aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
gamavor, 1) do you see the similarity between i) your remarks on turks and german remarks on the nazis and slavs, and more tellingly ii) turkish and pro-turkish remarks on the armenians at the time of the genocide? 2) do you know what kind of background the turks in germany come from, and what circumstances they might have been subject to given the fact that germany has a nazi recent past and turkey is not known for HER loving care for her citizens? 3) over a million women from former soviet republics come to turkey for prostitution, many are russians, ukrainians and belarussians. of the non-slavs, armenians are by far the most numerous, probably several hundred thousand strong. now if i had the same attitude toward the armenians as you have against turks, i could draw conclusions about the armenians very similar to yours about the turks! i have never resorted to that, in and out of the forum, and your attitude won't make me do it, either. but think about your attitude. regards,
-
dear mj, absolutely agree. let's prevent that from dominating, or we will look like the armenian-azerbaijani forum. we are all grown ups. we can do better than that. gamavor, would you please be so kind as to impart us the depths of your wisdom as to how you concluded that i was a "mistaken" turk? is it perhaps because i accept the genocide and seek dialogue? regards,
-
baboyan, what do you do with those turks who admit to what they (or rather their ancestors) did, even if their government denies it? regards,
-
oh god so you started off as someone who loved maths, then who figured out that he had to do something "useful" with it and ended up in the most mind-numbing subchapter of your beloved subject just do make a living, am i correct? it's a bit like mine, i started with historical linguistics because i love languages and studying their evolution, then was made to move to translating medieval stuff because somebody had to translate them (they are usually so boring that professors dump the subject onto the shoulders of their best students who are encouragedto take it as "apprenticeship" and "your first published piece of academic work" and then ended up translating business texts when i left academia. i still do that to make ends meet in this crisis. life is a bitch sometimes, isn't it?
-
dear martin, by the way, what was your field when you were an academician, if i may ask? dear timuçin, i visited your forum, liked it, and have a few suggestions: the black background kind of tires the eye, and perhaps the mateial could be visually a bit better organised. for instance, i found hye forum the best organised and visually most appealing of all forums that i have been to (not that i have been to all that many). it does not tire the eye, everything is clearly organised, so if you want to laern something about armenian painting you know where to go to, or feel too good and think you need to be depressed and insulted, you know where to find gamavor's, or, wh00t's, or paul bunyan's postings. i have not noticed them under "culture" (i may have missed). i think if you got the background lighter (white is just fine) and organised the topics a bit more it would be just fine. regards,
-
dear martin, (now that the name issue is clarified). i almost fully agree with what you say re academics. they are necessary, though, at least in certain fields. i have observed that the really good (and useful) academics tend to devote themselves fully to their work, and publish relatively little, buttheir publications tend to stand the test of time. this is especially true of "hard" subjects such as the exact sciences and - may i add - languages (not literature, though). i have always found it a bit difficult to accept that subjects such as "political science" or "semiotics" could be counted amongst the "serious" academic subjects in the first place, since 1) they - as far as i can see - are difficult to reduce to numbers or other EXACT definitions, hence a degree of ambiguity is built in, and 2) most people whom i met who were in these fields ended to have an agenda, an axe to grind, so to speak, and were using their academic credentials to twist the "truth" - whatever that is - as they willed. history is a different matter. as a branch of the humanities, it has so far eluded most attempts at reducing it to numbers, but this is perhaps the case because the further back you get, the less numerical data you can have. i also think that historians would become a good deal more accurate and enlightened if they knew more about the rudiments of economics, and perhaps of the exact sciences. the problem with most academicians engaged in the humanities is that the stuff they produce has little or no market value - few people are interested in it, even fewer read it, and even fewer understand it. this also results in the fact that few people check the quality of the stuff they produce. i know from my own field of historical linguistics that much of the stuff produced until very recently had very poor methodology, the holes in which could be picked up by any layman with a decent general background in the subject. may i also add that in my field - and also in near eastern history - most of the most competent historians and linguists of earlier times were not academically trained, but government agents, amateurs with a lot of money from their parents, dilettantes, and in a few cases, people originally from a completely different academic background, such as doctors or biologists. i think that although academia as a profession has a good many merits to it, it also has paved the way to the production of quite a lot of mediocre and substandard stuff by mediocre and substandard minds. academia has, unfortunately, become the refuge of many people who cannot face "real life" outside their ivory tower. but it is still a worthwhile experience if you happen to be in the right field in the right place at the right time. pity i wasn't. regards, ali suat
-
dear mj, i thought you were "martin", since i read some postings that were addressed to your arguments that were addressed to "martin" - or did i get it wrong? i would like to reply to the above posting, but have confused the identities, and don't know anymore who's who. i would be grateful if you could clarify. regards, ali suat
-
dear timuçin, i would like to know more about that study you mention. could you give us references? and second, regardless of what it may have been like in ottoman times, today in turkey, anyone who is a muslim and calls himself a turk is considred a turk by the bulk of the population. i understand that the grey wolves still have some trouble accepting caucasian muslims as turks, and they keep looking for "dönmes" behind every move they consider a plot against the turkish republic, but they do not represent the mainstream of turkish society. i think their attitude has more to do with a sense of insecurity and other personality problems than with any serious scientific or political position based on sound reasoning. i am part shapsug, part circassian (we used to refer the shapsug as georgian rather than circassian), part greek, part slav (russian, ukrainina, and serbian) part italian, aprt french, part albanian, and part god knows what else, and i consider myself a turk and nothing else as far as national identity is concerned. (i also have some turkic blood in my veins: my mother's family was originally kayı, my dad's afshar (karaman, they are a branch of the afshar) and way back we have a crimean tatar (giray, probably) in the family. but of course, nationality is one trhing, ethnicity another, and race is still another. i have seen you other posting, i shall come to it later on. regards,
-
the original name of van was "tushpa" in urartu times. now since both urartian and hurrian were caucasian languages - like georgian, laz, circassian etc. - and not indo-european, this name is not armenian. but the current name "van" seems to me very similar to "venk, vank" in modern armenian which i understand means "village" (there are dozens of villages so named in eastern anatolia. could anyone clarify what "van" meant and what language it came from, please?
-
re place names: almost all place-names in turkey wich are along the lines of türkyurdu, öztürk, horasan, güzelyurt, etc. are obviously new coinages. a friend of mine from erzincan had once told me that her hometown's name was changed to gülbahçe "rose garden" from the original "stemi" which was armenian. also, many place names that still exist do actually derive from pre-turkic languages, but are corrupted due to a change in pronunciation. examples are bayburt (papert), ağlasun (from greek sagalassos or sagalasson, and sounds very much like turkish "let him cry"), geyre (from original caria of antiquity), all names ending in -girt (kert) like malazgirt, mazgirt, etc. in addition, eastern anatolia is still full of villages that are called "venk" or "vank", and tatvan of van lake fame meant "foot of van" in the local armenian dialect. even if they change the names, the population tends to remember them.
-
what is a turk, a race or culture? well, being a turk who has specialised in turkish history, culture and language, i dare say i can clarify the issue for you: he is a turk who speaks a turkic language as his mother tongue. all other definitions fail. we have turks of various mongol types, of nordic caucasian types, of celtic types, of middle eastern types, even some of the negroid type! there is not a single passage to my knowledge in turkish historical documents that attest to any attempt at preserving racial characteristics (whatever they are) or excluding others on account of racial differences. so much for race. as for culture, although we ourselves thought of ourselves as primarily pastoral nomads with little or no tradition of settled civilisation, new research from central asia is casting doubts on this. i seems there was some settlement in that inhospitable area, in rare pockets where agriculture was possible. we were vey acquisitive of other cultures, though, and today one can discern elements of chinese, iranian, indian, arabic and other middle eastern cultures as well as greek, armenian and slavic in our various cultures. the one unifying trait, however, is language: alnmost all major groups have been able to preserve their languages, and with the exception of a few (very few) most turkic languages are similar enough to be mutually intelligible. this creates a great feeling of unity that extends from the balkans to the adriatic. as far as anatolian turks are concerned, they will not one day find out that they have more greek, armenian etc. blood in their veins, they already do. throughout the ottoman empire it was enough for a non-muslim to convert to instantly become a turk, and this was common knowledge. that was one of the reasons why there was not a hint of nationalism until the latter half of the nineteenth century. the upheavals of wwi and the subsequent imposition of a nationalist doctrine caused a temporary break with the real past as we were busy creating a mythical one, but a few things happened lately that reminded us: 1) dna analyses have been conducted in various places in turkey, partly for archaeological, sociological, medical and defence reasons. to the best of my knowledge there has not been a single case of any proven strong genetic link with central asia. in fact, all evidence shows that the anatolian people have remained by and large constant, with some additions, throughout the last few thousand years. the imposition of different cultures was not necessarily brought about by very large-scale migrations. 2) you can tell people from different regions in anatolia, but you would be hard put to tell an armenian, turk or kurd from a given district, and people are well aware of this. 3) moreover, the dissolution of the soviet union now gives us ample opportunity to see central asian turks, who at least physically are very different from us. so basically we are a nation based more on a common language and sense of kinship than anything else, especially race. race considerations in the determination of affiliation and especially group solidarity have usually been foreign to us. regards,
-
i had forgotten to answer the below paragraph by timuçin: "By the way, when one is comparing numbers about a particular genocide, one should use the numbers before and after the genocide. You are using numbers before the Armenian genocide and the ones that are from our time. Are we to assume by this that the Armenian Genocide lasted until, let us say, 1980s?" no timuçin, there has been a misunderstanding here. what i had said was that there were some 1,295,000 armenians in turkey prior to the genocide according to official sources, and some 200,000-300,000 in 1927, when the first census of the republic was taken. and today, there are some 50,000 if i am not mistaken, though the armenians themselves quote any figure between 40,000-85,000. what this means that about a million armenians who were there prior to the world war were not there anymore only twelve years later. and about half of them are known to have made it to third countries (again i found this figure to vary substantially from one armenian source to the other, and would appreciate an armenian here to shed some light on it: how many armenians are known to have survived the genocide?) i do not for a moment assume that the armenian genocide lasted until 1980, but let's face it, the property tax (varlık vergisi) of the wwii era, the 6-7 September 1955 events and the latter tensions in the 70s due to cyprus did make life very difficult for non-muslims in turkey. but that's another issue that probably belongs to another heading, not here. regards,
-
i keep encountering problems with this editing and quoting business. the "dear mj" at the beginning is not there, i tried to put your paragraphs into inverted commas and blacken them, but they came out as above. and also, i have no idea where that smilie came from next to the word "genocide" (unless my keyboard has a weird sense of humour of its own). apologies to all readers. by the way, thanks for the references which i have checked and found useful. gotta leave now, it's nine twenty p.m. over here. regards, ali suat
-
“I would like to the best of my understanding (which is perhaps not the best) to address some of the issues/questions and a couple of technicalities. It is agreed that the term “genocide” has been contemplated by Lamkin precisely in describe the Armenian massacres of 1915-1923. Lamkin has come up with the term before the occurrence of the Jewish Holocaust, if I remember correctly. Obviously, the readiness of the international community to accept such a term, and moreover, to come up with an international Resolution under the auspices of UN is itself indicative that there were not one or two Genocides in the history of world, but the their number was so compelling that they felt necessity to separate a special legal category in the international law.” I take your word for it. I haven’t read the original documentation behind Lemkin’s coinage. “Genocide have taken place all over the history of the mankind. But it is not our fault that others have not survived at all to pursue condemnation of it, or the world civilization at the time has not been on the level of adequate preparedness to condemn those genocides of the time, or if other groups have not been able to put forward adequate social and political organizations to pursue its condemnation.” I agree. “We don’t maintain that the Armenian Genocide is the only genocide in the world history, or necessarily the most brutal. It is just something that concerns us directly. We just hope that the human civilization is mature enough now to address the issue of the Armenian Genocide, and hopefully to put end to all genocides. As so, our genocide is not an issue of mere historic justice (there are so many injustices in history, even only in the Armenian history, that it would be naïve to expect to see them addressed). The Armenian Genocide is a matter of continuing reality in some ways.” I agree. “But I disagree that Muslims have no chance of receiving adequate attention if they are able to raise adequate awareness. As a matter of fact, the Greek atrocities towards the Muslims/Turks are recognized. I thik you have adequately explained in your passages why the world doesn’t concentrate on the sufferings of Turks – your culture is based on “eye for eye” principle, i.e. if somebody has committed an ill towards “you,” “you” don’t wine about it, and resolve the issue “yourself.” It is not indeed the case with us in principle. We are a different culture. As much as in other contexts I claim that Armenians are far from being Christians, nevertheless the “eye for eye” is not widely accepted in our culture. Not necessarily because we are powerless (because we reject that principle, by in large, even in our personal lives), but because we follow to another motto, which has unfortunately not evolved yet to the level of “love your enemy,” but we are somewhere in the middle.” By what I had said about fixing your problems youself and not whining about them, I did not mean an “eye to eye” culture, which is not part of our “high” culture. What I wanted to say rather was that if you are wronged, the most reliable person to right this wrong is you, because you are going to take your own problem more seriously than anyone else. Other people are simply not going to be half as interested in it unless and until it suits them. This is not a desirable state of affairs, nor is it (in my opinion) one that would lead humanity to further heights, but it is the bleak reality. Look at the way the international community handles the issue: everyone who knows about the issue knows that the armenians have been murdered. But if millions of dollars of deals, stability in the middle east and the oil flow are at stake, your interests dictate that the genocide issue must be put aside as long as you need the ally in question. This may make us puke as human beings, but that’s the way states function. So in sum, what I have said was not “if he kills you, kill him back”, but rather “if you are seeking justice, first rely on yourself and not others, as others by nature are not going to care as much as you do.”. Re “love your enemy”, it is not as strange to our culture as most outsiders think, although our version is “win him over”, a more factual and result-producing approach in my opinion. We have formed one of the most extensive and long-lived Empires of World History, and you can create a state by shedding blood (in fact almost all states that I know of are formed that way) but you cannot keep it in your hands by simply shedding blood. As we say in Turkish, you cannot destroy a state with picks and shovels but with cruelty. Also (a fact little known by most Turks themselves) one of the major contributions of the Ottomans to Islamic Legal System was the compilation of Kanunnames (Legislations) that were to function alongside the Sharia, to which every Muslim State had to pay lip service, at least. You know that the Sharia is very much a “an eye for an eye” lawcode, though not quite so much as Old Testament Law. Now the Kanunnames, I think originally compiled by Suleiman The Magnificent, though in existence before him, changed a good deal of the “tit for tat” into money fines and lighter physical punishment. Did you know that there is not a single recorded case known in the entire Ottoman history of a thief’s hand being cut off according to the Sharia? The Sharia orders this very clearly. Now the Ottomans would pass the Sharia verdict, then forge a link to the Kanunname, and convert the punishment to bastinado and/or money fines, imprisonment, and forced labour to serve the wronged party. This spirit is to be found throughout Ottoman legislation, and it is – at least to me – not indicative of a “an eye for an eye” mentality. “I also think that our pursuit of the condemnation of the Genocide is not about the responsibility of individuals who may or may not be alive even, at this time. Most of the more responsible individuals have already been brought to justice one or another way – either the Turkish courts have executed them for their crimes of massacres, or the Armenian avengers of the time have executed them (taalat, for example). So, for us the issue of individual responsibility is a non-issue. The issue is the state .” I am relieved to hear that. “The more balanced and common sense Armenians don’t consider the Turkish nation as the guilty party of the Genocide though, certainly, you would find some in and out of this forum which may claim it.” I know – I had met Genocide survivors and they were of the same mentality (of course I wasn’t a Turk who denied the thing). “Most of the Genocide survivors accounts (including my own grandparents) attest to the fact that many Turks have saved or have tried to save Armenian lives.” Not a few also died with the Armenians while trying to save them. "The declarations of many of our day Armenians along the lines of holding the entire Turkish nation responsible for the Genocide are resulted from few things – the denial of the Turkish, nation by in large, that the Armenian Genocide has been committed by the Ottoman Turkey, and moreover, the accusations that to the contrary, Armenians have committed genocide against the Turks." You would be surprised at how many people deep down their throats actually accept the genocide in Turkey, but cannot come up with it for a variety of reasons at least two of which are fear of persecution and sense of guilt and disgust with their grandparents and the “heroes” they were taught to worship at school. I know of a number of personal encounters between Armenians and Turks, and if the Armenian is diplomatic enough, the acceptance and condemnation of genocide tends to roll off the tongue quite soon. Don’t forget that most Turks were until very recently more afraid – with good reason – of their own state than the entire Armenian Nation put together. Regarding accusations of the Armenian Genocide of the Turks. While I do agree that the Armenians could not logically be engaged in such a thing, because first of all they did not have a state (it is states that mastermind genocides, not common people), let us face it: in the last decades of the 19th Century, you would not be hard put to find a sizeable group of Armenian intellectuals who would rather see the Turks dead as a nation, and worst of all, take part in reaching that end. This of course does not extend to the population at large, and therefore the Turkish position of “they killed us, we killed them back” is baseless. But there were such people. Also, if we take the view that even killing a single person on the grounds of his ethnicity constitutes an attempt at Genocide, then there are quite a few Armenians who do not come out that clean, aren’t there? The same yardstick must be used to measure evil. My criminal is not better than your criminal, and yours not better than mine. "The psychological trauma that the new Armenian generation is experiencing in the result of this stance of the Turkish nation, at least the appearance of it is the primary reason for such outbursts, which I cannot justify no matter what. I also would go as far as to claim that hating someone for being Turk is a borderline Genocidal behavior – the only missing thing is the opportunity to massacre them in such case. So I would urge the haters of the Turks or any other nationalities as an a priori feeling to evaluate their own emotions, first." I completely agree. But as I said, if you meet individual, informed, open minded Turks in an environment where they do not feel the fear of the state or the sense of being “cornered by the enemy”, they come out with it quite easily. The worst mistake that can be done is assuming that Turks would accept and repent only under pressure. Under pressure Turks simply turn into oysters that shut tight and keep that way for a long time. Look at me, for instance: my grandfather had told me what a mistake it was to have done the things we had done to the Armenians (without mentioning the word “genocide” and to have said that the issue was resolved for the next fifty years (implying, but not naming, Talat). He said “it is coming out now”. This was in 1980, if I remember correctly, a year before he passed away. This was my first exposure to a different interpretation of the events at the tender age of 14. The second was when my grandmother had related the story of my dad’s wet nurse (who was an Armenian lady) “whose two sons were gone in the killing”. She used the word “kıyım”, the folk word for mass killings, and not “soykırım” the official word for genocide, which is a literal translation, and has political overtones. So there was a “kıyım” in which people had died, contrary to the official version (at that time – military government – the state was denying the whole thing, even the killings themselves). Later on, in the west, I was exposed to other material of course, and made up my own mind on the subject. For me, to accept the thing was a matter of personal integrity and humanity before all else. At no time have I been subjected to any pressure by an Armenian or anyone else to be made to accept it. Indeed, I recall a few instances where the subject was brought up in a political debate in an international environment, where I immediately felt in the trenches, and, although not denying the killings, resorted to justifying them by saying that it was a tit for tat. You see, people will do anything when they feel cornered, and the first thing you have to do in resolving such conflicts is to ease both parties, especially the one who is going to “foot the bill” so to speak. Otherwise you risk losing them. "And I wouldn’t worry about the chance of the Armenian-Turkish relations being beautiful. First, they have never been beautiful, even way before the Genocide, and the Armenian-Russian relations are not beautiful either – neither historically nor in our days, as much as one may be tempted to think." I mildly disagree. There was a lot of common culture between the common people of Anatolia. The Ottoman State, of course, is another matter, but their relations with Turks were hardly any better. "I, personally, find difficult to address Timucin’s following argument: The trauma that we are supposedly be dealing with may not even be the continuation of the original trauma in some cases, but the creation of a secondary one through interactions with the existing justificatory discourses with the original trauma. I don’t quite follow him. It may be interpreted in multiple ways. Therefore, I would hold until further clarifications." I think what he means is this: the survivors were the ones directly affected by the disaster, and they were suffering from the very real loss of their loved ones: people, places, and a lifestyle which they knew and loved, whereas the latter generations, not having a direct experience of the disaster, were being traumatised by the constant keeping alive of the memories that their parents and grandparents, and not they themselves, had. And the issue turned into a blood feud. If this is what Timuçin is implying, then it leads to a “get over it” stance, which I cannot accept morally. If we want the Armenians to stop persisting in bringing out the issue today, then we have to stop persisting in our denial. But I do agree – if this is what he means – that it has become a blood feud, and nothing good comes out of blood feuds. "I would also like to add that the atrocities of the Communists in USSR were not directed at any specific ethnic or national groups. Any ethnic/national group of the former USSR would claim that the most terrible atrocities were committed against them, because “Stalin hated them.”" I think I had said what you say here. "I think we have some in this forum who behave like five years-olds, but fortunately, the Armenian nation has been wise enough collectively to bring together mature group of people to deal with the issue beyond the rhetoric." I hope they shall prevail. "And you are right that the best thing that has happened to Armenia in the last decade is the independent Republic. Until than, even our own tragedy didn’t belong to us – it belonged to the Kremlin and to the various Secret Services of the world, who used the Armenian tragedy as a tool for exerting pressure on Turkey." I hadn’t meant that the best thing that has happened TO ARMENIA in the last decade is the independent Republic. I had meant the best thing that has happened TO THE REGION IN GENERAL AND TURKEY IN PARTICULAR in the last decade is the independent Armenian Republic. You may find this strange, but this issue is now a state issue, and can only be finally put to rest if the two parties put it to rest at state level – for this there must be a n Armenian State. You see, until the independence of the Armenian Republic, the issue was between the Turkish state and various western states, the Diaspora, and terrorist groups. Now the various western states kept bringing it up to further their interests, the Diaspora – at least partly – used it to keep Armenian identity alive in a sea of odars (how is my latest Armenian word? The others are vart, turchun, kam, hach, tun avor es, tun hay es, es tacik em, ksi ksirembur), and the terrorist groups, well you don’t expect a state to bow to a bunch of terrorists, do you? The problem is that the Turkish Republic is a state, and has a constant responsibility toward Turkish citizens. It can only enter into a meaningful dialogue with the Armenian state, which also has the same responsibility toward Armenian citizens. And they are the only two bodies that can solve this issue definitively and prevent it from being a toy in the hands of third countries. That is why the best thing that happened as far as at least this issue is concerned is the emergence of the Armenian Republic. "However, the fact remains that the Republic of Armenia has proposed through multiple channels and venues to start a constructive dialog with the Republic of Turkey, without being a hostage to the history, and it has always been denied by the Turkish side, making the subject contingent to Armenia’s relations with third countries, and dropping the “allegations of the Genocide.”" Now here the “third country” is Azerbaijan, and let me be clear on this, both Turks and Azeris see themselves (at least officially) as one nation, two states. The Turkish government has got himself engaged in the Nagorno-Karabagh issue probably even more than Azerbaijan is engaged now, and they cannot get out of it (especially with the Grey Wolves in the coalition government). Moreover, Turkey has lost a good decade after Ozal in continuous bickering in political life because of low-caliber politicians, another legacy of the 1980 coup. We don’t have statesmen today, we have politicians. As far as “dropping the allegations of Genocide” are concerned, as I had said earlier, the government has first to prepare the public opinion, only then can it move toward accepting “the open secret that everyone knows about”. Again, please refer on my previous postings regarding the development of the Kurdish issue. "I couldn’t quite understand the alleged statement of Dadrian linking Sultan Hamid to CPU. As much as I know, he has not written anything of the kind. The argument that he has contemplated was that the massacres of Armenian committed by Sultan Hamid were the preludes of the Armenian Genocide, and the idea of the elimination of the Armenian minority of Ottoman Turkey was already in the agenda of Ottoman Turkey. The only missing thing was the opportunity, which was provided by the WWI." To me it seems a bit too much like a conspiracy plot. I may be wrong, of course. I doubt that Sultan Abdulhamid really planned to liquidate all the Armenians, since he was not a nationalist (he made life hell for them). "I am also not aware of any Armenians who deny the Armenian Genocide. Where does such information come from? The Istanbul Armenians?" No, my source for this was a Turkish historian appearing on TV who had said that an Armenian historian had written something to the effect that “the Ottoman State had used its sovereign right to figt an enemy within and to protect its territorial integrity”. I hadn’t noted the Armenian historian’s name, but as far as I recall he was a Soviet Armenian historian. I am not building anything on this, unless and until I read the said historian. I also would like to add that the emergence of Dkmadjian or Mikoyan in American or Soviet political elit has had nothing to do with Armenian Diaspora or Armenia. Dokmadjian was an American of Armenian origin, and if in his conduct there was an element of Armenian Agenda, he would’ve had zero chance to reach the heights he has reached. As to Mikoyan, the history of Armenia has only few such traitors, who have sacrificed the interests of the Armenian nation to the ideology of the World Revolution. As to Andropov, I couldn’t follow what does he have to do with Armenians. You may be right, anyway, you are better able to judge the Armenian Diaspora then I am. I thought Andropov was originally Andropian (it was in Turkish newspapers at that time with a big fuss about it).
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: to chinese scholar before talking about turkish barbarism, have a look at what china is doing to the tibetans, uighur turks and other minorities in china and the international condemnation it receives. also, do not forget the dozens of famines inside china throughout last century and this one that the chinese government - unsuccessfully - tried to hush up. one also wonders why taiwan (free china) is still not uniting with mainland china. is there something they don't like about it, and if there is, what is it? also why did so many people try to leave hong kong when it was about to get united with china? could tienanmen have something to do with it? i have enormous respect for the chinese civilisation, not least because of the very crucial contributions they made to mankind, not the least of which are paper, the printing press, paper currency, porcelain, the compass, gunpowder, silk, tea, and the smallpox vaccine. i also respect the chinese greatly for still preserving a written tradition that stretches back to almost 1500 BC. but, with all due respect, barbarism has unfortunately been a companion of all civilisations from the greek to the mayan, and the chinese one is no exception. also, please do not forget that amongst your contributions to mankind numerated above, all of them save silk, the compass, tea, and porcelain were passed to the rest of mankind by uighur turks (paper, the printing press, the smallpox vaccine), or the mongols (printed currency, gunpowder). they were not the only things. both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route. if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. one final note: i am sure as a scholar you know the things the shang dynasty (first recorded dynasty of china, traditionally considered to be the inventors of chinese writing) used to do with the skulls of their victims, don't you? regards,
-
“Well, you know, many people like to identify by color and race especially if they are influenced by the Western way of thoughts. I am Chinese, and we never had this concept. My people only identify through their common culture of 8,000 years.” This is not entirely accurate. African students in China complained aboutChinese racism in international platforms, and the Chinese throughout history referred to Turks and other “northern barbarians” as “fire-haired monkeys”. The Chinese still refer to the non-Han minorities in southern China as “monkeys”. A Chinese-paid English academic at Oxford is known to hava said that “the Chinese say that they brought morals to Tibet, all of whom had venereal disease” to which the reply on the Tibetan side was “you know how we call venereal disease in Tibetan? Chinese disease!” “Our race incorporated many different nationalities and it is still continuing this process today.” In a process called forced assimilation and, at times, genocide. Your race is currently conducting above-ground nuclear tests in the vicinity of Uighur cities in Sinkiang to make sure that all the Uighurs get radiated and are unable to reproduce viable offspring. “It really bothers me when I visit Korean and Japanese forums and those people there constantly talk and brag about their supposed kinship with the Mongols and the Turks only because they all speak Altaic languages.” If people speak related languages, then you have a strong case that they are related. For instance, hate it though Tibetans may, they cannot ignore the fact that their language belongs to the Tibeto-Burman subgroup of the Sino-Tibetan languages, the “Sino” part of which refers to the Chinese dialects. “Yet, scholars are still not firm in their research especially with the inclusion of Korean and Japanese into this language group.” This is true, but there are two theories that are gaining ground these days: 1) that the Indo-European, Uralic, Altaic, Inuit (Eskimo) and most Paleosiberian languages belong to one vast Eurasiatic family, and 2) it is the Austroneasian elements in both Korean and Japanese that blur the picture, otherwise, their inclusion in the Altaic family appears to be pretty sound (to those who are not linguists: Austronesian languages are those that are spoken in Indonesia, Malaysia, Polynesia, Micronesia, Melanesia and Madagascar, in addition to a few islands off southern China.). “And, in their forums they also constantly belittle everything Chinese as if we never existed. It gives me a sense of them having some inferior complexes. Needless to say, Chinese do not have to remind Koreans, Japanese, Vietnamese, Thais, Laotians, Burmese, etc. of where they got their written language, food, architecture styles, music, philosophy, religion, etc. We know it was all from us, and not from Genghis Khan (Jengiz Han).” If they do that they are an immature and ignorant bunch. Just ignore them. “It is also hard to imagine how Koreans can claim kinship with the Turks of Turkey. They are both completely different; believe me.” The Swedes and Bangladeshis are kinsmen even though they are completely different from one another. “Why is it that wherever Turkish people have migrated to, they have never lived peacefully among its neighbors? From China all the way to modern Anatolia, they have left a trail of bloodshed and horror. They are a predatory race. They take by force what nature has denied them. Chinese history can attest to this.” The same holds true of the early and later Greeks in Antiquity (the Greeks arrived in Northern Greece shortly after 2000 BC, and expanded to the south a few centuries later, and there is a 400-year long break in the archaeological record of the area between 1200 BC-800 BC, when they had destroyed the indigenous civilisation and later established their own culture), of the Romans (“They make a wilderness and call it an Empire, they make a desert and call it Peace” in the words of the Carthaginians), of the Vikings, the Russians, the Byzantines (ask the Armenians in this Forum what the Byzantines had done to them prior to our arrival and how the Cilician kingdom came into being), the Indians, the Persians, the Vikings (ancestors of the Scandinavians, the most peaceful and civilized members of Europe today), the Europeans of the last 500 years, the Mayans, the Inca, practically everyone who built an Empire. The difference between all of them and you is that your trails of blood and horror were largely confined to China, to your own people, and ours was spread to Eurasia because Eurasia being southern Siberia, subject to permafrost nine months a year, is not exactly conducive to the existence of large numbers of human beings. So whenever there was a population increase, or people have had enough of the killing cold and dreary pastures and realised life was better to the south and west, they migrated south and west. Not because they were bloodthirsty savages. “Around 100 A.D.s, a brilliant Chinese general--Prince Ban Chao fought an all-out war against the Turkish Huns. He beheaded and lopped off the heads of the hated Huns. All the adult Hun males were slaughtered; and the Chinese armies pursued them into what is now the country of Ukraine. All the adult Huns were killed. So many were killed, that it is said that only children and weak Hun women survived.” Speaking of genocides…. “After this victorious bloodbath and cleansing of the Huns from China, one obedient tribe of the Huns were allowed to remain in China and serve as border guards. They later changed their tribal name to "Goksalan Turk," or "Sky Braves." “ The name is “Göktürk” (originally “Köktürk” , dear. It means Blue Turks or Sky, Celestial Turks. “They, too later became strong enough in the 5th cent. to constantly raid China. Then, in the late 7th cent. A.D., China was reunified under a vigorous and warrior aristocrat. Emperor Li Shimin was half-Chinese and half-Turkish (Dulgor tribe on his mom's side). He understood Turkish tribal warfare methods. Unlike some other Chinese emperors, he not only felt content to drive the Turks back beyond the Great Wall. But, he even took the offensive and invaded their territories.” So it took a half-Turk to unite you guys defeat the full-Turks, the Chinese could not do either themselves. “Employing the best Kung-fu skilled warriors, polished good Chinese sabers, banners raised, the soldiers marched off playing the Chinese drums, cymbals and the sorna (Chinese folk oboe).“ Sorna is what we call zurna, and comes from Iran. The Armenians have it, too. By the way, Kung-Fu is a more recent invention, I thought, was it in place that far back in time? (only curious). “Everywhere they met success against the Turks. From 620s-640s A.D., Li Shimin decisively beat back the Turks and eventually enslaved them. He was recognized as their "heavenly Khan." All the Turks were deported into China proper. For many years, the Chinese nation lived in peace, prosperity and celebrations.” Not all, dear. The Oghuz (my ancestors) were to the west of those enslaved. “Some Turks themselves eventually assimilated into the Chinese race. But, some complained of inhumane treatment and abuse.” Can you tell us why? “In the early 700 A.D.s, one tribe broke away under Bilga Kagan and his adviser, Kultegin. They fled back into Mongolia and developed the first Turkish written language (still used by Mongols today). Their descendants were later betrayed by their kindred Uigur tribes. The combined Uigur-Chinese armies finally crushed the Turks and they moved on to Central Asia and the Middle East under a new Oguz confederacy.” This is a bit of an over-simplification but generally true as a nutshell history. At that time, “Turk” was a name given to a small group of Turkic tribes. “Today, the Uigur Turks are still a minority group controlled by China. Their ancestors willingly surrendered to the Chinese king. They chose to be Chinese, and they are "Chinese Turks." I learned to speak some of their language and I know about how they feel. I remember 2 years ago, a Turkish tourist middle-aged man from Izmir visited Beijing, China. He toured the Great Wall of China. He knelt and kissed the wall. He then said: "Allah Wakbah." Myself and this tall Chinese policeman cornered him and asked what he meant by all this? He said in English: "That his blood and ancestry belonged here on this wall." The Chinese policeman find out his intentions, and then with much joy hugged this Turkish tourist. And, I said: "This wall is the heritage of everyone. So many people died on this wall." I said in broken accent Uigur language: "Hosh galdanez. Chok menet tarum. Esem miseh bizim. Yalla Alla." To my surprise, this Turkish man understood everything I said. All the words. He hugged me, and we all took pictures. Chok menet tarum- I am grateful. Chinese and Turks today are no longer enemies. But, we dumped the trash for other unfortunate people to clean up.” “Allah Wakbah” is probably a horrible corruption of “God is Greatest” (Allahu Akbar) in Arabic. As for “yalla alla” I can’t make head or tail of it, even though I am familiar with a good many Turkic languages, including Uighur. Besides, your apparently friendly encounter with this man is in stark contrast to the lines following it, don’t you think so? “Chinese were enemies of Turks in ancient past. Now, Armenians, Arabs, Greeks, Russians and Iranians carry this burden. The Chinese ancestry of Mamikonyan family makes this even more interesting, because their early Chinese ancestors may have fought Turks on the Great Wall in China. Chinese-Turks-Armenians all had a shared linkage and destiny. Armenian brothers (as well as Iran), hang in there! Your day will someday come. If we did it to the Turks 1,300 years ago, then you can too. We pass our war banners on to you.” So shall we wish you good luck in a future genocide of the Turks to be carried out by most of Eurasia, or what? Grow up, man. You seem to be an intelligent guy in some places. You can do better than that. Regards,
-
to chinese scholar before talking about turkish barbarism, have a look at what china is doing to the tibetans, uighur turks and other minorities in china and the international condemnation it receives. also, do not forget the dozens of famines inside china throughout last century and this one that the chinese government - unsuccessfully - tried to hush up. i have enormous respect for the chinese civilisation, not least because of the very crucial contributions they made to mankind, not the least of which are paper, the printing press, paper currency, porcelain, the compass, gunpowder, silk, tea, and the smallpox vaccine. i also respect the chinese greatly for still preserving a written tradition that stretches back to almost 1500 BC. but, with all due respect, barbarism has unfortunately been a companion of all civilisations from the greek to the mayan, and the chinese one is no exception. also, please do not forget that amongst your contributions to mankind numerated above, all of them save silk, the compass, tea, and porcelain were passed to the rest of mankind by uighur turks (paper, the printing press, the smallpox vaccine), or the mongols (printed currency, gunpowder). they were not the only things. both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route. if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. one final note: i am sure as a scholar you know the things the shang dynasty (first recorded dynasty of china, traditionally considered to be the inventors of chinese writing) used to do with the skulls of their victims, don't you? regards,
-
If Turkey and Armenia join the European Union
aurguplu replied to edward demian's topic in International
edward the point is that turks are not that afraid about armenians buying land in turkey and settling there are citizens of the turkish republic. the point is that if they do that, and become a majority there, then how can you expect them not to struggle for union with armenia, which means cessation of territory by the turkish state. the turkish state would then have its right as a sovereign state to defend its territorial integrity, as any state is perfectly entitled to do. the armenian side is right in saying that no true reconciliation and sincere relations can take root between the both of us unless and until the turks recognise the genocide, may i add that the turkish side is equally right in saying that no true reconciliation and sincere relations can take root between the both of us unless and until the armenians make a point of unconditionally accepting and respecting turkish territorial integrity. regards, -
Dear Timuçin, Here is my reply: “To be honest, I was not expecting a barrage of Armenian Genocide 101. Considering that you are a professional historian, I was expecting something more sophisticated than what I already know and heard many times so far. Perhaps, you have the idea that I have just recently encountered the subject, and therefore, you thought not to be so harsh on me by starting from the ABC of the Armenian Genocide and the subject of genocide in general. Well, I thank you for being so considerate. “ I am not a professional historian. I am somebody who studied the region’s history at university, learned Arabic and Ottoman (I speak the standard western languages as well), and came back to Turkey aspiring to be a professional historical linguist (not historian), only to see my career truncated by yök and the stifling academic environment in Turkey. I have never lost my ability to read the original documents and also to read – and read through – historical narratives, so I would perhaps better qualify as an amateur historian, or better still, a competent layman (since I haven’t produced anything of note in the domain since I left academia). I had started with an ABC account of the Armenian Genocide since 1) it is in the ABCs that the most extreme forms of denial on the Turkish side and analysing the event out of its context on the Armenian side differ, and 2) I did not know the level of your previous exposure to the subject, so I started from scratch, and 3) I find it easier to develop a subject from scratch to a conclusion, since I can follow my own narrative better this way and do not lose track of my argument (I fear that I have not been particularly successful in that in my postings, though). “To start with, I am not denying the Armenian Genocide, although I find quite many theoretical difficulties, especially approaching from anthropological and psychological levels, in maintaining and believing in some of the positions on some key concepts. For example, what is genocide? Is it complete annihilation of a culture, a people, a language or all of these things? “ Genocide is a crime clearly defined under international law. It basically refers to the deliberate destruction of a racial, ethnic, religious, social, or political group of people IN WHOLE OR IN PART simply because of what they are. The destruction may take the form of 1) deliberate direct killing, 2) imposing conditions upon members of the group that would bring about their deaths (for instance, if you cram 500 people into a train which would normally take 200, and then make them cross a desert with no food or water and sanitation for weeks on end, and if people die because of that (they would), that would also be a genocide, and no-one would care to look for written proof to show whether it was intended or not. Such actions are ordered by statesmen, and no statesman is silly enough not to realise that such conditions would bring about death on a massive scale), 3) preventing reproduction (the Chinese are conducting above-ground nuclear tests in Sinkiang (Chinese Turkestan) to make sure that the Uighur Turks are not getting viable offspring so that they basically die out, 4) removing children from the community and giving them to other groups to be raised as members of that group, 5) preventing and/or dissolving marriages within the group and forcing women to marry outside the group. I may have missed one or two things, but that is basically it. Now it is clear that thus defined the term “genocide” describes any course of action which prevents a group of human beings as decribed above to preserve their lives and identity as that group. It is also clear by the above definition that by this definition human history is little more than a series of genocides, and they go back to the dawn of time. As pointed out above, it is at least as old as the Old Testament. Now the word “genocide” is new (it was created by Rafael Lemkin after wwii to describe the Holocast) but the crime is as old as humanity itself: if you read the Old Testament, most of the things the old guys did (and Jews of all people) clearly fit the current definitions of Genocide. In fact, even though the term “genocide” is a recent coinage (from the greek genos (people) and Latin cidere (to kill)), the terms “holocaust” (Greek), or “shoah” (Hebrew) or katliam (Turkish) describe the same phenomenon (katliam is an Ottoman coinage of two Arabic words, “katl” (killing) and ‘aam (people, public, general) with a Persian izafet construct: katl-i-am: killing of the people). So one may argue that the concept of genocide is an old one, even if the term in vogue now is new. “The funny thing about this subject is that neither the Jews nor the Armenians were completely annihilated as opposed to some other groups who were. If a group is completely eradicated from the face of the earth then there can be nobody to say that there was a genocide. So, we need not so complete genocides in order to have genocides. There were some groups, for example, some American Indian nations, or to some extent, at least one Circassian nation, who were erased from the face of the earth to the point that there is nobody today even to bring up their cases.“ I am sorry Timuçin but this is not true. No offence intended, but that shows that you are not aware of the specialised literature on these people. I am not an expert on either the Circassians and the American Indians or other groups, but I know that what happened to the American Indians and the Australian Aborigines is commonly described as “genocide” in most of the concerned literature. The reason why we hear less of them is that we have already been so imbued by loads of movies like Soldier Blue, Dances With Wolves, 1492 etc., progressivist movements, documentaries, that it is now common knowledge that what happened to the American Indians best fit the definition “genocide”. The reason why we don’t hear of the Genocide of the Australian Aborigines is that 1) Australia is so far away and is not a very major player in world affairs, 2) there is no Aborigine Diaspora outside Australia to speak of, let alone an influential one to blow their own trumpet (both the Greek and Armenian Diasporas were and are very, very powerful in American and Soviet business and politics (Dukakis, Deukmejian, Mikoyan, Andropov etc.) in general and Hollywood in particular 3) the Greeks and Armenians are amongst the earliest Christians (the New Testament was written in Greek, and the first nation to adopt Christianity as a state religion were the Armenians) and we are Muslims: now the centres of power in the world are the USA (Christian), Europe (Christian), Russia (Christian), Japan and China. Of the five centres three are Christian and they rule the world and control all major information channels. It would be naïve to expect that we as Muslims would get the same hearing for our various sufferings. All the same, every organisation other than perhaps the states (Australia, USA and the former colonial powers) do recognise these as genocides. Mind you, specialist literature on Caucasian affairs also does. But it doesn’t get heard as much as there is not a significant Circassian Diaspora (other than in Turkey or Jordan) that is in a position to blow its own trumpet. Also, it is my impression that we Turks (this includes all other ethnicities who now consider themselves Turks in nationality) find it beneath our dignity to talk about past sufferings. In fact, the fact that the Government has adopted a line like “if Turks carried out an Armenian Genocide, the Armenians did likewise” puts most Turks to shame, not because of whether or not it happened, but according to our culture, which I am sure you know as well as I do, if you think you are wronged, you go and right it yourself and don’t whine about it to third parties. It may be good character, but it doesn’t work in international politics. International politics is all about getting what you want through a mixture of whining, pleading for help, offering bribes, threatening if you can, etc. it is a complex process that we have not yet grasped as a nation. “But, I will skip discussing this subject right now, and instead concentrate on some of the points in your post. The outcome of the events in Anatolia at the end of the Great War was definitely genocidal, whether or not there was such an intention. Here I agree with you, and this has always been my starting point in analyzing the Armenian Genocide. Because of the genocidal character of the outcome, I use the term genocide. “ That is the main point. Good for you. This is the thorn in the flesh. “I am not obsessed with the subject of proof at all. The people who know me from my previous many discussions on this subject can tell that I have almost never discussed documents to prove if there was genocide. Since I start from the outcome, I actually do not need any documents to prove my case. To me, what is important is that regardless of what various personalities may have intended the outcome was the annihilation or removal of enough number of Armenians from the locality they perceived as their homeland to the point that the result was the eventual lack of effective population for Armenians to be able to reproduce themselves both culturally and physically in this particular locality as Armenians. This I call genocide or a genocidal outcome, if not a true genocide by definition. Therefore, I do not need documentary proof to show that there was a genocidal attempt against the Armenian nation.” I understand we are in complete agreement here. “On the other hand, documentary proof is needed, if our intention is to figure out who the responsible party for this genocidal outcome was.” I agree that we need documentary proof to CONCLUSIVELY demonstrate the responsibility of specific individuals, but there is a substantial amount of CIRCUMSTANTIAL and COMPELLING evidence that point to Talat, Enver, Bahaeddin Şakir, and Dr. Nazım, to name a few. I cannot conceive what evidence would exonerate them. “It is even more needed, if the intention is to find a guilty people, an ethnic group for the crime.“ I would be wary of accusing an ethnic group for a genocide. To me, there is an ominous parallel between killing an ethnic group in whole or in part (men, women and children) and accusing an ethnic group in whole or in part (men, women and children) of a crime, ANY crime. It is a criminal form of stereotyping. “So, these genocide discussions are in some ways not altogether about proving there was genocide of the Armenian nation, but about proving that a particular nation, the Turkish nation, which at the time of the crime did not even exist as a mature nation in the modern sense, but as a religious group, was responsible for this crime.” I agree and disagree at the same time. I disagree because 2) I know for a fact (not only from historical studies but also from family memory) that a genocide of the Armenians did indeed take place, and that at least Talat was responsible for it, and 2) if I were an Armenian genocide survivor or descendant of one, I would devote a very substantial part of my energy to raise awareness of the issue. I agree because 1) the Great Powers, who had vested interests in the demise of the Ottoman Empire, first had to establish a “moral cause” to campaign against the Turks. I did my military service as a 2nd Lieutenant (Asteğmen), and one of the first things that we were thought about warfare was that you first have to establish a moral cause to mobilize the people 1) to die, 2) to kill for it. If there isn’t one, you have to create one. I strongly suspect that this last did play a major role in the events that culminated in the genocide. You find the same principle in Sun Tzu’s Classic, “The Art of War”, too. “And, the assumption is that by receiving their apology, the Armenian nation will be magically get themselves out from the trauma brought by the memory of the genocide, or rather, by the secondarily produced and reproduced memory of the original event. Is this going to be reliving in different terms or coming to terms with what happened? If this is the assumption it is a naïve one. The recognition, condemnation, repentance and apology will not undo what is done. But it will at least relieve the pain of the survivors which our government doesn’t even recognise as based on facts. They maintain it is a figment of their imagination. It will remove the thorn in the flesh, but then of course you have to treat the wound, and whatever you do, some scar will remain. It is a bit like this: I see human relations like a vase. A vase has two functions: to hold water and the flowers (the functional one), and also to be beautiful (the aesthetic one). Now Turkish-Armenian relations have slim (not zero) chances of being beautiful again, at least in the foreseeable future, but they have a high chance of holding water if both sides act intelligently. “The trauma that we are supposedly be dealing with may not even be the continuation of the original trauma in some cases, but the creation of a secondary one through interactions with the existing justificatory discourses with the original trauma.” I personally agree, but the Armenian audience in the forum would be in a better position to reply to that. At any rate, the claim Taner Akcam makes that the Turkish nation is sick may actually be that we have two sick nations, and coming to terms with the genocide may end up curing, although in a limited fashion, both nations.” I agree. This is why I am on this forum. An apology issue is actually not a very easy one, when there are good number of extremely nationalistic bunches on both sides. An apology may prove very effective and beneficiary for personalities like, I do not know, MJ, Winston, you, some others, and I, but there are also many others who may take the whole issue of the apology in many different ways. “As we all know, after the Germans were made to accept their so-called crime for the Great War, more than 40 million people died.” It was Stalin who did it, and even the Soviets later condemned him. His crimes were the result of a pathological personality, a nation with no tradition of, and aspiration to, democracy and human rights, worldwide paranoia, an economic-philosophical doctrine that was completely out of touch with reality, and an utter lack of respect for human life in general (Russians and Georgians suffered no less under Stalin than the rest of the Soviet Union). “And, when we look at the increasing numbers of racial violence especially in the Northern European countries, including Germany, the issue of apology becomes even more important and difficult to deal with. There is the issue of working this apology business into a new cultural discourse or meta-narrative. This can be done in many ways.” Europe has an unfortunate tradition of racism that is almost as old as the European identity itself; but the recent upsurge has more to do with the abuse of welfare by immigrants with no historic ties to Europe than with the endemic racism in Europe in my opinion. Note that the West Germans are only slightly more symphathetic to East Germans, whom they perceive as working less and getting more out of the welfare system. “In the above case of Germans, it was done in one particular way that ended up costing the lives of millions of people.” I lost it here. How did the German apology end up costing millions of lives, or did I get you wrong? “On the other hand, The ideology of communism, through its brotherhood of peoples and cultures, chose not to get into this subject, other than repressing the old late medieval and early modernist meta-narratives, and now we have people killing each other both in Balkans and Caucasus.” Never mind the ideology, but the Communists did horrible things in their countries on ethnic grounds. Millions of ethnic Turks (Tatars, Kazakh, Kirgiz, Uzbek etc.) were deported from their ancestral homelands ostensibly on the grounds that they sided, or would have sided if the opportunity were given, with the Germans in WWII, and are only now allowed to return, and only in a few cases, with no compensation or whatever. Also, Communism did not solve the age-old conflicts in the areas concerned. It only put them in a deep-freeze. When it thawed, they resurfaced. “For example, when I apologized my almost five-year-old daughter just yesterday for something that was my fault, her reply was ‘apology is not enough’. Yes, it is not enough; it is simply not going to create wonders by itself.” I agree. But we are not dealing with five year olds here (even tough some of their numbers sometimes act as if they were). In this hindsight, I think that the best thing that happened in the last ten years is the coming into being of an independent Republic of Armenia. That Republic will eventually realise that it has an image to live up to, responsibility toward its own citizens, neighbours that it has to learn to live with, and opportunities if he does so. You need responsibilities to mature. If Armenia and Turkey were run by competent businessmen who could put first things first, both countries would be so much better off and not pose a threat to anybody. “Another point: when you start reading Dadrian, you are going to be disappointed with your claim that , “refer to the killings of 1915 as the armenian genocide, and not, for instance, the killings by sultan abdulhamid ii in the 1890s? atrocious though they were, the killings of abdulhamid were designed to "reprimand, chastise" (tedip etmek) the armenians, and not to exterminate them.” For example, Dadrian tells us that “First of all, the Abdulhamid-era massacres were the first Ottoman attempt in modern times to launch, on a massive scale, exterminatory massacres against a non-Muslim subject nationality” (Armenian Forum – Summer 1998 – Armenians, Turks and the End of the Ottoman Empire, by R.G. Suny). If you can get your hands on this source I would definitely recommend it, especially since it also includes perspectives by some Turkish historians. At any rate, you will have to read all of Dadrian’s works, since his ideas evolved in time as well. And, you will see that he is not really about separating these two sets of massacres qualitatively, and his ideas do count very much among the Armenians.” I have not ret read Dadrian, so I am not in a position to reply. I find his understanding of the events as you quote them a bit far-fetched and forced. Sultan Abdulhamid II and the CUP leaders had almost nothing in common in terms of political outlook and aims. But I repeat, I have not read the book, and this particular suject is far too complex to be done with with a summary analysis. But allow me to point out here that I am impressed with the quality you put forth your arguments with, and also especially the fact that you cared to read the other side’s version from their own publications. Very few Turks do that. If our numbers increase, we may make a difference in our society in term of understanding the basic fact that you cannot have sound opinions without sound knowledge. “When I said that everyone in Turkey accepts that Armenians were killed in great numbers, I was simply trying to say what I said, none of the stuff you posted.” Sorry, then. I did not mean to put words into your or anyone else’s mouth. “They of course do not accept that it was a genocide.“ Why “of course”? Is it natural not to accept something that is a fact? “Only the very educated ones accept is partially true, as there are very educated ones on the other side who do not accept it.” I had also heard that some Armenians do not accept the Armenian Genocide as a Genocide, but do not know any more of this than that. Could some Armenian members of the forum inform us more on this, please? “By the way, this ‘educated’ thing is kind of funny, since the Armenians were killed, namely the designs to get rid of them, which led to their being killed, were done, by the very educated lot at that time. Genocide is a crime that belongs to not so-called primitive cultures, but to the so-called educated and civilized cultures.” This I largely agree with. “There is also the topic of the Muslims who were removed forcibly from various places in the Empire at the end of the Ottoman Empire. You go by those last names maraslian, sivaslian, demircian in presenting your case, but is not this a bit weak argument, since there are also a lot of last names in Turkey showing us that the carriers of these last names came from localities outside the present day Turkey such as ‘koprulu’, serezli, selanikli. What about this? Should we declare this a genocide, too? By the same token, we can also say that there were many Muslims living in outside of Anatolia in numbers that were in millions, but today they are in thousands. Was this a genocide, too?” This is at least partly the result of the Population Exchanges between Turkey and Greece in the 1920s, and partly, yes, what I would call Genocide. They are not called so by anyone except for a few specialists (not all of whom are Turks o Turcophiles), simply because 1) Turks have such a bad press themselves (the Kurds, Armenians etc.), and 2) believe it or not, the scholars who try to expose them and bring them to world attention get not tangible support whatsoever from Turkey. Such things require a very large army of competent scholars equipped with ample resources and a constant flow of cash. Now a Turkish professor in a state university gets paid about 800 USD a month, he cannot lead an existence worthy of his status let alone buy books, and when I was a Lecturer at the Istanbul University Faculty of Letters back in 1992-1993, the Faculty Library had not had a regular budget to make acquisitions since 1974! And Turkish Studies chairs abroad are only now being assisted by Turkey, and that largely to produce glossy coffee table books or engage in the dogfight against the Greeks and Armenians. This is no way to defend your position in the international arena. If you don’t blow your own trumpet, no-one else is going to do it for you. By the way, when one is comparing numbers about a particular genocide, one should use the numbers before and after the genocide. You are using numbers before the Armenian genocide and the ones that are from our time. Are we to assume by this that the Armenian Genocide lasted until, let us say, 1980s? “… I would like to clarify that I am not denying there was a genocide, although it might be denied if we really want to get technical about the definition. I have posed a few questions here in order to present some different dimensions of the whole thing.” If you are not denying there was a genocide, then we are in agreement. As for getting really technical about the definition, you can deny anything when you get technical enough about definitions. Also, no two genocides (or no two things, for that matter) are the same: the point is that they have enough things in common that allow them to be grouped together and enough differences from other events that allow them to be set apart from them. But your questions were provocative, stimulating and beneficial (for me, at least). Thank you. “By the way, the numbers are important in genocide discussions and definitions. If you kill 10,000 people out of a population of 1 billion, it is not a genocide. But, if you kill 150 people out of a population of 200, it is a genocide.” I disagree, and it also doesn’t agree with the accepted definition of the term genocide. If you kill a single person because he is an Armenian, then your action is directed against the whole Armenian nation, and that is attempted genocide. If you kill someone because he is Ahmet, Mehmet, Agop, Artin or whatever, then this is homicide. The difference between a Homicide and a Genocide is, as far as I shall understand, that a homicide attacks one or several specific individuals because of traits specific to them, and it doesn’t attempt to extend it to an entire group of people who share the same social characteristics. Genocide, on the other hand, attempts to wipe out a group who all share certain social characteristics (race, ethnic group, language, religion, etc). Therefore, numbers are not the defining characteristic of a genocide.
-
gosh, i did it again. and again, it is the second posting that is the edited one. sorry, mj. i belong to the pre-electronic era of mankind and currently trying to evolve. cheers, ali suat
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear everybody, i think the turkish state at the moment has the following approach as far as genocide recognition is concerned: when i was young (i am 34 now), i.e. in the 80s, the very word genocide was enough to get you into prison. begining with özal's later years, many things have changed. as you know, i have been contributing to this site for the best part of a year by now, and had recognised the genocide at the outset. i also do that in discussions in turkey wher ex-military types are present. so far nothing at all happened to me. meanwhile, i understand vahakn dadrian's book was translated into turkish four years ago with the title "jenosit" and can be freely bought in this country. several armenian professor of history (i only know of grigor ssouny) have been to turkey to give lectures reflecting their version of the story. nobody gets arrested. the assyrian priest (i forgot his name) who was arrested about a year ago for claiming the genocide took place, was released later on. all these seem to confirm what i had said in an earlier posting: i think the state is currently preparing the turkish society for the psychological effects of an eventual recognition of genocide. remember that a survey showed that 11% of turks believed in the genocide? that is almost one member of each turkish family, statistically speaking. i think the state first wants the people to be exposed to the other side's version of the story, so that they start to think that it really "might" have occurred. after all, this is how comon people think: if there are so many people who maintain that such a thing occurred, and if they are the descendants of the victims and survivors, there must be a grain of truth in it somewhere. note that turks do not deny that the killings occurred, or fail to condemn them, what they deny is that it was a planned, deliberate action to exterminate the armenians from anatolia and the armenian uprisings were not the major motivation behind it. but for this to come to the desired conclusion, namely the recognition, repentance, and compensation, one significant obstacle has to be definitively moved out of the way for good: perceived threat from the armenian side on turkey's territorial integrity. if this persists, and worse, if it temporarily subsides just to gain new groud (so it will be interpreted by the turkish hardliners) only to resurface once the genocide is recognised, it will backfire, turkey will shut itself up again and we will all be back to square one. mind you, turkey can go a long way avoiding the recognition as it is a strategically important country with a dynamic economy (never mind the current shambles). it is also a country of 65 million people that no market-minded state would like to lose. so i was actually relieved to read some of the postings here, as i was dismayed to read some others elsewhere in the forum. most turks (i regret to include myself) are anxious that genocide recognition will bring about land claims from the armenian side. by this i do not mean the physical return of the land to the descendants of survivors, but rather an official demand that part of eastern anatolia be given to the republic of armenia. some of you may find this anxiety of ours (and mine) ludicrous, or at least far-fetched, but it is a sincere one and a substantial proportion of the material that we keep encountering only reinforces it. i understand that many armenians themselves concede that they adhered to the naive (their word) belief that if they rose up against the ottomans, the great powers would support them in their struggle for independence. they did not then, and would not do now. not that we genuinely fear that such a secession could ever take place, but that some inept politician may really mess things up and the situation can get out of hand and end up inflicting new damage to both parties who have suffered so long. i wish i had never felt i had to write these last lines. i just want this tragedy to end for good not to repeat itself ever again. regards & peace to all, ali suat
-
dear everybody, i think the turkish state at the moment has the following approach as far as genocide recognition is concerned: when i was young (i am 34 now), i.e. in the 80s, the very word genocide was enough to get you into prison. begining with özal's later years, many things have changed. as you know, i have been contributing to this site for the best part of a year by now, and had recognised the genocide at the outset. i also do that in discussions in turkey wher ex-military types are present. so far nothing at all happened to me. meanwhile, i understand vahakn dadrian's book was translated into turkish four years ago with the title "jenosit" and can be freely bought in this country. several armenian professor of history (i only know of grigor ssouny) have been to turkey to give lectures reflecting their version of the story. nobody gets arrested. the assyrian priest (i forgot his name) who was arrested about a year ago for claiming the genocide took place, was released later on. all these seem to confirm what i had said in an earlier posting: i think the state is currently preparing the turkish society for the psychological effects of an eventual recognition of genocide. remember that a survey showed that 11% of turks believed in the genocide? that is almost one member of each turkish family, statistically speaking. i think the state first wants the people to be exposed to the other side's version of the story, so that they start to think that it really "might" have occurred. after all, this is how comon people think: if there are so many people who maintain that such a thing occurred, and if they are the descendants of the victims and survivors, there must be a grain of truth in it somewhere. note that turks do not deny that the killings occurred, or fail to condemn them, what they deny is that it was a planned, deliberate action to exterminate the armenians from anatolia and the armenian uprisings were not the major motivation behind it. but for this to come to the desired conclusion, namely the recognition, repentance, and compensation, one significant obstacle has to be definitively moved out of the way for good: perceived threat from the armenian side on turkey's territorial integrity. if this persists, and worse, if it temporarily subsides just to gain new groud (so it will be interpreted by the turkish hardliners) only to resurface once the genocide is recognised, it will backfire, turkey will shut itself up again and we will all be back to square one. mind you, turkey can go a long way avoiding the recognition as it is a strategically important country with a dynamic economy (never mind the current shambles). it is also a country of 65 million people that no market-minded state would like to lose. so i was actually relieved to read some of the postings here, as i was dismayed to read some others elsewhere in the forum. most turks (i regret to include myself) are anxious that genocide recognition will bring about land claims from the armenian side. by this i do not mean the physical return of the land to the descendants of survivors, but rather an official demand that part of eastern anatolia be given to karabagh. some of you may find this anxiety of ours (and mine) ludicrous, or at least far-fetched, but it is a sincere one and a substantial proportion of the material that we keep encountering only reinforces it. not that we genuinely fear that such a secession could ever take place, but that some inept politician may really mess things up and the situation can get out of hand and end up inflicting new damage to both parties who have suffered so long. i wish i had never felt i had to write these last lines. regards & peace to all, ali suat
-
dear mj, i checked some of the sites you suggested. they are fine. thanks a lot. regards, ali suat
-
dear mj, i must admit that i honestly did not know about the thing that cambon wrote, and had never read in anywhere either in books or online until now. if it can be proven to be authentic, it must be translated into turkish and published here. i cannot fail to note the parallel between this and what the army has been doing with the kurdish question. regards, ali suat
-
superb i especially liked the birth. couldn't it be a bit larger? they remind me a bit of the greek frescoes in my hometown ürgüp (cappadocia, of fairy chimney fame). regards, ali suat
