Jump to content

aurguplu

Members
  • Posts

    623
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by aurguplu

  1. dear shirag, very interesting posting but 1) what are your sources? when i would write something like this, i would include the sources i gatherred the info from as well. 2) i happen to know a thing or two about ancient turkics, but i don't think you can talk about them in the 3rd millennium BC. most of the current turkic languages (with the exception of chuvash and khalaj) are about 1,500 years old at the most, khalaj perhaps a few centuries earlier and chuvash older still. so a realistic date for common turkic is sometime in the middle of the 1st millennium BC. there can be ancient turks in 3rd millennium bc i and only if turkic is not (or not as closely as thought) related to mongolian, which indeed is a very strong possibility. 3) your postings include many words that are way too similar to have been borrowed from ancient turkic. the forms you cite would be quite different in ancient turkic from the modern forms both in shape and meaning. also, armenian, an indo-european language originally from the balkans, underwent massive transformation when it arrived to eastern anatolia and the caucasus in the 1st millenium bc, where proto-armenians encountered the urartu and other caucasian peoples. to give one example, the armenian word "erku" meaning "two" is of the same root as "two", but it takes quite some linguistic research to figure that one out. there are i am sure many words in armenian that are of turkic origin, as there are some in some turkic languages that are of armenian origin. but their shapes would be quite different depending on which dialect they were borrowed from/borrowed into and at what time. one should also note that indo-european began to infiltrate into turkic way back in central asia in the form of tokharian. i know someone who does research on that, and it appears that some very, very basic vocab items are from tokharian. so one should be careful "finding" parallels between turkic and armenian, where the parallels may really be between turkic and other indo-european. there is also a distinct possibility that turkic and indo-european might be related, but this is a long shot. we can discuss this later on if anyone is interested.
  2. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:there were armenian factions that plotted and acted against the empire, and the empire had sovereign rights to deal with them, violently if necessary, to preserve its existence. no empire has sovereign rights to extend the punishment of a criminal to its innocent next of kin. that, as i shall understand, is the gist of the matter in the armenian genocide. you cannot interpret a law, right, interest or whatever to pass a death sentence on an entire nation. and i am afraid that was the point we missed in the above discussions. regards, Hello again Ali. I don't have the time now (nor wil I for the next several weeks) to address all of your points raised here (and they are good ones) - though I wish I did have the time because I welcome this discussion. Let me just say that your last point made here is something we can all agree on I would think - and in the end it is all that really matters. Briefly though - Nubar certainly was exaggerating to gain sympathy for his people before the victorious Alied Europeans - he stretched and fabricated to make his case that the Armenians deserved some spoils of victory. Do you really think that if (Ottoman)Armenians (in Eastern Anatolia) had even one tenth - even one one hundreth of the men under arms as is implied here that the Genocide could have happened unabated as it did? Would we not have heard of major military confrointations (outside of Russian initiated action or some very minor/isolated resistance/rebellion? Why are there no accounts whatsoever of any deportation convoys being rescued/liberated? - not a single one. Do you think that the Ottomans could have even held the countryside in the face of such forces (with the Russians also pressing trhe attck...). Please. Also - it should be noted that until 1917 (Russian Revolution & breakdown of control over the army) it was Czarist policy to ship Armenian to the Balkans to fight because of fear of potential Armenian nationalist ambition. Bottom line - actually very few Armenian combatents prior to 1917 in Anatolia. Sure some isolated guerilla bands - some who espoused this philosophy of provoking the Ottoman Turks to bloody retubution with the hopes of outside intervention - this is true. But the CUP and others in charge (including German military in Anatolia who do not report anything concerning any significant Armenian threat or action - just the opposite in fact) were not fooled - yet Talat & Co. were able to use the reports of the very few instances to fuel the fire of hatred - not difficult since many Ottoman Muslims were refuges from the Balkans and had witnessed the type of actions that you (and the CUP propaganda) claim were being conducted by the Armenians. Additionally the Armenians were a very convinient scapegoat for failed policies and the inability o the CUP to stem the collapse of a falling empire. They also were an oppurtunity to enrich the CUP and (in theory) provide for the war effort, provide housing for potentially rebellious refugees, sport and loot for bloodthirsty warlords and the war & these actiona offered the Turks the chance to realize Pan-Turnaic ambition and eliminate an increasingly vocal minority whose ties to outside co-religionist interests were always a potential threat to stability and Ottoman Turkish rule over their citizens & countryside. For this was (the) Genocide commited.dear thoth, this will be a partial response as i am short of time (we all seem to be pretty busy these days). i shall try to address a few points you raised in your above posting. 1. re noubar. he might of course have been exaggerating, as his stance was basically "we bled for the common cause, and therefore have a right to a place of our own". but the thing is, some of the things he said are verifiable from other contemporary sources and witnesses etc. it is true that quite a few armenians had been organising against the empire way before the war. it is true that they had a separatist agenda. it is true that they were protected, assisted, encouraged, trained, financed and even manned by the great powers, especially russia. the numbers, he might have exaggerated with the 50,000 volunteers but the 5,000 armenians in french armies (these were active around antep if i remember correctly), and the 150,000 in the russian ranks are verifiable from these countries' sources. also as i pointed out, noubar delivered his speech to those who had fought the war and knew exactly what each participant did to what extent. he could have overdramatised certain things but he could not have painted them a picture which they knew to differ too much from the reality they themselves had witnessed. so the noubar testimony, some exaggeration aside, is an accurate reflection of the facts in its broad outlines. 2. as with the later kurdish issue, legal restrictions on a nation does not necessarily impede a nation's capability. the kurds are not allowed almost anything, yet in the late 1980's and early 1990's the pkk was asking for kurdish visas on turkish passports 20 miles east of erzincan, and the visas had to be issued by the kurdish "consulate" in belgium! and the pkk was 50,000 strong at the peak of its power. they were capable of antitank and anti-aircraft operations, and brought down a few high ranking officials and statesmen. so don't underestimate a well-organised group's action capability (plus the armenians had a legal right to organise, whereas the kurds didn't. they still managed to. imagine what the armenians could have done with their legal rights!). so even if the numbers and ratios are subject to dispute, yes, i do think that the armenians had everything they needed to organise militarily in a substantial manner in the eastern provinces, and have no reason to believe that they didn't use the opportunity. and also do not forget that in guerilla warfare the ration of classical army to a guerilla army is about 1:17, i.e. it takes at least 17 soldiers of a classical army to do in one guerilla (i am flaunting here my army training as a tank officer). of course we are proud to have brought this ratio down to 1:1.5, by using counterguerrilla, but in 1915 we did not have counterguerilla capability, and were using kurds and circassians, or worse, convicts to make up for that deficiency. also, regarding "Do you think that the Ottomans could have even held the countryside in the face of such forces (with the Russians also pressing trhe attck...). Please." well, it was precisely the countryside where the ottomans had least grip, and for a greater part of the war until 1917, when the russians got out for internal reasons, the situation in the countryside was dire. it wasn't only the armenian militia, of course, the kurdish, circassian, and turkish militias all contributed to the pandemonium. re "Also - it should be noted that until 1917 (Russian Revolution & breakdown of control over the army) it was Czarist policy to ship Armenian to the Balkans to fight because of fear of potential Armenian nationalist ambition." this i didn't know. at any rate there were russian armenian volunteers both in the russian army as well as militia operating in turkey. this is a fact. the russians may have had such a policy, but then where and how did these guys come from? we keep repeating a line in turkey that some czar - i think it was alexander ii - said that he wanted an armenia next to the turkish border with no armenians in it. are you aware of this quote and if so, what do you think of it? re "Why are there no accounts whatsoever of any deportation convoys being rescued/liberated? - not a single one." this is a stong point. well, during the kurdish uprising there was a very strong kurdish militia, but still, some 2,000 villages that sheltered them were evacuated. to the best of my knowledge the pkk never undertook any operation to stop a single evacuation. they rather made sure it received as much coverage as possible in the west to popularise the issue and condemn the turk (the hardliners' line with the armenian organisations sacrificing their people to draw attention to their cause). the same could have been the case with the armenian deportations, also, it could be that they were strong enough to cause damage in the countryside, which was de-manned (males conscripted to the army and ended up in far away places) but not as strong to carry out such an operation against the ottoman army or kurdish militia. also, they might have chosen to concentrate their efforts on depopulating the countryside first and then dealing with the regular army in larger theatres. but i concede that this is a strong point in your argument, and i am not rejecting it in total. 3. i agree with the material gain and scapegoat-finding motives of the CUP, also the attitude of muslim turks - especially that of the muslim refugees from the balkans - and their being used by talat and his men. but that alone cannot fully explain it. a scapegoat must be a goat first. if the armenians had not given them the pretext, they would have had no pretext to use. the jews, just as rich, with greater connections everywhere, alike of a different religion, traditionally mistrusted, despised and disliked, with lower rates of fluency in turkish, suffered nothing similar, because they did not participate in the attempt to break up the ottoman state. 4. as i had stated in earlier postings, i do not think that pan-turkism was initially a motivating factor in the genocide. i think that they first planned they genocide (and i very, very strongly suspect the initial inspiration, and much of the planning, were german), and then they realised that such a move could also open up the way to central asia, and then it was drummed. i think so because at the time pan-turkism was a very young ideal with little or no roots in "turkish" society, which had not even yet got used to the idea of defining itself as turkish. so they could not rally up the people behind them saying that they had to get rid of the armenians to join our central asian brethren, because no-one cared. they could only rally people up by pointing the visible danger of turkey breaking up, and infidels taking over the country, and killing off the turks. this was far more relevant than the brethren in the altai mountains. but of course, when the idea of getting rid of the armenians was planted in minds, that fringe benefit was also seen. let me also point out here - for sake of accuracy and scholarly honesty - that i am perhaps in the minority with this line of thought, both among foreign scholars and probably the turkish ones as well. the foreign scholars would accept the pan-turkic theory because a) they are familiar with parallel developments from their own histories, it serves the purpose of painting a bloodthirsty image of the turks, c) it can be used endlessly against the germans for having implanted the ideas (pan-turkism was born in berlin) and d) it is partially correct. the turks would embrace that theory because a) republican ideal stressed turkish identity, if not any pan-turkic ideal (the soviets!), the CUP were the scapegoat for the disintegration of the empire (to be honest, they were largely responsible for it) in the republic, and c) turkish pride probably found it hard to stomach that we lost the empire just because of the incompetence of the CUP, maybe we had to find some grand ideal. all this said, it is not to be denied that there was a pan-turkic ideal that cost us a great deal. i may perhaps be wrong in downplaying the role played by pan-turkism, but frankly speaking, i don't see that it was a driving force strong enough to result in something like this. but perhaps i am wrong. in the above discussion - as in many other discussions about armeno-turkish relations - both parties suffer from the one-sidedness of the sources to some extent. i am familiar to a certain degree with the theses and at least the secondary sources of the turkish position, and also some western sources, you are familiar with the armenian versions of the same kinds of sources. now much of the picture that emerges from both groups of sources largely reflect the truth, or rather, several truths. of course the sources are imperfect: they are biased, exaggerate certain facts, downplay others, omit yet others, and in some cases are not above inventing things. this is understandable because both emanate from parties that fought. you can take me to many armenian families who can tell me stories i could rarely if ever hear in turkey, i can take you to turkish families who could tell you stories you would never hear from your armenian community or anywhere in armenia. if we are narrow-minded bigots, we will stick to the stories of our respective communities - which are undoubtedly to a very large extent demonstrably true -, but if we are more than that, we will cross the isthmus and examine the other's stories with a critical eye. this is why i keep disagreeing with Domino when he says that turkish sources are biased and therefore to be dismissed. no. of course they are biased, as are the armenian ones and probably most of the other ones. there were very few, if any, totally impartial observers at the scene then. if we had hindu or chinese or japanese or non-muslim, non-christian african sources relating the events, we could argue that they would be as free from bias as possible and accept their verdict. but this is not the case. most of our sources are from people who were directly involved in the conflict. therefore we must read them all. gotta dash now, cheers, [ June 20, 2002, 08:27 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:The Armenians were a diverse group.The Armenians of the Western regions of Anatolia did not expect their regions to come under Armenian sovereignity. You confuse a number of revolutionary leaders with the Armenian community leaders as a whole. There were elements of Armenians in OttomanTurkey who were comfortable with the status quo, and who were an integral part of the Ottoman economy.The Ittihadists painted all the Armenians with one brush and underttok a genocidal campaign of every Armenian irregardless of age, sex or religious belief. Only in Istambul were the women and children spared. This was probably because the Turkish leaders did not want to inflame the passions of the West by conducting such a campaign where it would be viewed by the European diplomats en masse. i largely agree, especially about the existence of a large chunk of ottoman armenians who had no truck wit the revolutionaries. the thing is that they were pacifists, and pacifists are usually not very active people. the revolutionaries, although smaller in number, were more active and thus able to create greater turmoil. the fly is small, but it makes your stomach turn, as we say in turkish. i largely agree that istanbul and a few other western provinces) were spared the massacres because they would have been too visible, but 1) armenians originally residents of the eastern provinces could come to istanbul with their families to escape the massacres, and 2) some categories of armenians (like some religious denominations and specific places in anatolia) were spared the deportations. i do not confuse the motives of the armenian leadership and those of the armenian community as a whole. obviously, the community was a very diverse group, with some opposing the empire and others supporting it, but as i said above, the rebellious faction was louder. the whole thing is not incomparable to the plight of the kurds during our 15-year long conflict, where you could be a 85-year old veteran of the independence war with your medal proudly on your chest, and your grandson could be a member of the pkk because your people cannot speak their language in the country you fought to create. the armenians had major contributions to ottoman life, thus they had in a sense, invested in it, but of course the structure of the state, especially the legislation, failed to give you an equal status with the muslims. so morally speaking it is totally understandable that an armenian who contributed more than his fair share to the empire would resent his being treated as less than a less contributing member of the empire, especially a kurd. i will continue with this, but have to dash now, cheers,
  4. quote:Originally posted by MJ:On the other hand, when one reads a little bit carefully what the Turkish hard-liners say, one case extract a great deal of confession. Is that literally what they say, Ali, or did you just paraphrase their thesis? Thanks. dear mj, of course there is a great deal of confession. the whole absurdity of turkey denying the genocide is statements to the contrary made by the contemporary turkish eyewitnesses and perpetrators abound. if you really tried to erase the memory of the genocide from turkish sources, you would have to do away with a substantial chunk of post-ottoman turkish literary figures, which you cannot do. the absence of popularly disseminated information in turkey stems from the low reading rate of the population (as distinct from the literacy rate) and also the difficulty of linguistic access to the sources from the terminal ottoman-early republican periods due to the script and language reforms. ostensibly done to increase literacy and the influx of western ideas into turkey, and also to "break away with the ottoman past (ostensibly meaning the sultans etc.)", in my opinion one of the welcome fringe benefits was that access to the records of the last few years of the empire and first few years of the republic was thus effectively eliminated. the above summary of the hardliners' position has been distilled from years of experience so does not reflect the stance of any particular person. but i think that i have reflected it reasonably accurately, and that many hardliners would subscribe to it. by the way, i am positively surprised that you say there is a great deal of truth in it. if this stance were adopted by both parties to the conflict earlier, perhaps a solution could by now have been found. i had forgotten to add a major important part to it, which i shall do as soon as possible. cheers,
  5. dear everyone, i think one stance that turkish hardliners adhere to is worth quoting here: "the armenians say that we killed them all for no reason. false. the armenian leaders made a cold-blooded calculation that if their peoples would suffer atrocities at the hands of the ottoman turks, european christians would intervene like they did in the case of greece and the balkans, and that in the ensuing melee, the armenians would get a piece of land with their help. hence, they were inclined to regard any mass casualties resulting from their terrorist actions as martyrs that had to be sacrificed for the cause. they rebelled, killed, and stabbed the turks in the back at a time of war, and then the europeans disposed of them the same way they disposed of the arabs after the loss of our arab provinces, and more recently, as the usa disposed of the kurds after they sided with them against saddam and were gassed by him. and now they are whining. if they had got something out of that, they would be whining a good deal less, since they would consider the dead as martyrs necessarily sacrificed for the liberation of armenia. so in reality they are whining about territorial and political loss rather than human loss, and all this whining is actually about getting the territories back rather than making us recognise the genocide and/or pay compensation for it. go talk to any armenian, accept the genocide and payment of retribution, and see if they stop there and not come up with land claims. if they genuinely wanted nothing but recognition and compensation, they would stop there or at most ask for the return of their immovables and a right to resettle where their ancestors had lived, respecting turkish territorial integrity and accepting to live under turkish rule with equal rights as any other turkish citizen (here the human rights record of turkey is passed over in silence). but they don't. in any discussion about the subject where the turkish side has conceded to accept the genocide and reparations, territorial claims invariably followed suit. you cannot separate one from the other, because they don't. and therefore you should never venture to accept the genocide, even if it is a fact. the day you accept it, you pave the way for territorial claims, and guess whom will the russians, europeans and americans support? muslims or christians? it all boils down to that." how would you guys respond to that? regards,
  6. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Dear Ali, Just one late comment... At its apogee, which was in 1919, the Regular Army of the Republic of Armenia has numbered about 60,000 heads. How do you see a number 205,000 being anywhere close to being realistic? Probably one can bring also few other arguments to negate the insinuation... but why? martin, i do not know the first thing about the armenian army in 1919, so i cannot do more than conjecture. here are some explanations that i can offer (none of them are strong positions that i would venture to defend, as i don't have data on the subject at my disposal): 1. i 1919, the genocide had taken place, a substantial number of armenian males liquidated or deported, so 60,000 was all that you could come up with IN 1919 in that particular area. it does not say anything about 1915 or before. 2. the 60,000 armenians in the armenian army were not the only armenian under arms. the russian army had always had good numbers of armenians in its ranks. so if push came to shove, you could probably field more than that number if the russians were on your side (which they frequently were-and are). 3. armenia has never really been a free nation, and its military capability might have been shorn by russian demands (russians, although traditionally your allies, are little more symphatetic towards you then the turks are when interests collide, and youu would agree, wouldn't you, tat there could be a clash between you and the russians over conflicts of interest in the caucasus if it weren't for the turkish - or broader speaking, muslim - threat. russians just use us as a bogey to keep you in check. if we weren't there, they could be turks to you. 4. you didn't have the money. you had more people than that, but couldn't come up with a bigger army for want of cash. 5. you had a regular army of 60,000, and a far greater militia, which had arms, would fight for the armenian cause, in line with RA demands, but wouldn't show up in official listings of the classical army. such an organisation would be a very sensitive thing to do in view of the terrain (eastern anatolia and armenia are more suitable to gureilla warfare than classical warfare), neigbours' and allies' (read: russian) demands, and cost a good deal less. this last one is especially plausible in view of te fact that irregular armies have played an increasingly important role in conflicts for the last two centuries. we lost the balkans and arabia largely to irregular armies, and saved anatolia thanks to them. the same concept was in operation recently in yugoslavia and the caucasus, to name but two theatres of war. but as i said above, these are mere conjecture and not my "position" regarding the topic, as i do not have an informed one. you may well have facts that refute them one by one. if so, i would like to know. regards,
  7. dear everyone, 1. i did not use a turkish propagandist's conjecture on the existence of 205,000 armenian soldiers, i used that of an armenian, and not any armenian, that of THE REPRESENTATIVE of the armenians an international conference after wwi (hence a more reliable source than you with your bridge to dublin and your army in georgia, sorry tb). so as they say in turkish, i am his liar. 2. boghos noubar did not deliver his address to a bunch of know-nothings, but other representatives of the countries involved in the dismemberment of the empire, whom he could not tell something they knew not to be true (military matters are carefully recorded, you cannot just make up any number and expect people to believe it). 3. the speech was delivered after the war and not before, so noubar could not have used it to bribe or blackmail the allies (so tb, i am afraid your parallel there is inaccurate). he appears to have just made the point that they had served the cause as much as everyone else, and suffered for it as much as, and actually considerable more than, most others. 4. i insist on using the noubar letter, and shall only accept criticism of it based on other documented evidence that such a force did not exist. since armenian conscripts in the russian and french armies are well documented (not by historians but the military records themselves), and it is known that armenian armed militia did exist prior to the genocide (the armenians themselves do not deny this), this is going to be a bit difficult for you, tb. you may downplay the numbers but not much else. 5. the armenians frequently claim that they could not have an army or militia because they did not have an independent state and had no rigt to carry arms under ottoman legislation. well, the kurds do not have a state and they do not have a right to carry arms (that second can of course be partly disputed), were periodically disarmed during the republic, but that did not prevent them from staging 28 rebellions in 70-odd years and forming a pkk which was 50,000 men strong at the peak of its power. they were periodically bombed, deported, disarmed, resettled, their language banned etc (there are really very few things left that didn't happen to them), but that did not prevent them to acquire some serious military capability. from the 19th century onwards, the ottoman armenians were under russian "protection" by a series of treaties, and yes, they did have the capacity to organise inside the empire through the patriarchate and other civilian institutions. they had a printing press (well before the turks), schools, societies, their youth studied abroad, frequently in countries that later took part in the dismemberment of the empire, and they did organise. and another point the armenians frequently bring up, namely the difference between ottoman and russian armenians, well, carrying the pkk example further, the pkk is organised in turkey, iraq, syria, and iran, in addition to european countries,and can infiltrate turkey from anywhere they want. so the armenian case that they did not organise militarily because they couldn't is not that strong. 6. tb says that empires do not have a right to exist. i agree. i also agree that any entity that has been formed and perpetuated by violence has no right to exist. and when we look at the word today, we see most of them gone (some, like china, are still there). by extension i understand tb also says that if you are under an empire against your will, youu have a right to rebel. i also agree. but when you rebel, you must take into account that the empire you are rebelling against is not going to sit there with its arms folded on his chest. it too is going to assert its legitimate right as a state to preserve its existence, and fight. here we come to the next point in my argument which i had been advocating since i joined this forum and which sorely has been gone amiss in the last battle of words i am afraid. here it is: 6. the armenian genocide is a fact. it is also an abomination, since a genocide by definition involes the killing of an entire group of people because they belong to the group by dint of ethnicity, religion, language etc., and not by some common act which could be considered a crime by any stretch of the imagination. the ottoman government could have considered fully legitimately that an attempt by a group of armenians to overthrow it in order to replace it with other entities constituted a crime against itself, and that it had a right to take the necessary measures to defend itself, but it should have confined these measures to the perpetrators of that crime rather than extending it to the bulk of the armenian nation, without regard to their innocence or guilt. this is what they did, and this is why it is a crime. i fear that the armenian side is falling into a trap (that one could, by a far fetched argument, even argue that was dug by turks): on the one hand their "classical" position was that the fact of the genocide ought to be divorced from the fact that some armenians took armed action against the ottoman empire, on the principle that you cannot justify the killing of innocents by the deeds of their criminal next of kin (and that therefore the turkish position that they were punished for their crimes is untenable), and then on the other hand, some armenians come forth and say that reports of armenian armed action and existence of treacherous armenian factions within the empire prior to the genocide are nonsense or greatly exaggerated, which can be demonstrated to be false, as the noubar letter itself does. there were armenian factions that plotted and acted against the empire, and the empire had sovereign rights to deal with them, violently if necessary, to preserve its existence. no empire has sovereign rights to extend the punishment of a criminal to its innocent next of kin. that, as i shall understand, is the gist of the matter in the armenian genocide. you cannot interpret a law, right, interest or whatever to pass a death sentence on an entire nation. and i am afraid that was the point we missed in the above discussions. regards,
  8. Domino, i know you don't like this, but i will keep quoting from the boghos noubar address, from the very one you posted above. boghos noubar states that armenians were enrolled at the (from our perspective) enemy ranks from the very beginning of the war (and not from the beginning of the deportations). the numbers of total armenian military enrolment boghos noubar gives in that address adds up to 205,000. now two things are particularly striking here: 1. 205,000 is a fairly large number. if we are to accept that the armenian population of the empire at the time was slightly over two million (almost a million above the official ottoman census figures of 1914), then we find that the ratio of armenians under arms to the total armenian population of the empire is about one to ten, i.e. a full 10% of the armenian population, or better said, 20% (every fifth) of all armenian males were under arms fighting the turks. if you object and say that the 150,000 were from the russian army and acted under russian military command, and can only realistically consider at most the 50,000 volunteers from within the empire itself, still you arrive at 50,000:2,000,000, which gives you 1:40 of the total population, and 1:20 of the total ottoman armenian males. so every twentieth armenian male volunteered to fight the ottomans. now the turkish population is almost 70 million strong, and our standing army is somewhere between 550,-700,000. i shall take the upper figure to please you, but still we arrive at a ratio of 1:100 for the entire turkish population, and 1:50 for the entire male turkish population. currently, one in every fifty turkish males is serving in the army (staff and non-commissioned combined). and turkey is the southeastern flank of NATO, and a country that fought a bitter civil war in the southeast for fifteen years. it is also a country with a very strong military presence in almost all spheres of life, and some 30,000 troops stationed outside its borders in an international dispute (cyprus). still, its military ratio is 1:50. yours was 1:20 at the time of the conflict, two and a half times higher than turkey today. also bear in mind that 50,000 armenians out of 2,000,000 people mean that there was at least one armenian male from every tenth armenian household in turkey, if you consider the average armenian household to be composed of 4 people (a modest estimate, if you increase it, you decrease the number of households, and increase the ratio of militant-furnishing houses to total houses. have your pick). statistically this means that there was at least one armenian from every single armenian settlement down to the last village, unless you claim that some armenian vilalges had fewer than ten households! (of course we know that in reality some regions supplied more than their fair share, some less, and some not at all). to carry numerical comparison still further: in the fifteen year long war we fought against kurdish separatists, the total death toll on both sides was 29,000 (this number was revealed immediately after the capture of öcalan, and has been revised upward several times, first hitting 30,000, and then 40,000. i take the first number for i believe it reflects the truth more closely). this war was fought with far greater armies and for a much longer time, and over a greater area: it was carried out to europe as well. it was also ever so bloody in that both parties were very seriously equipped by the superpowers of the time (the turks had tanks, helicopters and planes, the kurds, terminal guided anti-aircraft, and anti-tank missiles, for instance. both sides had machine guns with 20 rounds per second capability and 100 to 400 meters effective range. and both sides were thoroughly trained i both guerilla and classical warfare. still the death toll was 29,000). now the population of turkey in 1914 was some 17-18 million (actually probably slightly more), and after the war it aws down to 11-12 million. 6 million people, one third of the population, were gone. over two million greeks were killed/displaced/deported, and over a million and a half armenians met the same fate. this adds up to three and a half, at the most, four million. the remaining two million missing were the muslims (which includes turks, kurds, circassians, other caucasians and some arabs). now our reported military casualties in the first world war (the whole of it) were 325,000. this means that 1.7 million muslims who died were civilians. and nobody talks about a genocide of the turks (not even the turks themselves). Domino, do you realise why we get so indignant at times, even those of us like me, who recognise the armenian genocide and what it stands for? we lost a sixth- a seventh of our population at the hands of invading armies and traitors in our country, and nobody even talks about it, perhaps mainly because we do not make an international fuss about it. but isn't it a classical case of "when indians kill, it is a massacre, when whites kill, it is a victory"? to us it is. and if you are wondering how you guys managed to form such a military organisation under the ottoman empire, all you have to do is check the publications of the armenian patriarchate then and also the russian "protection" of christian minorities in turkey. you can also check today's - and any other day's - "on this day in history" whenever you check into the forum. do it & see. cheers,
  9. hagarag, i checked the site and found the following links. i cannot see any turkish news article of the said date and content. i checked every item headline that contained "turk" in it. sorry, but did i miss something?? i would appreciate if you could help. thanks in advance for help, regards,News Articles on -- Thursday, 13 June 2002 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Georgian churches in Turkey doomed to destruction AAA: Detroit-Area Activists Host Assembly Membership Forum Celebrate with Young Artists; Mahler's Fifth is on the house 50 Held in European Offshoot of Bank of New York Investigation ARU Urges Parliament & Prez to Take Steps to Defend Country's Image Visit of the NKR Minister of Foreign Affairs to the USA Karagyozian Memorial Has Implemented Charity Programs for Children Smuggled Marble Icon of great Cultural Value Returned to Armenia Gyumri's Gohar Choir and Symphony Performs Internationally France has changed its OSCE Minsk Group co-chairman Czech police break up gang smuggling Armenians into EU countries ANKARA: Union Leader Opposes EU Membership Involving Pol. Conditions San Fran: 'I, Witness' Sydney: Boxing: Fenech unleashes 'raging bull' PRAGUE: Police breaks up gang smuggling Armenians UK Bradford: 'Support industrial cities' urges peer ANKARA: Turkey, Armenia forming ties, step by step Women's Chess GDP Growth in Armenia Was 9.3% in January-April of 2002 Armenia Thinks Realization of Concrete Anti-Terror Steps a Must Eine Kleine launches summer series PanArmenian News - 06/13/2002 PanArmenian News - 06/12/2002 ARKA News Agency - 06/13/2002 ARKA News Agency - 06/12/2002 RFE/RL Georgia/Russia: Naturalization Issue Further Strains Rel'ns GT: Demands for President Kocharian's impeachment in Armenia Down with motherhood? AZG Armenian Daily #110 - 14/06/2002 PH Armenia Connectivity Meets with Armenian Network in Boston and DC Libaridian again in Baku 1105 Diaspora-Armenians study in Armenia RFE/RL Armenia Report - 06/13/2002 Hayastan fund says to continue nation-devoted projects Yerevan Opera & Ballet House to see a major repair Mcconnell Underscores Importance of Opening Armenia-Turkey Borders Kocharian Receives Representatives of Youth and Students Orgs The Government Raises Probability to Hold a Special Session President meets the youth and students Kocharian, Margaryan provide Armenian Youth Fund "spiritual support" Armenian DM meets with newly appointed French co-chair of OSCE MG Caucasus Reporting Service No. 133 - 06/13/2002 Training and Scholarships in Armenia Armenian Mirror Spectator On-Line - 06/13/2002 Calendar of Events - 06/13/2002 Four Armenians Win "Internet Grand Prize" on Game "What Where When?" Hearing of "Meltex" Ltd's Appeal to be Held Tomorrow Armenian Teachers Win Contest "My Language is Your Friend" Libaridian Discusses Artsax Problem in Baku Chinese Official Arrives in Georgia on Four-Day Visit Influential Armenian Businessman Dies in Car Crash My Armenian Dinner ANKARA: Transport and geopolitics in the South Caucasus BHC: Neri Terzieva: "Interethnic 'bartering' is impossible" BHC: How long will we keep forgetting about the Armenians? RFE/RL Newsline - 06/13/2002 ANTELIAS: Assembly; Concluding session ANTELIAS: HH Aram I and the Assembly delegation visit Lebanese Prez. India, Russia & Iran To Iron Out Operational Issues [ June 18, 2002, 07:16 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  10. quote:Originally posted by Domino:"Thoth, I do not question Armenian activities here. Ali asked me about Nubar, now the only reason that someone will ask to read Nubar adress concerning Armenian activities is for apologistic reasons." ????????????????????????????????????????????????? "I am not saying Ali is denying the genocide, I am saying that he is an apologist, all apologists are not denier." i am getting bored with this. how many times should i say that there is no apology for the murder of one million innocent people? "How should I answer, when someone ask me to read foreign reports during the 19 centuries, when these revolts that are described have been eradicated by Abdul Hamid iron hands ?" in a conflict you read both sides to get an impartial view. and if the facts are obvious, no amount of reading will change the final verdict, don't you worry. no amount of german sources for instance will changethe fact of the holocaust. "Now about Karabekir, for me this man is an Himmler, and reading him about Armenian said "revolution" would be the same thing s reading Himmler memoirs about a said Jewish revolution, that he was forced to take self-defense mesures. If you think there is something to be understood from Karabekir memoirs, then the same could be said about people such as Himmler." in fact many things could be understood from the himmler memoirs (if they exist), at least the guy's mind. "I could be unjustfly hard with Ali, but what angers me from his part, is the comparaison of Ottoman monument destruction with the deletion of Armenians presence from the region." to me both are destruction with the aim of eradicating a past in mind. the destruction of the ottoman stuff is admittedly more comparable to stalin's destruction of russian cathedrals or mao's cultural revolution than to te destruction of the armenian monuments in turkey, but in both cases, intentional destruction is intentional destruction. and you are not the only people with grievances. [ June 18, 2002, 09:32 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  11. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:See Groong today re: Turkish News article of 4/10/02. Read the whole article. These guys want us to disappear. They claim that Russians placed us in Armenia to create a barrier between Turks and Central Asian Turks. And we are supposed to open a dialogue with these surreal bastards? hagarag, i would appreciate if you gave the internet address of the said site so that i can check it (i am not technologically advanced). a word of note: imbecility is not a crime under turkish penal code, and democracy means you can talk. if you have garbage in your brain, garbage will come out of your mouth. i think we are facing such a GIGO case. i had not heard even the MHP mention something like that! ps to arine: your attitude is very similar to these guys' attitude toward the armenians. hint, hint. cheers,
  12. Domino, this is getting out of hand. remember that i have not denied the genocide and ittihad culpability, so i have no interest in resorting to denialists' techniques. what i am saying is that you cannot take into account only reports that support your arguments and ignore other that don't. if karabekir was the man who fought armenian forces 1919-1922, and then written a book titled "our independence war", you cannot afford to ignore it, even if you hate his guts and think he's lying through his teeth. i agree with what you say about german sources being compiled for military intelligence reflecting what the compilers observed. these sources also talk about the actions of german officers, don't they? and there are many other sources from way back talking about armenian separatist activity that dated way back into the 19th century. as some of these sources are (i gather) armenian, you can hardly accuse them of being on the turkish side! also please refer to the boghos noubar address to the great powers after the war, where he states explicitly that the armenians had been on the side of the invading forces since the beginning of the war. a copy of this speech had appeared in this forum not so long ago. was he also a turkish agent? Domino, the problem is simply this: there are facts that are unpalatable to both sides (and probably more than both sides). while i came to this forum and accepted those that are unpalatable to our nation, i find the armenian side a bit fett-dragging in accepting those that will undoubtedly be unpalatable to them. i know that nothing will diminish turkish culpability in the genocide (and therefore i am not exerting effort on such futile pursuits), but some facts will put some (additional) blame on others, and i regret to inform you that some armenian leaders, the church, and some others, together with the germans and russians, are included in this list. and ignoring evidence that you don't like won't make it go away. we ignored the armenian genocide for almost ninety years now, did it go away? and as far as my comparison of the fate of ottoman and armenian remains go, i stick to my opinion in general terms. you may know more about the destruction of armenian stuff, but may i humbly point out that i probably know more about the destruction of ottoman stuff. regards,
  13. dear Domino, dear steve 1. i am aware of the deliberate destruction done to armenian, greek and other stuff. i myself saw greek churches in western turkey (mudanya and elsewhere) in shameful condition. this is of course not going to be an apology, but much ottoman stuff was also deliberately destroyed during the republican era, especially the one party rule (1923-1950). you can see a lot of buildings in istanbul where the ottoman inscriptions were destroyed and replaced with latin script ones. also, even though not political in nature, there has been a wave of destruction of provincial ottoman and seljukid stuff, especially derelict buildings that fell out of use. these were hacked to bits and the bits were sold to antiquarians, collectors, architects, interior decorators etc. you can still see muslim tombstones used as bartenders' platform etc., a most disgusting sight. even though that latter destruction is not deliberate, the net result is the same. 2. re sources: you may say that karabekir is not reliable. you may be right. i may say that the armenian or oter western sources of the time are not reliable. i may be right, too. these people were not impartial observers but parties to a conflict and by definition cannot - and cannot be expected to - be impartial. you should not read karabekir with a view to believing what he says. and in fact, if you don't read him together with the memoirs of his opponents, you will almost certainly get a most distorted and incomplete picture. the same goes for the sources of his opponents. that's what i was trying to say. cheers,
  14. Domino, 1. none of the sources, including german and austrian ones, can automatically be considered impartial. that does not necessarily mean they are not correct. they may in fact describe the events as they saw them very accurately. the points are 1) that they may have seen only one side of the events (and no event is one-sided), and 2) being austrian or german instead of british or french may not necessarily make one impartial against the turks: the german/austrian is still a christian, as are the armenians, and the turk muslim, and 3) many observers also relied on eyewitness/survivor accounts the problem of reliability with such sources being obvious. 2. most ottoman monuments were destroyed precisely for the same reason the armenian monuments were: to erase the memory of the past. and then, in the 20th century, turks were made to hurl insults at their ottoman ancestors for three generations, and an attempt to learn and teach old turkish (pre-1929 alphabet and language) could be a criminal offense if it were conducted outside the university. cheers
  15. hi everyone last night i found dr. rıza nur's letter to kazım karabekir and karabekir's reply to it. nur indeed proposes that ani be destroyed, which karabekir rejects on the following grounds: 1. ani ruins are vast, like the walls of istanbul, and even if they were destroyed - which in itself is no mean feat - they would still remain as ruins on the same spot. 2. the destruction of ani ruins would be more likely to stir up sentimen amongst the armenian religious community than to quench it. the tone of his reply to nur's suggestion read as dismissive in the original memoirs. the material is found between pages 960-970 (i think the reply was on page 969) in the original edition. by the way, the original edition was from türkiye yayınevi and not nebioğlu yayınevi. apologies. the second edition (1988) that i have is from merk yayınevi. its language is simplified (documents are left in the original language), headings are given to "chapters", and it contains biographies of prominent persons of the period, but there still is no index. but still, i would consult the original edition. cheers,
  16. one more thing: about this trace wiping off business: there is still a good number of armenian monuments here and there (even though they are usually - not always- labelled under different names) and some of them (especially akhtamar) seem to be in quite good shape (better shape than some seljuk monuments nearby, actually). if there really was such a policy, how come they are still standing? cheers,
  17. is anyone familiar with the memoirs of rıza nur (again, the original version). dr. rıza nur had to flee turkey for having insulted ataturk (or something like that), and as far as i know he published his memoirs there. i have not read them, so cannot judge, but we have been talking about this letter business in dadrian, and the thing does not appear to be in the original edition of karabekir. does anyone know whether dr. rıza nur makes a reference to it in his memoirs or other stuff? cheers,
  18. i forgot to add: the first edition has no index, so you have to plough through the thousand-odd pages to find what you are looking for if it is not mentioned in the table of contents. cheers,
  19. ok guys last night i checked the entire table of contents of the first edition of karabekir's istiklal harbimiz. first: there is no letter by dr. rıza nur relating to ani or anything else. his name simply doesn't appear in the table of contents. second: there are references to ani ruins and its significance to the armenians, by a letter from an armenian commander, and that these lands should be ceded to armenia on these grounds, which karabekir flatly refuses. meanwhile, i strongly suggest that the armenian side read these memoirs - in the original of course - there is much that they will find a bit hard to stomach, but it is a very thought-provoking and informative reading. and i repeat if dadrian used the second edition instead of the first without giving adequate explanation for this choice of editions (or simple oversight) then this is a very serious blow to his reputation as a historian in my opinion and i stick to it. cheers,
  20. dear steve, i checked my copy of karabekir (printed 1959-1960, nebioğlu yayınevi copy no 661) this lunch break (i live walking distance from work). there is something completely different on page 905 and i have to go through the entire volume. well, almost, as the thing is more or less in chronological order. as i have said i have not read the thing in its entirety yet, but it would be a very thought-provoking read for anyone interested in that segment of history, tuk and non-turk alike. his memoirs were kept in his family after he passed away in 194?, and they waited for a decent moment to publish them (by then ataturk was dead, inönü was voted out of office for ten years, and the centre-right democrat party was living its most corrupt days). to me the memoirs have so far shown no trace of "editing": there appears to be mention of everything that he encountered, obviously from the perspective of a turkish soldier who took part in the struggle, andit has the drab, matter-of-fact style of a soldier, down to a turkish that needs some editing and a horrible orthography (karabekir was known to have opposed the script reform). also, i must admit that i am more than a bit disappointed with dadrian if he really used anything other than the original edition. it is a matter of course that in scholarly works you use original editions of your primary sources and not later ones, unless these later editions have some merit that the first ones do not contain. in such a controversial subject as the one we are discussing, i cannot accept anything other than information derived from original sources. cheers,
  21. Domino, i forgot to give you the e-mail: aurguplu@yahoo.com thanks in advance, yours, ali suat
  22. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Steve, Has his memoire not been published after his death ? And after 1920 ? Everything after that for me is not credible. You are right Dadrian quote him, but Dadrian also quote Kutay, when he question his references concerning the so-called Talaat memoirs. No ? Domino, if you are referring to cemal kutay, please note that he is generally not regarded as a serious historian by anyone, turk or non-turk alike. since i am posting this from the office, i do not have my references with me, but i will look up the karabekir stuff. as for karabekir's memoirs not containing anything about the genocide, there is plenty of stuff regarding mutual killings (and remember that karabekir was stationed elsewhere during the genocide in 1915-1916, so he could not have taken an active part in it. now as i had stated earlier, there are references to "the plight of the armenians" in relative abundance in literary works, memoirs etc. of the earlier republican period, so i still keep wondering what the scale of the destruction of records re the genocide was. after all, a man no less than falih rıfkı atay (sort of court biographer of ataturk) made references to what was happening to the armenians in his novel zeytindağı (mount of olives), where he mentions an ottoman ***** telling him that they were recruiting convicts from prisons for "that job" (what the job is is never explicitly mentioned, but it would have been taken for granted by the readers of the time). i think that they were more concerned with erasing records referring to the ties of specific persons to specific war crimes, but i wonder whether they were trying to erase the record of genocide per se. after all, virtually the totality of anatolia was subject to the deportations, and the entire nation saw the armenians go and not come back. how can you erase this? as for your hatred of ataturk, it may be a bit futile to engage in this much further, as i can understand your opinion of him is set, but i fear my message of him having inherited a situation as opposed to creating one has been missed. i will check the karabekir memoirs for the p. 905 reference, and yes, i woud be pleased if you could send me the dardrian stuff in pdf format (at the moment i am getting prepared for marriage and have to count my pennies). cheers,
  23. Domino, i was not expecting this to turn into an attack and defense of ataturk, but as i can see our opinions regarding ataturk differ strongly. allow me to voice my objections: first, as stated before, mustafa kemal had inherited a situation and not created one. second, the war against the armenians in the east was fought mainly by kazım karabekir, and to call it ataturk's minion shows - apologies - that you perhaps need to read a little bit more on kazım karabekir and mustafa kemal (Domino i don't intend to offend). now this reading business is important, especially for those of you who can read turkish, because you will - just like the turks - fall into the trap of believing that the "istiklal harbimiz" of kazım karabekir that you buy at any shop in turkey is what he really wrote. well, it isn't, actually. you have to get your hands on the first edition, which was collected from circulation soon after it was published, and the sanitized version appeared a good deal later. i had first bought the second edition (which has the same dimensions, format, and cover, and only a tiny note somewhere thta it is the second edition), and had only read a few pages before i could get a copy of the first edition, and my second edition copy is in a box waiting to be sold now. the bad news concerning the first edition is that the language is the old style, orthography and punctuation are not amongst his strongest points, nor is -apparently - grammar, bt it is obviously a most candid portrayal of what transpired as he saw and understood it. by the way, the armenians mostly appear within the russian context. i think it would be a very sobering - if not agreeable - reading for both turks and armenians, but BEWARE guys, the first edition. another point about the first edition is that it is kind of difficult to get hold of and the damn thing is a collector's item now with a pretty massive (for me at least) price tag at over USD 100. and then you have to make sure that all the thousand odd pages are actually there (they aren't always). i haven't finished reading istiklal harbimiz, but the impression that i got from the passages that i read is that the armenians appear as a very belligerent lot and almost constantly in military connection with russia and secondarily with the western powers. i do not want to hurt armenian national pride, but the prevailing turkish attitude has always been that the real enemies were the great powers and russia, with the armenians only being used as a tool. many of the heroes of the independence war are known for having expressed privately their sorrow for what happened to the hapless common folk, but they were also quick to point out that the blame largely fell to their leaders who lead them to disaster with their short-sighed and unrealisable policies. of course one could ask whether there was no way to separate wheat from chaff, but one must not forget that we could ask that qustion today, as we are sitting in our armcahirs in the security of our respective lands with internationally recognised borders and no imminent threat to our very existence in sight. the situation then was rather different, and a lot of rough justice was inevitably done. as for you hating ataturk more than talat, i again think you have to raed a bit more about him. this is the man who said of the fallen in gallipoli "mothers of children who fell here, don't cry, for they are now sleeping in the bosom of a friendly nation", and this is the man who had lifted the greek flag that was put underneath his feet to be trampled upon by him as he entered izmir victoriously, saying that "the flag is the honour of a nation, you do not have the right to trample upon it". i had heard from an istanbul armenian whose family was originally from tokat, that one morning the entire armenian community of some squalid tokat village they came from was summoned by the muhtar who said to them "tomorrow morning i shall not see any one of you here". so the entire community packs and boards a train to istanbul where they have relatives. at the interim stop in ankara, ataturk sees them at the train station and understands from their condition that all was not well with them, so he asks what is going on. they relate the story, upon which ataturk tells them "go back to your village, and tell that guy that if he molests you again i shall personally nail him from his ears onto the door of his office". also do not forget that he is reported in a los angeles times issue of 1926 - in an interview with a swiss reporter - to have said that "these remnants of the union and progress patry should be made accountable for the millions of lives of our christian citizens". Domino, as i have said, i can understand and symphatise with your hatred of turks in general and some turks in particular (though i must hasten to add that hate is not a healthy feeling, and will ultimately hurt you), but don't you think that you should know mustafa kemal a bit better before passing judgement on him? i think that your hate of him - in your words even greater than your hate of talat ***** - is misplaced. i can understand that we both, being parties by dint of heredity to this troubled past, can frequently find it rather difficult to separate our personal feelings from the cold truth before us, but it is the one thing we must do, for only by approaching the problem in this manner are we going to be able to solve the problem. more on this - and other points - later, i gotta get back to work now. cheers,
  24. dear thoth, here is a hasty and partial reply to one of the points you raised: i doubt very much that ataturk seriously had a pan-turanian ideal, he was too much of a realist for that. the reason why he said turkey for the turks was that at the end of the empire it was quite clear that the TURKISH component of the empire was under attack from the west (exposed crystal clear by the infamous sevres treaty). by then, the notion that non-turks (even other muslims) could not be trusted anymore was no longer the product of some xenophobic imagination but observable (and observed) reality. the arabs had rebelled following a welshman (lawrence), the kurds had started with their independence movement (though these were also heavily mixed with islamic aspirations), and the local greeks had fought on the side of the invading greek force in 1919-1922. so could you trust them if you were a turk? he used the cruel but effective method of population exchanges, the greeks of turkey and the turks of greece were exchanged. cruel but effective, and in the final analysis, kind: no-one died. and at the end, turkey ended up with a population well over 80% kurdish, most of the remainder being a pacific arab minority and a rebellious kurdish minority. the empire was gone, the caliphate was gone, ataturk at any rate was a westerniser with open contempt for things religious (though his contempt for religion itself was obviously more tacit) and he had to build a country from scratch, for this you first have to find somethingto glue the nation together. as ottomanism, islam, socialism (the CUP were socialists of sorts) had all failed, and the only visible thing on the ground was turkish nationalism (after all, this was the only thing the vast majority of the population had in common) what else in your opinion could he use? allow me to add one observation that i made about turkey that western educated people find a bit hard to understand: in the west, you have had pronounced political identities for quite some time. people embraced ideas and not people. there were relatively well educated populations, the principles and foundations of the states were reasonably well laid out, and people tended to follow them to varying degrees. not so with turkey. when you look at the last century of the empire, especially the last decades, you see quite clearly that people who proclaimed themselves adherents of this or that political idea had in fact very little sound knowledge of the ideas they said - and thought - they were embracing. these people typically took some of the more salient features of various western ideological currents, and pretty much ignored the rest. i hope i am not straying from the subject, but i am a historical linguist by training, and an avid reader of the world's classics (though i have not raed them all yet: this is a lifetime project). islam ceased to be an intellectually productive civilisation at about the time the ottomans came on the scene (they don't have to do anything with it, the thing just got ossified) and the ottomans were in a sense the romans of islam: very effective soldiers, brilliant organisers, and no innovators: no ottoman philosopy, no ottoman science, no original ottoman literature etc. by the 19th century ottoman intellectual life was a desert, and it was getting pretty obvious that a return to the glorious islamic past was no solution. so we turned to the west. but we took the mechanical achievements of the west (military technology, the exact sciences etc.) and paid scant attention to the deeper philosopical undrecurrents that made the west the west. throughout the ottoman period, there was a great dearth of the translation of the western classics for instance (and imagine that there was practically no printing activity prior to the 1870s). learning foreign languages, unless they were arabic or persian, was never the turks's forte or inclination, and consequently you had a largely monolingual elite with only very partial and heavily censored access to western ideas. these people could not have absorbed various western ideologies and grasped their principles thoroughly. and indeed, they hadn't. so it is pretty dangerous from the point of accuracy to use the suffix -ist within the turkish context. instead, when you look at the problems they faced and the "solutions" they came up with, you see a very strong ad hoc component there: "this failed, let's try that. oh sh*t, we are in a fine mess, c'mon let's get out of it as soon as we can. we cannot have the luxury to make long-term plans, let's save the day (and our face)" and you see this pervasive ad hoc dominated and unprincipled approach to any problem, not only the major things like the armenian question, but minor affairs like the everyday running of some state department. this is one of the main reasons why i oppose expanations such as the young turks planned the genocide way before, and that the war served as a cover. the war may indeed have served as a cover, but for god's sake, enver sent 90,000 troops to sarıkamış in the dead of the winter in summer clothing! and this is the minister of war of the ottoman empire! as we say in turkish, he was so maladroit that he could not guide two geese to the water and come back with both of them! what could this guy plan in advance? frankly, even though the above might be an exaggeration, the fact that they were not particularly good planners stands from their record. and i despise these guys so much that i cannot bear the though of them being given credit for abilities they decidedly did not possess, such as planning. they sank the six centuries old empire in six years, a**eholes! what was the point of getting into wwi? sorry i got heated up a bit, an in the excitement of the moment, some of my assertions might have been slightly exaggerated and a bit wanting in accuracy. but the gist of my position, i hope, is clear. i'll address your other points later on, with a cooler head. take care friend,
  25. dear thoth, i was a bit busy lately, here is the reply: in general i agree with most of what you have said. my major points of disagreement are: 1. the position of ataturk. most armenians maintain that the CUP started the "cleanup" of armenians, and mustafa kemal and his forces finished it off, with the implication (so i gather) that the whole thing was a premeditated plan. i beg to differ. please understand as i start (i guess that's clear by now) that i am neither a denialist nor an apologist, but someone who coldly pursues the truth. first of all, there was tremendous dissent within the CUP on a great many issues, including, but not confined to, the handling of the various minority demands and problems. second, the CUP was not a uniform body in itself, and as many impartial (not turkish) historians asserted, the genocide was premeditated, planned, and executed by a secret inner clique within the CUP, without the majority of the CUP members' knowing and/or consent. my knowledge of the workings of the nazi party is limited, but my impression is that from its ascent to power all the way to the actual holocaust there was little doubt about the motives and activities of the nazis within the party, germany and abroad. it was simply common knowledge that one of the raisons d'etre of the nazis was to get rid of the jews for good, and it must have been obvious to all but polyanne that their "transfer" to some homeland in the east was a mere figleaf. this was not the case with the cup. i doubt most sincerely that they had the idea of exterminating the armenians at the outset (back in 1909) when they took power. it seems to me that at that time they were still thinking that some aspects of the multiethnic empire could be saved. it appears to me that disturbances caused by some armenian factions - which although at that time did not represent the majority of armenians in any way, were growing in both numbers and effects - made them to take that sort of desperate decision, and once the decision was taken, the material gain to be gained from such an operation must have been obvious to them. but i doubt that the plan to exterminate the armenians had its roots much before our entry into the war, and i had also expressed my conviction - which most forum members agree with as far as i understand - that it was most likely the germans who had instilled the idea in cup minds. now as far as ataturk is concerned, 1) he was never an actual member of the cup, although he was following them very closely, and 2) he was busy in gallipoli when the genocide was taking place. i had listened to a conference two years ago in turkish tv where some professor (or was it someone else?) maintained that one of the main reasons why mustafa kemal was chosen to lead the independence movement was that he was not tainted with war crimes in anatolia (we know what the were, don't we?). to me this sounds not like mere propaganda but actual historical fact, for it is becoming increasingly well-known that he conducted the independence campaign with the knowledge and consent of both the palace and the british, and a former war criminal was unlikely to get such consent, especially from the british. we must also be careful to istinguish between the genocide in 1915 and the further ethnic cleansing that took place in the independence war 1919-1922: in 1915, an entire nation, by then largely composed of defenceless women, children and the elderly, were treacherously concentrated, marched, put into conditions that would obviously result in their deaths, and in a number of cases, were killed outright. in 1919-1922, the turkish army, having had lost the great war and with it practically the empire, was fighting armed militia within anatolia, of which armed armenian groups also formed a part. many of the atrocities committed by the armenians that the turkish side publicises ever so often date from this period. i hope we are agreed that atrocities are atrocities no matter who commits them, just as i agree that the armenians did have a moral right to defend themselves against the incoming turkish army after what had transpired in 1915, but we must understand that while the situation in 1915 was largely as a result of the perpetrators' own doing, that in 1919-1922 was a situation that the kemalist forces had inherited. if my elder brother kills your whole family without my knowledge and consent, i can understand your indignation and desire to kill my whole family (blood feud), but that does not mean that i will not defend myself. his is what i understand of the episode in a nutshell. as far as the argument that the turks wee planning to establish a purely turkic state and eventually reunite with the central asian turks, enver and talat (especially enver) had such ideas, but apparently as a last resort now that the empire had failed, and not ideas cherished from early youth as frequently claimed (i may be wrong on that). but one thing is certain, mustafa kemal certainly had a very dim view of such ideas, and made no secret of that fact during his lifetime, and was wise enough to stick to those borders he secured during the independence war once peace was established. after the war, he was one of those who had condemned the cup for their deeds (the 1926 interview with the swiss reporter). i am not a kemalist in many respects, but let's give god's right to god, and caesar's right to caesar. more later, cheers
×
×
  • Create New...