Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. It was impressive - the ceremony, but it took me a while to figure out what the event was about, not knowing what it was in advance! There was a strange bit near the start where a lot of characters dressed in historical costumes dance around a big white circle while the lead character recites lines that were delivered in a style that was a bit like a cross between rap music and opera.
  2. I saw the (perhaps overly lavish?) opening ceremony on TV in Igdir, Turkey, where the TV reception from Armenia is better than for Turkish TV stations! Maybe not a cast of 1000s, but there must have been at least 500 or 600 performers in it, not counting the actual games participants.
  3. Yes Arpa - it is an eyewitess account. Rest will follow shortly (when I get the time to write it since I am travelling in those parts now).
  4. The Turks had broken open a gaping hole in the floor of the chapel, revealing a vaulted crypt beneath. In that crypt two labourers were digging - crunching human bones underfoot as they casually tossed up to the surface shovelfulls of material - rubble, soil, human bones, pottery, and other artifacts. This could be a typical scene of illicit digging for treasure in any abandoned Armenian church in Turkey. But it was not. This was an archeological excavation, Turkish style, in one of the best known Armenian monuments - the narthex chapel of the early 13th century church of Tigran Honents at Ani. On the surface an "archaeologist" was present - but he was more interested in showing one of his three female assistants (none of which looked to be out of their teens) how to record a piece of carving that pay attention to what the labourers were doing. In any other country he would be down in the crypt, but Turkish archaeologists do not like to get their hands dirty by doing actual digging - that is beneath their professional dignity. The pile of rubble grew bigger and the "archaeologist" came over to pick out anything he found interesting. Bones were thrown onto one pile, pottery onto another. The pıle of dislocated bones looked to be from at least 10 skeletons. Occasionaly the labourers would throwup single items. A large pıece of wood was thrown up - it split into two on landing. One of the assistants picked up the two bits and put it into a plastic bag, splıtting another piece off in the process. Perhaps it was a part of a coffin - who knows sınce its context was not recorded. A large piece of textile was thrown up - for Ani a thing of great rarity. The same assistant picked it up by one end - holding it at arms length as if it were a dead animal. It was crushed up and popped into another plastic bag. The "archaeologist", seeing this and revealing at least some training, uncrushed it a little and put some air into the bag before sealing it with a knot. Once the cursory inspection was completed the debris, still thick with bones and pottery, was loaded onto a wheelbarrow and taken a few meters to the edge of a slope and then tipped over - onto the remains of walls that fell in the 1988 earthquake. Seeing enough, I left the church to view the rest of the "excavations". ...to be continued.
  5. And in addition we have the "did he fall, was he pushed, did he jump" questions about the death of Ani's first husband. Questions which could be metaphors for questions about the fate of Armenians in 1915. Which is why I really dislike this film - Egoyan is too superficially clever for his (and the scripts) own good. Maybe after 100 or so films about the Armenian Genocide have been made there is a place for a film like Ararat, but not now. Seeing all those wine-guzzling, pseudo-intellectuals, preening and posturing in front of each other at the party in one of the early scenes made me think of how Egoyan would probably fit in with them very comfortably with that sort of crowd, and of how I'd like to go through them all with a really sharp chainsaw.
  6. The customs officer character didn't insist there were drugs in the canisters. It was the Armenian character (Raffi, I think his name was) that insisted there was not drugs but film in them. When they were opened there was, indeed, drugs within. If you are looking for symbolism, then how about this. In spite of all the contrary evidence and common sense, in the end Raffi says something like "I have to believe there is film in the canisters". Is Egoyan saying that the Armenian genocide story that Armenians accept is actually myth that has no relevance (and little or no truth) but that Armenians have to believe in it, because the truth is too awful for them to contemplate? If this is not what Egoyan is saying then how else can the so obviously fraudulant "history" that is prominantly displayed throughout this film be explained? Steve
  7. Vava - how on earth can you say this film was "Art". There has been universally negative chriticism of Ararat on "artistic" terms. There was nothing "artistic" about the film. The camera work was dull and unimaginative. The script was laboured and contrived. The characters were just shallow caractures. The soundtrack was heavy handed and cliched. The directing was full of rip-offs from earlier and better Egoyan films. The "film within a film" was, in acting terms, worse than the wost TV movie, in cinematic terms a cross between a typical piece of Soviet propaganda blended with a typical American "Rambo" movie. But that is not what I found offensive - it is the actual content I find obscene. Arpa thinks it is a "complete lesson of history, politics, art and some other social and doctrinal issues". In reality, every one of those "lessons" are lies or distortions from truth that are lies in everything but name. For Egoyan to produce his piece of filth at the expense of the Genocide victims is the real obscenity. Steve PS, there were 9 people in the cinema when I saw it for the first time, there were 5 people in the cinema when I saw it for the second time (to check whether it was just as bad as I thought the first time around). It got the audience numbers it deserved.
  8. Ararat is the most obscene movie I have ever seen. Only a cretin or the vilest sort of Armenian rascist could find even the smallest thing of value in it. The abomination that is this film is exceeded only by the abomination of Armenian diaspora society that will accept without objection the cartload lies that this piece of cinematic filth contains.
  9. Something that the US Central Command should consider buying: WW1 MILITARY FIELD NOTES - MESOPOTAMIA 1917
  10. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Steve, the Riggs family was well established in the Ottoman, in many regions, like Smyrna, Constantinople, there was many Riggs as Rev. I came accross a work, that probably I have somewhere here, refering to some other Riggs, I can search for you if you want. Thanks, your search would be welcome! I was thinking he was perhaps Henry Riggs' father.
  11. I've got a 1913 envelope sent from Anatolia College in Marsovan to a Rev. Charles Riggs in Constantinople. Anyone know who he was, and his family relationship with the well known Henry Riggs (who was in Harput and wrote "Days of Tradgedy in Armenia"). Steve
  12. quote:Originally posted by Rubo: Right analogy! Chess lovers and players know how every decision one makes affects the game as a whole and politics in Washington or anywhere is the same game played which only most skilled succeed.(I know the obvious differance lol) One talented foreign minister can do a lot. Nothing strange about my personal principals. I am and was always against the war as a human being but also I am Armenian, member of a tiny tribe hence my preference will always be supporting her before my personal morality or interests. AS long as Turkey denies the Armenian Genocide and does not provide any compensation then I will always pounce on Turkey on every opportunity. It is in my blood I can’t help it…Call me vengeful if you will it does not bother me. Korn thanks for understanding my message. Which is why so many Hyestan Armenians don't deserve any consideration. Like you admitted, double dealing and backstabbing is in your blood. You are completely untrustworthy. Your word means nothing. You are always out for yourself, expect everything from others, take whatever is going, but give nothing of substance in return. Nothing you say is believable because, if circumstances change, you will discard those beliefs like an unwanted coat. And nothing about the dangerous emptiness of your "morality" will ever bother you - even when other Armenians, following the inevitable logic of that same morality, stab you in the back. Hitler loved chess, so did Napoleon - sending milios to their death like they were nothing more than playing pieces. I hate chess and I hate chess players.
  13. quote:Originally posted by gamavor:One thing is for sure. The patterns and the colors of the carpets are Armenian. Even a lay person can recognize them without the "S" signal. That is the very thing that is not "for sure" - the style of Gantzhorn's book reminds me of Turkish books that try to prove a Turkish origin to almost everything.
  14. Not the same martyr, Arpa. This martyr, Father Salvatori, was killed in 1895. I seem to have lost (or perhaps not saved) the picture.
  15. quote:Originally posted by Rouben Malayan:Dear Arpa. I dont think we have to look for a proof that those carpets are Armenian. They are. One of the biggest experts on the Oriental carpets Volkmar Gantzhorn (who published a book called Oriental Carpets, TASCHEN, 1998) clearly states that the usage of "T"="S" in oriental carpets is an identifying mark for the christian Armenian carpets. Gantzhorn's book is not really a credible work. It is filled with inaccuracies, generalisations, and fantasies. I've heard this from various experts on Oriental carpets, and I know it to be certain in the sections in which he tries to connect Celtic art with Armenian art; those parts of the book are particularly ludicrous.
  16. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:For your unpenetrating mind I must say I was in the anti -Iraqi war rally in Boston among my friends! As for hating Turkey? Politics is about opportunity and Turks have played this game very well through centuries and there is no reason why strategic thinking can be characterized as hate. [/QB] So what on earth were you saying? Presumably you must agree that Turkey has done the right thing in refusing America access (which also happens to be the thing that 90 to 95 percent of the Turkish electorate wanted). Yet your words show you want to take advantage of the difficulties Turkey will have after making that correct decision. And you would want Armenia in a role of "reliable partner" of the US doing the exact opposite of Turkey and saying yes to whatever America wants. I hope the rest of those in that Boston anti-war march were not so lacking in sincerity - it looks like a case of "I'm against the war, except if it is going to benefit me". Steve
  17. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:I hope Turkey's standing with US greatly damages due to refusal to allow US troops for now. Apparently BUSH threatened visiting Turkish officials that Armenian lobby is waiting to reinstate the genocide bill in congress. I hope US finally realizes how unreliable Turkey is as an ally and hopefully looks towards Armenia for more reliable partner in the region. You are a stinking bit of s**t. And much more. If I was to verbally express exactly what I felt about people like you then I'd be banned from this forum. So if it was Armenia rather than Turkey that America wanted to transport its troops through, then you would happily agree to it? That seems to be what you are saying. I don't doubt that you would allow hundreds of thousands to die in Iraq just so you can feed a little bit of your sad, ongoing hatefest against Turkey. The world does not revolve around Armenia. Armenia could vanish tomorrow and it would make no difference to almost everyone. The only power that Armenia can be certain of ever possessing is the authority it should possess by being morally correct in everything it does. But you (and the likes of Kocharian) would not have a clue about what I am talking about here. If the Turksh parliament continues to hold fast against US intimidation then Turkey's standing with the rest of the world will be greatly enhanced. It has done its EU aspirations no end of good. Maybe Armenia in its present state would make an ideal "partner" for America - the same sort of ideal partner that a drunken whore would make for a murderous gangster. Steve
  18. Ebay will probably erase this soon: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI...2&category=1467 For sale: Country of Turkey "You too can open a front from turkey, still spots available to invade Iraq, Syria, Georgia, Armenia and of course Iran. All while basking in the warm mediterranean sun. And while you're there why not enjoy a night of kurd bashing".
  19. quote:Originally posted by wh00t:Whoooops, didn't look at the date of the initial post. And yeah, eBay says age will be up for "up to 90 days" after end of auction. And it also depends on the seller keeping the picture online, often it is just erased after the sale. I'm not sure if I saved a copy of the postcard, I'll have a look, but I don't think I did. If I did I'll post it here.
  20. When people of Mr Keisling's ability start to desert the American establishment, you know Bush's regime is eventually doomed to historical oblivion and condemnation, whatever happens in the short term. (PS: I seem to remember that some (or all?) of his book on Armenia can be read on www.cilicia.com). From an article on Groong: J. Brady Kiesling was Chief of Political/Economic Section at US Embassy Yerevan from August 1997 to July 1999, and subsequently served one year as Deputy in the Office of State Department Special Negotiator on NIS Conflicts, i.e., as Deputy U.S. Representative on Nagorno Artsax conflict. In his spare time, Mr. Kiesling travelled to all the provinces in Armenia, and co-authored a modern English-language travel book "Armenia Rediscovered." Completing a tour of duty in Washington, D.C. in July 2000, Mr. Kiesling was posted to U.S. Embassy in Athens as Chief of Political Section (third highest ranking post at the Embassy). His diplomatic career spanned nearly 19 years. In addition to English, Kiesling speaks fluent Armenian, Ancient and Modern Greek, and some Hebrew. He's an archeologist by training.
  21. I can answer my own question. This is from a description of a book: BOOKLET : "L'ASSASSINAT DU PERE SALVATORE PAR LES SOLDATS TURCS " ( THE KILLING OF THE FATHER SALVATORE - A CATHOLIC PRIEST - BY THE TURKISH SOLDIERS " ; WITH A TESTIMONIANCY OF AGHASSY , ONE OF THE HEADS OF THE INSURRECTION OF ZEITOUN, TRANSLATED FROM THE ARMENIAN BY ARCHAG TCHOBANIAN, WITH A PREFACE OF PIERRE QUILLARD ; PARIS EDITION DU MERCURE DE FRANCE , 1897; 45 pp. THE MASTER PIECE OF THE HISTORY OF THE EVENTS OF ZEITOUN , THE ATROCITIES COMMITTED BY THE TURKISH REGULAR SOLDIERS ( AND NOT UNCONTROLLED TCHETES ) , THE KILLING OF A MISSIONAR THE FATHER SALVATORE BY THE SAME TURKISH SOLDIERS. ROMAN CHURCH IS ACTUALLY STUDYING A POSSIBLE "BEATIFICATION" OF THE FATHER SALVATORE, MARTYR OF THE FAITH , KILLED WITH AN EXTREME VIOLENCE BY THE TURKISH SOLDIERS. WE CAN FIND ALSO ABOUT THIS EVENTS ON THE MEMORIES OF PAUL CAMBON, FRENCH AMBASSADOR IN CONSTANTINOPLE DURING THE 1895-1896 EVENTS AND HAMIDIAN ATROCITIES
  22. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Steve, I can address your hyperventilation/imsinuations sentence-by-sentence, but I really am not interested. Or, as Cartman would say, "F**k you guys, I'm going home!"
  23. quote:Originally posted by MJ: quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: quote:That says a lot. How can someone who has big gaps in basic general knowledge of Western culture feel able to pronounce on things about that culture with such certainty? Wow! You got me, Steve. I do confess that my knowledge in general needs a lot of improvement. I love learning, however. ? What disturbed me about you confessed ignorance is that it never occured to you to do a simple internet search on Gore Vidal to find out who you had never heard of. If you had then you would have understood that he is a person of some importance. But no, it's a case of "I 'ain't heard of him, so he 'ain't worth knowing about". quote: quote:So the protests of the millions of people that have been marching against American warmongering, plus the voices of the hundreds of elected politicians and the hundreds of religious leaders from the Pope downwards, can be cast aside thanks to your experience with some Swedes you talked to in a bar years ago! What a "road to Damascus" that event must have been for you - it seems to have shaped your entire outlook on the non-American world. MJ, you have seen a black sheep in a field, and immediately assumed that all sheep in the world are black, when all you should actually have assumed is that one half of one sheep in that particular field is black! Those millions of people do not have the perception of the threat that Americans have. Additionally, those people have not ever been subjected to the experience that Americans have in the recent history. Moreover, if one day, these European people would find threatened, I can assure you that they would appeal to the American “warmongers,” much like in the case of Yugoslavia. Additionally, the marching “peacemakers” have to also give themselves an account on how they have made the war more of a reality by encouraging the tyrants of the world and providing them with leverages. In 1933, when Hitler came to power, no one on the earth, especially in Europe, raised the alarms. When Germany swallowed Czechoslovakia, among others, there was no peacemaker to come out and march on the streets to demand Hitler to abstain from violence. The burden of the liberation of the conquered countries was left to the “warmongers.” Among others, France surrendered immediately (by rightfully earning reputation of world’s fastest surrendering army). When Kosovars were being slaughtered by the Serbs, or when the Serbs were being slaughtered by the Croats, I don’t recall these peacemakers marching on the streets. At that time, when the threat was to Europe, they did not consider the Americans to be "warmongers," but due to their reluctance to spend the necessary funds, or potentially risk theor lives, it was left to the Americans. I can go on and on, however, as I have mentioned before, I really don’t want to drain my energy on this argument. I have to also note that my experience with the Swedes was brought for illustration purposes and it didn’t mean that I have made my inferences based on that example. I thought that this was also obvious. I don't know what it is that has switched you back onto "tub-thumping" mode. It's very disapointing and puzzling. You were very reasonable for a while, especially after Bush washed his hands of any Genocide recognition, lifted sanctions on Azerbaijan, and began grouping Armenians in with Iranians and Egyptians and the like. Americans are not converting (i.e. fooling) anyone anymore. Those days are over forever. There is no going back. We all know the Emperor has no clothes, and that the Emperor IS a monkey. And (to give you a history lesson) America did nothing about stopping Hitler until Germany declared war on America. America, then as now, only acted out of its own self-interest and cared nothing for any county but itself. quote:Oh dear, you have started ending things with personal insults again. If it comes across as an insult, I am sorry – it has not been my intention. However, the crux of my statement (I thought obviously) was to express my disappointment with the material of a person, who I, otherwise, am of very high opinion, which I have expressed occasionally, including in my "last sentence" – as much as my opinion may not matter. [/QB] It's my experience that people who go around talking a lot about intelligence (and common sense) generally think they have that quality in abundance, and (even if they don't state it) think those who they disagree with are seriously lacking in it. That is why I thought your words appeared to be an insult.
  24. quote:Originally posted by MJ: I don’t know who Gore Vidal is. Never have heard of him. That says a lot. How can someone who has big gaps in basic general knowledge of Western culture feel able to pronounce on things about that culture with such certainty? quote:What I know however, that there is an obnoxious leftism on the rise in the US and, especially in Europe. There is an obnoxious anti-Americanism, especially in Europe. I remember about 10 years ago I was out for a drink or two with some Swedish colleagues. They claimed they hated US. I asked why? Their response was very direct – “They are too rich, and we hate rich people.” More I look at Europe, and I travel to Europe. This is the conclusion I come to – at least some of the European countries. So the protests of the millions of people that have been marching against American warmongering, plus the voices of the hundreds of elected politicians and the hundreds of religious leaders from the Pope downwards, can be cast aside thanks to your experience with some Swedes you talked to in a bar years ago! What a "road to Damascus" that event must have been for you - it seems to have shaped your entire outlook on the non-American world. MJ, you have seen a black sheep in a field, and immediately assumed that all sheep in the world are black, when all you should actually have assumed is that one half of one sheep in that particular field is black! quote:Finally, I find very sorry that a person of your intelligence and character would resort to such expressions as “monkeys and apes” when expressing yourself on such serious issues as the world politics and peace and war are. I, for one, have much higher expectations from you. Oh dear, you have started ending things with personal insults again.
  25. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Steve, My argument has been solely directed at the word “pilgrimage” (though I have used that term in the past, myself.) . So let's reclaim the word "pilgrimage" from religion. Or invent a new word. quote:BTW, I didn’t quite understand your question. Neither do I, so forget it quote:My understanding is that Etchimiadzin is built on a site of a destroyed pagan temple. Is it not so? However, I am not aware of Etchimiadzin, Hripseme, etc. ever being declared as “holly sites” by the Armenia Church (who else might declare something in Armenia as “holly site?”) However, I would gladly accept my mistake if you would care to educate me on the subject. I'm not entirely sure about the Etchmiadzin church, but the other two (the St. Gayane and St. Hripsime churches are built on their supposed graves. I don't think people can "declare" a site holy - it either is holy or isn't. The Church can try and encourage or surpress a site's popular recognition, but the initial "holiness" is not in their control.
×
×
  • Create New...