Jump to content

aurguplu

Members
  • Posts

    623
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by aurguplu

  1. quote:Originally posted by Anshnork: How can one actually trust that this is true? It is all written in the quran, but who was the author, REALLY? Where did he obtain this information? Hundreds of cultures have existed on this earth, and most, if not all, of them have developed some sort of relgion or spirituality. It is quite obvious to us today that some these beliefs were completely WRONG. And even though each system of belief would claim their knowledge came from a higher source, we can reason that somebody made up the myths. Can it not be true that our monotheistic cultures of today have been created in a similar way? Not from divine revelation, but from imaginative visions of important people? anshnork, i wasn't expressing my own opinion but the doctrine of islam as i understand it (which i claim to do). of course we have no way of knowing, and we have reason to believe that 1) we don't have the messages in their original form, even in the case of islam, and 2) they might have been at least partially composed by persons rather than god, in fact the old and new testaments do not pretend to be the literal word of god in the sense qur'an does, anyway. whether the whole thing is one big lie is of course another matter. we shall know when we are dead. regards,
  2. thorny, 1. the founders of a religion cannot be blamed outright for the practices and lack of brains of its adherents centuries later. 2. may i humbly point out that i have read the qur'an (in arabic, turkish, english, german, and russian) and studied it for four year at university. although much of my knowledge is rusty now, i think i have a right to claim that i know about the qur'an just a wee bit more than someone who hasn't even completed reading it in translation! 3. my knowledge of christianity is admittedly less, in that i only read the new testament in its entirety (and that in english translation) and am currently plowing through the old testament, came all the way to samuel (again in english translation). my bible is the new international version, which is a new translation into english. the translators say it does not differ all that much from the king james' bible, i take their word for it. now as for my views of the three religions: from a scientific point of view, they are all different versions of the same basic religion, monotheism. all are coloured to varying degrees by the practices they relpaced, opposed, or erased: most of the biblical stories can be traced back to mesopotamia (such as noah's ark), the ban on various foodstuffs may have something to do with the earlier animistic religions the semites practised, the concept of the one god having a son may either be a misinterpretation of the hebrew greeting common in the holy land at the time of jesus, as pointed above by anshnork, or it may be the influence of hellenism. the hellenised jews and and other pagans might have found it rather difficult to grasp the concept of a god that is as abstract as it would have been in the purest form of monotheism. the cross, symbol of christianity, has the story of jesus dying for our sins behind it, but something very similar to it was a religious symbol in ancient egypt. and finally, mecca, the holy city of the muslims, was a trade centre and repository of effigies of deities in pre-islamic times, and the practice of hajj (pilgrimage) is a pre-islamic one (as is the structure of the kaabah), and non-religious historians regard the practice of the pilgrimage as a political move to preserve the importance of mecca in the islamic era. i agree with most critics of religions, and am not a practising muslim myself, for one very simple reason: while there may indeed be something eternal and superhuman in their basic message (if you believe in god), the actual practices and regulations are obviously designed by man for man. they might have been improvements for their time, but are impediments today. and also, there are quite a few things that are either borrowings from earlier times or later accretions. all this aside, the three religions obviously agree on the belief that there is a single god, and that it cares about us humans. what they differ in is the interpretation of god's nature, and its implications. i see islam basically as an internationalised version of judaism minus the concept that god created man in his own image (why is god a he and not she? besides, is he white, black, mongol, or what?), and christianity as a hellenised version of a reformist movement within judaism. they are sects rather than distinct religions as far as i am concerned, and it would have been a good deal more obvious if we guys didn't have three different clergies that made quite some living out of the differences. what they differ from is not so much one another but rather hinduism, buddhism, confucianism, and all the other isms. regards,
  3. may i say a few things on the reconciliation committee and genocide recognition. some turks doubtlessly harbour the desire of "postponing indefinitely" the genocide recognition issue by such "reconciliation committees" when other methods fail. but as mj has pointed out, the very fact that there is a reconciliation committee attests to the fact that there is something to reconcile about, and that both parties (including the one which previously ignored it) recognise this fact. this is not compatible with the attitude of a denialist. as i have stated in previous postings, i think that the turkish government is currently preparing the turkish public opinion for an eventual recognition of the genocide. this is only logical, because a government cannot openly embrace a stance on a delicate issue which it knows is not supported by its people. so you do a bit of social engineering by preparing the people to the idea. how do you do that, very simple: remove the barriers on the way to the other side's version that you had erected yourself in the first place, and the people will discover the truth themselves. i think it is very clever.
  4. quote:Originally posted by MJ: I have heard from many Muslims that the prohibition of eating pork in Islam has been imposed only due to health reasons. Additionally, the Old testament provides another list of animals/birds wish are "not clean" for consumption purposes. the pork-eating business can be explained as follows: muslims consider that the pig is the only animal that is known to eat its own feces. its meat contains parasites because of that, and the meat is by nature unclean. now i doubt if the ancient arabs had any sophisticated knowledge of medicine, but you don't have to live in the 20th century to be disgusted by the eating habits and general lifestyle and sheer sight and smell of pigs. after all, that's why we call filthy individuals pigs and not sheep or cattle, isn't it? there is also another explanation, one that i favour to some extent, that the pig was a totemic animal in the early animistic semitic religion, traces of which found its way into the monotheistic religions. it is quite possible that the idea of monotheism was born not amongst the semites but amongst the (closely related) ancient egyptians, and the jews got the idea when they were in egypt from the egyptians and then interwove their earlier religion around the idea of monotheism. after all, it has been observed in history before, and a historian with no religious beliefs (hence no religious prejudice) would entertain that possibility. any comments?
  5. a believing muslim who is also informed might say something like this: all three religions are different versions of the same religion. the first one, jewish, was one confined to one chosen people (would i be accused of anti-semitism if i said that this is reminiscent of the "superior race" heresy of the nazis?) and therefore not universal in its message (here i shall not dwell upon actual jewish practice which included proselytism). the second was christianity, which probably didn't start off as a different religion but as a reformist and universalist movement within judaism, and the concept of god having a son, anathema to a monotheistic religion, can probably be ascribed to the fact that the holy land was much hellenised and romanised at that time, and these people were pagans with gods with human attributes. it took a bout three centuries for christianity to gain permanent ground in the eastern mediterranean, and a good deal longer to spread to much of europe. it was only shortly after that it gained that ground in eastern mediterranean and was gradually expanding into the rest of europe that a second reformist movement came, to purge the religion of the blasphemous thought that God might have a son. this is called islam, which means submission. allah simply means God with a capital g as opposed to a lower-case g. the idea that there is a christian god and a muslim allah is nonsense as far as the muslims are concerned, but there is a difference in our conception of god: god is one and only, has no beginning, no end, no gender, no family, is not begotten, shall not beget, is everywhere at the same time (therefore does not have a physical shape, because the very concept of a shape means that the object in question occupies some parts of space and not others), is basically free from all qualities of its creation, especially humans (if you actually read the quran, you see that he is not free from anger, wrath, revenge, as well as love, compassion, etc, which are all human qualites). another major distinction of islam is that there is nothing, no-one between god and man. although current practice is far removed from the original concepts, mohammad is just another man with no extraordinary powers and not much in the way of miracles, and does not occupy a place between man and god (of course the current practice has got nothing, i mean nothing, to do with the original). there is (or ought to be) no clergy in islam. so a muslim cleric is really a contradiction in terms. i hope this will help a bit. and i would like comments on my view that christianity is a universalised and hellenised version of judaism, and that the concept of god having a son is a result of hellenistic influence. thanks a lot & regards,
  6. ladies & gentleman it is a fact that many sites give error: unable to retrieve the requested url etc. i do not know whether this is the result of turkish censorship, poor maintenance on the part of the website concerned, problems with electronic data transfer, or simply something wrong with my hardware, or worse still, with my ability to use the computer (i am a homo neanderthalensis electronicus when it comes to using technological gadgetry). certainly, quite a few sites are off my reach, but since i have never been unable to reach certain well-known sites where i could get my daily dose of turk-bashing, i doubt it is intentional. regards,
  7. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Ali, that reminds me, are you aware of Abdi İpekçi's daughter speaking up about her family? They were Sebutaycı, and they said that another prominent person who was in charge of foreign affairs at the time (either our minister, İsmail Cem, or Akarcalı was also one. My mother told me about this; I haven't watched the program myself. thorny abdi ipekçi was a selanikli (or sabetaycı , and ismail cem is his cousin. his full nam is ismail cem ipekçi. another member of that community was the late gülçin telci, author at hürriyet. i don't know about bülent akarcalı. regards,
  8. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by gamavor: The question about Indo- European homeland is not something that historians agree upon. Many scholars believe that Asia Minor (Anatolia) is the original birthplace of the Indo-Europeans. Even if we agree that the homeland of Indo-Europeans is Southern Russia and Ukraine, geographically speaking these regions are much closer to Armenia (at present and in the past). In that sense the only "foreign body" in the picture are the turks. They don't belong there and they knew that. Any comparisons with white settlers and past (ancient) invasions of Indo-Europeans into their native lands are simply ridiculous. To me, they sound like a very naïve excuse. Kind of “you see, we are not the only curst nation in this world.” This attitude leads to nowhere. gamavor, i agree that the indo-european homeland problem is an unsolved one. the one theory that had gained widespread acceptance was that it was somewhere in southern russia. this theory had the great advantage of explaining the geographical distribution of the historically attested indo-european language subfamilies, and also the widely believed genetic relationship the ancestor of indo-european had to uralic (and perhaps altaic and paleosiberian languages). common sense dictates that a language family might be genetically related, or at least share common features with, its geographical neighbours. now caucasian, afroasiatic (formerly known as hamito-semitic), hurrian, urartian and sumerian and other language isolates from pre-indo-european anatolia and the middle east are worlds apart from indo european in terms of phonetics, basic vocabulary, morphology, and grammar in general (altogether language typology), whereas this is not the case with uralic and surprisingly with altaic and a good many of the paleosiberian languages. stanford linguist joseph geenberg and various russian scholars have argued rather convincingly on this. i have recently read an online abstract outlining the theory that the homeland was eastern anatolia and the caucasus, there appears to be archaeological evidence in that direction, and it also explains some linguistic puzzles and borrowings in indo-european, but poses more problems than it solves. all this aside, there is hardly anty evidence that the historically attested ancient indo-european peoples ever had a clue that they were related linguistically. only the greeks and romans perceived that their languages were related, and the romans explained this as them being descendants of some tribe which fought at troy. i was also informed orally that alexander the great had noticed that "there was something" between greek and sanskrit when he invaded india. other than that, the europeans only knew that their languages were more similar to one another than say, arabic, hebrew, hungarian or turkish until about the eighteenth century, when systematic work was carried out. there is no evidence whatsoever of a consciousness of a common indo-european past, and the indo-europeans gleefully slaughtered one another throughout history. as for the turks, they do not base their right to belong here or anywhere not on linguistics or geographical origin, but on their sword. this is the only observable criterion that the people of the world actually have been using anywhere anytime. the russians belong to central asia no more than we belong to anatolia (and probably a good deal less in fact, since we are the biological and cultural descendants of the asian invaders and the local population, whereas they are for the most part just slavs misplaced) but they are there and will stay there unless and until someone has the power to throw them out, of which there is no sign today. to compare the turkish invasion of anatolia to the european invasions of the americas, africa and australia is not simply ridiculous, but sound historical practice, which does produce unpalatable results for the europeans in question and forces them to kick the habit of harbouring a "holier than thou" attitude towards other conquering nations. if europeans are expecting that turks and other conquering nations (the arabs, for instance) leave their conquered lands and get back to wherever they came from, they should set an example by sailing back to the old continent and leaving the americas and australia to the americans and the australians. they won't do that, will they? he who has never sinned, let him cast the first stone.
  9. thorny, 1. is the word you are looking for "sanctuary"? 2. reactions to public recognition of the armenian genocide can be diverse: i. some, esp. in the conservative traditionalist faction either look at you with sarcastic eyes and say "who are they? i don't know them." and when you reply with a capsule description of them (not containing the genocide), they reply back "are you one of those who says that there was a genocide, and that we should give anatolia back to the greeks, armenians and kurds?" it is a waste of time and probably dangerous to talk to them. ii. some others say that it was a tit-for-tat, or merely in self-defense, as they had rebelled and tried to carve up the empire. it is very difficult to argue against them, as a) what they say is partially true, and a lot of turks have had personal experience of armenian brutality in ww1 and later in the independence war, they are understandably not symphatetic to anything armenian and their attitude is pretty much a mirror image of the general armenian attitude towards the turks. iii. some others say that it is all lies, and that we good turks should not believe in them, for they (the west) is still trying to put an end to the existence of turks. iv. some tell personal experiences of the genocide, like an armenian grandmother (surprisingly common), the loss of armenian neighbours, the loss of their masters (many artisans, especially the coppersmiths of erzincan. others say that they know in their village people who tried to save the armenians, and perished with them (quite common, this is gonna be serious trouble for the turkish govt when they recognise the genocide). v. an enormous number of people who try to hush it up are ex-armenians. it is even said that by looking at the current name of such a "suspect", you can in some cases tell the original armenian name. for instance, vahap is basically vahan or vartan, numan is nubar, arman is ara (arman is also an armenian name, but some turks have it) erman is either arman or armen, ragıp and yakop are hagop, hayri is hayk, and there are a few others. i have found these ex-armenians the most difficult (and untrustworthy) ones to deal with. vi. there are quite a few people, especially amongst the kurds, and in the anatolian countryside, who had armenian neighbours and deplore their fate. these do not deny the genocide (or rather the killings, the concept of genocide is a bit abstract to them) and mistrust the government or anything that smacks ofthe state. many yörük and türkmen tribes saved quite a few armenians from the massacres, and were in any case horribly treated by the ottoman state throughout the centuries. vii. your sophisticated intellectual city-dweller accepts the killings, and then goes on to extreme lengths to "prove" that they were not part of a genocide. they would go as far as saying that turks would be incapable of genocide, because if they were, then why didn't they do it earlier on, when they were strongest. i personally find it rather tedious to argue with such people, especially when i know that their attitude is not sincere in any case. besides, i happen to be a straighforward man, and simply not capable of nor inclined to the pseudo-logical, -philosophical, and linguistic gymnastics these people resort to. they are expert demagogues. viii. some are more or less along my lines. ix. some, usually among the the grey wolves, say things like "serves them right, they killed us we killed them back, i wish there were more so we could kill more of them, we gave them a lesson they still didn't get it, let's give another one, the ottomans were so stupid not to have killed them off when they had the power, etc etc". i deem it pretty dangerous to hang around anywhere near these guys and usually keep silent when i see them. x. some deplore the whole thing, and yearn for the "good old days" of the empire when everybody lived in harmony. of course, they know zilch about the last century. azat, i doubt if the internet is controlled in turkey. i have been saying what i have been saying for a year now, and am still alive. regards,
  10. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    a query does the word "khakhonch" (written in turkish as hahonç, stress accent on first syllable, the h is the ch in scottish loch) mean anything in armenian, or does it ring any bells to an armenian? regards,
  11. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by khodja: As a historian, I can state that historical methods and linguistic methods of determining origins of peoples will be soon obsolete. The tried and true methods are being usurped by the advancements of science. Yes, languages and cultures can change over a few generations. Genes, however, change much more slowly. The Human Genome Diversity Project is now mapping the peoples of the world. When the results are in there will be little to disagree upon. The initial results are astounding. It will blow the chauvinistic Armenians among us right out of the water. These "emperors" will have NO clothes. khodja, 1. about a decade ago, there was a genetic survey being conducted in the eastern black sea region, which could not be completed because word had leaked that the staunchly muslim and nationalist population of the region was genetically no different from the armenians. the people were fuming, they took it as an affront, and refused to cooperate further. 2. during the s-300 missile crisis with greece about two years ago. a village in the black sea region, a stronghold of the mhp (the grey wolves), protested the greeks and took the very nationalistic decision of "not speaking greek in public in the village anymore". 3. the founder of the mhp, the late a.t. (you know whom i mean) is frequently rumoured to have been of armenian origin and aware of the fact since his relatives spoke armenian. 4. ziya gökalp, the founder of turkish nationalism, is a kurd from lice, diyarbakır. he never entertained the latter lunacy that the kurds were an ancient turkish tribe. 5. the ethnicity of atatürk is a taboo subject in turkey, and speculation is rampant. 6. in almost every case where a dig takes place anywhere in turkey, and some old bones are unearthed, the subsequent dna analyses reveal that the local population is genetically related to the bones, unless they are known to have been recent (19th-20th centuries) immigrants from central asia or the balkans. 7. the population of anatolia when turks came in must have been around 12-15 million, whereas the incoming turks can not be proven to have numbered much bove three million (the nationalists have tried to swell the numbers, but available records do not support them). 8. a good number of the registers of the ottoman empire all the way from the fourteenth century, which have been prepared fo critical editions, can still not be published on account of the evidence of gradual or sudden mass conversions to islam in anatolia. and, finally, turks are for the most part fully aware of the fact that they are far more similar to the neighbouring peoples than the central asians. all they have to do is look at the mirror. regards,
  12. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    khodja, i share your hopes. as for the turkish official histories, just let me tell you that for most intelligent turks, "official history" means "lies". come on, we lived in a country where almost ten per cent of the whole population was armenian. our neighbours, our business partners, people in our government, our small-scale artisans, the people who built the dolmabahçe palace, our doctors, grocers etc. many of them were armenian. do you think we don't ask the question of what happened to them all, or whether they were all insurgents? the time will come. as i said many times before, to think of the genocide was a crime a decade ago. today you can conduct surveys in turkey where you ask people whether they think the genocide did take place, and eleven per cent are vocal enough to say "yes". i!ll be damned if there will not be a formal recognition of the genocide by the end of this decade. regards,
  13. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by khodja: Ali, I agree that there are definite differences between the Jewish and Armenian Genocides, one being racial (genetic) the other religious and cultural. I also agree that Armenian mercenaries gave Talaat a excuse to eliminate the Armenians en masse. However, near the end of the period of extermination of Armenians the Triumvirate changed the rules and ordered that Armenians could save themselves by embracing Islam only after they had reached their destinations. The "destinations" planned for Armenians were not on this earth, therefore even this option to save themselves was denied them. khodja, i wasn't defending the triumvirate. near the end of the period of the extermination they had the blood of a million innocent people in their hands, a fact which does not affect one's psychological balance positively, i presume. the bastards lied to their closest friends, including the rest of the ittihad and terakki. i can't wait until some more of the memoirs of the prominent people of the time is published, and we will all see the past in a new light. more on this later regards,
  14. anshnork, i am a turk from istanbul. i was exposed to the fact of genocide when i was fourteen. it was my grandfather who made some remarks about it a few months before he passed away. and in my family, which was a very political one, nobody ever denied the genocide in the event in cropped up in conversations. the overwhelming majority of those turks who deny the genocide are honest in their approach: they really know zilch about it. now that genocide recognition has been hitting the headlines round the world (and especially in turkey) there is general awareness of the fact that we are ACCUSED OF something, but people still think that is a lie because there is not much, well nothing really, if you are in turkey, in the way of solid evidence that the genocide indeed occurred. the government knows this and capitalises on it. i have known about the genocide since about the end of 1981. later on, i rad about it, from both turkish, armenian, and third party sources. i still maintain that my knowledge of the issue is woefully inadequate (there is so much stuff in so many languages that you have to read, plus it is an inaccessible and potentially dangerous subject, especially if you belong to one of the nations concerned). i have never been forced to accept the genocide, rather i came to my own conclusions about it by what my family told me and by what i read in the academic literature. i have also encountered some armenian in life, both in turkey and abroad, but their stance toward the genocide did not affect me much since i already knew about it by the time i first met them. a lot of armenians think that the turks will not accept the genocide unless forced to do so, i beg to be an example to the contrary. i have been moved to accept it by the sheer weight of evidence in front of me, and i believe many of my countrymen would do the same. so it is your duty, if i may say so, to publish the evidence, at least for your people and mine, because this is an issue that concerns both of us directly. good luck in your endeavour. regards,
  15. raffi, re islamic lands: iraq and syria were majority muslim for over half a millennium by then (without that much of bloodshedding), and, o.k. i agree with your point re anatolia, but consider the fact that it ws already called "turchia" at the twelfth century by the italians. and no matter whether it was islamic or not, the mongols still flattened it. alpha, i agree with you that they destroyed more than they constructed, but then again, what was the positive viking contribution to world culture? and their descendants today are amongst the most civilised nations of the world. i believe that all human societies have trhe same basic capabilities under the same conditions, and the meagre conributions to world civilisation by the mongols and by the turks is a function of the inhospitable terrain they were born in rather than any genetic defect or what. central asia is basically a frozen flatland with no tree cover and arable land, and no civilisation has ever been born in such an inhospitable terrain. the conquests of turks and mongols must be seen in this light: they were forced to get out of there by mother nature in order to make a better living, simply because the land is not suited to sustaining large numbers of people. they were better fighers and more cruel than the settled peoples to the south, because if they weren't, they were going to die out. it is a simple fight for mere survival. my ancestors' two tribes (the kayı and the avshar) came to turkey because 1) the avshar had to find better pasture for their flock, and 2) the kayı were driven out of their homeland in khorassan by the mongols. no one is inherently evil. we came to anatolia because if we didn't we were going to die out.
  16. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: Ali, the spoken language of the Uruatians is not known, only their written language. Since the written language was used by the ruling elite it is possible that the ordinary people spoke a completely different language. Indeed, since the Uratian empire was large it likely that there were several languages other than "Uratian" spoken anyway. And remember also that races can change their spoken language in remarkably short time periods, three or four generations is all it needs. i agree with what you say. perhaps i was forced to bring up the issue and adopt this position in face of some recent attacks concerning our right to be in anatolia. it is possible, though i doubt it for linguistic reasons, that the ancestors of the armenians were amongst the constituent peoples of te urartu state. i doubt it for the following reasons: armenian is an indo-european language, probably belonging to the same group as phrygian, which itself appears to have been closely related to the ancient illyrian and thracian languages, and only slightly more distantly to greek. it is generally accepted that the indo-european homeland was in what is now southern russia and ukraine. there is archaeological evidence that there were at least three major incursions into anatolia: ca. 2000 bc (or earlier), which brought the hittites and the anatolian subgroup of indo-european, ca. 1600? bc. that brought the greeks who wrote in linear b, and some were in anatolia i understand, and ca. 1200-1100 bc that brought the "sea peoples", the phrygians etc. (i do realise that i overlook here the earliest surviving pieces of indo-aryan (sanskrit to the common reader) in hittite sources from the early 2nd millennium bc (especially regarding equestrian stuff), and the later cimmerian invasions) it is most likely that the anestor of the armenian language was closely related to phrygian, and came to anatolia at the same time. if i can remember my dates correctly (i am writing from the office and my books are at home), the chronology makes it more likely that they were the destroyers of urartian culture than one of the constituent parties of it). their relation to urartu is perhaps more comparable to the relation of the turks to the armenians: they put an end to their political existence, and took over much of their culture save their language, in exactly trhe same fashion as we did centuries later. i understand that this theory may be very unpalatable to most armenians, who see in themselves a continuation of the urartu, but perhaps as a non-armenian and non-turk you are better able to offer an unbiased criticism of my position. p.s.: i am familiar with the works of the russian and georgian scholars gamkrelidze and ivanov, and that of colin renfrew, who put the indo-european homeland in eastern anatolia and ascribe the spread of farming into europe to the expansion of the chariot-riding indo-europeans. it is a powerfully argued theory, but it fails to answer a few very important nagging questions, which we can explore later if you feel so inclined (i myself would be glad to do so). and, although it is entirely possible thatthe elite of urartu spoke a caucasian language while the populace spoke an indo-european one, it is also entirely possible thatthey both spoke the same language! linguists generally consider examining thefirst possibility when there is some evidence pointing in that direction. is there one? regards,
  17. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    khodja, 1. i agree with the points you raised. 2. i do not recall either in my recent or earlier postings to have questioned the fact of genocide, nor its inherent criminality and the impossibility to find a moral justification for a genocide, any genocide. therefore, you do not have to try to convince me that there was an armenian genocide, and that it was a crime against humanity, because i know that, i knew it long before i joined this forum, and i have been taking some serious risks trying to expose the rest of my countrymen to the grim reality, even with my commanders during my 16-month military service (i was a tank 2nd lt (non-commissioned officer), and commissioned tank people are not noted for their brains nor their tolerance! (to think of it, it was quite rash of me to have told one of the captains whom i was teaching english that it had occurred and that it was a crime (in fact he conceded that it had occured and that it was a crime, but that such things did happen when a empire was about to break up, he then pointed out the collapse of yugoslavia and the inaction of europe during the bosnian genocide, at which point i could not argue back)). what i am saying is that the separatist actions of some armenian factions that started during the reign of sultan abdulhamid ii (who treated the turks only marginally better than the armenians) with a view to inciting the turks to retailate with atrocities so that the christian west would intervene as it did in the balkans to save those christians from the hands of the muslim turks and give them their state (this is not a theory but the printed programme of many of the armenian secret societies of the time, unless all these books i read on te subject written by turks armenians and other non-turks are lying), eventually brought disaster upon the armenian nation in the form of the genocide, because a secret clique inside the committee of the union and progress had already decided to get rid of the armenians in order to create a purely turkic (or, more realistically, muslim) empire that would stretch from anatolia into central asia, and they were already looking for a pretext to carry out that grisly deed. so my earlier posting regarding the remarks of a cypriot remains standing. the armenian revolutionaries took a calculated risk with the lives of their own people, thinking that they would liberate the majority by sacrificing a minority. this would probably have worked if it were sultan abdulhamid that they were dealing with, because for all his unspeakable cruelty, he was a classical ottoman type sultan in these matters: what he wanted was absolute obedience, he would do anything to get it, but once you gave that to him, you were safe: he did not harbour such lunatic ideas as killing off all non-muslims in order to create a purely muslim, far less a purely turkic, state: he even used non-muslims in his state administration at the highest levels. he was an empreror who wanted absolute obedience, that was all. the young turks, on the other hand, were nationalist, purist, and racist, and wanted to create a nationally, culturally and racially pure state. you see, the motives of those who masterminded the genocide were quite different from those who actually carried out the killings. the populace that was engaged in the killings were genuinely fearing that the armenians did pose a real threat to their existence (and they had reason to think so), a significant number of them were also former victims of the muslim massacres in the balkans, russia, and elsewhere, so they acted in revenge. there were also quite a few who joined the killings for material gain: booty (the kurds for the most part). they unwittingly served the "grand design" of the triumvirate (we call this the triumvirate, but i personally believe that the idea was originally that of one man, talat, rather than enver, cemal, and the others, and that in all probability it was the germans, or at least his exposure to german culture and military, that planted the idea in his mind. the germans are currently de-classifying the relevant archives, i bet it will prove to be very interesting reading). i think that the armenians have always made the mistake of comparing the armenian genocide to the jewish holocaust, and this was the main reason it was usually rejected in so many countries: there are several reasons for this: 1. in the jewish case, there was no provocation at all, and germany was not facing imminent military defeat and eventual collapse in which the jews were a fifth column in collaboration with the enemy, 2. even though the young turks were racist and nationalistic, or better put "purist", theirs was not one of genetic (biological) purity, but rather cultural and political purity. it appears (to me at least) that they were not against the existence of people with different genetics, but people with different cultures and hence with a potential for future separatist demands. tey wanted a state in which everybody was unanimous in their desire to keep it in one peace. this is in stark contrast with the nazi case, where they attempted to "kill the genes" of the so-called non-aryans, regardless of their fidelity to the german state or not (and to the best of my knowledge the jews were never asking for a separate state within the confines of germany.), and 3. the jews are understandably very much against the classification of their trauma with other cases, however horrible they may be, because theirs is really without equal in human history. not even the armenian genocide comes close to what the jews went through. i can understand that. in view of the above, i have been advocating for the past few years that the armenian genocide is far more comparable to the bosnian one than the jewish holocaust. i see a very significant difference between racism based on perceived genetic differences and ethnic hatred based on perceived hostile stance between two peoples: one is about something that you are born with and can do nothing about (and, more significantly, does not shape your personality unless your culture dictates to you that you are different from the rest of humanity on account of your genes and should base your attitudes about yourself and the others on your genetic makeup rather than your and their personal qualities), the other is a conscious stance that you acquire over the span of your life through culture. and the fact that members of your family were offered conversion to save their lives strengthens my position: if it were the armenian genes that were under attack, they would not have been offered that. (i know that there were cases where the jews were offered conversion to catholicism, but as far as i can see, most of those who converted were butchered anyway. this is a topic i know a good deal less about, and would welcome comments/corrections/information). this topic is so broad and deep that it might requiree a separate heading. i apologise for my convoluted prose, i wrote this off without re-reading it, and i realise the sentences are overly long and may contain grammatical mistakes. i a m waiting for comments. (i will address "aliyah" in another posting). regards, [ October 12, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  18. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    harut, this is what i was going to post sometime in the future. i completely agree with you. the most serious burning issue between the turks and the armenians is the denial of the genocide, and the days of this attitude are numbered. when we get this out of the way, all the other problems will be solved a good deal more easily. khodja, here is a hardliner's comment (this is not my opinion (at least the moral part of it) but is basically what many hardliners think in turkey: the west, after centuries of oppressing the natives in america, africa and australia, is now repenting and doing things for them. the reasons why they have been doing this now and have not done it until about the end of the last century are the following: 1. at that time the subjugation of the natives was not complete (native americans fought the usa until the end of the 19th century, and there were programs in the usa designed to strip them off their culture well until the first quarter of this century). they can talk about it today because the natives as a separate entity linguistically, culturally, and even racially are on their way to extinction. there is nothing more that the usa has to do actively because the natural processes of assimilation and extinction have gone too far to reverse the trend. so today you can give them human zoos called reservations (in most cases a fraction of their original land, in a few, even not their original land but some other area), call these a state, have them draft constitutions in their languages (which are dying out, anyway), and not worry a bit, because they will be nothing more than a curiosity in the great melting pot of america. there has never been an independent indian state that has been a member of the united nations, and there never will be one. there is only one (as far as i know) native language in the whole of americas that enjoys co-official status with spanish, and that is guarani of paraguay. to the best of my knowledge, neither nahuatl, nor any one of the mayan languages (not even yucatec, huastec, or quiche, spoken by quite a few million people between them) are co-official in any of the states where they are spoken, because they still constitute a danger (remember the zapatistas, the killings in guatemala). 2. north american indians did not have either the degree of cultural sophistication, or cultural/linguistic unity, or sheer numbers to constitute a genuine threat either to the usa or to canada. therefore the americans and canadians can afford to be far more obliging in giving them the rights they give, because they do not have to fear any separatist action (perhaps the mohawks in canada are an exception). our situation is in stark contrast to them: we did not kill off the earlier inhabitants of anatolia when we conquered it, in fact, until the arrival of nationalism on ottoman soil in the 19th century, the armenians constituted a good ten per cent of anatolian population, and the greeks probably double that figure (the percentage of kurds was a good deal lower, actually, but this is a topic on its own). the people we conquered were for the most part left to speak their language, practise their religion (church building continued in turkey under the ottomans, a fact rarely admitted by either the greeks or the armenians), call themselves whatever they wanted, and were organised into millets and were pretty much autonomous in their internal affairs, only the top being responsible to the sultan! in hindsight, this attitude, while to the credit of the ottomans, was perhaps the greatest mistake they made: they conquered peoples, and chose not to eliminate or assimilate them: they were allowed to exist, fully preserving their separate identity. of course, they betrayed the empire that had treated them so much better than the civilised west treated its own conquered peoples, at the first opportunity. another difference was that while the west conqured peoples in most cases markedly inferior to them in terms of cultural sophistication, technology and sheer numbers, the turks conquered the greeks and the armenians, both literate civilisations with a very strong sense of identity, a high level of civilisation, a formalised world religion (with adherents all over), a high degree of technological expertise and not negligible numbers. these peoples posed a far greater potential threat to a weakening empire than the natives of america, africa and austalia ever could, yet they were treated with ha good deal more dignity than these latter were. and today we are more reviled by the so-called "civilised world" than that "civilised world" itself. it is true that the armenian genocide, the armenian massacres of sultan abdulhamid, the massacre at chios in greece in the 19th century, and quite a few more are blots in turkish history and human history in general. but our record still stands far better than that of the west, which, as pointed out, is responsible for the disappearance of a quarter of humanity. we had the power to completely eliminate both the greeks and the armenians for almost a millennium, we did not do it. we do deserve credit for that, first and foremost from the greeks and the armenians themselves, just as we do deserve condemnation for the genocide and other crimes. you say you come from a noble family of cilicia. you know you are an armenian. you speak armenian. your culture is armenian, and it is alive and well. you know that your culture will pass onto your children with no hindrance. and your people have been the subjects of barbarian turks for almost a millennium! now replace you, armenian and barbarian turk with he, she (for people you know about) the natives, civilised west, and five hundred years, and see with your own eyes how much of it applies. many hardliners in my country think that if we had converted the greeks and armenians to islam, and forced turkish upon them, we would not have had any one of these problems in the first place. i am disgusted by such an idea, but i have seen the ugly truth in so many of such ideas that i don't know what to say to them. could you offer me an idea?
  19. it is not correct to say that mongols did not contribute to human civilisation. true, they themselves perhaps did not invent anything of note, but they were instrumental in the transmission of much chinese stuff to the west, including, amongst others, the printing press and paper currency. also, both chinese and islamic art owes a lot to the mongols (and more to the turks) in terms of an ornamental vocabulary. they were also the first empire to rule over such distances, and had a bureaucracy and postal system far more effective than anything in the west or the middle east. of course, they were also amongst the greatest barbarians of all time. they are the major reason why so little in terms of physical remains survive from the islamic lands they flattened, notably syria, ıraq and anatolia.
  20. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    by the way, re stolen heritage: the indigenous people of anatolia do not exist anymore. they were called the khatti, and their language was already extinct by the early second millennium b.c., replaced by the indo-european hittite (who took over their name) and its relative luvian. luvian was also widely spoken in greece prior to the arrival of greeks in about 1600 b.c. the armenians are thought to have arrived much later, about 1200-1100 b.c., from moesia in northern greece, whither they had come from present-day romania or thereabouts. and they were very probably part of the group of "sea peoples" who were responsible for the destruction of the hittite empire, and later, that of the urartu kingdom. now the armenians talk of being the inheritors of urartu culture, while two of the vital components of their heritage - their language and ethnic name - have nothing to do with the urartu (the urartu language is known from inscriptions, and is a close relative of the latter hurrian, and both of them probably belong to the same family as present-day georgian and circassian etc, so these people, who are still in the region, probably have a better case in caliming urartu than the armenians do). the "mingling" of the incoming armenians and the indigenous urartu was nothing peaceful if the distinctly warlike nature of the relics of indo-european incursions that are being dug up today are anything to go by. so the "arrival" of the armenians into anatolia and their subsequent development was very much along the same lines as those of the latter-day turks. so what makes the heritage of the armenians not "stolen" and that of the turks "stolen"? what gives you - and not us - the right to claim urartu heritage and land? that you carry their genes? that you have been there longer than we have? that whatever you did, you did it so long ago? and that your victims are extinct, so that they cannot incriminate you with anything, and they are only the romantic subjects of study of some archaeologists? you were formed by pretty much the same "historical processes" (read: invasion, plunder, rape and murder) as we were. do not forget.
  21. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    in case anyone thought that by "clean-up" i meant a re-run of the genocide. NO. i meant, if you want to do some spiritual clean-up, some reconciliation, repentance and compensation with the past, start home. i, and many people like me, have started home by digging up the armenian genocide issue. everybody has some issue to dig up, don't they?
  22. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    quote:Originally posted by khodja: Ali, Nations of our era attempt to project civility. Other than your nation which nation in the last 200 years has totally exterminated the nationals of lands they wish to possess? The Holocaust was different because the Nazis only coveted the assets of the Jews, not their ancestral lands. the american whites, for example. three-quarters of the native american languages, together with the peoples who spoke them, are extinct today. the australian whites, for example. same as above. the germans in africa, for example (they all but killed off the herero). (isn't it funny, these are all germanic-speaking northern europeans, they are responsible for the extinctin of about a quarter of humanity. they have a much better chance of being nominated for the "barbarian of the past millennium" award than we are, not a single nation went extinct under our rule of almost a millennium.) the chinese in tibet and sinkiang, for example (the chinese are deliberately inflicting conditions calculated to bring about the death of entire populations, such as man-made famine in tibet and above-ground nuclear detonations in sinkiang. by the way, turks did not totally exterminate the armenians, otherwise you would not have been there to talk to me. the criminality of the armenian genocide is second to none, but we are in distinguished (!) company here. at least we do not try to give others a lesson in civilisation. the nation that droped two bombs on japanese cities has the audacity to do that. and, by the way, they still have not apologised officially. khodja, i understand you are an american-armenian 8if i am correct) . here is a humble suggestion: you want to do some clean-up, start home. i want to do some clean-up, and i have started home with the armenian genocide.
  23. aurguplu

    The stolen heritage

    the turks did not acquire their caucasian type by mixing with the anatolians. the place where they come from in central asia, originally the foothills of the altai mountains, lyes at the boundary of the natural distribution of the caucasian and mongol races. there have been caucasians in that region (and in sinkiang in chinese turkestan) since at least the 2nd millennium b.c. from their first mention in historical sources, the people we know to have been turkic-speakers have always been mentioned either as mongoliod or caucasian in appearance, so much so that some ethnonyms, such as "cuman" meant fair-haired, as did the name given them by the russians (polovtsy) and the germans (falben). chinese sources frequently mention turks as "red-haired barbarians", hardly the description of a mongol. this was partly due to the early presence of tokharians in sinkiang, who spoke a western form of indo-european (like english and german) and were culturally quite close to the celts and germans, judging by the material remains they left behind. according to legend, the oghuz (the branch of turks who moved into anatolia, and who are also the ancestors of the anatolian turks, the azeris, and the turkmen) were composed of 24 tribes, at least two of which have names that rae known to be non-turkic. these are the döger ( the turks themselves see themselves as a linguistic group: he is a turk who speaks turkic. so all this rubbish about the racial attributes of turks is just that - rubbish.
  24. thorny, she is, and is a friend of mine from oxford.
  25. quote:Originally posted by khodja: Aurguplu, Only a very small number of Armenians died in hand-to-hand combat with Turks in a war combatant situation. The great majority, I would say approximately 99% of Armenians, died in a soykirim. As for the Turks who died during World War I, 99% died in battle or from other war related causes, with a miniscule number dying from Armenian revenge killings after the Genocide. i partially agree, but there were armenian killings of turks (or, rather, christian killings of muslims, contemporary documents do not regularly refer to ethnicities), and - a point turks frequently make and armenians frequently downplay (though not deny), there were armenians serving in the ranks of the enemy, the russians and french in particular. the armenians themselves used this point to win the favour of the west for an independent armenia (see boghos noubar), and although the number of ottoman armenians that served in enemy ranks was not that high (and not that low, either), they performed vital services for them, especially scouting in anatolian terrain. and a good deal of this predated the deportation orders and was used as a pretext for it. it cannot be stressed enough that nothing justifies a genocide, but the fact remains that the actions of a not insignificant minority of the ottoman armenians did in fact play into the hands of those murderers who appear to have had the idea of exterminating the armenians anyway. when these things happened, they had the pretext for the deportation which they would use as a cloak for the genocide. and many armenians today are weakening their case by pretending that the young turks deported and killed the armenians with no provocation from the armenian side, only acting upon "suspicion" that they would betray the ottomans, when the armenian uprising was indeed in full swing in many areas and the local armenians had formed regular troops. i am currently collecting info on this from turkish sources, which is a time-consuming work (they are so disorganised), which i am going to work into a chronological order. a lot of garbage is flying around in both turkish and armenian non-academic sources, and a degree of discipline is in order. i stress here again and again that nothing on earth can justify a genocide, and that a faction of the young turks (talat, enver, said halim, cemal, bahaeddin shakir etc.) are to blame for it, but are there not a few, very few, armenian shoulders that are carrying the blame for the disaster that befell their nation? i know of a cypriot greek who privately admitted (to other cypriot greeks, mainland greeks, and some turks) that the cypriot greeks had provoked turkey to invade the island by calling for a union with greece (enosis) in open violation of the cypriot constitution and massacring some turkish villages to this end, prompting a military response from turkey. the man was of course not some turkish-paid agent or whatever, nor did he accept the divided state of the island, but was cognizant of the fact that they had made a mistake which had played into the hands of the enemy. i shall post more about this when i get this chronological stuff completed. regards,
×
×
  • Create New...