Boghos
Members-
Posts
1,746 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Boghos
-
quote:Originally posted by naira: That should be smth, I've missed when i droped FOR A WHILE my armenian issues and let myself involved in some crazy "liaisons amoureuses". [ May 28, 2001: Message edited by: naira ] As the Che said: "Hay que endurecerse pero sin perder la ternura jamas". Liaisons amoureuses, ça veut dire presque toujours des liaisons dangeureses . [ May 28, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
quote:Originally posted by naira: Turkey did not recognise yet the state of Armenia. I think the land reclamation is a "ill" part of Genocide recognition movement. It's my position, though I understand why Armenian Disapora leaders would like to bring this issue on the frontline as well. For me the whole point is in fact of Recognition of Genocide by Turkey itself. I see how many armenian activists are determined in the fight for the Recognition of Armenian Genocide by the USA. I like their determination, and I think it is a key decesion that should bring us to the next step. The recognition of Genocide by Turkish Parliament and official excuses of Turkish Government. This is the culmination of my fight. It's may sound horrible, what I'm going to say next. But I beleive in what I'm going to say. I care less about the lands. I'm for the recognition of Genocide by Turkey itself, followed by excuses accompanied by actions in commemoration of victims. The question of Recognition of Genocide for me is rather a moral question than material. It's not about money, it's not about lands lost. It's first of all about the relief. Its for those from my grand-grand fathers and mothers who lost their lives because of their ethnic difference. Dear Naira, Turkey was one of the first states to recognize Armenian statehood. But that doesn´t really mean much. Giving up the lands claim is smart move. Why ? Because this is the only way we can advance. For a sovereign country to give up territory it is an unusual situation, either because it sees a major advantage in doing that a quid-pro-quo, or most often because of war. In any case the problem of Armenian does not seem to be land at the moment. Arguably a way out to sea would be very important, but that is a different approach to this matter. I do understand your point, and I share it. But I give up on the lands claim because it is counterproductive. Just on a sort of doctrinary sense, borders are temporary, by definition. It is only because we are used to 50 or so years of more or less stable borders that we think that the worls is and will always be like that. Another point, I think that Turkey has much more to gain from genocide recognition than we Armenians do. That will help them cleanse their nation, they will eventually be respected and not blamed, its like repentence. In any case it was an Ottoman crime. It will force them to look for other scapegoats. For us apart from the moral victory it will also force us to look under the hood and deal with other issues. But Turkey is a very insecure country, so it will take a long time for it to happen, it seems to me. They need first to get rid of the Army into politics.
-
quote:Originally posted by naira: I thought Kocharian said already Armenia's position on lands. It seems to me he announced once that Armenia has no territorial pretentions regarding Turkey. I thought Turkey doesn't want to recognise armenian state, untill it won't drop accusations of Genocide commited in Ottoman Turkey in 1915. I think Kocharian has said that. But the issue is not only the Armenian state but also the Armenian diaspora. How can a state of which one is not even a citizen give up his/her rights ? When will the diaspora give up on Genocide recognition ? Never, unless it completely assimilates. So this is not a state to state issue only. It is not quite clear how much of a role the diaspora plays in Genocide politics. But it certainly has increased after Levon left. Are there folks who have studied this issue closely? Yes, there are. But this is essentially realpolitik.
-
quote:Originally posted by naira: I'd say anarchy is 'way of living' that should be discovered as well. It's very seductive :-) I smell, you, Boghos. You seem to be a "vilain". Indeed.
-
It appears to me, from far, I must confess, that one of the major losers of the redemocratization of Armenian were women. Not because democracy is intrisically unfair to them but rather because of the particular environment that the country found itself after it. Emigration and economic deterioration has not only broken families apart but forced women to either remain home or to look for jobs that are not what they wish, aimed or had the potential for. It also appears that male chauvinism has increased, not that it didn´t exist before, but as a natural consequence of the more vulnerable status of women. It becomes a sort of vicious circle. So, where do we go from here (non-deterministically speaking) ?
-
I can´t tell you about anything about Armeniancafe because I have never visited the place. But as to censorship, I think there is a very fine line separating that from maintaining an orderly discussion for the benefit of the majority and the preservation of minorities positions and opinions. What I have observed is that many forae have started with the best of intentions but have in a quickly reverse Darwinist process become an echo chamber for frustrated pseud-nationalists, chauvinists and other people that find comfort in having their own positions confirmed and repeated ad nauseam. Anarchy is the strict political sense is what I would like to see. But as I said that is my position, other people in the forum defend other types of positions and our interaction is what makes HyeForum, hopefully, an interesting place. Even though it is clear that the Internet has allowed for the exchange of ideas among Armenians all over, the medium itself seems to appease, on a more steady basis, those that are misfits in their own communities. By saying misfit I do not imply a negative connotation, but rather those that do not fit well into the traditional structures of communities. But these are also the people that tend to be involved with other issues that not just Armenian patriotic mumbo-jumbio, they express their creativity, dissidence, irony, knowledge etc in many other instances. I am inclined to think that the Internet opened up room for many that were before voiceless or had been exiled within their own communities. They were joined by those that have had an "Armenian" intellectual life. That was only and is still only possible in Armenia (even though Lebanese Armenians may claim otherwise ). So, with time, Armenian inteligentsia and its previously orphaned sons come together. Please do not read my words with the same severity that you apply to our resident writer .
-
Dear Harut, I think Kasparov has not made it clear. Once he was a bit irritated with this whole story of people asking him if he was Armenian, felt Armenian, etc. He is very close to his mother, Clara, but this has much more to do with Oedipus than nationality, it seems.
-
Renowned linguist in Turkey was in charge of the Turkish Language Council for many years. He was personally appointed by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk.
-
Circassian, Let me make a quick summary of your positions: - you do not trust any diaspora Armenian - all diaspora Armenians hate Turkey - I am not a humanist but whatever you think I am It is a pity that all of them are wrong. If you are here for serious and honest dialogue, so be it. But it appears to me that this is not your objective. You do not have answers but just ad hominem attacks. Hence I will not bother with you anymore. Since we believe in freedom of expression, however racist, misguided and ill intentioned it maybe, you are most welcome to express your views. Something that Turks in Turkey, Kurds in Turkey and others in Turkey are not quite allowed to do. We do not have a constitution that strips citizens of their rights in certain cases. Goodbye and good luck, Ignegi kendine batir cuvaldizi baskasina. [ May 26, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ] [ May 26, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
I believe that the resolution of this question will necessarily mean a stage-by-stage process. Actually it can be argued that most negotiations towards conflict resolution do not bring about a final solution, they evolve around the objective conditions of the parties involved. There is actually one really major issue at stake here from the Armenian side, realistically speaking: Genocide recognition. Admittedly, if ever Turkey recognizes the Genocide, a far fetched possibility at the moment (in spite of the fact that some liberal sectors in Turkey are for it), it would want to see the issue of reparations dealt with as well. And this is where things become more complicated. How can any Armenian government give up on that ? It cannot. Maybe Levon T-P had a window to get to that, but there was not enough time. Moreover that Karabagh conflict became a major obstacle for the Armeno-Turksih relationship, not because Turkey is really interested in Karabagh, and by now not even Azerabaijan (which was mostly a playground for Grew Wolves and a vehicle for the mainstream Turkish rightist politicians to appease the ultra right), but because it weakens the Armenian position and its demands. Anakara´s position is very inflexible. I don´t believe Genocide recognition is a possibility in the near future. The reason is that whenever Turkey feels vulnerable, either externally or internally, it moves to the right. And the right in Turkish terms is fascism. Turkey is in a very difficult economic situiation now, and this will evolve into problems in other area as well. The Kurdish problem has temporarily cooled off, but it is not reasonable to expect that it has been resolved. It has not, it will re-emerge, as all unsolved conflicts have the tendency to do. It is amazing how much energy the Turkish state puts on attacking the Armenians in the diaspora. This is dealt with at the highest levels of the state. Turks perceive themselves as the victims of slander and prejudice. Of course that is very far from the truth, but it also means that there is no willigness to negotiate at all. At all. Naturally a middle ground solution, where Turkey would recognize the Genocide and Armenia would give up its reparation claims would be probably the best one could expect, but even that is unlikely. Let´s not forget finally that there is a major distinction to be made between the claims of the Armenian Republic and those of the diaspora.But that is a whole different issue altogether.
-
quote:Originally posted by circassian: For diasporean armenians to strangley remain silence to those " HUMAN RIGHTS " issue's means they don't really care. Despite the fact that most diasporean armenians are in a better financial situation then any of the other participants on this issue , on a personal level being richer then an afghan or a chechen or an armenian proper or a turkic person is not enough for diasporean armenians to take a breath & ask themselves the eternal question ; Why do I as a diasporean person should not condemn russia for intefering and causing the greatest suffering to all people in my region of the world for the most part of last century. Why do I prefer to focus on the Evils of 1915 while I prefer to remain silent on current evil actions against human kind especially if the victims happens to be the turks. that is Dogmatic as far as an indivisual is concerned. [ May 26, 2001: Message edited by: circassian ] Circassian, As much as most of us Armenians would like to see an improvement in living conditions for everybody, and this includes health, education, job security, freedom of expression, movement, religion, recognition of past injustices etc. Unfortunately given our limited resources we have mostly focused on Armenian issues. It is true however that in many countries Armenians have fought alongside the indigenous population, for example one of the biggest heroes against the Nazi occupation of France was an Armenian; Iran has in the figure of Yeprem Khan one of the heroes of its constitutionalist movement at the beginning of the century, and there are many other examples. What I suggest is that if you want to fight human rights abuses, torture, repression of minorities: start at home. There is so much to be done in Turkey that it should occupy your and many hundreds of peoples´ time (if they are not beaten up, jailed or killed.). Meanwhile we´ll busy ourselves with the recognition of the Armenian genocide and other issues that are closer to our hearts, but are certainly not the only ones that we deem necessary to resolve. I, together with many of my compatriots, pray for the day when Turkey becomes a true democracy, when freedom of expression and even of religion is fully respected (why nobody talks about the massacres of Alevis, which if I remember well are Muslims and Turks, in Kahramanmarash anymore, for example ?). If you need our help, let us know. Finally as you have yourself said: "Okuz altinda buzagi aranmaz." For the benefit of those that do not know Turkish: "Do not search for a calf under an ox".
-
Even before the fall of the Soviet Union, Turkey was already preparing a diplomatic offensive in the Caucasus and Central Asia. In all of this countries you´ll find, for example, Turkish sponsored schools. But this didn´t last very long. And a number of reasons acoount for that. Some: - the larger states such as Kazakhstan perceive themselves as too important to be under any sort of sphere of influence that is not Russia, China or the US. - there is very little real afinity with the Turks, and in spite of Russian emigration the political and even cultural weight of Russia is still very much felt. - Turkey has had a lot of internal problems to deal with, both in the political and economic sphere. Moreover its diplomacy has never been geared towards this type of work, nor is it a country with the necessary ability to lead. - after a while, the very few efforts in Central Asia were seen as a sort of bribe by the host countries, and as some sort of waste by the Turks. Even in Azerbaijan the Turks have had limited success. I don´t think pan-turkism stands much of a chance. [ May 25, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
Dear Alpha, I think you make a number of valid points, especially in terms of the lack of savings and the structural defficiencies that enable sustainable development, such as enforceability of contracts and the like. As to monetary policy I disagree. I think the issue is not its tightness. Although it does seem to be a bit tight, the problem is more related to the same structural problems you were refering to. It is very difficult to borrow at all not because interest rates are high, but because credit is simply not available. On the other hand monetary policy has been quite effective in keeping inflation under control, and that is very important. We need to creat a credible framework to allow investments to take place in a natural manner. This is not an economy where monetary stimulus by itself will work. Actually in the current circumstances it might even backfire.
-
BTW, when I was in Iran I went to Yazd, one of the major centers for Zoroasters outside Bombay. I was able to talk to a few very interesting people, and visit the towers of silence...
-
The Avesta was written in Avestan. Avesta itslef, a compilation of texts does not have a precise meaning, some scholars translate it as "text" others as "knwoledge" or "wisdom". Avestan is somewhat similar to Pahlavi. Avestan is an Indo-Germanic language belonging to the Iranian group. Such as Pahlavi. The spoken form of Avestan is very similar to Sanskrit, and there have been many studies in that direction. I am sorry to answer before Tornado who is probably more qualified than me. But Zoroastrianism interests me a lot.
-
Gayane, Congratulations. All the best. Boghos
-
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: You couldn't have said it better, Boghosinho. (And this comes from a Turk - would others understand why or would I be labeled insensitive?) Very simply put: it bears no relation to the Armenian Genocide. What has been done cannot be undone. Insensitive ? I don´t see why. As painful as many episodes have been in Armenian, Ottoman and Turkish history if we don´t look at them under an honest optic we will not go anywhere. That is what you do and have been trying to communicate to many people for as long as I have seen your posts.
-
One argument often used by Genocide denialists is that the Turks also suffered major losses an were actually the victims of seditious Armenians. The Turkish government, or to put it more precisely, its more hawkish faction, has gone as far as erecting a monument to commemorate the victims of a "Armenian genocide of Turks". There have been numerous other manifestations in that direction. It is a fairly recent strategy in its intensity, even though the argument itself has been around for quite a while. It is only for internal consumption and at the most for rehashed use by "academics" at the pay of the Turkish government (some shameful acts by these "academics" have been quite well documented). However where I think the denialists fail to understand that the Armenians do not deny that there was Turkish suffering. That is not the issue, but simply that the Armenians were victim of a state sponsored and organized campaign of ethnic destruction and forceful removal. That is called Genocide, there is no other word for it. Turkish deaths at that time, on the other hand, however terrible, were not a result of that. They were a result of war and disease mostly. Of course there were very small groups of Armenians that fought back, but these were indeed very small, as properly documented, and casualties very limited. Hence it is not an issue of denying a well understood and painful historical phenomenon with another. But rather of trying to come to terms with the disgraceful acts commited against a defenseless minority. Yes, it has happened to Turkic peoples in other instances. I promptly accept that. But it bears no relation to the Armenian Genocide.
-
There is also the epic of "Rostom and Zavarian". A comedy in many acts actually.
-
Tornado, Another place where there are courses of Armenian language and culture is the American University of Armenia. http://www.aua.am/
-
Here is an article in Romanian of all languages, it is quite informative on his scientific achievements. By virtue of my knowdledge of romance languages I can understand most of it. http://ararat.go.ro/19/19art11.html There is also an entry about him in the Armenian Encyclopedia.
-
very old socialist joke: Capitalism is the exploitation of men by men. Socialism is the other way around. Why Sovetakan Hayastan was more expensive than Pravda ? Because you had to pay for translation.
-
Is it true that during Soviet times you could order food over the phone ? Yes, but delivery was through TV.
-
If you visit Karabagh´s ethnographic museum you´ll be able to see a section on H. Adamian. It is claimed that he is a Karabaghtsi.
