-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH: I can't agree with this statement (as a universal statement). I know that I am no expert, but I have been to the theater at Aspendos between Side and Antalya (it is simply wonderful) - as well as to other Greek structures in Turkey that have been restored and I think that the restored buildings serve a great purpose - more so - to the common folk - then just a pile of old stones and such. That being the case I cry with you regarding the poor quality of the work and the destructivenss as witnessed by the (so-called) resorations as can be seen on your web page and that you allude to here. Obviously the restorations should be done right. Your points regarding the motivations for the restorers is also well taken. Just the same - I would love to see an Ani (or parts of it at least) resotred properly - not by these hacks. It is certainly criminal what they are doing and how they are going about it. Thanks so much for documenting such and bringing it to our attention. It wasn't meant to be a universal statement but as far as eastern Turkey goes I think it could be. Thanks for your encouragement, by the way! A lot of the sites in the west of Turkey are paid for by foreign funds, who have greater control. There seems also to be a greater motivation to preserve the buildings (as opposed to just making money out of their reconstruction). But the truth is that western Turkey doesn't really care much about eastern Turkey - if they did then the PKK problem would never have arisen (even the Turkish government admits this, although they say the neglect was merely developmental).
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Not very delightful, not very genteel, I know. But ya watch it anyway! I dont usually watch it, but was just switching between channels (excuses!) and started looking because Cher was on. Was that her real hair, I wonder - or a blond wig? Actually, I agree with your "nice lady, cool and unflappable" comment - I doubt if she could have survived for so long in showbiz if she wasn't.
-
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: OOOOOOOh my gooooooosh! No - I didn't see any such piles. But, isn't it a bit odd that the colour of the stone in the first picture is much lighter than the original stone overall, which is somewhat very light brown? They are from different sides of the building - the first is from the side facing the valley (facing west) the other is from the south facade. But the colour difference might just be due to the light.
-
PRESS RELEASE Art Poster Campaign for the recognition of Arm
bellthecat replied to 15levels's topic in News Feed
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Thorny, First, in this context, the government of Armenia has immediately acknowledged the fact of the explosions. There hasn’t been any attempt of a cover up by the Armenian side. Have you read NOTHING on the subject? There has been nothing BUT cover-up from Armenia. quote: Nor The Cat has introduced or presented any evidence about the damage of these explosions, regardless of whether he has that evidence or not. I have visited his web site at the time of our previous discussion, and have found only a small paragraph about the “fat-cat” Armenians building mansions using the stone of Ani quarries for the prestige of it. First of all, I find that declaration very unprofessional and out of the context. And it is substandard material for his own site, which otherwise is a very good one. MJ, your distortions are getting too much now. Nowhere did I use the phrase "fat-cat Armenians" My exact words on the website are: The Stone Quarry In 1999 a quarry was opened on the Armenian side of the border (directly opposite the Cathedral) to extract stone to clad Yerevan's new cathedral. This cathedral is being built to mark the 1700th anniversary of the Armenian state's conversion to Christianity, and it was decided to use "Ani stone" as a gimmick to attract the rich foreign donors needed to pay for the construction. It is unlikely this quarry will be closed when the cathedral is finished - there are plenty of politicians and criminals in Yerevan who would like the cache of having a mansion built of stone from Ani. In addition to the obvious environmental damage to the landscape and constant sound of heavy machinery, with each explosion from this quarry the fragile buildings in Ani literally shake. quote: He tells us that he has written about it to “some Armenian architectural organization a year or so ago.” I would like to know what organization, and I would go after them. RAA: (Research on Armenian Architecture), with offices in Armenia, Germany, and America. I do not want you to "go after" anyone - you seem incapable of reasoned thought on this subject, and would do more damage than good. -
quote:Originally posted by gamavor: Ali, All of the bad things mentioned by you as a crime or just tragedy that had happened in the course of the history are well known. The point is that all those tragedies have been healed more or less. This is not the case with your race and your stolen (meaning adoption from other cultures of basic customs and life sterotypes because of lack of their own, because of their backwardness)culture. You are simply ...turks! Capish? Capish?!!! A fine example of the everyday use of an Armenian cultural idiom not stolen/borrowed/adopted from anyone else.
-
PRESS RELEASE Art Poster Campaign for the recognition of Arm
bellthecat replied to 15levels's topic in News Feed
quote:Originally posted by Rouben Malayan: What is your point Steve? You are sabotaging our work everywhere you can. What is it you want? Firstly - I question the real value of these posters. They are artistically attractive, but I think you are only going to be preaching to the converted. In general, posters tend to reinforce held opinions and do not change opinions. But maybe I will be wrong. Secondly - personally, I do not think posters are an appropriate medium to discuss historical events in detail - they are too much like politicians "sound-bites". This is a valid chriticism that can be placed on the whole "genocide-recognition" campaign - extreme simplification to appeal to the limited time and understanding of politicians (eg: the constant repeating of Hitler's non-existant statement on the Genocide). Thirdly - all the simplified propaganda just clowds the real issue. Have you never read any Turkish anti-Armenian propaganda books? Most of their content is devoted to easily dismissing the nonsence produced by Armenians (such as the Hitler statement referred to earlier, or the "Tower of Skulls" photograph, or similar fabrications). By the time they have done all that, they don't need to bother trying to address the Truth of the Armenian genocide because by using Armenians' own words, they have discredited themselves as witnesses. Fourthly - I saw from your replies in the "cultural Genocide" posting that you do not really have the interests of Armenian monuments at heart. I think that to you they are just another bit of cannon-fodder to throw at the Turks. I do not think you are interested in realistic ways to preserve them. Maybe, if the discussion had been allowed to continue, some realistic solutions might have been suggested - but instead you just quit and ran (mouse-like) for cover. Steve PS For the Ani quarry, see: http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/quar...arry/quarry.htm -
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: have you seen the pictures of what those heads did when they were on shoulders? Ali, everyone knows that these Turkish special forces "rambos" can kill whoever they like, and then just put a gun beside then, which makes the victims PKK and thus it is all OK. Even if they were PKK such activity is not acceptable. Reproduce a picture like this enough times and Turkey's percentage chance to enter the EU goes from single figures to zero. Todays only Croat fascists and the occasional KLA terrorist can get away with this sort of thing (but they have German support). Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Click here! Orelse did any body see Graham norton on Friday night? He had Cheras his guest. I think she looks like a nice lady, cool and unflappable by his filthy humour, unlike some of his other guests. Also ,Look at Ali G's new rabiz look! Click here! Or maybe she has has so many facelifts she was worried that if she did smile her entire face would snap apart! Fortunately she seemed a lot more human when interviewed while attending some film premiere (that Harry Potter thing?) in London.
-
quote:Originally posted by Juggernaut: What about the thousands of Afghans that have died or are about to die from US bombing, sanctions and starvation? Are they less human? And what about the 1 million Iraqi children? NOT 6000, BUT 1 MILLION Very true! It seem that one black day in America is worth more than a century of black days for everyone else. The vile arrogance of America sometimes beggars belief.
-
PRESS RELEASE Art Poster Campaign for the recognition of Arm
bellthecat replied to 15levels's topic in News Feed
The mouse thinks it can roar! -
Why do people think writing this will do any good? There IS a real problem concerning the preservation of Armenian cultural remains in Turkey - but this sort of rubbish just makes things worse. (People - read this quickly! MosJan might do a "malayan" and removes the whole thread ). quote:Originally posted by MosJan:[QB]NEW FACTS ABOUT ARMENIAN MONUMENTS IN TURKEY As our readers remember at the Yerevan session of PACE culture, education and science committee that took place recently it was once again stressed then the Council of Europe condemns any encroachment on cultural-historical values of any nation. At the session Turkish and Azeri representatives tried to prove that such facts are not registered in their countries. Turkish envoy Karkam Husein announced that Turkey does not destroy any Armenian cultural value deliberately, as far as the country’s law condemns such acts. Is it really so? Let’s put aside emotional approaches and present the mere facts. According to UNESCO 1974 data out of 913 Armenian historical buildings that survived 1915 genocide 464 were fully destroyed, 252 were ruined and 197 needed quick repair works. In recent years statistical data about the situation of Armenian religious monuments and churches in the territory of Turkey are received not as detailed. Many scientists, architects, historians, reporters, photographers and simply tourists who visited Turkey in recent years made many publications, issued books and made researches on this theme, based on which we gather the clear image of the situation. The data given by the above-mentioned people show that most part of 3200 monuments are destroyed. During decades only 100 churches and chapels were researched well. The research of the rest of cultural-historical values is difficult in the eastern provinces of Turkey because of special military regime in the provinces introduced since 1987. quote:The regime forbids visits to Armenian historical-cultural monuments. This is simply not true. quote:William Tarlimple, reporter of the Independent, made such an announcement recently: ‘Turkish or any foreign scientist is not encouraged to make researches in Armenian settlements or write about the history of Armenia. A British archeologist (who, like all the others whom I talked to, asked me not to publicize his name) told me the following: ‘It is impossible to investigate any place where Armenians lived in past. I tried to get a permit to make excavations in an ex-Armenian settlement, but it was useless. And if you try to make research without a permit you will be persecuted’. This is a near complete fabrication when compared to his original words! The actual words are "It is simply not possible to work on the Armenians. Officially they do not exist and have never done so. If you try to get permission to dig an Armenian site it will be withheld, and if you go ahead without permission you will be prosecuted" quote:There are many facts to prove that such things really happen. For example a French historian Tiery was detained in 1975 for trying to draw the blue print of an Armenian church near Van. He was cruelly ‘questioned’ at the jail for three days, and only after that was let free and had to escape from Turkey’ (William Talrimple, ‘From the holy mountain’, HarperCollins Publishing House, London, 1997, page 85’. More distortions. The actual words are "the truth of this was graphically ilustrated in 1975 when the French archaeologist J.M. Thierry was arrested while making a plan of an Armenian church in Van. He was taken to police headquarters where he was fiercely interrogated for three days and nights. He was released on bail and managed to escape the country. In his absence he was sentenced to three months hard labour". Even the author's name is wrong - it is William Dalrymple. quote This "report" is a well known fabrication and "Steven Kamachian" does not exist. This would be obvious if the whole "report" was given - it is a fantasy in which the "author" claims to have visited Ani by boat, crossing the river directly from Armenia! There were also no foreign archaeologists working at Ani the year he claimed to have visited. quote:Lebanon-Armenian Levon Tashchian gives the following evidence: ‘In September 1998 I visited Western Armenia, and was touring in Mush, when in front of a villager’s house I saw an Armenian holy sculpture which has a shape of plate, and where Armenian children were being baptized. It served as a place where the cattle was drinking water from. I hardly noticed it when villagers and policeman surrounded me, took my photo- camera, smashed it into pieces and made me leave the village’. More lies I think! What village was involved? The usual lack of detail! I visited Moush that same year with a group of American Armenians and had no trouble - another similar group visited the place in september and, as far as I am aware, they also had no trouble. I assume from his use of the word "touring" that he was part of that last group. quote:Turkish mass media itself writes about the destruction of Armenian monuments. Cumhuriyet writes that St. Virgin church of Kesaria is turned into a disco bar, Radical is worried about Diarbekir’s Armenian church, which is fully ruined, ‘Towards year 2000’ weekly informed that holy sculptures and paintings are destroyed in St. Cross church of Aghtamar and Yeni Yuzyil alarmed about privatization of St. Mary church, and the plans of its destruction and turning its place into a market. This church in Kayseri is used as a gymnasium, not a disco bar. There is no recent damage to Acht'amar - in spring 1998 I photographed and reported to the relevent authorities the severe damage to parts of the relief carving that occured in late 1997. quote:Of course it is very difficult to present the full situation of Armenian monuments on Turkish territory. Now many of them are located in such places where people are not allowed to go. Under such conditions to get facts about Armenian historical-cultural monuments that are on Turkish territory is very difficult. Nevertheless Azdak tried to give as precise information about the situation as possible- issuing a special appendix about the issue. All areas of Turkey are accessable, and always have been accessible (since the early 1980s anyway). It just depends on the amount of effort (physical and financial) that a person is willing to make. (From Armenians, is the amount of effort nil?) Steve
-
This whole Armenicum rubbish is just a sad sign of the collapse of Armenian science after the highs of the late Soviet period. It reminds me of Eastern European countries like Hungary or Poland - during the 1960s and 70s (after all the good scientists had left for the west) it was from these places that miracle "cures" for baldness, etc. seemed to always originate.
-
Will it be a nice easy road for all the new Azeri tanks (bought by American money) to travel along?
-
Ali - in this book, are the individuals specifically mentioned as being Armenian, or have you gone through the book picking out Armenian sounding names? steve
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: re the bells and coffee: 1. bells: people have hd bells since time immemorial, but the use of churchbells three times a day dates to what i had told in my earlier posting. my reference for that was 1) an entry i had read years ago at oxford, 2) an anglican priest, and 3) an article in "the economist" withinthe last five years. i am sure we can find someone who knows more about churches and bells, and ask him. can you ask an armenian, greek, american or some other priest? The oldest surviving bells known in Christendom are probably from Ireland and Scotland. Examples from the 8th century or earlier are known (they are hard to date exactly). These are hand held bells that look like very large cow-bells. They are known to exist at least as early as the 6th century (they are mentioned in manuscripts - and were objects held to have great ceremonial power and importance). Even bigger bells were mounted in very tall round towers, but no early examples survive. The use of bells arrived late in Anatolia - you can trace their expanding usage via dated buildings, such as the campanile-like bell tower in Trabzon, from 1427. There were several bell towers in Ani from a slightly earlier date (possibly due to Byzantine influence) - one is known from an inscription dated 1291.
-
Does anyone here know how long the name "Ani" has been in use as a womans name in Armenia. Does its usage date back earlier that the mid 19th century? Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by TigrannesIII: no, only turks should have to do that- seeing as how everything 'good' from that culture is stolen principally from Armenian and Greek culture. Look at all the cultural things that Armenia has "stolen" - little things like television, telephones, the internal combustion engine, electricity, trousers, and a few million other things. quote:Originally posted by Juggernaut: Thorny, I too would like to know what good has come out of Turkey, escpessially recently..... Er, what good has come out of Armenia, especially recently (like within the last 900 years). You are on the wrong track here. The best thing you can say of a country is that nothing particularly BAD has come out of it, and you would probably be correct to say that of Armenia.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: i agree with you. i have rarely seen a restoration in turkey (or pretty much anywhere else, in fact) that i preferred to the unrestored state of the monument in question. I'll try and post (in a day or so) some horror pictures of what has happened to the Ishakpasa palace near Dogubayazit. Steve
-
either don't touch it at all or hire some non-Turkish / non-Armenian experts (who will probably tell them to leave the building alone). There is not a single building in Turkey - Turkish or Armenian - that I know of that has been improved by a "restoration".
-
Or ....maybe the problem is that there has been too much silence already on all these (and countless other) atrocities. Steve
-
Experience tells me that that is the case when it concerns this subject! The idea that a group of fat urban living business-types could map even a fraction of "Armenian culture and historical sites in Turkey" is ludicrous. And we all should shudder at the prospects of the dreadful damage that their "restoration" of Ach'tamar will bring about. -------------------------------------------- TABDC Maps Armenian Culture-Historic Sites In Turkey YEREVAN(Armenpress) Kaan Soyak, the co-chairman of the Turkish-Armenian Business Development Committee (TABDC) said the TABDC has been mapping all Armenian culture and historical sites in Turkey for about one year, in order to start their repair and restoration. He said their efforts to map such sites in Eastern Turkey is nearing completion, praising Vergin Serob, a TABDC coordinator, for her contribution to the work. He also said theater construction for the restoration of medieval Armenian cathedral on Akhtamar Island have been under way for two months. The reconstruction efforts are financed by American-Armenian benefactor Hrair Hovnanian.
-
quote:Originally posted by Azat: I do see that, I think I misunderstood what you were saying originally. The old picture posted by Movses looks like the one I posted. Am I wrong? I can see that there are some differences, but it looks like the same church to me. BTW: I was in Armenia this past summer and was horrified at the reconstruction that had been done in the inside of Edchmiadsin. It looked horrible. It felt like I was in a Russian church. They had not even tried to restore the paint damage from years of Candle burning, but had just painted over the old. Yep, it is the same building - I was just trying to say that the state of the church before this new restoration was NOT the state shown in the old photo (the website says it was), and that there had been a restoration (or, more correctly, a consolidation) in the recent past which had ensured the preservation of the building.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: As a matter of a broad statement, I don't think that any of the historic monuments should be restored. It just erodes their historic significance. Time for a ticker-tape parade - MJ and I agree on something! Steve
-
MJ, would you please explain your strange, (bordering on obsessive) dislike of the word "khodja" - a word which, as far as I am aware, simply refers to a wealthy merchant. Steve
-
Untrained eye - you said it! Don't you see that the roof has been consolidated and all the missing stone tiles on the roof have been replaced (and that in the new "restoration" all those tiles, including the surviving original ones, have been ripped off and replaced by ones that do not have the characteristic ribbing). Also see how the missing gable on the south facade has been rebuilt. The Soviet restoration shows admirable restraint, only rebuilding those parts that are necessary to maintain the structural integrity of the original medieval structure. The ignorance of those involved in this new restoration is breathtaking - why did they just not go the whole way and demolish everything and rebuild anew - I bet there would be much more money to be made that way (for money making, be they by the contractors or the avaricious priests, is the only explanation for such vandalisim).
