aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: I thought it might be Farsi because I saw a couple of place names in Iran on the map, things like Qara Tupraq or whatever... So it is Turkish, huh? yepp it's a good old central asian word. it is abundant in iran, afghanistan, northern pakistan, as these places are full of turks (one third of iran speaks azeri, kashkai, turkmen, and khalaj).
-
hagarag, i am not quite sure that the total truth will ever be revealed, but enough of it to arrive at a much more accurate and balanced picture, yes, that will happen, and my gut feeling says that we are going to witness that sooner than we dared think. it may wel happen in this decade. turkey has so far gone quite some way in addressing the grievances of her disaffected kurdish minority (of course there is much more she has to to), the only really serious obstacle remaining, in my mind, is cyprus, and secondarily the aegean. now since cyprus is a security issue, where the soldiers have more say than freely elected politicans, i really do not know when this will be solved. but i am sure some general will one day look atthe map and see all the borders to the west of turkey removed, globalisation rampant, click on the internet and communicate with people on the otherside of the globe, and see the ridiculousness of a tiny island like cyprus divided in two. that will happen one day, but when, i don't know. cheers,
-
hagarag, thanks for the compliment. we have had three politicians in my family on my dad's side, my great-grandfather, my grandfather, and my dad. they were all out to save the country, and forgot to save themselves (financially speaking). when i was young (i have been writing that line for a while now, it's getting depressing) i tried to do my bit to save turkey through academia only to get disillusioned by the entire concept of academia in turkey. so at the moment i am trying to save myself. also, i am known for having opinions that differ from that of the general public over here, and i am not noted for having the political skills that others have (these latter either subscibe to the prevailing opinions or just say whatever the people want to hear - nobody wants to hear the truth). frankly speaking, i do not see myself as a man with political capabilities, but i would like to do more for the solution of turkey's conflicts, both domestically and internationally. cheers, (by the way, sorry for the delay in the 2nd half of my posting of armenians in the ottoman empire, i hope to ge it done tomorrow) [ November 14, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Ali, I don't think Nubar *****'s letter gave any numbers. Additionally, I don't think that anybody has removed it from its original thread. mj, i recall having seen numbers there (at least in the version that timuçin posted). i am not implying that anybody has removed it, but i can't find the thing. it must have been somewhere under genocide (gosh with our habit of jumping from topic to topic, this forum has started to look like my study desk to me (no offence intended)). how about the first person relocating it posting it under a separate title under genocide so that we can get back to it with ease? i think it will create quite some discussion. i hate it when the documents i am referring to are not under my nose and have to quote from memory. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: Dear Ali, As reasonable and enlightened you may be in many respects, you are utterly wrong in this characterization. The Armenian "revolutionaries" were few in number, and had never amounted to any real threat. The sporadic "noises" from the provinces were the result of the appalling treatment Armenians endured despite their surreal degree of passivism. The vast majority of Ottoman Armenians were apolitical. Of all the ethnic groups that had the "potential" to rebel, Armenians were probably the most pathetic one, and the ruling party certainly was wily enough to know it. In fact, that knowledge gave them the audacity to carry out the "deed". Best Regards, Twilight Bark [ November 13, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] dear tb, o.k. i know, and have said before, that 1) the rebellious armenians did not cosntitute the majority, 2) you do not kill innocent armenian civilians because some armenian rebelled and killed turks. you go and nail that armenian and that one alone. 3) the young turks appear to have had the idea of getting rid of the armenians anyway, so the armenian rebellions only served as a pretext. so much i hope we agree in. now the rebellions: a letter by boghos noubar *****, the armenian representative at the paris? conference after ww1, which has been posted somewhere in this forum several times (once by me) states that armenians had joined the enemies of the ottomans in quite substantial numbers (way more than a few thousand) since the beginning of the war. there is also abundant literature, by the armenians and non-armenians alike, on the terrorist activities of armenian factions from the last decades of the 19th century. although it is probably true that the absolute majority had sided with the ottomans, it is equally true that a numerically significant minority had sided with the russians and the french (the boghos noubar letter gives a figure of at least 40,000 if i remember correctly. by the way, it was timuçin who posted it, then i re-copied it from there and posted it somewhere else, went back to look for it to post it here, it isn't there. can anyone tell me where it is, please?) so while turks have to learn to live with the fact that what transpired was a genocide, the armenians also have to learn to live with the fact that they were "not little lambs", as one british statesman of the period had put it. we both have to revise our perceptions of the past. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: The above statement is entirely wrong - the Ottoman government actively encouraged Jews to settle in Palestine, and the existence of a large Jewish community established during the last half of the 19th century was an important reason behind the emergence of Israel as a state in 1948. This close historical co-operation with the Ottoman regime was the reason that most Jews in Palestine sided with the Turks during WW1. There may be darker reasons as well (alleged Jewish connections with the CUP and Young Turk movement, masonic conspiracies, etc.). It has nothing at all to do with silly invented history deriving from the story of Jews fleeing from Spain (both Israel and modern Turkey have a "fondness" for continuing to propagate that story as a reason to explain their close alliance). steve, while i agree largely with what you say, i have to point out that the "story" of spanish jews settled in istanbul in 1492, apart from being true, also means a lot to both nations - especially the jews concerned, who owe their very existence today to it. there are also a very large number of crypto or ex-jews, the "selanikli", who have traditionally reached very high levels in turkey. our current foreign secretary, prof. ismail cem, is such a one, for instance. it is of course obvious that the current love-affair between the israelis and the turks is more a result of realpolitik than historical affection, but it also remains a fact that apart from the two shameful instances in republican history - the 6-7 sept 1955 events and the earlier property tax business - one would be hard put to find any anti-jewish action in post-tanzimat turkish history, and also, jews persecuted elsewhere have frequently ended up in turkey, not only in 1492 but also during ww2. also, we as a nation are generally in good terms with the israelis that we see, and anyone who knows us knows of our opinion of the arabs (mine is an exception). regards,
-
hagarag, the reaction of the turkish groups, and the jews' alliance with them, stems from certain basic facts: 1. i had outlined the reasons for turkish reaction in an earlier posting, just to repeat in outline here: i. most turks genuinely believe in what they say, i.e. that it was inter-ethnic warfare and not state-planned genocide due to the brainwashing they have gone through for three generations, ii. the armenians did provide the yong turks with an excuse by inciting revolts and siding with the enemy, iii. an enormous number of turks (over three million), civilian as well as military, died in wwi, which no-one in the west talks about, iv. genocide claims usually surface during election times in the usa or europe, and are addressed by politicians none of whom are armenian or represent armenian interests, v. genocide claims almost never come without other claims attached to them, most notably land claims, vi. the attitude of the republic of armenia regarding the territorial integrity of turkey is unclear, vii. armenians, including the republic of armenia, are clearly the aggressors in the nagorno-karabagh issue, and armenia is currently occupying azeri territory OUTSIDE nagorno-karabagh and has already carried out ethnic cleansing by displacing a million azeris, viii. the turks have justified concerns that the territorial integrity of turkey is questioned by the west, not only in the case of the armenians but also that of the kurds. 2. now the jewish-turkish cooperation in this issue: i. jews are in a hostile environment in the middle east, and their only friend is turkey (we recognised israel back in 1948 or 49). ii. we are probably the only nation on earth who had consistently good relations with the jews: turksih jews came to turkey from spain in 1492, fleeing the inquisition at the hands of the christians. iii. both nations have a common enemy: militant islam, which tries to destroy both secular turkey and israel, iv. this is most important: the jewish holocaust is probably the ultimate abomination of human history. history has seen quite a few abominations, ranging from genghis khan to stalin, to the inquisition, the slave trade, annihilation of the native americans and the australians, but the jewish holocaust is really without parallel, and their efforts to oppose any attempt at equating any other tragedy with theirs is understandable: the armenians had rebelled, and the rebellion was most brutally put down; and then, seen as a threat to the existence of the state, they were all but annihilated. though barbaric and atrocious, it does not really compare to the holocaust, where the jews were eliminated WITHOUT PROVOCATION ON THEIR SIDE. i have maintained in previous postings in this forum that the armenian genocide was far more comparable to the bosnian genocide than the jewish holocaust. none of the above of course neither denies the fact of genocide nor diminishes nor justifies it; but - i hope - it gives it a new perspective. the issue is going to take a totally new turn as the easing of the ban on the discussion of the genocide in turkey starts to bear fruit. i think this is the most important area to focus on, and not the reactions of the turkish groups outside and the allegiance of the jews with the turks. cheers,
-
mj, a point about the above posting re armenian history: "For instance, the most ancient Greek historians speak of striking similarities between the inhabitants of Cappadocia, Phrygia, and Armenia, in their language and customs, so much so that the Armenians and Phrygians were sometimes said to be the same people. So the Armenians were spoken of by some ancient writers as a colony of the Phrygians; and the Cappadocians as a colony of the Armenians. The different languages of the three, on account of their striking resemblance, have been called different dialects of a common language." we (the cappadocians) spoke dialects of hittite and luwian, both of which are very close to one another. the languages of lycia, lydia, and adanawa (present-day adana) were also very close. phrygian was spoken further north, and was written as a liturgical dead language until the third century a.d. you find phrygian tomb inscriptions in many places in central anatolia but not to the best of my knowledge in cappadocia (cappadocia is a very clearly defined area, and quite easily defended thanks to the fairy chimneys). we never got on quite well with the greeks of the western shores, and preserved our language and culture well into the christian era. we turned christian early on, but developed heretic sects, which the byzantines tried (unsuccessfully) to crush. byzantine authors knew that various non-greek languages were spoken in central and eastern anatolia that were the same as those of the "white syrians" of that country: neo-hittite. to the best of my knowledge they spoke of the survival of our language in the mountains of isauria (northeast of antalya) in the sixth century a.d. later on, when the turks came and the byzantine empire was gone, the christian population (some of us had converted to islam, and there also were the karaman, a clan of the afshar, who settled there and intermarried with the locals) was called the "greeks of karaman", but this was originally a designation of the orthodox religious community rather than ethnicity. despite the best efforts of contemporary greek historians, the "greeks of karaman" have never been proven to have spoken greek in everyday language. in fact, they spoke a divergent form of turkish from probably the eleventh century, but always with many mistakes in it; so their native tongue was something else. we still have many hittite words in the turkish spoken in cappadocia, and our material culture differs from that of the other neighbouring regions very sharply (we have our distinctive pottery style, with a characteristic sheen, which you find in hittite works and nowhere else: no other region of anatolia produces pots like ours). and we are still very different from everyone else, even the people of kayseri, who are not reliable merchants. cheers
-
quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: Ali - you do not live in a city where you experience everyday terror - you live in Istanbul. If you want to experience everyday terror I think you should be living is Bingol or Mus or similar places! You seem to be saying that just because one side commits atrocities it is OK for "your" side to do it. But all you are doing is pouring more fuel on the fire. I suspect a lot of people here will see direct parallels with this photo and similar photos taken during the Armenian genocide. I wonder - would you like to live next to those soldiers, would you like your daughter to marry one? Your views are not barbarian - they are just rather thoughtless. ok steve, alright, i do not live in a city where we experience everyday terror. we experience everyweek terror (now english is one new word richer ). when i was a child, we did experience everyday terror: our house was machine-gunned, my dad's car was planted a bomb, my parents' friends were killed by extreme left or extreme right, i had to choose the german school instead of galatasaray (the french "lycée imperiale") although i had won the exams, and both my grandfather as well as my father were its graduates, the terror was one of the main reasons why my parents divorced (my mother couldn't handle it any longer) etc. etc. so don't tell me about everyday terror. diyarbakır and muş were until very recently what istanbul was like in the 1970s, in which we grew up. i have one very simple attitude toward terrorists: treat them with their own medicine. see one, kill one. i do not care about their opinions, grievances, etc. if they kill INNOCENT people as opposed to the sources of their grievances. for some reason it is always the common people who keep dying, and the generals, politicians etc., rarely if ever foot the bill (and don't you tell me about the protection they might have, we had protection, nothing is easier to circumvent it). and also think about the plight of the soldiers who cut the heads: these are boys of 18-early 20s who in the prime of their youth are sent to die off in mountains in the dead of the winter. they have a higher death rate than the guerillas because they are not local and usually less well trained than the guerillas, and they also experience what they see as the locals' treachery: they are brainwashed that there are no kurds and that no-one is being oppressed in turkey, and that therefore all dissent is invariably separatist. would i like to have someone like that as a neighbour? well, no. but i have a lot of friends who have fought in the southeast, i myself could have been sent were it not for my kidneys (people from my platoon were), and if there were such a problem again in turkey, then i would probably go there to fight (at least i would not run away). now i would of course tell you that i would not do things like that, but the thing is right now i am in a heated, ventilated office room with no reason to suppose that a gun is being pointed at me right now, and i have no fears that underneath the floor i am walking there are mines. put me at the slope of an icy mountain in the southeast under these circumstances with one bottle (a quarter litre) of water for one week, make me march 40-50 kms a day on average with 33 kgs of equipment that i have to drag, make me see my buddies get shot, blown up, etc. by the enemy that i can't even see, do all that for four months, and i might well change, so might you. this has got nothing to do with any inherent barbarity, but with the circumstances you are in. i know that the pictures are reminiscent of the armenian genocide - and i hate it. but in the present case we know that 1) the heads were very probably not innocent, and 2) they were supported in their equally barbaric acts (pictures of which are rarely shown in western media) by the eu until very recently which the eu itself had not denied while they were suppotring them. put yourself into my shoes. what would you do?
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: There is a non-Aremnein word popular in such cases in Armenia - khiyar (pre-reincarnational). mj, does "khiyar" mean "cucumber" in armenian, and "an idiot" by extension? just curious. regards, ali suat
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: Ali, The depths of your understanding of the issues continues to astound me. You are such wonderful resource in educating Armenians as to the dynamics of what is transpiring in the Turkish community. A key point that you have made is what fuels Turkish xenophobia is the miserable treatment they get from Christian Europe. Irrational Armenian hatred of present-day Turks does nothing to ameliorate the differences between our peoples but fuels Turkish intrasigence on the Genocide issue. dear hagarag, thank you very much for your comments, and may i say you hit the nail in the head in your last sentence (to drive it deeper, may i add: the turkish intransigence generated by the armenian stance makes it difficult for turks like me to expose my countryme to unpalatable truths of the past. turks know that their ancestor did terrible things to other peoples in the past, just as everyone else (and they were done terrible things, too, just as everyone else), but tend to turn into oysters when these facts come attached with claims that attack their territorial integrity, sovereignty and, in some cases, very existence). i do not like turkish intransigence, i try to combat it, but i cannot fail to note that it is only human nature to respond in such a manner if you are in our shoes. ragards,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos: Indeed, Winston you are quite right. Armenians have been making carpets for a long time. I have also a number of Armenian inscribed pieces and own several books on Armenian carpets. As much scholarship as Ali shows I think he is incorrect in saying that carpets are exclusive to nomadic people. Carpets have been an absolutely common feature of most villages in the Caucasus, and many of the so called Caucasian carpets could be called Armenian. Karabagh is just but one of the types of Armenian carpets. Carpets are, and were a feature of people´s life everywhere in Anatolia and the Caucasus. Moreover if you find a carpet woven by a Cristian (that is with crosses or cross-like symbols for example, but not only) odds are that it was an Armenian. It is true that there are carpets woven by Muslims that were simply copied, and the other way around is also true. Carpets have been a part of Armenian life for a very long time. o.k., thoth & boghos, i have been misunderstood. i did not claim that carpets were exclusive to nomads, or that armenians never wore carpets. we know that there was carpet and rug weaving in anatolia by the time the iliad was composed (homer talks about them), and very possibly much earlier. advances in archaeology tend to 1) constantly push the dates of several basic inventions such as pottery, weaving, plant and animal domestication and farming, and 2) reveal the multiple origins of these activities, i.e. that they were probably invented independent in several different parts of the world at different dates. the activity of making yarn out of plant and animal (especially plant) fibres is now known to go back to at least 30,000 years. the dog is now known to be domesticated several times from several independent breeds, pottery has been invented in different places several different times, the same goes for agriculture and metallurgy. one more thing about christian symbols: turks freely use them everywhere, and also something as basic as a cross motif was around long before christ. it is the other, more complex, motifs that show unmistakable signs of cultural cross-fertilistion and continuity. cheers,
-
ok everyone, i could not have known the importance of carpet-weaving amongst armenians as well as you do, so it looks like i was wrong (but i had not said that armenians didn't weave carpets or anything like that). you will probably know that one of the oldest known human settlements that could be called a city was unearthed at çatalhöyük by the british archaeologist james mellaart (whom i have had the pleasure of getting acquainted with personally). mellaart (much later) published a two?-volume set on the site, in which he gives pictures and drawings of the motifs found at çatalhüyük and compares them to the textile motifs of the turkish carpets still woven in the area today. you really don't need to be an expert to notice the obvious continuity in many examples (though in some cases he may have jumped to premature conclusions). he had also related the following story to my professor at oxford, prof. geoffrey lewis: as he was digging in çatalhöyük, he had noticed hand figures stamped on the walls in red ochre (you put your hand on the wall and draw its contours in red ochre, or you dig your hand in red ochre and stamp it on the wall) in arrangements. he then noticed something he hadn't noticed before in the neighbouring village: the same hand stamps on the same kind of walls with the same red ochre. when asking what they meant, the villagers simply said "anane (custom)". eleven thousand years! what happened to anatolia is this: anatolia has been invaded by countless different people in history. none of these invaders eradicated the former inhabitants of the place, and each added something of its own. there have also been countless changes of ethnicity and linguistic affiliation, so that today there is practially no way of telling a turk from a kurd, or a kurd from an armenian, or an armenian from an assyrian, or an assyrian from a greek etc. you could tell different people from different regions to some extent until the turn of the century, but with the advent of the 20th century and increased mobility, even that has become all but impossible in major migration receiving cities. so this whole thing about this nation stole that from that nation in anatolia is groundless. a sizeable portion of turkish speakers of today are the descendants of armenian speakers only a few centuries ago, and you can repeat the same with any combination of peoples who are known to have been in anatolia ad infinitum. that's why i choose to cherish the sheer complexity of anatolian culture as it is and not try to divide it into artificial compartments of ethnicity, language and religion (race? in anatolia? come on!), and i invite all anatolians to do the same rather than bicker about what motif belonged to whom. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: Ali, BTW, when do you anticipate completing your translation work so that you can post the remainder of the names of Ottoman Armenian notables from volume 2? dear hagarag, i have actually completed the second part of the list, but right now i am completing a translation (of something much duller, just to earn some money), and as soon as that is over i shall post the list. i hope it will be sometime later tomorrow or wednesday at the latest. cheers,
-
dear rouben, i doubt that the turkish state exerts any significant pressure on turkish expatriates in europe or the usa on the subject of genocide and other issues, for the following reasons: 1. they can't. turks outside turkey are by definition outside the grip of the turkish state, and even if the government uses their families back in turkey to blackmail them (something that i have not heard reported), the pressure they will face from the eu and the usa will force them to back down, 2. they don't need to. since our entire nation has been brainwashed on this issue for three generations, the turks have a natural instict to see an attempt at turkey's very survival whenever they are confronted with the word "genocide". you really have to neither motivate nor force any turkish community to act against any such attempt, they will do it instinctively. and the fact that they are getting the treatment they are getting in europe as individuals (especially in germany) doesn't help to change the long-entrenched belief that christendom as a whole will do anything to destroy the turks. 3. they don't care. all warfare, including propaganda warfare, costs. you have to be willing to pay the price if you expect to win the war. in the case of propaganda warfare this is mostly cash. not the sort of amount that will rock the finances of any nation, but the sort of amount that no poor student, or student body, or expat ngo, or lone businessman can provide. turkish governments and business circles have been notoriously stingy when it comes to financing turkish propaganda outside turkey. i know this personally, as i was a member of the ottoman society at oxford university in the late 1980s, which wound up after two years because the government, the business circles, individual turkish businesses in england, couldn't come up with even a few hundred pounds per year to finance the society. we didn't have money to mail party invitiations. so don't you worry about any turkish state activity of consequence against genocide affirmation. there wasn't one, there isn't one, there won't be one. the guys would rather buy themselves new mercedeses and seaside mansions and holidays in switzerland than finance anything that is ostensibly in the service of turkish propaganda. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by Rouben Malayan: Dear Ali, Thank you for the posting. I only would like to note that the work of virtually all turkish organizations in Europe consists of denial and cover-up and in the most fierce manner. Armenians, the victims of the genocide in 1915 and their descendants, fall victim to propoganda and agitation, blackmail and sabotage in present day throughout the world. Netherlands is a good example, the Katch'kar errected in Assen and mass hysteria on side of turkish organizations in Holland proves that Ankara is keeping very tight grip even on those turks who live in a free society outside Turkey. Soon there will be another court ruling regarding Assen, more publicity we get out of it, better will it serve our cause which is just. I thank you for taking rational approach on this subject, you are very rare and perhaps the only person of turkish origin to which opinion people (at least myself) listen to. Best regards, Rouben dear rouben, thank you for your reply. it is understandable that the work of most (though not all) turkish organisations even outside turkey re the genocide concentrate on its denial and cover-up, because 1) it is the policy of the turkish state, and 2) the turkish people are deliberately kept ignorant on this issue, so the turks who defend the turkish position outsde turkey genuinely believe that they are on the right side and you wrong, 3) they are usually confronted with xenophobia, turcophobia, discrimination and racism in europe, and naturally develop a defensive attitude, 4) the genocide issue keeps being reheated whenever there is an election in germany or france, or some international problem, so turks (rightly) think that those who bring it up do so to further their own interests, and don't care a bit if there was a genocide or not, 5) the issue is brought up by europeans, themselves seasoned practicioners of genocide, and 6) the genocide issue rarely comes on its own: it is usually attached to some greek and/or kurdish action and attempts to bring turkish territorial integrity in question. this naturally puts turks into psychological trenches, who have genuine - and not totally unfounded - concerns that their sovereignty and territorial integrity is still questioned by the west. this feeling has been exacerbated by the bosnian genocide and the russian action in chechnya (we have the impression that the west acts if it is christians that are killed, and just watches if it is muslims that are killed), and the current afghan war does not help to improve things. the ongoing occupation of about a fifth of azerbaijan outside nagorno-karabagh and the one million internally displaced azeris, plus the uighur genocide currently underway in sinkiang (chinese turkestan) also do little to help your cause, especially the former. so the armenian genocide turns into a huge snowball of international conflicts when it comes attached to other issues. turks also - like anyone else - tend to react negatively to attempts to force the recognition of a crime they genuinely believe they did not commit. maybe my experience concerning the genocide may give you some helpful ideas as to how to approach a turk regarding this matter: my family was involved in politics since ottoman days until the last decade, and one member of my family was a member of ittihat ve terakki during the genocide. now the genocide was planned by a secret clique inside the ittihat ve terakki, and no-one except talat and enver and possibly one or two more figures knew its true nature until it had actually started and reports reached istanbul of the atrocities that took place in eastern anatolia. the deportation itself was not much different from similar measures taken during wartime by many nations, including the usa (wwii, the japanese americans). what people realised too late was that it was being used as a cloak to kill off the armenians altogether and not simply to relocate them temporarily. the fact that the reality of the armenian "incidents", as they are called in turkey, differed substantially from the official version, was first mentioned to me by my late grandfather about a year before he passed away (i was 14). my dad's wet nurse was an armenian lady "whose two sons had gone in the killings", as my grandmother had put it. so there were indeed killings in which people had died, which was news to me. then i spent long years in the west at high schools and university, during which i had ample opportunity to be exposed to the armenian version of events. i had at first protested like any "good turk", but my earlier exposure to some of the reality prevented my protests to turn into the hysteria that turks usually fall victim to in this issue. since i was a curious and reading guy with quite some international experience by then, i viewed the evidence in front of me (from turkish, armenian, german, and other sources) and concluded that there was indeed a genocide. one of the most shocking facts that i had discovered was that the armenian and turkish versions mainly differ in three points, i.e. the numbers of the dead, armenian treachery during wwi, and the intent, but that they do not differ in the fact that a substantial portion of ottoman armenians had died, and that the armenian population of turkey was reduced through killings and deportations to a fraction of what it was before. two the most surprising discoveries i made was that the official turkish version did actually fit the internationally accepted definition of genocide to a significant extent, and that the genocidal nature of the incidents (the intent) was actually mentioned in contemporary turkish sources, which were - and still are - freely available in turkey. most turks do not realise that, because they do not study it systematically, they dismiss it merely as an attempt at destroying turkey. i believe it to be important to note that never in my life had i been subjected to pressure to accept the genocide. i came to my own conclusions from the evidence before me. and therefore i do not believe i) that turks will not accept the genocide except under pressure, and ii) that turks will accept the genocide if enough pressure is applied. i posted numerous entries in various places in this forum, where my views can be seen in greater detail. i invite you to have a look at them. i think it would be more fruitful to get guys from both sides together who are agreed on some crucial basic points such as the fact of the genocide, and then discuss what can actually be done. i would be willing to help. regards, [ November 09, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: What about my bringing up the controversy over Şerare Yetkin's work on Turkish carpets and whether some of them might indeed have more to do with Armenians than they might with Turks? Don't they mean anything to you? thorny, i refer you back to my earlier posting on this particular subject. i used to know a thing or two about carpets in my student days, have been actively researching them, both in turkey and outside it, and have rarely encountered any carpet, kilim, cicim, zili, sumak labeled as armenian. the few instances where i saw armenian works was one saddlebag in kuşadası, a few pieces in the shop of a relative of mine, and pictures of some karabagh pieces in a western book. in the west, the main market for carpets, the carpet business is a huge one, and armenians are very prominent figures in it. during my eight-year long stay in europe (england, france, italy, belgium, switzerland) i have never encountered an expert on carpets talk about armenian carpets. this is not to say that they don't exist, but they obviously do not constitute a major armenian art form. the architecture, stonework, metalwork, jewellery, watchmaking, and miniature-painting of the armenians, on the other hand, is mentioned everywhere. this is in fact very logical, for carpet weaving by definition is a nomadic art form, it is the furniture and dwelling of the nomad, and the two greatest carpet producing nations of history, the turks and the persians, are both nomadic in origin; whereas the armenians, sedentary since probably 800 b.c., are specialists in architecture and stonework, as a logical outcome of their lifestyle. now we must of course be against non-turkic work being ascribed to turkic peoples, but we must not get carried away and ascribe our own works to others. i recall having a heated debate with some "expert" on the art of the levant, who commented on some pieces of carpets that they were greek and armenian, and went on to provide a very tortured explanation what some of the motifs meant. as he didn't have a clue as to what he was talking about, he was bullsh*tting. when i asked them what some specific signs on the works meant, he gulped, gasped for air, provided several contradictory statements in the same explanation, in brief, made at tilt of himself, at which point i lost patience and pointed out that the signs in question were the tribal insignia of the afshar and kayı tribes, both of which i happen to belong to (my mom is kayı, my dad afshar, but since they know zilch about turkish ethnography, they only have the haziest notion what the names mean). he didn't know where to look. if you happen to visit a european museum, and see islamic works of art, they are usually labelled "asia minor", without the word "turk" ever present. it takes some familiarity with the various islamic styles and the specific art in question to realise that they are turkish, i even recall having warned some museum staff at one occasion that a work they had labelled as "persian" (a piece of calligraphy, was in fact the work of a well known turkish calligrapher from istanbul, whose work i had seen in books, private collections, and had even touched one at my master's workshop! the attitude in europe against turkish artistic achievements stems from the now debunked notion of turkish ineptitude for fine arts. increased tourism, better museums, better catalogues, international exhibitions like that on suleyman the magnificent years ago and the sabanci calligraphy collection more recently, and most importantly, scholarly works conducted by european and american experts help to dispel that myth. we should not import a prejudice on turks inside turkey that is dying out in europe itself. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Oh good. It's good to see people responding to this topic, because it's an interesting and important one. I think that's absolutley right, the point about onlookers saying how terribe the international events are, and the few that can do something about it don't. To be looking on is as bad as committing the deed yourself. Bear with me if my information is not correct, but The first impression I got about the Turkish Police force is that it is known for being corrupt. And also against it's own people. There have been articles posted on this forum, about it abusing their own women. Is this right? I mean , Ali is a real person telling the situation as he lives it, he's not just some article. As the others are not either. But you see, I don't know enough about these things! Mabye I need to be taken in hand and properly trained. [ November 08, 2001: Message edited by: Kazza ] kazza, the turkish police is corrupt, violent, ill-trained, ill-equipped and unprincipled (allowing for exceptions). no doubt about it, the state and the police forces themselves admit it. now let us examine each of these traits in turn: 1. corruption: the police is corrupt because i) he must be in order to make ends meet. your average police in turkey gets something around $100-150/month salary if i am not mistaken. now the starvation threshold of a 4-person family is above that. the bribes they receive from, say, drunken drivers are called "soup money", indicating where they go. there you are. ii) he can be and get away with it: corruption is all-pervasive in turkey, and people do not see much moral wrong with petty officers taking bribes if they are left on the brink of starvation by the state, which meanwhile gorges itself full with outsized mercedeses, antelope-skin leather upholstery, new mansions, salary increases when all salaries are cut by three quarters etc. the time-honoured practice of corruption was even sanctioned by our late prime minister & president turgut özal, who, upon commenting the absymal quality of life of civil service personnel, said "my civil service personnel know how to get by, they find a way in any case". also, they have been issued authority and a gun, and turkey, never being a free society, simply bows to power. 2. violence: violence and torture to specific groups (communists, separatists, even facsists and fundamenalists) was originally ordered from above either to make them talk or to intimidate opposition. now you have to separate state-ordered systematic torture from wanton violence at demonstrations. the first is being abandoned now thanks to massive western pressure and an increasingly open society that is developing inside turkey. the second stems from the behaviour of the demonstrators and the unaddressed problems of the police. most western (and some turkish) civilians miss the essential point that if you are going to use violence, you have no moral right to complain about violence being used against you: if you behave like an animal, you are going to be treated like one, and frankly speaking i see nothing wrong with that. now if the civilian demonstrators smash property, beat up people, call for the overthrowing of the state, and attack the police, what would you do if you were a policeman? 3. ill-trained: the sight of the police handling primary evidence with bare hands at the crime scene of the murder of üzeyir garih, a well-respected businessman, was on all tv screens and showed crystal clear the lack of training of our police force. this is again a question of money and efficient, principled state. you cannot blame the poor guys for that. it is the government that should foot the bill. 4. ill-equipped: the turkish police uses outdated and faulty equipment, has a shortage of protective equipment, legal investigations are made on a shoestring budget, and the criminals are frequently better equipped and trained than the police force. 5. unprincipled: yes they are. read the above and tell me whether you would not be if you were a turkish policeman. we are not going to get anywhere unless and until we recognise that the people whom we accuse of violating human rights are human beings too and are entitled to the same rights as we are. cheers,
-
dear rouben, i have already put the first half of the list of the ottoman armenians of note under famous armenians. i hope to be able to post the second half sometime next week. some of those slain in 1915 are mentioned as such (not in the armenian genocide, of course, but armenian "incidents"). it is a very depressing list, as you can see quite a few individuals who had rendered valuable services to both the armenian and the turkish nations. the details of the source i took them from are there, the book is freely available in turkey. the free circulation of such books gives credence to my conviction that the turkish government is easing the ban on the subject, and as i said before, we may well see the official recognition of the genocide sometime this decade. such publications help the formation of a public opinion inside turkey that will be favourable to the recognition. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: So, Ali, you are proposing Armenia to let another country to slaughter its Armenian minority? IS that what Turkey did in Cyprus? Also, are you familiar with International Law, in particular with the clause of Nations' Right for Self-Determination? [ November 08, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] i forgot to add that in the cse of nagorno-karabagh, i do not blame the armenians for their armed resistance against the azeris. it is the oe million internally displaced azeris who are almost all from the regions neighbouring karabagh, not in it, that we have a problem with. i am pleasantly surprised that an armenian of all people found a parallel between karabagh and cyprus. yes, you are in very much the same position as we were in cyprus, and you have about as much chance getting the annexation or independence of karabagh recognised as we have with our turkish republic of northern cyprus.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Dear Ali, Could you elaborate further on the subject of the "agressors," so that there is no ambiguity in what we are talking about. Then, perhaps, I would have some comments. well, if a country is engaged in armed action or is supporting armed action inside another country with a view to putting an end to its territorial integrity, that would mean "aggression" to me.
-
quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: Ali, everyone knows that these Turkish special forces "rambos" can kill whoever they like, and then just put a gun beside then, which makes the victims PKK and thus it is all OK. Even if they were PKK such activity is not acceptable. Reproduce a picture like this enough times and Turkey's percentage chance to enter the EU goes from single figures to zero. Todays only Croat fascists and the occasional KLA terrorist can get away with this sort of thing (but they have German support). Steve steve, we know of the deeds of the turkish commandos. all commandos everywhere have always been doing the same, that includes the serbian, russian, british, and american commandos. we know that they kill non-terrorists (not whomever they like) and put guns next to them. but the thing is when you kill such ones, you are unlikely to pose with their heads (just speculating). second, being paranoid does not mean you don't have enemies: one of my duties as a translation officer was listening to the med-tv (the pkk propaganda channel) and there they did not deny the things we have always accused them of doing. you do not live in a country where you experience everyday terror. i do. if in my country you stop buses, ask for "visas" to kurdistan, kill turkish civilians, poison city water mains, explode bombs in shopping malls, kill teachers in front of their wives, scalp the heads of my soldiers and PUT THEM ON and take pictures with them (have you seen these pictures? i have, and not in govt propaganda channels), kill two year old kurdish babies in their cradles, then i chase you to the ends of the earth, and when i get you (there is no if, i will get you), i do as i please with your head. and if people cannot accept this, they should first turn around and look at themselves and not support such organisations in the first place. the pkk had semi-official status in almost all of the eu until it turned around to shooting germans. if i am going to be called a barbarian for that, so be it. i couldn't care less.
-
kazza, re the lydians: no, they had nothing to do with the turks. turks were still at the foothills of the altai mountains then (but classical greek and later roman historians and geographers did refer to tribes and nations further west that we know today were turkic-speaking. the lydians spoke lydian, a close relative of hittite and luvian (it is descended from one or the other, i cannot remember which one now). this group of languages is known as the anatolian subgroup of indo-european languages (to which greek, armenian and english also belong). lydian or its ancestor hittite-luvian and its close cousin lycian were originally spoken over a much wider area which included greece, and many place names in greece and turkey derive from these languages: as a rule of thumb, all names that have -ssos or -nthos in greek are originally from these languages (like knossos, xanthos etc.) it is also becoming increasingly clear that the trojans of homer were luvian or lycian-speakers, as opposed to the achaeans, who spoke greek. hope this has helped. cheers,
-
kazza, while khodja does the research on the lydians, here is some brief info on them: the lydians were an anatolian people who were linguistically related to the earlier hittites and luvians (like the spanish and the italians are). they were there during most of antiquity probably all the way to the birth of christ and slightly beyond. they lived at a place called "lydia" (aptly enough) which was along the southern aegean shore. they have distinctive architecture, very different from hellenic, and the later hellenes did borrow a few things from them. money (or rather, coinage) was invented in that part of the world (the chinese also used bronze implements as money, but my memory fails me when it comes to dates) by the lydians, and then quickly spread to the rest of the mediterranean basin and beyond. the time was around 7th century bc. and the coins were made of electron (an alloy of gold and silver) and were called "stater" again if my memory doesn't fail me. i am sure khodja can post more (and i would appreciate to know whether the name of the coinage really was stater, i need to know), but meanwhile this will give you capsule info on them. by the way, the NAMES of dolma, sarma and yalancı are all purely turkic dolma means filling, sarma means wrapping and yalancı means liar, or fake. of course the actual food itself has little to do with central asia since most of the ingredients are middle eastern in character. but the central asians do have the concept of filled stuff, because it is one way to preserve and transport otherwise perishable and difficult to handle foodstuffs. as for kebab, again the NAME is arabic from kabba but since it is basically a piece of meat on a skewer and must have been around since the neanderthals you probably cannot credit the arabs with the invention of it, unless they are willing to consider themselves apemen. turkish coffee is called turkish coffee because that specific way of preparing it was invented in ottoman turkey. the plant itself is either of arab or ethiopian origin (i mean the discovery). arabs did use coffee, but those days mixing it with butter and turning it into something that looked like marmite (but tasted less bad) was more common than drinking it the way we do now.
-
have you seen the pictures of what those heads did when they were on shoulders?
