Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. quote:Originally posted by Domino: This brings me to believe that there is attempt to sabotate Egoyans film, I don't know how, tht there is things tht dosen't make sens, the oppositions of the critics are too important, and even more important when for a same distinct ellement, there is complatly an opposition in the critics. I also remarked something the majority of those that have criticised the film, started with these rhetorics such as "Armenians says 1.5 million died and Turks says etc..." I may sound paranoiac Whether you are or are not I don't know - but you WILL sound paranoid to others. Has Egoyan suddenly become some sort of sacred cow, above any criticism, becasue his latest film happens to concern the Armenian genocide. Like everyone else here I have not seen the film, but if the reviews are correct in their details then the film does seem ludicrously over plotted. I didn't hear anyone saying that those who condemed the awful "Pearl Harbour" film were part of some secret Japanese plot, or those that criticised "Titanic" as a ghastly piece of kitch were part of a plot by cruise ship owners concerned about loosing business.
  2. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ali, here is my short answer to you. I still can not trust Karabekir memoirs, and even his honesty, for many reasons. ........ect. etc. etc. Domino, I don't see the point you are trying to make. Nothing you are quoting comes from Karabekir, and if you are saying Karabekir should be ignored because he is like those writers you have quoted then why are you quoting those writers if you hold that THEY should be ignored :-) But seriously, Karabekir, even where he is lying or distorting, will be valuable. An example just comes to mind, in one of the Turkish propaganda books, (Gurun's "Armenian File" I think), the author quotes a passage from Karabekir in which Karabekir writes that he personally put Britain's armistice representative in eastern Turkey, Col. Rawlinson, into "protective custody". This "protective custody" was actually a six month confinement in a concentration camp in Erzurum in which he almost starved to death and survived only because he was exchanged for Turkish war criminals on Malta. How can we point out such deliberate lies unless we study the writings of those that have produced them. Steve
  3. quote:Originally posted by Traveller:bellthecat wrote, "... there was no influence on European architecture!" Well-informed on Ani as he is, bellthecat is wrong here but I can't blame him for it :-) There is a signifant Armenian architectural influence on early Hungarian church architecture, especially in the X-XII centuries. Trav, I am interested, but back up your claims by mentioning specific buildings, and what features in these buildings you consider to be "Armenian". When Armenians talk about Armenian architecture having influenced European architecture it is influences on late Romanesque, Gothic or Baroque architecture that is normally being talked about. I presume that is what Der Manuelian was claiming since the phrase "subsequent European cathedrals" was used. This is the claim that I was saying has no basis in fact. (Though, since I have not seen the film in question, perhaps she is referring to earlier buildings in certain specific regions, in which case she is right to some extent). Obviously there HAS been an influence on European architecture if you are considering, for example, the territory of the Byzantine empire, or the early Kievan Russian state. As for Hungary - I don't know anything of the early period you are referring to. For later periods - the words of Cyril Mango (Byzantine Architecture, 1978) are worth considering: "The origin of the Moldavian dome has been the subject of much discussion. Since nothing of the kind is found in either Byzantine or Western architecture, scholars have been searching in other directions. The ever-useful Armenians have been pressed into service". Mango is being sarcastic here, seeing no reason why the dome could not have originated in Moldavia. Steve
  4. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:one more thing: about this trace wiping off business: there is still a good number of armenian monuments here and there (even though they are usually - not always- labelled under different names) and some of them (especially akhtamar) seem to be in quite good shape (better shape than some seljuk monuments nearby, actually). if there really was such a policy, how come they are still standing? cheers, Not really Ali, there is almost nothing left. Obviously a lot of the destruction is as a result of 85 years of decay, or expanding urban development, or people taking away stone for re-use, but a lot is deliberate. For instance, name me a single town or city (except Istanbul) that still has a pre-1915 Armenian graveyard - they have ALL been deliberately destroyed. Most Armenian building inscriptions on houses or on fountains have also been destroyed. If you see an old fountain with an empty square hollow in the masonry, that will have been where an Armenian inscription would have been - you can see this everywhere in Turkey. The most well known destruction of a church was the demolition using explosives of the monastery of Khtzkonk. It was destroyed by the Turkish army in the late 1950s. Today, the villagers there are a bit hazy on the actual date of destruction (they say it was in the 1970s) but still confirm its destruction was caused by the army. Achtamar was protected because it is on an island - but of the famous monastery of Narek that was only a few miles away, not a stone remains. (And 3 or 4 years ago even Achtamar was attacked by someone using a pickaxe). Its not even confined to Turkish territory - in the mid-1980s a Turkish army unit crossed the border into Syria to destroy an Armenian church in Kessab - their commander didn't like it that an Armenian church was visible from Turkey! Steve
  5. quote:Originally posted by Domino:I do not think it could have anything to do with erasing Armenian presence, erasing Armenian presence was planned years after. That is what I am presuming - that began to happen later, starting in the 1950s and 60s. Dadrian says Nur ordered that "the monuments of Ani be wiped off the face of the earth" saying that he (Karabekir) would "be rendering a great service to Turkey when you accomplish this goal". Obviously, the monuments of Ani were not "wiped off the face of the earth" but all traces of the Russian period excavations do seem to have been destroyed, presumably to remove any reason for Soviet archeologists to want to visit Ani. Dadrian, presumably going by what Karabekir writes, says that Nur's letter was sent in response to suspicions that soviet historians were spying on the Turks by pretending to study the ruins of Ani. However, this is not a credible reason as there would have been nothing to "spy" on - there is no strategic value to Ani, and there are and never have been any Turkish bases, etc, at or near Ani. Either the Turks had reverted to a society in which culture and history meant nothing and where anyone with the inexplicable wish to study such things obviously had to be doing something ilicit, or, like I said, they really they were just trying to remove legitimate reasons for Armenians to be within Turkish controlled territory. The second is probably the true reason, but the first is not impossible - to this day most Kurds in eastern Turkey are incapable of grasping the concept of someone being interested in an historical monument for its own sake. In their eyes you must be there to try and find the vast amounts of treasure that every Kurd (of whatever degree of education) seem to be genetically pre-programmed to believe lies under every old building. Steve
  6. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ask it to him. Steve, the newer edition would not add new stuff that the old had not, when these stuff are against the government position. Would it ? Which is why the older one should have been the one Dadrian consulted. But since he gives page numbers for later editions he could not have actually done so. Perhaps he did not know there was a difference in the various editions, I didn't until Ali told me.
  7. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:dear steve, i checked my copy of karabekir (printed 1959-1960, nebioğlu yayınevi copy no 661) this lunch break (i live walking distance from work). there is something completely different on page 905 and i have to go through the entire volume. well, almost, as the thing is more or less in chronological order. Thank you Ali. I'm interested if Karabekir says that there was actual destruction done, or if it didn't get further than a request from Ankara. I think there probably was destruction as almost all traces of the Russian excavations have vanished, including sections of buildings. But I wonder if it was done to remove evidence of Armenian presence in Turkish territory or remove a reason for Armenians to have an interest in that territory. Steve
  8. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ali, Dadrian is known to use orginal versions. Then why doesn't he cite the original in any of his references - after all, for the average non-Turkish reader the later editions will be just as hard to come by as the original?
  9. After looking the website I can't see any valid academic reason for this course to exist. Maybe it's only there to provide employment for those in the blossoming Armenian-genocide industry. The intro makes it clear that it is intended only for Armenians, this automatically nulifies its serious academic value. And what do they say it offers: It "offers instruction by a number of top scholars in the field". "Instruction" is not a word often used in university circles! Driving tutors instruct you, not academic lecturers! I guess they are using this word to preclude any chance of discussion or disagreement with the participants. "You will learn how your personal identity is influenced by issues of genocide and human rights" Another indications that it is for Armenians only. "You will be able to express yourself more effectively on issues of genocide and human rights". Translation - you will be able to spew out on demand the views you have been "instructed" are true and PC, without any actual thought process being involved. Or am I being too cynical as usual? But there is certainly a place for discussing the validity of these sort of events. I think I'll use this as reason to dissect what took place this year in Britain's "(happy) Genocide Day". I'll write something here soon. Steve
  10. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Yes in fact, I saw also this foote note from his work concerning the Implication of the physicians in the genocide I think. I also tried to find more without success. Yep - for those that are interested it is footnote 82, p192, in "The role of Turkish physicians in the World War 1 genocide of Ottoman Armenians" an article in "Holocaust and Genocide Studies", volume 1, 1986.
  11. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ali If Karabaekir memoirs are as "good" as Talaat one, then I don't need to read it. I suggest you to read the Armenian genocide in Turkish sources by Dadrian, or if you can't find it just tell it to me, I will send you an attach of the PDF in your email account. Memoirs of Turkish officials are as credible as a child story taking his night dreams to reality because he still dosnt know what is the difference between reality and dreams. For example Talaat memoirs were forged to the core, the author of his biography to the invitation of the editors of "Son Havadis" was asked to prove that Talaat memoirs were autentic, he declined probably knowing that Dr. B. Sakir "screened them" it was also recorded in German archive "Stchtung der Memoiren Talaat Pascha (Politische Abteilung III/Türkei PO 11 No. 3, File 1), communicated to the German Foreign Office on May 21, 1921. After the war, and the disolution by the Kemalists of the Turkish tribunal a real kind of "Gestapo" police was institutionalised to erase any left traces of the genocide from public record, manipulations of memoirs were done before their publication(Talaat one was an example like reported by the Germans). So I do not give any credibility over an alleged memoir from Karabekir. Domino, I think you may be unjustified in dismissing Karabekir's writings - after all, as you yourself admitted, Dadrian mentions him many times in his footnotes and sources. In the 1920s Karabekir narrowly escaped being murdered by Ataturk. (After discovering an assasination plot, Ataturk did a "september 11th" and decided to destroy his potentual enemies and rivals by falsely accusing them of being complicit in the plot). Karabekir was forced to retire from public life and he spent much of the remainder of his life writing his memoirs - although he is hardly likely to openly implicate himself or Turkey in genocide he did not have a reason to censor himself when writing about smaller, individual, incidents. Steve
  12. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: now this reading business is important, especially for those of you who can read turkish, because you will - just like the turks - fall into the trap of believing that the "istiklal harbimiz" of kazım karabekir that you buy at any shop in turkey is what he really wrote. well, it isn't, actually. you have to get your hands on the first edition, which was collected from circulation soon after it was published, and the sanitized version appeared a good deal later. i had first bought the second edition (which has the same dimensions, format, and cover, and only a tiny note somewhere thta it is the second edition), and had only read a few pages before i could get a copy of the first edition, and my second edition copy is in a box waiting to be sold now. Ali, I am interested in a passage in Karabekir's memoirs where he mentions instructions he got to destroy Armenian monuments at Ani, from a Dr Riza Nur in a letter dated 25th May 1921 - there is a short reference to it in one of Dadrian's footnotes, but Dadrian does not eloborate on it in depth (and he has not read the original edition). Dadrians reference is: "Istiklal Harbimiz" Istanbul 1969, p905. Is there anything about this event in the original edition you own? And what position did Riza Nur have in the Turkish government (All I know is that he was the deputy-head of the Turkish representatives at the Lausanne confence). Thanks Steve
  13. I thik you are over-reacting a bit. There are probably plenty of other places in the world that would quickly leap at the chance of hosting this museum - so given the choice of Yerevan having the museum or not then the answer probably should be to have it. It is not going to do any harm. Whether or not this person could have spent his money on something more beneficial than antique glass is a different issue - but turning oranges into glass is a neat alchemy trick!
  14. quote:Originally posted by Arpa:[QB I wish I had made a copy of that documentary on the Discovery channel in which a group of archeologists, some European and a Turk were digging in the region of Van when the Turk held up a stone tablet with Armenian inscriptions that I could read with great ease, when asked what language it was he looked into the camera and without even batting an eye said; "We don't know, it is an exotic and extinct writing that we have not deciphered yet.[/QB] It was not a Turk that said this, it was a stupid American "Noah's-ark-hunter", a minor "academic" from some hicksville American college if I remember rightly. (I have it on tape, but please have mercy and don't ask me to re-watch it!) It was on an Armenian gravestone that the American said was an anchor from the ark!!
  15. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: is there any study of the armenian properties appropriated by the turkish state after the events? if i remember correctly, there was a law back in 1920 that stipulated that the "abandoned goods" of the armenians be returned to them or their inheritors. that law was repealed by another law in 1922, which practically confiscated that property and later on distributed it (sold?) to turkish citizens. i am asking this because even though i keep hearing of these claims (most of which are no doubt true), i have yet to see a claim that rests on either documented evidence or gives reference to a study of the subject. i would be grateful if you can clarify. thanks in advance, yours, I remember seeing lots of abandoned and derelict or semi-derelict old houses in Trabzon on my first two visits to that place in the late 1980s, early 1990s. Presumably they were all Greek owned properties. When I revisited Trabzon in 1993 I found that they were all either being renovated or being demolished, which suggested to me at the time that some sort of time limit had passed and they were now considered to be abandoned property, but I never found out anything specific. However, I consider this emphasis on property rights to be very distasteful. It is just another example of rich and powerful wanting to remain rich and powerful and to hell with the poor. The vast majority of Armenian victims had no fixed property and had very little wealth, and I think that most of the diaspora stories about the vast estates and mansions they left behind in Turkey are at best just rose tinted memories - (or did only the rich survive?) Rich Jewish relatives of rich Jewish holocaust victims get their art treasures back yet the millions of dollars paid in compensation to the descendents of ordinary Jewish victims lie undistributed in the bank accounts of Jewish pressure groups. American relatives of victims of the pan-am flight blown up over Lockerbie are going to get millions in compensation from Libya, yet America pays nothing to the relatives of Iranian victims on the airliner shot down by the American navy a year earlier. It's all about power, and showing that the powerful have a God given right to remain eternally powerful, and nothing at all to do with justice. Steve
  16. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:From "The Economist": A harmless enough statement, you would think. Scientifically oriented among us may find it uplifting. But it immediately made me think "So if a society does not ponder such questions in the mentally disciplined way that high-energy particle physics or modern cosmology employs, they may be regarded as less worthy of defending?". Or for that matter, less worthy of caring about after they are decimated and gone. Next time you encounter "why should I care about your tragedies?" attitude from otherwise "enlightened" members of the Western civilization, think of how the Armenians and the other Near Easterners seem to them, and the above statement might shed some light on the situation. Hmmmm... you really have not a clue what he is talking about! - but maybe you are at the dawn rather than the twilight of your understanding. He is saying that a country (ANY country) that has the foresight to consider the pursuit of knowledge for knowledge's sake to be worthwhile is for THAT REASON a country and culture which is worth defending (by its own population). And he used the word DEFENDING, not the word DEFENDED. Given that many Armenians on this board have abandoned their homeland for the pursuit of short term, individual, material gain it is inadvisable to be attacking those that have the wisdom to think of higher things. Steve
  17. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Its easy for the Kurds to recognise something that will adventage them... when the big, big enemy is Turkey... but one wonder what they will say, or will they accept if Ararat, the same Ararat that Kurds consider the heart of their homeland is given to Armenia ? I agree Domino - but if there is ever a change in the current borders (which, anyway, I think is very unlikely to ever happen) then a likely scenario is that Ararat will become part of a self governing (or even independent) Kurdish state. Will the Kurds then give Ararat back to Armenia - don't bet on it! Steve
  18. quote:Originally posted by MosJan:a refugee minority within Armenia expresses its shame for having been unwitting participants in the events that led to the day of grief, April 24. Unwitting?!!! Actually, they willingly, joyfully, participated in the killings. They probably committed the majority of the actual "hands-on" killing (as opposed to those that deliberately sent Armenians into a situation where they would die of starvation, or dehydration, or at the hands of Kurds or Chechens). quote:Kurds involuntarily became participants in the Armenian Genocide.What historical fantasy does he believe in, or does the word "involuntarily" have a different meaning in Armenia! If you want to see who is using in public the concept of genocide in the pre-1914 Ottoman empire than look at the statements of Kurdish leaders, who were constantly making threats to massacre the Armenians living in "Kurdish" areas if they were ever to become politically equal to the the Kurds. quote:That is a black spot in our history, which we are trying to erase not by denying the fact of Kurds' involvement but vice versa," says Goran Mustafa, representative of the Kurdish Workers' Party in Armenia.Denying the facts seems to be exactly what he IS doing! quote:Kurds became a tool of death in the hands of Enver *****'s Turkish exterminators.Tools are inanimate objects. Guns are "tools" - they don't choose to fire on unarmed civilians. Knives are "tools" - they don't choose to slit throats. Hammers are "tools" - they don't choose to crush sculls. The Kurds using these "tools" did the choosing! They chose to willingly to kill, and kill, and kill, until there was no-one left to kill. quote:Both forcedly and by deceit and fraudulent promises Kurds were persuaded to slay and plunder dislocated groups of Armenians.Forcefully!!!!! Words almost fail me. How were they "forced"? What "promises" were they given? The only difference between what the Kurds did in 1915 and what they did in the decades (and centuries) before 1915 is in the scale of their killing. They needed no threats or inducements to do what had always come naturally. Nor did they just slay "dislocated groups" - they killed any Armenians living amongst them. quote:While (Christian) Armenians were being wiped out, the Kurds were being forced to adopt Islam and subsequently became de facto members of the Turkish onslaught.This deceit knows no end! The Kurds were the first Islamic nation in modern times to set out to deliberately exterminate all Christians living among them. This happened in what is now northern Iraq and Turkish Hakkari, in the 1830s. Only the invasion and intervention of the Ottoman army stopped every Christian there being murdered. The leaders of that genocide are still revered amongst Kurds to this day! And (thanks to American help and protection) since the 1990s their descendants in northern Iraq have now almost completed that genocide. quote:It is a legacy that has shamed Kurds for generations since - especially now, when the Kurds themselves are claiming persecution by the Turks.I really do not think Kurds know the meaning of the word shame. quote:"Until we have our own country, every day will be a genocide for us," says Kiarame Saiat, director of Kurdish programs broadcast on National Radio of Armenia.They certainly do not know the meaning of the word "genocide"! Steve
  19. Do you mean "Irish republic" or "Northern Ireland"! If it is the latter then there is a printed directory of Armenian addresses in Britain that will probably list everyone there. I don't have a copy to check it out - maybe someone here will, or you can buy it from here: http://www.caia.org.uk/content/itemsforsale.htm
  20. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:The show focused on Dr Lucy Manualian and her studies of Armenian Churches and monestaries and the influence of the Armenian architecture on subsequant European cathedrerals and the like. Hmmm ...that last bit must be rather short - since there was no influence on European architecture! quote:Also of note was a short piece concerning her great uncle (?) who had extensively documented Ani (for 20 years) around the turnm of the century. He sketched and painted a very many buildings - was frustrated that they were never published (in his lifetime)...etc etc Yes they were!!! The guy's name was Fetvadjian.Many of them were published in postcard form, I think they were also published in book form because there is a book by Fetvadjian called "The Ruins of Ani" published in venice in 1906. (I have not seen the book but it probably contains his paintings). Steve
  21. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:places like Manchester and London had Armenian populations at that time but did not have their own churches until the 20th century. Steve Sorry, not quite correct! There was a church built in 1870 in Manchester - but it looks (from the outside anyway) just like a typical Victorian church. Before that they rented space in another church (from 1863). Steve
  22. I've heard nothing. But I doubt if this is true. Why would there be an ancient Armenian church in Ireland? Although it depends what you mean by "ancient" - maybe it is just about possible if it was from the 19th century. But unlikely - after all, places like Manchester and London had Armenian populations at that time but did not have their own churches until the 20th century. Steve
  23. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:the Hai-Horoms, Armenians who belong to the Greek Orthodox Church, are almost never mentioned. What about Greeks who spoke Armenian and worshipped in Armenian churches? They are noted by some travellers in the Egin/Kemaliye region. Has anyone more info? Steve
  24. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: with all due respect (if you are referring to sinan), the architect in question was most probably not an armenian but a greek from ağırnas/bünyan/kayseri. that's what he wrote of himself in his "tezkiretül bünyan". true, there is popular folk memory that he was armenian, but available documents cast doubt on that (he may have been an armenian affiliated to the greek orthodox church, though). I don't have the information to hand - but I have read that there are specific documents that suggest he WAS Armenian, including letters by him to Armenians in his home village, and letters written to the Ottoman court intervening on behalf of Armenians in that district. But regarding your Bünyan village, I passed through this place a couple of years ago (I just saw it briefly from the bus window) - and thought I noticed a monument to Sinan in the village, which puzzled me because I have also met someone who specifically went to visit the village now called Mimarsinan near Kayseri because Sinan was said to have been born and lived there. So, which is the correct village? Steve PS Regarding "Turkish churches" - the imam of the new mosque now installed inside the 10th century Kars cathedral/Apostles church says, in all seriousness aparently, that it was built by "Christian Turks"!
  25. quote:Originally posted by MosJan:ARMENIA INTENDS TO BUY 3 ATOM BOMBS AND NUCLEAR DELIVERY VEHICLE FROM USA APRIL 1. The Armenian authorities applied to the USA to buy 3 atom bombs and nuclear delivery vehicle. According to information ARMINFO received today, April 1. However, it was later discovered, due to a quite unforgivable error in translation, that they had actually asked for three slightly radioactive pomegranates. :-) http://www.vestris.com/cgi-agnes/one/agnes...TMLArticle+3822
×
×
  • Create New...