Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. I don't think money is the problem at all. It is priorities and organization. They are in the wrong order and in short suplly, respectively. By the way have you tried www.radiohay.com ? [ April 10, 2002, 04:56 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  2. This is very serious. It is there. His name was Adamian. Now if this is true or not, the fact that he invented the colour TV, I cannot tell.
  3. Of course. When I visited the historical museum of Karabagh I learnt that the three colour television was invented by an Armenian.
  4. Boghos

    Tushay!!! Boghos

    Hello dear Arpa, I knew about Boghos, and to tell you the truth I was not thrilled when I discovered it, but not disappointed either. Better than be called Claudius, or Claudio, Claude, etc, isn't it ? My paternal grandfather was called Yeprem, another interesting name from an ethymological/historical perspective. Do you remember what Baronian said about "Giragos" ? [ April 10, 2002, 11:39 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  5. quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by wh00t:Does this not make him the only current state leader to make such a proclamation (with the exception of Armenia)? Bravo, Jacques. I am surprised that you are surprised. After all Jacques is Armenian isn't he? Isn't his real name Hakob Shirakatsi? Yes, of course he is Armenian. Unfortunately we also have our Kevork Aboosh
  6. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:[For me, keeping my Armenian identity is my most effective way of thumbing my nose at all the "bully" cultures of the world. Twilight Bark[/QB] I completely agree. It is the same for me. We are probably one of the very few that can have, at the same time, a sense of community and a strongly developed individuality (which sometimes borders stuborness...).
  7. No, I don't remember Baronian's story. But I should, he is one of my favourite Armenian writers. BTW, do you know how to say "grenade" in Turkish ?
  8. Maybe my sense of humour is not in full gear today...but there are so many topics for April Fool´s jokes. OK, I will not be a grumpy old man (which I am not, old at least ) )
  9. I know, but I am not sure it is in good taste to post it in the Genocide list.
  10. ?????????????????????????????????????????????????
  11. We are currently having the XXV Bienal de São Paulo http://bienalsaopaulo.terra.com.br/ , one of the most important art exhibitions in Latin America. Armenian is represented by Azat Sargsyan whose art presented in the exhibit is a performance. That is all fine were it not for the fact that part of it was done naked. For the joy of people like me that were absolutley delighted to see the shock in the more, let´s say, old fashioned minds of our community ) .
  12. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:dear boghos, when you attack talat and enver and all the other killers i am all with you. they killed your people and stained our honour. but when you attack the entire turkish nation - and when you say turks this turks that you do, even if unintentionally -, you attack these people and me also. and when you attack me i defend myself. perhaps a little fine-tuning of language and greater consideration for the other side would suffice to solve that conflict. all the best, I understand what you are saying, but I thing it would be sort of awkard to write: " Turks except for a few Turks, blah, blah, blah". When we are dealing with state crimes the use of Turks, Turkey or the Ottoman Empire is interchangeable for those that have good will. Just one thing: you wouldn't know how much I would love to travel in Anatolia withou fear. Turkey or Armenia.
  13. As you said, we see many things in the very same or similar light. Please accpet my apologies if I ever went overboard. I do believe that the Armenian Genocide has some singular characteristics. It doesn't make it more "important" than others. To be quite frank, in what concerns me everything has already been said about the Genocide. I am not interested in the minute details or in who were the accessories to the crime. The verdict is obvious. My interests reside in the policies of the Republic of Armenia going forward and the related complexity of interaction among the various assymetric players. The Genocide and all its implications are but a part of this issue. Best regards, Boghos
  14. Dear Ali, You imply that I portray the Armenian Genocide as a crime of larger importance than all other atrocities because of my emotional attachment or lack of objectivity. Nothing could be farther from the truth. It is exactly the opposite. The analysis of countless other episodes in history has convinced me of what I wrote and maintain: that Turks have a special place in the pantheon of atrocities in history. In practical terms it doesn't change anything, it is simply recognizing history. I did not grow up brainwashed by a weak state. In my family there was never mention of the Turks or Turkey in derogatory terms. I have no anti-Turkey bias. I have never felt the prejudice that Turks feel in Europe. I can understand your defensive posture and even your anti-European Middle Eastern stand. I just think that you are wrong in the way you analyze the Genocide. And that indeed you have spoken about several subjects that you seem to understand little about. I have seen that in other threads but I could mention, for example, your comment about the Jews in Germany not feeling attached to the land. I think ad hominem attacks are of course ridiculous. And I have had my share of them. I do not want this to evolve into a shouting match. Absolutely not. Nor do I want to convince you of my point of view, since I see that your answers most often distort what I write rather than focusing on its essence. Dear Ali, I very much welcome your presence here, a fellow UWC graduate of all things. Please understand that for me the Genocide is much more a Turkish problem than an Armenian one. Cheers, Boghos [ March 29, 2002, 03:23 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  15. Literature is one thing, state sponsored genocide is another. Peoples of the world share many similarities and a few dissimilarities. I maintain that Turks have a special place on the Pantheon of atrocities. I do not deny all the other atrocities commited by other people, even against its own people, like the terrible situation of North Korea. But what the Turks did is only at par with what the Holocaust. As to the Christian crimes against Muslims, I never denied or diminished their importance. But don´t forget that the Turks and hence the muslims were never gracious guests in those parts of the world. The fact is that the Turks are essentially a warrior nation, up to this day ruled by military, and hence what they brought to the world was either the wealth of the conquered people or imperialism of a miltary nature. Don´t be ridiculous comparing the Cherokee experience with the Armenian Genocide. Or misquoting me. I sense in your comments a guarded hostility towards Armenians that reappears over and over on this "you are not the only victims, blah, blah, blah". If this is what you have to say about the Genocide your message has come across. so rest your case. In the meantime try to sound less like an omniscient. Yor bluffs have been unmasked several times. [ March 28, 2002, 11:25 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  16. I entirely agree that the Kurdish question is much more an issue of Ataturk´s ideology than anything else. The reference to the Ottomans is just that the tendency to solve things by the sword has remained. Languages have disapeared all over the world, it is a result of what some people call "cultural genocide", but I find that quite extreme, languages will disappear, change, etc as a result of cultural imperialism, or in more neutral terms: the prevalence of a culture over another for whatever reason. All languages are full of Americanisms. Is that bad ? I don´t see why, it is foolish to fight against that. If states concentrated in giving proper education to their people, that would be enough, but you cannot stop the tide. Language is a living entity, not something confined to a glass redome. Naturally, the imposition of another language is quite different and you have mentioned the example of the Irish. The Cherokee trail of tears: as unfortunate as it might have been it was not done with the same intention or cruelty as the Armenian Genocide. Look there were no Americans rejoicing while young Cherokee girls were made to dance naked while people abused them, there were no burnt churches with the faithful inside, there were no unthinkable rapes and other forms of terrible abuse against women and children, and the list goes on. There has never been, by any colonial power or otherwise, an effort of the scale of the Armenian Genocide. The holocaust comes next. This is a fact. Colonial powers were often very cruel to their subject population, but they never tried to anihilate a population on the scale of the Armenian Genocide. This is your heritage, I am afraid, it is not shared by all the other European countries, or America, Canada, and even latin America. It is just not the same. Cruelty is an integral part of history, but some nations are especially good at it. [ March 28, 2002, 06:49 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  17. Inspiration is irrelevant if it is taken as a determining factor. One thing is saying that Germany had a role, which is not under dispute whatsoever, the other is to use that as an explanation for what is essentially a domestically inspired, executed and even popular accepted state crime. There is no sense of shame or guilt in Turkey, as there is no shame or guilt towards Kurds or Alevis for that matter. When talking about human rights I am not interested in comparing the Ottoman Empire to other cruel and imperialist endeavours, but rather saying that the tradition of Turkish cruelty and mistreatment of minorities has continued in the republic, it is just natural. Turkey is not a victim of its geopolitical situation, but rather one of the very few winners. Just imagine what it would be without the almost non-stop support from the United States and all the multilateral organizations under its control. It probably would have disintegrated by now or in permanent civil war. Now as to the national liberation struggle, you say: 1. have you read boghos noubar, or others, claming how they had sided with the allied powers since the beginning of the war, and that therefore they deserved a state of their own. or, more to the point perhaps, are you not aware of the activities of the armenian patriarchate that go back to 1878 (if i remember the date correctly). or, even more to the point, would you say that the ottoman armenians in the late 19th century - before the hamidian massacres - had not harboured ideas of independence and not taken some inspiration from the greek and other balkan struggles? was the concept of an independent armenia completely new to the armenians prior to the 1890s or 1915? were there no societies that promoted the idea, no written material printed by the patriarchate and distributed across anatolia, no maps in armenian showing a dismembered ottoman state and an independent armenia emerging out of it (i saw some of these myself)? please do not get me wrong. i do not "accuse" armenians of treason. you have every moral right to rebel against a government that is not legitimately yours and treating you in a horrible fashion. you cannot "accuse" a nation for wanting to be independent, but accusing the state that governs them to attempt to protect its very existence is also tricky: imagine that you are a white american citizen. you respect human rights and deplore the plight of the native americans. at that time, one indian nation forms about ten per cent of the total american population. they have managed to keep their ethnic identity, have not forgotten what the whites had done to them, they were sophisticated, and at that time america had grown weak and was attacked by enemies who promised these natives (and all other disaffected non-whites) their own piece under the sun. the natives are inspired by the dissolution of the soviet union and how their natives got their independence. so they form societies and secretly prepare for a rebellion to ultimately throw off the white yoke and get their land back. the move gets widespread to the point that something must be done about it, and remember, the usa is not any longer what is was decades ago. you are the compassionate white american (preferably wasp) with power. what would you do, boghos? you have a moral right to prepare for a fight, but wouldn't it be naive to expect that the state in question would not take any measures? do we see that in history? is that what the french, the british, the dutch, the germans, the spanish, the portuguese, the americans are recorded to have done with their subject peoples? to see them get organised for rebellion and watch with folded arms? Yes, I am very familiar with all these. What's your point ? Have the Dutch, English, Portuguese, Spaniards and French deported a whole population from its historical lands and in the process killed hundreds of thousands of people, the Armenians have disappeared from Anatolia, have you forgotten that ? As to the "oil" theory, I am not saying that it is new, but rather that you, with the appropriate use of a disclaimer have brought it to this forum. It is just irrelevant in what concerns the Genocide, but of course you or anybody else can claim otherwise. There is very little else to be said about the Genocide. It is true that scholarship has improved markedly. Dadrian being, in my view, a major move forward. But the fact is that the objective truth had already been well established already. Genocide is genocide, all other aspects are merely icing on the cake.
  18. Dear Ali, It seems to me that your case in what concerns the Genocide was based on the accpetance of it as a historical truth, but with mitigating circumstances, such as the "decisive" influence of German ideology on carrying it on. Not only that but going as far as stating that were not that to have happen, most likely the Genocide wouldn't have taken place and Armenians would have been living happily alongside Turks ever since. TB has done a good job in demistifying this theory, if we can call it that, so I won't go further than saying that this typically Middle Eastern sort of conspiracy theory mindset is removed from the truth. Believeing that the Ottoman Empire was an example of tolerance and respect for human and ethnic rights is akin to believeing that the Easter Bunny will be at your doorstep shortly. Now you come up with a rehash of already tired nonsense such as "the Armenians were not loyal" (and the typical implication that they probably deserved their fate) and a new but completely groundless theory that oil had anything to do with the Genocide. Do you also believe that all the Balcan nations were very happy living under Ottoman yoke and were it not for Russia they would have remained under the Ottoman's magnaminous umbrella ? Dear Ali, it is not only Turkey's recent record in human rights that is a disaster (you are still looking at the European Union through very powerful binoculars, I am afraid), it has been so from the very beginning.
  19. A peculiar study... "The symbol of the swastika, most commonly associated with the WWII era and the Nazi regime, has a much deeper history and has fascinated people throughout history by its complex, mystical meanings and codes. The understanding of these codes has been thought to be expressed through its symbol. The swastika has been widely used in various cultural symbolisms of religious and astronomical nature throughout the Armenian Highland, Mesopotamia, Africa, China, India and Mesoamerica. After careful examination of the Armenian alphabet, one would find that half a dozen of its letters are nothing more than modified versions of the famous swastika symbol. Armenian letters such as: Ke, Kea, Xe, Pe, Fe, and Ea have their origins in the ancient proto-Armenian petroglyph writings found in the Armenian Highland. The earliest depictions of the swastika found in Armenia, date back to the Neolithic Period of human cultural evolution (aprox. 7000-5000 B.C.E.) Very often, the swastika is symbolized in the form of the solar disk, commonly found in the stone carvings of the Armenian Plateau, Iranian Plateau and ancient civilizations of Anatolia and Mesoamerica. Looking back through history the meaning of the word swastika is found in several languages. The Sanskrit root of the word swastika is svar, which means brilliance, illumination or shining. The closest contemporary equivalent to the word is found in the Russian language, where the word svet means light. In the Armenian language, the second portion of the word swastika--the ast, also referred as asd--means power. This is also the root of the Armenian word Astvats, which means God. Thus, the word Astvats is translated as "all powerful" or "giver of power/s." In this context would refer to physical and spiritual health, clarity of mind or perhaps even salvation. Thus our examination of the Sanskrit roots of the word brings us to the two archaic meanings of the words svar, (meaning brilliant or shinning) and asti meaning powerful or god. And so we get the meaning of the word swastika, which is: all powerful/shining God. In ancient times, References such as, "all powerful" or "brilliant" were assigned to the many gods of polytheistic religions. Later these descriptions moved into the context of many current, established, monotheistic religions. In the past when kings acquired their royal throne, they were also referred to as the 'shinning one.' This also allowed them to claim their divine right to rule over their dominions acquired "from the god's themselves." The sun, our only source of light, has been symbolized by the swastika because in ancient times, many people, seeing the sun as a life giver considered a God itself. As many other peoples world wide, the Armenids of the Armenian Highland and Mesopotamia had been referred to as: "the children of the light". This concept is found within the essence of the word "Ar-men,” where "Ar" is the name of the ancient Armenian sun god known as (referred to as Ra or Ra-Amon by ancient Egyptians). In addition, the word "men" theoretically would stand for the people or worshippers of the sun god, thus we get "Ar-men" and "Ar-men-ia." The ending of the word Armenia, the 'ia' is said to theoretically stand for the location, thus we get Armenia, meaning "the land of the sun-worshippers" or "the land of the children of light". For more information about this topic: ”The Book of Stars” by Dr. Edward Sargsyan ”The Evolution of the Armenian and World Alphabets” by Dr. Melkon Khandjian Or visit the Hayk Institute at www.arminco.com/Armenia/haik.html"
  20. quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:My answer to TB´s question is very simple: whoever has any reasonable ground to claim he is Armenian, is an Armenian. In other words: if you consider yourself Armenian, than you are an Armenian. This is a decision that should be left to the individual in our case. We have a large and complex diaspora, nobody has the right to say who is Armenian or not, except for his own case. ========= Boghos, it is a shame that you are not judge and jury about armenianism. This is not in sarcasm. I mean it sincerely. Several years ago I was talking to a scientist from Armenia. This was even before the breakdown of the SU. I don't remember how the conversation got to the deifinition of an Armenian, while I was arguing that "an Armenian is he who professes to be one", this scientist who professed to be a non-bleiver, an atheist, who considered religion and Christianity to be nothing but superstition, expressed the idea that he would find it very difficult to accept some one who did not subscribe to Christianity, even more specifically to the Apostolic Church, as an Armenian. Go figure! Its been so long that we don't even remember what an Armenian would be without having to subscribe to a building with a cross on top. When Bert Vaux's article appeared in the media I wrote a somewhat angry letter commenting on our assumption based on the fact that the Hamshenites "still preserve the word Astvats in their vocabulary and that they still remember such holidays as Vardavar etc.", it is a wishful thinking on our part that they may yet be salvaged. They may. If we modify our definition of Armenianism, but even more so if our church and clergy would send missionaries to convince them how and why it is better to be an Armenian. As of now, I am sure those Hamshenites are quite satisfied with their lot, specially in the light that Armenia is not a Utopia yet and being an Armenian is not one of the easiest ways of existence. What if those Hamshenites express the desire to get back to their ethnic roots on condition that religion not be an issues? Would you, Boghos, and all the Boghoses of armenialand accept them as such and let them build mosques in Yerevan? Lastly, Can we make them say "blessed are those who profess to Armenian", just like the Turks say "Ne mutlu Turk um deyene". Would our bishops and vardapets leave their penthouses and Cadillacs in NY and LA and preach to the Hamshenites? As Vahan says the Hamshentsis speak Hamsheni Barbar which belongs to the western Armenian family of dialects, i.e. the "k@" family as opposed to the "oum" family. They have many diphthongs such as "a" as in "bad", "oe" as in the French "boeuf" etc. Ali can corroboarate this. In the Hamshen region of Rize there is a mountain 2937 meters high that even today is labeled as Kackar(Khachkar) Dag in maps, and Ardehen (Ardeshen, as we have seen before the -shen ending is distinctly Armenian as it means "built by") city on the Black Sea. Hamshen, the original name was Hamamshen, a semi autonomous pricipality is believed to have been named after Hamam Amaduni together with his brother Shapuh Amatuni (I don't know where the Hamam name comes from). During 789-790 AD these two princes to escape Arab invasion and persecution, together with 12,000 of their subjects, moved mostly from Artaz region of Vaspurakan and settled on the coast of the Black Sea. They were granted land by Konstantin VI of Byzantium where they established Hamamshen. (I mentioned above that that Mountain is the turkified form of Khachkar, this reference mentions it as "Kajkar Ler" (brave-stone, or could it be that it is "GajKar,i.e. chalk/gypsum)..... to make it short; the Hamshenites were forcefully islamized in late 19th and early 20th centuries, since at the beginning of the 19th c. they were still mostly Christian. Until the early 1900's the prinipality had maintained its semi-autonomou status, albeit heavily taxed. During the Russo Turkish war of 1877-78 many Hamshenites were either exiled or moved to Abkhazia, Crimea and Russia. I agree with you that it will be impossible or nearly so for the Hamshenites to go back to their ethnic roots. First and foremost because as you said, they probably have no motivation to do so. I feel that all the talk about this "silent minority" in Turkey is at best wishful thinking. We probably should look at them as being part of the most assimilated parts of the diaspora such as early Polish and Hungarian Armenians. The fact that they are geographically in historical Armenian is a mere coincidence in this case, as not only them but millions of others will not easily give up the "Ne mutlu Turkum diyene" (which is another example of Ataturk's skillful nation building effort...). As for religion, the role of the Armenian church today is a very interesting phenomenon per se. Its power in Armenia significantly increased after independence as one of the few organized, hierarchized, widely present institutions that was suddenly unleashed. And that represented somewhat of a counterpoint to the previous system. But it has no sense of mission beyond what it had been doing in Soviet times in Armenia and the diaspora. Of course there are exceptions within the church, but there always are exceptions anyway. Perhaps in the future the church might revert to a more missionary type work, since it is fighting an uphill battle in the diaspora where there is freedom of religion. But perhaps not. The Armenian Church seems to believe that its "national mission" is a mandate of God, and not a mandate of the people. So, the most we can hope when we meet an Armenian cleric is that he is polite, well educated and has a good sense of humour. Helping bringing back those that are on the verge of leaving or have already done so is beyond the realm of what could be deemed reasonable. Dear Arpa, thank you for your always interesting historical background on issues.
  21. My answer to TB´s question is very simple: whoever has any reasonable ground to claim he is Armenian, is an Armenian. In other words: if you consider yourself Armenian, than you are an Armenian. This is a decision that should be left to the individual in our case. We have a large and complex diaspora, nobody has the right to say who is Armenian or not, except for his own case.
  22. Boghos

    History of wine

    quote:Originally posted by THOTH: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Hello Winston, Lebanon has also the Ksara wines. But in my view Musar is without match.... I will look for it. Is it a wine to be drunk young or cellared. Are there variations in vintage? ****Musar is only declared in the best vintages, hence you´ll find a 4 to 5 year gap in vintages. It can be cellared for a long time, but a 1991 for example should be ready to drink.**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos: For France I am essentially a Bordeaux drinker, but that doesn´t prevent me from trying all the different regions. It also very much depends on my mood and the food. Bandol, for example is quite interesting. I am a bih drinker of champagne.... I agree - Bordeaux is where it is at. (Have you ordered your 2000 futures yet? I am debating ordering more - still great ones to be had...just the prices are steep...but imagine upon release?) I particualrly enjoy Pomerols & St Emillions (Merlot based) - though the more powerful/tanic Puilacs & St Juliens are often excellent...and of course all the rest... (I am building a bit of a vertical on Moutouns...as much as I can afford...not much yet really...I do have a nice range of Troplong's - are you familiar? nearly always scrumptious IMO). I still find that Southern Rhone is excellent for great value & highly drinkable (& powerful) red wines. - My type. Northern Rhone great as well - though generally pricier...I enjoy the "budget" Crozes & St Josephs too though - for "everyday" drinking. And I just had a nice - very well aged Bandol the other day - very exceptionally smooth...it is Nebbilio - the grape - is it not (I don't recall for sure)? **** I am not buying the 2000 futures, actually I hardly ever do (this is a result of the bull market for everything, and I have tried to stay away...). It is amazing how all the Grand Crus have risen in price, but I suspect that prices will stabilize if nit fall (except for Port ) )I am not familiar with Troplong (well, there is a lot I am not familiar with...I have been lazy in the past few years when it comes to France...) St. Estephe´s also make good "everyday" wines. By the way I have nothing against Burgundy, quite the contrary, it is just that I used to eat heavy meals that usually went better with Bordeaux. Bandol is usually made of a blend of Mourvedre and Grenache, sometimes with some Syrah, that is as far as my knowledge goes.**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:I can have a Sauternes once in a while, but I prefer Port as dessert wine (and that´s where the strength in my cellar is, but one should really focus on Vintage Ports, in my opinion, 45´ and 55´ are a bit ridiculously priced, but you still can get a nice Quinta do Noval 1963 for a "reasonable" amount or the better aged Tawnies.... I love both/all. Sauternes do have a special place in my heart though...for some reason I seem to have vivid memories of some very nce times while drinking them...(and to me they are so rich & lovely...never had Yquem though..Ruiessac & others...As for Vintage Ports - yes - But I can hardly see spending even what it takes for a "63 (though I have been [recently] tempted. I have several '77s that are about ready (I think) and quite a few more recent vintages (lots of '97s...including a Noval, Grahmes, Nieport & others). I am partial to Taylor (& to a lesser extent Grahmes) in general (witrh vintage as well as tawneys). Have you every had any Greek desert wines that you think are special? ****I have never had Greek dessert wines, I have just had your run of the mill Retsinas and Boutari, as far as I can remember, the only thing they go well with is feta or khorovadz ) . I have tried a few Yquems, and it is indeed special,...also Rieussec, which I remember fondly, have you tried "Y" ? the second label from Yquem. In Port I love the 77´ vintage, especially Taylor´s, they age a bit faster here since I don´t cellar them. . I have stopped buying with the 1994, it was getting ridiculous, Port for the next several generations...**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Austria and Switzerland are two interesting countries. Very sweet Austrians (trockenbeerenauslese) wines are good, but a German Eiswein is prefered in my opinion. Switzerland has some good wines, but they tend to be more expensive than a similar quality wine from anywhere else (no surprise, is it ?).... Gotcha - not surprised (concerning the swiss). Have never had a trock or even an Eiswein yet...I must! ****You really must, Eiswein is something very special and not that absurdly expensive.**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:I am a big fan of South Africa, especially the wines from Thelema and Kanonkop. Simply excellent.... Really? Never heard of these - what grapes (red I assume)? Again any vintage advice and are these imidiate drinkers or better off cellared? These can be drunk young, 5 years in my book. I am not a white wine drinker, with very few exceptions, so I have only tried the reds, they have usually Cabernet Sauvignon or Merlot and its blends. I can´t recall the vintages, but I will have a look at home. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:A nice and affordable Chardonnay from New Zealand comes from Brajkovic. Of course Australia has several good wines and a few outstanding ones. ... I keep hearing of the outstanding NZ Chardonnays...but since its not my fave (nor my wifes) we don't drink much anyway..and I tend to go for price...(though always with quality in mind...just not not paying the big bucks for what I belieive is ussually an overated and only moderatly interseting wine...I ussually enjoy my Rieslings more...) ****Overrated wine is an understatement. You are quite right. Buy everything S. African that you see, then you´ll decide on what you like, there is no better value in my mind.**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Argentina has seen great improvement in the last few years. I would recommend Catena Malbec, or if you prefer Cabernet Sauvignon, they also have a good one. The malbec is more interesting in my view, though. Chile also has good wine, but I prefer Argentina, but I am in the minority camp on this one. The rest of S. America has no noteworthy wines.... I understand that Argentina is on the rise. I purchased a Catena Malbec but have yet to try it. I like Malbecs - but can certainly imagine them to be better then the ones I have had - the concept is good - IMO - my kind of wine. I enjoy Chilean wines...though the prices are rising so they become less of a bargain...good easy drinking cabs & merlots though... ****You are right about Chilean wines, they have risen in price and also in quality, I just can´t tell you they don´t get me going. Incidentally I had an excellent one at my dad´s last week, but I don´t even rememer the name, maybe it was Caballo Loco...**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:All the Armenian wines I tasted were horrendous ( I prefer Kotayk, as in the beer ) ) Same applies to Georgia. Turkey is horrible. Morocco and Algeria have drinkable but mediocre wines.... I keep hearing of these fine Georgian wines and some noise about one or two good Armenian wines (I'll have to check my Oz Clark atlas again or wherever it is I saw such...) ****Let me know when you find them ) . quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Portugal has some decent red ones such as Barca Velha, Pera Manca, Tapada dos Coelheiros and the different Vinho Verde literally green wine, meaning not yet mature. But I prefer Spain with its more robust reds.... Some of the dry Portugese are nice that I have had..my experience is more with Spain however. I quite enjoy Spanish reds...though I have yet to have a super super "fine" one...I just find it hard to pay the $ for Pesqurra (sp) when I can drink an Alta Riojo 904 or such that is very enjoyable...and much cheaper...(and save the "real" $ for Bordeaux or Italian (see below) ****It had been quite a while I had heard of 904, a fine wine, Rioja has excellent wine for meat. Naturally you should also try Vega Sicilia, especially if you are building a Mouton vetical ) .**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Italy has several good wines but one has to be very careful. Lots of funny things still happening...... Funny? Such as? I don't understand - as Italy makes among my favorite wines. I go ape over Barolos & Brunnellos as well as some of the Super Tuscan wines out there (except for price of course...but some affordable very very nice ones can be found)...but these are among my all time favorite wines...I just can't wait until all my "97 vintage of all of the above is ready to drink (the Brunellos that I have pre-ordered are due to arrive soon.....I keep hoping...). And did I mention Amarone? (I am a big Allegrini fan in general - have you had any of their single vinyard [very affordable] reds or their Amarone?) ****Once again dad´s come to rescue me providing me with excellent Gaja wines. I used to be a buyer for my father in the mid-80s, but gave up for a variety of reasons. Now, he does Italy, I do the rest. Even Britain has some good reds...... OK - you have lost all credibility.....LOL. No really - didn't know they grew any wine in Britain...really.. ****I know, you are not alone in that. I confess it sounds a bit odd, even London restaurants don´t like to carry them...but they do exist...**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Sorry for the hastily written response, but I am quite busy. Haven´t even been able to phone Martin )... Look foreward to hearing more...****Likewise.**** quote:Originally posted by Boghos:PS: I remember in Budapest in the 80s one could buy a bottle of the very rare Tokaji Eszencia fromthe 40s for something like US$ 50... Surely a destination once commercial time travel becomes available...LOL. I've never had it (of course)...but even the very rich 6+? Putunyos can often be quite heady...(still I prefer my Sauternes...LOL)...though Tokajis are very very nice I agree (and unique in their way). Now take the bullet out of the chamber - its alright that you missed your oppurtunity for fortune and very fine drink...there are other reasons to live of course...and other great quaffs to be had...(still...)[/QB] ****Indeed.****
  23. Boghos

    History of wine

    Hello Winston, Lebanon has also the Ksara wines. But in my view Musar is without match. For France I am essentially a Bordeaux drinker, but that doesn´t prevent me from trying all the different regions. It also very much depends on my mood and the food. Bandol, for example is quite interesting. I am a bih drinker of champagne. I can have a Sauternes once in a while, but I prefer Port as dessert wine (and that´s where the strength in my cellar is, but one should really focus on Vintage Ports, in my opionion, 45´ and 55´ are a bit ridiculously priced, but you still can get a nice Quinta do Noval 1963 for a "reasonable" amount or the better aged Tawnies. Austria and Switzerland are two interesting countries. Very sweet Austrians (trockenbeerenauslese) wines are good, but a German Eiswein is prefered in my opinion. Switzerland has some good wines, but they tend to be more expensive than a similar quality wine from anywhere else (no surprise, is it ?). I am a big fan of South Africa, especially the wines from Thelema and Kanonkop. Simply excellent. A nice and affordable Chardonnay from New Zealand comes from Brajkovic. Of course Australia has several good wines and a few outstanding ones. Argentina has seen great improvement in the last few years. I would recommend Catena Malbec, or if you prefer Cabernet Sauvignon, they also have a good one. The malbec is more interesting in my view, though. Chile also has good wine, but I prefer Argentina, but I am in the minority camp on this one. The rest of S. America has no noteworthy wines. All the Armenian wines I tasted were horrendous ( I prefer Kotayk, as in the beer ) ) Same applies to Georgia. Turkey is horrible. Morocco and Algeria have drinkable but mediocre wines. Portugal has some decent red ones such as Barca Velha, Pera Manca, Tapada dos Coelheiros and the different Vinho Verde literally green wine, meaning not yet mature. But I prefer Spain with its more robust reds. Italy has several good wines but one has to be very careful. Lots of funny things still happening... Even Britain has some good reds... Sorry for the hastily written response, but I am quite busy. Haven´t even been able to phone Martin ) PS: I remember in Budapest in the 80s one could buy a bottle of the very rare Tokaji Eszencia fromthe 40s for something like US$ 50... [ March 19, 2002, 06:03 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  24. Lehistan is an interesting word, but it is not only Armenian it is at least also Farsi and Turkish (even though the currently used word is Polonya).
×
×
  • Create New...