Jump to content

aurguplu

Members
  • Posts

    623
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by aurguplu

  1. tatavla, i forgot to answer you last line. i personally agree that no land at this day and age should belong to one ethnicity alone. ethnic distribution and national borders just don't match. the thing is the preservation of states. when a state sees its preservation in danger, it resorts to violence, and that means war. if we are going to live in our region peacefully, then we have to 1) recognise the historical and demographic realities of our region, and 2) attempt to make the cloak fit the body and not vice versa. since the borders themselves cannot be changed without violence, because the people who live within them are not prepared for it, we have to go around this problem. this can be done in two steps. in the case of turkey, the first step (which is already being taken) is the relaxation of the concept of nation-state to allow room for ethnic differences. as far as i can observe in my country, anatolian identity is a great bond, and people have no trouble calling themselves "citizens of the turkish republic" or "turkish citizens". the problem arises when turkey imposes turkish ethnicity as opposed to nationality (which is loyalty to the turkish state) onto different ethnicities. this is being wrapped up now with the new laws, and popular attitude also tens to support it. the second step to be taken is the removal of borders save on the maps. at the moment the border between armenia and turkey is a physical reality which you can't cross. borders within the eu, however, are no longer physical realities: you can cross from one end of europe to the other without your passport. you don't even ralise that there is a border. and this makes sure, for instance, that it no longer matters either to germans or the french whether alsace is in france or germany. if we can solve our differences regarding the genocide and manage to peacefully resettle those armenians who would want to come back, then these issues can be discussed in an atmosphere with the principal elements of violence removed. the main reason why turks are so adamant about refusing to discuss such issues is because they still see it as a genuine threat to their very existence in anatolia, and not without reason, may i add. once the reasons for this sort of outlook have been removed for good, then things may change. this is what happens in america and australia. once the dominant nation realises that the original inhabitants no longer pose a threat, arrangements can be made to provide them with a dignified existence (not that i am impressed with either the american or the australian achievement in this issue). and i certainly see no reason why an armenian shouldn't be able to visit ararat or even have a house at its foothills as long as he accepts to live as a loyal citizen of the republic where ararat is.
  2. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali, this is not the first time that you are confronted with one of your country's policies and you immediately flee to "But, that's not MY opinion". Okay, we get the point, you're a good guy, but that's not helping us solve our differences. You may not be interested in expanding Turkey's territory, but who's listening to you? The Turkish government? ATAA? The Committee Against Baseless Genocide Claims? Who's more powerful, you or them? In short, I care less about your personal opinion and you should care less about mine. If we are here to discuss our nations' differences, then we should stick to our nations' opinions and not start getting personal. Btw, this is the first time I hear of Mushki being my ancestors. Nairi nairi, i don't flee anywhere but hold my ground. my country has policies that i oppose. if you oppose some of these, then we have something in common. what do you expect me to say? that it was right to attempt to assimilate the kurds? that it was right to forbid languages? that it was right to make money out of aghtamar and never mention it was an armenian church? or to deny that a genocide took place? these are/were my country's policies, and i oppose them. since when is this called "fleeing"? also, how did you come up with the idea that my country is trying to expand? cyprus? this is a whole item on its own, and if we really had meant to expand, we would have taken over the whole island and not just a bit. what else is there? we are adamantly opposing any threat to iraq's stability, and we have no border issue with any other neighbour as far as we can see. as far as i know we also have no territorial claims anywhere outside our internationally recognised borders.
  3. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali, this is not the first time that you are confronted with one of your country's policies and you immediately flee to "But, that's not MY opinion". Okay, we get the point, you're a good guy, but that's not helping us solve our differences. You may not be interested in expanding Turkey's territory, but who's listening to you? The Turkish government? ATAA? The Committee Against Baseless Genocide Claims? Who's more powerful, you or them? In short, I care less about your personal opinion and you should care less about mine. If we are here to discuss our nations' differences, then we should stick to our nations' opinions and not start getting personal. Btw, this is the first time I hear of Mushki being my ancestors. Nairi nairi, i don't flee anywhere but hold my ground. my country has policies that i oppose. if you oppose some of these, then we have something in common. what do you expect me to say? that it was right to attempt to assimilate the kurds? that it was right to forbid languages? that it was right to make money out of aghtamar and never mention it was an armenian church? or to deny that a genocide took place? these are/were my country's policies, and i oppose them. since when is this called "fleeing"?
  4. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:This is really true.Asiatic people always respected those who were alike - strong,brutal.And the stronger you are the more the respect. That's why Turks and Persians always were so respectful to russsians but not to Armenians who were nothing for them. so did the greeks, romans, russians, the germans, the british, the french, the americans, in fact anyone who built an empire. and they weren't all asiatics. and it is not strength and brutality that we respect, but the guts to hold your own, and face whatever comes. what you call "respect" that we show to those stronger than us is not respect: it is being circumspect. what i would show you if you could get land from me by the sword is not being circumspect. it is respect. it is a tribute to a character that holds something dearer than his life and is ready to give it for that something dearer. no matter whether you are stronger or weaker than me. just have the guts.
  5. quote:Originally posted by gamavor:Dear Friends, Don't forget that Ali is a turk. Honest, but turk. He sees nothing wrong with the sword, massacre, opression, etc. as long as his anscestors were the authors of these crimes. His excuse? Well, they were turks too, by the will of God. So if turks occupy lands, impose unhumane conditions on anybody else that is fine. It is regretfull but fine. If someone tries to retalied he is a terrorist or not sane. Ali is smart but millitary unexperienced. People learn from their mistakes, ....sometimes! Cheers! 1. i see everything wrong with these crimes, otherwise i wouldn't be in this forum. there was one two years ago who didn't (raven) and some people will remember him. 2. my excuse: for the genocide, none. we are guilty and i for one am sorry. for our being here, the same that an american has for his being there: history. 3. i have 16 months of military service behind me, four of it in a tank. i wouldn't choose to use it but as a last resort, though. what's your military experience, gamavor? [ August 14, 2002, 10:53 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  6. quote:Originally posted by nairi:what would you do if the urartians were alive today and came up to you and said "listen, buddy, no matter what you say about being the inheritors of urartian culture, you are a balkan immigrant after all (your language says so), and i was living on this land before you came, and i am back now, ge the hell out of my land."? Ali jan, let me take your pain away. Armens and Hayasas never invaded Urartu. They immigrated and gradually assimilated to become what we now call Armenians. The only time Armenians colonized was under Tigran II, and that barely lasted 50 years. How can you compare? nor am i always in agreement with my country's policies, Ali, we're discussing Turkey and Armenia, not Ali and Nairi. Can you stick to the subject? Nairi 1. that's not what the hittite and urartian sources say about the mushki, your ancestors. 2. i am not the turkish republic, and you are not the armenian republic. i am an individual turk who has his own opinions of his state's dealings (and no say in it save one single vote). i cannot be expected to voice anything other than my own opinion. and i may be in full agreement with you over some blunder that my country is engaged in. but at the end of the day, it's my country and i have none other. you can throw it out of your life, i can't: i have to live in it and improve it if i want to improve my own life. that's what i am trying to do.
  7. quote:Originally posted by Arpa:I think this topic has wandered way off its original message. This will be my last reference to it. Yes, Ali is a Turk and he speaks like a Turk. He speaks from a position of strength whereas we speak from a position of the beggar. Beggars are pests and they are usually shooed away and dismissed. Ali says nothing new, as friendly as he may be, and I am sure he is a friend we seem to miss his point. I mean, POINT!!! He is still wielding the sword while we think our PEN is mighty. Our pen may have been mihty at one time until, that is, the Turks also learned to use it. No, abuse and twist it. hey still are not good at it but now they have discovered, in their iwn words a long lost "friend", masters in the art of the crooked pen. At tbis point our pen seems to lose its acuity just as their's is getting sharper by the day. Ali is rattling the sabre while we still believe that the PEN is mightier than the SWORD. It may, in the long run, a long, long run. In the meantime we should mind our own business and stop thinking that we can teach an old dog new tricks. In other words, let the sleeping dogs sleep. Ali knows this slogan very well; Let the leeping giant sleep. Do not step on the tail of a sleeping dog.(Yatan itin kuyrugna basma). What is even more ironic and tragic is that the Ottoman sword was forged by the Armenian as the Turkish sword of today is still being fashioned by our so-called soul mates. Yes, we forged the swords, the cannon balls, the muskets and the bullets for the Ottoman army while we ourselves lost the art of using it. We made swords for them while we mastered the art os making khachkars for ourselves. Look at some Armenian surnames. Ali will gladly translate them. Topji-ian, Kilij-ian, Fishek-j-ian, Tufenk-ji-ian. We built the carts (Araba-ji-ian), we furnished the mules (Katir-ji-ian) yet we lacked the nerve to us them. WE wre the ironmongers and the steel forgers, Demir-ji-ian, Polad-ian. I can go on and on. We are still good at these arts only if we learn how to use them and stop scrtaching stones into crosses. Crosses that have and will come back to haunt us time and time again. In closing. I will repeat the words of Teddy; "Walk softly and carry a big stick". Our stick is not big now, the more we talk about it the bigger THEIR stick will get. This is not the time to talk about reparations and regaining of lost lands. It was lost by the sword, it can only be regained by the sword. In the words of that great modern philosopher, Ali Suat, we have many immediate issues to deal with. Let us worry about preserving what we have now. This does not mean we will ever forget but we will shut up until we are in a position to speak in like language, i.e. from a position of strength. It may take a thousand years but, then again we are not going anywhere soon, we have not gone away for 5000 years, we are not going away in 5, 50, 500 or even the next 5000 years. I think we have said everything there is about this subject. i basically agree with the above. allow me to add: the greeks, the serbians, the bulgarians, the arabs were in the same situation as you were. they rebelled, fought, and liberated their land from our rule. have you ever heard of any turk who claimed these lands back? we respect those people who can fight us the way we fought them. no matter who wins. the last byzantine emperor died sword in hand. he has my respect, even if he lost his city to me. he held on to what was his till he breathed his last. after all, none of us is immortal. he died an honourable death. and look at you. your land was taken by the sword, not the pen, and you are trying to get it by the pen. what would your past heroes, those who had conquered that land from te hittites and urartians say about this? ever thought of it? just as it takes money to live a life, it takes a fight to get a land. there are many people out there who are all so nice and civilised and wonderful, and work for xxxxholes, because they don't have what it takes to make money. xxxxholes do. this applies to us. any reason why it shouldn't apply to you?
  8. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Yes, Ali. Everything you say here, comes across as justification for the Genocide and lack of remorse. And then, it looks like, "now let's make a deal." And the Genocide did not occur in the vacuum. It occurred as a culmination of seven centuries’ of oppression, non-centralized killings, rape, forced conversion, looting, stealing of identity and heritage, and so on. I think you get the idea. no, mj nothing justifies a genocide and this is not an attempt at political correctness. i am as honest about this as i am about our right to keep our country in one piece. a genocide happened and it continues to dog us daily. this will go on until it is recognised, apologised for, retributions paid and the people allowed to resettle. and of course, when that last one happens, there must be no two ways about them living as first-class citizens of the country. a re-run of anything like their treatment under the ottomans, even before the genocide, won't do. as we say in turkish, a madman throws a stone in a well and forty sane men can't get it out. this is our situation after the genocide. talat did this, and it is done. we can't undo it, we have to learn to live with it and get going. you and we, both of us. this does not mean that all we have to do is to say "well it happened, sorry, too bad (as some people here imply that i am saying)", but we have to take genuine steps to heal the wound to whatever degree we can. since it cost lives and since it is so recent the healing will not be anywhere complete, not at least in our lifetime. we on our part have to recognise it, apologise for it, pay reparations for it, allow you to resettle, return or pay for whatever property you had that still survives, and make sure that you live as first class citizens in a country that has learned from its past. that far i can and am willing to go, because i think it this is what has to be. but i stop short of ceding land. i fully agree with you that it isn't "right" that you take over somebody else's land, but that is the way all land everywhere has been taken. and your ancestors had also done the same thing over three thousand years ago, otherwise, why do you speak today a language that came from the balkans and not a caucasian language?
  9. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:as turkey has no eyes on external soil in general and in armenia in particular Ali, I think it's common knowledge that if Armenia's army wasn't so strong and if the international community didn't care so much about Armenia, Turkey would have long build a corridor to Azerbaijan and beyond. Don't be so ignorant. Your country is still blockading Armenia. Why? Because you don't care about expanding your territory? Because you love Armenia? Because you want to normalize ties with us? Give me a break. Like I said, and very honestly I don't mind repeating myself a thousand times if I have to, it is Turkey who has a problem with Armenia, not vice versa. As long as you put all the blame on us and justify everything your country has done so far, you are neither helping with the healing process, nor with the normalization of ties. Get it? Now go take a rest and contemplate what I've just said. Nairi this i think is wandering off the topic, but i myself do not care so much about a land corridor to azerbaijan, nor am i always in agreement with my country's policies, as it should have been clear by now. also, i do not at all think that a corridor to azerbaijan is worth having if the price is war and perpetual instability in the region.
  10. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by Arpa:PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT I HAVE NOT READ MAJORITY OF THE POSTS IN THIS CATEGORY. BUT THEN AGAIN I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO. I HAVE WITNESSED SUCH EXCHANGES NUMEROUS TIMES. TO ME IT IS AN EXCERCISE IN FUTILITY. I HAVE ALSO HEARD THAT SUCH EXCHANGES ARE A "DIALOGUE". NOT IN MY VOCABULARY. TWO MONOLOGUES DO NOT A DIALOGUE MAKE!!! WE WILL GET OUR TURN OF MONOLOGUE TOO. THERE IS ONLY ONE WAY OUT OF THIS QUAGMIRE. THAT IS "IN KIND". UNTIL THEN WE WILL ABIDE BY THE WORDS OF THAT GREAT AMERICAN PHILOSOPHER TEDDY ROOSEVELT; "WALK SOFTLY AND CARRY A BIG STICK". WE MAY NOT HAVE A BIG STICK YET. WE HAVE ENDURED THIS TURKISH GOBBLEDIGOOK FOR A MILLENIUM WE CAN WAIT A FEW MORE YEARS. UNTIL THEN "MUMS' THE WORD" arpa, 1. that wasn't a monologue but a dialogue. both parties were clear in their positions. the fact that they didn't agree doesn't turn it into a monologue. it has just been a dialogue with no results. you do run such a risk when you get into a dialogue. 2. you haven't endured any turkish gobbldygook for a millennium. a millennium ago, you endured the sword (a sword is not gobbledygook, it is always very clear what it is), then you endured the rule (that was also very clear, i guess), then in the 19th century you endured a sharply deteriorating condition (that was also very clear, i guess), hamidian massacres (i won't ask whether these were clear or not), a brief partnership in the young turk regime in which you preferred to keep an ambiguous position), and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide. any gobbledygook you might have endured dates from the post 1915-23 period, when the turkish state systematically denied what happened to your people. as i am sick and tired of repeating my position re the genocide and its denial once more, i won't get into that. you have never endured any gobbledygook regarding the land issue: you had a very clear answer: no. as far as we are concerned there isn't one. you can create one of course, by putting your nation at great peril. the greeks tried it in 1919-22, and then in 150s-1974 (cyprus), and have found out that there are certain lines you just can't cross. as far as you suggestion concerning the expansion of armenian military capability and the get even with us, i say you would be wasting your precious resources for a dubious adventure that will probably cost you more than it isa worth even if you win: it may very well be a pyrrhic victory. as turkey has no eyes on external soil in general and in armenia in particular, you would be wise to keep that in mind and concentrate on your efforts on rebuilding your country and having normalised relations and trade with your nations. who knows? you may even have peace one day. the worst kind of military-bent person is the one who has no military experience or aptitude. cheers, Dear Ali, It is quite a pity to read your posts having in mind that you are an alumnus of the United World College. I say that because as I probably told you, I am one myself. I realize the merit of your contributions to this forum, which is in any case open to anyone that respect the rules, merit or no merit in their contributions, as far as I understand. But facts are facts. The Armenian Genocide is a fact. Ottoman guilt is not up for discussion. Turkey has to deal with the legacy of the Otomman Empire and its own. And let me tell you the obvious: it is not a very nice one in anybody´s eyes, except for Turkey´s military and its nationalistic-on-the-verge-of-fascist population segment. What we don´t need is someone with the usual inferiority complex manifesting itself as a pretense superior. Oh, wow Turkey is a big country, lots of weapons, fighters (maybe a bit disorganized, judging by what goes on in Afghanistan, but still a force to be reckoned with) Of course Armenia will not engage Turkey militarily. Of course Armenia doesn´t have any demands on Turkish territory. Of course states and peoples behaviour is circumstantial and the future is not set in stone. I suspect that you know all that but you choose to create havoc by misquoting or using diversionary tactics. Quite sad, I must say. dear boghos, 1. the fact that i am a uwc alumnus does not mean that i will not defend what is mine to be nice to others. 2. i know and have never disputed the fact of genocide, ottoman culpability, and the unfortunate legacy it has left both for armenians as well as for turks. 3. no nation with an aspiration to civilisation brandishes weapons against anyone on every occasion, but there are some occasions that merit it (and the weapons that we both brandish here are mere words, may i remind you. when it comes to actual warfare i am pretty sure that most of the hottest weapon-brandishers on both sides will not show up). all i want is to preserve what is mine, and that is west of the river araxes. i have no eyes whatsoever on ROA, and will never have. not because i can't, but because i simply don't. i am concentrated on improving what is mine, which is no mean task in itself, and if there is any lesson i got from the experience of the ottoman empire, here it is: empire? no thanks. a number of the posts in this particular thread equate the possibility of turks becoming civilised with their giving of the eastern half of anatolia. that won't happen, i'm sorry. turks won't get an inch east of the border, but they won't move an inch west of it, either. you are welcome (as far as i am concerned) to live as first-class citizens in a civilised turkey after the recognition of the genocide, payment of reparations etc., and i would do my best as a humble citizen of turkey to this end. but no-one is welcome to take an inch of my land and place it under some other state's rule. that's where i take up arms. what would you do if the urartians were alive today and came up to you and said "listen, buddy, no matter what you say about being the inheritors of urartian culture, you are a balkan immigrant after all (your language says so), and i was living on this land before you came, and i am back now, ge the hell out of my land."? 4. i am not trying to create any havoc. i am saying something very simple, a real no-brainer: i want my country to stay intact, and will not tolerate eyes on it. i recognise its diverse heritage, the right of each and every nation on it to live as equals, i also recognise that wasn't the case in the past, and that is something which i deeply regret & don't want to see in the future, but i also want that all constituent parts of my country should make it a point to keep the country in one place. can you show me a single state that does not demand it from its citizens? 5. i refuse the charge of superiority complex. but i am also aware of our own power, as you are. that power isn't there for nothing. we are reluctant to use it, but we will if we are pushed to do so. we are merely issuing warnings now "don't cross that line and make me angry" that's all. we are not sending armies or anything, we just want you to ge our message.
  11. quote:Originally posted by MJ: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: This is just shameless... What a pity. mj, what is shameless about it? or did you once again took some word of mine mean that i find a justification or whatever for the genocide? or do you think the genocide occurred in a vacuum and was totally unconnected to what had happened before?
  12. quote:Originally posted by Arpa:PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT I HAVE NOT READ MAJORITY OF THE POSTS IN THIS CATEGORY. BUT THEN AGAIN I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO. I HAVE WITNESSED SUCH EXCHANGES NUMEROUS TIMES. TO ME IT IS AN EXCERCISE IN FUTILITY. I HAVE ALSO HEARD THAT SUCH EXCHANGES ARE A "DIALOGUE". NOT IN MY VOCABULARY. TWO MONOLOGUES DO NOT A DIALOGUE MAKE!!! WE WILL GET OUR TURN OF MONOLOGUE TOO. THERE IS ONLY ONE WAY OUT OF THIS QUAGMIRE. THAT IS "IN KIND". UNTIL THEN WE WILL ABIDE BY THE WORDS OF THAT GREAT AMERICAN PHILOSOPHER TEDDY ROOSEVELT; "WALK SOFTLY AND CARRY A BIG STICK". WE MAY NOT HAVE A BIG STICK YET. WE HAVE ENDURED THIS TURKISH GOBBLEDIGOOK FOR A MILLENIUM WE CAN WAIT A FEW MORE YEARS. UNTIL THEN "MUMS' THE WORD" arpa, 1. that wasn't a monologue but a dialogue. both parties were clear in their positions. the fact that they didn't agree doesn't turn it into a monologue. it has just been a dialogue with no results. you do run such a risk when you get into a dialogue. 2. you haven't endured any turkish gobbldygook for a millennium. a millennium ago, you endured the sword (a sword is not gobbledygook, it is always very clear what it is), then you endured the rule (that was also very clear, i guess), then in the 19th century you endured a sharply deteriorating condition (that was also very clear, i guess), hamidian massacres (i won't ask whether these were clear or not), a brief partnership in the young turk regime in which you preferred to keep an ambiguous position), and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide. any gobbledygook you might have endured dates from the post 1915-23 period, when the turkish state systematically denied what happened to your people. as i am sick and tired of repeating my position re the genocide and its denial once more, i won't get into that. you have never endured any gobbledygook regarding the land issue: you had a very clear answer: no. as far as we are concerned there isn't one. you can create one of course, by putting your nation at great peril. the greeks tried it in 1919-22, and then in 150s-1974 (cyprus), and have found out that there are certain lines you just can't cross. as far as you suggestion concerning the expansion of armenian military capability and the get even with us, i say you would be wasting your precious resources for a dubious adventure that will probably cost you more than it isa worth even if you win: it may very well be a pyrrhic victory. as turkey has no eyes on external soil in general and in armenia in particular, you would be wise to keep that in mind and concentrate on your efforts on rebuilding your country and having normalised relations and trade with your nations. who knows? you may even have peace one day. the worst kind of military-bent person is the one who has no military experience or aptitude. cheers,
  13. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, It maybe that you are right in spite of all the evidence to the contrary. The Turkish Foreign Affairs Ministry has published booklets on the Armenian Question once in a while and the embassies have been somewhat instrumental in putting Turke's unsusteinable position forward. It is not by brainwashing people that you solve this problem. You seem to believe in some kind of Orwellian masterplan for this...quite funny, I must say. If the Turkish State would simply praise the Armenian heritage in the country, name historic places clearly as Armenian and introduce Armenians as one of the key Anatolian civilizations, for example, that would be a step in the right direction. turkey will be taking steps in that direction, and maybe sooner than you think... wait and see.. cheers
  14. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Dear Ali, I find it a pity that you are not related to the Germany-based "Union or Committee Against Genocide". Their whole agenda consists of fighting against committees and organizations such as "The Committee Against Baseless Genocide Claims", struggling for freedom of speech in Turkey, releasing political prisoners and assisting the Armenians in healing from the genocide and its continuing denial. Ali Ertem and Bulent Gul have attended April 24 commemorations in Yerevan for the past decade or so. This year Bulent Gul was in Yerevan on April 24 and Ali Ertem in Paris on invitation of the Armenian community. About Turkey's recent move: I guess you're unable to see that Turkey is blatantly inciting hatred and potential war instead of heading towards recognition and peace. Let me be more specific. How would you react if you were taught, with ample evidence, that the genocide did not occur, and that the Armenians are spreading this lie all over the world just to make Turks look bad? Would you still like us? And would the number of "alternative" thinking Turks increase, in your opinion, decrease, or stay the same? Nairi 1. i am sorry. i misread it and confused it with the "commitees against baseless genocide claims" that we have in turkey. since i am based in turkey, i have no connection with them. i don't know if they have a branch in turkey (it would be a rather foolhardy thing to do as yet: you have to wait for the state's evolving stance to do something and survive). 2. you cannot teach with ample evidence that the genocide did not occur: armenians in turkey 1915: 1,295,000 armenians in turkey 1927: 300,000 armenians in turkey today: 45-60,000. and these are the official figures. you can say things like "well, there is no written proof, no orders, no anything", but someone would be quick to point out that the same applies to the jewish holocaust. you see, we evaded this issue until now. material relating to it (which actually abounds in turkish) was not collected, archives were closed, and there was a general taboo on the subject, so even in a room full of people who knew what happened no one person could say anything for fear of being spied. it is the one subject where you cannot voice your alternative opinion openly. the kurdish issue was like that when i was a teenager. now all restrictions on it are removed. it didn't happen in two days, but once you set the ball rolling, things happen remarkably quickly. and also don't forget: when i was young, the official sources were pretty much the only sources available. today on the other hand we have the internet, satellite tv, tourism, you name it. there is simply more info around and even things like dadrian's genocide is being sold without getting collected. so don't be so negative. don't of course expect the schools to start teaching everything the way you would like to see, after all it is the state, but eventually things will fall into place. cheers,
  15. quote:Originally posted by nairi:HOW MUCH SLOWER MUST THIS GO ALI???!!! At the rate Turkey, its embassies and organizations around the world are going, this may take another 8000 years or more to solve. WHAT alternative books? We read your books and don't believe a word. Why should an educated Turk believe our books if yours are written as well, if not better? On the side: What do you know about "The Committee Against Genocide" or "The Union Against Genocide", chairman Ali Ertem, vice-chairman Bulent Gul? Are you in any way related? Nairi that's an incentive to write good books . i know nothing about these organisations or people, nor am i in any way related. i think it is a bit of a waste of time if these guys just rehash the official story. cheers,
  16. quote:Originally posted by MJ: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: First, let me start from saying that I don’t see why Armenia doesn’t have the right to discuss border or territorial issues with Turkey. As far as Nalbandian goes, I don’t know who he is. Have not heard of him. The name of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia is Oskanian. Anybody else speaking on the subject of territorial claims to Turkey is irrelevant. Additionally, if some governmental employee is making formal declarations which go against the ones made by the President, he/she has to resign first, and then make such declarations, because then it is sort of fake. The only Diasporan Armenian Minister that I know in ROA is Oskanian, whose opinions always are representative of those of the President. Armenian State is not financed and ran by Diaspora any more than Turkey is financed and run by the US, EU, the International Monetary Fund, the World bank, etc. Your impression about a lot of unhealthy Armenians is accurate. That is one of the sad legacies of the genocide. You can read the texts of the Russio-Turkish and Kars Treaties of 1921 in Turkish and French in the Web page of the Ministry of Foreign affairs of Turkey. While, I agree with you that just the availability of International Law doesn’t manifest itself enforcement of such law, and I am far from being so naïve as to believe that the legal framework is anywhere enough to resolve territorial problems. As you can understand, the Armenian side has emerged victorious in the battles for Karabagh under the circumstances of having the International Law on its side, and this problem being of much smaller scale than the one with Turkey, this has not yielded satisfactory results. However, I don’t see why should the Republic of Armenia shy away from pursuing its legitimate rights. Also, I hope that you don’t of me as being so naïve and living in such a world of fantasies that would think that Turkey would cede any territories, nor you think I am so naïve that would think that Turkey would collapse and the territories would go to Armenians, nor would think that the Kurds would rebel against Turkey, per se, and by some “smart Armenian trick” the territories subject to discussion would be donated to Armenians in a gesture of remorse for the participation of the Kurds in the Armenian Genocide, or since we “share common enemy,” or some other absurd “theories.” dear mj, i agree with most of what you say, but can't resist commenting on the following: "Armenian State is not financed and ran by Diaspora any more than Turkey is financed and run by the US, EU, the International Monetary Fund, the World bank, etc." now turkey IS financed and run by the usa, eu, imf, and world bank to a very large degree. and it affects our internal politics to a very large degree. for instance the overwhelming majority of the people want to see ocalan swing on a rope, but since we want to get into the eu and land on german money, we can't hang the bastard (don't censor this last word as an insult, i was complimenting). cheers,
  17. quote:Originally posted by MJ: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: I would like to respond to an earlier material of yours, to which I could not respond earlier due to time limitations. You have asked, “would there be an armenian revolutionary movement if the russians, the french and the british had not inspired, agitated, encouraged, proselytised, educated, financed, and armed the armenians against the turks? “ My answer is yes there would’ve possibly been. The reason of Armenians’ “Rebellion” (which has not existed) was not the European or the Russian support, but their lousy living conditions under the Ottoman rule. Also, wherever Armenians have been armed (like in Van), they have not been slaughtered but through resistance have been able to save the lives of significant numbers. I would also like to invite your attention that as others, you call the Armenian activists Revolutionaries and not Liberators (though in the past, occasionally you have used the term “separatists.”) Revolutionaries are not separatists. They try to improve the country they leave in. In this sense, there was no difference between the Armenian Revolutionaries and the Young Turks. I think later in your material you sort of agree with these arguments. About the “separatist agenda.” I wish you where right. Additionally, I would like to add that separatists are those who want to separate lands from a host country. Few Armenians wanted their own lands back. It is disingenuous to call such “separatists.” I also agree with your arguments that the West has not been saint, either. However, the west recognizes its lack of sanctity, does not hold the victim responsible for being victim, does not continue its vandalism, and does not demand that its once victims drop any conversations about their claims, or else… This is what makes the genocide a contemporary issue. Otherwise, it would have belonged to the pages of history. The rest of your material can be qualified as you saying, “We are strong and you are week. If you can, come and fight us.” Well, that was always well understood. But we still want to think in terms of “goodness” and “badness.” Hope it is not too much to expect from the Turks. It has nothing to do with what we feel about the Turks (I don’t mean individual Turks but the nation in its entirety). And it is not because of being naive. We just have genuine interest in living next to a civilized country. I also remember you quoting me somewhere, and claiming that in “cold blood calculations, Armenian Revolutionaries have provoked massacres of Armenians hoping that Europeans will come to help.” While I might’ve claimed that some Revolutionaries have acted in cold blooded calculations, I have never meant to say that this has been a determining strategy explaining the massacres or the Genocide. Additionally, I have not meant to say that they -those of them who have adhered to such mentality, have done it out of “European” considerations. I have just meant that they have tried to awaken the Armenians – without much result, anyway. dear mj, i agree with a number of points that you raised. just a few notes below: 1. i wasn't implying anything by using "revolutionaries" here and "separatists" there. sloppy usage, may be, but i also think that as these were confused times, perhaps many people belonged to both. 2. i can understand that the basis of armenian rebellion (which you claim barely existed) was their lousy treatment under the ottomans. true. and therefore, i would not seek to morally accuse a subject nation to rebel against the ottomans, after all they wanted to live in dignity. fair enough. but of course, the ottomans could only be expected to strike back and a tragedy would happen (though it needn't be a genocide). 3. you (and many other armenians) claim that there wasn't much of an armenian rebellion or separatist activity to "justify" (as if anything could) ottoman reaction. this may be true in that there were perhaps 1.5 million armenians in the empire, and only a few tens of thousands joined armed struggle, while many others, especially the middle classes further west in istanbul, tried to talk them out of these activities. but of course, the fly is small but it makes your stomach turn. 4. of course it is not naive to think in terms of goodness about the turks. if it were, i would be very sorry for my nation. my nation is also not out there to kill your nation off, or otherwise harm you, as many of you apparently still fear, but believe it or not, or rather agree with it or not, they genuinely feel that they are also a wronged party. they do not necessarily see you as the ultimate villains, they rather maintain that you have been unfortunate pawns in a much greater conspiracy staged by the west and suffered terribly at the end. what they do not accept (rightly or wrongly) is that there was a premeditated plan to kill you off, and they genuinely believe that all this stuff about genocide recognition etc. is about getting hold of the six provinces. now you may find this ridiculous, but we have just got out of a 15-year long separatist kurdish war which was practically run by europe, and are therefore very alert to anything that smakc of turkey minus a chunk of it. you may call us paranoid, but even paranoids have enemies, and now, for god's sake, we are not your favourite nation, are we? of course the way the kurds were treated was beyond horrible, but do not forget that these people after all constituted the bulk of the actual killers in your genocide and are now sitting on the land on which you were sitting before 1915, and are claiming that land for themselves! at the end of the day, it is not naive to expect that if turkey no longer feels a separatist threat and when territorial claims have subsided, you will have a civilised neighbour that will not have eyes on you. after all, turkey has no land claims anywhere (not even cyprus), and anytime such claims were voiced (like mosul and kirkuk) they were silenced by the army rather than anyone else. as i say, the solution to all these problems is the dropping of land claims once and for all. 5. i know that you didn't mean that the armenian revolutionaries/liberators were calculating on a genocide. i didn't mean this myself. they were calculating on a series of massacres abdulhamid style, perhaps, that would give the west the pretext to intervene, but of course, nothing like a genocide. no-one was expecting it. i gotta dash now, cheers
  18. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Dear Ali, MJ just reminded me of something I wanted to ask you previously. What harm did it cause England after it returned all its colonies to their original inhabitants? How much did England suffer after they had no more control over India, many countries in Africa and numerous islands in the Caribbean? Also, what harm did it do to France to leave its colonies, including Morocco, Algeria, Lebanon, Haiti and many other countries? One more. How much did Holland suffer after returning to its original size (a little bigger than Armenia)? How much world power did Holland lose after leaving Indonesia, Surinam, the Caribbean and Africa? Also, how much honor did Holland or the Boers lose after De Clerq freed Nelson Mandela? And lastly, how much harm did it cause Holland to erect a monument in their own country dedicated to the horrors of slavery and colonization? Nairi dear nairi, you are right, but consider the following: nobody was trying to divide south africa or holland etc in two (nor had the power to do so). in our case, although we are confident that no-one can divide our country, the eu and russia for instance gave us serious trouble with the pkk, and the cyprus stuation is there to see. all we want is to be sure that no-one is going to attempt to divide our country. cheers,
  19. nairi you are being a bit unfair. what you want is that turkey ultimately recognises the genocide. o.k. you are a turkish politician and recognise it in a country where 89% of the population GENUINELY BELIEVE that it wasn't one. how long will you last? what you do is to prepare the public for it. and this is how you do it. of course they will defend the turkish thesis (just as you defend yours), but the very admission that there is a problem will turn the public eyes to "alternative" sources, just as it has done on the kurdish one. can't you see? this attitude of yours make it really difficult to go on for those of us who are striving to see the issue settled once and for all, you know. the turkish population is not on our side. the turkish state is not on our side. the armenian state is not on our side. the armenian population is not on our side. well, i am wondering what makes me go on when nobody is on my side.
  20. a small step for others, a giant leap for us. the very fact that the armenian question is going to be put into school curricula means that the government is admitting that there is a question in the first place, a thing they had never done until now to the best of my knowledge. such a step was totally unthinkable when i was at college. good for the state. and i think this proves my oft-repeated suspicion that the government is consciously preparing the national psyche to allow for the eventuall admission of the genocide. but i can't help adding the below comment: i am a bit confused. i am posting this n the 11th, three days after this piece of news was posted, and as far as i can see no armenian cares about it enough to even bother posting a comment. do you really care that much whether turkey recognised the genocide or not? i am not that sure anymore.
  21. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:if an armenian were able to reside in turkey, live a first-class life, openly say he is armenian and practice armenian way, get into and out of the region (including neighbouring armenia), hold dual nationality (it is possible under turkish law), then, what do you think, would it really matter that much that mount ararat is on the turkish side of a practically nonexistent border that you can cross even on foot? Ali jan, I think most Armenians want exactly what you described above. The group of Armenians that does want "lands back" will have to adapt themselves to the majority of Armenians who don't. There's nothing for Turkey to fear.that is something that we can eventually achieve, then. cheers,
  22. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:5. anyway, let's not munch our words: there is no way save warfare to make turkey cede territory, like it or not. and of course if this is our attitude (which it is) then we can be expected to do anything in our power to crush the land claims issue anywhere and everywhere we see it with whatever means we have. by advancing land claims you are basically telling me "get outta here, man, i'm gonna move in" and i say "over my dead body". this is what it takes to take land. as far as turks are concerned, land claims is not an issue that we can be expected to discuss. if anyone wants our land, let him take it from us the way we took it in the first place if he can. then it is his: have you ever seen us advance claims on central asia under the soviets and the chinese? do you now? you don't get land by claims, but by the sword, and if you don't have a sword to take it, then you don't get the land: we don't have the sword to take the altai mountains back, and therefore we don't talk about it, because we know that it is not by talking that we are going to get it. if you don't take my word for it, talk to any other nation which has actually taken land. there are plenty of them all over the place. This sounds very hostile Ali. Are you really sure this issue can't be solved peacefully? Nairi dear nairi, frankly speaking, i cannot see my nation agree to cede territory (especially one where they are now the majority), and looking around, i see no-one else doing it. i do not mean to be hostile, but i will defend what i consider to be mine if push comes to shove. but there is a way out: the europeans have been slaughtering one another for millenia over land issues, and now there are no borders between the lands that were drenched with their blood over and over again until fifty years ago. and they can now use it jointly, and don't care whether alsace is in france or germany, or schleswig-holstein in germany or denmark, or whether there is a "belgian" nation, given the fact that it is only 150 years old and the only thing that unites the protestant, french speaking walloons and the catholic, dutch-speaking flemish is french fries by their own admission. and brussels is the capital of europe! at the present state neither the turks nor the armenians seem to show the capability to think in these terms. if an armenian were able to reside in turkey, live a first-class life, openly say he is armenian and practice armenian way, get into and out of the region (including neighbouring armenia), hold dual nationality (it is possible under turkish law), then, what do you think, would it really matter that much that mount ararat is on the turkish side of a practically nonexistent border that you can cross even on foot? what do you think? also do not forget that people these days are less inclined to fight over land than living a good life. let's hold on to what we have and concentrate on making it better rather than trying to hold more. that's what we have learned from the ottoman experience. cheers,
  23. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Dear Ali, "what neither the turkish population nor the turkish state denies are the KILLINGS. they then set out to relate how te whole thing was mutual, i.e. both peoples killed eachother, and that the turks acted in self-defense (which is actually true in a number of cases)." Right, just in some cases.One cannot say that Arm population was homogeneously exterminated since some armenians in some distrcits had friends,respect,influence,etc. " what they deny is that there was a PREMEDITATED PLAN to exterminate the armenian nation as a whole (=GENOCIDE) that the state had worked out perhaps even before the beginning of wwi (this is the armenian position). you cannot blame the people for believing this for the following reasons: i) they people themselves had no plan to kill the armenians off, whether guilty or innocent, ii) you cannot of course expect the state to inform the public that they had such a plan (if they had one)" I agree with both. But there could not be such a fast massacre and deportation without a well-prepared plan, Ali. How,who,etc did it is a thing for investigation but it could not be done without the state.And nobody actuallyblames the whole turkish population for the genocide. iii) the deportations and killings were not applied to all districts and all types of armenians, and some armenians who were "mistakenly" deported were then sent back to where they came from and survived the war You are talking about some minority whereas the majority was massacred and deported. i agree though. iv) the turkish state had cited the russian threat and armenian treachery in the border provinces as a reason for the deportations, both of which were actual facts that were painfully experienced by the turkish people living in the region and carried out some revenge killing True. But going deeper one can ask a simple question - why should armenians try to "join" russians if everything was fine in turkey? Wasn't that a kind of response to the attitude toward the arm population in anatolia? v) the armenians did not and do not help their cause for genocide recognition by refusing to separate it from territorial claims. as far as we can see it is clear that the armenians are using the genocide issue to get a chunk of eastern anatolia and unite it with armenia (= they would not be content to live as first-class citizens in a civilised, prosperous turkey if there were one: the land MUST be taken away from turkey and given to armenia no matter what). Ali, where this information comes from? Armenian state has its position and you should follow that but not what different armenians from different diasporas say. vi) it is common knowledge which mj (if i am not mistaken) had also acknowledged in this forum that the armenian revolutionaries had made a cold-blooded calculation that if the turks were incited to kill the christian armenians, the christian west would move to intervene and give a chunk of eastern anatolia to the armenians (=necessary sacrifices must be made for our fatherland, the end justifies the means type of thought) I am not well aware of this but I guess that might be true. vii) we rarely if ever see the germans blamed side-by-side with us, when it is known fact that they had practically organised the whole thing (the germans recently released the documenation on that and do not deny their involvement). if we are to be fried, let them be fried with us. I agree. i think in the future when two countries (Arm/Turk) come closer to solving this problem all these thing will show up. but can it be done if today we have a recognition from german side but not from tukish whoch is more important. viii) as i have stated above, there are documents sitting in foreign countries' archives which pertain to the question and which are waiting to be published. when this is done, we are going to have a much different picture of the whole issue. Yes, and hopefully that will help solve the issue not vice versa. Thanks, Ali and good luck! Vahan dear vahan i agree with most of the points, but one: o.k. the armenians rebelled because of the pretty horrible ways of the ottoman government, and then the genocide took place. now a genocide is wrong no matter what, and as log as we stick to "we did this because you did that" there is no way out. we are neither those who killed nor those who were killed. we are all born one, two, three generations after that and have by a cruel twist of history inherited the memory of that nightmare. now we have to look toward the future and build our lives again and not allow this issue to dog our lives for generations to come. i guess you do not want your children living in a perpetual state of torment and desire for revenge, just as i don't want mine to live in a perpetual state of guilt, denial, doubt and paranoia. that's why i want my nation to eventually recognise the genocide and us both to get over it. to do this, turks must feel secure that their territoral integrity will not be put in jeopardy if they accept the genocide. you drop the land claims, we drop the denial. deal? cheers,
  24. quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by aurgucurious.dear rubo,======hagarag is basically right. being a turk is a cultural thing. if you speak turkish, are muslim (there may be exceptions to this), eat dolma, köfte, döner kebap, baklava, drink çay, türk kahvesi, rakı and ayran (there may not be exceptions to these save perhaps for rakı tly looking for a shortcut to big cash and early across your forehead, two black eyes, a nose the shape and probably the size of a potato, and a HUGE moustache (if you are a man), have fake blonde hair, black eyebrows and dark skin (if you are a woman), spend a ton of money on your outward looks and almost nothing on your brains (turks don't read much), etc. etc. then chances are that you are a turk even if your ancestors came from patagonia. see?[/QB] Dear ali, For amoment I thought you had lost your head and were describing an Armenian. Except for the fact that "an Armenian is BORN as such rather than MADE. There are no others in Turkey but Turks. Armenians are Christian Turks, Jurds are Mountain Turks, and so on. You see? An Armenian is an Armenian and is an Armenian. The Yezidis in Armenia some of which can write and speak better than 90% of all Armenians are Yzidis, can never be Armenians. Lt's forget the Yzidis and other minorities. Thos who don' subscribe to the monophysite doctrine, or was it the diphysite? Who the hell cares!! Are not true Armenians. There may those who may know more Armeniaca than the Catholicos will every know are not Armenians because they may differ on such esoteric points as "how many angels can dance on the head of a pin", are not Armenians. How do I know? I see one of them every morning while shaving. By your admission some 10 to 100 thousand Turks migrated to the Armenian Highlands. How could a mere guest minority overwhelm the native population? Why did they not learn the Armenian language and convert to the Armenian way of life and faith? You see? We had blood analysis laboratories in Armenia then as we do now. We were eons ahead in DNA analysis and it was deemed that those Central Asian nomads could not pass the test of "pure Armenian blood!!!" and were labeled as such. No matter what one eats and drinks, no matter how many euphemisms one has for XXXX., one can never be an Armenian unless one is born of two pure bred parents, no matter that their blood may have been "polluted" by Turkish blood along the way, be it with consent or coersion. An Armenian is one only if the Church says so. Even the State has little to say about it. I undertand they are building and rebuilding more churches in Armenia. Armenians may not have invented much but they surely invented that self destructive behavior. They sincerely believe in "qulity" and shun "quantity". Someone may choose to quote that idiotic poem; Menq kich en bayts...kanq"(We are few but we are...." WE ARE WHAT!!!???[/QB] dear arpa, i fully understand your point; and it shows crystal clear why we have managed to build a empire after empire and you have just managed to survive, getting ever smaller: we accept those who want to join us, accept our ways and give us something. in this fashion we grow in numbers. we couldn't care less what blood flows in your veins if you are prepared to shed it for our cause. a turk is not a turk because someone else says so, but because he says so (and those who don't say they are turks don't become one no matter who else says it: look at the kurds). one is not a turk because the mosque says so because the mosque is concentrated on islam which has a universal message and not ethnicity which doesn't have one. and at any rate even if it did no one would listen because it is none of the mosque's business. and i think there is a lesson in this for us both, one for you and one for me: three apples fell from heaven: one to you, one to me and one to him who related thisstory. cheers,
  25. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Dear Ali, While it is correct that there is no consensus amongst Armenians on the subject of the Genocide as far as the land claims are concerned, I think you have missed the crux of my statement – politically relevant Armenians do not mix the Genocide issue with the land claims. I also want to let you know that we understand that the contradictions between our Republic vs. Diaspora are going to be used by Turkey and Turks at least for rhetoric purposes, and Turkey is not going to deal with the issue unless it has no other way to go around it. As you know, states deal with states. States do not deal with Diasporas. Additionally, land claims are advanced by states and Diasporas have no relevance as far as the lands go. I also would like to point that the position of the Republic of Armenia has been crystal clear on the subject of the land claims in view of the Genocide, and as late as a year ago, the President of Armenia has made unequivocal declarations along these lines. It is obvious to any healthy person that one can not claim lands which have not been controlled by “him” for close to 1000 years based on such literary terms and myths as “Western Armenia,” etc. Additionally, there are no two governing Armenian bodies. There is one – the government of the Republic of Armenia. There is also a disappearing and chaotic entity called Diaspora, straggling for its identity and relevance – big deal. Additionally, there is only one framework under which Armenia (and not Diaspora) could present land claims to Turkey – it is the fact of the Kars Treaty (along with the Russo-Turkish Treaty) of 1921 violating the basic norms of International Law. This is also well understood by both governments and the knowledgeable people of healthy mind. Unfortunately or justifiably at this time, the Republic of Armenia has decided not to pursue the issue at least for now. Perhaps due to the understanding that in such case it has to deal with two regional superpowers – Russia and Turkey. Additionally, the government of Turkey being signatory in both treaties clearly understands its terms. It also understands that the Genocide in no way threatens Turkey’s territorial integrity. However, to deflect the public opinion inside Turkey as well as to direct the focus and the efforts of Armenians in an unproductive direction, Turkey successfully uses the fluff which comes with the Genocide claims. This way, Turkey is always one or more steps ahead of the Armenians, and it leads and manipulates Armenians the way it has successfully done for centuries. After all, it is enough for Turkey to have one statement along the denialistic lines to capture the focus of Armenians and preoccupy them with the efforts of the “denial of the denial” rather than the core issues. Sad? Sure. But this is apparently who we are. You may ask whose fault it is. I would say of coarse those who allow themselves to be treated as children with deficient brains. I have to go to work. Dear MJ, 1. I understand your position that the politically relevant Armenians don't mix the genocide isse with the land claims, but i still disagree with it. I know that Kocharian made an explicit statement that they didn't have land claims, but at about the same time a guy called Nalbantian (forgot his position, but was some important official guy) said that it was time to discuss the "border issues between turkey and armenia". this is what i mean when i say that we are confused about the armenian position regarding the genocide and land claims. one member of your government says one thing and another says another thing. who are we going to listen to? (by the way, i know - don't ask me where from, just trust me - that that Nalbantian statement was bought by the Diaspora for 2,000 USD. This is another reason why we are reluctant to separate the ROA from the Diaspora, which is unrealistic anyway: some of ROA ministers are Diaspora Armenians. The Diaspora finances, or claims to finance, Armenia. Do you realistically think that you can separate the two? 2. States deal with states and not diasporas. True, but if a state is partially financed and run by a diaspora (and it is, MJ, isn't it?), then you are indirectly dealing with the diaspora when directly dealing with the state. 3. you say it is obvious that no-one healthy can claim the lands which have not been under one's control for over 1,000 years based on words such as "historic". this definition gives me theimpression that there are a lot of unhealthy armenians out there, since there are so many that advance these claims. 4. re the kars treaty and the russian-turkish treaty: i don't know if it violates intenational law: i neither know the treaty nor the international law concerned. but as far as i can see, it is just another case of international law being violated. the cold truth here is that it international law will never have force behind it unless and until there is a strong body behind it that actually enforces it and defends it when it is violated. there are i am sure a ton of such cases all over the world which violate international law. well, the national law has the teeth and claws the international law obviously doesn't. can you see the clout in the u.n. to enforce such a law after their repeated failures everywhere? 5. anyway, let's not munch our words: there is no way save warfare to make turkey cede territory, like it or not. and of course if this is our attitude (which it is) then we can be expected to do anything in our power to crush the land claims issue anywhere and everywhere we see it with whatever means we have. by advancing land claims you are basically telling me "get outta here, man, i'm gonna move in" and i say "over my dead body". this is what it takes to take land. as far as turks are concerned, land claims is not an issue that we can be expected to discuss. if anyone wants our land, let him take it from us the way we took it in the first place if he can. then it is his: have you ever seen us advance claims on central asia under the soviets and the chinese? do you now? you don't get land by claims, but by the sword, and if you don't have a sword to take it, then you don't get the land: we don't have the sword to take the altai mountains back, and therefore we don't talk about it, because we know that it is not by talking that we are going to get it. if you don't take my word for it, talk to any other nation which has actually taken land. there are plenty of them all over the place. cheers,
×
×
  • Create New...