Dear Arpa and Armat,
Few lines of disagreement - if you may.
To all “historian” connoisseurs who claim to have enough knowledge of history so as to preach it to others: what is History if not merely a monologue of interpretation. What IS History? Is it not a select of specific events, selected over a multitude of other events in view of specific comprehension of causality. And WHO is it that takes upon himself the task of INTERPRETING history – are/were these individuals classless? Do they have no interest? These are just a few questions before asking “why did Armenian move not eastwards, but westwards?” If I was there and then, maybe I would be better equipped to answer your question, dear Arpa, but one thing that I would not do is to draw one-dimentional parallels or trajectories through historical occurances.
As regards to Melkonian Educational Institute, it is not just a school, but a cultural stronghold that is important for Europe, Middle East and Africa. It is not a day-school to serve the Cypriot Armenian community, but a Boarding school that caters for children from over 40 countries.
Please do not think that your proposals to sell Melkonian and invest it in Armenia are somewhat original – in fact that is what the AGBU’s vague plans are. But does the public in Armenia want that? So far they have said a big and bold “NO”. They would rather see an institution like Melkonian to continue its existence in Cyprus then to see Hanging Gardens built in Yerevan. The Armenian Government too sees existence of Melkonian as an important matter as far as its foreign policy is concerned.
Furthermore, Garabed Melkonian left $1.5 billion worth (in today’s money) so that “Melkonian Fund” is established and so that ONLY the annual interest from that fund go toward Melkonian school and Yerevan State University. He made specific arrangements to see Melkonian exist forever. What remains today of “Melkonian Fund” is only $5.5 million and AGBU refuses to publish reports as to what on earth happened to all that wealth.
More, Melkonian Brothers did not give property rights over Melkonian school to AGBU. All the rights that the AGBU has are the rights of administering the “Melkonian Fund”. The Deed of 1925 clearly states that this is the case. But AGBU, in fact, did sell a large chunk of Melkonian lands in 1986. The AGBU has no legal right to close the school, but if nobody stops them they will !!!
The Deed also clearly states that if AGBU goes bankrupt, or if it finds itself unable to carry the mission of Melkonian, the rights to administration of Melkonian Fund and of MEI will pass on to Echmiadzine.
So you can see that nobody has the right to close that school or sell any of its parts. And there were very clear arrangements to insure that the Melkonian Fund remains untouched and that Melkonian school exists forever. Now, which pockets did all that wealth of $1.5 billion go to?
As for me, you may stay assured that I’m not a Cypriot and I am not a member of any political party. I am, in fact, from Armenia. And, Yes, my concern for Melkonian is inspired by passion and as any matter of blatant injustice inspires passion in a politicised being. The more you read into the subject matter the more you will realise how rotten and corrupt the AGBU’s actions are.
That is why this is not only about “just one school in Cyprus”, but it is a tip of the iceberg – an injustice that exists within our communities and we allow its perpetuation.
If people want, they can go to www.SaveMelkonian.org and read all about it and donate securely there. We have issued an Open Letter to ALL Armenian persons, please download it there, read it and forward it to all Armenians that you know.
Thank you
Garen