Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. quote:Originally posted by MJ: Stalinist terror is taken way out if proportions by pretty much everyone I come across in the Western Society. I don’t mean to claim that it has not been a horrific regime, but I mean to claim that its impact on the Armenian culture has been marginal. Primarily, because effective the end of the WWII significant migration has taken to Armenia, and the new comer Armenians have not only been short of the baggage of Stalinism, but by injecting the whatever culture they have brought with them, they have diluted to a very significant degree the mentality of the Stalinian period. This is very idiosyncratic to Soviet Armenia, since it is the only republic which has experienced very significant influx of “western Armenians,” eventually constituting perhaps not less than 30% of its population. Anyone who doesn’t understand this is talking from his own projection and not out of knowledge – to put it softly. Yes, this is an important factor, but most people came to Armenia right after WWII and Stalin died in 1953. So even though most did not undergo the worst of Stalin terror they felt the aftermath of it. Society doesn´t rid itself of absurdities so quickly. Moreover post-war immigration was not exactly a pleasant event for the newly arrived. And their difficulty in integrating was a long lasting phenomenon.
  2. [ October 04, 2002, 10:28 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: quote:Originally posted by MJ:On the subject of the “little Stalins,” … the Cat drifts again. The current Armenian generation has neither seen Stalin nor has been oppressed. Soviet Armenia has been the freest Republic in the Soviet Union enjoying widest freedoms, and the culture of Stalinism has not found home even in the worst 5% of the population. Come on MJ! The Stalinist terror was just as bad in Armenia as it was elsewhere in the Soviet Union - perhaps more so because you had the prospect of anyone who wanted to openly express their Armenian identity running the risk of that identity being represented as un-Soviet. And most of that repression was inflicted by Armenians on ther fellow Armenians. Do you really think all the deep-seated psychological and cultural damage caused by that was miraculously cured the day Stalin died? Someone who grew up in Armenia the 30s, 40s and 50s will be only be in their 60s and 70s now - their children perhaps in their 30s and 40s. They ARE ALL still the current Armenian generation.[/QB]Here I have to agree with Steve. BTW, there is a nice documentary about Stalin and Stalinism in Armenia. You can get a copy at AGBU if you want.
  4. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Tigrannes III, Do you know that in 1955 my father's doctor prescribed cigarettes for him to calm him down on his top-secret stressful job? I knew it ! I knew it ! Hagarag´s father is James Bond... [ October 03, 2002, 10:43 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  5. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Boghos - I am a sceptic by nature and I think that there are lots of folks who could benefit by the books you have suggested. (not that I don't also believe that some things are just beyond our ability to expl;ain/comprehen right now...)However I do not view the global warming hypothesis as being in the category of "Bad Science" - though perhaps/certainly there has been some on this subject. Overall I think the empiracle evidence as known/presented/etc is/should be enough to cause some alarm...at the very least...and generate (at least some) action before it might be too late... I agree with you, it is beyond my knowledge of science to have an informed and educated opinion on the subject. Nevertheless debunking popular mtyhs is an interesting proposition per se. I didn´t mean that global warming and its "tree hugging" critics are necessarily fake, I just said "caveat emptor".
  6. Boghos

    Behind believe

    quote:Originally posted by Domino:Has someone read this ? http://www.eraren.org/eng/articles/Armenia...hScepticism.htm Is that what the "Institute for Armenian Research" call actually research ? This "work"(if we can call it a work), is just an example of pseudo-intellectualism, selectivally quoting works, when these works conclude the compleat opposit of what the author here try to make us conclude. He goes even as far as quoting Yair Auron, without indicating that the quoted taken from his book was a critic of the Israeli politic not to agree with it. What is even more ironic is that Sedat Laciner( a PhD ) even refer to Israel Charny, and start his work by refering the Standford Shaw, an individual that is even less credinle then Turkish diplomats. And then, an important part of his references are based on the incident with Peres, trying to extract the maximum over it, and try to picture it as anti-semitism... After reading what he wrote, one wonder if his PhD is supposed to prove his credential, or to hide his ignorance. Quite sad if not plain ridiculous. If that´s the way Turkey intends to do "research", they better think of something else. But a good employment opportunity for self-described "scholars".
  7. Over and over again we see apparently worthwhile causes embraced by well intentioned people even though often enough there is feeble credible evidence for a given view or theory. I suggest a couple of interesting books on the theme: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detai...glance&n=507846 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detai...997528?v=glance
  8. Talking about transliteration in an awkward way: I think it is clear that increasing education in Russian was part of Stalin´s homo sovieticus. But is there any credence to an alleged plan to replace the Armenian alphabet with cyrillic during Stalin ?
  9. Armenian is one language. I completely agree that the apparent difficulty in communication that exists between speakers of Western and Eastern variety is due essentially to limited knowledge of the language. It should be kept in mind that many diasporan Armenians have had only limited formal education in Armenian or even none at all. When you combine that with the inevitable influence of the host country you get Arabic words, English words, Portuguese words and so on. I think there is nothing surprising here. Languages are living entities. We cannot expect them not to be influenced by the prevailing mainstream culture or cultures. So, it has been Russian in the case of SSRA. It appears to me that the main difference between E. and W. Armenian is the decay in grammar quality in the diaspora. In some countries, notably France, there has been an effort to "preserve" the language. As far as I understand this has brought limited results. But again it should be no surprise. Languages evolve, or change if you prefer, in a very chaotic manner. Languages should not be preserved, they should be used. Perhaps in the not so distant future the ROA will be able to help improving language use and bridge the various gaps. Once ROA writers get more press, TV improves, cinema reappears, magazines and newspapers evolve, segments of the diaspora will be very receptive. But as I have also said several times before together with MJ, the diaspora is a temporary phenomenon. PS: What language has three words for telephone ? [ October 01, 2002, 08:17 AM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  10. Boghos

    Kirk Kerkorian

    He is on the cover of the current issue of Barron´s.
  11. Oh, yes, I forgot to say: Ali, dear boy, you are making a lot of progress. Soon we´ll be able to take you out of remedial class . What kind of nonsense is all that garbage...
  12. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:OK - where to begin - Boghos - OK noted - will try (repetative/lengthy posts). As for me being naive - OK - maybe - but if I am I wouldn't know it right? LOL. And yes - I do take great stock in (my own) self-righteousness - and in taking a moral and balanced position - trying to understand the perspectives of others - etc - shouldn't everyone feel this way (I think...) Well I don´t think I am entitled to define what everyone should feel. It is neither reasonable nor realistic. But yes, you are a good guy . BTW you haven´t read my private message of weeks already.
  13. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: quote:Originally posted by THOTH: I understand your recent frustration (though not so much with MJ - as I think you have misinterpreted him) - but with some others who have focused on their points of disagreement with you (and were a bit nasty) I am curious Thoth. Do you include me in those who were "a bit nasty"? If so, could you expand on the points that you found unfairly "nasty"? Thanks.TB Well, count me in, I had the honour of being mentioned by name. I feel better now that Mr. Urguplu understands a bit more of what land claims are about, at least he alludes to my post on that but does not mention me by name because he doesn´t like to give in. Winston (THOTH) self-righteousness goes a bit too far sometimes. But he is improving somewhat. Just needs to make his posts a little shorter and less repetitive. Incidentally, I share many of his values I just think he is too predictible and a bit naive. Sorry Winston, but my comments were overdue.
  14. Boghos

    Language

    quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:You seem to be a really nice teacher of political correctness.So do you. [[/QB] Ok, ok I am a bit humourless today. One of these days I will write on some of the mistakes that Armenians make when speaking Portuguese, starting with the feminine-masculine switch... [ September 26, 2002, 04:32 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  15. Boghos

    Language

    quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:It is nice to make fun of accents and grammar when one is not a native speaker... Why go on another site for that? Just surf around Hye Forum a bit, beginning with your own entries.Thanks for the suggestion. You seem to be a really nice teacher of political correctness. After you solve the problems of Armenia , drop me a line. [ September 26, 2002, 03:19 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  16. Boghos

    Language

    Engrish ? Believe it or not this site exists: http://www.engrish.com/ It is nice to make fun of accents and grammar when one is not a native speaker...
  17. Hello TB, I just wished that Ali had the sort of reasoning you allude to. The poor chap is lost in so many contradictions and factual mistakes that it is not clear what he thinks or proposes all the time. I really don´t think he has any agenda, he just seems to find entertainment here. You see, people get a kick out of the most incredible things. It is just a pity that many of us, including myself, ever took him seriously. Poor soul.
  18. You could be right. In any case, someone here should send him the phone number of TARC.
  19. Japan has teritorial claims against Russia. Portugal against Spain, the latter in turn against Britain. Guatemala against Belize. Surinam against Guyana, which has land claimed by Venezuela. Malaysia against Indonesia. Claiming land is a right of any state. It obviously does not assess merit or likelihood. It is beyond any reasonable doubt that the ROA would be entitled to claim land from Turkey. It is not reasonable to assume at present that such claims would have any practical consequences. As Martin has already stated Armenia does not claim Turkish, not even Georgian or Azerbaijani land, even though it could based on various factors. Of course states can use any number of pretexts in order to avoid the recognition of the obvious. The "threat" of land claiming is a risible one. Denial is not a healty condition for a person or a state. Of course imbecility is an even worse diagnosis. Especially if accompanied by lack of self control.
  20. Boghos

    Language

    • In a Tokyo hotel: Is forbitten to steal hotel towels please. If you are not person to do such thing is please not to read notis. • In another Japanese hotel room: Please to bathe inside the tub. • In a Bucharest hotel lobby: The lift is being fixed for the next day. During that time we regret that you will be unbearable. In a Leipzig elevator: Do not enter the lift backwards, and only when lit up. • In a Belgrade hotel elevator: To move the cabin, push button for wishing floor. If the cabin shoudl enter more persons, each one should press number of wishing floor. Driving is then going alphabetically by national order. • In a Paris hotel elevator: Please leave your values at the front desk. • In a hotel in Athens: Visitors are expected to complain at the office between the hours of 9 and 11 A.M. daily. • In a Yugoslavian hotel: The flattening of underwear with pleasure is the job of the chambermaid. • In a Japanese hotel: You are invited to take advantage of the chambermaid. • In the lobby of a Moscow hotel across from a Russian Orthodox monastery: You are welcome to visit the cemetry where famous Russian and Soviet composers, artists, and writers are buried daily except Thursday. • In an Austrian hotel catering to skiers: Not to parambulate the corridors in the hours of repose in the boots of ascension. • On the menu of a Swiss restaurant: Our wines leave nothing to hope for. • On the menu of a Polish hotel: Salad a firm's own make limpid red beet soup with cheesy dumplings in the form of a finger; roasted duck let loose; beef rashers beaten up in the country people's fashion. • In a Hong Kong supermarket: For your convenience, we recommend courteous, efficient self-service. • Outside a Hong Kong tailor shop: Ladies may have a fit upstairs. • In a Bangkok dry cleaner's: Drop your trousers here for best results. • Outside a Paris dress shop: Dresses for street walking. • In a Rhodes tailor shop: Order your summers suit. Because is a big rush we will execute customers in strict rotation. • Similarly, from the Soviet Weekly: There will be a Moscow Exhibition of Arts by 15,000 Soviet Republic painters and sculptors. These were executed over the past two years. • In an East African newspaper: A new swimming pool is rapidly taking shape since the contractors have thrown in the bulk of their workers. • In a Vienna hotel: In case of fire, do your utmost to alarm the hotel porter. • A sign posted in Germany's Black Forest: It is strictly forbidden on our black forest camping site that people of different sex, for instance, men and women, live together in one tent unless they are married with each other for that purpose. • In a Zurich hotel: Because of the impropriety of entertaining guests of the opposite sex in the bedroom, it is suggested that the lobby be used for this purpose. • In an advertisement by a Hong Kong dentist: Teeth extracted by latest Methodists. • A translated sentence from a Russian chess book: A lot of water has been passed under the bridge since this variation has been played. • In a Rome laundry: Ladies, leave your clothes here and spend the afternoon having a good time. • In a Czechoslovakian tourist agency: Take one of our horse-driven city tours we guarantee no miscarriages. • Advertisement for donkey rides in Thailand: Would you like to ride on your own ass? • On the faucet in a Finnish washroom: To stop the drip, turn cock to right. • In the window of a Swedish furrier: Fur coats made for ladies from their own skin. • On the box of a clockwork toy made in Hong Kong: Guaranteed to work throughout its useful life. • Detour sign in Kyushi, Japan: Stop: Drive Sideways. • In a Swiss mountain inn: Special today no ice cream. • In a Bangkok temple: It is forbidden to enter a woman even a foreigner if dressed as a man. • In a Tokyo bar: Special cocktails for ladies with nutes. • In a Copenhagen airline ticket office: We take your bags and send them in all directions. • On the door of a Moscow hotel room: If this is your first visit to the USSR, you are welcome to it. • In a Norwegian cocktail lounge: Ladies are requested not to have children in the bar. • At a Budapest zoo: Please do not feed the animals. If you have any suitable food, give it to the guard on duty. • In the office of a Roman doctor: Specialist in women an other diseases. • In an Acapulco hotel: The manager has personally passed all the water served here. • In a Tokyo shop: Our nylons cost more than common, but you'll find they are best in the long run. • From a Japanese information booklet about using a hotel air conditioner: Cooles and Heates: If you want just condition of warm in your room, please control yourself. • From the brochure of a car rental firm in Tokyo: When passenger of foot heave in sight, tootle the horn. Trumpet him melodiously at first, but if he still obstacles your passage then tootle him with vigor.
  21. Boghos

    Armenian Car Horn

    How about: "Bank Ottoman kravadz e..." ? [ September 24, 2002, 04:14 PM: Message edited by: Boghos ]
  22. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:MJ - I think you last two sets of comments are right on the mark. And I agree with what you are saying concerning Ali's ideas about supposed land claims - strikes me as an excuse....and even worse is this (somewhat distorted IMO) tie-in of Nogorno-Karabagh. Again - its another convinient roadblock...and your observation concerning lack of remorse...this is key. I cannot suppose to read Ali's mind - but I do still think he is fundementally a good person with a corageous stance (considering his circumstance) - I also see that he has certain blocks that - as you suggest - may require some additional maturity/insight/empathy/whatever to overcome... Well, well, better later than never...
  23. Rich, I agree with some of your contentions on the ARF. But I disagree with you on their influence on Armenian independence. That was almost exclusively a combination of Soviet and domestic (ie non-diasporan) events. That there had been a pro-independence movement, or at least increased sovereignity pursuance, in Soviet Armenia is beyond doubt. That the Soviet grip was reasonably strong, albeit with some important concessions over time on language instruction for example, to mention just one element, is also clear. In other words Armenia and the Soviet Union were not static, quite the contrary. Not trying to downplay the importance of Armenian nationalist movements it appears to me that Armenian independence was more a result of the center´s weakness rather than an autonomous event. Sectors that were already pro-sovereignity had already been occupying more room on the streets and offices. They soon were handed a state. Up to this point the ARF didn´t play any significant role, if anything it opposed much of what was going on. Further on it established a modest position in the ROA and as such it remains. As to the ARF and Karabagh, that is perhaps what you are referring to, I think that this card is overplayed but I´ll leave to other people to discuss this matter. Bear in mind that there is a big difference in the ARF appeal as a historically nationalist body and its actual role in the conflict. Furthermore the role of certain ARF factions in the beginnings of the Armeno-Azeri conflict will eventually come to light and that may not be a nice picture. It is true that the ARF´s reputation for culture preservation in the diaspora is the strongest one. I am not quite sure what that represents in practical terms. On the other hand they have proposed a certain monopoly of Armenianism that is neither reasonable nor healthy to the diaspora as a whole. As to ASALA at this point I do not have enough elements to ascribe to them exclusively the resurgence of interest in the AG and/or its recognition. Bear in mind that AG recognition by several states is not simply a result of Armenian actions but also a result of other geopolitical interests. Yes, Armenian lobbies have been quite effective in many instances, but we have to be careful with our "Armenian centrism" in the analysis of world events. I am about to leave for a trip, so let me stop here.
  24. I wish to join you in hoping for the future and at the same time believing in the present. Just a few comments: - I fully agree that ARF and Armenian communists share a number of "values" and are minted from the same metal. The ARF is much less mature, politically speaking, for its very recent only involvement in the day-to-day political life Armenia. ARF pretense difference is in its self-declared nationalism, which reners it a contradition in terms. But more about this later if other participants deem it interesting. - As to ASALA I think it should be viewed more as a product of the time rather than a purely Armenian inspired organization. The seeds were planted in the 60s (actually Cuba got its independence in 1959, Che Guevara assasinated in 1967, Paris 1968, Civil Rights movement, etc) for the emergence of "revolutionary" groups. Lebanon was a natural place for ASALA given the large Armenian population, the Palestinian movement and the increased tentions within Lebanon. It had a very weak center of command which made easy the establishment and cooperation of pretensely similar organizations. Even the Japanese Red Army operated there. ASALA borrowed the lingo and strategies of its larger and more organized similars. Its final objectives were obviously impossible. It was, as most failed initiatives are, staffed by inexperienced and romantic-idealist militants. I will refrain from passing judgement on whether ASALA was detrimental to Armenian interests. But in essence it was a coincidence of factors that led to its emergence, not any thought out strategy. It had so much appeal to the Armenian youth in Lebanon at the time that the ARF decided to launch a comoeting organization. Its demise was apparently brought about by two factors: fragmentation and efficient operation of Turkish and probably American secret services.
  25. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Well Winston, let´s not get carried away here, "if the US didn´t exist, blah, blah" that is an impossible and unreasonable supposition. My analysis is ex-post. Perhaps I refer to a possible near future where the US is no longer the dominant player financially, militarily or culturally....let us suppose that China has this role...or (gulp) Europe (EC)....Sure hard to envision how this could occur without (basically) the collapse of all we know...so obviously this is theoretically speaking...or perhaps the issue is that without the US - it means (basically) the collapse of all we know...thus (I propose) that all these folks who rail such againt the US are basically calling for the collapse of everything as we know it...and to be replaced by....? (some Communist/Muslim/Totalitarian supposed paradise....????? - here is the reach....)[/QB]Yes indeed there are some prospects that are frightening...But I think the US will remain as a hegemon for a long time to come, for exactly the reasons you hav pointed out before. If there is an up and coming country, that is China. But let´s forget about it for the moment and try to enjoy life
×
×
  • Create New...