Jump to content

aurguplu

Members
  • Posts

    623
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by aurguplu

  1. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:Dear Ali This question does intrigue me and have not had satisfying answer. Present Turks in Turkey look very much western in their features. Originally they looked more like Turkic tribes at present Turkmenistan. It is logical to deduce that present Turks have predominantly native population’s genes i.e. Armenians, Assyrians, Kurds, Greeks, Lezgi and so forth; My question is this, why do most Turks identify themselves as Turks when they carry perhaps five percent of their original blood line? If as an Armenian I knew I had all these mixed genes in me then I would have showed greater respect and tolerance to local inhibiters.Don't get me wrong, I am not after putting the Turks down but just curious. dear rubo, hagarag is basically right. being a turk is a cultural thing. if you speak turkish, are muslim (there may be exceptions to this), eat dolma, köfte, döner kebap, baklava, drink çay, türk kahvesi, rakı and ayran (there may not be exceptions to these save perhaps for rakı since it is alcoholic), enjoy making keyif with your friends under the shade of a plane tree, play tavla, constantly complain about the government, enjoy ottoman architecture, iznik tiles, ottoman calligraphy, have a love-hate relationship with the greeks, are confused about whether you are european or not, ignore traffic lights, beat people who stop at red lights, support fenerbahçe, galatasaray, or beşiktaş (and now trabzon), unload an entire cartridge of 0.65 calibre bullets in the air in a residential area when your team wins or your brother/sister/son/daughter/nephew/niece gets married, buy a stock and then ask a research guy about what you've just bought, are constantly looking for a shortcut to big cash and early retirement, respect women, beat them, worship your mother and grandmother, have a swearword vocabulary that is constructed around fifty different versions of xxxx your mother/wife/sister and all female lineage seven generations back and don't see a contradiction there, are deeply xenophobic but would not allow a foreigner in turkey pay his own meal on grounds of hospitality, think that all european women are potential whores and come to turkey only to sleep with those dark hairy guys (of whom you are one), want to date girls but don't allow your sister to date a boy because of naamuuus (honouuuur) and therefore can't date anyone actually because all sisters have brothers who do the same and still don't get the message, carry a stick in your car to beat that young lad fifty meters away because you are sure that he looked at your daughter through the screened (black) windshield, have one thick black eyebrow running across your forehead, two black eyes, a nose the shape and probably the size of a potato, and a HUGE moustache (if you are a man), have fake blonde hair, black eyebrows and dark skin (if you are a woman), spend a ton of money on your outward looks and almost nothing on your brains (turks don't read much), etc. etc. then chances are that you are a turk even if your ancestors came from patagonia. see?
  2. i forgot to add to the above post the following: of course, all of the above put together does not mean to say that what transpired was not a genocide. to me the issue is clear: armenians in turkey 1915: 1,295,000 (official ottoman figures) armenians in turkey 1927: ca. 300,000 (official turkish republic census result) (i rounded up the figure as i cannot remember the exact figure off the top of my head). armenians in turkey 2000: about 40,000-65,000. it is crystal clear. what is not crystal clear is the whys, wherefores, hows and whos. it is this that should be our discussion point, not whether it took place or not.
  3. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Ali, The genocide was made mainly because of territorioal problems and so many people were killed. Today the well known fact is officially denied by your state again because of some probable land claims from Armenian side. What i don't understand is that according to you most turks have the agreement upon the genocide (they accept that fact) but on the other hand it is still being denied by the state (!) very actively. Genocide recognition has nothing to do with land claims though and I as i understand it is denied OFFICIALLY because there may be some problems regarding the land in the future(as you think). So, trivially speaking, you say no, there was no massacre knowing the opposite at the same time.And you say that not only to us but also to the whole world. Clarify me this, please, if I am mistaken. Vahan vahan you have slightly misunderstood me. what neither the turkish population nor the turkish state denies are the KILLINGS. they then set out to relate how te whole thing was mutual, i.e. both peoples killed eachother, and that the turks acted in self-defense (which is actually true in a number of cases). what they deny is that there was a PREMEDITATED PLAN to exterminate the armenian nation as a whole (=GENOCIDE) that the state had worked out perhaps even before the beginning of wwi (this is the armenian position). you cannot blame the people for believing this for the following reasons: i) they people themselves had no plan to kill the armenians off, whether guilty or innocent, ii) you cannot of course expect the state to inform the public that they had such a plan (if they had one), iii) the deportations and killings were not applied to all districts and all types of armenians, and some armenians who were "mistakenly" deported were then sent back to where they came from and survived the war, iv) the turkish state had cited the russian threat and armenian treachery in the border provinces as a reason for the deportations, both of which were actual facts that were painfully experienced by the turkish people living in the region and carried out some revenge killing, v) the armenians did not and do not help their cause for genocide recognition by refusing to separate it from territorial claims. as far as we can see it is clear that the armenians are using the genocide issue to get a chunk of eastern anatolia and unite it with armenia (= they would not be content to live as first-class citizens in a civilised, prosperous turkey if there were one: the land MUST be taken away from turkey and given to armenia no matter what). vi) it is common knowledge which mj (if i am not mistaken) had also acknowledged in this forum that the armenian revolutionaries had made a cold-blooded calculation that if the turks were incited to kill the christian armenians, the christian west would move to intervene and give a chunk of eastern anatolia to the armenians (=necessary sacrifices must be made for our fatherland, the end justifies the means type of thought), vii) we rarely if ever see the germans blamed side-by-side with us, when it is known fact that they had practically organised the whole thing (the germans recently released the documenation on that and do not deny their involvement). if we are to be fried, let them be fried with us. viii) as i have stated above, there are documents sitting in foreign countries' archives which pertain to the question and which are waiting to be published. when this is done, we are going to have a much different picture of the whole issue. i have to rush now, but i hope this clarifies a bit. cheers,
  4. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Dear Ali, First of all, unfortunately, I do not have time to go back and read everything everyone wrote. Secondly, I don't see where you got your claim that Armenians (financially) support PKK. Thirdly I don't think you understood what I meant by "academic genocide". Allow me to explain. Next time you pick up a book about Turkey, check the index to see how often the Armenians are mentioned and read what is said about them. The same works with (European) encyclopedias: check how many entries are dedicated to people or products of Turkish descent and how many of Armenian. Also compare the entries under Turkey and Armenia and see what it says. You're still not convinced? Pick up any random travel book about Turkey and do the same (actually the more commercial and widespread the guide, the more chance you have of finding clear examples of Academic Genocide). Allow me to reiterate that I do not speak of Genocide Denial or minimization. I speak of Armenian cultural contributions that are very clearly minimized and/or blatantly omitted. I'd like to know how you feel about this. Nairi nairi, o.k. i get it. the thing is i prefer a very narrow definition of the term "genocide" which is killing off a group because they are that group. the wider definitions of genocide and applying the term "genocide" to other types of annihilation have in my view the effect of watering the term down. i prefer to keep my terms clear and unambiguous. i understand the point re turkish academic writing. i resent that, too. but bear in mind that turkey is not yet - and has never been - a free state, and during the kemalist era we were concentrating on creating our national myth. all nations do this at various times in their histories, and then they grow out of it. to the best of my knowledge there are NO sources in turkish that talk about the armenian cultural presence in turkey, and since the ver subject was taboo, you couldn't really go around asking "why". (for your info, redgate's book on the armenians is being translated into turkish now). of course the state wanted to erase armenian cultural presence as much as it could (though leaving some conspicuous landmarks such as ani and aghtamar in place), this was part of the turkification plan of anatolia put in place in the 1920s. things have changed in the meantime, and this heritage, deliberately ignored but not totally destroyed, is coming to the fore now. as for myself, i hate the whole thing, and as should be clear by now, i tend to use foreign sources concerning the pre-turkish history of anatolia. re the pkk: it is common knowledge, the pkk openly talked about it, there have been joint pkk-asala operations against turkish targets, and i myself had witnessed armenians donating cash to the pkk on various occasions in western europe (and waving the cheques in front of my nose). cheers,
  5. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Dear Ali, Just because a few of our revolutionaries (just like the few Grey Wolves among Turks) resumed their separatists agendas beginning of last century, still should not have given the Young Turks the right to exterminate us ALL and worse, to pass on the denial policy throughout four generations of Turks until now. Although I agree with some of what you say, I regret that you fail to mention that the way your government has treated us and continues to treat us presently is beyond horrible. You even go as far as to justify the Genocide, the rape and barbaric murder of hundreds of thousands of innocent women, children and fetuses. None of our revolutionaries and none of the treaties should withhold your sincere sympathies towards our innocent victims whose bones still lay scattered, without proper burial, in different parts of Eastern Turkey. What angers me as well in your reply is that you fail to mention why present-day Turkey persists in its academic denial of Armenian existence. Denying and justifying the Genocide is one thing. Going as far as to eradicate our existence at an academic level is a whole other. And finally, Turkey HAS the power and uses it very cleverly to divide and rule us. If it didn't, it wouldn't spend billions of dollars a year to counter Genocide "allegations" and Armenian history and existence in general in academic institutions, media and the political arena. Nairi dear nairi, i have lost count of how many times i have said in this forum that nothing justifies genocide, and still can't get my message across. i am at a loss as to how any one of my words could be taken to mean that i justify the genocide and see it as a right under any circumstances. i merely point out that under certain conditions it does happen, just as rape and murder and plunder happen under certain conditions. these are explanations, not justifications. if you look at the social and economic history of germany between the two wars, you can see how events developed in such a manner that it was something not at all unexpected that hitler rose to power and went on slaughtering the jews. the hstorical record gives you enough clues to come to the conclusion that something like this was imminent. but no one in his right mind would ever use this as a justification. justification means just that: maintaining that what happened was right. so the young turks or anyone else had no right to kill allthese innocent people and i have never said they had. they committed one of the greatest crimes of history. i did not touch the academic denial of the genocide in turkey today for three reasons: i) i couldn't see you bring up the issue, 2) the reasons are obvious, and i had discussed them over and over again in numerous postings (look under "genocide"), and 3) at the end of the day, who cares? everyone unbiased knows it was one, including many turks, and the government until recently could suppress it only by force (i cautiously claim that things are changing now, albeit slowly). the turkish government only makes a tilt of itself by constantly denying it, and their agruments sound increasingly unconvincing the more you learn about the issue. after all, what you say about certain subjects says more about you than the subject concerned, and this is the case with this issue. but there is another reason why turkish academicians deny the genocide (or rather, say that it wasn't a genocide and believe what they say): no-one denies, or attempts to deny, that the armenians were practically eliminated from anatolia. that much is settled fact. to qualify it as a genocide, which by definition can only be organised, planned and carried out by a central body, i.e. the state apparatus, you either have to show through documentation that the INTENT to eradicate an entire nation was there, or, failing that, you have to show that the nature and scale of the operation was such that it could only have been planned by a state and directed against a specific group of people. now the difficulty with the first option is that authenticated documents conclusivel demonstrating that the cup gave orders to liquidate the armenians are lacking, in fact orders to the contrary abound. this you can explain away very convincingly that if they had decided to kill the armenians off, they would not choose to leave an incriminating trail of paper behind them. after all, there is not a single piece of paper in german with an order to kill the jews off signed by hitler. yet no-one doubts that jews were killed, and that hitler was the architect of the crime. i accept the genocide for instance, since the look of it is that of genocide: it was quick (one and a half years), it was aimed at a specific group (not even the assyrians were targeted), it eliminated that group almost completely from the area in question, seized its property, and wrote them off the history books. here you don't need any paper documentation to prove that it was a genocide: that it was one is obvious. an important technical reason that genocide is denied is that archives relating to it (and they are there, believe me) are dispersed: some in france, some in england, some in the usa, some in germany, some in armenia, and, most importantly, some in russia. we keep our archives regarding this issue closed at least partly because these countries keep certain portions of their archives closed. after the war, many armenians who were working in the archives left turkey with the "relevant" portions of the archives. this gave them a wonderful opportunity to selectively use the facts, which is the academic form of lying. plus we would very much like to know what is written in the archives of these other nations who were all involved in this at the time. germans, for instance: there is revived suspicion - which the germans are not denying anymore - that the germans took part in it: this was reported at the time of the events by many sources including german ones, but later dismissed as wartime propaganda. now it is opening up again and we all should brace ourseles for some pretty mind-opening reading. you see, i look at the armenian genocide a little bit like an agatha christie novel: there is a victim and eight suspects, all of whom had excellent reasons to kill the victim, all of whom were present at the crime scene, and all of whom could have committed the crime. moreover, in the case of the armenians, everyone knew that everyone wanted to get rid of the armenians. various people wanted various things: the russians wanted to get down to the mediterranean and middle eastern oil, the only way to do both was through eastern anatolia, which was at the hand of the turks, to dislodge them armenians had to be used, and they had to make sure that as many of you died as possible so that you didn't pose a problem to them after they conquered the region. the brits wanted to stop the russians, who were using you, but wanted the region for themselves without any armenians in it, because being christian and industrious, they would make more difficult subjects to rule than the moribund mohammedan turks, kurds and arabs (so they thought). the french, always in for a revolution, wanted to stop both the brits and the russians, and the germans, who had not until then acquired an overseas empire, wanted to get down to the arab oil and remove everything that stood in their way. it was not clear until the last minute on whose side the turks would be, but either way it would have been pretty awful for you anyway: everyone wanted you to go. the reason why turks decided to kill you was very simple: they took the separatist threat that you posed very seriously. they hired most of the job off to the kurds, who are your traditional enemies anyway, and who had been living off plundering you, and they did it gleefully, and are now sitting on the land that was once yours, (and you are financing the pkk, very smart, you). again, don't take this as an attempt at justification (i am amazed at how many people fail to see the difference between the two). do not forget that decision makers those days never put human lives on top of the list of priorities, if they had, the wars would not have erupted. i should expect your comments on my above analysis, which i had posted several times in this forum. and please read my past postings before saying things like i justify the genocide or don't feel sympathy for the victims. cheers,
  6. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali jan, 1. Azeri Turks are not the only native Turks in Armenia. 2. I agree with you that Germany was forced to democratize as a result of international pressure. I also agree that since Jews were a foreign element in Germany, Germany had no fear for land claims. However, as you probably already know, Armenians, throughout history, have adapted themselves to their environment, with or without foreigners. The only times Armenians asked for independence was after their repeated pleas for equal rights had fallen on deaf ears. If Turkey and Azerbaijan would respect our rights and freedom, why would most Armenians want to secede from Turkey or Azerbaijan? 3. When was the last time Turkey democratized and shared its land equally with all its minorities to conclude that it'll be a disastrous endeavor? I think Turkey's fear for Armenians is slightly, if not very, exaggerated. If there's anyone who should be afraid it's Turkey's minorities. We know what Turkey is capable of. You've shown us time and time again and you continue to do so. Please refrain from blaming Turkish hostility towards Armenians on Armenians, without looking at Turkey's oppressive past and present first. 4. The division among Armenians regarding what they desire from Turkey should be blamed on Turkey, not Armenians. If Turkey had recognized our plight from the beginning, resolved the issue of oppression and inequality, there would be no reason for Armenians to be divided today. Turkey has mastered the "divide and rule" policy and is applying it to Armenians without mercy. 5. The longer this issue persists, the more difficult it will be solve. By putting all the blame on Armenians and expecting them to perennially propose practical and peaceful solutions, which Turkey consistently dismisses, Turkey is only frustrating Armenians more and more as the years go by. Please keep in mind that Armenians would preferably concentrate on other issues than that of surviving against hostile neighbors. 6. If Armenians, unlike Native Americans or Australians, are "industrially evolved", then shouldn't this be a double reason for Turkey to "take advantage" of our skills, knowledge and experience? 7. I can only hope that your point 6 will come true. But as things stand today, I am deeply pessimistic about our problems being solved in the near future. As I understand there are still too many Turks who are convinced that this issue will not be solved until Armenians are an almost extinct race. Cheers, Nairi 1. i didn't know that. who else is there? 2. i know the armenians adapted to different environments throughout history, but that was because they were aware that they had no power tyo change these environments. the parthian empire, the greeks, the romans, the byzantines, the seljuk and ottoman turks and finally the russians were all too strong for the armenians to handle on their own and until the 19th century, when the great powers became interested in the region for their own benefit no-one knew or cared about the plight of the armenians. and the armenians, once they thought they had the backing, did act. tell me: would there be an armenian revolutionary movement if the russians, the french and the british had not inspired, agitated, encouraged, proselytised, educated, financed, and armed the armenians against the turks? meanwhile i do agree that the way the armenians were treated in the empire especially in the second half of the last century (i mean abdulhamid ii) was no way to treat human beings, and yes, i would also revolt if i were an armenian living then. but then everyone hated him and in 1909 he was deposed to the cheers of the entire ottoman population. the armenians were invited into the government but that did not prevent them from following a separatist agenda. there may lie an answer to your question: at the beginning, the cup was really trying to make a better country for everyone. but when they saw that no-one was participating, they quickly abandoned the idea and focussed on saving what could realistically be saved and made live. you are asking when turkey shared the land with all its minorities equally and gave equal opportunities to everyone. first, true equality as we understand it today is a very recent phenomenon worldwide. in the west, which is the self-styled promoter of "civilisation" today, you were not human if you weren't white & christian until earlier last century. the rest of the world was even worse. after all, that calamity called nationalism and obsession with ethnic purity and race is the west's gift to the rest of the world, and quite a recent one at that. when you look at the ottoman empire, true, there were differences observed between the various ethnic groups and non-muslims had a worse deal than the muslims, but later in the 19th century there were great strides which allowed them to attain governmental and even military posts (you have armenian *****s)! it was a development from bad to less bad or even better if ou like, and if it weren't for your armenian revolutionaries, after the deposition of abdulhamid ii, there could have been hope for both sides to live in a better turkey (i concede here that our decision to enter the wwii was the one mistake that brought us down. we ought to have avoided that as long as possible). so we come to the element of trust. you know how we felt when the sevres treaty was shoved under our nose? well, let me tell you: you live in a neighbourhood. you know you are not popular. you have fought fistfights with the other guys in the past and beaten them, now they are stronger and want to do you in, and you know it. you have an enemy. the enemy does not attack you openly at the first opportunity because a) you are weaker now but still quite strong, and he hasn't decided with his other buddies how to carve you up, and of course, everyone wants everything just for himself. and of course, if you are not going to attcak him in the foreseeable future, you have to keep diplomatic relations with him alive (diplomacy= the art of saying "nice doggie" until you find a stone) . so you keep saluting one another when you see eachother in the street, raising your hat and exchanging smiles. but you know he wants to kill you. then there is the showdown, a fight to the death where he wins and you lose, and you see the look in his eyes when he delivers the fatal blow. this is what we saw at sevres. and this is why "trust" is not part of our vocabulary when dealing with past enemies. we also don't expect to be trusted. if you fear that we are going to invade you, go ahead and arm up, but you'll be wasting you money 'cause we retired from the empire building business. shop closed, no deliveries, sorry. we don't have eyes on anyone else's territory anymore, not because we are more civilised and nicer or anything, but because the ottoman empire, in its desire for world domination, had used up the anatolian turk, and for centuries we died in places we had never heard of, plus they hadn't put stone on stone in anatolia. we have had enough of it. now we have a country that's big and habitable and still vastly underpopulated despite our best efforts , and we are busy building it from scratch. it keeps us busy. we also don't want anyone else's land, because land comes with people on it, and while we might have some use for the land, we can do without the people and it's too much of a hassle these days either to assimilate them (for instance it didn't work with the kurds) or to get rid of them(look at what happened to yugoslavia), so whatever advantage you might have in getting a chunk of land outside is offset by the far greater disadvantages it entails. in brief, days of conquest are over. so we are on our little turf, you on yours, i am not out to get you, but i would think twice before getting into anything common with you - and living on the same soil under the same administration is getting into something common - in view of the recent past and the present. overall i think my approach, though perhaps not particularly amicable, is the most realistic one and probably has the great advantage of being workable. 4. i doubt turkey ever had the sophistication to divide and rule the armenians. first, it's kind of difficult to divide and rule people who do not live in a country controlled by you, and second, turkey had and continues to havea very serious shortage of qualified personnel in the humanities. to the best of my knowledge, there weren't enough ethnic turks who actually spoke armenian until about two years ago when the army started armenian courses for cadets. turkey does not even have the most basic rudiments to carry out such an operation against the armenians or anyone else. and don't be like us: you are divided because of your own shortcomings, not because someone divides you. 5. i partially agree. but our efforts to stall the issue stems from our conviction that it won't stop there. after all, you must have seen with your own eyes in this forum that a goal to retieve "lost provinces" of historic armenia and unite them with roa is alive and kicking, and in the final analysis we interpret the NKR for instance as a first step in that direction. our interests dictate that it must be the last step. turkey will simply not budge unless and until it sees the land claims issue dead and buried on the part of the armenians. 6. we would like that, of course, but again, it is a matter of trust. how can we trust that these guys will not turn their skills and power against us to get a piece of our land when we give them the opportunity to use them? plus, in the ottoman empire there was some (much exaggerated) division of trades and skills along ethnic lines, but since the non-muslims left, these trades have been taken over by turks, and the skills redeveloped, and we are not doing that badly, either. if you are in europe today, a car, fridge, or tv set that you plan to buy may well be of turkish manufacture. today we have a growing pool of talented people that keep emigrating because there is too much talent chasing too few jobs. 7. i still have hope that my point 6 will eventually be materialised, though whether i will live to see it is another matter. you are wrong in thinking that there are so many turks who think the armenian problem will be solved only when there are no more armenians, sure, there are some, but they do not characterise the population. after all, all countries have the likes of grey wolves. turkey just wants its territorial integrity be respected without ifs and buts, that's all. cheers,
  7. quote:Originally posted by Tatavla:i think that it is not necessary that Western Armenia is given to the Armenians. What i would really like to see is: 1)Republic of Turkey should cease to exist as Turkey. Instead, for example; it should be named Anatolia. 2)It should not belong to any 1 nation or religion as it does right now. Instead, it should be a multi-ethnic country, where; any group of people have the same rights as the others, and won't be oppressed/marginalized because of their nationality/religion/ideas etc... 3)It should be a truly democratic and progressive country. tatavla, 1) this was thought during the formation of the republic, and in fact the turks had never referred (at least officially) to anatolia as turkey. the westerners had, though, since the 12th century (i think the first was plano carpini), in fact even before the ottomans. we adopted the name "turkey" officially a) because everyone else, including our enemies in wwi, was calling it by that name, we saw that multi-ethnic states don't work, c) with the empire gone, religion silenced, we needed something to hold the nation together d) by that time anatolia was full of turks from lost provinces of the ottoman empire and sometimes even beyond (the cetral asian turks), and the one thing almost everyone had in common was that they were all kicked out of some place else because they were muslim turks. it was pretty obvious to them that they were turks, were hated by non-turks, even if they were fellow muslims, and in return they had very little sympathy and consideration for the plight of non-turks and non-muslims in their midst, and e) by that time the greeks and armenians were mostly gone, the (then) few kurds were bought off/silenced, and the place was really over 90% turkish, so why call it anything else? you will have to get used to "the republic of turkey" as the official name of that part of the world, i am afraid. and it looks beautiful on the map. 2) if you mean to say that everyone should be first-class citizens and not discriminated on the grounds of religion/language/ethnicity etc. i agree. but it should stay in one peace and those who own it should be committed to its staying in one piece, whatever origin they may come from. otherwise we'll be back to square one, which was not a good place to be in. besides, today it belongs to the turks and kurds and regardless of how much they might whine about their plight (o.k. there have been some pretty horrible episodes) many kurds, especially those out of the eastern provinces, are not doing that badly at all. the car park mafia in istanbul is largely kurdish : , and also with the recent laws their plight is getting noticeably better. 3) yes. we want that, too. cheers,
  8. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali jan, 1) At different times, under different presidents, minorities in the Soviet Union were either praised or oppressed (including Armenians), so there's nothing unique about what happened to the Turks. As far as I know, Turks have equal rights in Armenia where they are free to speak and learn their language, practice their culture and religion, and participate in the Armenian life. In fact, at the moment, percentage wise, there are more Turks in Armenia than there are Armenians in Turkey. 2) Just because your neighbor jumps off the roof doesn't mean you have to follow in his footsteps. Turks repeatedly raise the argument that if this or that country has done it, then why can't we? Ali, Australia grants full freedom to Aborigines now and has even dedicated a "National Sorry Day" for the atrocities their ancestors committed against them. America has given Native Americans special rights over certain areas that were once theirs. Germany has not destroyed a single concentration camp. What has Turkey done for the Armenians? 3) Ali, have you ever asked Turks who have recognized the Armenian Genocide what it is they would sincerely want to offer or return to the Armenians? How unanimous is their reply? And how would you react towards your perpetrator if you were raped? Would all Turks react the same if they experienced it? Would ALL Turks want justice or compensation? Would it be fair for the perpetrator to say: "Well, since my rape victims are not unanimous about what they want from me, I won't give them anything." Should Turkey not be the one to offer us some sort of compensation without us even asking? 4) The Armenian Diaspora was formed as a result of the Genocide. Diaspora Armenians theoretically belong in Turkey. However, many survivors also fled to Armenia. You cannot separate the two. Moreover, we will not allow you to separate us, simply because we are all Armenians, regardless of where we live. 5) Ali, when was the last time you visited Eastern Turkey? Could you tell me why such large areas not far from the Armenian border are entirely deserted, neglected and hermetically closed off? Tell me Ali, what harm would it do to Turkey if these territories were offered to people who do care and who do want to live there? 6) On a personal note: I don't care what that whole territory (Turkey-Armenia) is called. As far as I'm concerned it could be called Ghana or China. All I want is to be able to walk in and out of that territory without any restriction or hindrance whatsoever from anyone. Nairi nairi jan (i guess the "jan" is our "can" with "c" pronounced as "j" in "jam". am i correct?), 1) i know there is nothing unique that happened to the turks, i wasn't trying to say that. in fact the precise opposite: what happened to you (albeit on an admittedly smaller scale and slower pace) happened to us, too. and we also have our homeland (the altai) under foreign occupation. so i do understand and symphatise with the armenian position on a purely moral ground, but this is not a fair world, is it? just understand that it is not unfair only to you. as far as turks in armenia are concerned, well, i know some who emigrated (either to azerbaijan or to turkey) and they tell quite a different story. in fact, on paper things may be all right, but in practice these guys all prefer to leave the place. there must be a reason for it. after all, armenia is at war with azerbaijan and without normalised relations with turkey. who is right and who wrong is a long story, but the atmosphere is obviously - and cannot be expected to be - conducive to living side by side in the same country. besides, there may be more turks in armenia than armenians in turkey, but many of these went there from turkey to establish businesses. they are, strictly speaking, foreigners who do business there. azeri turks, who are native, are almost all gone. 2)about the practices of my neighbour. i am afraid this applies to everyday life on a small scale, but on larger scales such as states, it doesn't and never did. states' actions are frequently fashioned after the practices of other states, because we do not live on a desert island but in a society of nations. re the australian/american and german comparisons: i. australia and america are amongst the strongest nations of the world, and no-one has the power to push them either way concerning their treatment of their minorities. you are stuck with their policies whether you like them or not. when you are that strong, you can afford to give whomever what you like because you can be certain that they will never acquire the power to get anything from you that you are not prepared to give. ii. in the case of both the native americans and the native australians, you are not dealing with one nation each, but by a collection of several hundred tribes that are not bound by anything other than their plight in the hands of the white man. they speak different languages, have different customs, have had internal conflicts before and during white rule, and especially in the case of the native americans, this was used against them. iii. they have practically lost their languages, customs, their entire culture, which only survives in museums. when your culture is gone, your very motives to launch a sustained attack against the enemy is gone: can you be expected to fight for something that is not there anymore? iv. in the case of both groups, they have no external connections: they were unique, isolated cultures of their homeland, and you cannot expect any third party (an external power) to campaign for them seriously, and as we both know, this has never happened. no other nation really cares enough about their situation to do anything about it, especially to do anything that will arouse australian or american hostility. v. these cultures, very interesting though they may be, are lithic (=stone age) cultures that were doomed to extinction when faced with an industrialised culture. entire components of industrial civilisation is absent from them: no metals, no native writing, no written history, literature etc, no monumental architecture, no economical foundation beyond subsistence level, and most importantly, no talent pool of individuals dedicated to the liberation of their peoples. so if you are an american or australian, you can give them pretty much everything they want, because you can be sure that whatever you may give them, they will never have the power to do anything with it that may harm you in any way. vi. there is not a single independent native american or australian state with recognised borders, standing army, separate currency, government structure, embassies abroad and a seat in the united nations. as long as these are absent, they can never be a serious threat to anyone. re germany: germany did not do what it did out of its own accord. after wwii, it was levelled, invaded, divided into two, denazified, demilitarised, in short, generally broken down and remade according to a democratic model imposed by the invading enemy as the german people themselves proved evidently uncapable of doing it themselves (hitler was elected). plus their enemy, the jews, are strong, numerous, close-knit, well educated, righ, and powerful, and they are absolutely everywhere and in the right places. so australia/america on the one hand and germany on the other do not really compare. 3) i agree with your points but repeat that this is not the way the world turns. whatever my personal feelings about justice and morality in such an issue, i have to work out from a practical standpoint if i am to achieve any results. the problem of a lack of unanimity amongst the turks and armenians is a practical hurdle in the solution of the problem, not a moral one. 4)i partially agree with what you say here, but at the moment you are acting as if you were two different bodies with different, and at times conflicting, agendas when it comes to turkish-armenian relations and the genocide issue. this makes it difficult for the turkish side to formulate one coherent approach. 5)i have been as far as tokat, yozgat, erzincan and the black sea coast in northestern turkey, and i know what you mean. there are several reasons why the area is the way it is. the first is that these areas were never that developed in the first place as the main power centre of the ottoman empire was istanbul and west of it (the balkans) as opposed to anatolia. the second is wwi, where the armenian as well as the turkish infrastructure was destroyed. the third is istanbul which sucked anyone with money or talent or both out of these places so no-one went there to do anything. the fourth is the kurdish issue, which masde the turkish government hesitate to invest there, and which made industrialists, both turkish and kurdish, flee the area. it is basically a war-ravaged country. the fifth is the social structure there, which has never been really conducive to industrial development (i mean feudalism). what harm would there be if these areas were opened to people who cared about it and wanted to live there? well, nothing as long as you could be sure that these people (who are ethnically different from the restof the population) would not then attempt to form a numerical majority there in order to secede from turkey and unite with the armenian republic. do not forget that the jews did pretty much the same thing in the holy land: they were allowed to settle, which they did, they then started buying land from the arabs, which the arabs sold and once they formed a majority in certain areas (also using the guilt factor of the western psyche after the holocaust), they started armed action against both the british and the arabs, and today the israelis are in, the british out, and the arabs down! we have seen that movie and don't want it to play in our theatre. 6) i symphatise with your wish. i am allergic to borders & restrictions myself. if the current development go on the way they do, this may well be possible in the near future. cheers,
  9. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Don't play dumb Ali. You know I didn't mean the ROA. i wasn't playing dumb, and if you want an answer, here it goes: our original homeland (the altai mountains) is an autonomous republic under russia now. before that it was part of the soviet union, and before that it was a part of the russian empire. it got invaded by the russians in the 19th century if i am not mistaken, got settled by the slavs to such an extent that the turks are in a minority now, the use of the language was at times discouraged/forbidden, and later on, under the soviets, care was taken to split up one language into as many official languages as possible to make sure that people couldn't properly communicate in their native tongue, and chose to speak russian instead. i don't know what the situation is now, but at the time of the breakup of the soviet empire the language retention rate there and in the adjacent central asian republics was below 50%. the use of the term "turk" as national/ethnic/group designation was forbidden under the soviets on pain of death/siberia/psychiatric hospitals, and people were not even allowed to get out of the soviet union if they hated the life there so badly. many of the "groups" were forcibly settled thousands of miles away from their homelands in god-forsaken places, others were made to die under dubious "circumstances" etc etc. briefly, they had and continue to have a pretty miserable life, and their homeland (and in all probability they are the first humans ever to settle there) is run by other people. we as turks of turkey can protest this situation as much as we can, but realistically speaking there is nothing we can do. just as you look at mount ararat we look at mount altai and we both do just that: look but not touch. and if all we can do is look at but not touch when it comes to the altai mountains, i see no reason why the same should not apply to you. clear?
  10. the above postings (and quite a few others elsewhere in the forum under various threads) show quite clearly that many armenians in fact do not separate genocide claims from land claims. it also appears that there is no discernible consensus on this issue as opposed to the genocide claims: armenians are unanimous in their position that the genocide occurred, that it should be recognised, apologised for, and compensated by some form of payment along the lines of the jewish holocaust settlement. but they are not agreed whether or not they should include land claims in that, or pursue land claims separately on different historical grounds, or pursue them at all. another serious problem that we turks face when dealing with this particular issue is the presence of two bodies instead of one: there is the roa, and then there is the diaspora. in many cases what one says is diametrically opposite the other and undermines the other's efforts. we see the roa take vague, unclear, and at times self-contradictory positions on the issue, and not all roa government representatives speak with one voice. we are at a loss as to whom to listen to and when. under such dubious conditions, we prefer to stick to our old, conservative and frankly speaking hostile position, because it is clear, it is the one we know best, it is open, and does not leave much room for any tricks: you can have false friends, but not false enemies: they are always real. i am afraid this will go on as long as there are two "governing bodies" within the armenian community: the roa and the diaspora. if you want turkey to talk clearly, you first have to make clear whom you want turkey to talk to in the first place.
  11. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Hey Ali - I know its slightly off topic but have you gotten married yet? If not when is the date. Just curious - and wondering if I just happened to be in town do I get an invite - LOL! Its a long shot but I thought I'd at least inquire...I promiss not to get too drunk and start calling the party guests nasty names & such... I must warn you however that my gag wedding gifts have got more then one new wife not talking to me (and trying to convince her new hubby - my [ex?]friend - not to do so either...LOL) dear thoth, i got bad news for you (well, for me, actually). we didn't make it... we have had quite a tough time recently (health and economical problems) that proved too much. so no marriage i am afraid. but if you are around, you are more than welcome to have a pint. just let me know when you are around. (you can leave me a private message, as i check into the forum a bit rarely these days. cheers,
  12. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:but i also want my country to stay in one piece, as anyone else wants the same for his/her own country. Ali, why is it okay for Turkey to stay in one piece, but not Armenia? Nair i didn't say it's not o.k. for armenia to stay in one piece (i mean roa)?
  13. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: While I can agree that there should be normalisation and that without it all peoples suffer - and I do not think that the Genocide issues should necessarily stand in the way (as I don't think this is the Armenian government position - but a Turkish Government claim/excuse) - at the same time I absolutly cannot see true normalisation with the current Turkish attitudes - I mean really now would Isreal have relations with Germany under similar circumstance. Even more I have read Turkish Government rational for why relations are not normalised. Besides blaming the Karabagh situation soley on the Armenians (and calling for an end of "occupation" of Azerbaijan [including Karagbagh] the Turkish Government demands as a precondition that Armenians give up all Genocide "allegations". Furthermore they place blame soley on Armenian (for its "hostile" attitude) for why relations are not normalised - ignoring Turkish blockades and general lack of effort on behalf of normalising relations. In fact Armenian has made many overtures for normalisation and does not include demands for genocide recognition or such - to my knowledge. So with all of this official hostility from turkey - how can you expect Armenians to react? dear winston, an increasing number of the turks do understand, symphatise and agree with the armenians' desire to see the genocide recognised by the turks. and i had posted contributions here that highlighted my stance on the issue that was essentially a moral one. the problem is that it does not stop there: if all that the armenians (quite a diverse group, i understand) wanted were that the genocide be recognised, compensation paid, property returned and even the right to resettle were given, then turkey would not be so intransigent. the real problem is that most armenians who keep the genocide issue alive tag it to the territorial claims issue. you can talk quite a few turks into accepting the genocide. an increasing few - like me - are willing to do that without being forced to do so. but we see over and again that as soon as you accept the genocide, the next sentence is "now get the hell out of half of anatolia (the six eastern provinces) and give it back to us". this attitude on the part of the armenians, i.e. refusing to separate the genocide issue from the territorial claims issue, dogs the whole thing. it makes life very difficult for those of us like me who would want to see the truth publicly acknowledged, for our own psyche as well as for that of the armenians (as mj rightly points out), by giving a super card into the hands of our opponents in this issue (the denialist camp), who say - evidently rightly -: "if we accept the genocide, they will ask for compensation until they get it. if they get it, they will ask for return of immovables. if they get that, then they will resettle on the land and try to form a majority next to the armenian border. if they get that, too, then the next step will be to push for the independence of this chunk of land to annex it to armenia. this is a very powerful argument, all the more so as nagorno-karabagh is evidently moving in that direction (the historical situation of NK and what the soviets had done with it is of course a different matter), and i have no convincing counter arguments. now i want the genocide to be recognised, for the good of my nation as well as for that of the armenians, but i also want my country to stay in one piece, as anyone else wants the same for his/her own country. if the armenians unequivocally and convincingly separated the two issues, and frankly speaking did away with dreams of getting a chunk of eastern anatolia, then they would have had a very, very strong hand in getting the turks recognise the genocide. cheers,
  14. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Ali - I am so very sorry to hear about your situation. I hope that you can work it out somehow and that things wil be looking up for you. Winston. dear winston, thank you for your good wishes, but we actually decided to separate. that's better for both of us, i hope. we have good memories of eachother, but we had rushed it a bit, and maybe gt to know eachother after we had decided to get married. anyway, we are both agreed that at least we have decided to separate before we got married than after. i have had many friends who had got married in their twenties and divorced a few years later, with child and all, and then it's a really big mess (my own parents divorced more than twenty years ago, and i wouldn't want it to happen to my children). we still respect eachother and we are sure we will one day find the right person, but that wasn't the case this time, i'm afraid. i feek o.k. it's been a month now. anyway, the invitation to a pint remains standing if you are around. cheers,
  15. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Aurguplu, I know that you are not so naive to believe that I am the only Armenian who believes that certain parts of present-day Turkey rightfully belong to Armenia. Kars and Ardahan provinces were part of Armenian provinces under the Czars. Ownership of these provinces adjacent to the Armenian Republic can even be found in the Armenian constitution. So my comments should not alter your trust or lack of trust of Armenians one iota. Given what you have related in the past about your family, I have no doubt that our families knew each other. It is probable that they had business and governmental dealings with each other and may even have sat together over dinner at each other's homes. These Amiras did not want to rock the boat, for they had too good a life in what was then Constantinople. I know that my family members tried to talk sense into various groups of Armenian agitators but to no avail. They were not part of the movement. Their fate was in no part a result of their actions as their operations were an integral part of the Turkish economy. Please seperate one issue from the other. hagarag, 1) i know you are not the only one. we had had a discussion about that issue way back with mj, for instance. i have had comparable discussions with greeks and kurds as well. the only thing i say is that you cannot expect the turks to agree to that sort of thing. in fact, it is extremely rare that any nation does. the morality of the issue is of course another matter, but the facts remain: the usa does not get out of originally native-american owned territories, australia and new zealand don't get out of aborigine or maori lands, russia does not get out of non-russian "provinces", arabs don't get out of north africa, and china does not get out of sinkiang or tibet. why should we? and this highlights the difficulty of the solving of the genocide issue: turks are fully aware of the fact that once they accept the genocide claims and payment of reparations, then land-claims will inevitably follow. and these claims will not merely be restricted to personal possession of land, but eventual secession of that territory to be annexed by armenia. that is the whole point. and you cannot blame a state for performing its most basic duty, that is, preserving itself: survival is the most basic instinct of anything alive; and any acceptance on the part of turkey of any territorial claims is going to pave the way for the eventual application of the sevres treaty, which was our death sentence as a nation. you cannot accept us to sign our own death warrant. 2) my family (my great grandfather) was in the CUP for quite a while. he was one of the more important ones as he had good relations with the non muslim communities and these relations were partly entrusted to him. so it is quite probable that he might have met with members of your family, and indeed there are business cards of prominent armenians amongst his papers (which we still keep) and there are records of his conversations with armenian mps in his diaries (which i am preparing for publication). but he was not a businessman, so no "business talk". 3) i understand that the amiras did not want to rock the boat and that they wanted to talk sense into the revolutionaries, but to no avail. the same thing happened to old-style ottoman turks as well (my greatgrandfather was one in many respects). you see, these guys were the children of an empire with an essentially imperialistic outlook, which at that time was basically to preserve the empire with all its constituent parts, land, people and all. the new guys, like talat, enver etc were different: they were trying to make something new out of the crumbling structure, and they knew that the old multinational empire was doomed. your family and mine were probably caught in between and paid for the mistakes of others. i think this is one of the most tragic aspects of the whole thing. your outlook towards the whole issue would be quite different if your family had actually participated in the revolutionary activities of the period (like mj had once said: if we had fought and lost it in a war, at least we would say well we fought and lost. but that wasnt the case (i hope i am paraphrasing you correctly, if not, sorry mj). i think right now what we both nations have to do is this: 1) accept the facts (both sides), 2) respect eachother's territorial integrity (both sides) and 3) start having normalised relations once again. the real thaw between the two peoples will come after that, and it will probably take at least a generation. but we have to start. by the way, what do you think of the recent eu adaptation package that passed just this weekend, including the right for minority foundations to acquire immovable property? cheers,
  16. quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:you'll have to sell the bridge to someone else i am afraid. ..... i might have an offer: i have several buildings and bits of buildings from central anatolia that once were greek or armenian churches and other stuff (inscriptions). since turkey does not regard post-byzantine non-muslim stuff as "of historical value" and frankly speaking, would rather see it go, it is quite easy for us to get them out of the country. i can furnish you with most of a small provincial church if you want. you will have saved both the church and me. what do you say? Dear Ali Suat, I say "subconscious is a powerful thing". Trying to get rid of things Armenian, eh? I am not that surprised, after seeing earlier that you could only imagine Armenians in their homeland "100 years after reconciliation". I understand your intelligently nationalistic position of acknowledging the genocide and moving Turkey onto better and greater things. I also understand your clever desire to see an "enlightened" Turkey that in the end loses nothing from the exercise but gains absolution, acceptance, and the freedom to be fully civilized. I understand the desire for an "accept the crime but not its consequences" solution. But I do not like it. I may not be alone in that. I know I digressed. And I know I am being slightly unfair. But I feel compelled to dissect the fundamental, human motivations. You will have completed your cultural enlightenment when you actually want the Armenians back, with their full, cultural, local autonomy. The mock "diplomatic negotiation" was fun, but I do not think anyone important is going to listen to us and borrow from our positions. What the "important" people will be attuned to is the general sympathy level of the two peoples. And playing the role of amateur diplomats stops being productive after a while, as in our case. Of course, if many many Turks and Armenians engage in this much dialog, the real diplomats' job will be a lot clearer and easier. We have reached our depth, and are unlikely to engage in discussions that make us grow. I hope other Turks and Armenians dive in a bit more, and engage "the other side". I wish I were more optimistic about a widespread engagement anytime soon, though. Cheerio, Twilight Bark dear tb, 1. subconscious: if i were that sort of guy, then what am i doing here trying to establish a dialogue with you? 2. what i said earlier: it wasn't an exercise in wishful thinking, it was (i believe) a coldly realistic position: suppose we admit to the genocide tomorrow, before it has sunk into the population, and armenians come back (assuming that you will actually find any armenians who would want to return to live side by side with the turks, and in eastern anatolia of all places). there will inevitably be brushes between the two peoples. as i have stated numerous times in this forum, the overwhelming majority of the turkish (and kurdish) population enuinely believes that there was no genocide, and that the armenians behaved just as atrociously as the turks and kurds (meanwhile again most do not deny the killings themselves). the armenians believe the diametrical opposite with equal passion. and since this is not an intellectual exercise but a tragedy that affected every turk and armenian directly or indirectly, it is extremely likely that eruptions here and there will occur. therefore i would frankly speaking be wary of any large scale settlement of the places concerned before both peoples (as opposed to states) actually reached common ground. 3. my intelligently nationalistic position. well, i am nationalistic (but not the kind that says we are the best and destined to rule everyone else). and i take "intelligently" as a compliment, thank you. i am sure you understand that i am a turk after all and my position will always be a turkish one (as you are an armenian after all and yours will be an armenian one). we have to accept that there is no suc thing as "objective truth" in these matters, and i am afraid the same thing goes for "justice". i do genuinely think that armenians have been wronged and something must be done to right it, but that something will have to stop short of actually ceding territory or any other steps that will eventually lead to it. look at the middle east now and tell mre whether it is at all realistic in that poitical environment to allow any large-scale armenian resettlement in anatolia and not expect a separatist warfare in a few decades' time at best. i have people whose interests have to be defended, and if we don't, then who will? 4. accept the crime but not the consequences: no. but don't forget that no-one who took part in the crime is alive today (unless they are past 100). so we are not the criminals ourselves. you might argue that we are their descendants. true, and so are the americans, the australians and anyone else who is in a country that was invaded by his ancestors. and so are you, after all, you (or rather your language) came here from somewhere else (the balkans). the fact that it was three thousand years ago does not make it any different: imagine we hold on for another two thousand years: we'll be just as native as you guys are now. ). no, i am not saying acknowledge the crime but not the consequences: the consequences, such as compensation, should eventually be paid and will amount to a hefty bill. 5. re regarding the return of the armenians as "cultural enlightenment": i checked the genocide posting "turkish misinformation" today (2 august 2002) and saw hagarag's and other guys' postings there. and you want me to trust those returning armenians? would you if you were me? i am still an optimist, and i think in 100 years' time there will hardly be any borders left in the region, as is the case with europe. but our descendants will be very different from us and will have acquired other notions of morality, humanity, courage, patriotism etc., mind you. they will persist as turks and armenians, but these will mean very different things to them than they do to us now. think about it. cheers,
  17. tb, i'll answer the rest later, but you'll have to sell the bridge to someone else i am afraid. we are in deep sh*t economically speaking here and it's getting deeper by the day (and at the tender age of 34, we are not getting any taller). i might have an offer: i have several buildings and bits of buildings from central anatolia that once were greek or armenian churches and other stuff (inscriptions). since turkey does not regard post-byzantine non-muslim stuff as "of historical value" and frankly speaking, would rather see it go, it is quite easy for us to get them out of the country. i can furnish you with most of a small provincial church if you want. you will have saved both the church and me. what do you say? cheers,
  18. quote:Originally posted by HOVSEP KASHISHIAN:VERY INTERSTING AURGUPLU,AS AN ARMENIAN BORN IN JORDAN AND SPEAKING BOTH LAGUAGES,A GOOD CHUNK OF THE MODERN TURKISH LANGUAGE HAVE ARABIC WORDS,IS THERE ANY EXPLANATION BESIDE THAT THE TURKISH LANGUAGE WAS INFLUENSED BY THE KORAN ? yes and no. it was influenced by the koran like all good muslim languages were supposed to do (and are). but since islam in practice is way more than just the koran, it borrowed vocabulary from most parts of the arabic linguistic heritage. also, islamic culture was a common theology, philosophy (mostly greek, partly iranian, and partly indian derived, with traces of chinese stuff maybe), law, everyday life (buildings,food, clothing etc), arts & crafts etc.; in short, practically all walks of life were dire ctly affected by it, and arabic vocabulary flowed into turkish not always in koranic contexts. also, with islam came the aruz ('arood in arabic) metre into turkish poetry, which is said to have derived from the gait of camels. to the best of my knowledge, all literatures of the central islamic languages (arabic, pesian and turkish) use it. now aruz requires long and short vowels, and the oghuz dialect which became standard in turkey (istanbul) did not have long vowels (its ancestor did). so there was a need for arabic and persian words to make the metre match. then there is the fact that turks tend to brush under the carpet, namely that there indeed were arabs in southeastern anatolia (as there still are) and we have also mingled with them (as we have with others). hope this helps. cheers,
  19. gamavor, your post barely deserves a reply. please read my postings CAREFULLY before you answer them so that you don't repeat the things in them thinking that you are refuting a statement of mine. as for us being a foreign body in a foreign land, so are most people these days. are the whites in america native? plus we are as much anatolian as everyone else in terms of genetics, everyday life, popular religion etc. it is islam that distinguishes us from the rest and not much else. that was probably the poorest reply i ever got since i joined the forum.
  20. hagarag, i have read the stuff. true, at first sight it looks like that, but the guy might be right - i am not saying that he is - partially right after all. consider the following: 1. kurds have been in southeastern turkey, northern iraq and northwestern iran for a good 2,500 years and probably more. so you would take the clais of many kurds to their homeland at face value... and would be wrong: there has been going on tremendous shifts of entire peoples in the area at least since the turkish arrival in 1071 AD and possibly a good deal earlier. a great number of the tribes currently inhabiting part of the region were originally brought there by selim the grim and suleiman the magnificent in the 16th, and murad iv in the 17th centuries, to name but three occasions. there are also cases where entire turkish tribes became kurdish-speaking, and later, kurdish (this is not govt propaganda but actual historical fact): for instance, any kurd with a surname like batallı, badıllı badilli etc. comes from the oghuz tribe begdili. 2. the original inhabitants of istanbul were greeks until we showed up, right? right (well, no, actually, the earliest recorded ones were thracians, but this is beside the point). so the greek minority that still exists in istanbul and lives in the old, pre-ottoman greek quarters are descendants of the original inhabitants of the city, right? wrong! when mehmed ii conquered the city, he gave the greek natives the choice between staying in istanbul as christians, keeping their belongings (some churches excluded), and leaving the city with their movables. most chose to leave. he was a bit disappointed, for he wanted a city full of every race of the empire, so he took some greeks from the pontic region (sinop, if i remember correctly) and planted them there. so the istanbul greeks of today for the most part are descendants of these pontic greeks and not the original inhabitants of the city. so after all it may very well be that there was indeed some armenian settlement of the region by the russians in the last few centuries. and the russians might indeed have thought of blocking our way to central asia by doing that. such things happen. in contested areas, people shift back and forth all the time. for instance, some places in nagorno-karabagh were inhabited by azeris for centuries and armenian settlement there was actually quite recent, in some places as recent as the last 150-200 years. then the azeris there became refugees, and armenians asserted their right to artzakh on the grounds that there were armenians there since time began. true and false, the armenians were there for a long time, but they were not the first, nor were they the only ones, nor did they inhabit the region uninterruptedly for the last three thousand years. history is not that simple. what is ridiculous, though, is his refusal to admit that the armenians were there from about 1,000 bc anyway and both the russians and turks are latecomers. his claim that the area was inhabited by turks way before our arrival in the 10th century is absurd. this is the outfall of the kemalist policy of asserting our right to live in anatolia by using history. there are sporadic instances of turks in the area from the early centuries ad and perhaps late centuries bc, Herodotus talks about the Yrkai and Pliny the Elder about Yurcae and some other guys about the Turcae but that's about it. i am afraid there will be such stuff emanating as long as the policy of denial and refusal to admit that armenians even existed as a culture continues. there are changes in that direction but changes are slow, fitful and painful. but things will get better. cheers,
  21. i forgot to add: there is a recent theory, in fact probably a revamping of an old theory, by colin renfrew and cyril babaev that the home of indo-european was eastern anatolia. there is evidence both in favour and contrary to the argument. do you know about it and what do you say? cheers,
  22. dear tb, 1) you have quoted and answered the wrong paragraph; but at any rate, i had stated clearly that i could not envisage turks existing as turks at 3,000 bc (for that matter, hardly any nation alive today directly goes that far back IMO). 2) i am not trying to distance myself from the mongols or anyone else. all recent research (mostly linguistic) tells that we are not as close to the mongols as everyone - including us - once thought. the languages are much more distantly related - if at all related - than previously thought. all turkic languages are known to be genetically related, and with the exception of chuvash, they were one language at about the time of christ or at best very slihgtly earlier. chuvash, probably, is more distant. 3) it should have been clear by now that i have no imperialistic tendencies. in fact i think that if the ottoman empire had come up with the idea of a controlled downsizing - like the british and more successfully the russians - the lot of the turkish peasants would have been a lot better today. we would not have died in places we had never heard of for centuries . 4) i have much more economical explanations for early armenian history. one must beware of the differences between identity of names and identity of ethnicities. for instance, the word "roman" and its derivations meant at various times - and sometimes at the same time - an inhabitant of the city of rome, a latin speaker, a greek under roman rule, a byzantine greek, anyone subject to the roman empire regardless of ethnicity, and later on, even the anatolian turks had called their country - and sometimes even themselves - "rum". a similar phenomenon can be observed regarding turkish history. outsiders who had no knowledge of the language, customs or ethnic origins, at different times called all nomadic groups who used bows and arrows in warfare "türk". many turkic-speaking ethnic groups did not call themselves "türk" until fairly late: in the case of oghuz turks, for instance, a difference between the oghuz and turks was observed until the 12th century. some turkic nations today are known to have had ancestors who spoke languages other than turkic: the kirghiz and the yakut are two examples. in anatolia, the people whom we call "hittites" called themselves "the people of (ka)nesha, and their language "neshumnili". the "hittites" were the hatti, the original inhabitants of anatolia. the indo-european speakers that spoke languages of the anatolian type (hittite, luwian, lydian, lycian, carian, palaic, cappadocian, and possibly sidetic) are thought to have come into anatolia at around 2,000 bc or slightly earlier. they took over the name of the nation they conquered, just like the turks had done with the name of "rum" later on. the "sea peoples" which included the phrygians, came to anatolia 1,200-800 bc and might have something to do with the destruction of one of the layers of troy. now these were thraco-phrygians, and to the best of my knowledge the equation moesian=mysian=muski (in hittite documents)=(sa)mekhi (georgian appellation of armenians) is a favoured one amongst archaeologists, and not turkish ones. there might indeed have been a dynastic name that survived and became the national name of another ethnic group. you have that sort of thing everywhere, especially europe. for instance, the french claim descent from the gauls, have a germanic name, and speak a romance language, in an area which was originally inhabited by non-indo-european speakers! the term "german, germanic", the basis of "german" in english, is a celtic word thatthe celts used to describe their neighbours, meaning "the loud ones". so in brief, no, i don't think anyone made up any fictitious dynasties or anything, and since those days territorial disputes were settled by the sword rather than arguments about who came first, no-one had any incentive to do so. i do not doubt that those guys related what they knew to be true. there is an argument that armenian was spoken in anatolia probably around 1,200 bc, on the grounds that there are hittite words in armenian. this may be true, but a) hittite, or its descendants, survived long after the dissolution of the empire in about 800 bc, there are hittite words in some turkish dialects, either through greek, kurdish or armenian. i am not trying to downplay armenian antiquity in anatolia, but only trying to show the pitfalls of rashly equating names and people. the armenians, at any rate, have been in anatolia so long that they don't need to resort to any tricks to further antiquate themselves. and it would be equally absurd to attempt to deny their rights to exist in anatolia on the grounds that they are, strictly speaking, "outsiders" (at least linguistically) who came from the thraco-balkan region in 1,200-800 bc. 5) yepp, the scythians. i had forgotten to include them. hope this clarifies. regards,
  23. hagarag, you may partly be right. this is what i would call "the identical looking perceived enemy syndrome". turks are quite aware of the fact that by and large most armenians look like turks, live like turks, eat like turks, etc. but there are certain differences that are mysterious and malignant (!), such as a different religion, a different language and names, and a separatist agenda. this makes them ever more suspicious. you perceive someone as an enemy but cannot pick him in a crowd. you know (or hold) that he wants to get away with a chunk of what you consider to be your land, and do in as many of your people as possible in the process, and keeps in the back of his head memories of days when you were not yet there (in anatolia) and dreams of days when you won't be there anymore. added to this is the extreme ignorance of things armenian on the turkish side (no turk speaks armenian, almost none have ever been to a church, an armenian home, never socialised with one, hardly ever seen one, and you get the picture. i hold that it is impossible to get two feuding nations to make peace unless and until both sides know some hard facts about one another - and themselves. and i think that any book, tv programme, visit of an armenian cultural group, or any group of ordinary armenians to turkey will do far more than any two state delegates coming together and talking in the polite but dishonest language of diplomacy. cheers,
  24. quote:Originally posted by Arpa:A question to Ali. Dear Ali, What does the Kamus say about "mugam/maqam/makam"? Also, what is the oringin of "kaimakam". As I see it it may be a contraction of "qaed el maqam" , "leader/supervisor of order". In the US some towns, villages and cities have supervisors as they don't have mayoralty in their charters. dear arpa, sorry i hadn't noticed you had posted this. now: (i haven't checked the kamus, but i know this one) maqam (first a short second a long) comes from the arabic root "qama" (first a long second a short) which means "to stand". it is a deverbal noun meaning "place of standing" i.e. post, position, etc. in turkish classical music there are also maqams, and they mean something about the way you sing the songs. thus you have rast makamı, kürdili hicazkar makamı, nihavend makamı etc. as i am a complete non-starter when it comes to the intricacies of turkish classical music, i am afraid i cannot help too much with that. "kaymakam" is an arabo-persian construct, (qaim-i maqam) both words are arabic and both come from qama, they are bound in the middle by the persian -i, which means something like "of". it literally means something like "he who stands at the post" and denoted the municipal authority of kasabas (townships between villages and cities in size and importance), as it still does. i hope this helps, cheers,
  25. hagarag, i wasn't around for a while and the groong of today doesn't get to before 22 june. anyways, i take your word for it. regards,
×
×
  • Create New...