Boghos
Members-
Posts
1,746 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Boghos
-
Very much worth reading. http://www.gomidas.org/forum/archives.pdf
-
http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg33137.html
-
First of all, it is undeniable that Kurds and Yezidis or Kurd/Yezidis have had the most fertile ground for their cultural development in Armenia (this is by some of their leaders own recognition). This shouldn´t be seen as a privilege but an evidence of how Armenia compares to all other countries where they live. Second, I don´t think anybody that has a reasonable understanding of nationalism and politics will fail to admit that it is likely that a few problems would arise between Armenians and ethnic minorities. This is a result of the independence process, which does not end simply with proclaiming an independent republic, but it is a far more complex and longer process. Of course this is not a justification for any sort of abuse, but the real, palpable evidence so far has been of very minor difficulties. And that in an absolute standards comparison, not even looking at the neighbouring countries treatment of minorities. The first, and natural inclination of a freed people is to protect their own, and later if the situation allows or if the ideology permits, extend it to minorities in practical terms (unlike the Ottoman Empire and Ataturk´s Turkey). Third, this issue has its Armenian dimension for two major reasons: emigration and its justifications in the eyes of the receiving countries; and the Kurdish question in a broader context. The first one is understandable and sad, some people will go to any lengths in order to get to their goals. This kind of exaggerations are well documented and even Armenians have in some cases claimed refugee status based on bogus allegations (as have every other people in the same situation). The second one is much more complex, it deals with the geopolitical nature of the Kurdish question, the interests of the different actors, where the Kurds/Yezidis of Armenia are merely a pawn in this game. Without extending myself much further I think suffices to say that Armenia has been dealing with this issue in a very correct manner (unlike what the Turks claimed for a moment, Ocalan was never hiding in Armenian territory, for example), it tries to be as neutral as possible. But it is faced with much more powerful and well funded interests. It is easy to understand how a minority, albeit not mistreated but perhaps a bit disenfranchised might find appeal, perhaps romantic appeal, by being part of a much wider movement. That also causes problems for everybody involved. Finally, I fail to see any reasonable grounds to claim that any ethnic group in Armenia today is singled out for bad treatment by the government. Certainly not worse treatment than ethnic Armenians themselves. [ June 09, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
Bravo, Steve ! I am very much looking forward to reading your always interesting insights.
-
Quite right. I have already written them. But please post your letter.
-
I know of at least an instance where a group of Armenians from the diaspora went on a tour of Armenian sites in Anatolia, from Armenia (through Georgia, well understood). The mayor of Kars apparently arranged for a police escort of this group, these were ethnic Kurd. This was related to me by a participant. As to the objectives of the owner of Hotel Vartan, I really have no more details. But this issue was apparently well discussed in the Turkish press.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: i was the first turkish student of the united world college of the adriatic, a member of the united world colleges whose patron saint is prince charles. the idea belonged to dr. lester b. pearson, if i recall correctly and it runs something like this "how can there be peace without people loving eachother and how can that be if they dont know eachother". so the idea was to bring together students of the last two years of high school and make them live together for two years in a campus. particular attention was given to put together students from "conflicting races". so jews and palestinians, south african whites and blacks, chinese & japanese, indians and pakistanis etc. would end up in the same room, and of course there was a code of conduct at the school (love eachother or else). when these conflicting races were first put together they were like the novice lion tamer who had never tamed a lion before and the novice lion which was never tamed before. only the two were of equal strength, so we could have wonderful fights to watch if only the supervisors had allowed it. they didn't, damnit. Dear Ali, I was the first diaspora Armenian (I am Brazilian by nationality) on the Armand Hammer UWC class of 87´. I have been reading your posts. I was sure that the UWC experience would eventually get to this. By the way, we should honour Lord Mountbatten he was really the guy that started the whole thing. I am sure we have common friends.
-
RAID ON SO-CALLED HOTEL Anadolu News Agency 07 June, 2001 RADIKAL (LEFT) The Tourism Ministry cancelled the tourism management licence given to Victor Bedoyan, an Armenian citizen who opened a hotel in eastern Van province. The Ministry said that the conditions have changed while Bedoyan will file a lawsuit in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Bedoyan got the licence and two-star plate for his hotel named ''Vartan'' which means victory in Armenian language, from the Tourism Ministry a week ago. The Ministry cancelled the licence in a week. Tourism Minister Mumcu said that the licence was cancelled because Bedoyan made some arrangements contrary to the licence
-
Dear Winston, I am quite comfortable with the way the world perceives the Genocide, Turkey and its absurd pesudo intellectuals for hire excepted. We are at a point where no amount of propaganda from the Turks will change perceptions. There are many reasons for that in my view. But most importantly: it is very difficult to hide or transform an obvious truth.
-
Dear Martin, I confess I thought about it, but the topic didn´t allow me.
-
OK, darling, I was never doubting your scholarship and knowledge.
-
Dear Tornado, I have seen many English, a few French. No doubt Russian, but that is not within my language universe. There are a few old Turkish-Armenian dictionaries which are a treasury in my view. I have knowledge of an Armenian-Spanish dictionary made in Argentina, a really fine work, not very large, but very well done. Very hard to get, I am afraid. There is also an Armenian-Portuguese dictionary made in Brazil. It is not at the same level as the Spanish one, but still not bad. That one is available in some bookstores and through the church in Brazil.
-
Shoah is how Jewish people refer to the Holocaust. It is a word play with "There is no business like show business". Most recent and controversial book on the subject is this one: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/185...4965249-1079741
-
They are going to fine people that have web sites with "untrue news, insults and similar material". The government will fine itself and its hired writers . Turkey Restricts Web Content Updated: Thu, Jun 07 8:47 AM EDT ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) - Turkey's parliament passed a law Thursday that subjects the Internet to the same restrictions as print media but abandoned plans to require official permission to set up a Web site. The law provides for fines of up to $85,000 for Web sites that publish "untrue news, insults and similar material." However, the government abandoned clauses in an earlier draft of the law that would have required permission from local government authorities to set up a Web site in Turkey and have forced the owners of Web sites to provide printed copies of the site to a local prosecutor every day. The law also contains clauses that bar individuals or firms from owning a majority share in a television or radio channel that has more than 20 percent of the average annual national audience. It imposes fines on channels that violate broadcasting standards instead of the previous practice of temporary closure. A controversial clause revokes a ban on media owners entering state tenders. Opposition parties had argued the ban should be maintained, saying its removal could lead to a dangerous convergence of interests between politicians and media owners.
-
Our Century (Azerbaijan) June 6 - 12, 2001 «Turks, be vigilant» Erich Fygle's book «The Truth About Terror. The Armenian Terrorism-Sources and Reasons», issued in Baku in Russian language, has not been, yet, used by those people and organisations whose competence is rendering the Armenians provocation harmless. The Austrian researcher, cinematographer and writer, Erich Fygle, known as the most consistent protector of the Turks and Azeris against the Armenia propagandistic diversions has recently visited Baku. During his meetings with the public of the country he shared his creative plans with them. He, namely, told about his idea to shoot the documentary film about Azerbaijan. An interesting dialogue took place between the writer and the audience at the Baku State University, the management of which had invited E. Fygle to come to Azerbaijan. The discussion was focused on the writer's book of «The Truth About Terror. The Armenian Terrorism: Sources and Reasons». Published in the West in three languages, English, German and French, the book was issued in Baku in Russian, last year. The writer has kindly agreed to answer the questions of our correspondent. -Your book, is one of the few researches of foreign authors, which with the scientific scrupulosity and argumentation unmasks the legends about genocide allegedly conducted by the Turks at the beginning of the XX-th century. What has the further fate of the book been like? -The Armenians have conducted the act of ideological terrorism; they bought almost all the copies in German and French. But I had succeeded in publication of the book in English. And now we have a Russian copy of it, as well. Unfortunately, the book has not, so far, been acquired by the persons or organisations responsible for making the Armenian provocation harmless. It is worth mentioning that even the Austrian embassy has no copy of the book. -Of course, we should do our best to get the readers acquainted with this work. You have done all you could. By the way, had you recognised the danger you were involving yourself in by touching the subject the falsified interpretation of which has been protected by the Armenian extremists not only with the help of the pen and computer means but the guns, also? -My intrusion into the «prohibited zone» was caused by the death of my friend, the Turkish diplomat, Erdogan Ozen, in the result of the terrorist act. I knew him well and my book has been devoted to his memory. He was a very kind man with high professional skills. He always helped the families of the Turkish workers. One morning I turned on the radio to hear the terrible news: Erdogan had been in the car that exploded in the centre of Vienna, near the Turkish embassy. Shocked with the friend's death I began the detailed study of the «Armenian matter». I was not touched or convinced by the Armenian legends any more, though, frankly speaking, I, as all the Austrians, did remember that there was the time when the Turks besieged Vienna and a priory sympathised with the «poor Armenians». But I overcame the prejudice and preconception. Having accumulated lots of facts and documents, and interviewed many people, and shot the unique visual material I came to the conclusion that shocked the western reader: 2.5 million Moslems were killed by the Armenian terrorists in the Ottoman empire and Azerbaijan during the events of 1915. In the course of the military actions and the deportation the Armenians lost 300 thousand people. So, who has performed the genocide? -But you are one of the few in the West asking this rhetoric question. -The world public's opinion is captivated by the ideas, dictated by the Armenians, and incompetent and unfair writers. The legend about the genocide is supported by a number of falsified sources. They are, first of all, the «official documents» forged and published in 1920 by some Aram Andoyan, and the novel of «Forty Days of Musa-dag» by Frans Verfel, that, in essence, is the interpretation of crazy inventions of Andoyan. The truth is that the Armenian in their blind wish to take revenge of the alleged genocide had killed the Turks with extraordinary brutality. The Armenians and their friends deliberately ignore the fact that the tragedy of involving the people in war was caused not by the Moslem brutality but by sinister fanaticism of the Armenian terrorists who had foisted the idea of the «Great Armenia» to their people. -How may the Armenian terrorism be prevented? It is necessary to hold the negotiations, to eliminate the reasons of mistrust, not to increase the number of mutual offence, and naturally, to fight against the mortal force of the legends. The key to solution of the Armenian terrorism matter, its victims being the Turks and Azeris, should be searched for in historic events. These events of the early XX-th century marked by the grasping «partition of the Ottoman heritage» should be considered from the positions of historic objectiveness. It should be reminded that it was the Armenians who performed the aggression against the Azeris in 1919. And the tragedy has repeated nowadays: the Armenians have occupied 20 % of the Azerbaijan territory, carried out the ethnic clearance in Armenia and Artsax and deprived million of people of their home. In this situation I think that the Turks have to «wake up», finally, and activate their efforts to neutralise the Armenian propaganda. The Armenian lobby is strong, powerful and possesses huge capital, while the Turkish and Azeri communities in the West live in the state of the bliss fatalism. To conclude I would like to say : «Turks, be vigilant».
-
Note: Turkey is one of the few countries where the real fascists, the MHP, are in power. The MHP is viewed as a nice,nationalist force by the mainstream press. When their most important leader, Alparslan Turkesh, died, the Prime Minister attended the funeral, and it was in the first pages of the leading dailies. This is a country where everything is tilted to the right as it is for practical purposes a military dictatorship dressed as a democracy. STATE MINISTER AND DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER BAHCELI IN FRANCE Anadolu News Agency 4 June, 2001 PARIS - State Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Devlet Bahceli, the leader of the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), criticized France which had adopted a resolution recognizing so-called Armenian genocide. Speaking at the Fifth Congress of the Turkish Federation in French capital Paris, Bahceli said on Sunday, ''parliament of a country does not have the right to distort another country's history. Such an attitude will damage efforts to provide global peace and stability and contradict with universal values. Jeopardizing friendly relations and cooperation ties among the nations through such allegations stemming from racist feelings, is an attitude as negative and dangerous as distorting historical facts for the sake of a few votes. Our citizens living in foreign countries have a great responsibility in explaining incoherency of these ugly slanders against Turkey.'' Bahceli stressed that genocide had never been committed in any period of Turkish history. State Minister Faruk Bal, Industry and Trade Minister Kenan Tanrikulu, and Ismail Hakki Cerrahoglu, Huseyin Kalkan, Mehmet Telek, Kursat Eser, Sevket Cetin and Oktay Vural, the deputies of the MHP, were also in attendance at the congress. [ June 06, 2001: Message edited by: Boghos ]
-
I remember when the Americahay had t-shirt with the words: "Kiss me, I am Armenian". Never really understood it.
-
My dear Naira, It is always difficult to answer these types of questions because they involve sweeping generalizations. I think Canada can be divided in at least five different components: Québec, Western Canada ex-British Columbia, British Columbia, Eastern Canada and indian population/northern Canada (mindo you there ara aboriginals all over the place bu in my view they share a lot of political similarities). Western Canada is not very different from what the Americans call the Midwest, hard working hillbilies. Québec is Qúebec, the Quiet Revolution being a very important but seldom refered to period. Eastern Canada is Ontario, a sort of small NY state. BC is an interesting plavce, the original population is a mix of Anglophiles and California style dudes, it has seen also a very strong Oriental immigration wave over the years; Indians or Native Canadians, are just that, I will not go deeper into this topic because thre is enough controversy already and it is no interesting from my point of view. So, that would mean that we would have to create stereotypes for Americans as well.That would take too much time, and would probably be very boring in any case. I think Canadians are sufficiently different from Americans.They are usually more conservative, more reserved. After all Canada was initilly settled by people running away from the Republican movemment in the US and as Richler puts is by the ssum of France (as Australia in relation to Britain), Etc. Whatever, have a drink on me.
-
Canada is a member of this community of "gentle" nations, of which the Scandinavian countries used to be part, ad now apparently only Sweden insists in being seen as such. This has been quite useful in the international scene as it helped them advance their economic agenda as well. Even though these countries corporations and sometimes even governmnents acted in avery similar fashion to their big brothers USofA and Great Britain, they were never perceived as "imperialists". I am not saying that these countries,two of which I have been a frequent visitor and even temporary resident, are exactly the same as Big Satan. Far from that. But they are not saints either.
-
The following are excerpts of an exclusive interview with United Press International's Life & Mind Editor Claude Salhani. UPI: In your opinion, the Armenian church, which is the oldest state church in the world, has survived seven decades of Communism. How is it growing and is it appealing to the young people? Karekin II: For 70 years the church was tolerated and the activities were very limited. After the collapse of the U.S.S.R., the church got freedom to act, but the Armenian church was not prepared for the transition from one set of realities, to this new one. That vacuum which was created over 70 years when the walls of Communism came down, ... there was this hunger and the people embraced the church very strongly. For example, when this happened, the church did not have enough clergy -- remember 70 years of Communism had curtailed that, we did not have churches, we did not have the means. So one of the first things to do was to prepare to meet the needs of the people. The church suddenly found itself in a position where it had to meet all these needs. First we had to deal with preparing new clergy, new teachers, religious education classes, and to revitalize the preaching. All this was part of the reorganization which was all destroyed under Communism. One of the other important things we needed to do, which we are doing, is to build new churches in various cities and towns which were lost over the years. To reopen and repair old historical churches across the country. One thing we must stress is despite Communism and atheism that came with it, the Armenians never lost their faith deep in their hearts. That was always there. The faith was in the heart of our people, because in all the history, the church played a great role in keeping the identity of the nation. In that way the church was taken as a national church. UPI: Do you have trouble attracting young people to the church? Karekin II: No, in fact it is surprising to note that for every available place in the seminary, we are getting four applications. We have a shortage of priests because we don't have enough seminaries. From 40 students that we were allowed to have during the Communist period, we have 250 now. But it is not enough. UPI: What are your relations with Rome? Karekin II: We have very warm and brotherly relations not only with the Catholic church and the pope as such, but also with all other Christian churches. I was in the Vatican last November and met with Pope John Paul II. I invited the pope to come to Yerevan (the capital of Armenia) and he said he would come to visit. UPI: The relationships between Rome and some Orthodox churches are somewhat tense. How are you getting along with the Western church? Karekin II: This ecumenical spirit that we have has opened us to other churches and has allowed us to have good working relations with the others. We have good contacts throughout existing dioceses and communities. The very fact that we have these diaspora communities in the West and elsewhere ... all these are a bridge between the mother See and the other churches. UPI: Are you happy with the World Council of Churches? Karekin II: We are members of that, we are actively participating, and the moderator is one of our clergy. We have no reason to leave the WCC. We are convinced that in this millennium, the only way to improve everything for mankind in this case is by cooperation and coordination and understanding of all churches. And the WCC is a forum for cooperation and understanding UPI: What is your position on Jerusalem? Karekin II: Our position is that it should have a special status. And any solution should not jeopardize the sanctity of the holy places there, and not jeopardize the free expression and activities of the churches that exist there. UPI: What kind of special status? Karekin II: An open city status. So we are not saying that it should belong under this or that administration. That is not the major concern. Whatever administration it may be, joint administration, or single, the important thing is that whoever manages or administers should not jeopardize the status of Jerusalem as a holy city and the free expression and the free movement (for all faiths). That kind of open city. We are saying internationalization, we are not saying United Nations. UPI: Do you see yourself and the Armenian church negotiating in the dispute with Azerbaijan over Nagorno Artsax? Karekin II: What we are trying to do is to create an atmosphere to facilitate the ground in which the two heads of states (of Armenia and Azerbaijan) can operate towards a peaceful end to this conflict. Along those lines, through the mediation of the head of the Russian Church, Alexiy II (patriarch of Moscow and all Russia) we had a meeting a few months ago with Sheikh ul-Islam ***** Zadeh of Azerbaijan (the spiritual head of the Azeri-Turkic Muslims and chairman of the Baku-based Muslim Spiritual Board of Transcaucasia). We expressed our willingness, all three of us, to stand behind through our work to create a positive atmosphere so that the peace process can go ahead. UPI: Do you see any trends towards unification between the Armenian church, Rome and the Orthodox church? Karekin II: Of course that is the final objective of every Christian and it is a lot of work. We pray that it will be a reality one day. -- Copyright 2001 by United Press International.
-
Genocide bill before Canadian Parliament debated but defeated by one NO Vote Armenian News Network / Groong June 1, 2001 Special eyewitness report By Antoine Terjanian OTTAWA, CANADA M-285 is a law proposed by Canadian MP Sarkis Assadourian for the official recognition of the Armenian Genocide by Canada's Parliament (and Government). If approved, the bill would have become law. The motion was presented by Sarkis Assadourian at 13:30 hours today and seconded by Ms. Augustine (Etobicoke-Lakeshore, Liberal Party), while the 'Members' Gallery was filled with Armenian supporters. Ambassador Papian sat with the Armenian supporters instead of his reserved 'diplomatic area'. As promised, Assadourian first recognized the Armenian supporters, the Armenian Cultural Association of Ottawa and Ambassador Papian in the Gallery, as well as Ambassador Ogut of Turkey, who was sitting in the diplomatic gallery. After presenting a good historical background on Armenia, Assadourian received unanimous consent from the House to table important documentation on the recognition of the Armenian Genocide in other countries and International Institutions. He then had a choice of either designating the motion as votable, or asking again for unanimous consent of the House. He chose the latter. Everyone in the House shouted their consent, except for one MP dressed in pink, who came for a few moments only to register her dissent, did not take a seat at her usual desk and left immediately afterwards. The bill was therefore defeated and withdrawn from the orders papers, however, six more MPs spoke to the bill till the House adjourned at 14:30. The whole thing was broadcast live with the title: Armenian Genocide motion. Gurmant Grewal (Burnaby, Canadian Alliance - former Reform Party) said he had received representations on the issue from the Armenian Community as well as from the Canadian Turkish Associations, and used up his time mainly to take shots at previous Liberal and Conservative governments for what they did to other ethnic minorities in Canada. Madeleine Dalphond-Guiral (Laval, Bloc Quebecois) gave an excellent, well documented presentation in support of the motion. Bill Blaikie (Winnipeg, NDP) also gave a well documented refutal of Turkey's arguments and challenged them to recognize the Genocide themselves, lest they felt some solidarity with Ottoman deeds, and were thus still implicated. Bill Casey (Cumberland, Progressive Conservative) also gave a well thought presentation in favor of the bill. Gar Knuston (London, Liberal governing majority) read again the statement made by Canada's Foreign Minister's Parliamentary Secretary who in 1999 described the tragedy as a 'premeditated act to eradicate a minority within a country' and expressed hope that peace would prevail in the region, and denounced such acts of barbarism and inhumanity towards fellow humans. Ken Epp (Alberta, Canadian Alliance - former Reform Party) spoke in support of the bill, and related how his own family was murdered by armed gangs (of Bolsheviks) in his Grandmother's 'old country' (Ukraine??), and also condemned all such acts. Sarkis Assadourian concluded by thanking all those who participated in the debate, while regretting that it did not lead to the conclusion he was aiming for, he vowed to continue the struggle, for 'although the Armenian people are prepared to forgive and make peace, forgiving has no meaning unless the offender expresses regrets on past deeds and asks for forgiveness'. The full edited record will be published by Hansard and will be available on Canada's Parliamentary website tomorrow.
-
In Foreign Parts: Aanjar, Lebanon - Why exiled Armenians blame the French for their dreadful secret The Independent - United Kingdom; Jun 2, 2001 BY ROBERT FISK FOR A town of sorrows, Aanjar blushes roses. From the roadside, smothering the front doors, all the way up Father Ashod Karakashian's garden, a stream of pink and crimson to mock the suffering of the Armenians who built this town on the malarial marshes of eastern Lebanon 61 years ago. They are proud people, holders of Lebanese passports now, but holders, too, of one of the darkest secrets of the Armenian past: for they were "cleansed" from their homelands twice in a century, in 1915, then in 1939. If they blame the Turks for both evictions, they blame the French as well. And Hitler. Mostly, they blame the French. Father Karakashian's sister Viktoria was just 10 in 1939 but she remembers her family's second disaster, a miniature genocide compared with the one and a half million who died in 1915, but none the less terrible. "The French army escorted us all the way," she said. "But we were dying. My brother Varujan was only a year or two old, but I saw him die in my mother's lap in the truck. Like many of us, he had malaria. "The French didn't seem to know what to do with us. They took us first for 40 days to Abassid in Syria. Then they put us on ships for seven days. We landed at Tripoli and the French put us on a cattle train for Rayak. From Rayak, they brought us to Aanjar and here we remained." Like most of the Armenians of Aanjar, Father Karakashian and his sister were born in Musa Dagh, the Armenian fortress town in what is now south- eastern Turkey, which held out for 40 days against overwhelming odds during the 1915 Turkish genocide of Armenians. Rescued by French and British warships, the Armenians of Musa Dagh were cared for in Egypt, then sent back to their home town with the French army in the aftermath of the 1914- 18 war. And there they lived, in part of the French mandate of Syria, until 1939 when the French government, in a desperate attempt to persuade Turkey to join the Allies against Hitler, "gave" Musa Dagh and the large city of Alexandretta back to the Turks. The Karakashian children were born after the 1915 Armenian holocaust but many of their neighbours have no parents or grandparents. Even when they arrived at Aanjar, then in the French mandate of "Greater Lebanon", they continued to suffer. "There were plagues of mosquitoes and this place was a wilderness," Father Karakashian says. "The French gave each man 25 Lebanese pounds to break the rocks and build homes for themselves. But many people caught malaria and died." In the first two years of their ordeal - in 1940, when most of Europe was at war - the Armenians of Aanjar lost 1,000 men and women to malaria. Their crumbling gravestones still lie to the north of the town. The walls of Saint Paul's Patriarchate in Aanjar are covered with photographs of the Armenian tragedy. One, taken from an Allied ship, shows the survivors of the heroic siege of Musa Dagh climbing desperately on to a warship in 1915. Another shows French officers welcoming Armenian dignatories back to Alexandretta (now the Turkish city of Iskenderun), with several men from the French army's "Armenian Brigade". In the 1930s, they built a memorial to the siege (it has been destroyed by the Turks) and when they were forced to leave again before the Second World War, the Armenians took their dead, Serb-style, with them. The corpses of 18 of the "martyrs" of the 1915 battle of Musa Dagh, whose bodies had been left untouched by the Turks until the French came back with the Armenians in 1918, were stuffed on to trucks in 1939 with the refugees, and brought to Aanjar alongside the living. They rest in a marble sarcophagus next to St Paul's Church. "In Eternal Memory", it says on the marble in Armenian. But memory has been softened for the people of Aanjar. "In the first 10 years after leaving Alexandretta, the people - there were 6,000 deportees who came here - wanted to go back," Father Karakashian says. "Then after the Second World War, a lot of our people emigrated to South America. Now we don't want to return. But I went back last year for a holiday. Yes, there is a tiny Armenian community left in our former bit of Turkey around Musa Dagh, 30 families, and they've just renovated the Armenian church. The Turks there are polite to us. I think they know what happened and they respect us because they know they are on our land." The shame of France's surrender of the sanjak of Alexandretta, including Musa Dagh, is an untold stories of the Second World War. Fearing that Turkey would join the German Axis, as it did in the 1914-18 war, France agreed to a referendum in Alexandretta so the Armenian and Turkish inhabitants could choose their nationality. The Turks trucked tens of thousands of people into the sanjak for the referendum and, of course, the "people" voted to be part of Turkey. "The French government made the decision to give the place to Turkey and of course the Armenians realised they couldn't live there anymore and requested from the French government that they be taken away and given new homes," Father Karakashian says. "They wanted to be rid of the Turks. So they left. The French made an agreement in their own interests. I blame the French." The final irony, of course, is that Turkey did join the Allied side against Hitler, but only in the last days of the conflict, when Hitler was about to commit suicide in his Berlin bunker and when the Second World War had been safely won by the Allies. The sacrifice of Alexandretta was for nothing.
