aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
11 June 2001 dear berj, hello and thanks for the welcome. Hope to post more. Regards, ali suat dear boghos, so we’re from the same clan! I am UWC Ad 83-85, so your senior! Re getting together people: I think the UWC experience would help a bit but not too much. this would be because of the small number of people involved, and the fact that they would inevitably belong to the student/cultural/economic/political elite of the countries. They would also already be civilised, open to dialogue, and somewhat knowledgeable about the past. Though I can tell from my own experience that there are always new things to learn! Now I see very little point in getting people together to seek a common ground if these people do have quite some common ground in the first place. Take me, for example: there is little point in getting me together with an Armenian to discuss whether there was a genocide, who was wrong etc, since I already know and openly accept that there was a genocide and that we were wrong. The point is in getting the “wildlife” on both sides together to learn to live with facts and with one another. I think there are several serious problems in getting people started in such a dialogue: 1. Security: thorny rose expresses concern over my exposing myself so openly. She is partially right. Although this country is changing, the fact that an Assyrian priest was tried for having said that there was indeed an Armenian Genocide (he was later released if I am not mistaken) shows that the change is not complete yet. 2. Knowledge: to discuss any issue in a fruitful manner you need knowledge, and it is both difficult and dangerous to attempt to get yourself informed on the Armenian Genocide in Turkey. True, you can get to any publication that defendes the Turkish position, but getting at those that defend the opposite is considerably more difficult and dangerous. Also, to even ask to get access to the archives is not advisable. Add to this the fact that Turks in general are – and have never been – great readers, and you get an ill-informed crowd that will start a dialogue. 3. Interests: there are people and institutions on both sides who will be adversely affected by such a rapprochement on both sides, and try to kill it in the nest. On the Armenian side, people and institutions have been making quite a living off the tragedy via books, films, documentaries, educational programmes, university departments, research institues, political lobbying etc. Turco-Armenian reconciliation will mean most if not all of this will be gone. Would you want that if you were a Professor of Armenian Studies at, say, UCLA, for instance? On the Turkish side, people have had material gains from the Genocide in the form of looting and would fear it to go (I must say their fears ae unfounded). There are also quite a few Turks of clandestine Armenian origin who would best see the issue put to rest silently for fear of having their roots exposed (there are far more of those than I previously thought, I understand). 4. Fear & Mistrust: Both Turks and Armenians will fear and mistrust eachother for having “ulterior aims”. The Turks will fear that the Armenians are going to try to retake Eastern Anatolia under the guise of “reconciliation”, or at least extort as much money and concessions from the Turks as they can. These can be anything, ranging from hard cash to solving the Nagorno-Artsax problem the way Armenians would like it to be solved. The Armenians, on the other hand, will probably fear seeing in this yet another attempt at denying or at least playing down the Genocide. I am sure they will fear other things as well, but I think it is better for an Armenian to write on them. I think what we can do is the following: we can invite a few people over to Turkey, and talk more face to face. It would be best if we could bring together public figures from our communities, or maybe at least prominent students who are likely to come to higher positions in the future. We can also – I am thinking aloud – initiate an oral history project where survivors & their relatives from both sides talk. I know the Armenians have done this within their community, but to the best of my knowledge the Turks have not – except for a few propagandist pieces that we know of. I have ties to the Turkish Foundation for Social and Economic History, and maybe something can be arranged. Let’s think about it. For those who think I am dreaming, let me tell you this: the atmosphere in this country is changing. When I was a child no-one dared to question the official version of anything. For instance, to mention the word “Kurd” was a criminal offence. Now there are dozens of bookshops in Istanbul where you can get Kurdish books and newspapers etc. No-one, not even the army, seems to have any restrictions on openly discussing the issue. It has become such an overworked issue that many people simply do not care anymore. A few months ago Gaffar Okkan, the police chief of Diyarbakır, referred but many separatist Kurds as “the Kurdish capital” was gunned down by Hizbullah guerillas, a fundamentalist Islamic terrorist group once used by the state as a countermeasure to combat the PKK. The entire city of Diyarbakır marched in the funeral cortege. One teacher, when interviewed, gave a particularly touching account of why he was there. He said: “I come from a culture where a man is not allowed to weep. I didn’t weep for my mother, nor for m father, nor for my brother, but for Gaffar (Okkan).” Now five years ago Diyarbakır was the capital of the PKK. Things change. So must we. Two decades ago we did not have the discussing environment we have today. As a result, today a growing number of Turks come to think that there might after all be a grain of truth in what the Armenians say. After all, how did these guys from Sivas, Kayseri, Adana etc. end up in Los Angeles? I am sure if you took opinion polls every second or third year in Turkey (the first one last year) the percentage of people who thought that there was indeed a genocide would increase each time. And I think that is what the government wants. They know that they are fighting a losing battle trying to stop the resolutions recognising the genocide: they are not preventing, merely delaying the inevitable. In the mean time, they are allowing the Turkish public to be exposed to the truth in small doses so that they can deal with it when the whole thing comes rolling down. And we are seeing the results already: check that last issue of Atlas and see for yourself. It also has an English section. Whatever we do, our efforts will be like a snowball. Let’s start the ball rolling, and it will grow. Thorny Rose, what do you think? Regards, Ali Suat
-
dear winston, thanx for your encouragement in your last post. allow me to clarify one think in one of my earlier posts today: this is re atlas magazine. i dont call 1915 "1915". it's atlas' last issue that has a separate volume on that year labelled 1915. i myself call 1915 1915 and the armenian genocide the armenian genocide. it's a pity that you dont speak any armenian. people shouldnt forget their language just because they live in america. i have cousins in california, first generation americans, and the eldest speaks and writes pretty well, the middle one gets by in speech but has trouble reading, and the youngest one barely strings a sentence together. it's a pity, cause living in this world and only speaking one language is like living in a castle and not getting out of your one room. it hurts me particularly because i have a lifelong interest in languages, speak a few of them, but dont speak greek because my grandmother and grandaunt would switch to turkish whenever we entered the room. by the way, i hope the government is still sending students there. i think they are changing a bit, too. dont forget that its almost nine decades now, both the victims and the criminals are long gone. thirty years ago it would still have been difficult because some of those old sharks were still alive. today they have no-one alive to protect. i will carry the discusion further starting monday, but have to dash off now. take care,
-
dear mj thanx for the welcome. we had some tough times over here. times are still tough, but we are getting used. i am all right. check out my idea on getting the lion tamer and the lion together and see if anything can be done if you please. take care,
-
dear winston, i was the first turkish student of the united world college of the adriatic, a member of the united world colleges whose patron saint is prince charles. the idea belonged to dr. lester b. pearson, if i recall correctly and it runs something like this "how can there be peace without people loving eachother and how can that be if they dont know eachother". so the idea was to bring together students of the last two years of high school and make them live together for two years in a campus. particular attention was given to put together students from "conflicting races". so jews and palestinians, south african whites and blacks, chinese & japanese, indians and pakistanis etc. would end up in the same room, and of course there was a code of conduct at the school (love eachother or else). when these conflicting races were first put together they were like the novice lion tamer who had never tamed a lion before and the novice lion which was never tamed before. only the two were of equal strength, so we could have wonderful fights to watch if only the supervisors had allowed it. they didn't, damnit. anyway, we were all human, and however we might hate, dislike, despise, mistrust etc. eachother, we would all unite against the common enemy the aliens (the supervisor/teacher/headmaster/cook etc.) like in the movie series by sigourney weaver. this made us overcome differences and some of these guys became great friends. it was by far the most enriching experience of my whole life. i think something similar might bring the turks and armenians together again. i suspect that the most hateful remarks from both sides emanate from turks who had never seen an armenian before and from armenians who had never seen a turk before. my father's wet nurse was an armenian, my desk mate at high school was an armenian, i had once dated a woman who was part armenian, i had a turkish armenian intern at my office for a month or two, so i have a built-in "brake" if you like it when i talk to or about armenians. i dont like statements that start "you armenians ..." because they include people whom i know and love. before the genocide, there was a human dimension in turkish-armenian relations. after all, we did live together largely in peace for over eight hundred years, didn't we, and it wasnt simply because we were militarily strong and you were weak. here are two sayings: "i have learnt that you can conquer a country on horseback, but you cannot rule it on horseback (Kublai Khan)", and "a state is destroyed by cruelty and oppression, and not by picks and shovels". i am disappointed, but not surprised, that the TACt experience came down in flames. in any fight, the most vicious attacks are levelled by the cowards far away from the battlefield, and they are in words, not deeds. people who face one another are instinctively compelled to be more polite to eachother. i am thinking about bringing people together physically, like these 150 armenian americans visiting turkey. would anyone have any ideas about that? regards, (and sorry about my typing)
-
dear thoth, i have been to this forum before under different headings that discussed the issue of genocide. mosjan, mj, levonyeshilian, berj, raffiaharonian and surorus were amongst those with whom i exchanged views. i am 34 (soon), lived in the west for 7 years and in egypt for one, studied oriental studies at oxford, returned home to be an academician in 1990, put an end to my academic career in 1993 (after a year at istanbul university) and have been mostly in business ever since. i am not working for the government - i dont work for people i dont respect if i can help it - and you can contact prof. berktay and survive the encounter - he does not bite, sting, vomit venom, fart noxious fumes, or cause damage otherwise. nor does the government seem to care much for whatever he says. since i was originally trained as a historian (a linguistic historian, to be more precise), i was invariably exposed to the armenia genocide issue. my famly also had some experiences with the issue: my grand-grand father was in the ottoman government in 1915, and was apparently one of the few who realised what talat and enver were up to and tried to stop it - without success unfortunately. my father's wet nurse was an armenian who had lost both of her sons in the killings. i had an armenian desk mate at high school in turkey and so on and so on. but all said and done, i know something terrible happened back then and feel that both you and we have to develop an attitude toward the issue that will enable us to draw the necessary lessons, make sure it will never repeat itself, and will not stand in our way toward peace and understanding as neighbours. i dont want my children to grow up hating or being hated by people simply because one is a turk and the other armenian. attitudes are changing in this country, and the internet is a great help - their recent attempts to restrict it wont work. the block headed blokes are not as smart as some internet buffs out there. we have a new generation of people who - although unfortunately not great readers - are not buying government bullshit anymore. and many turks have been and still are abroad. there they get exposed to stuff they cannot hope to encounter at home. all these change people. i hope you guys understand one thing: it is true that our ancestors did horrible things to your ancestors, but that does not make demons out of an entire nation. after all, the things that the whites did in africa, america and australia do not make one proud, do they? 1915 is a black page in my nation's history. every nation's history is full of them. as they say: "happy is the nation whose history annals are blank". i suggest we open up a discussion somewhere in hye forum on how to get together the more sociable members of our communities. what do you say? regards, ali suat
-
dear Domino, re numbers & presence of various ethnic groups in an army. in general i agree with your point. but i think the misunderstandng stems from my inadequate exposure of the matter: in ww1, there were a number of ottoman armenians from eastern anatolia who had joined the ranks of the russian forces mostly to serve as scouts and guides in the anatolian terrain. they were not particularly numerous, nor did they by and large form the backbone of any unit, but they were instrumental in the guiding of the russian forces in anatolia. they did not only know the natural features, but also the ethnic setting, which settlement was muslim and which christian etc. they themselves might directly have killed very few people, but they made it possible for the russians to create enormous havoc in anatolia. now i would fully agree with you if you protested that the deeds of a few cannot be used to blame - much less punish - a whole nation, this is a stance we frequently encounter in turkey and protest just as strongly, but i hope you understand that in wartime conditions such things do not really help improve relations between feuding peoples. i still stress the fact that this does not in any way justify the genocide or turn it into anything else. they clique within the c.u.p. appears to have acted with a premeditated aim of getting rid of you guys to pave the way for a culturally uniform (=read culturally impoverished) state. such states are easy to rule, like an army column. anyway, waiting for your reply, yours, ali suat
-
hi everybody, i have been away for a while - over three months, in fact. well, it's famous - or infamous - by now that we have had our xth financial crisis and the imf and world bank are asked to clean up the mess again. meanwhile, almost half of the financial sector in istanbul is out of job, including half of my department. we were quite busy for a while taking things over from guys - ladies in fact - who had to go and only now found some respite. i shall be back with more comments, but i am not sure whether i should try to complete my expose of berktay, since it is less fresh on my memory now and i dont any more remember very clearly which were his ideas and which mine. i can give it a try if people are still interested, but there are other new developments that are just as interesting. i suggest those who know turkish to check out the last issue of Atlas - a travel magazine, sort of turkish national geographic (with a blue cover). there was an extensive treatment of 1915 in the last issue. also, some 150 americans of armenian descent are now in turkey. they have been to the sites in istanbul and are now in kayseri to commemorate the 1700th anniversary of armenian christianity. a friend of mine from a political organisation is with them, unfortunately i cant join because i am tied to that goddamned office. anyway just let me know if you are still out there and intersted in new postings. regards, ali suat
-
Dear everybody, I have been to a closed-circle discussion with Professor Halil Berktay (public enemy number one since he acknowledges the Genocide as a Genocide) last night (20/02/2001) and share my impressions with you. As the (all Turkish) audience was already prone to acknowledging the Genocide, he did not have to munch his words and pronounced the G-word. There was no hysteria. He went on to discuss the Genocide, various Armenian and Turkish positions, the consequences of Genocide recognition and relevance of the issue to the present. I shall deal with each of them in turn, but first a warning/disclaimer: my version of his position appears here without his knowledge or consent, and does not bind him in any way (he never implied that I shouldn’t use his views in such a discussion, though). I have also woven in my interpretations and extrapolations, often without notice. I am saying this because I do not want to “put words into his mouth”, and also I want to avoid claiming the whole material as mine. Now down to business: His analysis of the issue can be read under these headings (these are mine): 1. Turkish and Armenian Positions 2. Context of Genocide 3. Fact of Genocide 4. Aftermath 5. What is a Genocide and What Not? 6. On CUP members concerned 7. On Turkish stance 8. Possible Consequences of Recognising the Genocide 9. The Changing Attitude of the Turkish Authorities 10. Conclusions 1. Turkish and Armenian Positions: As the issue is long polarised, most historians on both parties belong to the extreme stances. The Armenian extreme stance is “event not context”, and the Turkish one(s) are “context and event”, which tends to degenerate into “context not event”, or, worse still “context, no event”. Event not context: Those Armenian historians who hold this position see the Genocide issue first as a criminal and only then a historical issue. To them there is only the “event”, and the “context” in which it appears is largely irrelevant, as no “context” ever justifies or legitimises such an “event”, and they see in any attempt to analyse the “event” within the framework of a “context” a hidden apologetism, or worse still, denialism. In plain English, their position is this: “The Turks carried out a genocide of the Armenians. This is a crime before it is a historical [and therefore analysable] phenomenon. There can be no reason for a Genocide, and the very thought of such a reason is tantamount to the crime itself. Thus, the proper place to discuss the Genocide is not a university, forum or panel, but the courtroom. And any attempt to sit down at the same table to talk with the Turks is treason, for it automatically implies a revision of our stance.” This is the most extreme of a variety of similar positions. Context and/not/no event: Most Turkish historians, and quite a few western historians, hold the first position. It goes without saying that most Turkish historians who hold this position are apologists or worse, denialists, they are no scholars in the true sense of the word, but the propagandists of the official Turkish position for a variety of reasons. Such Turkish historians usually degenerate into the second and third versions (not/no) of this position. Most western historians, however, see that they must analyse the issue within the framework of the context in which it occurred, because nothing comes out of nothing: there must have been things that must have led to the genocide, and to say that is one thing, to condone or justify the crime is wholly another. After all, the prosecution first collects the evidence, and then seeks the motives behind the murder before pronouncing the verdict. In this, they attempt to follow the same logic they apply when dealing with the Jewish Holocaust. The event not context stance precludes any possibility of dialogue as a result of its inherent conviction that any attention paid to the context and not the event might – intentionally or not – serve the denialist stance. The context not/no event stances, especially the latter one; also preclude the possibility of honest dialogue, in fact, there is little point in engaging such a dialogue, as these stances are primarily designed to deny the Genocide. If they cannot do it by relying on facts (and they can’t), then they attempt to drown the issue within the context and deliberately distract attention from the main topic at hand. The way out is obviously a middle ground: context and event. Turkish and Armenian historians with a solid technical knowledge of both the context and the event, an open mind, academic integrity (read honesty), and above all, courage, must meet in “security zones” where they would not be pushed by their governments to propagate the official versions and not harrassed by intellectual terrorism to discuss the issue. Turkish historians should not use the context to defend an apologetic stance, and Armenian historians should not abstract the issue from its context to present it as explicable only by the criminality of the perpetrators. One could perhaps draw a parallel between the current analyses of the Jewish Holocaust, where it is acknowledged that the humiliation of Gemany in WW1, the imposition of a weak Weimar Republic upon a people with no experience of democracy, the extremely inflationary environment of German economics, and the success of Hitler in reviving it by militarising it, must also have played a significant role in addition to the endemic Anti-Semitism in Germany (and Europe) and the personal evil of Hitler and the Nazis (The parallel with the Jewish Holocaust is my addition). Berktay had recently attended a conference where both Armenian, Azeri and Turkish historians, Foreign Office members, and other state officals were present, where he had made the above suggestion, and it was hailed by the Armenians and Turks alike as the only way out of the current impasse. “This matter can only be resolved the way Professor Berktay proposes” and Armenian historian said. Berktay also referred to Grigor Suny and Libaridian, both of whom seem to have said very interesting things: one said that the attitude of most Armenian historians who refuse to talk to Turks, and who brand anyone who does so as a traitor created an impasse, and the other said that there were those who had a problem, who wanted to analyse it, and find a solution to it, and there were also those who “loved the problem (Libaridian’s phrase)”, and made it their raison d'etre (this last remark is my wording). I think he referred there to those who had carved out a living out of the Genocide (academic career, books, etc.), though I couldn’t find the opportunity to check this with him. This concludes my survey of his version of the Turkish and Armenian positions. 2. Context of Genocide: The Armenian Genocide took place in 1915, when the Ottoman Empire was in its death throes. The Empire had been losing ground (literally) to the West, and there had been a constant loss of territory since the late 17th Century. One outcome of this, but not immediately apparent in a cursory glance at the issue, was the plight of the millions of Muslims who had lived in these lands for a few centuries already as Ottoman subjects. These people were subjected to the most awful treatment by the new victors, the Christian local populations who had just gained their independence and exacted their vengeance of the Ottomans on the remaining Muslims on “their” territory, and most of these Muslims then had to flee these lands to the safety of the ever-shrinking Ottoman Empire. The huge numbers that came in created great economic, social, and to a certain extent, political stress in the decaying Empire; and these people also brought to Anatolia a hatred of the Christians that was by and large not present there at all: Muslims and non-Muslims had been living side by side without any major quarrels, and the state of the non-Muslims in the Empire was perceptibly better than that of the Jews in Europe or the Indians or Blacks in the Americas. Their self-worth largely destroyed by an unending stream of defeats at the hands of the Europeans, economically and socially traumatised by incessant warfare, persecutions, forced conversions, deportations, massacres, and last by not least, the prejudice on the part of the local Anatolian Muslim population they encountered in their “safe haven” (this last is mine), these new arrivals were filled with hatred toward the Christians whom they saw as the reason for all the evils that befell them; which they passed onto the Anatolian Muslims. Berktay quoted an English poet, W. H. Auden, who was in New York at the start of WW2, and who wrote the following lines as he heard the news of German troops invading Poland: I and the general public know What all schoolchildren learn Those to whom evil is done Do evil in return (How well do these lines express the sentiments of both Turks and Armenians!) This state of affairs carried on throughout the 18th and espacially the 19th Centuries, by the middle of which the imminent disintegration of the Empire was an open secret. All thinking men, and there were many, thought of just one thing: how to save what was left of the Empire. It is in this context that we see the likes of Enver and Talat emerge. They were, in Berktay’s words, “rootless and ruthless”, all Balkan (mostly Macedonian) refugees, who got an inkling of the western mind through the military education they had (mostly in the Balkans) and could see the birth, growth and nature of nationalism there. Berktay quoted passages from two stories of Omer Seyfeddin. The first is about a young Ottoman Turkish officer stationed in Bulgaria, who had developed a sort of a platonic relationship with a beautiful Bulgarian girl across the street where he was stationed: the girl would hang washing in the balcony and cast long, smouldering looks at the young officer, singing a beautiful song. This eye-to-eye platonic “romance”, as the officer sees it, lasts until the officer finally decides to seek the intermediacy of a Bulgarian to meet with her, upon which the Bulgarian (the Good Bulgarian of the story) says she is no good for him, for she is the daughter of a guerilla leader who was hanged by the Ottomans the year before, and the song she sang (which the young officer had mistakenly reasoned to be a love song) turned out to be “nash nash tsarigrad nash” (ours, ours, Istanbul shall become). Upon this, he is shocked, but cannot help admire her unyielding stance and adherence to her nation’s cause, and despise his weakness for having even contemplated a romantic relationship with a girl from the enemy camp for sheer lack of national consciousness! The second story, the plot of which is irrelevant, centers on a group of young officers on their way to Anatolia, talking about how Anatolia is the last refuge of the Turkish nation, and that that was the land they should have developed etc., the real revelation of the story comes with the emergence of the fact that not one of them had even been to Anatolia before! This was the atmosphere in which the last Ottoman officers’ world view was developing. The likes of Talat and Enver had grown up and lived in an almost unbroken episode of violence: 1908: deposition of Abdulhamid II, the “Red Sultan”, 1909: the Good Event: the Revolution of the reactionaries and the interference of the military, 1912 through 1915: the Balkan, Libyan and World wars, and finally, the Genocide. These people knew violence as the only means of reaching their goals, and they had only one goal: to grab a piece of the decaying Empire for the Turkish nation, the only candidate for which was Anatolia. They had only one goal and one way to reach it: violence. They had no Plan B. That union of means and ends made them incapable of doing anything but violence (the last two lines are my addition). One man, however, differed from them in one radical fashion: Mustafa Kemal. He saw a means in violence to reach the end, but violence was not the only means he was open to, and very early on he started to think that violence could not be the the only way to have what you got: you have to want what you can keep yours through other means than violence. That was probably the main reason why he concentrated on Anatolia as the future homeland of the Turks, and not concentrated any effort to salvage any other part of the Empire, and paid no heed to the pan-Islamic and pan-Turkic dreams of Talat and Enver. Of him more later. I related to Berktay the Armenian theory that Talat and Enver wanted to get rid of the Armenians that were on their way to Central Asia, and Berktay said that he did not agree with it: he thought that there were so many things that made the Armenian Genocide an inevitability (no justification intended) that one did not need to invoke that. Besides, he thought, that the pan-Turanian ideal grew stronger in Enver after his escape, i.e. after the Genocide. His opinion was that there was already so much accumulated hatred that the slightest spark would cause an explosion of gigantic proportions: “Armenians were left holding the bag (his phrase)” of this accumulated hatred of Christians, and when it exploded, it was far more severe than anything that had preceded it. Berktay was asked what he thought of Armenian separatism and terrorism that had preceded the deportations, and he said that he did not think all that much of that: there were not nearly a million Turks killed (as claimed by denialist or apologetic Turkish historians) by the Armenians, first of all considering the then population of that part of Anatolia (which he estimated at about three million in all, at any rate below five million), there could not have been that many Muslim deaths, or else, how do you explain the population of the area after the foundation of the Republic? Besides, the Armenians were never nowhere near so strong as to carry out a massacre of these proportions. Besides, the Armenian gangs attacked villages whose male population was out in the fighting fronts of the Empire, and there are usually not more than fifty to a hundred people in a typical Anatolian village of that area, so they had to destroy at least a thousand villages to hit the million mark! He said that the Muslim deaths at the hands of the Armenians in Anatolia amounted to a few thousands at the most. (I agree with his reasoning, but strongly disagree with the number. One reason for this is that the Armenian gangs frequently acted together with the Russian and French regular forces. So all these people killed were not necessarily killed by ethnic Armenians, but by multinational forces of which Armenian gangs were a part. A comparison can be made here with the numbers of Jews killed by the Germans: Germans frequently used local collaborators to carry out their acts, and even formed military units of them. Anyway, I myself think that the actual numbers killed by the Armenians are in the realm of a few tens of thousands to slightly over a million. I guess we shall never know as no exact toll of the dead was ever taken.) So the Armenian Genocide appears as something that could be seen from a mile away. This concludes my survey of his version of the Context. I shall post the remaining portions as I complete them. Remember that this is my interpretation of his exposé with my additions (which I have diligently sought to identify as such wherever they appear), and does not claim to be an authoritative version of his position. [ February 23, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
Dear Mr. Aharonian, I think you understood me correctly. I understand the initial reaction to Turks in this forum given past history and the e-diots like raven. I share your desire to see a civilised Turkey and a solution to our bloody problems, too, and I think this can only be achieved through a dialogue between individual Turks and Armenians, as nothing constructive can be expected from the politicians (ours, at least) unless people from both sides push for it. In such a dialogue, we must first try put hysteria aside and talk calmly. This will make it easier for both parties to find a common ground and develop it from there. And also please understand that the overwhelming majority of Turks harbour no ill-feelings toward Armenians as such, but as they go through an educational system that deliberately cripples the free, enquiring mind common to us humans, and as they first encounter the issue of Armenian Genocide by the time their world view has developed, they get a shock. They cannot conceive that their ancestors might have done such a thing, and they see themselves in a defensive position, in the trenches so to speak. You cannot have a constructive dialogue with someone who has this sort of mentality. Raven was one such, as far as I can see. In the final analysis, I doubt that he had a hidden agenda or anything. Apparently he was fed the official rubbish in Turkey, and really came to believe (as most ordinary Turks do) that it was the Armenians who carried out a genocide against the Turks rather than the other way round. And he also sees (like most Turks) in anyone who raises the issue an enemy of Turkey who wants to tear the country apart. In this he is not entirely wrong, but this is a dangerous generalisation that closes the door to dialogue and reconciliation. I shall develop this further as soon as my exposé of Prof. Berktay's conference is ready. Regards, Ali Suat Urguplu
-
Dear MJ, Thanks. I am not that rare a breed, though. I was exposed to the other versions of the "official stories" of Turkey from an early age onwards, and that led me to the study of history and languages. That also put an end to my academic career in Turkey a year after it started. Which I don't regret, though, as it was full of those Turks that you are used to, and I was either going to leave the place or pose (could never become) as one of them for the rest of my life. Now people can talk more freely in Turkey. Of course, we have the occasional hiccups like the Assyrian priest who is being tried for saying that there was an Armenian Genocide, or other writers in jail, but we shall overcome. My children will grow in a better Turkey (I hope). Regards, Ali Suat
-
Actually I found your words rather disturbing - as if you implied that it was now normal for academics (like politicians) to write their works with the active intention to deceive "amateur" people by slight of hand (or language). I hope it is NOT normal amongst academics. Steve, is is of course not normal for academics to use their talents that way, but unfortunately a disturbingly large number of them end up doing it. this is i guess common to most conflict-ridden topics, not only armenian genocide. most do it with evil intentions, but there are also some, who have no evil intentions, but either cannot get rid of their almost subconscious prejudices, or get carried away with enthusiasm. as you read more and more history books, you get to recognise those who fall into the second category by their style, but those in the first category are difficult to detect without a serious foundation in the topic and are by far the most dangerous breed of intellectual around, as far as i am concerned. so you can never be too paranoid. that was a good point you raised. regards, ali suat nullActually I found your words rather disturbing - as if you implied that it was now normal for academics (like politicians) to write their works with the active intention to deceive "amateur" people by slight of hand (or language). I hope it is NOT normal amongst academics. quote [ February 22, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
thanks levon i am writing out the discussions with prof. halil berktay, but it will take some time as 1) it is long, and 2) we are currently dealing with a serious financial crisis in turkey, and i have to give this matter top priority. so there may be some delay in my postings for the time being, but i hope in about a week's time things will improve. meanwhile, anyone can run any check they like on me. got nothing to hide. cheers, ali suat
-
ok everybody 1. i agree with the suggestion that we should move the phrygians, samekhi, urartu etc. to history rather than genocide otherwise we will drift into endless speculation about what happened in 1200 BC and lose touch with the genocide issue. i will submit a post under history as soon as possible, and my postings re genocide & related (promise) will appear here. regards, ali suat
-
surorus, unfortunately nope. you are not allowed to pursue more than one undergrad degree under the oxbridge system unless you are top of the pops in academics (i was middling to goodish only), and classical arabic grammar and ottoman prose are enough to make yu repent all your past, present and future sins for four years. and since i was going to specialise in turkish historical linguistics, there was little point in me taking the courses in christian & armenian studies, since curricula at oxford are very demanding and guided by your tutor anyway (not that i find them unimportant). there was one turkish armenian lady, a graduate student from a turkish university, with whom we had occasionally talked about the genocide and present state of the armenians in turkey, so i got exposed to the fact that it wasn't all roses for the armenians in turkey at that tender age. regards, ali suat
-
surorus, sorry for the lameness of pembroke, oxford's web site (if it is really pembroke, oxford's web site). i haven't been much in touch with the college since i graduated (got my b.a. conferred in 1991 and visited the place in 1998 only), and never visited their web site. if you still have doubts about my affiliation to the college, you can write to them and get the info if you feel so inclined. since it isn't a state secret, they shouldn't give you any trouble. here is the address: the college secretary pembroke college oxford ox1 1dw united kingdom i can't recall the phone number off my head, but this should be good enough. my full name is ali suat urguplu (used to spell suad when i was there), matriculation date: 1986, graduation date: 1990, subject: oriental studies (tukish with arabic), tutor at college: prof. alan jones, degree conferred: b.a. & then an m.a. (found eligible for it two years later without writing a thesis ), grade got: ii.i. (second class, first division). i hope this is enough info. yours, ali suat [ February 21, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
Dear Berj, Please feel free to check anything i write. the fact that i am not a propagandist does not exclude the possibility that i may be inaccurate in details and wrong in conclusions. as for the footnotes, thank you. i write these mostly from the office at off-hours, and my library is at home (and there isn't much stuff there about the genocide). i am writing out the exposé of Prof. Berktay with my additions. i shall post it when ready. regards, ali suat (by the way, is your name berj or armen? i would like to refer to you by your name, if you permit)
-
dear mr aharonian, 1. i am not a tiger, and you are not a kitten. you are an accountant, levon is a dentist, and i am head of research at a brokerage firm. i got a b.a. & m.a. in oriental studies from pembroke college, oxford (not cambridge, surorus, please), where the focus of my study was turkish and arabic languages & literatures, early islamic history, ottoman history, and uzbek. i came back to turkey with the aspiration to become an academician, but the academic atmosphere stifled me here, didn't want to leave the country, and hence ended up in the business world. i have not had much contact with academics save private reading and discussions with various academicians and non-academics since 1993. as my area of specialisation was not 19th century ottoman history in general and the armenian genocide in particular (my specialiation would have been linguistic history if my career were not truncated by the xxxxs in the establishment), i do not think i am much more knowledgeable in the area than and well-read lay person would be. since i had also declared from my first posting onwards that i myself suspected an inner clique in the CUP cabinet that might have masterminded the genocide, it should be obvious to anyone who reads my postings that: 1)i am not attempting to deny the genocide or convince anyone that it wasn't really a genocide. 2) i am not creating a hypothetical turkish genocide of the armenians. 3) i am not trying to be apologetic about it (trying to legitimise it). i am merely trying to share my opinions of it and some info that i keep hearing in turkey with you. i saw that most of you were not aware of this, and you saw that some of that must have some grain of truth in it, as some of my points were confirmed by levon (re famous crypto-armenians and the presence of a much larger hidden armenian community in turkey than previously thought). i am also striving to be as impartial as possible (i acknowledge that this is going to be as difficult for me as it is for you, since we are the two parties involved), and try to act in an honest manner. there is nothing to be gained from trying to convince you, the victims of genocide, that the genocide was not a genocide, and to imply that i am engaging in such a futile pursuit is an insult to my intelligence (no offence intended). i am merely trying to develop a discussion on various aspects of the tragedy that we both lived - and are still living psychologically - that will, i hope, enable us to have a more accurate perception of it. many people study the genocide for various reasons: some never to forget, some never to acknowledge, some to use it as a glue to hold the diaspora together, some to use it against the turks, some to make a living out, some to seek justice. i study it for the same reasons most germans do: prevention is better than cure. since i say "never again", i. e. do not want to see yet another genocide, i have to know as much as i can the hows and whys of the previous genocides so that i can be alert to any future ones as a world citizen not only in my country, my region, or anywhere in the world. and i fear that we (turks and armenians) cannot acquire that expertise and ability to act proactively with our present attitude. this is why i am here. i hope this has been clear enough. i am waiting for your (everyone's) comments on this. yours sincerely, ali suat urguplu
-
quote:Originally posted by surorus: Aurguplu, Just out of curiosity I have visited the web site of Pembroke College, and went of the alumni list. However, I could not find your name neither in registered nor in missing alumni list. web page surorus, you looked me up in the wrong place. i graduated from pembroke college, oxford, not cambridge. the link you provided me took me there. look me up at pembroke college, oxford, and if you still don't find me, them i'll contact the college. (by the way, my surname is urguplu and matric date 1986. don't look me up under "s" or "1990". yours, ali suat urguplu
-
On the way I write Berj; As stated before, I am not a denialist, and will accept arguments provided that they are based on facts and persuasively argued. This doesn't mean that I will accept anything put in front of me. I am not an agent employed by the Turkish state, nor am I a self-styled defendant of the Turkish position. There are enough of them around, and some of them even visited your website (RAVEN). You don't need any more of this. In 1915-1916, an inner clique of the CUP cabinet, of whom Talat was chief, took a decision to liquidate the bulk of the Armenian population of the Empire, and by and large they succeeded. Genocide. No quibbling about that. Now let's get that sorted out and move further in the discussion. If I got the rest of your message correctly, you think that I am trying to put up a nice face, move your attention from genocide by arguments & topics not really relevant to it, and then perhaps deal with the genocide issue on my own ground, hoping for a victory, or let it die out in the ensuing debates about everything under the sun save genocide. No. But I do get your point that we did stray from the main subject, and I shall be back to it in my future postings. Thanks for the warning, though. No more Phrygians. They are irrelevant to the topic and difficult to spell anyway. I attended a closed-circle conference by Professor Halil Berktay in Turkey last night which I shall develop in a later contribution under Genocide. Cheers, Ali Suat
-
surorus, thanks for the info. i am not an alumnus in that i am a celebrity whose contribution to humanity has been recognised by the college, and therefore i am not a bit surprised that i don't figure in that list. by the way, i don't recall having pretended i was one. i studied there 1986-1990, got a i.ii. (upper second) in Oriental Studies, and two years later was awarded an M.A. if there is a list of graduates (not alumni) on that website (i never checked it), i should figure there. if i don't then i shall contact the college. if i am on their mailing list when it comes to asking for donations, then i should also be on their list of graduates. yours, ali suat
-
Dear Hakob, To talk about Turks in genetic terms is like talking about Americans in genetic terms. As a French historian put it “he who speaks Turkish is Turkish”. I think this is the most logical approach we can have to define the Turkish identity (I particularly favour it because I am part Greek, Russian, Ukrainian, Albanian, Hittite, Serb, Bosnian, Circassian, Georgian, Crimean Tatar and God knows what else, and would probably classify as anything other than a Turk on genetic grounds, but I consider myself Turkish). This is the case not only with Turks, but with many other nations, too: millions of people of Mongol appearance who are known to be the descendants of the hordes of Turks and Mongols who overran Russia in the 13th-14th Centuries now consider themselves Russian and have every right to do so. You don’t have to look any further than Lenin. “Turk” always seems to have had a political rather than ethnic connotation, and now some people of Turkic origin (i.e. Turkic speakers) gave their name to countries and places that are not Turkic today (e.g. Bulgaria, the original Bulgars were a Turkic-speaking nation, closely related to the Huns and present-day Chuvash in Russia, but the Bulgarians today, who bear their name, are Slavs in speech and culture who had assimilated them by the 12th Century), then nations whom we know were not Turkic were sometimes called Turks (most notably the Hungarians (Magyars) who had moved to present-day Hungary from around the Ural mountains before the 9th Century, as a part of a Turkish confederation. The name “Hungary” is Turkic and probably means “Ten Tribes”.). The Mongols, who started the disturbances in Central Asia and caused the displacement of tribes, were largely assimilated into the more numerous Turks linguistically, hence the Mongol appearance of Central Asian Turks east of Iran today (Early Chinese sources describe some people whom we know spoke Turkish as red-haired, green eyed, monkey-like people, i.e. Europeans). Central Asia marks the border between the Caucasian and Mongol races, and it is evident that much mingling and assimilation took place there since time began. You can never talk about any period of Turkic history where there is at least not one documented case of linguistic assimilation and/or mixed marriages (we also use the institution of marriage as a means of settlement of disputes, so after every clash with any nation, mixed marriages did inevitably occur). As to the Asiatic faces in Turkish and Persian art: Islamic miniature painting has some of its origins in – guess where? – Tibet! It was an art that never tired of clichés, and Turks continued to paint themselves as broad faced, slanted eyed Asiatics long after they ceased to look like that, and the few famous examples of Ottoman miniature painting that I can think of that deviate from this rule are the portraits of Mohammed the Conqueror and Suleiman the Magnificent. That of Mohammed the Conqueror was based on Bellini’s work, and that of Suleiman the Magnificent probably on another western depiction of him. My interpretation is that these people looked so very obviously different from the clichés that the painters were forced to make some concessions, and of course, western influence was also a factor. We painted Arabs with slanted eyes, for God’s sake! An addition to Hakob’s point re Turkish genetics: according to legend, there were twenty-four Oghuz tribes that came to Anatolia, some twenty-two names are easily recoverable from place names (that of my mother’s original tribe, Kayý (pronounced Qyeh), is the most numerous). Two of these twenty-four names are known to be not Turkic in origin: these are Yazýr (originally As-er, meaning “As-man”, the As were an Iranian tribe who the Greeks knew, incidentally, the continent name Asia comes from there and was extended to the name of the whole continent much later.), the other Döger (originally Tokhar, the Indo-European nation that you are talking about). Remember these are the two names that we know are not originally Turkic, there may be a few others of dubious etymology that may also be of non-Turkic origin, too.). This is another thing that neither Turks nor their neighbours know much about: most people are apt to equate the arrival of the Central Asians with the arrival of the Turks, but these “Turks” 1) were called Turks because the Arabs had met Turks who had called themselves as such a few centuries before, and applied the same name to all nomadic archers regardless of their ethnic origin, so the Mongols ended up as Turks in Arabic historiography, pretty much like the Magyars who had suffered the same fate(!) at the hands of the Byzantine historians.) 2) were already an amalgam of Paleosiberians, northern Chinese, Mongols, Manchu, Tungus, Tibetans, Tokharians, Sogdians and other Iranians, Jews, Slavs, Scandinavians (Swedes), Goths, and God knows what else, in addition to a few Turks, and, last by not least, the “Turks” who arrived in Anatolia called themselves Oghuz rather than Turks, and were always a most unruly element in the Turkish confederations. There are tiny differences between the Oghuz dialects and Turkic proper (ancestors of Uzbek and Uighur) like Grabar in Istanbul and Krapart in Yerevan, but these were so much blown out of proportion that one can very occasionally see in the writings of the 11th-12th Centuries Oghuz and Turkic considered different languages. Similar things, of course, can be seen in Europe, too: there is a reason why Germans are called German in English, Deutsch in German, Allemand in French and Saksa in Finnish! Dear Levon, Ataturk was a pragmatist: he had a mass of people who by and large had only two things in common, both of which Ataturk was the sworn enemy of: an Ottoman past and Islam. So he couldn’t use either in nation making: common values are like a glue that hold different parts of a nation together, and if you don’t have enough to do the job, you have to invent some, or elevate other things to the status of common values. The myth of forty Centuries of Turkish Anatolia (which made instant Turks out of the Indo-European Hittites and the mysterious Sumerians, whose language admittedly bears some resemblance to Turkic), was one such, a common origin of Anatolian Turks was another, and the forced imposition of Turkish to non-Turks (most famously as we all know to Kurds) was yet another. Remember that Ataturk was a soldier turned politician (and proved brilliant in both), and to him truth was a matter of debate for scholars, philosophers and people so inclined, of which he was neither. He needed “facts” to serve his purpose of making a whole out of many different parts. May I add that by and large he seems to have succeded. So I would probably challenge the view that what Ataturk did was a mistake: he had the formidable task of making a nation out of a people whose ethnic identities were multiple, whose nationhood was never allowed to develop under the Ottoman Empire, who spoke different languages (the household language of one of the Defence Ministers of Ataturk's period was Bulgarian), and whose only bonds were an Empire that was gone and a religion deliberately kept well away from any reformist movement both by the Arabs and the Ottomans. What else could he do? Dear Martin, I hold an M.A. in Oriental Studies from Pembroke College, Oxford (England). I couldn’t continue my academic career in Turkey for reasons that must be clear by now, and frankly speaking I don’t much regret it: one of the things that made me sit next to the way out was the use of “Armenian” as an insult in a political discussion about Ismet Inonu. I am not a friend of Armenians, nor I am an enemy of them, I am sure they are no different from anyone else in that they have good people and bad, dishonest and honest, cowards and heroes, and I cannot associate with people who use a nation’s name as a swearword. By the way, one mistake you made in one of your past contributions: you said you guys have been living in Anatolia for 2,000 years. I beg to differ: you probably were part of the Sea Peoples who destroyed the Hittite Empire at around 1200 BC. There is a region called Moesia in Thrace, and Mysia in Anatolia, referring to the same ethnonym and clearly showing the eastward migration of an Indo-European people about 1200 BC, at about the time of the Trojan War. In fact, Greek history talks about the Phrygians moving into Anatolia from the Balkans at shortly before the Trojan war. The name of the Phrygians comes from “Bryg” and means “brigand”, this word in English comes ultimately from the same Indo-European root. The Phrygians were referred to as “Muski” by the Hittites, the identity of this with Mysian and Moesian is clear. Now a very interesting point: Herodotus describes Armenians as Phrygian colonists, and the Georgians call the Armenians “(Sa)mekhi”. Now Herodotus is not normally considered to be a reliable source, but the Georgian parallel is interesting. If this were all we knew, we would be perfectly justified to pronounce the Armenians as Phrygians, but unfortunately history is not so simple: the Phrygian language has survived in writing, albeit in an ossified form and scant, formulaic remains, until the 3rd Century AD, and what little we know of the language still causes fierce debate amongst historical linguists: originally thought to be a member of the Hittite-Luwian subgroup of Indo-European, it is now commonly thought to be distantly related to the extinct Thraco-Dacian and probably Illyrian (whose only surviving member is Albanian), but the scant remains show a language very different from Armenian. This is probably for three reasons: the Phrygian that we know from the inscriptions was a dead liturgical language already by late Antiquity, and doesn’t reflect the subsequent developments of the spoken language, and Armenian was first written down by Movses of Khorene in the 5th Century AD (if I am not mistaken, I am again writing this from my office.). So there is a time-gap of about ten Centuries, during which time Armenian was very heavily influenced by Hittite, Iranian and the non-Indo European Urartu and other Caucasian languages. Armenian was so heavily influenced by these languages that its affiliation to the Indo-European was long a matter of dispute. Linguists had a hard time finding the correspondence between Armenian erku and English two, to cite just one example. I think the most plausible explanation for this is that the ancestors of the Armenians probably spoke something close to Phrygian, if not Phrygian itself, and moved to Anatolia from the Balkans with them. The name “Phrygian” might have been an adjective (brigand) rather than an ethnonym, and the ethnonym might have been something like Myski. The development of Hye as the Armenian national name is another matter. What all this boils down to is that you guys must have been here for about 3,200 years , and went through the same processes of displacement of the natives and gradual assimilation of and into them, and genetic mingling. I think this has been long enough again. I am waiting for your comments, and then I shall write on. Cheers, Ali Suat
