Boghos
Members-
Posts
1,746 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Boghos
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ:Boghos, I agree very much with your assertions, except that I think the war with Iraq is very unlikely in the nearest future, unless Iraq does something truly outrageous - of the scale of the invasion of Kuwait. But, nevertheless, Iraq is the week nerve of the region, and the regional geopolitics is going to spiral around Iraq, in the near future. So far as the issue of Iraq exists, Turkey is going to be irreplaceable for the US, for example. The positioning of Iran in the region in this context is most unclear. So, I would predict a lot of realignment in the region in the coming decade. And in this context and in this period, God forbid Armenia is under the control of schizophrenics. Dear Martin, Iran is quite an interesting question mark. Apparently it is collaborating with US intelligence on terrorist matters, that is according to the Washington Post. Regardless of the stance of the more conservative members of the clergy and the government it seems that Iran's repositioning towards the West has become inevitable. It has been somewhat stalled by the current administration ridiculous posture and a few internal issues. I think longer term we should probably be more concerned with S. Arabia than Iran. We have a few cards, we should play them very carefully. [ August 13, 2002, 05:37 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Rubo:What being ahead means ? Simple: we have our country, let's consolidate it . Dear Boghos why should we consolidate our country? Meaning why should we give Karabagh back to Azerbaijan when the peace process is still going on and we might likely end up with a better deal. I already said once that Karabagh Armenians are the ones who can decide their future. If they decide they want to be ruled by Azerbaijan then it should be acceptable to all. International monitors and US did arrive in Karabagh to oversee the presidential elections. This is a very positive step. It demonstrates that even US is recognizing the Karabagh de facto independence perhaps not officially but nevertheless it could of refused to send monitors. Political gain and settlement issues are not separate from the people whose lives matter! I suggest take a vacation to Karabagh and talk to people there and see if they want to be ruled by Azeris. Regards Ruben Dear Ruben, I have been to Karabagh. But it is not necessary to go there in order to see that they do not want to be ruled by Azerbaijan. I am not saying give Karabagh back in a plate. I am saying that a compromise within reason is the logical outcome. But Armenia is far removed from any sort of foreign policy priority for any major country. So it will take time.
-
Dear Ali, It maybe that you are right in spite of all the evidence to the contrary. The Turkish Foreign Affairs Ministry has published booklets on the Armenian Question once in a while and the embassies have been somewhat instrumental in putting Turke's unsusteinable position forward. It is not by brainwashing people that you solve this problem. You seem to believe in some kind of Orwellian masterplan for this...quite funny, I must say. If the Turkish State would simply praise the Armenian heritage in the country, name historic places clearly as Armenian and introduce Armenians as one of the key Anatolian civilizations, for example, that would be a step in the right direction. [ August 11, 2002, 01:32 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ:Boghos, ... I also would like to join you in asserting that the very existence of the Republic of Armenia is endangered in perspective, unless its economy can be put back on tolerable, at least, tracks. Additionally, it is desperately short of a moral boost. However, I think very little depends on Armenia (or Karabagh, or even Azerbaijan and Turkey) at this juncture in history. In my view, our issues may be resolved only in the context of global regional processes and cooperation. At this time in history, it means the issue depends on the clash of the European and US interests in the global region, since the only solution that I can see is in the context of Globalization. Yes, I also think that any long lasting solution will only happen when a new architecure for what is called academically the International Systemtakes shape. The article you posted in "International" is very interesting and just a piece of this complex puzzle that mixes a difficult economic environment and a lack of leadership across the board in the international scene. As such Armenia is but a mere detail, and I believe were it not for the diaspora and its political weight, it would have had a much tougher time simply existing. The issue of Armenia-Karabagh-Azerbaijan is not relevant at present. The only issue that has some importance in the region is Iraq. And this is what has kept Turkey's position as a key ally (one of the most obvious evidences is the endless support of the IMF and other multilateral organizations). Chechnya has already been defined as a internal Russian matter. We have been lucky that Azerbaijani oil has been so far just a mirage. Furthermore there seems to exist no desire in Europe or America to antagonize Russia. So there is also no interest in playing the Turkey card by them in order to improve the situation, from an Armenian perspective, or otherwise any desire or interest to solve the Karabagh conflict. The worst trend, however, is unfolding before our eyes: the US economy seems to be in for some tough times. And with it the US agenda will focus on domestic issues. Wars only as a distraction.
-
quote:Originally posted by Rubo:Dear Bogos I would like to state my views, which are somewhat, differ. I do agree on compromise but that should be decided by Karabagh people as well. · Armenia and Karabagh have the definite advantage having won the independence by the lives of fifth teen thousand of our finest people, one has to question the wisdom of going back to status quote . · Azerbaijan is in no position to challenge Armenia or Karabagh and their population is slowly but surly are getting used to Azerbaijan without Karabagh despite of what empty threats Aliev makes. · Time is in our fever. We have the “goods” · One does not capitulate totally when one is ahead. · Turkish border issue is exaggerated, there is plenty of commerce going on right now even with “closed borders” · It is much more beneficial for Turkey to open borders with Armenian since their economy is in severe situation now. · If we stock up all these point, then we can see that Armenian has no reason to capitulate. I agree that Azerbaijan is in no position to threaten Armenia. But that is as far as we agree.I don't see why time is in our favor, quite the contrary, I am afraid. I am not saying we should rush into anything. But if we believe that a strong Armenia is the objective (an not an idyllic romanticized version of it), then we should move towards that in no uncertain terms. As to Turkey benefiting more than Armenia through open borders, that is simply not true. A handful of Turks may benefit, the Trabzon area merchants and politicians seem to be the most vocal. Armenia has about the size and the average income per capita (in purchasing power terms) of a mid-size Turkish city. It makes no difference to Turkey whatsoever, it is a political decision. Finally, I am not advocating capitulation, quite the contrary. Capitulation is not moving ahead, it is wasting valuable resources in causes that will in any case be dealt with in the future. It is a simple opportunity cost analysis. What being ahead means ? Simple: we have our country, let's consolidate it . We never possess as strong qualities as we believe, nor as large drawbacks. Let's not overplay our hand, nor obviously should we underplay it. Let's be realistic while we can and stop daydreaming. I have seen an incredible number of Armenians with a lot of potential. Many have not fulfilled it...Why ? They believed it was a gift of nature that they should be entitled to the best of everything. The world simply does not work like that. And they were lost in unessential fights and misunderstandings. We need focus.
-
I think one of the central points of Alpha's posting is what the ROA main agenda should be. It is quite obvious that embarking on territorial expansion dreams, and that is what they will remain for the foreseeable future, is plain foolishness. Karabagh should be dealt with in realistic terms and as soon as possible, main objectives being the protection of the integrity of Armenians and some kind of lasting peace (I harbour no dreams that Armenia and Armenians will be off screen for Turks, ever. Call me a pessimist, I prefer to be realistic.) As to Armenia itself, in spite of the fact that it is very desirable to see an improvement in civil society the main objective should be improving economic conditions and security. One can argue that development of civil society and economic growth go hand in hand. Yes, in an ideal world that is true, but coming back to reality: the agenda should be strengthen what we have beyond any doubt. As to the diaspora - ROA apparent dichotomy that has been hinted at several times here: of course there are such differences. But interests coincide either because views are similar, one has a stronger hand or one or both parties are to profit. And often a combination of these elements. In other words a complex reality, where there is no room to blame one or the other. Essentially, if the view that developing ROA in the most solid way possible does not take precedence I afraid that we'll be forever immersed in an unpleasant imbroglio. And even our survival as an independent nation might be threatened down the line. Some think that compromising is a show of weakness, I believe it is exactly the opposite. [ August 11, 2002, 04:03 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Accelerated:Khan, and Carsten Jancker (shaved head, 191cm striker) look like they have just been relieced from their duties at the Hitler Youth . Yes, but I don't think they have been relieved from duty...
-
The ghettos are slowly falling apart as the younger generation, with perhaps the exception of some disefranchised groups in California, sees that it is not possible to function properly in the real world being locked up in a self contained make believe sort of Armenian Disneyland. I think I am just repeating myself here as I do not believe that the diaspora has any future whatsoever. I believe in Armenia. There is no high calibre "snap out" intelligentsia in the diaspora because these talents are not interested in an ocean of hardheadeds know-it-alls "nationalists". It is too much effort for very likely poor results. I think we should think about the concept of a "secular" Armenian. In other words some one that is well aware of his roots but looks to the future in his own country.
-
Cher Aharon, that makes two of us. This Oliver Kahn is a good goalkeeper, but not better than Marcos or Dida or Rogerio. He is a clown.
-
Very good points, TB. I don't see the secular Armenian as an alternative to anything else, nor do I believe that we'll ever have them in any meaningful numbers. I just think that he/she exists and is the natural candidate to be the link between the country and the diaspora. I also take your point on the ghetto issue. A ghetto can even be helpful but firsthand evidence in the case of Armenian points to a different reality. So far. I think that there is a cultural issue here as well: while in the jewish ghetto the objective is/was to be better than anybody else, in the Armenian ghetto you have to be better than the other Armenians, or perceive yourself as being better than them. Harsh words, I admit, but no too far from the truth. Once again I don't believe in the diaspora, and you mentioned some of the reasons why we have not much staying power. As such the secular Armenian is the one that will play a similar role to the Irish and the Jews, to mention too influential groups in particular (diaspora) issues. How's the bread coming along ? [ July 02, 2002, 02:22 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
Hello Martin, Interesting topic indeed. I think one of the main problems of the dynamic that you referred to is that this "active" segment of the diaspora consciously or unconsciously drives out the most interesting "forces". They find a much better outlet in "odar" circles. On the other hand I think we should not be surprised by this. It is almost impossible to create a modern civil society within an "active" Armenian ghetto. Simply because the very reason for its existence is the closed-mindedness and passive xenophobia that prevails. Armenian communities are much more diverse and complex that at first sight. The "active" ones are mostly an inheritance of the Middle East and Iran (perhaps less so). Particularly the Lebanese who have been strongly influenced by the long story of conflicts and antagonism in Lebanon. The deep seated communities of mid-size cities in the US and France for example are very different. Their children have not been so brainwashed by pseudo-patriotic nonsense. Growing up as an Armenian, whatever that is, is in large part a reflection of your parents atittude to what the Armenian heritage represents. And hence your very important point about the burden that one typically carries or is assigned. We have to ditch the victim stygma without giving up the obvious truth. Perhaps that is the hardest part.
-
Hello, hello, On Ronaldo's haircut: his most interesting statement was that he was sure to be a nuisance to mothers as the kids were to immitate him...and he is right. Oliver Kahn being chosen the best player by FIFA is preposterous. But FIFA is just a mobbed up body.
-
Thank you. It was very nice watching the game and then going to Avenida Paulista and watch the people celebrate. Oliver Kahn got his medicine after publicly challenging Brazil. I hope this brings about an improvement in the country's soccer structure. That would mean that Brazil remains number one for years to com.
-
Yes, I have another guess: Brazil . Turkey was not bad but Rustu really saved the day.
-
KOCHARIAN AND ALIYEV READY TO SIGN A PEACE TREATY? - This conclusion is implied by the latest statements of the two Presidents [11-06-2002 'Karabagh Conflict'] "Zerkalo" newspaper (Azerbaijan) By R. Mirkadyrov "We are now in the final stage of finding the ultimate solution of the Karabagh problem", the Armenian President Robert Kocharian announced in his interview to "Sovetskaya Belarus". The Karabagh problem is one of the most sensitive ones in the South Caucasus. He also noted that "it is a lengthy conflict and is rooted in early last century". Robert Kocharian reminded that this issue is being actively discussed with the President of Azerbaijan. "A year ago we thought we were close to the solution. Yet something did not work", the President said. According to Robert Kocharian the details of its resolution by a mutual agreement are not disclosed, since the technology for solving such conflicts presupposes some closed part of the negotiations process. As the head of Armenia noted, it is done so as separate components are not pulled out from the whole pack and are not manipulated with. Robert Kocharian informed that there already exists an agreement with the Azerbaijan President Heydar Aliyev in the nearest future. "There is the will, there is also the activeness of the mediators to organize this meeting. We are truly very persistent in searching ways for solving the Karabagh problem", the President said. Robert Kocharian noted that in the issue of settling such conflicts, it is not enough to simply find a solution, "one must also find a political will, assistance of the international community, mediators for the practical implementation of the agreements achieved". "We are now at the final stage of finding a solution. Even if it is found, we will have very serious, difficult work on its practical realization", the President concluded. Practically at the same time, in unison with Kocharian several similar statements were made by Heydar Aliyev. Before leaving for Saint Petersburg, Aliyev answered the question of whether there is a necessity in holding an antiterrorist operation at the occupied territories, saying, "this is an unjustified opinion". "Holding a counterterrorism operation in the occupied territories will mean beginning a war", Aliyev said. Besides, according to Heydar Aliyev, the Presidents of the two countries must meet in the nearest future, and at this meeting it will become clear what concessions Armenia is ready to make. As to the date of the meeting, it is not known yet, the AR president said. "I do not think it will take place anywhere this month", Aliyev said. Further, in the course of his visit in Saint Petersburg, Heydar Aliyev also made several statements showing the peaceful attitude of the head of Azeri state. At the final press conference having touched upon the problem of international terrorism, the AR President said that our countries (Azerbaijan and Russia) had earlier than other countries come to face this evil, that has no motherland, no national or religious identity. "We understand better than everyone else that one cannot solve this question by purely power methods. Only an effective mutual dialogue of cultures and civilization can prevent this threat and eliminate the roots of this phenomenon once and for all", Heydar Aliyev thinks. Thus, speaking about terrorism, Mr. Aliyev apparently meant also the aggression of Armenia towards Azerbaijan. The fact that the head of the state thinks the solution of this question by purely power methods to be impossible is quite noteworthy. Further, the President, when answering the questions of Azeri journalists, actually discards the possibility of a counterterrorism attack on the occupied territories saying it was equivalent to starting a "war". In essence this statement by Heydar Aliyev almost fully resembles the situation of the early last year, when the whole world maintained that the parties were very close to signing a peace treaty. Then, during the discussion of the peaceful resolution options in the parliament, all the progovernmental politicians announced that the international community will never allow Azerbaijan to liberate the occupied territories by power, yet, after the failure of another negotiations cycle Heydar Aliyev started to say that the patience o! ! f Azeri society was close to its end and the people demanded that the occupied territories be liberated by force. The attitude of the President again made a turnaround of 180 degrees. It should be reminded here that at the current stage Heydar Aliyev himself was the initiator of accelerating the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan. As Araz Azimov stated during his visit to Washington, he, during the talks in Chechia passed the Armenia party the proposal of Aliyev to organize a meeting of Armenian and Azeri presidents. On this background the statements that one must not take the announcements of Kocharian about the "final stage of a search of solution to the Karabagh problem" seriously do not sound convincing. Besides, the OSCE Minsk Group is currently becoming apparently active. Its co-chairmen will meet in June in Lisbon. This was stated by the acting OSCE chairman, Portugal Foreign Minister Antonio Martins da Cruz. He also said he intended to discuss the Karabagh conflict resolution with the Russian administration during its visits to Moscow on June 27. Notably, Heydar Aliyev paid his visit to Saint Petersburg immediately after the summit between the Presidents of Russia and the USA, where Armenia and Azerbaijan were pointed out the necessity of compromise in the resolution of the Karabagh conflict. At this background an impression is formed that the OSCE Minsk group cochairmen are coming to Moscow to learn what the answer of Aliyev to the appeal of Bush and Putin is. In short, the information received by "Zerkalo" that Azerbaijan is experiencing pressure directed at inducing Baku to accept the unprofitable peace proposals is actually confirmed… -- Yerevan Press Club of Armenia, 'Yeni Nesil' Journalists' Union of Azerbaijan and Association of Diplomacy Correspondents of Turkey present 'Armenia-Azerbaijan-Turkey: Journalist Initiative-2002' Project. As a part of the project www.mediadialogue.org web site has been designed, featuring the most interesting publications from the press of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Turkey on issues of mutual concern. The latest updates on the site are weekly delivered to the subscribers.
-
Excellent. It will be my pleasure.
-
Yes, yes, Osheen Mosditchian...I know him very well. But Varujan Burmaian is not Armenia´s ambassador to Brazil, but the opposite, Brazil´s ambassador to Armenia. The rest is fairly OK. I was in Rio for the weekend. Excellent winter, temperature around 28 C and blue skies. You cansit on the beach the whole day on and you get a nice tan in a few days. Next diaspora conference I´ll be there .
-
"Osheen Mozdichian, 60, from Brazil, said: “The music of Ara Gevorgian touches us. The last time I was in Armenia was in 1992, when everything was darkness. Today I see not only Sardarapat but also all of Armenia wrapped in light." Friend of mine, from my father´s generation, have known him for a long time.
-
Dear Aghtchik, My most sincere admiration for your well balanced and coherent approach. Citizens democracy is exactly this you've shown us.
-
Well hagarag count me as another one who'll not bother anymore. So long.
-
That´s part of the changes they are implementing in order to join the EU .
-
Dear TB, First of all it is quite clear that I misread you. I think that even the concept of "leaders" (I thought previously that you were referring to someone like Bronfman, from the WJC) ie secular institutions that occupy the space of the church already exist and they cannot be called a success. Perhaps not a failure, but certainly not a success. The only type of institution that would really foster hayootioon in the diaspora is a high quality Armenian school. But this doesn[t replace the Church because of a different temporal dynamic. It is more wishful thinking than anything else. I guess I am going back to my previous stated point that the diaspora will inevitably disappear for practical purposes, it will be a complex process of immigration vs emigration combined with the melting point, but it will vanish. To be sure it might be able to stand alone in places where it is much more difficult to assimilate, but these are just exceptions. This is the pessimistic(some call it: realist) long term view. That does not mean that we should just cross our arms and wait for the debacle quite the contrary, but we should not fight a losing battle (even though we seem to like it). We should have focus and devote what we can: "from one according to his capacity, to one according to his needs" .
-
Originally posted by Twilight Bark: [[/qb]First, we have to make them want us I guess. How do you do that?[/QB] Nobody wants us and haragag hates us comfortable living Armenians. Another note: after NYC I went down to Palm Beach for a conference and then spent the weekend at Universal Studios, staying at the funniest fake Italian seaside village mockery I have ever seen. But I digress...I wanted to buy the villains t-shirts to bring over as gifts for my serious looking friends, you know Dastardly and a few others. They don't exist ! Oh, America, only purity and well meaning deeds . [ May 28, 2002, 02:26 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
I recently watched this movie that won a few prizes, I think even the Leon D´Or. The movie itself is interesting but nothing really worth writing home about (interesting expression...). But the soundtrack is really nice, especially the second song http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/clipserv...2629460-2084127 . By the way talking about India have people seen Peter Sells in "The Party", if I recall correctly. He portrays an Indian guest at a party (what else). Very funny if somewhat old.
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: I think the Armenian Church is a spent institution that should withdraw from a "leadership" position. I think that should happen even if there is a danger of leaving a "power vacuum" in the diaspora. The existence of the vacuum perhaps would provide a motivation for qualified leaders to appear. Hello TB, The leadership position of the AC in the diaspora has deteriorated significantly. It is now much more interested in aligning itself with the powers in Armenia proper. The Church failed to create cadres of a quality that would help maintaining its position in the diaspora. It has very little to offer to most diasporans except maybe for celebrating ritual acts. I think there is no vacuum at all, and there will never be. But that is a doctrinary position. We will not see any leaders arise simply because Armenians in the diaspora are not looking for a leader. Even if there was such a high caliber person that would make a "leader" he would probably do much better in an odar environment. Finally, a leader for what ? I think what we need is to have well established "processes": make sure that we are close to the people we need to be in a professional manner and help Armenian in any way we can. I think Armenia will improve very quickly once the perception that it is cleaning up its act prevails. We are not very close to that, but perhaps closer than in the past. The Armenian Church will always be there. Churches in many countries have played an important role in protecting democracy and human rights, this is not the nature of our church. Most of our churchmen see themselves as the guardians of "hayootion" and should be treated accordingly. Public servants without a real mission...But if there is a recommendation to them: "Do not disturb".
