Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Boghos - good comments (I will refrain from further on the Hiroshima debate - only to say if one is questioning my position please read all that I said on thi issue) The US is disliked/hated for many reasons. Much of this is understandable (again for a variety of reasons) however much is severely misplaced IMO (some for the reaons that have already been stated here). Suffice to say that if the US did not exist in this world of ours here & now it would be a much much worse place. Can the Europeansd be trusted (not to appease the next Hitlwer, not to purely act in narrow self interest) - can the nasties be kept at bay? And the US is the engine that drives the world economy. I'm not discounting all the other activity - but a world without the US would be a poorer, more violent and more dangerous one for everyone IMO. Well Winston, let´s not get carried away here, "if the US didn´t exist, blah, blah" that is an impossible and unreasonable supposition. My analysis is ex-post.
  2. A few comments: - anti-americanism: based on ideological grounds, anti-imperialism etc - it should be no surprise to anyone that powers act as they act, it has been like this from time immemorial. I even think that of all hegemonic powers the UDS has been the least harmful to the rest of the world. More often that not it is used as an excuse to justify domestic failure in many countries. - anti-amercanism: based on envy - the European version of it. I have absolutely nothing against Europe, actually on the contrary, but let´s view things as they really are, Capitalism in its true form only exists in America and a few other places. It does improve standards of living. - anti-americanism: based on culture, especially american middle class consumerism and ignorance of world events - even though this is a personal issue, that is based on values that are very much open for discussion, it is a simplistic view of society. Most countries have similar middle classes, and on the other hand the US has a very sophisticated segment of worldly upper middle class people. Armenian anti-americanism - usually a phenomenon of recent immigrants that have diffculty adapting September 11 - well I guess there are so many things you can mourn that it is left to the individual to decide, but when all the other tragedies are used not to feel sorry for 9/11 it doesn´t sound right Hiroshima, atomic bomb - to believe that the decision was based on the cost of human lifes is to accept propaganda. WWII was very bloody, and humans are often not very nice, draw your own conclusion. Come on this was the country that interned its very own citizens of Japanese origin Being a diaspora Armenian - for me it entitles being a good Armenian, whatever that is but also a loyal citizen of your respective country, whatever that is, too [ September 18, 2002, 11:22 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  3. Boghos

    Soviet humour

    A while ago we had a thread on Radio Yerevan jokes. I found this site which has several pages on different types of jokes in the Soviet Union. If you are a fan I strongly recommend it. http://www.nctimes.net/~mark/htmjokes/
  4. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Well Boghos i agree that these various supposed counters to the Genocide such as claims of the sedition of Armenians are non-sensicle - but there are plenty of others who are swayed by such counter-charges etc. Thus I do see an obligation - as one who possesses some facts on thi sissue to debate the points. I know that you have expressed that you feel this is worthless and that there is no debate - I understand your position. But at the same time I beleive that left unchecked Turks and others will come to beleive that there is truth with these charges/excusses. Well I see some value in demonstrating otherwise. And I see value in diologue with Turks - and certainly not just on the Genocide issue - but certainly it is a primnary issue between Armeniasn and Turks and one that I think most Armenians are not satidfied with the status quo and wish for change (recognition and more...). I have full confidence that Ali is a Turk who is more progrssive in his views on this issue and could be a conduit to enact some change in the views of other Turks - I see this as a good thing. Are there some problems (form my perspective) with his views - yes And hads he recenty perhaps displayed some arrogance or combatitvness etc - yes Perhaps - but having read through the posts I certainly see that and more comming back at him. I think we Armenians are sometimes blind to how we come accross to others. that somehow our (certainly righteous) moral indignation is a sheild for us to shut out anything else - any other views or perspectives. Certainly Turks and others often express views that we obviously find distasteful and difficult to deal with - but Ali - for the most part does not strike me as someone who is just playing with us or such as you suggest. Heh - but you are an adult and are plenty bright enough to make up your own mind - just don't accuse me of being blind or weak or whatever it is youare saying just because I see this issue differently then you. So OK - we are both disapointed in one another....fine. I agree with some of your ideas. But I think we shouldn´t overestimate our role here. No hard feelings.
  5. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Well I'm sorry to hear you feel that way Boghos - and obviously I don't agree. Just a question or two though - Do you see any value at all in communication with Turks on this issue? If so which Turks? Are there really any out there who hold what you might consider to be acceptable views (outside perhaps the Taner Ackams - who obviously apeal to us but aren't hardly in good graces with his/their own...) Yes, of course I see value in communicating with Turks. I see value in discussing a number of issues but very little when it comes to AG. I much prefer someone like Filiz who has a clear, simple position rather than all this pseudo-enlightened pretensely politically correct debate. You see this is not the UN club at Jefferson High, and we are not going to solve anything here. Ali and I are alumni of the same school system, indeed one devoted to international understanding, we simply have a different outlook and moral stand. Armenia is not my pet project, I am not an internet warrior. I am just an Armenian interested in my people and my country wherever they are. If you find comfort in the fact that Ali is more reasonable than other Turks you have met around, so be it. We should be more interested in Armenia and Armenians than in Turkey. I have Turkish friends as I have Argentine or Canadian friends. But I am not going to waste time trying to sound cute on the Net by being friendly to Turks (and implying that I am a warm soul trying to solve the world problems). You seem to believe that there should be a special place for Turks just because they choose to come here. I do not. Needles to say realism is essential when it comes to politics, that is precisely the reason why AG is not up for discussion. Common sense and some knowledge of history tells you everything you need to know about it. It is a fact and not subject to this idiotic sedition charges. It is quite a pity that you miss out on the essence of what has been recently discussed here. I do not want to sound harsh, but your attitude belittles our history, you just don´t realize it, or feel it. But enough is enough, we have met in this and other forae several times, I thought my positions were quite clear. I guess I was wrong.
  6. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Well I'm sorry to hear you feel that way Boghos - and obviously I don't agree. Just a question or two though - Do you see any value at all in communication with Turks on this issue? If so which Turks? Are there really any out there who hold what you might consider to be acceptable views (outside perhaps the Taner Ackams - who obviously apeal to us but aren't hardly in good graces with his/their own...) Yes, of course I see value in communicating with Turks. I see value in discussing a number of issues but very little when it comes to AG. I much prefer someone like Filiz who has a clear, simple position rather than all this pseudo-enlightened pretensely politically correct debate. You see this is not the UN club at Jefferson High, and we are not going to solve anything here. Ali and I are alumni of the same school system, indeed one devoted to international understanding, we simply have a different outlook and moral stand. Armenia is not my pet project, I am not an internet warrior. I am just an Armenian interested in my people and my country wherever they are. If you find comfort in the fact that Ali is more reasonable than other Turks you have met around, so be it. We should be more interested in Armenia and Armenians than in Turkey. I have Turkish friends as I have Argentine or Canadian friends. But I am not going to waste time trying to sound cute on the Net by being friendly to Turks (and implying that I am a warm soul trying to solve the world problems). You seem to believe that there should be a special place for Turks just because they choose to come here. I do not. Needles to say realism is essential when it comes to politics, that is precisely the reason why AG is not up for discussion. Common sense and some knowledge of history tells you everything you need to know about it. It is a fact and not subject to this idiotic sedition charges. It is quite a pity that you miss out on the essence of what has been recently discussed here. I do not want to sound harsh, but your attitude belittles our history, you just don´t realize it, or feel it. But enough is enough, we have met in this and other forae several times, I thought my positions were quite clear. I guess I was wrong.
  7. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:I am particualrly disapointed in your increasingly hostile tone Boghos. Sure - Ali may hold some views that we as Armenians find offensive...but don't tell me you've never shown the bottom of your shoe to an Arab! And yes - we should be concerned with offending Turks - as not all are truly deniers in any informed sense - they are people - our brothers even in a sense - and regardless our conduct reflects who we are - and it disgusts me to see us emulate that which we claim to despise. Regardless of our differences civility (except perhaps with the most blatant types) is always called for - and I think that we must learn how tro cooperate with the Ali's of Turkey - and here with Ali in particualr - I mean really now - look what he is saying - it is in no way so unreasonable - in fact I comend him for his (core) positions on the Genocide. Lets not pass up the oppurtunity for dialouge and being able to appreciate perspectives other then our own. Let be civil - and stop the nastiness - it is uncalled for (with Ali) - IM(VSH)O. Winston, I am once more disappointed but not susprised with your stance. People much more patient and articulated than me have already responded to Ali (TBs most recent post, and also Arpa, a gift to this forum). I see no value in a dialogue with Ali just because he is a Turk. I do not choose my interlocutors based on race, faith or whatever, that is quite obvious. I have already made very clear my views that he simply doesn´t know enough about the issues at hand and his often revealed aggressive posture shows his contempt for Armenians and an undertone of cruelty. He is just a sad punk with too much time on his hands making a fool of people like you. I do not time for that and find it quite insulting. I have even less time for those self ascribed protectors of good values and morality. False prophets.
  8. Ali, it was you who wrote: "...and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide". It is part of a larger text of yours reproduced above. I will not comment much further except for saying that this is the usual accusation against Armenians: sedition. Not counting the overtone. So give up your righteous nonsense. I will not bother anymore. Good bye.
  9. Oh and by the way, while I am waiting for your book please send me your address so I can send you a copy of your biography. It is called Medzabadiv Muratsganer .
  10. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Ali, Please notice that YOU are not the only one being insulted here. I have received similar treatment. This behavior is based in the Armenian psyche, of professing to be "HOLIER THAN THOU." It is a bunch of hogwash and has gotten Armenians into trouble throughout the centuries. I ask again, why did an Italian doctor in the employ of the Ittihadists get so much pleasure in torturing Armenian priests? His family had lived in Istambul for centuries, and his family were Christians. What was it about the Armenian priests approach that had enraged him so? In the absence of any government or other institutions for centuries, the clergy formed the Armenian psyche. The warp in the Armenia psyche emanates from this. Am I right in getting the impression that the Armenian priests that you say were tortured by this Italian doctor were rightly so ? that it was the priests fault ?
  11. Ali, There is hardly anybody in this forum that has been proven wrong so many times as you, trying to show knowledge that you clearly do not possess. But this is not an issue of knowledge, it is a moral issue. As you have written: "a millennium ago, you endured the sword (a sword is not gobbledygook, it is always very clear what it is), then you endured the rule (that was also very clear, i guess), then in the 19th century you endured a sharply deteriorating condition (that was also very clear, i guess), hamidian massacres (i won't ask whether these were clear or not), a brief partnership in the young turk regime in which you preferred to keep an ambiguous position), and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide" You are an angry young man...I can even have sympathy for the sad state that you find yourself in. But this is not a place for online therapy.
  12. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:dear arpa, i must confess i didn't quite understand what your point was, so i am afraid i cannot furnish a reply (if there's anyone out there who understood, could you please explain?) cheers, First of all I must say it is nice to have an Oxford self-appointed scholar from Turkey here. It goes without saying that the ability to comprehend is essential to any student of languages. Or anything else. I do not wish to be an interpreter of Arpa´s words, just to add on what he wrote. It seems to me that generally speaking you were well received at this forum. It is true that once in a while there have been unreasonable posts directed to you. But this is not just your privilege, it is just a fact of life in this and other forums. People such as TB, MJ and Arpa among others have discussed several issues with you in the best possible faith. What has disturbed some is the fact that even though you have discarded the ludicrous arrogance that you initially displayed, that you seem to be here to mock. And mock what many perceive to be very serious issues. Essentially to mock Armenians. I prefer those that come and state their case very clearly, and also those that have some sort of emotional balance. You fail in both cases, I am afraid. You go from praising the sword to preaching love and peace. This psychological phenomenon has been well documented, but I will not dive into it. For all practical purposes my sense is that you act out a deep seated sentiment of insecurity and inferiority and you try lessen that through mockery. This is not unlike many of your countrymen, in Turkey and abroad. Reflected in how Turkey behaves as a state, as well. It is a pity, but that´s how it is. My grandfather never hated Turks, nor obviously taught us to hate them. Now I understand why. Out of compassion. [ September 11, 2002, 08:03 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  13. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:boghos, thanks for the summary. allow me to give my version: aurguplu (personal): ag recognition & compensation & resettlement. will deal with land claims separately. turkey: denial until land claims drop (or until we together with azerbaijan are the only two states left to deny it). ostrich mentality. roa: ag recognition, compensation, opening up the borders, normalisation of relations. unclear position re land claims. diaspora: diverse. ag recognition (all), compensation (almost all), land claims (may be not the majority, but enough to block the issue), resettlement (almost none). proposed solution (to be discussed behind closed doors): sequence of events: 1. roa makes clear statement that i) it does not and will not harbour land claims, and ii) will not support diaspora claims to this effect. 2. representative diaspora organisations drop land claims from agenda of political goals to be pursued. 3. turkey recognises ag, apologises, agrees to pay compensation germany-style, and returns property to individuals (not roa) wherever feasible, allows resettlement. 4. relations between roa and tr normalised, trade booms. question: who thinks the russians will just watch this, and how come? thanks, I think we differ on the sequence of events. Turkey´s genocide denial is not related to non-existent land claims...
  14. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: If you need a consultant on how to use the services of the German welfare state, go to Kreuzberg. This is a fact.
  15. Summary: aurguplu - AG recognition for giving up land claims Turkey - denial campaign ROA - AG recognition and a few economic concessions, no land claims diaspora - there is no unified position, realistic: AG recognition and a few economic concessions See ? [ September 10, 2002, 09:08 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  16. Boghos

    Last Name

    Giragos...even Hagop Baronian has written a small description of someone called Giragos. Here in Brazil they translate it to tye equivalent of Sunday in Portuguese, which may not be a very common name but at least it is not funny . Well, there are a few interesting (not to say funny) first names in name such as Partoghomios. But nothing beats the Soviet realist names...which were already discussed in a thread here.
  17. Boghos

    ArmeniaNow

    The good people that used to work at ArmeniaWeek have launched their own website called ArmeniaNow. The format is the same. There is a letter explaining why they decided to leave. In any case for the time being both sites survive.
  18. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, You have repeated several times in this forum that the Turkish government is preparing the population for AG recognition. Nevertheless all we, poor mortals, have been able to see points to the opposite. Turkey´s line is: let´s repeat the lie over and over again. And even give it a varnish of respectability by funding "academics" in Turkey and abroad. Turks in their vast majority not only deny that the AG took place but also have ill fellings towards Armenians. It is hard to believe that it would be in any Turkish politician interest to put forward this kind of proposition. Much less the military, for obvious reasons. This sounds exceedingly like some sort of conspiracy theory. It simply does not exist. Now, if you could present some concrete evidence of what you have been defending things would change dramatically. Who knows, we, the very organized, rich, powerful, influential, omniscient and omnipresent diaspora, could give you a hand. This whole discussion is not moving forward because you fail to understand what Armenian wants and that the diaspora is mostly irrelevant when it comes to important decisions. Turkey´s line that the Armenian diaspora is all powerful and magnificent, that you swallow so easily, is simply borrowing from the same arguments that is made about the jews almost everywhere. It is just a more comical and farcical version of it. Issues in Armeno-Turkish relations are not that complex. Actually they are quite simple. The solution, however is rather difficult because Turkey is very far from feeling secure about itself in almost all matters. dear boghos, 1. i have lately been talking to some People Who Would Know re turkey's evolving stance over the ag issue, and they said the observed the same thing. let me tell you the concrete pieces of evidence that i can think of: i) i have been to this forum for the past two years, which i do not doubt for a second that the turkish security checks in on and off, and have survived so far, and neither me nor anyone i know have been molested/made life difficult for or anything like that. ii) there are an increasing number of turks who are having similar experiences, iii) for the past few years, genocide-related material giving the armenian version of events has been freely entering turkey and even translated into turkish and has not been removed from circulation iv) some turkish armenians have referred in public to "a tragedy" that their nation had experienced that the turkish state has not yet addressed properly (e.g. hrant dink of agos): these same individuals are still alive and well and functioning as they did before v) a turkish minister from a very senior family wrote a book called "the beads of salkım hanım" narrating the story of the infamous property tax of the wwii period, where a main character, a jewish person, was changed to an armenian one (leon to levon) by the (armenian) director of the movie (etyen mahçupyan) and references were made to 1915, although it created great hype, no-one had a brush with the law, vi) roald grigor-souny gave a few lectures at turkish universities giving the armenian version of events. he wasn't shouted out, but after the lecture some from the turkish audience gave their accouns they had heard from their grandparents about how the armenians in their district were killed. nobody got to meet the police after that, vii) halil berktay gave an interview to a high circulation newspaper in which he described the CUP guys as the ancestors of our modern susurluk guys (you know what i mean if you follow turkish affairs). the article appeared as a centrefold double-page spread (or was it single page?) and halil berktay, the interviewer and the newspaper are still alive and kicking. viii) zülfü livaneli, a popular ex-communist singer, political activist and columnist, published an article where he asked the question of "for how long more are we to pay for the crimes of the ittihadists" ix) atlas, the turkish version of the national geographic, produced an issue mainly devoted to 1915 (with that title) where a glimpse of a highly unofficial version of the story can be read between, and sometimes directly on, the lines, and finally x) a senior politician, one of Those Who Know (forgot his name) had characterised the change from leon to levon in the salkım hanım movie (see v) as "a part of a greater plan to psychologically prepare the nation to the fact that what had happened to the armenians was a genocide". i think these are enough to show that some very serious changes are taking place in this country. the fact that almost all of the above took place in the last two years is a point that strenghtens my argument. as far as the still lingering turkish official position is concerned, i derscibe it as controlled retreat: it would be a very foolhardy state to acknowledge such a thing before having properly prepared the nation's psyche for it. as far as the diaspora is concerned, we are first and foremost busy with the american and french diasporas. i had never heard of the brazilian or dutch diaspora, for instance. it may be because these two countries, especially the usa, are of paramount importance to turkish interests, and the diaspora there is the largest, most vocal, richest, most powerful, and most dedicated. we are especially uneasy with the fact that some diaspora members have big stakes in the american media and entertainment industry (kirk kirkorian for instance). we see this as a weapon that can be used in propaganda warfare. you may of course point out here that until ararat, not a single movie (or am i wrong) was actually made on the subject, and i may agree that we are perhaps exaggerating this threat. but still, it is there. as far as the comparison with the jewish diaspora is concerned, i stick to my argument. do you honestly believe that israel could survive for one day in the middle east without american support, and that there would be that much american support for it in view of the most blatant excesses they have comitted against the palestinians, especially recently, if there were not a very rich and powerful jewish lobby in america dedicated to the cause of aliyah? cheers, The fact that people are not being murdered by stating the historical truth is probably an improvement. But not exactly proof that the state is preparing the population for AG recognition. Or is it not Turkey the country that recently created an "institute" of Armenian studies, and whose embassies protest all over the world against the AG ? Morevoer books such as "Jenosit" by Dadrian were not published in the last two years, but before. Similarly, Kurdish revolutionary groups such as Kizilirmak and Yorum have had their CDs sold openly for years, but that does not mean that the Kurdish question was about to be resolved. You see there is a big difference between given access to a few irrelevant intellectuals to material on AG and "preparing the population for AG recognition". That is just tokenism. On the diaspora: first of all I never said that the Brazilian or Dutch or Singaporean diasporas were relevant or irrelevant. If by saying that you were trying to disqualify me as a source, by saying that the American and French diasporas are what really matters, implying that I shouldn't know, well, welcome to your "scholar" world. In any case, I am just saying that the role of the diaspora is overplayed by Turkey for obvious reasons and you swallow the bait. I think you have acknowledged that yourself to a certain extent. I do agree that the diaspora has been important for Israel. It has also been important for Armenia. But that does not mean that it dictates foreign policy. I can cite several instances where Israel acted without the knowledge of the US and sometimes even against it. Yes, the diaspora has helped lobbying in Washington and Paris. But it is much weaker than you seem to think. It is helped in Europe by the uneasy feelings animosity that most European countries have for Turkey. I can however understand where you are coming from: a product of Kemalist brainwashing and the longstanding paranoia of a still dying empire surrounded by unfriendly neighbours. I don't mean in a bad or insulting way, it is simply how things are. Just a few words on the Susurluk vs CUP analogy: I admit I don't know the context this was said but more often than not these comments have the underlying theme of "how great, tolerant and peaceful the OE was" and was spoiled by those mafiosi. The myth of the OE is another sickness that doesn't seem to go away. Dear Ali, I realize you are a good person, but believeing on what you want to believe, through some fallacy of composition, and being privy to information from "people in the know" are signs that a rest is merited and perhaps a bit more. [ August 23, 2002, 02:26 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  19. Dear Ali, You have repeated several times in this forum that the Turkish government is preparing the population for AG recognition. Nevertheless all we, poor mortals, have been able to see points to the opposite. Turkey´s line is: let´s repeat the lie over and over again. And even give it a varnish of respectability by funding "academics" in Turkey and abroad. Turks in their vast majority not only deny that the AG took place but also have ill fellings towards Armenians. It is hard to believe that it would be in any Turkish politician interest to put forward this kind of proposition. Much less the military, for obvious reasons. This sounds exceedingly like some sort of conspiracy theory. It simply does not exist. Now, if you could present some concrete evidence of what you have been defending things would change dramatically. Who knows, we, the very organized, rich, powerful, influential, omniscient and omnipresent diaspora, could give you a hand. This whole discussion is not moving forward because you fail to understand what Armenian wants and that the diaspora is mostly irrelevant when it comes to important decisions. Turkey´s line that the Armenian diaspora is all powerful and magnificent, that you swallow so easily, is simply borrowing from the same arguments that is made about the jews almost everywhere. It is just a more comical and farcical version of it. Issues in Armeno-Turkish relations are not that complex. Actually they are quite simple. The solution, however is rather difficult because Turkey is very far from feeling secure about itself in almost all matters.
  20. Boghos

    GAVUR/GAVAR

    quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:There is an interesting article about "gavur" at the very end of this page I just don´t know if it is legal for Ali to read it... Very good Boghos. I'll save that article with all the cliches about gavur. However they left one out; "Gavurun son akli benim olsun"(I wish I could have the gavur's last thought/idea). It is another version of monday morning quarterbacking.BTW; Is that site Kurdish? Yes, it is a Kurdish site.
  21. Boghos

    GAVUR/GAVAR

    There is an interesting article about "gavur" at the very end of this page: http://www.ozgurpolitika.org/1999/12/15/allkosb.html I just don´t know if it is legal for Ali to read it...
  22. Boghos

    TURKEY, THE BIRD

    The scientific name of the wild turkey is meleagris gallopavo. In Spanish, turkey is "pavo". As Arpa has already said in French it is "dinde" which points to the same ethymology as a number of other languages including Armenian, Turkish. It is interesting however that among three important romance languages: French, Spanish and Portuguese languages the origins for "turkey" are clearly different. Nice trivia question is: what country has the same name as a bird in one language, whereas the same bird is the name of a country in another ? I am sure that those that are better versed in English than me could write this in a nicer way.
  23. Boghos

    TURKEY, THE BIRD

    Dear Arpa, Let's make things a tad more interesting. In Portuguese, turkey is "peru".
  24. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by Arpa:PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT I HAVE NOT READ MAJORITY OF THE POSTS IN THIS CATEGORY. BUT THEN AGAIN I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO. I HAVE WITNESSED SUCH EXCHANGES NUMEROUS TIMES. TO ME IT IS AN EXCERCISE IN FUTILITY. I HAVE ALSO HEARD THAT SUCH EXCHANGES ARE A "DIALOGUE". NOT IN MY VOCABULARY. TWO MONOLOGUES DO NOT A DIALOGUE MAKE!!! WE WILL GET OUR TURN OF MONOLOGUE TOO. THERE IS ONLY ONE WAY OUT OF THIS QUAGMIRE. THAT IS "IN KIND". UNTIL THEN WE WILL ABIDE BY THE WORDS OF THAT GREAT AMERICAN PHILOSOPHER TEDDY ROOSEVELT; "WALK SOFTLY AND CARRY A BIG STICK". WE MAY NOT HAVE A BIG STICK YET. WE HAVE ENDURED THIS TURKISH GOBBLEDIGOOK FOR A MILLENIUM WE CAN WAIT A FEW MORE YEARS. UNTIL THEN "MUMS' THE WORD" arpa, 1. that wasn't a monologue but a dialogue. both parties were clear in their positions. the fact that they didn't agree doesn't turn it into a monologue. it has just been a dialogue with no results. you do run such a risk when you get into a dialogue. 2. you haven't endured any turkish gobbldygook for a millennium. a millennium ago, you endured the sword (a sword is not gobbledygook, it is always very clear what it is), then you endured the rule (that was also very clear, i guess), then in the 19th century you endured a sharply deteriorating condition (that was also very clear, i guess), hamidian massacres (i won't ask whether these were clear or not), a brief partnership in the young turk regime in which you preferred to keep an ambiguous position), and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide. any gobbledygook you might have endured dates from the post 1915-23 period, when the turkish state systematically denied what happened to your people. as i am sick and tired of repeating my position re the genocide and its denial once more, i won't get into that. you have never endured any gobbledygook regarding the land issue: you had a very clear answer: no. as far as we are concerned there isn't one. you can create one of course, by putting your nation at great peril. the greeks tried it in 1919-22, and then in 150s-1974 (cyprus), and have found out that there are certain lines you just can't cross. as far as you suggestion concerning the expansion of armenian military capability and the get even with us, i say you would be wasting your precious resources for a dubious adventure that will probably cost you more than it isa worth even if you win: it may very well be a pyrrhic victory. as turkey has no eyes on external soil in general and in armenia in particular, you would be wise to keep that in mind and concentrate on your efforts on rebuilding your country and having normalised relations and trade with your nations. who knows? you may even have peace one day. the worst kind of military-bent person is the one who has no military experience or aptitude. cheers, Dear Ali, It is quite a pity to read your posts having in mind that you are an alumnus of the United World College. I say that because as I probably told you, I am one myself. I realize the merit of your contributions to this forum, which is in any case open to anyone that respect the rules, merit or no merit in their contributions, as far as I understand. But facts are facts. The Armenian Genocide is a fact. Ottoman guilt is not up for discussion. Turkey has to deal with the legacy of the Otomman Empire and its own. And let me tell you the obvious: it is not a very nice one in anybody´s eyes, except for Turkey´s military and its nationalistic-on-the-verge-of-fascist population segment. What we don´t need is someone with the usual inferiority complex manifesting itself as a pretense superior. Oh, wow Turkey is a big country, lots of weapons, fighters (maybe a bit disorganized, judging by what goes on in Afghanistan, but still a force to be reckoned with) Of course Armenia will not engage Turkey militarily. Of course Armenia doesn´t have any demands on Turkish territory. Of course states and peoples behaviour is circumstantial and the future is not set in stone. I suspect that you know all that but you choose to create havoc by misquoting or using diversionary tactics. Quite sad, I must say.
  25. Dear Martin, It is quite diffcult for me to understand how involved Iran maybe with terrorism. It is probably safe to assume that most hardcore factions remain supportive of militant Islam, as they have been in the past in Lebanon for example. I saw evidence of that not so long ago. It seems to me that states support of terrorism is probably exaggerated, unless that given state possesses mass destruction weaponry and hence could use terrorists as delivery men. Otherwise there are so many fractures in the world that it is not so hard to operate somewhat freely and cause enormous damage. S. Arabia is a threat especially if it blows up. I understand that repression has been very fierce in the last 15 years, but still one should not underestimate it. All in all I think we have not been playing our cards that badly.
×
×
  • Create New...