limit. Such people should be banned from ebay because they are bad for both buyers and sellers.
-
quote:Originally posted by Rubo:March 12- By Chekhengel’s orders, Kars is given to the Turks. Policies of Transcaucasian Federation's government resulted in loss of Kars. The chairman of Transcaucasian Federative Democratic Republic's government Mr. Chkhenkeli ordered Lieutenant-General Nazarbekov, commander of the Armenian corps, hand over the city to the Turks without fight for all that the general himself was categorically against that decision as his armies had a real opportunity to repel Turks' attack and to keep Kars fortress area for more than a month. The objections of the commander of the corps were rejected, and the city and the fortress of Kars that had all resources to stand against the enemy at least for a month was given up with almost no resistance. MJ I do question your loyality! But the real damage was perhaps the example that the loss of Kars showed to Armenia's allies - it indicated to them that Armenia seemed unwilling or incapable of defending itself even when it had enough soldiers, supplies, and arms to do so (which it had in the case of Kars). Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by gamavor:I see nothing wrong of recapturing of all historical lands of Armenia and expulsion of the aggressors back to their native Mongolia. Ho hum, very amusing! Gamavor, if you believe that then you have the balls of a lion, body of a shrew, and brain of a lemming!
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear steve, 1. i think i will need to draw you a list of references you can consult re this issue. i do not mean to sound slighting or anything, but to say that russians were not involved in such conspiracies betrays a very serious lack of factual knowledge, i am sorry. Dear Ali Better than giving references would be to give some facts - although I have not followed my advice because the book I cited is difficult to summarise or take extracts from. It is still the definitive account of the actions (and strategies behind those actions) of all the battles between Russia and Turkey in the Caucasus, and the authors had full access to both Russian and Turkish archives. quote:(the russians did have a policy of russification, now you are not going to deny me that), Yep, I have to, until you define what you mean by "Russification"! Russia merely insisting that Armenia stayed within the empire's borders, and follow that empire's laws, is not really sufficiant to justify such a term. quote:3. that russians have traditionally been keen on descending to the mediterranean ever since the time of the normans is basic history: they needed to descend to the warmer mediterranean to be able to conduct maritime traffic throughout the year and be closer to the southern belly of europe (and the middle east and africa). this is such a basic "given" of international politics that i shall not elaborate it further. Again you do not understand things - the great fear European countries had was that the russian empire (along with the American "empire") was different from their empires in that it was a continuous land mass. So they developed a policy of containment and an obsession about Russia finding "roads" to India or Syria or somewhere else. I have read no evidence that these obsessions were reflected in the reality of a real Russian threat - a fact recognised by some at the time. "I cannot help thinking that a great deal of misapprehension arises from the popular use of small scale maps. As with such maps you are able to put a thumb on India and a finger on Russia, some persons at once think that the political situation is alarming and that India must be looked to. If they would use a larger map they would find that the distance between Russia and British India is not measured by the finger and thumb, but by a rule". Lord Salisbury, June 1877. quote:4. the russians did have eyes on the eastern front, Eyes yes, but little else. Throughout WW1 that front was a side-issue for Russia, always under supplied and short of troops. This was because Russia believed that, however extensive any victories there were, the final outcome of the war would be decided elsewhere. In fact, Turkey was seen as a side issue by all the main combatants except Turkey. quote:and in fact, kars changed hands between turkey and russia, on more than one occasion if i remember correctly. in the 20th century, No it didn't, Turkey captured it twice from the Armenian republic. (Maybe "captured" is the wrong word since Kars was handed over to Turkey almost without a fight). quote:stalin formally demanded kars and ardahan and a few other western provinces from turkey.This was restricted to Kars and Ardahan only, and based on those areas being part of Russia before 1917. The demand at the time was real (Turkish populations on the other side of the border were deported), but was probably mostly given for bargaining purposes against European territory and was quickly dropped. quote:part of this was also oil: the oil wells that russians had dug in the two years (1915-1917) in northeastern turkey are still there (and some did yield some oil).Oil!! Where??? quote:there were persistent formal and "informal" demands several times by russian ambassadors (including sazanoff) to grant free passage to russian ships, including warships, and to allow the russians establish military bases on and south of the dardanelles "to protect the ottoman empire against the british" that were politely but firmly refused by the porte (or rather the cup). Free-passage of all ships was guaranteed by Turkey as a result of the post WW1 Dardanelles treaty, and re-ratified by Turkey many times (until the 1950s I think) - so allowing access to Russian ships would not really have caused harm to Turkey. But this is just Russia trying to get around that "confinement" policy I mentioned earlier. quote:(mind you, by the way, cyprus was originally "borrowed" by the british ostensibly to "protect" the ottoman empire and the eastern mediterranean against any southward russian expansion).In return for forcing Russia in the Treaty of Berlin to give back almost everything she captured in the 1870s war against Turkey! (Plus the wiping out of several large and outstanding loans to Britain, I think). quote:5. as someone who has actually done his military service in central anatolia, i know from first hand experience that once you get eastern anatolia, it is a piece of cake to get the rest. This is not true - if you HAVE travelled through eastern Turkey than you must have had your eyes closed. I have been along every road, and over every pass in eastern Turkey (in most cases many times) and I know the geography of the region better than almost anyone. Eastern Turkey was virtually inaccesible from central Turkey until the building of the Sivas-Erzincan railway in the 1930s. quote:besides this is what we had done after all, isn't it? i am afraid you have to consult a military map/expert here, steve. You mean "done" as in crossing Anatolia? But there is a big difference between transporting a horde of horsemen from the 1070s and a mechanised 1914 army. If the Greeks had possesed just one machine gun at Manzikert they could have wiped out the whole Selcuk army! And I've seen far more pre-1920 maps than you Ali, they are still all banned in Turkey! quote:6. turkey did not keep territories on grounds of practical uses. otherwise we would never have gone to the yemen. That was my point, that Erzurum and Van was being kept for political reasons, not practical military or economic ones. quote:re uses: what use is the rock of gibraltar or the falklands or northern ireland, and why is britain still holding on to them, and going to war if he authority there is challenged? Ali, these places are still part of Britain because the people there want to remain British citizens. And on the subject of Ireland - it might be interesting for you to compare the way the British empire resolved its "Irish Question" and the Turkish empire resolved its "Armenian Question". quote:7. "... because there was no-one to give it away to" oh c'mon steve, even you guys stationed military experts and units there. really... What are you talking about here? quote:8. i symphatise with the armenians' wish that they merely wanted better security and rights (and i do not shrink from admitting that their plight, especially in the hands of the kurds, was little short of appalling) but the thing with human nature is that human desires are endless: the armenians constantly painted a picture (in turkish eyes at least) that the more they would get, the more they would want, until they got all the land that was traditionally called armenia. You are so totaly wrong here! The act of doing nothing, saying no to every reform however modest, imprisoning or murdering anyone who makes even the most reasonable and reasoned demands, rejecting all helpful outside advice, all this encourages extremism. Any "pictures being painted" (such as the staged series of confiscated weapons photos) was propaganda invented by Turkish CUP extremists and directed at ordinary Turks. quote:9. the turks did give tripoli because at the time they were militarily not in a position to engage themselves there: a constant aim of the western powers, who had realised that turkey was the "sick man" of europe and would die one day, was to bring about the death at a time when it would be best for their own national benefits, and also to force the ottomans to open to fronts at the same time (basic military doctrine: you engage your opponent in two places, and move in for the kill in a third place where his forces are weakest).No government in Europe wanted to see a collapse of the Turkish empire - they tried to prop the place up with loans, alliances, military support, and encouraging reforms and modernisation, while turning as much of a blind eye as was possible to the numerous attrocities commited against the empire's Christian minorities. This was because they foresaw the wars that would result from the empire's end, and believed that Russia would be the main beneficiary. The status-quo was a better alternative, preferably with a reformed and modernised Ottoman empire, (but no real reforms ever happened). Those wanting to see the destruction of the Turkish empire wanted it to happen for moral and humanitarian reasons. quote: i think many members here have trouble seeing things in a greater perspective: That is very true - but I think in this case you are displaying the same fault - seeing things only from a Turkish perspective! quote: the armenians were a mere pawn in a much greater game of chess that was about the dismantling of the ottoman empire, the russian expansion into the mediterranean, the middle eastern oil, and the holy places. the real players in the game were far bigger, and none of them placed arenians in the centre of their plans for the region. besides, the armenians were strategic to a certain degree, but were not indispensable. it is this that the armenian revolutionaries failed to realise and therefore failed to develop a plan "b": what would they do if their allies had first incited them against the ottomans, and dropped them once their usefulness was over? cheers, Hmmm ...this "chess" analogy is only really aplicable to describe the complicated manouvering and alliances that were designed to avoid a European war. Armenia was not important enough to have a part or place in this. I remember a few years ago feeling disgust at the unreasoned criticism thrown at a European politician for describing the Jewish genocide as a "minor detail" in WW2. For it indeed was a minor detail - it did not affected anyones wartime aims or strategies to any great extent, it won or lost no battles, and concerned only a tiny part of the overall wartime population. Exactly the same is true for the Armenian genocide - but you seem to be trying to excuse it by saying it WAS an integral part of the greater "game" that was the First World War. But it was not - it was unconnected to any of Turkey's military strategies of the First World War. This is why your viewpoint - that the Armenian genocide happened but should be seen within (and as a result of) the greater context of a world war and that war's causes - is not a valid viewpoint. The point about genocide is that it occurs outside the context and customs of normal war: that the two main examples of it did occur during major conflicts is a mere coincidence, a coincidence that can obscure the reasons why genocidal acts occur (and that can also obscure genocide itself). Steve
-
Some Turkic elements in Armenian, Greek and Latin languages
bellthecat replied to Shirag's topic in Language
quote:Originally posted by nairi:You know what I mean Steve. There's no point going into it. Nairi Hmmm, so it is a language you alone speak. Try to moderate your use of it, because throwing around racial insults is not going to win you any arguments - in fact, it will do the exact opposite! -
Some Turkic elements in Armenian, Greek and Latin languages
bellthecat replied to Shirag's topic in Language
quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali did you know that "Turk" means "filthy" in European? Nairi - I'd like to learn to speak this language called "European". Where can I get a dictionary? Or is it a language that you alone speak? -
quote:Few last words. Never in our history, an Armenian Army has lost a battle to a Turkish Army – it has been quite the opposite any time the two armies have faced each other. MJ, to make a statement like that, your glasses must be more than just rose-tinted - they must be almost opaque!
-
quote: we have no anti-armenian folk literature that has to be weeded out to make it look respectable (that has to be done with all european literature re the jews, for instance). there are no racial armenian stereotypes in turkish folklore (other than a general notion that you are a trading and artistically gifted nation) the way there are jewish stereotypes in european folklore. there are no stories like "armenians eat muslim children for passover" in turkey. there is not a single abusive term that designates "armenian" in turkish that i know (and i am a linguist). Come on Ali! Human stereotypes are the basis of almost all Turkish humour, which is why I can laugh at it even though I don't understand most of the words. More seriously, PKK suporters were called "Armenians" by Turks not because they thought they were etnically Armenian but because "Armenian" was an abusive term to call someone. Like your "arap" (Arab) equivalent for the English word "nigger". And there is loads of anti Armenian (and Greek) literature produced, intended for the uneducated masses (home produced films, comic strips, etc.).
-
quote: so much for the Young Turks. now young turks: the young turks of today do not regard their country an empire... Probably true, (MHP persons excepted). But quite a lot seem to think Turkey is an island, which is just as dangerous! Ignorance of the rest of the world, and especially neighbouring countries is profoundly bad.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: 3. i am disappointed to see that a man of your intelligence and grasp of the subject cannot see the danger that turks saw in losing an inch of the land in the east: the danger was not you, it was the russians. after all, the armenian unrest, apart from being provoked by the appalling treatment of the armenians in the 19th century, was to a very large degree a russian-engineered affair with the single goal of descending to the mediterranean. the russians had been conducting a two-pronged attack on the ottoman empire since about the 18th century, the one component of which was the establishment of their presence in the balkan affairs (the western route to the eastern mediterranean), and the other, the creation of "an armenia without armenians in it" (alexander ii, if my memory does not fail me). you were going to be used against us to get a chunk of eastern anatolia, you would then be dealt with one way or the other, and once the mountainous high terrain of eastern anatolia was conquered, it would be a piece of cake to sweep across the central anatolian plateau both to the southeast mediterranean and to the aegean. look at history and you will see that any large eastern power that held the eastern anatolian highlands eventually swept into eastern mediterranean with ease. Dear Ali, I don't understand why you often refer or hint in your posts to some sort of Russian conspiracy to use and then dispose of Armenia. There is no evidence for any such thing. The Russians were quite happy to allow Armenian culture to develop in areas it controlled as long as activities there did not go as far as promoting sedition. Russian atempts to control the Armenian church were not directed at eliminating Armenians as an ethnic group - that is just mostly 19th century propaganda from the Constantinople patriarchate who could not envisage an Armenian being an Armenian unless he belonged to an all powerful Armenian church. Throughout the First World War, the Caucasian front was very much a side-issue for the Russian army, and all their battles and strategies there were defensive in nature (read Muratoff and Allen's "Caucasian Battlefields"). There was never any grand plan to march to Constantinople (or Adana) via anatolia, and for someone in Turkey to suggest that there was is rather ludicrous - you should know the geographic obstacles involved in such an invasion! The Turkish state had little practical use for eastern anatolia (except perhaps as a dumping ground for deposed Turkish officials from the lost Balkan territories) and its control over most of the territory was slight. Compared to the pre-ww1 loss of territory in the Aegean or the Balkans (especialy Albania) the loss of the Erzurum and Van vilayets would have had little economic effect. Obviously it had political uses, with the Young Turks probably making bombastic "not one inch" nationalistic statements. But those same Young Turks gave away Tripoli to Italy without much protest or loss of face, so they could easily have done the same to eastern Anatolia - but all that is hypothetical because there was no-one to give it away to! The Russians didn't want it, the Armenians there merely wanted better security and rights. Steve
-
Dear Ali All those "reasons" you list for Turkey denying the Armenian genocide are simply not valid. The only reason Turkey denies the genocide is because Turkey has always denied the genocide. Turkey was denying the genocide as far back as 1915!! With such an overwhelming history of denialist statements and publications by the Turkish state and its representatives it is nearly impossible now for that state to start saying they were all lies. And it will continue to be impossible until the current ruling elites and establishments in Turkey lose their influences. This will probably never happen - unless Turkey joins the EU (and that is unlikely to happen). All the "reasons" you cite are not real reasons. They are just the "filler" material that Turkey has to use to fill all their propaganda statements and literature. And you can be sure more "reasons" are being concocted all the time. Take the curious theory presented (invented?) by one Erol Goka in the first issue of the Turkish propaganda periodical "Armenian Studies". He says that the Armenian genocide is mostly an invention of "western Christian countries" who are guilty about the Jewish holocaust and want to absolve their guilt by inventing another genocide to show they did not create the concept of genocide but "learnt it from the Turks".
