aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
khodja, after the independence war and the ensuing population exchanges with greece, the population structure of anatolia changed out of all recognition. the government at the time was a populist, if i may say so, socialist one, and one of the first things they did was some sort of land reform. land was redistributed among peasants, and as in so many such cases, many rather murky characters appropriated a lot of land, not only belonging to the armenians, but also greeks, and surprise surprise, to many turks. this is a still unsettled issue in turkey where court battles are still going on regarding this issue. if the success of ethnic turks in these battles is anything to go by, it will take at least a century for any armenian to get a penny for the lands his family owned. another problem is that the plots have been re-drawn and built upon. some have been appropriated by the state. i doubt the triumvirate guys have been able to carry off the wealth they usurped, becuase most union and progress families are in pretty bad shape today (a new state means new people). i would very much doubt that the majority of the people who live on former armenian property have had anything to do with the genocide, there were quite a few converted armenians who made a lot of money out of it though. i had explored this in a very early posting of mine, almost a year ago, i am sure mj would remember. the govt has one final thing to worry about, and that is these crypto-ex-armenians. this is a potentially very explosive issue in turkey. as stated before, these are the people who will resist any thaw in turkish-armenian relations because they have vested interests in the current situation. hope this will help. take care,
-
khodja, i agree with you 100%. as i have stated in past postings, the currently prevailing attitude of "what? genocide? never heard of it. what are you talking about?" is on its way out (this was the main refrain when i was young). it has currently given way to "the unfortunate events of 1915 cannot be classified as genocide", but even the turkish version of the events clearly fall within the genocide category. the only ecape route of denialists is the fact that there is no reliable documentary evidence that shows that the triumvirate actually issued the orders (the evidence from other documents, such as testimonies, eyewitness accounts, etc are compelling, but not conclusive evidence). now since we know that the jewish holocaust occurred, and that there is not a single piece of paper ordering the killing of the jews with hitler's signature on it, that last escape route of the denialists is also closed, a fact that turks will realise when they read some european history. people like me are working over here to expose their countrymen to the less palatable truths of their past, and we find ourselves in a situation that could be best described by the turkish idiom "to be able to please neither moses nor jesus". i for one expect the armenians to understand two things: 1) their version of the events is not the only truth, we also have things to say, 2) we have an already extremely difficult job to tackle, and if they are not going o help, they can at least not be an impediment. so far the armenians have by and large been uncooperative towards the few turks who want to change things, as can be seen from the attitude of the majority of diaspora armenians to the TARC. i understand their fears that this is yet another move by the turkish govt to bury the genocide issue, bt they also have torealise that attitudes are changing even in government circles. as i have stated repeatedly, they cannot take such a drastic step without first forming adequate public support for it, and this will not happen unless and until enough turks are exposed to the truth. they are pursuing this very cleverly, i think: first, they are removing the barriers to truth in front of us, and this has already started to bear fruit: the number of turks who think that what happened was a genocide is increasing. patience is vital.
-
mj, khodja, i am writing this out without having gone through the entire thread (maybe i should). i thought that mj had got the wrong impression of khodja's stance, indeed my impression of khodja's stance differed from that of mj, then mj pointed out diligently where i misread him, meanwhile khodja replied that i understood him so much better than mj. i hope to be excused if i told you i am slightly confused by now? who is who? who is trying to say what? and who is trying to say that the other one is trying to say what? (the first casualty in a confused mind is the grammar, excuse me). i think that you both either have a perception problem, or expression problem, with each other's postings, or find it rather difficult to come to terms with perhaps unpalatable facts that either of you put forward. i shall take one thread, that jewish one, it is one i can tackle: first of all, there is a hebrew ethnic identity, based on pretty much what all ethnic identities are based upon. tyhen there is the jewish identity, and all you have to do is read your old testament, jewish history of the last 2,000 years, and look at the present-day jews, to realise that to say they all came from a single genetic source is sheer nonsense. most jews wouldn't do that. judaism was a proselytising religion, it has recently re-started that (at least adopted a more hospitable attitude toward the converts). it is known that jews were all over the middle east, and that not all of them stayed as jews. the armenians may very well have some jewish or some other semitic blood, just as i may have some armenian blood (i would be surprised if i didn't have any). it amounts to nothing. the armenians may also have many jewish cultural traits, which also amounts to no great deal. we have them, too. every nation which professes a monotheistic religion inevitably has them and there is nothing wrong (or right) with that. it simply should not any longer be an issue at this day and age. now if your battlefield is the presumed presence or absence of jewish traits amongst the armenians, then you are a bit like the clerics in gulliver's travels (was it gulliver's travels or alice in wonderland?) who wage war against one another over the question of whether to break the egg from the pointed end or the blunt one. if the issue is the ottoman influence on the armenians, well, it was there, it is there, and it will have to be there to a certain extent unless you are willing to say goodbye to a good part of your present-day culture. and as for trying to ottomanise armenians, i think it is a losing battle (if there is anyone who is fighting it, which i cannot see), if only because there are no ottomans anymore, and will never be, simply because the nation that started it all finished it all out of its own accord. as the ottomans (the remnants) themselves say, ottoman is merely "a nice sound in the vault" (kubbede kalan hoş sada, sorry for the admittedly awful translation). as armenians you have the task of building up the republic of armenia, normalising relations with turks, (including the azeris) and becoming first class members of the family of nations. you are not that far from that, but you will find it much harder as long as you cannot formulate a reasonably coherent attitude toward the past and its implications that it adopted by the clear majority of the armenian community. i regret to say that i got the impression in this forum over the past year or so that you have some work to do to this end. i believe that there will be peace between our two nations one day, and hopefully in my own lifetime, but this will not be before you have peace within the armenian community. hope this helps a bit. i shal reply to the other issues mj raised later. take care & try to make peace,
-
khodja, there is at least one business family known to be of armenian origin: süren (fuat süren and his son faruk) they own the transtürk holding (currently in bad shape) and a number of other companies, i don't know much about them, but all their companies have had some serious trouble in the past. the son, at least, is very strogngly affiliated to galatasaray (the soccer team) and was frequently accused of neglecting family business in favour of the team. fuat süren's former secretary's daughter was an analyst of mine until the crisis. now three major families, koç, sabancı and eczacıbaşı: koç is a turk from ankara, he started making his money there and ten came to istanbul. sabancı's father was a cotton-piker in adana, he made it rich there and came to istanbul. eczacıbaşı was a son of a pharmacist, who studied in germany and made a huge business out of the health sector. i would take a closer look at sabancı if i were you (also, check out all businessmen affiliated to the mhp, a number of mhp guys are rumoured to be ex-or-crypto-armenians). good luck,
-
khodja, these are the problems you will run into: 1. the majority of armenian assets of value (especially land) were, to the best of my knowledge, not distributed across anatolia but concentrated in istanbul. these lands are now the property of turkish business magnates. even if you can persuade the turkish government in the distant future, your most formidable enemy will be these business magnates. i am sure a map of istanbul will show you what i am talking about. you can find the relevant people/organisations listed with TÜSİAD. regards,
-
sorry for the format of the above posting. i messed i up again with the "reply with quote" business.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Ali, "I am back in my hotel from a business dinner and few drinks after a long day. Wouldn't like to get back to the original topic of this discussion unless I can concentrate on it. However, there are a couple of short comments that I would like to make: 1. I would appreciate if you could also post the date of the letter of Boghos Nubar *****, if you have at your disposal. I truly don't know it. However from its spirit I can discern that it has been written in 1919. Is this an accurate guess? I also would like to ask you if by posting it here (which was a good thing to do), you meant that any of my arguments given on the subject of this letter were invalid?" ı don't have the date offhand (i am at work now and was lazy last night, didn't research my library thoroughly. i also got the impression that it was written in 1919, at any rate after the closure of the great war. i posted it there simply because i chanced upon it (it was posted by oz in us vs. them under genocide, i think, and there is some more info on the letter which i left there). the reason i posted it was i think we have to restart the position of the armenians on the eve of ww1. since i joined the forum, the main lines of my argument was: 1. what happened to the armenians in 1915 qualifies as a genocide, in that the whole population, regardless of stance in the war, were subjected to it. 2. nothing "justifies" a genocide. 3. on the other hand, the armenians were not "meek lambs" (as quoted from a british statesman of the period), and had been active against the ottoman empire way before the deportations (before these qualified as genocide). 4. this betrayal of the ottoman empire by the armenians (who were neither so few in number nor so insignificant in their influence on the armenian population) gave the triumvirate the pretext they needed to get rid of the armenians altogether, a desire which they appear to have harboured befor the war. 5. the people who carried out the actual killings did so for a variety of reasons such as revenge, booty, fanaticism, sense of betrayal, genuine fear of "kill or get killed" etc., but the design to exterminate an entire nation under the cloak of deportations rests with the triumvirate. 6. examined thus, the armenian genocide is far more comparable to the bosnian one than the jewish holocaust, and this is a very strong reason why the armenian genocide does not get the universal recognition the jewish holocaust does (if i were a jew, i would oppose it: what happened to the jews is really without parallel, not even yours comes close). 7. the armenian genocide was one aspect of the breakup of a multi-ethnic empire: to see it out of context is perverse. yet this is precisely the mistake that the armenians are doing. 8. both armenians and turks appear to be the least informed people on the issue at hand. as can be seen, this is going to be a long discussion. how about moving it to another thread, while you & khodja continue with your thaiboxing contest here? 2. Very briefly talking on the subject of Khodja, I would like ot remind the readers the phrase of one of the greatest thinkers of the century, A. Maslow, where he claims something like, "If the only instrument you have is a hammer, every problem in the world reminds you a nail." I find this phrase to be of incredible precision. my god. let me think. you wanna date a girl, and all you have is a hammer. you won't have much of a sex life, will you? if i were in such a situation, i would first distance myself from the problem a bit (if i can, acquire other tools, and only then tackle it again. remember: humanity started with chipped stones. but the tools that put us to the moon were not stones. think about it. And it applies to Khodja (I may guess his real first name is Peter/Bedros) very accurately. The thing is that being the low level partisan (primaries) functionary he is, he has a very limited set of skills, and there are few things he has been trained to fight against. And so that to be able to do it successfully, he desperately tries to define your perimeters and put you in a framework (regardless if it is applicable), so that to take the few things from his small bag of limited tricks, and execute his routine exercise. I would’ve not bothered discussing him if the problem at hands was not of wider scale character. mj, i am sorry to tell you this, but i can take out that last paragraph of yours, insert it into the speech of some grey wolf/establishment ideologue against the armenians, and it would not look out of place. my diagnosis of the situation is that you both have very strongly held opinions that are diametrically opposite one another. khodja, by his own definition, is an ottoman armenian, and he told in a previous posting that his family were practically christian turks. now his viewpoint is bound to be different from yours, if you do not share that heritage to the same degree. i recall a friend of mine get very astonished when he had witnessed german jews in israel preferring to speak german over hebrew fifty years after the war! the answer he got when he enquired was even more amazing: "you cannot know what it is like being a german jew." we should not forget the fact that despite the fact that we have an unresolved conflict and were at eachother's throats less than a century ago, we also have a thousand years of a common culture which permeats all aspects of our lives. i have far more in common with an armenian than with a kazakh, and you have far more in common with a turk than with some armenian colony in poland or china (yes, there are some over there) who got cut off from the rest of the armenians a thousand years ago. and while your attitude is basically "o.k., i can get along with a turk who accepts the genocide", but it occurs to you less that many of the things you describe as armenian are actually the product of that great melting pot of anatolia. khodja, on the other hand, appears to be more aware of that, and does not seem to mind it a bit. if there were no genocide, and if the ottoman empire (or whatever subsequent state) had improved its civil rights to the level of present-day european states, the ottomanised armenians would go on living happily as first-class citizens of a multinational empire, much as the present-day scots and welsh and other commonwealth nations of the united kingdom. why should they be enemies of a state to which they gave so much, if they could take as much as they gave, if the give-and-take relationship were a fair one? and why should they rebel if they saw that in the ensuing independent state, they would lose most of what they had in the empire, and probably gain vey little in return? i think this was the dilemma very many ottoman armenians of standing faced at that time. i believe that in thefinal analysis, all armed action has got something to do with finances. this is a very broad topic that again we have to pursue under a different thread. sorry my material has been hectic and disconnected, too, i shall try to be more organised in my later postings. I will address your previous posting on the subject when I can better concentrate on it.
-
o.k. everybody, now that we know that "khakhonch" means "snail", i would like to know if anyone knew of a village of rize (eastern black sea coast) that was called by that name, and what its fate was. could anyone help me out on that, please? thanks in advance,
-
mj, i found the letter by boghos noubar again, it was posted by oz in "us vs. them" "Dear Minister, I have the honour, in the name of the Armenian National Delegation, of submitting to Your Excellency the following declaration, at the same time reminding that: The Armenians have been, since the beginning of the war, de facto belligerents, as you yourself have acknowledged, since they have fought alongside the Allies on all fronts, enduring heavy sacrifices and great suffering for the sake of their unshakeable attachment to the cause of the Entente: In France, through their volunteers, who started joining the Foreign Legion in the first days and covered themselves with glory under the French flag; In Palestine and Syria, where the Armenian volunteers, recruited by the National Delegation at the request of the government of the Republic itself, made up more than half of the French contingent and played a large role in the victory of General Allenby, as himself and his French chiefs have officially declared; In the Caucasus, where, without mentioning the 150.000 Armenians in the Imperial Russian Army, more than 40.000 of their volunteers contributed to the liberation of a portion of the Armenian vilayets, and where, under the command of their leaders, Antranik and Nazarbekoff, they, alone among the peoples of the Caucasus, offered resistance to the Turkish armies, from the beginning of the Bolshevist withdrawal right up to the signing of an armistice. Boghos Nubar" now if the numbers in this letter is anywhere near the truth, it appears that as many as a quarter of a million armenians (the french foreign legion was mentioned elsewhere to contain some 100,000 armenians at the time) were under arms fighting the turks. that is as much as %10 of one of the higher estimates for the total number of armenians in the ottoman empire at the time. in comparison, the current turkish republic has a population of 66 million people, and a standing army of some 550,000 souls, less thean ten per cent of the whole population. so, shall we reexamine the issue of armenian involvement during the war prior to the genocide?
-
thorny, 1. i had told you that i am no advocate of islam, and that i distance myself from it partly for the same reasons that you do. 2. the believers of any religion have a lot of blood in their hands, true, but so do the atheists. 3. i think it is no use to try to reconcile believer thought and atheist thought. the difference is just too fundamental.
-
"I am literally out the door for my weekly trip, and can address the issue at this time only very briefly. Hopefully would revisit it later. And I would much appreciate that in the future you request clarifications from me instead of calling me names. Not that you are not at liberty to call me racist, but you couldn’t be further away from understanding the apparent controversy." I cannot see how I called you names. I merely pointed you that the manner in which you have used a Turkish (or Muslim) name to refer to your opponent was very much comparable to my experience as "artin suat". I am not claiming that you are racist or whatever, but tell me yourself, were you at our best there? "First, when people call you “Artin,” do you get insulted? Clearly this is just a rhetoric question. Is Mustafa a Turkish name or an Islamic name? I have thought Islamic." Well, if they know my real name and insist on calling me by another, yes, not because there is anything wrong with artin or being armenian, but simply because I am neither artin nor an armenian and never pretended to be. If you know who I am, then why do you insist on calling me something that we both know that I am not? I thought that by referring to khodja as mustafa or mehmet you were calling him a turk. Obviously, the armenians have more to sort out with turks than other muslims, right? "Another question, when you go to these Turkish circles and express your opinions on the Armenian Genocide do you introduce yourself with a name like “Saradarabad,” for example?" No, because 1) I have my own name which has served me reasonably well so far, and 2) I do not know that much about sardarabad to adopt it as a name, and 3) most turks would not have heard of it. "The title “Khodja” given to an Armenian is indicative of the Armenian enslavement throughout history and our assimilation." There were armenians who were referred to as "khodja" in the ottoman empire. Besides, so many armenian surnames have turkish components. Shall we call this indicative of turkish enslavement, too? Maybe you should develop a healthier attitude toward the past. About the genocide we are agreed (I presume). But it is about the rest of the last 1,000 years that you have to come to terms with. Turkish dominion on the lands in question is a fact. You were not the only nation to experience it. On the other hand, extensive loss of central asian culture in favour of an anatolian one and adoption of an essentially anatolian lifestyle is also a fact for us. If it weren't for our language and high (as opposed to everyday) religious affiliation, what difference would there be between us an the rest of the anatolians, past and present? One more thing: armenians have, throughout history, have proved very resistant to assimilation, at least the voluntary one. Forced assimilation is another matter and the title of "khodja" probably has nothing to do with it. (if his title were "yataghan" or "jizyah", then o.k., I would have agreed with you) "Tell me please, what is in your opinion the statement that the person coming to this forum is trying to make here? He says it is the title of his grand grandfather – shame on him." You have instantly put almost all ottoman armenians of note to shame. "In another episode he proudly describes how his titled ancestor has stubbed a knife into the national liberation movement and consciousness, and from all I can gather, it has not just been a psychological position, but something with real consequences for the other types of Armenians." I have to get back and read the relevant passage before I can address that one. "In this forum the person who introduces himself like “Khodja” does nothing else but stubbing the nation – there is not one positive material that he has posted." MJ, with all due respect, you are starting to sound like the Turkish nationalists that I am encountering over here. First, his opinions - and, o.k. background - may differ from yours, but that does not mean that he is stabbing the nation from behind. It simply means that you two differ. And as a legal alien (if I may use that term for myself) I have seen much sense in a good deal of his arguments. "His entire behavior is one of a fly, which gets attracted to the manure." It is a time-honoured intellectual practice. The fly is there because the manure is there. "And if there is no manure, he creates it himself." I doubt this last one. "His primary thesis in this forum, which he is carefully coming out with is that Armenians are of Jewish genetic makeup." This wasn't the impression I got of his thesis. All he was trying to say - as far as I got it - was that the Armenians have a habit of seeing themselves as a racially pure nation, whereas in fact they are jus as mixed as any other middle eastern nation. "First of all, scientifically speaking this is inaccurate (it doesn’t insult me however). But the most puzzling thing for me is that he is trying to make a statement out of it. He is trying to “prove” that Armenians are not a “pure” nation. First of all, who cares." Those who protest at it. If you didn't care, you wouldn't protest at it, would you? Second, in my view, anybody who tries to make classifications of nations on the basis of the genetics, and suggest policies on that basis, as he does, belongs to the fringes of the human society and is the real racist, if you are searching for racists here. This is part of the reason he disgusts me. I got the impression that he was trying to make precisely the opposite, namely to point out that classifications of nations based on perceived differences in the past - which include genetics - will soon be shown to have no basis in fact. In this he might have a point: in many cases, there are no convincing characteristics to distinguish a nation fro the others other than a national language and an awareness of a common past, but then again, our awareness of a common past, including our awareness of our own ethnicity - is at least partly shaped by a number of commonly held notions, many of which are either distorted or in te most extreme cases have the flimsiest connection to scientifically demonstrable realities. This is what I think he is trying to say and I see no racism here, rather the precise opposite. The person in defense of whom you rise, totally denounces the Armenian Sovereignty and Statehood, promotes an idea (among other such ideas) that Armenians where better off under the Ottoman Empire, because his ancestors had reached high positions in the Ottoman establishment, for example. If he said that (that the Armenians were better of under the Ottomans) then I missed it, I have to re-read his postings. And if he connected it to the sole example of his own family (which I doubt) then you would have been right. The question is at the expense of what? I agree with you here. Certainly, independence and sovereignty is best for a nation, and the Armenians did lose certain things under the Ottomans, even though their treatment up to Abdulhamid II was considerably better than the treatment of other subject peoples in other empires. As I have said many times in this forum, I have many Muslim friends – very close ones, I have no racial or ethnic issues with Turks, I have no anger for the past, etc. MJ, your anger for the past occasionally pops out. I don't blame you for it in any way: even though I am no armenian, I have a certain anger for what happened to the armenians, especially when I think that certain maniacs did it in the name of my entire nation. But I despise the Ottomanized Armenians like Khodja, while I may very much be supportive of the Turks – these Ottomanized Armenians are the liability of our nation. Another interesting thing to notice is his degree of Ottomanization being born (I assume) in America. By his own recognition, his family has been denounced by the Armenian Community. These ottomanised armenians form a very significant proportion of the armenian community. Besides, don't forget: to be ottomanised is to become a natural part of of a multi-ethnic world empire. It is by no means the same as losing your ethnic identity and becoming a turk. If his family made a living in the ottoman empire and rose to high posts, how could he not become ottomanised? Can you be anything in america without being americanised? In other forums he claims that he is hiding his real identity so that some Armenians “don’t come after him.” Ask him why should some Armenians leave aside their personal lives and their businesses, and “come after him?” What is it that he has done? Or maybe what is it that his grand grandfather as done, maybe? No comment. "This is a hectic material. I am sort of nervous because I am running late. If I find time and energy, will plug in from my hotel. Otherwise, if I would not be too tired from the trip, I would get back to the subject over the weekend. P.S. One last thing. If you are interested, ask him why does he support the Section 907, and what is it that bothers him in me not supporting it and not opposing its lifting. I am sure you can find the text of the Section 907 Resolution online." I have to read the section 907 resolution before doing that. Could you be so kind as to give me a link to it? Thanks.
-
mj, so i should not think that the people who call me "artin suat" on account of my acceptance of the genocide are using the armenian identity to insult me and commit a double crime by 1) insulting me because i defend a vision of the past that they oppose, and 2) insulting the entire armenian nation by using a typical armenian name as an instrument of insult? may be i should not have levelled such harsh criticism on meral akşener, tansu çiller's interior minister, when she called abdullah öcalan "ermeni dölü" (armenian seed). she later (much later) confessed that that was the one thing she had regretted the most in her entire political career. even the armenian community of turkey, which is rarel seen and hardly ever heard, protested at the affront. maybe we should not condemn her. may be she didn't say the things we thought she said. what do you think, mj? (by the way, my grand-grand father's name was mustafa, and one of my grandfathers' name was mehmet ali). i am waiting for your clarification of the issue. thanks in advance. take care,
-
quote:Originally posted by raffiaharonian: Although i hate to do that (he he he), I agree with many of Ali's postings. Not that much with the historical presentations , as much as with his line of thought about the infuence of religions on us. I think that Azad's poting has the following gap: The islam was 'created' in about 640 A.D. and at that time there was no Catholic Church as such. There was the Church of Rome, but not in the consept that we know it now. The formation of the Catholic Church can be attributed mainly to the 'SKHISM'=split of the Christian Church in 1045A.D. The split was between the Eastern and the Western Church. So basically the story or version of Azad is totally out of touch with reality of those times. Besides that if I am not mistakes at that time (around 600AD) the Italian peninsula was under heavy attack by the Goths.(ostrogoths or visigoths...) and the vandals. hence the Roman church was basically trying to survive the attacks and was begging for the help of its Eastern brothers , which never came. As to the consept of Dante, i have the notion that he claimed that good Christians will go to Heaven, while Jews and Moslems, nomatter how good or bad they are, they will stay in a limbo stage. They will never enter Paradise because they never accepted the truth of Jesus. I think it is called the 'purgatory'... I think somehow we deviated from the original subject , but i guess it was worth it, i enjoyed all of it , including the love romance between Martin and Khodja! ( I have a strong belief that those 2 would make great friends if were to meet in real...) wow! i am honoured and puzzled at the same time. i would appreciate your feedback on my historical presentations (of course since i dash them off at work, i have no way of re-checking them, but i think i have fared reasonably well so far. i also try to remove any "-centric" approach in my postings, i think the discipline of history suffered a lot from that. i can take any criticism which states that i put excessive store on linguistic stuff (i do, in the heat of the moment, it is my private passion and tends to creep into anything), and apologies for those less interested. i may also sound like and apologetic or whatever every now and then (and may be wrong in certain points), but i think you have rarely been exposed to a relatively informed version of history through the eyes of "the other", and i am trying to give that. lapses (inevitable), i own up to them. finally, my typing: it's god's fault to have given me sausage-like fingers and a generally clumsy physique. cheers, [ October 22, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
azat, pretty basic content but haven't found any howlers. so i think it's o.k. the list that i gave you earlier, though, would give you enough info to blow away most muslims in arguments. take care,
-
khodja, a word of solidarity: don't be put off when you are called "mustafa" or "mehmet" by people whose opinion of certain issues differs from yours. i am called "artin suat" whenever i voice my known opinion of the armenian genocide, by people who cannot stomach it. my usual refrain is that it is rude and a kind of racism to use an ethnic name or any name to designate an ethnicity to insult someone, at which point the more civilised ones shut up. as for the less civilised ones, well you can't help everyone, can you? regards,
-
thorny, what did the soviet union do? regards,
-
dear winston, can you give me the title etc. of that book by joseph campbell, please? and do you know whether it can be ordered online from amazon/barnes&noble? dear azat, o.k. i would sue that lacturer if i were you (just kidding). if you are interested, let me tell you briefly how we approach the story of early islam as academicians (my ex-would-be profession. sob!): 1. first of all, you look at the evidence: there are a set of recognised sources on islam, the first and foremost being the qur'an, the second being the life of the prophet. then there are various sources (most of them published and condensed in a manner accessible to the layman) that give you the early post-muhammad history of islam, which is still a hotbed of debate, among academicians as well as muslims. 2. second, you interpret the evidence. let me stress here briefly that the commonly accepted account of islam's origins as told by the original muslim sources does not differ substantially from the generally available academic versions on the subject in the west. there are a few very competent scholars who differ on the relative importance of muhammad versus ali and umar, for instance, and whether it was originally a jewish sect that turned independent, etc. but they are outside the general current of academic thought and very difficult to follow without a thorough grounding in the old & new testaments, the qur'an, the various syriac, coptic and early greek stuff on the matter (including a serious command of these languages), in brief, not that accessible to the common reader. the best translation of the qur'an is the one by muhammad marmaduke pickthall, an englishman who turned muslim. it also gives an account of the life of the prophet. you can start with that if you want to. then there are a few good books (i have tried to choose the ones relatively easy to plough through): the arabs by j. mansfield (a journalist but one who knows what he's talking about), history of the arabs by philip k. hitti, another by albert hourani. these will give you the general background and an extensive bibliography for further study. i can come up with more suggestions if you want, but you will have to give me some time, for i will have to run through my library and bibliographies. thorny, 1. you don't have to read mein kampf to know that nazism sucks, but i) you would know more about its development and how it could enlist so many otherwise brilliant members of a highly civilised nation, which i think is a necessity: prevention is better than cure, and in order to prevent, you have to know. ii) someone who has actually read it is quite likely to know more about nazism and thus in a better position than you to critise it, and iii) we know more about nazism than we do about early islam because it happened so recently and it is far better documented, and some of both the perpetrators and the victims were alive to tell the tale until very recently. this is not the case with islam. 2. i find it rather ludicrous (the most diplomatic word i can come up with) to compare muhammad to hitler, or islam to nazism. i believe (and see from history) that regimes based on tyranny, cruelty and oppression do not last that long, as in the case of nazism and communism, and even laissez-faire capitalism, or sultan abdulhamid's reign. the fact that islam is still alive (but probably not that well) 1400 years after its inception is enough proof for me that it is not the cruel, tyrannical regime that some portray it as so frequently. true, it falls short of today's human rights standards, but then again, which religion doesn't? and we may criticise muhammad for certain things, but what do we know of the milieu in which he lived? do we compare him to the rest of his tribe?. and if we are to judge him by today's standards, then we have to apply this to the rest of the prophets, and few, if any, would shine under that light. and finally, there is no excuse for nt reading: to read or not to be. regards,
-
winston, thanx a lot. i'll check it. thorny, i am not an apologist for the qur'an. nor am i a devout muslim, in fact i do not believe in any specific religion. i understand your indignation at the way the qur'an treats women and lures men to islam by the use of flowing milk and honey and of women as sex objects, but the book was revealed to a very, very primitive bunch of people. consider the analogy: two organisations try to make a very large bunch of english first-year students to listen to a lecture on the plight of afghan children. one just announces the date, venue, lecturer etc., the other adds "free booze after lecture" in larger font than the rest of the ad. which one is going to attract more listeners? i think that was the problem that islam faced at the beginning. and consider, muhammad had a total of thirteen wives throughout his life, bt he was married to khadija only until she died. and a lot of his other marriages are openly admitted to be political (not that the people of the time found anything wrong with this, by the way: marriage was a way of making political alliances and settling differences, and the opinions of the parties concerned was given little priority). i myself do find it rather hard to stomach that he married aisha at the age of nine (the marriage was consummated when she was twelve), but i doubt how much it differed from the practice of the day. again, i am no apologist, and i fully agree with you that whatever boon islam might have brought to humanity then, is long gone. regards,
-
MosJan, i doubt it is a religion that is aggressive, it is the people who practise it. nevertheless, i believe that animistic religions which do not proseltyse are by dint of this very fact less aggressive than religions claiming to have a universal message. a reading of the holy books and early histories of the three monotheistic religions shows that they all were very aggressive at the various stages of their history. there are quite a few passages in the old testament that would land most prophets concerned into the u.n. tribunal for human rights, the spread of christianity in northern europe, egypt and especially in the americas was largely by the sword, and islam spread also largely by force. even the relatively peaceful religion of buddhism had spread by the sword immediately after the death of the buddha, but was then rendered more peaceful. there are two things that make religions with a universal message aggressive: 1) the missionary zeal, the notion that it is your duty to convert me into christianity to save my soul even if it takes some force (don't take it personally, this is just an example), and 2) the notion that the unbeliever is a potential enemy. i have not seen any monotheistic religion that has a coherent policy toward nonbelievers. regrads,
-
azat, here are a few comments on that lecture you took at university: 1. the vatican could not have contemplated turning the arabs in north africa into catholicism, because there were no arabs in north africa or anywhere else save the arabian desert (not even in syria and iraq) at the time of the prophet. arabs were confined to a part of the arabian desert, and even places like the yemen and oman had non-arab semitic populations. in the north they were found as far north as the jordan (the famous city of petra was built by nabatean arabs), but syria and iraq had semitic inhabitants who, despite being close cousins of the arabs, and speaking closely related languages, were not arabs. the ethnic similarity between the two peoples contributed greatly to the arabisation of these countries. the pre-arab languages in the area were mostly syriac, assyrian, chaldean etc., all very closely related to both arabic and hebrew. an arab or hebrew speaker can learn these languages within a matter of weeks. north africa was inhabited by the egyptians (the ones who built the pyramids) who were conquered by hellenistic greeks and then romans and were amongst the original converts to monophysite christianity (like the earliest arenian christians). they were being given an extremely tough time by the byzantine church, and the people had so much enough of the whole thing that there was no effective resistance to speak of when amr ibn al as (the arab commander) conquered egypt (i can't remember the date offhand, but it was either late in the prophet's life or shortly after his death). the egyptian language then was called coptic, and was a direct descendant of the hieroglyphic one. now the semitic languages and egyptian are related, both being afroasiatic. further o the west lye the berbers (tuareg, kabyle etc.) who also speak related afroasiatic languages. so the whole of north africa and the middle east was in fact linguistically and culturally related, which might have played a role in easing te difficulties the arabs faced in the conquests (arabs to this date have problems with the egyptian christians and muslim berbers, though, and even muslim egyptians have reservations about considering themselves as arabs). 2. as for khadija, she was muhammad's wife, and the first convert to islam. none of muhammad's family, including muhammad himself, is considered a god or goddess in islam, which is a most strictly monotheistic religion. christianity worships jesus, but islam does not worship muhammad: he was just a mouthpiece for god and a role model for humanity (the second characteristic came into being after his death). now of course what muslims actually do is a completely different matter. i hope this will help. regards,
-
dear winston, i agree with what you say. sure ataturks don't come every day, and that we were blessed in a way few nations - and certainly no other post-ottoman or muslim nation - has been. but the thing that had produced ataturk was the severity of the times: we wre on the brink of extinction. i would not want an ataturk today simply because it would show us that we are on the brink of extinction once again. those were interesting times, and may i remind you of the chinese curse "may you live in interesting times". now we have to make do with the fact that if there is any potential ataturk, he is definitely nowhere near the parliament, and he keeps a remarkably low profile. indeed he may not be there at all. (goota dash now, bye)
-
winston, thanks for your remarks and encouragement. i have to answer two points you raised: 1. it may be (i think is) true that the turkish elite does not have a unified policy regarding the genocide, or the armenians altogether. i welcome this. i had rather that some people would come up and say honestly that they don't believe that what took place was indeed a genocide than see that everyone agrees on the surface that the genocide indeed took place. look at germany: they were made to accept the fact of holocaust, and still today there are neo-nazis (tons of them) and holocaust denialists. the thing is that if you make someone to accept something that he is not inclined to do, you will never be sure that that person has accepted it wholeheartedly, because during the process you break his pride. as stated before, i for one was never forced to accept the genocide by anyone, but simply accepted it in the face of the evidence. you need more guys like me (no boasting intended). as for the policy of the state, it is one of an ostrich with its head in the sand at its best, and no policy at its worst. turkey simply does not have an efficient foreign policy doctrine, as it does not have an efficient domestic policy, economic policy and what not policy doctrine. this is the result of three successive military coups which rendered the political system devoid of statesmen and full of politicos. we just don't have guys of the calibre necessary to formulate viable policies on such matters. 2. it may indeed be that some members of the reconciliation commission have somewhere in the back of their mind the idea of making the armenians drop their claims of genocide, or even more, convince them that there was indeed no genocide. i am sure some religious body in christendom has a science-religion reconciliation committee to make scientists drop their claims that the earth is round and the heavens were created in 15 billion years, or more still, to convince them that the earth is really flat and that the heavens were created in seven days. who cares? regards, [ October 17, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
thorny, when i was your age i was just as impatient as you. you learn to be patient over time. thirty years ago it would have been a criminal offense to say a word, or even a book on the genocide defending the armenian position (in the 1970s the police could simply storm into your house without search warrant, search it, and confiscate anything that they liked. our house was searched those days and my parents very nearly got into trouble for owning a copy of das kapital (my dad is a retired economist, das kapital is a textbook)). i had some trouble with a bekçi in 1984 for mentioning the word "kurd". i was called to have a chat with an ex-army MİT officer on thesubject of kurds (very civilised conversation, and nothing happened later on). up until the second half of the reign of ozal, all printred matter in kurdish was forbidden. ozal very cleverly maneuvred things so that kurdish stuff could hit the newsstands. today there is a kurdish press, there are kurdish books, tapes and things, and you can buy them freely in beyoğlu (not known to be a kurdish-majority place in istanbul) two steps from a police station. and now, very recently,, the legal barriers in front of kurdish have been removed. i suggest you get into yahoo and type basque and check the web sites on the language. you will find that the french and spanish polcies on basque were not until very recently much different from the turkish policy on kurdish, and still, there is much left to be desired. these are problems that cannot be solved overnight. today you can be exposed to the armenian version of events and get away with it, as we are doing currently. the state still has the power to crush us like a bug if they want to. the fact that they are not doing that is to me an indication of attitudes changing. this is what my common sense, knowledge of history and personal experience of turkey tells me. regards,
-
thorny, i don't know. i don't know enough about the nuts and bolts of internet communication to comment. all i can say is that if you want to be exposed to hefty doses of anti-turkish propaganda, all you have to do is log in, point your mouse and click. if anyone is out there to prevent us access to it, they are not very efficient, are they? after all, what are we turks doing in an armenian forum? would the national security council approve of such subversive behaviour?
-
quote:Originally posted by Azat: I know very little about religion so the following information could be totally wrong. I think that there is not much argument that Judaism and Christianity have a common theme/start, the thing in question is Islam. And from what I remember Islam started because of the need of the Vatican wanting to have control over Jerusalem where the Jews had control. Another problem was the true Christians in North Africa preaching the gospel. Roman Catholicism was growing in power and would not tolerate any opposition. Somehow the Vatican had to create a weapon to eliminate both the Jews and the true Christian believers who refused to accept Roman Catholicism. Looking to North Africa, they saw the multitudes of Arabs as a source of manpower to do their dirty work. A number of Arabs had become Roman Catholic. The Vatican wanted to create a messiah for the Arabs, a leader who would ultimately capture Jerusalem for the pope. An Arabian Catholic lady by the nake of Khadijah helped the Vatican. Her job was to find a young man become this leader to create a new religion and become the messiah for the children of Ishmael. She soon found young Muhammad, and they were married. Khadijah cousin Waraquah, who was a very faithful Roman Catholic as well had tremendous influence on Muhammad. Vatican sent teachers and advisors to young Muhammad, and he underwent intensive training. Muhammad devoured the works of Saint Augustine under Waraquah's teaching. Vatican then ordered Roman Catholic Arabs across North Africa to begin spreading the story of a great one. While Muhammad was being groomed, he was told that his enemies were the Jews. He was also told that the Roman Catholics were the only true Christians and that the others calling themselves Christians were actually wicked impostors and children of the devil who should be destroyed. Muhammad began receiving his divine teachings in a cave in Mt. Hira close to Mecca. Eventually, out of all these teachings came forth the holy book of Islam called the Koran. I think it contains much of Muhammad's writings. By the time Muhammad died, the religion of Islam was huge. The nomadic Arab tribes were joining forces in the name of Allah and his prophet, Muhammad. There was a point in history than that Islam gained it's own momentum like a snowball down a mountain side. Islam began to oppose the Roman Church. It refuse to hand over Jerusalem to Rome, which was the main reason the Pope organized the army of Islam. Instead they built a monument there, the Dome of the Rock, which stands to this day as a Pagan insult on the Temple Mount. Rome then took action to try and eliminate the monster (Islam) they had created and thus began the crusades. The Muslims were all but removed from existence by the crusades. All this again, was done in the name of Christ. I believe Islam has great respect for and worship of the Virgin Mary. Even Mohammed said that Fatima his daughter, "is the most holy of all women in Paradise, next to Mary." His own daughter who was considered a goddess, was set below Mary. Mary is called the Queen of Heaven, the Mother of God, and the Wife of God. It seems no accident that when Rome wanted to draw Islam into a closer, friendlier relationship, that there was a "Miraculous appearance of Mary of all places in the city of Fatima, in Portugal, that was named after Mohammed's daughter Fatima. Since that time the Virgin Mary has been called "Our lady of Fatima" and there is cult within the Catholic Church called the Blue Army of Fatima, who are Mary worshippers. The Islamist accepted this all to be veneration of Mohammed's daughter. ---------- Thorny – I believe the crusades are a perfect example of Christianity being spread by force. Also the “discovery” of the Americas and the conversion of the Incas and others in the new world was mainly done by force. azat, i have never encountered anything remotely resembling your interpretation of the beginnings of islam either in turkey, or in europe, or in egypt, or anywhere else (and i have an m.a. in oriental studies from oxford, which includdes the early history of islam). can you tell us your sources please? regards,
