Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. quote:Originally posted by MJ: Dear Boghos, I read the Washington Post Article on the Tax Cuts. Will get beck to you with respect to the other article when I read it. I am not impressed at all by the article. I think its material is selective - along ideological lines. It gives no specific information about the bill, its provisions, etc., but just interprets it in a way, which sounds arbitrary to me. (Let me tell you in advance that I am not familiar with the details of the bill at all). Basically, the idea of the article is that tax cuts (especially corporate ones) are bad. I disagree with it. They are good for the economy, assuming that the spending caps are observed. US economy has been going down for more than a year, now (taking with it the World Economy or the opposite way). The events of 9/11, in my view, have as much relevance to the "opportunity to move to the right," as they have transferred the economy from a declining mode to a recession mode. Clearly, something drastic had to be done. It is obvious, I think, that one of the primary factors stimulating economy is the consumer confidence, which has been very law, due to low expected corporate earnings which, in turn, has sent the primary financial benchmarks such as Dow Industrial, S&P500, NASDAQ, down. I think we both will agree that it hits not just the rich, but also the ordinary people, the middle class, even the lower class people. If nothing else, most of the Pension Plans, Retirement Plans, etc., are either directly tied to S&P500 of are strongly and positively correlated with it. Therefore, pushing the economy up is prerogative for everyone - not just the rich. Moreover, the direction of economy, as we both know is not very relevant for the rich. They benefit from both directions - the poor have no ability to short-sell in the market, or their such ability is very limited. Obviously, the reduced corporate taxes increase the expected corporate earning, which push the indices like S&P500 and NASDAQ up. The upward indices inspire more consumer confidence and more consumer spending, which guarantee increased cash flow into the industry, which is very good for everyone until the market saturates for another cycle. Therefore, I really do thing that the Corporate Tax Cuts are positive phenomena. I think that the imposition of Alternative Minimum Tax was an immoral and harmful thing in the first place, and I hope it would be eliminated, and the Tax Code would be simplified - it is a mess, now. As far as IBM's benefiting from the current Tax Cuts is concerned, I don't know where did the author of the article get the information. My understanding is that no one can tell it till the fiscal year is over for IBM. Logically speaking, it implies that IBM was supposed to pay high taxes regardless of its returns, if not for the elimination of the Alternative Minimum Tax. I understand that it is an assumption. However, I don't see again why is it bad to cut the unfair Taxes of IBM, GE and the likes. Vast segments of the population will benefit from it – from students to grandmothers, to consumers. My understanding is that Corporations (at least C-Corps) pay 33% tax on their returns. Why is it not good enough, and why should they pay Alternative Minimum Tax regardless of their returns? I am also puzzled again to see the traditional "tax cuts for wealthy" liberal line in this article. Tax cuts are for tax payers. More money people make, more taxes they will pay due to the volume, and not necessarily due to the rates. And these things were in the pipeline for long time. I don’t see the 9/11 being the triggering mechanism for them. The elimination of the Alternative Minimum Tax was being pursued for quite some time, as well as the Capital Gains Tax was. Moreover, reportedly, there was a consensus on Capital Gains tax way before the 9/11. I know that a lot of things that I hectically tried to convey here are things that you know much better than I do. What I would appreciate if you explain is which arguments of the author of this article do you agree with and why, even if we assume his reporting is accurate? Dear Martin, The Washington Post editorial is just an opinion, all the underlying supporting facts are not mentioned but are implicit. I have to disagree with you on the effectiveness of the tax cuts on consumer confidence. Corporations are supposed to be rational actors, they will invest, in other words spend, if they see reasons for that (a decent return on dollar spent). Currently, all surveys point to a lack of desire t invest in most sectors. Why ? Simple, overinvestment in the past. We are currently undergoing the normal but painful process of downsizing after a major expansionist cycle that lasted the better part of 15 years. So, even witn very low interest rates, tax incentives and an amazing expansion in the money supply, only time will allow for past exaggerations to be cleaned out of the system. that's why unemployment will most likely keep growing, and this will be the most important factor affecting consumer confidence. The process of deleveraging will be a painful one, personal debt levels are very high, even if one counts the sizable appreciation in family equity that was a result of the real estate appreciation. My point is that it is not by sending IBM a check (note, this is not speculation, this is a fact) that you´ll stimulate the economy. What is happening is that the government is paying back a number of very large businesses using the economy and Sept. 11 as an excuse. I hope you don't buy the idea that government and the economy are run by uninterested professionals. That has never been true, and of course will never be true. Even Friedman, one of teh very few serious liberals in America has spoken against this stimulus package. It is tantamount to waste.
  2. images/smiles/converted/jumping.gif
  3. Boghos

    SIAMESE TWINS

    I agree with Martin. The Turkish right was by far the most important objector. Moreover bear in mind that Trabzon is a very sensitive area for the Turks: it is not in the best economic condition and also heavily populated by Kurds. TB says that Tureky's leverage over Armenia would be enormous but rightly points out that the standard of living would probably be higher. Indeed. Interdependency is inevitable. We are a small country, we need to play the game exceptionally well.
  4. Here are just two links, there is much more. But have a look, and let me know what you think. On the stimulus package / tax cuts, there is an interesting Washington Post editorial: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/artic...-2001Oct31.html On civil rights, for example, an article from the New York Times (free registration, but necessary) http://www.nytimes.com/2001/11/18/politics...rchpv=past7days On the SEC and capital markets in general, there are numerous announcements that show that regulation has become a secondary issue, that the most important thing is keeping the markets "stable". far from it, it is allowing corporations to get away with irregularities that will down the line will come back to hunt investors. I shall write in much more detail about this topic if it is found to be necessary.
  5. Yes, of course it is. I was just illustrating how perceptions differ depending on where you stand.
  6. Boghos

    SIAMESE TWINS

    The Trabzon issue is quite a complex one, and it shouldn't be narrowed down to the Armenian-American elite looking after its interests only. If these interests are alligned with the RoA, for example, why not ?
  7. There are a few: - tax package to benefit corporations in a very nasty manner, essentially just filling up the coffers of such "needy" companies as IBM (actually the government should never support corporations this way) - curtailing civil rights - weakening the SEC and a number of fair regulatory practices of capital markets Essentially reducing the fairness of the free enterprise - civil rights combination that has made the American economy so succesful.
  8. Boghos

    SIAMESE TWINS

    Trabzon is considered by the Laz as their historical capital, whatever that means. But there is an important Kurdih population in and around Trabzon. A number of Kurdish political figures (that is turkish politicians of Kurdish origin...) were very much sympathetic to the idea of opening up the borders. Economic interests, naturally.
  9. Ah, if you are mentioning the fact that the September 11 incidents have produced a major swing to the right, or actually further to the right, I couldn't agree more. I don't think that the Republican hawks ever expected to accomplish so much, in such a short time span, so easily. Indeed democracy is taking the back seat.
  10. I agree that Armenians have this tendency.But it is interesting to note that outsiders do not perceive us as such. Can't it be that in the case of the Jews things are not so rosy as they appear to be ? I have so many times heard about how "united" we Armenians are.
  11. Boghos

    SIAMESE TWINS

    Indeed. This is how capitalism works. It is a system where everybody benefits albeit promoting inequality. Armenians are not exempted from that. There is a big difference between understanding how societies are structured, and what mitigating structures can be put in place to make sure that everybody has more or less the same chances, and promoting a conspiracy theory sounding view. I am not quite sure about what you mean by mentioning Trabzon. Please explain.
  12. If you happen to have read this book, interesting news: http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg40320.html
  13. Boghos

    SIAMESE TWINS

    What are you arguing for ? Instead of this not so veiled inferences, why don´t you state your case. Armenians have never been able to choose sides very well. But that´s another story. [ November 21, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  14. Dear Martin, good question...but not only that, what is the debate about, anyway ?
  15. You see, I might not even disagree with your opinions, but they are similar to saying "well, why don´t we end hunger in the world ?", "why should we have wars", blah, blah. What is your point ? The Armenian diaspora is dying. Better refer to AB as the chronicler of death.
  16. I watch with great amusement this Armenian-American Republican vs Democrat debate. If we can call it that. I can´t quite figure if this is some kind of accusation of some form, but it sounds more like some sort of 60s type fingerpointing of the "you are the bad guys", manicheism. It should be no surprise that most Armenians of the diaspora are located between the center-right to the extreme right. Even if the don´t call it that or are not aware of their political label. There have been, of course, small socialist and even communist groups in the diaspora. But most Armenians are small businessmen or the offsprings of such people. They tend to be more conservative. As to the Armenian press, the only qualification I have for the great majority of it is: a joke. I do read many Armenian papers and a few magazines. I list them under satyrical, even if they are not intended as such.
  17. quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian: PARALLEL LIVES ************************** Anna Akhmatova and Sylva Kaputikian. Two Soviet poets: the first anti-Soviet, the second pro-Soviet. Anna was labeled "a half-nun, half whore," by the Kremlin and refused publication. How did she survive? Barely -- but members of her family didn't. (When Stalin didn't like you, he didn't always kill you: he killed your family.) Sylva was translated into Russian, was awarded the Stalin Prize, became a best-seller and earned several million rubles in royalties. In her voluminous travel impressions she portrayed the world as a place in need of Soviet enlightenment. Speaking of life under Stalin, Anna Akhmatova wrote: "It was a time when only the dead smiled, / happy in their peace." After the collapse of the Soviet regime, Sylva portrayed herself as a Soviet dissident. The whole world reads and respects Anna Akhmatova. Who reads Sylva Kaputikian? A handful of Armenian dupes, not all of them Ramgavars. And if you want to know why, read the memoirs of Stalin’s daughter, where she writes: "Stalin is gone but his shadow still stands over all of us. It still dictates to us and we, very often, obey." Sylva Kaputikian is a for hire semi-literate intellectual. A shame, no doubt. However passing that rigorous a judgement wouldn´t be justified were it not for the fact that she remained a Stalinist much longer after Stalin´s death. She also took advantage of government sponsored travel in order to reward the diaspora with her incomparable gifts when it came to declamation. You know that Khachaturian wrote an Ode to Stalin ?
  18. quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Hello, Boghosinho! Were you being sarcastic, Boghosinho? I've never been called "Ms. Rose" by you. Either way, happy to see you around more often! Not sarcastic, no. It just sounded more respectful. You are getting older ) .
  19. It is most interesting how a simple mention of an "Armenian slut" put in proper context by Ms. Rose (thank you), gets way out of hand. Not that open forae are not created for that purpose, they are. But sometimes, as Freud said "a cigar is just a cigar". And we should keep it that way.
  20. It seems quite premature to attribute to TARC or any other similarly clownish initiative, a role in reducing Armenian claims in what relates to the Genocide. Indeed Turkey does devote a great deal of time and effort to negate Armenian claims, but to no avail. Even though in all fairness Genocide recognition pressure has arisen probably as much from Armenians travails as from the interests of various countries in putting pressure on Turkey for other reasons. Turkey is not exactly loved in Europe. It is a leftover from the Cold War that Europe has nott been able to shake. That is how, in realpolitik terms, how Europe perceives Turkey. As for the ordinary Turk, I think it is a complete waste of time. He´ll never accept it. He was brought up under the notion that Turkey and being Turk, is something special, one of the negative legacies of Ataturk. And also that Armenians were insidious inside Turkey and have been so ever since being deported. Trying to denigrate Turkey everywhere and everytime. In the intelligentsia it might be different. But it would be such a major turn to see Turkey recognizing the Genocide, that it appears that only romantics see it happening anytime soon. Turkey, in spite of Mustafa Kemal brave efforts remains a very insecure society. Recognizing the Genocide would only increase that feeling. Or else would help cleansing an otherwise disfunctional and highly violent society. [ November 19, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ] [ November 19, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  21. Boghos

    Turkish Economy

    Turkey Asks for Deferral of $5.6 Bln IMF Debt Payment (Update2) By Ali Berat Meric Ottawa, Nov. 18 (Bloomberg) -- Turkey is still trying to get International Monetary Fund permission to defer the repayment of $5.6 billion in loans from the agency in order to cover a financing gap, Treasury Undersecretary Faik Oztrak said. The $10 billion that the IMF plans to lend Turkey next year will be sufficient to bridge the gap only if the repayment is postponed, Oztrak said. Turkish officials asked the IMF in September to defer the repayment, due next year, and the IMF signaled at the time a postponement would be possible. ``If we're asked to pay back what comes due next year, then we'll request a new loan of parallel size to cover that,'' Oztrak said in a telephone interview from Ottawa, where he is attending a meeting of the Group of 20 nations. IMF Turkey representative Odd Per Brekk said on Friday the Fund expects repayment of the $5.6 billion next year. Economists estimate that Turkey needs about $20 billion from international lenders in 2002 if the IMF loan isn't deferred. Turkey's debts soared this year after an earlier IMF-backed economic program collapsed and the lira lost 55 percent of its value against the dollar. Public debt is expected to reach 90 percent of gross national product at the end of this year, up from 58 percent in 2000. Financing Crunch ``The money they are trying to defer is mostly the central bank's liability,'' said Baturalp Candemir, an economist at HC Istanbul Securities in Istanbul. ``It's not directly related to treasury's financing needs, but they still want to defer if they can to keep reserves healthy.'' Turkish officials are negotiating the maturity and cost of the new $10 billion loan, Oztrak said. Turkey wants it to be repayable over many years, so it doesn't confront the same dilemma it's facing with repayment in 2002, he said. ``This additional fund is of course helpful, but it is only to get over the February collapse,'' Economy Minister Kemal Dervis said in Ottawa, according to the Hurriyet newspaper. ``Turkey should not be going to international lenders for additional loans every six to eight months,'' he said. ``We have to put this money to good use.''
  22. A venture capital fund is an interesting idea. But I don't think thatthe existing projects such as Tufenkian's could be folded into such a fund. These are very specific, very "personal" initiatives. I can see a venture capital fund for investments in technology for example. Could be very successful and needs only relatively modest amounts of investment. As to Artsakh becoming a banking centre, with all due respect, that is an impossibility. And I will spare everybody a list of the reasons why that is so. It is quite obvious.
  23. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: Dear Ali, I know that you have accomplished a lot in the way of freeing yourself from most of the silly state indoctrination. And I assure you that I have a reasonably objective view of Armenians and Turks. So I know that not every Armenian was a "lamb". But an incredibly high percentage of them were exactly that. Clueless peasants who couldn't figure out what hit them until it was too late. Saying "majority of Armenians were not rebels" is quite misleading, although it may not have been intended to be consciously. Even in full mobilization of a community, the "majority" (i.e. greater than 50%) of the members would not be "rebels" or "soldiers". So acknowledging that "yeah, the majority of them were not rebels" is an information-free statement. The point is, the number of Ottoman Armenians who took up arms (or even were theoretically likely to) were absolutely tiny. Of the able-bodied Armenian men, probably not more than a few percent were involved in any activity that could be construed as "hostile". And where rebellion and resistance occurred, it was usually the result of too much oppression. Any other ethnic group would have rebelled in full force long before. Now "objectivity" does not demand that we ignore the facts so we look reasonable to less-informed outsiders. It was an unreasonable time, and the facts and behaviors of that time look absurd today. But that is how it was. Not all Armenians were lambs waiting to be slaugtered. But a vast, vast majority of them were exactly that. Let's get that straight and out in the open. It would be good education for Armenian chauvinists who like to fantasize that Armenians mounted a credible resistance like any "reasonable" group would. I am not necessarily saying that mounting a resistance would do any good, but they didn't in the vast majority of cases. Cheers and regards, TB Indeed. Armenian so-called revolutionaries have been portrayed very effectively by the likes of Hagop Baronian and Yervant Odian. if you haven´t read Comrade Panchoonie, I do recommend you try to get hold of it. Even observers of the scene that did not have the same ironical flair of the above mentioned writers shared their views. You may try Bank Ottoman, the autobiography of Armen Garo, member of the Ottoman Parliament and ambassador of the Republic of Armenia to the United States, a bona fide member of the ARF. Armenian revolutionaries not only were extremely naive, but also probably caused more harm than anything else to their own people. As to local revolts, there should be no surprise as you quite properly point out. They actually are not a result of 20th century oppression, but rather partly arise from the mid-19th century internal fissures derivinf from Ottoman decline and an ever present suspicion and envy of Armenians. Curiously, there is a major Armenian institution that has escaped scrutiny over the centuries: the Church. But that´s a wholly different subject.
  24. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: Ali, You are incorect concerning Armenian carpets. I not only own a few, I have several books on them and their history (perhaps I can post some facts/history) - and I have been to an exposition that focused on them (along with other carpets from the Caucuses) - several years ago at the National Textile museum in Washington DC. I don't claim to be an expert (Its not really my thing and my wife actually know more then I - having bought carpets in Turkey, Cyprus and elsewhere) - but I know that Armenian carpets have a very long history - are a major art form among (traditional village) Armenians and they have unique patterns/designs that differ from most Turkish (and Turkick) carpets. Otherwise, I do understand the points you are trying to make regarding the naysaying of Turkish cultural/artistic acheivements... Winston Indeed, Winston you are quite right. Armenians have been making carpets for a long time. I have also a number of Armenian inscribed pieces and own several books on Armenian carpets. As much scholarship as Ali shows I think he is incorrect in saying that carpets are exclusive to nomadic people. Carpets have been an absolutely common feature of most villages in the Caucasus, and many of the so called Caucasian carpets could be called Armenian. Karabagh is just but one of the types of Armenian carpets. Carpets are, and were a feature of people´s life everywhere in Anatolia and the Caucasus. Moreover if you find a carpet woven by a Cristian (that is with crosses or cross-like symbols for example, but not only) odds are that it was an Armenian. It is true that there are carpets woven by Muslims that were simply copied, and the other way around is also true. Carpets have been a part of Armenian life for a very long time.
  25. It is really amazing how much time and effort official Ankara devotes to anti-Genocide activities. I would think that their cup of tea is so full of other more important issues. It sounds like Peter Seller's "The mouse that roars".
×
×
  • Create New...