-
Posts
9,923 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
41
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Arpa
-
Am I too naively optimistic? Is this another beginning of an end? Fifteen years ago we witnessed another beginning of an end when the Berlin Wall came down. It has been 15 years. Are we in another 15 year cycle? Once there was the mighty Soviet Empire. It was the last of a series of empires to bite the dust. Since then there are a couple of mighty empires and and few minor ones (Turkey being one of the latter). In the above quote we read how "Turkey is an important NATO ally". Speaking of empires and alliances. Does anyone remember SEATO, South East Asia Treaty Organization or ANZUS, Australia New Zealand US. These were all treaties and alliances created after WWII just as NATO was. For a long time the latter was a small "private club" of mostly westeren European countries Turkey being kind of a distant cousin, mainly because of its geographical advantage. Just recently NATO has grown to twice its original number with the induction of such disparate countries, and whereby diminishing Turkey's strategic importance. Disparate countries indeed, some of them have the same value as Turkey did at one time by their proximity to the Russian Empire, yet disparate they are nevertheless. Many of the new NATO inductees have their own problems and agendas with their own neighbors just as Turkey has with its "brother in NATO" Greece. Has the NATO grown too big too fast for its own good? Will it burts at the seams and fall by its own wait? At this point, the way I see it the US is its biggest proponenent and champion, I don't think the Europeans, specially the more affluent west really care that much. The newer members may benefit at the present but slowly and eventually the EU will take over where NATO has left. Let's consider the above quote again. We have been hearing that cliche ad infinitum and ad nauseam ever since WWII. But look what happened in Ottawa. Remember what happened in Paris and many other world capitals? Just recently the New York Times joined other influential papers and reversed its decades long stance vis a vis the "Genocide". Can we all join in singing; "This is the dawning of the age of...Armenius..." Whatever happened to the "staunch NATO ally"? Whatever happened to Ankara's saber? You mean the NYT is not a subsidiary of Ankara Times? How come it does not rattle and scare Washington anymore? Did Turkey take too much for granted when it declined the US forces pasage to Baghdad? Has Ankara stuck out its tongue and thumbed its nose to the West once too many times? Whatever happened to the "tail that wgged the dog"? Did someone cut that tail? It it is time to hit and hit hard as the iron is hot. Has NATO become another "parap takar"? Is this another beginning of an end? Note. There is talk in Washington to disengage the US forces in Iraq and replace it with NATO. It will be interesting to see what happens.
-
Hingotani Hort/Five Legged Calf http://www.nbc10.com/news/3027731/detail.html Is this some kind of an omen and a portend for apocalytic events to come? Or is someone pulling my leg? :) Look here. Maybe now we know where some of our idiocies comes from. Red Heifer; http://members.ozemail.com.au/~adamgosp/heifer.htm Maybe now we will have one more amunition in our arsenal of insults. As a rule when Armenians want to insult someone and are too cultured to call them "esh" or some other beast they use "chorqotani/four legged". So, does this mean now we can go even one more step and make the insult even more effective by calling them "HINGOTANI"?
-
Armenian Quarter In Jerusalem
Arpa replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Barev Vayri, welcome back. You may already know about this. Enjoy it anyway. http://www.uwm.edu/~vaux/jerusalem.pdf -
ANCA and all the Armenian PACs deserve a round of applause. :clap: Its About TIME and Beating Around the Bush From the California Courier. Given the fact that the New York Times is one of the leading newspapers in the United States, its editorial policies and positions have a great influence on the coverage of issues by the media nationwide and even worldwide. The Times also helps shape the opinions of policy makers as well as the public at large. Consequently, its acknowledgment of the Armenian Genocide will have a devastating effect on the Turkish efforts of denial and reaffirm the historical facts. To amplify this effect, the news of the New York Times acknowledging the Armenian Genocide should be disseminated worldwide to all members of the media, government officials, and international organizations. Is this what is known as "revolution"? Meanwhile Bushwackers in the backwoods.... Remember that one of the Turkish words for "to bark/hachel" is "urumek/(H)urriyet". From AZG Genocide BUSH NOT TO USE WORD 'GENOCIDE' AGAIN 'Reliable sources' told Turkish Hurriyet that at his April 24 annual address to the Armenian people US president George Bush will not use the word 'genocide', for the 4-th time in a run during his office as US president. Hurriyet assures its readers that since taking up the post of US president, George Bush Jr. has 'on principle' come up against the usage of the word 'genocide'. The Turkish paper wrote that most probably Bush will continue 'in this way' in future, too, and the fact of the 2004 being an electoral year and George Bush being a presidential candidate 'will not change anything in this matter', implying the possible pressure the Armenian lobby may exercise over the current administration regarding the Armenian Genocide recognition.
-
Roger is the contraction of "right you are". An acknowledgement that a radio message has been received and understood. It may be of British origin. Repeat it fast several times and see what it sounds like.
-
Does this sound "alien/odar/otar"? Has anyone seen this name used? Probably not, since it is stated below that it has fallen out of use. OTAR From Turkish otar "pasture" i.e. "shepherd" which was used till XIX c. In Georgia it is still in use. The corresponding surname is Otaryan.
-
Boghos said it the way it is. I have said on numerous occasions. If you know you will not like the answer then why ask the question? The saying goes; "Ask a silly question, get a silly answer". In this case: Ask a loaded question, get a load of .... Who assigned them judge and jury anyway!!
-
Here is another gem from the same site. AMBAKUM Is a Hebrew name that comes from Bible and it is translated as ''wrestler'' or ''container''. In the previous century it was often met. Nowadays it is almost lost, though the surname Ambakumian is still in use. In fact I have been aware of this name even if I have not actually seen anyone named such. Obviously!! At times we have used the name to decribe people who don't know when and how to shut up. An-pakum. Motor-mouth? Remind you any on this forum? I finally found the answer. I had always wondered why the name of the minor prophet in the English Bible is Habakkuk and Ambakum in the Armenian. In Septuagint and Vulgate (whatever the hell they mean) the name is Ambacum. And according to some sources, contary to the above interpretation it is supposed to means (loving) "embrace".
-
Speaking of weird names, take a look at this. There may be others as well. Is this where our own "ananun muk" got his nickname? The following monograph is from this site; http://armenian.name/index.php?a=term&t=5f605f5fab615f5c ANANUN From Armenian an negative prefix and anun ''name'' i.e. ''deprived of a name'', ''having no name''. This strange name was given both to males and females. It was believed that those having the name were not listed in Gabriel's diary and for this reason they must live longer. Speaking of Gabriel, did you know that the Armenian curse "grogh@ tani" in fact means "let the writer/registrar take you". Most interpret it as "krogh@ tani" to mean; "let the bearer take you". <_<
-
There were no Armenians in Kesaria? Grigor the Illuminator who christianized Armenia lived there almost 50 years from the 239 to 287 AD where he was ordained a bishop and moved to Dvin. Was he the only Armenian there? I doubt it. As to Sinan's ethinicty, as Gamavor indicated there are documents to prove it. In the year 1573 Sultan Selim II ordered the Armenians of Kesaria to be exiled to Cyprus en masse. Sinan wrote to the Sultan pleading that his family be spared and the Sultan agreed. This is documented and was published in the June 5, 1930 edition of the periodical "Turk Tarikhi Enjumeyi Mejmousas", (Annals of Turkish History). All one has to do is look at his portrait and observe his nose!!! As to his religion, there is no indication one way or the other, by all assumptions he was still a christian. Stories of the sort remind me of debates about the Karsh brothers' ethnicity. The famous photographers. Even after their assertions on numerous occasionas of their Armenian origin there are and still are some who try to prove that they were either Assyrian or some such, solely based on the fact that they did not have the obligatory -ian surname. Lastly, how many Greeks do you with the "sinan..." surname. Look in any phone book or search on the net to see how many Sianians there are.
-
Dear Garen, welcome to the forum. Your passion and concern is commendable if only highly emotional. Before we go any further please read the following that was aired on this forum sometime ago. THere may have been many other similar stories. Church in Bangladesh http://armenians.com/forum/index.php?showt...t=0entry75196 You may gain much knowledge by reading Armenian history again. Somehow, for wahtever reason, ever since I became aware of this situation, we have been reading in the Armenian media, I can't help and think of the fall of Ani. I will spare the details as we all know what and how it happened. Just one point. Remember who it was that betrayed us and left ud to be devastated by the hordes. Here is my point. Yes Ani did fall, the land became very hostile and hazardous for the Armenian. They felt they had to move, find more a hospitable place. Kilikia. A thousand miles away from our ancestral homeland. Why did they not move eastward towards the heart of our homeland within Mets Hayk? Once again, I will make this short except ask a few questions. Where are all our schools in Kilikia? Where are our schools in Polis? What is happening to our schools in Halep, Beirut and other cradles of the Diaspora? What will happen to all the institutions we are building in our newly adopted cradles? Accordig to one report the Armenian population of Cyprus was 7000 at the highest. How many is it now? Since then many have and are still moving out, mainly to UK, Canada, America and places far away. Do you live in Cyprus? I doubt it. I said to reread Armenian history above. It seems some people, very few people have learned from our inglorious history and doing something about it to not repeat our mistakes again. Mind you, when we say "mistakes" we may be too harsh on oursleves, they may not have mistakes at the time, yet we may not have seen the writing on the wall, so to speak. The writing is very clear now, and we assume we can all read. I think some pwople are reading and understanding it. We have built nests in alien lands only to abandon them, some within a lifetime. The AGBU, the perennial sponsor of the Melkonian Inst. has seen fit to build their nests in our native land where it will hopefully last at least till the year 3000. They built the AUA, which at this point is doing very well praparing internationally adapt students and graduates. Would it not be wise to move the assets of the MI and merge with the AUA and make it an even stronger institution serving the natives as well as studenst from abroad be they Armenian or other? How long do you anticipate the MI to last? Until there is not even one Armenian left in Cyprus? Are we not tired of fighting "enemies" within and without? Is it not time to join forces and save our fighting where it belongs? We know very well who and where they are.
-
Once a gain Steve, thank you for a fascinating story. You seem to have a passion for archeology, is that a profession as well? One thing that has fascinated me is the location of the Battle of Avarayr. Of all the historical sites it seems to be one with the most detailed description. According to eyewitnesses (Yeghishe et al) it is supposed to be located at the bank of Tghmut River, which btw literally means "muddy", hence probably a very small creek. According to some sources the field of Avarayr coincides with the NW Iranian town of GaraZiaEddin of today. If you observe the map below it is directly west of Jugha/Julfa at the sothwest corner of Nakhijevan, next to that square at the top of highway 11. Move directly left from that point, at the intersection NS and EW highways is the town of GaraZiaEddin, about 2mm north of the highway sign(I think #32) designated with a white circle. It seems to be about 15 miles north of the largest city of the area, Khoy,at the bottom of the loop of route 11. What has puzzled me is that the said location, having been the best described historical site, and in a relatively less hostile territory, has never been actually investigated, not to my knowledge anyway. If the Battle of Avarayr did in fact happen and at that location one would be inclined to believe that there would be some traces and relics left be it animate(?) or inanimate. Does anyone know if the site has ever ever searched? How about it Steve? Will that be your next project? Map NW Iran; Click at the northwesternmost "horn" of Iran to get a detailed map of the area. http://www.arianews.com/iranmap/
-
What does this really mean? Is it that they are having too many hits? It's funny. I must have been the last one to open it. Other than that, judging from the item from AZG above the whole thing was a fiasco. One report estimated the crowd at 10,000 and another at 20,000. Then again from said report it seems like the major part of the participants were just curious spectators and bystanders. They don't seem to have popular support, the leaders and organizers must have deluded themselves blinded with personal and political ambitions. Just like one forumer was lamenting as to why Armenia cannot recruit "accomplished" (diasporan) diplomats like that woman French diplomat of Georgian origin. Has anyone heard of her miraculous :) feats yet? Is it "monkey see monkey do" again to imitate the so called "rose revolution" in Tbilisi?
-
Does any one know about the latest? It is now almost midnight in Yerevan Below may be the latest; http://www.arminfo.am/
-
Very good Acher! First a story. The entire clan calls on their neighbor to ask the hand of the young lady for their son. As is the Armenian custom, they all speak together, chit chat, small talk, about the weather, about business, politics, and of course girlie talk. Coffee after coffee, reading of cups. Hours pass, still no hint what the visit is about. The boys grandfather, the patriarch of the clan grows impatient and finally he asks if he can say something. Everybody quiets down and he speaks. "Look", he says, "we have wasted all of two hours, now it is time to tell you the purpose of our visit". (Of course he uses more picturesque language). "Will you let our handsome son make love to your beautiful daughter?". :) Amot! Indz amousin k@ lines? Will you be my spouse? In general in the Armenian "amousin" is used to mean the male spouse but in fact it is of neutral gender just like the English "spouse". While at the same time it infers marriage "amousnutyun". A more direct approach; Ari psakvenq=Come, let us wed.
-
That may have been a europeanization. Even then the kemalization/conversion of KH to H did not happen overnight, I do remember some women whose names were Khatun or Khanum were called Hatun and Hanum respectively and this by people who had left their villages long before Kemalization, it was probably an Istanbul thing. Back to Khandout/Khnadut one more cryptic reference from the Daredevils of Sassoun by Leon Surmelian. A footnote. Among others; ".... and Khnadut's father is an idependent chieftain, a prince of high rank in Iranian Azerbaijan. The Armenian bards present this Iranian princess as a perfection of all feminine virtues, even though she belongs to an enemy race. In some Variants she resides in Blue Rock, and her her nationality is not given." Of course we also know that "Khandut" is a variation of "Khandukht"(much like Sandukht)which literally means the dokhter/daughter of khan(prince/king), in Armenian we rather use "dustr" to mean daughter. There is not much to go about Khandut except the above. I may have failed to indicate that its mention leaves it open as to which derived from which. As to Kaput/Kapuyt you may have hit it on the head. Very good Steve. "Kapuyt: Berd Mets hayki Ayrarat nahangi Eraskhadzor gavarum. Fortress in the Ayrarat region of Greater Hayk on top of the mountain of the same name..... skip...Some think it is the walled castle whose ruins lay near the one time village of Hrhet. According to S. Haykumi it may be one and the same as the ruins which lie on the rocky bank of Kaputa/Kapuyt River." There seem to be several analyses of Sasuntsi Davit. I wonder if those living in Yerevan can shed some more light on those places.
-
What Gamavor means here is that the program was written by idiots for the consumption of the like. Yes Jennings is of Canadian origin. However it is surprising that he did not insert his two cents and recited the sentence of Paul having been born in Turkey without batting an eye. He should know better, he is intimatley knowledgable of the history and geography of the area. He was stationed in Beirut during the 70's where he not only learned the Arabic language but also picked up some Armenian pleasantries. A friend of mine had an exchange (in armenian) with him, things like "inchpes es" etc. I knew all that but this I did not know, look for his trysts with Hanan Ashrawi and other Palestinian beauties, enjoy; http://www.honestreporting.com/articles/cr...BCs_of_Bias.asp
-
It seems I was closer than I knew. In one of the reviews of Sasna Tsrer aka Sasuntsi David in the section about the dramatis personnae in an attempt to render historicity to the epic it is mentioned that up until the late 19th c. there were places known as Khandouti Dzor (valley) and Khandouti Berd (castle). Of course we know why it is spelled as Handut now. Since kemalization there is no "kh" in the Turkish, it becomes "h" or "k" just like Kharberd became Harput.
-
I meant to write about this subject as the program was on. I conked out after the first hour. There was very little new, to me at least. Did you notice that the program had wall to wall Armenian (duduk)music many of which I could sing along. Another that caught my attention was that the Apostle Paul was "born in Turkey". Huh!!! This is not the first time that nonsense of the kind has been aired. Of course, we also know that the legend of Santa Claus is based on a Turkish (Christian)Bishop. Yeah right!! Sometimes one wonders if the writers know what and where Turkey is. St. Paul was born in Tarsus, Tarson of (Kilikian)Armenia, during which time even that bird was not called turkey.
-
Dear Boghos you commit a great injustice to the "porniks" and "bozes" of this world some of whom may and do have a heart of gold. :) A creature lower than the above would fit him best. I did label my item Swiss Cheese and Turkish Mouse. How about we change that to "rat"? BTW. "pornik" is based on the Greek "pornos" as in pornography etc. I also noticed above that he calls Turkey his homeland.
-
Wonderful presentation and fascinating pictures. Thank you Bell. By any stretch of imagination Handut would not have to do with Khandout Khatoun or visa versa, the short lived bride of Sasuntsi David who bore him his only son Mher? We know that David of Sasun is a romanticized epic but many localities mention are real places like Misr/Egypt, Tabriz and even Sassun itself. Plus the places you describe are not too far from where David's dramatic stage so to speak
-
Here is another gem from the heap of garbage above. Is this guy for real??!! In case you didn't know Mura Ler has moved a thousand miles and now it is around Erzurum.
-
Maral et al. You may have heard this anecdote. If it was not sad it would be funny. Armen Aarartian became filthy rich selling Turkish carpets, apricot from Izmir and basturma from Kayseri. When he retired he decided to have his own country, he bought an island in the Pacific Ocean and named it Hayastan. He built a complete city with roads and traffic lights, a fantastic palace, a hospital, a university. a theater, an opera house, a sports complex complete with all the frills and an olympic size swimmimg pool, and more. The island fast became a tourists paradise. One question that puzzled most tourists was; he had built ONE of everything except that there were TWO churches, one each at either end of the isand. To the question why TWO churches he would answer; "You see that church at that end of the island? That is the church I DON'T go to" Just as in the case of Ani, the City of One Thousand and One churches, most of the churches being built now are are sponsored by people like the one in the above anecdote. The reasons may be many. Such as a ticket to heaven, in memory of a loved one, to see one's name in the media, adulation and admiration of the public or just plain partisanship
-
I chose to post this under general topic of Other resisting an intense urge to post it in the Humor dept. I find it hilarious but hardly funny. Swiss Cheese and Turkish Mouse The following article was posted under the subject topic of the Apostolic Church, subtopic Armenian Quarter in Jerusalem here; http://armenians.com/forum/index.php?showt...t=0entry59456 I just noticed it. I found it very amusing. Whoever this old goat Amateau is/was would have made a very successful Jewish comedian even if "amateur". It is amazing to what ridiculous lengths the Turk will go to prove the unprovable. Of course, knowing that they cannot fault the Armenian people as such and claim that we brought it upon ourselves, what with a segment siding with the enemy(Russians), that the Dashnaks and their ilk caused it etc. Only if they knew real history. I have to read the article again more carefully to see how many holes we can punch in this what I would call "Swiss Cheese and Turkish Mouse" Among many holes, observe below that Boghos Nubar is described as the founder of "dashank-zutiun". Is this reduculous or what!! It can't be further off the truth, Boghos Nubar was the founder of AGBU and by association the Ramkavar Party, the perenneial nemesis of ARF. Let's play a game. Let's see how many holes we can punch into this farcical comedy of errors. ======== Sworn Statement of Albert J. Amateau on the allegations that Armenians suffered "genocide" by the government of the Ottoman Empire On this eleventh day of October in the year of 1989, there appeared before me, a notary public duly commissioned by the State of California, Albert J. Amateau, known to me. In my presence the said Albert J. Amateau duly took the required oath and affixed his signature to this instrument as well as to every page of the attached Statement of Facts (nine pages), declaring it to be an integral part of his sworn statement. Wendy O'Steen, Notary Public - California, Principal Office in Sonoma County, My Commission Expires December 1, 1992, Signed and Sealed 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6- 7 - 8 - 9 - 10 Albert J. Amateau, residing at #413 Oak Vista Drive, in the village of Oakmont, City of Santa Rosa, County of Sonoma in the State of California, being duly sworn, deposes that he has prepared and hereby submits the attached statement containing (a) facts, ( extracts from published and/or uttered communications which disprove the allegations of Armenians that their ethnic brethren suffered genocide by the government of the Ottoman Empire in 1915-1923. These facts are submitted to oppose approval of resolution S.J.212, introduced by the Honorable Robert Dole, Senator and Republican leader of the United States Senate, at the first session of the 101st Congress of the United States. The said resolution seeks to designate April 24, 1990, as the "National Day of Remembrance" of the 75th anniversary of the alleged Armenian genocide of 1915-1923 perpetrated by the government of the Ottoman Empire. I was born in Milas, Turkey, on April 20, 1889. In 1905 I was a student at the American Internatioal College in Izmir (Smyrna), Turkey. At the time, The Reverend John McGlaglan was President and I attended classes in English conducted by Professors Lawrence and Evan-Jones. These details to make it possible to ascertain the truth of my statements. There, I became acquainted and friendly with many Turkish born Armenian students, most of whom were my seniors. Because my Grandfather, whose name I bear, had been the French Consul in Izmir, I was mistakenly considered a Christian and a Frenchman. The Armenian students felt that they could freely discuss their membership in Armenian secret societies, i.e., Huntchak and Tashnak Zutiun, and their active participation in secret military exercises to prepare themselves for military duty in their planned subversive war against the Ottoman Empire and nation. In alliance and collaboration with Tsarist Russia. In 1906 a number of wealthy Armenians in Izmir were assessinated. Mr. Hayik Balgosian and his friend, Mr. Artin Balokian, had been shot by two men in front of the Balgosian mansion in Karatash, an affluent section of Izmir. Days later, the large establishment in the center of the Izmir Bazaar, the SIVRI-SSARIAN, wholesale dry goods warehouse and store, was bombed. Mr. Agop Sivri-Ssarian and a number of his Armenian employees were killed. The perpetrators then sent secret messages, in Armenian printed lettering, threatening a number of Armenian merchants, doctors, lawyers and architects - unless they "contributed" the sums the leaders of the secret societies had assessed, the recepients would suffer the same fate as Balgosian and Sivri-Ssarian. A majority of these addresses must have "contributed". A few, who evidently were satisfied with their economic, social and political status, did not approve of the plans for subversion and rebellion. They informed the Izmir Police of their suspicion of the identity of the leaders of the secret societies and that the Apostoloc Armenian church on ERMENI MAHALLESI, the main Armenian quarters in Izmir, was possibly the repository of arms and ammunition for the planned rebellion. I witnessed the police raid on that church; and the truck loads of arms and ammunition which were taken out. Also the arrest of five priests and a number of other Armenians who were in the church at the time of the raid, including a few of my fellow students of the American College. Evidently I had not taken the disclosures of my fellow students seriously enough. Also, I could not understand the Armenian logic for rebellion against a country that had given its ethnic minorities the right to observe and practise their religion, conduct schools for the instruction of their young in their ethnic language and favored many of them with positions of trust. I knew of many Armenians in important positions in the Ottoman Treasury, Foreign Affairs, and as functionaries as consuls,. I knew of many affluent Armenian doctors, attorneys and even a couple of bankers and architects. It was well known that the Armenians were the merchant princes of the Empire and that the Sultan favored them, especially because, of all the ethnic communities, they were the only ones who spoke the difficult Turkish language as a second language to their own Armenian. Armenian terrorists in the United States and their duped friends have made it a career to assassinate Turkish consular officilas, supposedly in revenge for the alleged Armenian massacre in 1915. Their prelates, leaders, and even our own California governor, Mr. Deukmejian, have not seen fit to express their disapproval, and by their silence have tacitly approved of the assassinations. The leaders of the secret Armenian societies, Huntchak and Tashnak Zutiun, have continued their nefarious activities by agitating for the introduction of their alleged genocide into the instruction program of the public schools of the State of California. They have also been able, through their boast of one million Armenian votes, to influence State representatives in passing laws to place their Armenian program for a motion picture into operation. Now they are trying to have the Congress of the United States pass a resolution to designate April 24, 1990, as the 75th anniversary of their alleged genocide of 1.5 million Armenians by the "Ottoman Turks in 1915". I am amazed that intelligent and politically astute gentlemen, such as Senator Robert Dole, the leader of the Republicans in the Senate, and others, his colleagues, have been importuned to sponsor that resolution without any proof of the veracity of the Armenian claims. There is no doubt in my mind that Senator Dole and his colleagues are honest and honorable men. They have been duped to believe the Armenian allegations as true. To establish the truth to the satisfaction of the Senators, I am submitting extracts from statements - in fact, avowais - by Armenian leaders in their addresses and/or communications with their adherents. These extracts, and the entire statements, are unimpeachable, and the veracity of my quotes can be easily ascertained. I am also submitting statements of others, but especially of Professor John Dewey, of Columbia University, who investigated the Armenian claims of genocide. a) EXTRACTS from the November 1914 issue of the OFFICIAL ARMENIAN GAZETTE HUNTCHAK, published in Paris, France, by the Armenian Revolutionary Committee of the ARMENIAN NATION. This was a CALL TO ARMS! "...The entire ARMENIAN NATION will join forces - moral and material, and waving the sword of REVOLUTION, will enter this World conflict.... as comrades in arms of the Triple Entente, and particularly RUSSIA. They will cooperate with the ALLIES, making full use of all political and revolutionary means for the final victory of Armenia, Cilicia, Caucasus, Azerbayjan.... heroes who will sacrifice their lives for the great cause of Armenia....Armenians proud to shed their blood for the cause of Armenia...." -Please note the date. It was even before the declaration of war. EXTRACTS from a letter dated JANUARY 27, 1918, and published in the LONDON TIMES on JANUARY 30, 1918, signed by BOGHOS NUBAR, the recognized leader of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, TASHNAK ZUTIUN. This was a complaint that the Allies had refused to invite the ARMENIAN REVOLUTIONARY COMMITTEE HUNTCHAK to the PEACE CONFERENCE at which the treaty between Turkey and the Allies was signed in Lauzanne, Switzerland. "...The unspeakable sufferings and the dreadful losses that have befallen the Armenian Nation by reason of their faithfulness to the Allies.... The fact well known only to a few that ever since the beginning of the war, Armenians fought by the side of the Allies on all fronts... Armenians have been belligerents 'de facto' since their indignant refusal to side with the Turks... our volunteers fought in Syria and Palestine (at the time part of the Ottoman Empire) in the decisive victory of General Allenby.... After the breakdown of Russia, the Armenian legions were the only forces to resist the advances of the Turks whom they held in check until the armistice was signed. Thus they helped the British forces in Mesopotamia (at the time also part of the Ottoman Empire) by hindering the German/Turkish forces from sending troops elsewhere." ----Please note the reference to refusal to side with the Turks, the nation where they were born and of which they were a part. There is no claim of genocide. c) EXTRACTS from the MANIFESTO, delivered by His Excellency, HOVHANES KATCHAZOUNI, PRIME MINISTER of the ARMENIAN REPUBLIC (established after the First World War) at the CONVENTION of the ARMENIAN REVOLUTIONARY FEDERATION, in Bucharest, Romania, JULY 1923. This was in the nature of a report. "...In the fall of 1914, when Turkey had not yet entered the war but was already making preparations, Armenian revolutionary bands began to form with great enthusiasm... The ARMENIAN REVOLUTIONARY FEDERATION had active participation in the formation of these bands and the military action against TURKEY... In the fall of 1914 Armenian volunteer bands fought against TURKEY... This was an inevitable result of the psychology on which the Armenian Nation had been nourished during an entire generation... the winter of 1914 and the spring of 1915 were periods of great activity, greatest enthusiasm and hopes... We had no doubt that the war would end with complete victory for the Allies and Turkey would be defeated and dismembered, and its Armenian population would at least be liberated... We had embraced Russia wholeheartedly without any compun(...)... we believed that the Tsarist government would grant us self government in the Caucasus and in the Armenian vilayets (Turkish provinces where many Armenians resided), liberated from Turkey, as a reward for our loyalty, our efforts and our assistance. Unfortunately Russia did not keep its word..." One and a half million Armenians are claimed to have been massacred. The avowals of their leaders prior to and after the First World War prove that there had been no massacre - their leaders would have referred to it or claimed it as their calamity, or at least as their contribution to the Allied cause. The allegations of massacre and/or genocide are a later invention to compel the new Turkish Republic to cede to them the five vilayets where they had installed the Armenian Republic, which they later had to give up to the Turkish Republic after a brief war. The Armenians have ever since been trying to obtain either the territory to add to the Russian Armenian Republic, or a large sum of money as the price for stopping the terrorism. The Armenian people must blame their own leaders and their secret revolutionary societies for the subversive actions which led to their participation in the war with the Allies. They can blame Russia for reneging on its promise, and the Allies for not giving them due credit for their help, but they certainly have no reason to blame the Turkish Republic and/or even the now defunct Ottoman Empire, as their own leaders confessed. Let us now see what Professor John Dewey, of Columbia University, has to say -a broad minded Christian gentleman who went to the Middle East in 1928 to investigate the Armenian claims of genocide. This is extracted from his report published in THE NEW REPUBLIC, vol. 40, November 12, 1928: "Few Americans who mourn, and justly, the miseries of the Armenians, are aware that till the rise of the nationalistic ambitions, beginning with the 70s, the Armenians were the favored portion of the population of Turkey; or that in the Great War, they treacherously turned Turkish cities over to the Russian invaders; that they have boasted og having raised a hundred and fifty thousand (150,000) men to fight a civil war, that they burned at least one hundred (100) Turkish villages and exterminated their populations. I do not mention these things by way of appraising or extenuating blame, because the story of provocations and reprisals is as futile as it is endless. Finally, one recalls that the Jews took their abode in "fanatic" Turkey when they were expelled from Europe, especially Spain, by "Saintly" Christians, and they have lived in Turkey for some centuries, at least in as much tranquility and liberty as their fellow Muslim Turks, all being exposed alike to the rapacity of their common rulers. To one brought up, as most Armenians have been, in the Gladstonian and foreign missionary traditions, the condition of the Jews of Turkey is almost a mathematical demonstration that religious differences had no influence in the tragedy of Turkey, only as they were combined with the aspirations for political separation, which every nation in the world would have treated as treasonable..." Professor Dewey had evidently not been told of the rejection by the Jewish Communities of Turkey of the appeals by the European Zionists for political and financial assistance. Insofar as the Jews of Turkey were concerned, the Zionist proposals were "subversive", unless and until the Ottoman government agreed to them. At no time did the Jews of Turkey nurse aspirations for political separation from their Ottoman saviors, who had received them when no other country allowed their either entry or residence. In 1922 in Izmir, Kemal Ataturk, when he captured 100,000 Greek soldiers who had been allowed by the Allied governments to invade and occupy Turkey in Asia, said: "OF ALL THE ETHNIC MILLETS (Communities) THE JEWS ELECTED TO REMAIN LOYAL TO THEIR MOTHERLAND." Now for a brief view of Armenian atrocities against Muslim and Jews - EXTRACTS from a letter dated December 11, 1983, published in the SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE, as an answer to a letter that had been published in the same journal under the signature of one B. AMARIAN, claiming 1.5 million victims of genocide by the Ottoman Turks: "..We have first hand information and evidence of Armenian atrocities against our people (Jews) which preceded the so-called massacre of Armenians which you allege in 1915. Members of our family witnessed the murder of 148 members of our family near Erzurum, Turkey, by Armenian neighbors, bent on destroying anything and anybody remotely Jewish and/or Muslim. Armenians should look to their own history and see the havoc they and their ancestors perpetrated upon their neighbors... Armenians were in league with HITLER in the last war, on his promise to grant them self government if, in return, the Armenians would help exterminate Jews... Armenians were also hearty proponents of the anti-semitic acts in league with the Russian Communists. Mr Amarian! Prove that, as you say, a large scale massacre of Armenians occured. I don't need your bias." Signed ELIHU BEN LEVI, Vacaville, California. Attached as the last page of this statement is proof of Armenian collaboration with Hitler. My friend, Franz Werfel, of Vienna, Austria, a writer, wrote a book entitled THE 40 DAYS AT MUSSA DAGH, a history of the massacre of Armenians by the Ottoman Turks. The story was told him by his friend, the Armenian Bishop of Vienna and Werfel never doubted the Bishop's account. He did not investigate what he wrote. Years later, when the true facts about Mussa Dagh were established by the research of neutral investigators - which was never denied by the Armenians - Werfel discovered that he had been duped by his friend, the Bishop, with a concocted story. Werfel confessed to me his shame and remorse for hav THE TRUTH Fifty thousand Armenians, residents of villages in and around Erzurum in Turkey surreptiously ascended a mountain called Mussa Dagh (dagh is Turkish for mountain) with arms, ammunition, victuals and water, sufficient to withstand a siege of many days. Before ascending that mountain, they had captured hundreds of Muslim Turks and Jews, their fellow citizens and neighbors, with whom they were supposedly on good terms. They murdered them all in cold blood, for no other reason than they were Muslims and Jews. Thereafter, every night armed Armenian bands came down from that mountain and attacked the rear of the Ottoman and German armies fighting the Russian invaders. This was at the very beginning of the First World War, and part of the secret plans made by the Russians and assigned to the Armenian Revolutionary Federation. ing written that story, in which he had blamed the Ottomans as the aggressors and terrorists. The Turks were mystified. The Armenian attackers would disappear. Try as they did, at first the Ottomans were unable to trace the disappearing Armenians, but finally they discovered that Mussa Dagh was the hiding place. The Ottomans found the mountain fortress unassailable. They laid siege and waited 40 days before the Armenian rear guard conceded defeat and laid down their arms. But the Ottoman forces found the mountain empty. The large army had disappeared down the other side of the mountain where they had found an exit to the Mediterranean. French and British men-of-war had been signalled and they picked up the main army, transporting the soldiers to Alexandria, Egypt, then under the control of the British. Less than 500, the rear guard who gave themselves up, were zaptured by the Ottomans. Yet, in telling the story to Werfel to write, the Bishop had claimed 50,000 victims captured and put to death - an invented story, just as is the story of 1.5 million massacred in 1915. If 1.5 million Armenian lost their lives during that war, they died as soldiers, fighting a war of their own choosing against the Ottoman Empire which had treated them decently and benignly. They were the duped victims of the Russians, of the Allies, and of their own Armenian leaders. A few thousand Armenians may have lost their lives during their relocation, caused by their own subversion. In making this expose of the truth and disclosing my home address, I know that I risk Armenian harrassment. I have already been subjected to telephone and written threaths! However, the truth must be told. As one born in the Ottoman Empire, from which I emigrated in 1910 and have never returned to live, I must declare: 1) I am not and never have been employed or paid by any government in Turkey. 2) I am not now and never have been financially interested in any business in Turkey. 3) My parents died before the Second World War. My sister and brother-in-law, residents of the Island of Rhodes, were captured and murdered by Hitler's Nazis. I have no relatives or friends in Turkey. It should be evident that I have no motive in taking the risk, other than my conscientious duty to tell the truth out of my love for my native land. I beg the Honorable Senators and other government officials to demand from the Armenians proof of their claims and explanation of the statement of avowals made by their own leaders. Under the circumstances and in view of the above proof, I cannot conceive that the Senators can in good conscience pass that resolution. It is not enough to say that they do not mean to hurt the Turks or Turkish/American relations. By entertaining that resolution without proof, they are actually going against the interests of Turkey and the safety of the United States and of NATO. Albert J. Amateau
-
I have been holding my peace when this thread was hot with items like how the diaspora will assimilate in the western countries such as America, France etc. but not in places like Iran, Syria, Lebanon and even Turkey. There may be some truth her but it is mainly a matter of quantity rather quantity, that is, it is a matter of time rather than the character of the actors. One factor may be significant that in the latter countries assimilation is a slower process simply because there is such wide gap of religion and culture, that intermarriage is huge jump. We expand on these two aspects, yet suffice it to say that thnings will change and are changing. Observe the item below, and in particular pay special attention to where I have highlighted. I must also confess that I have not read every item in this thread. The following article is taken from here; http://www.dailystar.com.lb/results.asp The Daily Star, Lebanon April 5 2004 Tearing down Lebanese stereotypes of the 'Armenian ghetto' Special to The Daily Star By Houry Mayissian The discussion revolved around elections in Lebanon. Although the title of the course was "International Communication," our professor never stuck by the book, always trying to stir up discussions on a broad range of issues relevant to the course. I don't exactly remember what point he was trying to make, but he certainly made a point for me. Turning to one of the students he asked: "Who doesn't have the right to vote in Lebanon?" The student looked confused for a second and then, not so sure of herself, "Armenians?" she said. The answer the professor was looking for was of course "citizens under 21." At first I thought her answer was just funny; insulting to a certain extent, but also funny, because the young lady was a university student and particularly a journalism student. Then, it struck me. Is it possible that we've been citizens of this country for almost a century now and yet people know so little about us? Well, it seems that it is possible. The Lebanese not only know so little about their fellow Armenian citizens living here, but also the things they know are solely based on stereotypes. Two main stereotypes particularly revolve around the Armenians living in Lebanon: Armenians don't know how to speak Arabic and the Armenians live in a ghetto in Bourj Hammoud. These are the two lenses through which the Armenians are most often viewed. They are often blamed for living too close with each other, holding each other too tight. They are even made fun of, supposedly, because they don't know how to speak Arabic well or have a funny accent. While I do acknowledge that there are some elements of truth in these images, it must be said that they are overly exaggerated and often insulting. It is true that most elderly Armenians don't know Arabic well. It would be much wiser, however, to try to understand the reason behind it, rather than use it as a means to mock Armenians. Most of these Armenians constitute the first generation born after the survivors of the Armenian genocide of 1915 hit the region. Most of these survivors were orphans when they got here; poor, with no money, clothes, home or family. Gradually, they started building - building houses, schools, churches, cultural organizations, gathering places, sports' groups, and newspapers: In other words, building a home. The Armenian community came to be settled mostly in two major areas, Bourj Hammoud and Anjar, which are to this day mostly inhabited by Armenians. In these two areas the Armenians established tightly held communities, in which the coming generation grew up surrounded by everything that is Armenian. The kids went to Armenian schools, the youth gathered in clubs, the neighbor was an Armenian family, the shopkeeper was Armenian. Taking into consideration the Armenian genocide, the loss of family, friends and home which had a psychological impact on these survivors, it wouldn't be surprising that they held so tightly to each other, helped each other out and stood by each other. Their fear of a foreign land, foreign people and foreign language made them stick to each other and to the community. They seldom went outside of its borders. Perhaps, they didn't even need to. This is the reason behind the elder Armenians not knowing Arabic well. This is how the tightness of the Armenian community should be interpreted instead of being classified as a ghetto. The younger Armenian generations are past the problem of not knowing Arabic well. Despite that, the stereotype, sadly, still prevails. Even as a university student, I've had people asking me if I can read or write Arabic! Perhaps the media in Lebanon are to a certain degree responsible for this image, or to be more accurate, responsible for not changing this image. I remember that a few years ago a certain TV station had a special talk show on the occasion of the Armenian genocide. The featured guests were from the Armenian community. The show started with a discussion about the historical causes of the Armenian genocide, and its impact. Later, however, the host somehow segued into asking questions about the "Armenian ghetto." About why Armenians allegedly preferred to shop from Armenians and a couple of other outrageous questions. I, as an Armenian, was deeply offended to hear a program supposedly dedicated to the Armenian genocide and meant to be a gesture of compassion or support towards the Armenian citizens of Lebanon, which was turned into an interrogation about the so-called ghetto. It was not only rude, but also insulting. I believe that as long serving and faithful citizens of this country we deserve more respectful treatment from our fellow citizens. Houry Mayissian is a journalism student at the Lebanese American University
