Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. A common misconception is that there was one original view of Christianity that later branched out into several different interpretations. That view is usually put forward by those that look at the history of Christianity as the history of the Church, or Churches. Churches, as in Catholic Church, Armenian Apostolic Church are institutions created with the declared purpose of promoting Christianity, Christian values. They encourage this manicheistic view where the Church is some kind of moral reserve of society. I will not go much further for it is obvious that Churches are one of the various "actors" in the political scene. One needs only to look at the history of the Church, especially the Catholic Church during the Middle Ages, but I digress. My point is that the idea that there is some kind of doctrinary-insitutional monopoly, or for that matter oligopoly, on what Christianity proposes is utterly ridiculous. As Arpa has said Christianity in essence is very simple. There is hardly a need for an institution to intermediate. And perhaps there is nothing to be intermediated to in any case.
  2. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:The lack of awareness about the brother has probably been due to the Church's reluctance to advertise that "Virgin" Mary did not stay virgin forever, even if Immaculate Conception is accepted literally at face value. As I think was mentioned here a few times, this is an issue that was very much in discussion at the beginnings of Christianity. The smartest populists prevailed as myths are often easier to sell than reality.
  3. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:OK Boghos fine - truce? We disagree (somewhat) concerning Ali. All I have asked is to be a little nicer - certainly you don't have to be - this is up to you - and you can do as you wish - but I like Ali (and don't fully see your objections to him - is this because I understand the Turkish mind-set better then you - or vice versa or...who knows? - maybe saome of all...) - and yes - the idea of "good" (or at least rational/open minded) Turks (and/or non-Armenians in general with an interest in Armenians issues) being involved and contributing in this forum is something that I value. So I am for encouraging not discouraging behaviors. And like MJ says - we are a window to the rest of the world - and I would prefer (my bias is) that Armenans are seen as accepting at least somewhat of others and not just inward looking - unable to be flexible and such...but maybe I'm wrong (about Armenians...) - well I know Armenians away from this forum too...(and I'm also not disputing here that some of what Ali says may be offensive or incorrect etc)... BTW - my goal in publically opposing the Nick's etc of the world is not to convince them to believe that the Genocide actually happened. I know that no one can do that. It is to do my best to ensure that the fence sitters - be they Turks or whoever - who aren't sure of the facts - are not convinced the other way by the psuedo truths and outright lies of the other side. I happen to think this is a worthwhile effort (though am currently a bit btrnt out so I'm not so active on the boards of late...and of course there is a dearth of quality opposition!). Anyway I feel that I have at least a few success stories (that I am aware of - one of which is now very active doing "real" worthwhile work supporting Armenian Genocide and related causes). And even if by my opposition I cause the deniers to pause a bit and not be so zealous in spreading their lies - knowing I will show them for what they are - this too is a positive impact IMO. Domino deserves even more credit then I in this regard. But it is your right to believe otherwise I don't wish to dictate your thinking. However I do think it is something valuable and I think that any progress we make will be from the masses not necesarily the elites (and most of these masses don't reread...unless its phospher...). Truce.
  4. [ November 08, 2002, 06:08 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  5. [ November 08, 2002, 06:07 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  6. [ November 08, 2002, 06:06 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  7. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by Eduard Markosyan:ali, please...don't even go there. do you mean to insult the people's intelligence? do you talk about the same ozal who said "we'll remind the armenians 1915"? no one has ever seen changes in the turkish value system. you guys keep changing your mask, but your true identity ramains the same. in an interview to azeri newspaper 'zerkalo',, your new elected leader said 'the occupied territories must be returned to azerbaijan. and now the liberated artsak is an azeri's land, huh? do you guys value the land more than the people...is this guy calling for a war? hey, how about liberating the armenian territoris taken by the bloody bastards? what if we think about saving the armenian churches that are being destroyed for the past 80 years? eduard, 1. we don't wear masks, especially when dealing with the enemy (and you guys are not exactly in the friends category, you know that, don't you?). 2. i don't mean to insult anyone's intelligence or anything, but the following remarks may be offensive to some, even though that's not the intention (i repeat, that's not the intention): we are a major regional power 70 million strong. our current problems are great and many, but the armenian issue is not one of them. the armenian problem recurs only on every 24th april or whenever turkey attempts to get something from the eu/usa/russia that these guys don't want to give, or when they want to wrench something out of us that we don't want to give. you are a pawn in their hands. sorry to say this, but your interests are - and have never been - anyone else's priority (the same could of course be said of many other nations, including us). you have to realise that we don't have a problem with you, but you have a problem with us. i am one of those few turks who concede that we share by far the greater part of the blame in that "problem" (the ag), and are prepared to do what we can to solve/make good for it, but putting up with insults or arrogance on your part is not one of them. so i suggest you take a close look at us and just see: we don't have a mask, we have a face, it's an ugly one, especially seen from your perspective, but at least we are not trying to hide anything. we also do not see any need to hide anything from you, or plainly speaking, couldn't be bothered with it: you are not that important for us. sorry if this sounds offensive or arrogant (i intended neither), but things had to be put into the right perspective. regards, Ali, Ali, try to exercise some self-control old boy. Don´t let anger dominate you. I know you have a problem with that, but it is not healthy at all. The rules of the forum don´t mention anything about despicable people. But even if they did and hence would support your banishment, I would be against it. You amuse me. [ November 08, 2002, 05:07 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  8. It is true that many Armenians are anti-Turkey or anti-Turk or both. But that doesn´t mean that one should start with that as a premise when discussing Turkey with any Armenian, as you would be commiting the same mistake. I think your view of Latin America is outdated, very outdated. All the relevant countries have very little influence of the armed forces these days. The case of Brazil that you referred to and that I happen to know quite well is quite clear: the armed forces have gone back to the barracks and are not coming back. We could discuss this in great detail if you want. Historically the armed forces have been one of the few ways of advancement for the middle class, in social and political terms, this is no longer the case. Other countries: in Mexico the military have had very little importance over time. Chile is a case where the military are still somewhat influential, but not to the degree that it is in Turkey. Argentina: major headcount and budgetary reduction after the dictatorship ended, very little political influence. But my point is the acceptance of the military as the guardian of democracy even by liberal sectors of society is an example of how far Turkey is from an open society. Not the fact that the miltary may intervene in society. Moreover I was in Istanbul when Turkesh died, the newspapers treated it as the death of a nice old nationalist uncle. It is a society skewed to the right and with a military-militaristic bent. Further on Turkey and the EU: it would naturally benefit mostly Turkey. But the issues politically within Turkey are so tremendously complex and there is clearly no desire from all European countries to see Turkey in the EU, that it will not happen. Simple as that. Turkey interests me a lot. I have been to the country several times. There are many things that I like about it, many that I dislike and some that I abhorr. Relax chief, you have no monopoly on ethics and morality. [ November 07, 2002, 08:32 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  9. quote:Originally posted by Domino: quote: Turkey is an odd country where the guardians of democracy are the armed forces. Even many western educated and open minded Turks believe that the military have such an important role in preserving what they believe is democracy. This is such plain and obvious symptom of how far from any sort of democratic society Turkey is. Thats the clear sign of the Turkish society weakness, and the worst irony of all. How someone can be for democracy, and in the same time accept a such a militaristic control over a state, a military forces that has the control over a government that is supposed to be ellected to represent the population. Thats a form of a hidden dictatorial regime. On a brighter note, I am happy that an Islamic party has been elected, for sure islamic values are more human then Kemalistic nationalist sick mentalities, and if people think that by having elected an islamic party Turkey will close itself from the outside world, then I think they are disconnected from reality, moderate religigious values are far more compatible with the rest of the world than a Kemalistic nationalism and arrogance. The next intelligent step, would be for the government to put an end to this paranoia and over-exagerated militarisation of Turkey, and put the military as what it should be, rather than a government in itself. Excellent point. This has been one of the major issues in Turkish politics: how to break away from Kemalism but remaining in one piece. Self-ascribed "liberals" believe that the military can really protect democracy from the threat of so-called radical Islam. That´s ridiculous.
  10. Winston, The armed forces are not the "guardian" of democracy in any democratic country. They don´t unseat elected representatives nor ban parties. Of course democracies have numerous checks and balances. The Courts and the Legislative being the most obvious. They do not answer to the military. They are unlike many Latin American countries indeed. The military have next to no importance in most countries with the exception of Venezuela and a few other very minor players. If you have a different perspective and especially facts let´s have it. Not that this has any relevence to the discussion at hand. As to freedom of the press you seem to have a slightly biased position. Just look at any credible source for journalistic freedom. I will leave the issue of language aside for the moment but just remind you of a story of a Kurdish student that asked for a Kurdish language course and was jailed and tortured. After Turkey complied with EU demands, by the way. Shall I post the link ? Freedom exists mostly within Ataturk´s ideological legacy, whatever that is deemed to be. I understand your feelings of sympathy towards Turkey. But of course it blurs objectivity. What, if I may ask, is the danger of not having Turkey in the EU ? When I say "ever" I mean of course in a decent time frame, decades for example. "Never say never" is just a cliche.
  11. Turkey is an odd country where the guardians of democracy are the armed forces. Even many western educated and open minded Turks believe that the military have such an important role in preserving what they believe is democracy. This is such plain and obvious symptom of how far from any sort of democratic society Turkey is. As to EU, they should simply give up. They will never ever be accepted. The reasons are plentiful. It is just a minority of the middle and upper middle classes that live in a delusional state believing that their country will ever join the EU.
  12. Boghos

    Derenik/Ali

    quote:Originally posted by MJ:Thoth, You may disagree all you want. I know Gamavor personally. I have set with him not once, have spoken to him and have looked him in the eyes. If he is reactionary, then you and me are Eskimo. In fact, I would argue that he may be as liberal minded as you are. You are wrong if you think I have missed your point about the suffering of the common Chechen people. I empathize them all you want. I also empathize the sufferings of Azeris, Turks, Palestinians, Jews, Bangladeshi - you name it. But my utmost concern is for my Nation. My concern is not an idle tabloid concern for the sake of satisfaction of some ideological thirst. It doesn’t do much if I come to Internet and discharge by ventilating on how much “I am concerned about my neighbor,” when I have responsibility for my family. And this is not about Gamavor, you or me. This is about the wolves my nation is surrounded by. My neighborhood obligates me to be alert and mistrusting – there is not a single shred of argument that you can bring which would make me not feel that way – we have seen more than our share. And if you come to my house and advocate me to put my arms down, then I will just shut you as a provocateur and defeatist. Not because I am bloodthirsty. Quite the opposite – I hate blood. But I would not give anyone the opportunity to put me asleep and then to butcher my children. All this obviously is allegory. About the Chechens, again. For more than a decade Chechen bandits (and this are not handful but brigades and they are not transplanted from Mars but they come from the Culture of the common folk in Caucasian mountains) have terrorized Russia, they are on the frontiers of organized crime, have turned that capital of culture and science into medieval nightmare, they kill lawlessly on the streets, they rub, they impose “taxes” on all entrepreneurs. What makes them different from the rest of criminals is their viciousness – they take pleasure in killing. Neither their lives nor their victim’s lives have any value to them. They are brave on the streets of cities against the civilians but behave like chickens on the battlefields. They don’t fight like man but take pleasure in slitting someone’s throat. And when they are squeezed, they retreat to their mountains and play on the public sympathy and empathy pretending to fight for independence so that to garner international support. You say you are supporting their plight? Plight for what? What independence? Do you think they are interested in independence? Then you are as naïve as it gets. They no perfectly well that Chechnya has zero chance to exist based on the merits of economics. No economy is possible there if it is not for Russia. And they would not be able to plunder Russia if Chechnya is independent. All this ventilation about their independence is just wool in the eyes of the clueless like you. Do you really understand what is going on in Chechnya? Do you understand that there is one state that brings all that suffering on their common people – that is Turkey. Do you understand that has been going on for very long time. Cannot you see that Turkey c doesn’t give a damn about the Chechens and all it cares about is the creation of instability in the region so that the discussions of Russian pipeline cannot be discussed with any degree of seriousness. In fact, this is the only instance where Gamavor is fundamentally wrong. Oil companies have nothing to do with this. No investor of oil industry would put its money in a region such this. No drop of oil will flaw in this region unless there is a just and fair solution to the regional problems and unless regional security guaranties are established. This is the mistake of the Turkish Government – the game they play in Chechnya sets a precedent – they do it in Chechnya, Russians will do it in Georgia, and others will do it in Azerbaijan. For more than a decade the US government and the government of Turkey have lobbied Oil companies so that they invest in the Turkish pipeline. No Oil company has come forward. Guess what, the Oil industry is the most conservative industry that you can think of. No one in his right mind would put money in such a losing endeavor. So give me a break. Back to the subject of Homeland. Armenia is my spiritual Homeland. It is in my dreams. But I have pledged loyalty to the US without any hesitation and am equally proud of it. It doesn’t stop me from claiming ownership of Armenia, and I don’t need a Souvenir Passport, as eloquently put once by Boghos, to do so. About the trap. If you think I have nothing more rewarding to do but am wasting my time here by building trap for Domino, or whomever, I think you are losing your cool. I am trying to articulate some very basic things. I don’t think I am speaking complex language nor I am using complex logic. Everything I say is a simple as it gets. If someone doesn’t get it, it is for one reason only – it is not in his/her heart. About “helping Armenia” and “sending money.” You know what, I personally couldn’t care less about it. Even 12 years ago Armenians in Armenia had the resentment towards the Diaspora money due to their understanding that it is not going to help Armenia to stand on its feet and Armenia has to become not only self-sufficient but competitive. So give me a break again. Besides, I send money to place that you would not even imagine. I used to live in Moscow when the Mexico City earthquake happened. And I sent money there. I have sent money to Bangladesh or to variety of Police Fraternities or Orphans around the US. Don’t give me that garbage, please. What I am talking is not about helping Armenia. I am talking about feeling ownership over her. I don’t know how many times and how much simpler can I put it. About my dissatisfactions. Am I satisfied in my life? I have a pretty good life, beautiful family, outstanding career, incredible social and other opportunities. I will never be satisfied perhaps because my path is the infinity of self-perfection – intellectually and otherwise. It is a very dissatisfying journey no matter what. However, you see none of it. What you see is a deep dissatisfaction with this forum and the crap frequently contemplated here. If it was about someone’s personal thinking and respecting it, I would have no problem with it. But as I have said in the past, this is the Armenia Online – you like it or not. And as I have said once, “once you are on the stage, you are expected to perform adequately. Otherwise, leave the stage.” That’s all. Let me know when you are ready for us to tap into your cellar. Have to run. No time to read what I have written. It came as I felt. Taking personal issues aside for a moment, the essential content of Martin´s post (above) is perhaps one of the most important ever raised in this forum. However I am convinced that it is very diffcult if not impossible to discuss it to the extent that any meanignful result will come of it. Energies are mispent. The discussion of serious issues is turned into a boyscouts convention. Voluntarism is seen as an important venue for people like THOTH for whom Armenia is similar to Rotary Club or a curling team. The only reason we haven´t yet had a bake sale is because this is the internet, but we´ll get there. Winston, why don´t you travel to Armenia ? Maybe you´ll find out that it is perhaps not to your taste, or that it does not conform to your dreams. But let´s end this cheapening of important issues and ridiculous propositions coming from apparently serious and mature people. It´s quite alright that some of our people had quite naive positions at the end of the XIX century, beginning of the XX. But to act pathetically at this point in time is clearly a waste. Fortunately it does not have any serious implications.
  13. Boghos

    Derenik/Ali

    quote:Originally posted by THOTH: Let us take this oppurtunity to put Turkish fears to rest! That´s a great idea ! Winston ! Can you come up with any other cheap and useless slogans ? What else should we do ? Sing lullabies ? Oh, another Quijote: "Ah, ah, now I understand you, Sancho! Oh yes, lots of times, and I feel it coming right now. Get me out of this pickle, because it's already pretty messy in here!" Volume 1, Chapter 49, pg. 333
  14. Boghos

    Derenik/Ali

    Excerpts from Don Quijote that are quite appropriate for some of our "well intentioned" posters: "To tell you the truth...you've told one of the most novel tales ... anyone in the world has ever thought of, and the way you told it, and then ended it, is something never to be seen, and never ever seen, in the course of a lifetime, though I expected nothing less from your remarkable powers of reasoning." Volume 1, Chapter 20, pg. 114 "And so, to sum it all up, I perceive everything I say as absolutely true, and deficient in nothing whatever, and paint it all in my mind exactly as I want it to be." Volume 1, Chapter 25, pg. 157
  15. Boghos

    Why try?

    Thanks for the wishes.
  16. Boghos

    Why try?

    I always suspected that Sartres was Armenian...Now, I am sure. Well, this will be it for the moment, lest my wife finds out that I have been at HyeForum during vacation.
  17. Conversion of churches into mosques goes on even in our days: http://www.uk-christian.net/boc/97news3.shtml scroll down about 60%
  18. quote:As to Armenian churches being converdted to mosques, it will take at least four bulldozers to accomplish the job. Armenian churches have the cruciform shap and the altar invariably points to the east. [/QB]Bulldozers ? Sireli Arpa that shouldn´t be a problem...
  19. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by gamavor:Bellthecat, Please explain to me which part of my post is derogatory or offensive. To say something like this it should be a lie. Which part is not true. That turks "reshaped" many Armenian churches into mosques, that Ali's original family name steams probably from Turkmenistan, or the fact that turks are barbarians. Which one is not true? i tell you which ones: 1. i don't know of a single turkish mosque converted from an armenian mosque, probably with good reason, because as far as i can see the shape of the armenian churches would not support a muslim-style congregation. there are examples of greek churches turned into mosques, and some very early ottoman mosques scarcelyy distinguishable from byzantine churches, but this is at least partly because some greek shapes partially fit the need for muslim worship. if there are any armenian churches turned into mosques, please tell me which ones. 2. my original family name doesn't stem from turkmenistan. it stems from ürgüp in cappadocia. if this is going to make you happy, ürgüp is a corruption of the greek "procopios", which in turn is very likely to have been a corruption of some hittite or luwian name (i had seen in one - turkish - source that it came from the hittite "ur-kup" meaning soft stone, but since i know no hittite and haven't seen it elsewhere i take it with a huge grain of salt. 3. i won't get into yet another row about whether we are barbarians or not. it's getting boring. I also expect an intelligent discussion or at least an informed one. There have been several documented instances of Armenian churches being transformed into mosques. I am sure that Steve can provide you with an extensive least, otherwise you could simply look for yourself starting with the internet, for example here: http://armenianstudies.csufresno.edu/Archi...e/kars/kars.htm .
  20. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:i was expecting some intelligent discussion, all i got is a stream of insults again... Dear Mr. Urguplu, Kindly list the insults you refer to for the benefit of other forum members and/or visitors.
  21. In another thread Mr. Urguplu has referred to the limited education afforded to most of his compatriots. I recommend you read TB´s response to this and other of his assertions. I am glad to see that Turkey is moving into the right direction. Bringing education to its people. Teaching them the truth. Just imagine what would happen if German schools taught that the Holocaust was a fraud. This is the Turkey that wants to be admitted by the EU. Perhaps all topics for this theme should be made under the humour section. Turkish Daily News August 22, 2002 So-called Genocide Claims Will be Taught at Schools ANKARA -- The National Education Ministry has decided to teach issues related to so-called Armenian genocide claims as well as Greek-Pontus and Assyrians to elementary and high school pupils, starting from this semester. In this scope history and social studies teachers will be trained. Some 110 teachers will participate in training that will take place in Ankara. They will be taught the important points that should be give attention to when teaching. The book to be used during the studies will be, the one by Professor Yavuz Ercan from the Faculty of Language and History-Geography Department of Ankara University called, "Some issues and their reflections to today during the Ottoman Empire era". The aim of the curriculum is to make students more aware of the issues and lobby activities related to "Armenian Genocide Claims". The issues related to Greek-Pontus and Assyrians are also included in the project which will be applied to 5 and 7 grade pupils in elementary schools and all high school pupils. The five grade pupils will be given information on "Armenian Genocide Claims" and will be taught the Armenians' status in Turkey according to the Lausanne Treaty. More detailed information will be given to the seven grade pupils who will be taught the "Oriental Issue" and comprehend the politics of England, Russia and France in connection with the Ottoman Empire and the minorities in the Empire (Armenians). "Why did the Armenians bring up the genocide claims to the attention of the world again?" and "What are the aims of the Armenian terrorist organization ASALA's murders?" are the questions that are going to be answered during the lessons. In high schools, more detailed information on Armenians will be given along with issues relating to "Greek-Pontus and Assyrians". [ October 08, 2002, 03:07 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  22. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Boghos, Let’s assume that all new arriver Armenians have come to Armenia in 1946 – this is the worst case scenario. Those who where already adults, they were shaped people. They could’ve not become “little Stalins” in eight years. Those who where children, they were outside the reach of Stalinism and were under the influence of their parents, who under the worst case scenario would tell them to “shot their mouths” and not to speak. Either way, other than people being aware of the dangers, I don’t see them becoming little “Stalins.” Moreover, given that the post-war immigrants could not integrate with the “locals,” it would have been extremely difficult for them to be culturally transformed, as you mention it above, which is the truth. Either way, while a “loyal” fragment of the Armenian society has existed in Armenia – out of fear or careerism, Stalinism has never had any profound impact in Armenia (cannot speak about the 30s). I haven’t seen the documentary made by AGBU. The primary reason being that I consider the topic being a secondary importance in the Armenian landscape, as much as Armenians also, like others, have suffered from it. I take your point. But Stalinism which permeated the whole Soviet society, arts, science, etc did not simply disappear after the XX Party Congress. One of its most important legacies is the one party state and the lack of functioning institutions independent of it. Stalin created the beast, it only got softer over the years. In that sense the whole society was influenced by Stalinism. Now, if you are referring to the fact that in Armenia people never venerated Stalin such as you can find in as diverse places such as Tadzhikistan and small cities in Bulgaria, then, I have to agree. In any case my sense is that Armenians, by nature, are not driven into any sort of personality cult. At least of a political nature.
  23. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Here I have to agree with Steve. BTW, there is a nice documentary about Stalin and Stalinism in Armenia. You can get a copy at AGBU if you want. Do you mean the video "Enemy of the people"? I've got a copy. I have heard it cost the agbu a quarter of million dollars to produce - can't think how they could have spent that amount of money on it!!Yes, probably first class airfares, hotel and a little bit for film . But the interviews are sort of interesting, especially in light of the fact that there is so little material about it. Steve, this question has been asked several times in a way or another, but why are you so interested in Armenia and Armenians ? This is genuine curiosity.
×
×
  • Create New...