-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
Gallup Poll Exposes the Myth Of Turkish-American Friendship
bellthecat replied to hyecory's topic in International
quote:"A Gallup Poll taken last month in Turkey found that: Only 40% of theTurkish public "has a favorable opinion of the United States;" Only 19% of Turks "say that U.S. military action in Afghanistan is morally justifiable;" Only 21% of the Turkish public "likes President Bush." Don't make too much of that - you would get exactly the same results if you asked people anywhere in the world - except the 21 percent for Bush: that is really high. Steve -
The Arkansas Democrat Gazette (mentioned by Weems) has a website. http://library.ardemgaz.com There is stuff abour Weems on it, eg: it says he was a former prosecuting attorney who was disbarred in 1973. To get more info you need to pay $1.95 per article. You would think the AAA would have done such a search, to get properly documented evidence, but it appears they didn't. Maybe they thought $1.95 was too much to pay!
-
And Weems's reply. Didn't I tell you all it was a set-up to destroy Armenian credibility? Discounting extreme insanity on Weems's part (to write such a letter) that's what it now appears to be. Mr. Emil Sanamyan Research and Information Associate Armenian Assembly of America Mr. Sanamyan: I am writing to respond to your email to me dated February 13, 2002. Please be advised as follows regarding your offer to make a "correction" if I not am the Sam Weems you are talking about. Let us be very clear with each other-however you explain it-I am the Sam Weems you have attacked and libeled! I say to you yet one more time -I HAVE NEVER BEEN CONVICTED OF A FELONY IN DEWITT, ARKANSAS OR ANYWHERE ELSE AS YOUR CLAIM AND PUBLISH! It is to my astonishment that you continue to print and reprint this false statement. I do not understand why your "research" department has not yet taken the very basic action to verify if I am a truth teller. You could have called the Criminal Court in DeWitt, Arkansas to determine if I had been convicted there-yet you continue to refuse to do this basic research! You could have called the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette to determine if the article you use as your source is correct-yet you refuse to do that either! My question is this: Why do you fail and refuse to check truth when it is readily available, and said to you over and over again exactly where you can prove truth for yourself? Permit me to help your "Research Department" find truth that I am not a convicted felon: * I will be pleased to provide you with the name of the Criminal Court in DeWitt, Arkansas. * I will be pleased to provide you with the telephone number of the Criminal Court in DeWitt, Arkansas. * I will be pleased to provide you with the name of the clerk of the Criminal Court in DeWitt, Arkansas. * I will be pleased to provide you with the address of the Criminal court in DeWitt, Arkansas, and the directions of how to get there if you want to go and check the records for yourself. * If you want to fly to Little Rock, Arkansas, I will be delighted to drive you to the Courthouse in DeWitt, Arkansas. In that way you can more quickly examine all of the actual records for yourself. * I will be pleased to provide you and your entire "research" department with this information to assist you in making the smallest effort of making one simple telephone call. You will see that it will take only a few minutes to check to see if I am a truth teller when I say to you I have never-never-ever been convicted of a felony as you allege in your daily publications over and over again! Mr. Sanamyan, for your information, I have spoken with the editors and the attorney for the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. These gentlemen stated that neither you, nor any Armenian has ever called to verify the statement and article you claim to quote from their publication. Because you and your "research" department refuse to call this newspaper that you quote here in Arkansas, I am advised that the editor of the newspaper will contact you in writing to confirm to you and the Armenian Assembly of America the following truth that; 1. Sam Weems has never been convicted of a felony. 2. You and the Armenian Assembly of America are wrong and in error to quote the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette as your source, claiming that Sam Weems is a convicted felon. Come on down to Arkansas and I will personally take you to meet with the editors and the attorney for the Arkansas Democrat Gazette. You can ask these gentlemen face to face about your claim that I am a convicted felon. Come on down and I will be delighted to prove to you-face to face-that what you have printed about me is a total lie! In your last e-mail, you said that if I could prove I wasn't the Sam Weems in question, you would make a "correction." Mr. Sanamyan: This is an insult! It is your false accusations in your articles and your smear campaign that has caused me to receive hundreds of death threats and hate mail from Armenians around the world. I take such threats seriously! I tell you plainly that you and the Armenian Assembly of America will be held responsible if any harm comes to me because of the continuation of your false and untrue publication of the great lie about me. I also tell you plainly that I have asked for police protection because of the terrorist record of Armenian Americans here in the United States of America. [i have ommitted a particularly rambling section here! - steve] ....now then-back to the reason for this e-mail. I trust that you will choose to take the right and fair action, and permit me to assist you to prove that I am not a convicted felon nor am I a racist or your other made up tall tales you printed. Come on down to Arkansas and let me prove it to you. You will discover, for example that I have an unblemished record on civil rights. Armenia can't say that! If you do not choose to be honest, and if you do not choose to be fair-well-Mr. Sanamyan, that is what we have courts for in this country. This is not a "threat" as you have published-it is a "promise" that if you do not work out a written agreement with me, I make you this "vow"--that we shall meet in a non-Armenian court of law here in the United States of America. I would suggest that it is past time for the Armenian Assembly of America to hire a good lawyer to see exactly where you stand before you continue printing your big lie about me. I trust that you will promptly reply to this message, after consulting with your legal counsel. I trust that the Armenian Assembly of America will have the common sense to stop printing their horrible made up tall tales about me, make a public apology, and sign an agreement with me to right its great wrong. End of Story! Yours truly, Sam Weems
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Bellthecat, How can you dismiss Star of David/Solomon symbol found in Armenian artifacts as having nothing to do with Jewish influence when eminent ROA geneticist Yepiskoposyan found that Armenians have 1/3 of the percentage of males who have y-chromosome of Kohanim (Jewish priests) as do Sephardim males. So what? How does genetics influence the creation of specific motifs? Are only Jews genetically capable of placing one equal sided triangle on top of another inverted equal sided triangle and appreciating the visual effect thus produced?!! quote: BOTTOM LINE, I do not trust ANY conclusion made by ANY Turk about Armenians or their history, vis-a-vis Armenian-Jewish cultural matters. Hmm... I don't really need to reply to such a silly comment - except to say that I do not trust ANY conclusion made by ANY Armenian about Armenians or their history - there are too many vested interests at work. And that would be good advice for anyone to follow, anywhere. I wonder what your interest is, vis-a-vis genetics and your desire to see some genetic connection to Jews? Are are you as willing to admit to the proven genetic connections between Jews and Arabs for example. Most of these migration stories, be they Jewish or Armenian or whatever, are really just historical myths. Israel arose out not out of assimilation or migration, but of a concious separation from close neighbours, which is why there is little genetic difference between Jews and Arabs. Steve
-
The presence in Armenian art of the "star of David" symbol that was mentioned earlier has nothing at all to do with Jewish artisans. It is very widespread, for example you can see one in Ani's citadel palace church, from the 7th century: http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/citadel/citadel8s.jpg And on one of the two giant khatchkars at Aprank monastery, near Erzincan, from the 13th century. http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/aprank/aprank12s.jpg Actually the "star of David" symbol is not really the corect term, as it now has unpleasant undertones of Zionism. The proper art term is "seal of Solomon". However,in Armenia it may have no connection at all with ancient Israel, and may just be a local talisman symbol, and not even be connected with Christianity: I have a pottery sherd from Ani with a Solomon's seal motif on it, and such pots very very rarely had Christian religous symbols on them - mostly they had secular motifs or things like strange mythical creatures. Steve
-
Arturian ...do you actually live in Armenia From what I've seen most women in Armenia either either dress to look like sluts (seriously, sometimes ludicrously, bad makeup and seriouly bad-taste clothes) or they look as if they have just spent the last week digging up a field of potatoes. Is there an Armenian equivalent of an "English rose" - maybe under all the trashy surface there might be a few, but would a true "rose" ever wear such stuff?
-
Israel Foreign Ministry: "events cannot be compared to
bellthecat replied to wh00t's topic in International
Errr ...why do you all care what the official representative of a terrorist state thinks? We all know why Israel needs to think it has exclusive use of the word "gencide", a need that is now even stronger now that Israel is about to commit genocide on the Palestinians. -
Another new page has been added to VirtualANI: THE STEREOSCOPIC PHOTOGRAPHS OF ANI http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/kurkdjian/ O. Kurkdjian was an Armenian photographer based in Yerevan during the 19th century. He produced a series of stereoscopic photographs (stereographs) of Ani. It is not known exactly when the photographs were taken: sometime between 1875 and 1880, but probably after the Kars district (including Ani) was incorporated into the Russian Empire (i.e. after 1877).
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: the guys hired the history-expert version of erich von daniken Nice one, Ali
-
I don't know whether we should praise or murder whoever had the idea of preserving all that stuff! There must be soooooh much garbage there - of the 700 million messages maybe a few 100,000 will be useful to anyone. (And did something horrible happen to Mark on Tuesday May 12th 1981?).
-
quote:Originally posted by Aghtchik: Can someone explain to me why Thorny Rose was banned from this Forum? Ask PandukhT/Movses - he was responsible and he has been revealingly silent about it ever since.
-
quote:Originally posted by wh00t: Bellthecat, whatever serves to discredit the source will discredit the work. PS: And I though Canadians were above that sort of thing
-
quote:Originally posted by wh00t: Bellthecat, whatever serves to discredit the source will discredit the work. The fact that he was convicted of arson (!) and money laundering (I believe) will be a key defense. Not totally fair, but you could bet the Turks would squeeze every last drop of juice from something like this if the opportunity arose. You are entirely wrong! Seriously wrong. I know that since majority of persons reading this forum either grew up in America or the Soviet Union, and that both those countries have always made extensive use of black propaganda, slurs, inuendos, and lies to discredit their opponents, it may be difficult for them to realise the rest of the world has moved on from such childish activities. But Armenians, in particular, do not seem to have moved on at all. (How often have we seen anyone who disagrees with them being dismissed simply by being called a "Turk"). The allegations you seem to believe are true are (given that the individual has threatened to sue those making the allegations) almost certainly false. They were probably deliberately invented so that Armenians will spread then about, and then become discredited when the allegations are proved to be false. This has worked many times in the past - I have said it before that most Turkish books denying the genocide consist mainly of easily disproving false Armenian information (for example, the non-existent "Hitler statement", the obviously exagerated Patriarchate's population figures for Ottoman Armenians, obviously false photographs like the "pyramid of skulls", etc, etc.). By the time they have finished with all that, they can conveniently forget about answering the real facts.
-
quote:Originally posted by wh00t: Turns out this clown is a convicted felon. Watch where you are treading here. Attack him because of his views and because of the lies he propagates, not because of entirely irrelevant (and probably entirely false) allegations of a criminal conviction.
-
Domino, I wasn't claiming that Lynch's figures were unquestioningly correct, and they are based on 1890s figures, but Lynch had no vested interest to either underestimate or overestimate the Armenian population, so his figures are worth examining. As for Cuinet's figures - I don't have them to compare with Lynch's. But, in his book, on several occasions Lynch is strongly critical of Cuinet's population figures, so he would hardly have used them unquestioningly, if at all. I guess Lynch used his common sense and on the spot observations together with oficial statistics (be they Ottoman or Armenian patriarchate) to arive at his figures. Regarding the overly large number of children compared to men, I don't know how McCarthy explains this - but surely it must partly be due to the large number of Armenian men that migrated to the big cities for work, leaving wives and children behind. Many travellers during this period comment on that reality. I don't understand your "Vilayet of Alep (sandjak of Marash)" comment. Marash was not in the Aleppo/Syria vilayet. Lynch would have put its population in with the 751,000 for the rest of Anatolia. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Bellthecat. I didn't really studied Lynch numbers(other then taking a look at them from professor Panzac statistical compilation). But correct me if I am wrong, but his numbers are very close to the ones of Cuinet. Now I studied Cuinet enough in order to tell that his calculations were not accurate, and even Cuinet himself admit it, by saying that the Ottoman with a party ligne refused any investigation. Now some other points must be noted, Lynch appears to provide corrective values, but these values are not very well justified. Why an undercounting of 10 % of the womens ? Is he suggesting that Ottoman only undercounted of 10 % ? And what about then conserning the undercounting of the male population, that was well ignored and even recognised by McCarthy himself ? He affirm that the number of Armenian children do not match with the number of Armenian men. He gave the example of the city of Rize, where, when using the population stable tables, would have taken two times more men to match with the number of children(we see here, that even if the number of children are under counted, it would have taken two times more men to match the number, proving that there was a lots more men then what statistics shows, adding to this, the undercounted children, the Ottoman figures are very far from reality). This has been explained by demographic calculations with an underregistration of under 15 % for the Muslims, since they were polygamic, and that could have explanned much of this numbers. But not the Armenians, when McCarthy and others also just used the same kind of corrector values. I do not know about Lynch, but others have done it. There is also contradictions of what is the actual total Armenian population. This contradiction is found from authors such as McCarthy. This is what McCarthy say: “There were 1,456 million Armenians in Ottoman Anatolia in 1912, before the wars began. (this does not include the 28,000 Armenian residents of Southern Haleb Provinces, which became part of Syria after the world war nor the Armenians of Istanbul Province and Ottoman Europe, who were neither killed nor deported during World War I, although some were conscripted.) At wars’ end, 881,000 remained alive, a loss of 584,000, or 41%. Most of these victims were victims of the war fought between the Muslims and Armenians between 1915 and 1920, directly or indirectly through starvation and disease.” Now he don't include many of the Armenians here... population of Armenians ignored, pass well above 350,000. Lynch also pout the total of the Armenian losses to be under 400,000. Another fact is that the Armenian population in the Caucasus based on Lynch numbers are well under the official Russian statistics found in McCarthy's work. The question, is how Lynch came to these numbers ? Is he used numbers that were providen to Cuinet by the Ottoman ? In that case his numbers would be as biased as the ones provided by Cuinet, but Cuinet himself admit his numbers are not compleat and tha Ottoman didn't permited him to do a full investigation, and they choosed to provide him what to study. In the the Vilayet of Alep (sandjak of Marash) for example the Armenian population for the year 1892. The number is 4,300 an impossible number, only the church numbers per population would contradict this, another thing that proof that this number is not only wrong but even impossible(the true number was four time higher) is that only in the city of Marash the Catholic and Protestant Armenians were numbering 6008, and this without including the Gregorian’s(Cuinet p. 237). This number is based on the church registry and is also supported from Catholic and Protestant missionaries, when the populations of Catholic and Protestants that the missionaries were basing on was similar to a census, since it was not only based on the birth and death certificate kipped by the churches, but were verified by the Catholic and Protestant missionaries more particularly in Cilicia, were their missions were based on these precise numbers, and the numbers were nearly a direct counting of population. [ February 04, 2002: Message edited by: Domino ]
-
The Armenian population according to H.F.B. Lynch (from "Armenia, Travels and Studies" published in 1901). Lynch is very dismissive of the exaggerated population figures put forward by the Armenian delegation at the Berlin congress of 1878, and there is every reason to believe that his (Lynch's) population statistics are reasonably accurate. Lunch gives the total population of the Armenian Tableland in Turkey (Vilayets of Van, Bitlis, Harput and Erzurum, plus the Palu region of Diarbekir) at about the year 1890 as 387,746. Lynch says that a figure should be added to the above to cover the incomplete registration of females in the more remote regions. He suggests an extra 10 percent for Van, excluding Van city. (an extra 2,866), 13 percent for Bitlis (an extra 12,600), 7 percent for Erzurum (an extra 7,473). The total for this extra percentage is 22,939 - which gives a grand total of 410,685 Armenians in the Armenian tableland. He gives a figure for the rest of Asiatic Turkey as 751,500 (this including places like Sivas, Malatya, Diarbekir) and for Turkey in Europe as 186,000. There would have been a natural population increase between 1890 and 1915. There are also the massacres before 1915 to consider. (some Turkish sources, with no sense of irony, actually deduct several 100,000 as a result of the massacres of 1895 and 1909 yet still deny that these massacres actually took place!) To simplify things lets assume changes due to massacres and population growth cancel each other out. This seems to gives a grand total of 1,348,185 Armenians that could have been massacred by the Turks during the Armenian genocide. But it is not that simple - In 1915 Iranian Azerbaijan was under Turkish occupation, and massacres were inflicted on the Armenians living there. Lynch says 28,890 Armenian lived here in 1890. Let us say there were 35,000 by 1915. He gives no figure for Armenians in Syria and Palestine. In 1918 Turkish armies cut a swathe of destruction through Russian Armenia to reach Baku. Lynch gives the population of the Armenian tableland under Russia rule as 519,238. There would have been substantial population growth by 1915 - let us say it had increased to 750,000. Lynch gives the Armenian population for the rest of the Caucasus as 450,000 - say 650,000 by 1915. This includes places like Karabagh or Baku - both having substantial Armenian populations - at least 10,000 Armenians were massacred after Baku’s capture by the Turks in 1918. Let us say 300,000 out of those 650,000 Armenians lived in areas directly affected by the Turkish invasions of 1918 and 1920. Adding all this together we get a maximum of about 2,400,000 Armenians that COULD have been murdered by the Turks between 1915 and 192 (i.e. that were accessible to the Turks). Obviously not all were killed. A figure of 2 million Armenians murdered is an entirely impossible claim to justify - a figure of one million victims is easily possible. Given the numbers of refugee survivors, 1.2 to 1.3 million victims seems realistic. The total Armenian population in the Ottoman empire, and in the parts of Russian Armenia that are now part of Turkey (Kars, Igdir, Ardahan) seems to have been around 1,500,000 before 1915, based on Lynch’s statistics. Today it is about 40,000.
-
Recent world events show that by American standards, his understanding of history, politics, geography and justice are probably quite acceptable (to Americans anyway) ;-) The poor sod doesn't even know the difference between Moscow's Kremlin fortress and St. Basils cathedral (http://www.stjohnpress.com/photos.htm). And there is no such place as the "British Military Museum" (It's the "Imperial War Museum").
-
Two new pages have been recently added to VirtualANI: The Ani Stone Quarries: will Armenia turn Ani into an industrial wasteland? An account of the stone quarry that has blighted the landscape around the Ani ruins, with photographs. Plus a selection of media reports and responses to the quarry. http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/quarry/ A description, with photographs, of the ruins of the 10th century monastery of Saint George of Goms, on the shores of Lake Van in eastern Turkey. http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/goms/
-
quote:Originally posted by edward demian: Every nail driven into that church is a nail driven into the collective coffin of our enemies. Er.. I think you should sack the architect - there are NO NAILS in the St. Hripsime church! quote: Yes it is a faitheful reproduction of St Hripsime. The Architect Charlie Martin travelled to Armenia and chose that church. Could you not find someone with the guts to do something original, or be a bit more imaginative in his choice, or have some proper connection with the architecture? What does he know about Armenian architecture? What else has he seen except St. Hripsime? Did he chose it because it is the nearest church to the airport! It is not exactly the most suitable design for a small congregation. It will probably be as faithful as if Disneyland made it. Honestly, the whole project does sound quite ghastly - the sort of thing that a British TV company might later film to make fun of the crazy Yanks. Though it IS possible to build proper reproductions. I have seen film of a beautiful Serbian church that is an exact copy of a medieval one that existed in Kossovo (and was demolished after the American invasion). So maybe a copy of an Armenian church in Turkey would have been more appropriate, and valuable. quote: Now days, the ancient art of Masonry is dying. Very few projects use stone anymore. Nor is yours, really. Stone cladding is not masonry work. quote: As to all of you that are angry, I don't understand your anger. What I am doing is Art. If I was painting would you have the same reaction? I am pleased with the project. If we would have wanted a Mexican style church with an Armenian cross on it, we would have bought one for ten cents on the dollar. Why not produce something original that is still Armenian. But I suspect that is something that modern society, of whatever ethnic group, now cannot produce. (I could probably do it - but ya didn't ask me! And mine would be art - not a kitchy pastiche).
-
"The same man that write in Turkish Daily News an article titled, Turkey should use propaganda against Armenian allegations." NB - After the article appeared, McCarthy denied using the actual word "propaganda", and (if I remember it correctly) the TDN then admitted that he didn't.
-
quote:Originally posted by edward demian: Does anyone have a contact in Armenia for Tufa Stone? We are building a reproduction of the 7th Century, St Hripsime Church. Just don't f*ing get it from the Ani quarry Is the thing a life size reproduction?
-
Is Armenia really being blockaded by Azerbaijan?
bellthecat replied to MosJan's topic in International
Thanks, Edward - for posting the most amusing message ever But - if mosjan takes it as an insult then shouldn't Edward be banned - after all he repeated the insult THREE times!! On the other hand, I bet Edward is now so embarassed he'll never dare post anything here again -
quote:Originally posted by Azat: Armenians fought hard and only succeeded in wining the war after they stopped getting aid from Russia. Nagorno Artsax has not won the war, it have won the last few battles. This is not a war that Nagorno Artsax can EVER finally win on battlefields. (You are the one on drugs if you believe otherwise )
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag: bellthecat, Surely, you jest! The Azeri Army has shown itself to be inept time and time again. N was artificially included in Azerbaijan by Stalin and is now back in Armenian hands where it belongs. There are no Azeris in NK. It is an Armenian province. No Armenians to gurd the Christian monuments? What do you propose to do, have another Armenian Genocide? N0 - I DO NOT JEST (but I wish I was) It is almost certain that president Bush now that he has started his killing frenzy will extend it to Iraq. In this new war he will get no support from Europe or the Middle East (except Israel obviously). This leaves only Turkey and the US's new "best friend" Azerbaijan to support America's actions - and America WILL need their support (and airspace, and air bases). The price of that support will be the diplomatic "nod and wink" that whatever Azerbaijan and Turkey want to do in their internal politics is OK with the USA - and Nagorno Artsax IS an integral part of Azerbaijan according to US foreign policy. Armenia has diplomatically squandered the last 7 years (it seems they didn't even have the sense to take the domain name karabagh.org!) The foolishness of all this is without parallel when you consider that the NK army will always be unable to win an outright victory against Azerbaijan, the best it can do is win localised battles. And it only needs one major Armenian defeat for NK to collapse. Odds dictate that eventually a defeat WILL come, and all the signs and portents are that a new Azeri offensive will come soon, next spring probably. Steve
-
You can be sure that all these buildings will be "Armenian" again just before they are blown up by the Azeris after the fall of Nagorno-Artsax. I'll be surprised if NK still exists by the autumn of next year, and these (and other) monuments will probably be destroyed within a year after that date. (Lack of U.S. supplied high explosives and training will mean they will last a little longer than the Serbian monuments in Kosovo - most of which were destroyed within 4 months of the start of Albanian control).
