aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
hi to everyone again, first, i have not been able to post for a while for I AM GETTING MARRIED THIS YEAR! i had always feared the prospect (my dad is in his 3rd marriage), but at the tender age of 34, i finally conceded, and quite easily at that! i had to travel all the way to antakya (antioch) to get her family's approval, and i did! so, sorry for the absence but it was due to force majeure (love), xqz me. now re the points raised: i had pointed out earlier that members of this forum agreed on more points than they realised. broadly speaking, i agree with everything said under this thread, especially tb's analysis of the balkan muslims' attitudes towards the anatolian christians. that was very good, tb. now re the massacres and other armenian "subversive" activities in the empire prior to 1915: i have been telling that i would compile a chronology of them, so far i have not been able to keep that promise, partly due to the force majeure mentioned above, partly due to the difficulty of actually getting sources on the issue safely, partly due to lack of time, and partly due to sheer laziness (very naughty of me). most turkish sources that i saw tend to give graphic and detailed accounts of massacres from 1917-1918. there were disturbances before, and the russian armenians did horrible things, most of which still survives in folk memory (our maid's relatives in refahiye, erzincan were wiped out by armenians), but as far as folk memory is concerned, they are quite unable to accurately date the events and especially order them chronologically (before/after deportations). turkish sources that i saw tend to concentrate on massacres from 1917-1918 because they have pictures of them as well as survivor accounts (some such ancients are still alive at phenomenal age), but as for the pre-1915 and especially pre-20th century stuff, hard evidence as opposed to urban legends is harder to find. of course this is not to mean that the armenians prior to 1915 or 1891-94 had done anything on a scale that would warrant (excuse the term) the cruelties that followed. now re another point, i.e. whether the turks were aware of the nature and scale of the things that they were doing (or were being done in their name), allow me to point out that most save some half-dozen members of the CUP were not aware of the true intent of the deportations until reports reached istanbul. here an interesting issue to raise would be the rumelian origin of talat and enver and the anatolian origin of the others. my own great-grand father, who was a most prominent member of the CUP, did not realise what was going on until it was too late (he did manage to have some armenians sent back to istanbul, though). my impression has been that 1) the concept of "genocide" i.e. wholesale murder of a nation was alien to turks, turks rather tend to have a heavy hand for whatever they see as criminal attitude, but planned liquidation of a nation was not something they were familiar with (i suspect something teutonic there), 2) most of the individual massacres were carried out with a view to revenge (rough justice) for what had happened in the balkans and the caucasus, at least the actual perpetrators were motivated so, 3) the general population was by and large not aware that a countrywide extermination was going on, they could only see what was going on in their vicinity due to poor literacy (literacy rate was about 10%, mostly concentrated in istanbul and a few other big cities, in the east, where most of the armenians resided, and where most massacres took place, hardly anyone was literate) and almost non-existent communications (no mass media, and wireless was controlled by talat), 4) the reaction of civilian and offical turks to the extermination campaign was by no means uniform: some officers refused to comply with orders, risking their necks, some turkish and kurdish villagers sheltered armenians, there were fights between local turks (in kastamonu and kiğı (keghi) esp.) and the incoming army, 5) some very prominent figures of the ottoman ruling class, including people no less than abdulmedjid ii (later caliph) and fevzi çakmak (later marshall) are known to have made statements condemning the killings, and even mustafa kemal is reported to have made at least two statements on the subject, one in 1920 and another in 1926. also, the fact that most of the "abandoned goods" of the armenians were in fact looted by talat and his gang leads me to think that material gain was not an insignificant motivator in the killings, including their planning. my candid opinion is that there were perhaps fewer than half a dozen people at the outset who really knew what was to come, and the fact that it was executed relatively quickly (most of it within a matter of months) and in the turbulent setting of wwi gave people little time to react. i feel we turks have been deceived and led into disaster by the CUP no less than the armenians, and i feel disgusted that we still revere these figures in school books. zülfü livaneli had recently written in sabah about us carrying the sin of the CUP. good reading. cheers,
-
Gallup Poll Exposes the Myth Of Turkish-American Friendship
aurguplu replied to hyecory's topic in International
oh my hey guys, turkey does not get anything from the usa because the usa likes turkey or the turks. there are three main reasons turkey gets anything from the west for: 1. turkey is just north and west of some 85% of the world's oil. all the other states in the region concerned, save turkey and israel, are rogue states. 2. turkey is south of russia, west of iran, north of arabia, and east of eu. any statesman with the slightest claim to intelligence would do his/her best to include such a state among allies for strategic reasons alone. 3. turkey is israel's only ally amongst muslim countries, and has been so since 1949, almost immediately after israel was founded. and it has had a good record ever since. 4. turkey is the only muslim country which has shown a sustained and on the whole successful effort at westernisation, and thus represents a (the only) model for the rest of the islamic world. in addition, even though turkey has the human rights and recent historical (1915 etc) record that we all know, it cuts a far better profile when compared to countries such as syria, iraq, iran, russia etc. now as far us aid to turkey is concerned, first of all it is not quite that high, and second, it is not for free: the usa has crucial military bases in turkey, without which cold war survey of soviet military activity and more recently, the campaigns against iraq and lastly against afgahnistan would either have been much more difficult or downright impossible. in addition, the usa extracts a number of strategic resources in turkey (such as uranium and boron), the financial value of which are not disclosed. as for where the aid ends up: it never reaches us, ahmed efendi mehmed efendi, ayşe teyze fatma hala. it evaporates somewhere up there, and we never see any of it. so how can you expect the common turk to love the usa? for something he never gets his hands on? regards, -
hey guys it's been a while since i last contributed to the forum. now re this topic, i.e. whether the armenians had killed the turks, may i humbly inform you that such things did indeed occur. it is true that most such massacres (there were not all that few of them, by the way) occurred after 1915, so that you can call it rough justice if you can rough justice justice. some of them had occurred before 1915, though, some having taken place as far back as the last quarter of the 19th century. of course, these massacres, even if some of them were on quite large scales (involving several thousand victims), could not be used as a justification for the genocide later on. and of course, the notion "turks being victimised by armenians" is ridiculous on the larger scale of things. but one should not blind oneself to the fact that being a victim does not mean that no-one has been or will be your victim: the danger of this attitude can be seen in israel/palestine today: the jews there are trying to occupy as much land as they possibly can, and use the europeans' sense of guilt and sympathy to the very end to reach their goal. the serbs tried to do the same thing in the balkans with less success. and i hope it would no be too much to expect from the distinguished forum members to concede that merely being armenian does not make anyone immune to criminal inclinations. regards, ali suat
-
hyecory, ozkok's articles are written by a turk for the turkish public in a commercial daily. the function of the press is to form the public opinion rather than to accurately inform him. that second task is that of the researcher. official and semi-official attitudes toward the genocide and other skeletons in turkey's cupboard proceed like the mehter band, as we say (two steps forward, one step backward), not necessarily because the government is trying to gain time while busy preparing for a new trick, but for the very simple reason that the intelligentsia and much of the ruling classes (including the military) are much more liberal and progressivist in their attitude toward such sensitive issues than the populace at large. the problem is that they are heading a nation that is not - yet or rather, anymore - capable of handling the truth. the reason why we are not is that we have been deliberately forced to unlearn what we knew of the past, and we were also forced to unlearn logic, common sense, and reasoning. people thought and learned and judged and decided for us, instead of us, and about us for a good seven decades. and now, the top is trying to introduce a degree of liberalism into a population that was artificially rendered paranoid by three generations of state propaganda. it is not easy, nor is it without bumps and hiccups. but it is going in the right direction, and the main indication of this is that there is far more talk about the armenian "question" than there was ever before in the history of the republic. i remain confident that this decade will see the official recognition by the turkish government of those events as a genocide. regards, [ February 26, 2002: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
the above postings confirm my previous replies to concerns about turkish counterpropaganda. basically i had said the armenians had nothing to worry about. if this is the quality of counterpropaganda the denialists can produce, then i would just shut up and let the guys make a tilt of themselves. in turkish we have a saying "a clever enemy is better than a stupid friend". the guys hired the history-expert version of erich von daniken, my god! i can't believe it! cheers,
-
to add: may i suggest you read the preface of gerard chaliand to archavir chiragian's "la dette de sang" (original title in english: the legacy), and also, the famous letter by boghos noubar ***** to the allies after the war. may i repeat (i wonder if this is necessary) that i am in no way trying to minimize turkish guilt and maximize armenian one (which was infinitesimal, but still there). i am only trying to contribute to the emergence of a FACTUAL account of what really happened. q: how do we know that a factual account has emerged? a: i don't know for sure, but if all parties concerned (and this will include people other than the turks and the armenians) are EQUALLY displeased with what comes out, then we will probably be quite close to one. regards,
-
Domino, 1. the armenians were not killed simply because they were christians. there were armenian revolutionary bodies, formed in the late 19th century, with the aim of overthrowing the ottoman administration and establishing a free state. terrorist activities by some of these groups also date from that period. the armenians had also formed armed groups who had fought on the russian and french sides BEFORE 24th April, 1915. this is not taken from any turkish propaganda but from actual armenian accounts which give detailed info on the above moreover, armenian inflammatory propaganda directed at the ottoman armenians (in some cases multilingual) also abounds, and could be found in the libraries and archives of any self-respecting academic institution that specialises in the affairs of that period, not necessarily founded/run/staffed/financed/directed by turkey (some such institutions exist in england, germany, france, and the usa, for instance). 2. during the occupation of istanbul after the armistice, british occupying forces sent some 150 members of the CUP to malta WITHOUT CHARGES (i.e. they were detained with no reason officially communicated to them, and only passing, unofficial references were made to their "suspected complicity in alleged war crimes". the detention lasted for longer than a year, during which time the british in istanbul had confiscated the ottoman archives and sifted through the entire material WITH THE HELP OF THE ARMENIAN OFFICIALS who had previously served the ottoman government (so in fact these guys knew more about what happened than . at the end of the year, they found nothing that incriminating the 150 or so men they were detaining, so they released them and sent them back to turkey. one of these was my great-grandfather, so this information has not been gleaned from history books, nor from any turkish propaganda website, but from family accounts. of course, all this is in no way to mean that the armenian genocide did not take place, or that the overwhelming majority of those who perished were not totally innocent, and that it was not a crime that forms one of the black pages of world history, or that i am in fact a turkish grey wolf in disguise trying to convince the armenias whose ancestors perished in the genocide that the genocide didn't take place, that it was all an illusion. but the armenians do not have to resort to lines like "we were killed simply because we were christians" or "they got the guilty guys and then set them free" to defend their case. you do not need that sort of fabrication when the simple truth that armenian presence in anatolia was practically put to a most cruel end in about a year and a half. regards,
-
Is this the Turkey that will be admitted in the EU ?
aurguplu replied to Boghos's topic in International
dear Domino, dear boghos, i was not trying to be defensive, nor was i trying to defend the idiotic statement of ekinci. but the simple matter is this: the guy has made his way into the parliament, and this system called democracy that we admittedly do not administer very well, gives you the right of speech. so he speaks. what can you do, if you are ciller (not that she is any better), other than apologise to the patriarch. if you get him chucked out of your party, he'll move to anap or mhp, and of course by getting himself terminated over such a matter he'll be the darling martyr of the grey wolves, ensuring a step upward. i know that you do not much enjoy turkish in this forum, but allow me to add one couplet that (in my humble opinion) summarises the issue reasonably well (sorry for the rude nature of it): sıçtı cafer bez getir sulu sıçtı tez getir those who know turkish may perhaps come up with a matching english or armenian equivalent for the benefit of the forum members. (mj sorry for the rude word it contains) regards, ali suat -
konya, what could be the jews blamed of by any stretch of the imagination?
-
Is this the Turkey that will be admitted in the EU ?
aurguplu replied to Boghos's topic in International
boghos, pm silvio berlusconi of italy made a statement after the 11th september attacks saying that "the islamic civilisation is infreior to ours, and that we ought to be proud of ours, and not let them in etc" or something to that effect, to the amazement and strong condenmation of a substantial majority of the eu population. there are (or were) far right EMPs in the european parliament, who made statements comparable to that of ekinci regrading the muslims and other europeans of non-european origin. one of the pillars of the eu is freedom of speech. now god was most generous in handing out the faculty of speech to almost everyone, but he was a little bit less generous with the faculty of making sense when one speaks, hence the remarks of ekinci. under the turkish penal code currently in force, imbecility is not a criminal offence. in fact in turkey it is a highly useful trait, making a successful career in politics a good deal easier, as a cursory glance at out national parliament would reveal. currently the legal system is undergoing revision to match eu standards, but as far as i know, the penal code does not identify imbecility as a criminal offence, either. so we will have such people making some statements. maybe his was a belated reaction to the recent row over the movie (the beads of salkım hanım). at any rate, even a half-wit like ciller had the good sense to apologise to the patriarch, so i think we should regards this guy as an enfant terrible and not put too much store to his actions. do not forget: what you say about something says as much about you as it does about the thing you are talking about. regards, -
hi everyone, i see we are getting bogged down in the number business again. i propose we settle down on the following: 1. there are no reliable figures of the armenians in the ottoman empire prior to the genocide, or 1890-1895, ottoman, armenian, western, or otherwise. 2. the available figures range from just over one million to two and a half million. most armenian or armenian-quoted figures are between 1,100,000-2,100,000. the ottoman official figure is 1,295,000, so the 1,100,000 can effectively be ruled out. so we have an armenian population of between 1,300,000 (rounded up) to 2,100,000, averaging 1,700,000. i think this is a reasonably good educated guess to start with. 3. apart from 300,000 or so souls in istanbul and thrace, most of the remainder (over 1,000,000) resided in anatolia at the time. today there are some 400,000-600,000 anatolian armenians in the diaspora from the genocide all over the world as far as i can see. this means that about 500,000 armenians at least must have disappeared. allowing for a substantial number that converted, we can say that the dead are no less than about 400,000. now 400,000 dead is genocide. this is a quarter to a third of the population (statistically about one member from each family). 4. however much they can play with numbers, they cannot deny that mass killings occurred, since these are well documented and admitted by turks themselves. now mass killings deliberately committed by governments is called genocide. if all else fails, just ask who built all those churches in anatolia and where they are now. regards,
-
hi elchin, according to ottoman sources, there were 1,295,000 armenians in turkey in 1914. in the 1927 republican census, there were about 300,000 of them. today there are 65,000-80,000. what happened to them? regards,
-
dear twilight bark, i agree with most of your points, especially regarding genetics and language. i also share your antipathy of warlike tribes (or, war itself, rather) and the ghosts that haunt the topic "genetics". re the phrygian theory and the hayasa: of course, the phrygians caused some destruction when they came into anatolia, but this happened with virtually everyone everywhere. invasions aren't peaceful. regarding the hayasa, hittite, and the luvians, since their language is indo-european (or rather indo-hittite), they (the languages) must have come from somewhere, and linguistic research points to southern russia as the putative homeland of the indo-european languages. now indo-european homeland is a hotbed of debate, and it can well be said that it is on casters, but it is most likely to have been somewhere in russia (admittedly a big place) and in the vicinity of uralic. there are now some researchers (cyril babaev etc) who posit an anatolian homeland for indo-european, but this poses far more problems than it solves, and as far as i know, has not been accepted by the majority of the linguistic community. this of course is not to be taken to mean that the armenians are not native to anatolia, they have been there for at least three thousand years, and this is long enough to be considered native! after all they have been there for far longer than most people have been anywhere. regards,
-
whiteangel, you sound like a turk talking about the kurdish issue. are you chinese? regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Now businessmen in Istambul are organizing against recognition of the Armenian Genocide. What is the motivation here? Ali Suat claims that none of the wealth of Turkish industrialists emanted from the confiscated wealth of Armenians. Given the frenzy we see in Ankara, I would tend to disbelieve that premise. hagarag, when did i claim that? in fact i thought i had claimed, and demonstrated the veracity of, the opposite (i can do it again if asked). regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag: So Atom Egoyan directs a play "Salome" in Canada and a theatre reviewer of Jewish background, Tamara Bernstein, claims he is promoting the anti-Semitic elements of the play. Egoyan states that he is presenting the play exactly as Oscar Wilde depicted the story. I would bet anything that the Turks have their hands in this. They are petrified about "Ararat." They know that the dike is about to burst. They know that they are hiding something major. So they are stirring up Jews against Egoyan. I, for one, can anticipate their every move. Their modus operandi is something that some of us clearly understand. dear hagarag, with all due respect, i beg to differ: 1. egoyan may indeed be directing a play with anti-semitic elements in it. there are such literary and other works, many by major western artists, and if you are going to be faithful to the script you end up being compelled to reproduce the anti-semitic element. 2. i am not an anti-semite in any way, but i do suspect that the jews have a huge network of "moral policemen" throughout the world that spend an inordinate proportion of their resources on unearthing anything vaguely anti-semitic. the most dangerous thing to do in the post-holocaust wold today is to say anything that might possibly be interpreted as meaning that jews are anything less than pure angels with only the wings missing (look: if a palestinian whose entire family is being massacred by the israeli forces says anything against israel or the jews, it is anti-semitism, if israel elects someone like sharon (of sabra and shatila fame) as the prime minister, you may only comment favourably about it for fear of being branded an anti-semite). you really do not need a turk to motivate a jew against any alleged "anti-semitism". 3. the jews do have a problem with other people who have been victims of genocide, because they see theirs as really without parallel (in fact in this i agree with them). this is of course selfish, ignorant and immoral: the fact that the armenian, bosnian, cambodian, rwandan and other genocides of the 20th century were not quite as horrible as the jewish holocaust does not minimise their horror any the less. the jews really should be more considerate of the plight of others. 4. i think people are exaggerating the attention turks pay into the egoyan movie as well as the lenghts they are prepared to go to stop it. let me be clear on this: talk is all they will do. maybe they will ask the jewish lobby to do somethng about it, maybe they will hire some western actor to play ataturk in a propaganda movie. what they will not do is spend huge sums of money on it. and propaganda needs huge sums. absolutely colossal ones, especially when it is a truth that you are trying to hide and a lie that you are trying to push. i tell you, they won't do it. they didn't before. they even didn't do it in cases where they were right (like the oppression of bulgarian turks under the reign of zhivkov). turks don't like to spend money, they have a million excuses not to, they (the govt and the private sector) would rather siphon off the money and live a life in paris, london, new york, california. besides, as i had stated before, even in turkey itself, they are allowing the public to get more and more exposed to the idea of genocide. even if they are doing something like that, it would be just to "save face", they know they cannot do it forever. so i would not put that much store to turks conspiring with jews against the movie. relax & cheers,
-
dear twilight bark, 1. i agree with your points in general. in fact, it seems to me that members on this forum do agree on a number of things without actually realising it. 2. re the anatolian turks and armenians being closer kinsmen than the anatolian turks and the uygurs: on a genetic level this is true, as it is on a number of cultural traits, but two important points should not be overlooked: 1) on some important cultural points, most notably language, the two turkic peoples are obviously closer than they are to armenians and the chinese (to whom the uygurs would be more closely related genetically). now language is a very crucial factor, being far more than a means of communication, it is also the framework for a mindset, a way of looking at the world, and also, a repository of culture. 2) the turks came into anatolia mainly in two major waves in 11th and then 13th centuries, true, but then, there was a steady tricle of central asian turks into anatolia that lasted until early this century. many turks who were displaced by the mongol invasions ended up in turkey, some mongols (the mongols were never a particlarly numerous nation, and the bulk of chinggis' army was turkic) also became first turkified and settled in turkey, and later on, when the russians invaded central asia and tartary, many central asians and tatars fled to turkey. and also, in this century, we received a number of immigrants from russia, china, tibet, afganistan etc. now one point people in this country forget is that these people, like the 11th-13th century turks who came into anatolia, were already ethnically mixed. in brief, the turkic component in the makeup of anatolian turks is not confined to the 11th-13th century invasions, but the incoming turks were already quite mixed, anyway. 3. re the origin of the armenians and the phrygian component: now the phrygians did exist, and they spoke an indo-european language that is scantily recorded. armenian is also an indo-european language, although one strongly affected by caucasian languages. armenian forms an independent branch of the indo-european family tree, with no known close relatives. phrygian was written, although as a dead language (much like latin in the 15th century) up to the 3rd century ad, i.e. a century before armenian was written down for the first time. the two languages do not appear to be closely related, although the phrygian language is perhaps too poorly attested to allow for a comprehensive comparison. both languages show a closer similarity to greek than to the other indo-european languages, though. there is abundant evidence for the phrygians having migrated from the balkans (moesia), and to have first spent some time in western anatolia (mysia), and being known to the caucasians and the hittites by another name (sa-mekhi, muski). the phrygian king midas was very likely the mita of muski in the hittite records, i.e. a historical figure. the name "phrygian" comes from the same root as the english "brigand" and means the same thing. the ethnonym appears to have been something like musi, muski. this also appears to have been the name by which the georgians call the armenians (sa-mekhi). in brief, i would not treat the armeno-phrygian hypothesis outright as a fable, there appears to be a serious case for it. perhaps the most likely explanation is that the early armenian speaker were phrygian colonists (or some close cousin) who mixed with the indigenous anatolians. after all, the language must have come from somewhere! 3. re the armeno-turkish kinship being closer than our kinship with the uygurs. if this is the case, could i please ask the forum members to refrain from posting things like "mongol+greek+armenian+dog+rat+snake= turk" (i think it was hyecory). one should be more respectful of kinsmen. 4. re the myth of turkish past in turkey today: i) first of all, it is nowhere near as strong as it was in the 1930s when it was first invented. ii) the same republic that produced that myth also put enormous effort into discovering the anatolian heritage, and today we do have (a few) world-class archaeologists in the fields of classical and pre-classical anatolian history and archaeology. now these may sound to contradict one another, but if you keep in mind that the aims of the republic in the area of culture were fourfold, namely a) to remove from the turkish historical consciousness the ottoman, and more generally, the islamic, heritage and to replace it with something that would not be diametrically opposite the notions of westernisation, secularism and republic, to create a national identity instead of a religious one, c) to counter claims of being invaders by claiming turkish origins for the earlier inhabitants (the "turkish land for forty centuries" dogma), and d) to make the nation receptive to the former glories of anatolia, and also to claim ownership of them, then the whole thing may look more coherent. of course, this was part lie, part theft, part gross distortion of some historical truths, but it did serve its main purposes for the time: it turned our eyes away from islam to the west, we did become receptive to the western and by extension pre-turkish anatolian cultures, and of course anyone who carried these interests a bit further would never have encountered any difficulties in discovering that the hittites, sumerians etc. were not turkic. and today, if you declared at a university hall that they were, you would be the laughing stock of academia (even turkish academia). it was a temporary move. one should not forget the political motives behind it, and one should not exaggerate its influence on the current intellectual thought in turkey. it was a kind of "royal lie". regards, [ January 25, 2002: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
whiteangel, 1) i agree with most of what you say concerning the genetic makeup of anatolian and central asian turks. in fact, few if any educated turks would disagree. what few people realise is that we are perfectly happy wit the fact that we are central asians+anatolians+iranians+slavs+greeks+armenians+anyone else we came across. of course, if you have been mixing with people, your culture is also going to be mixed. i can pick you any carpet from central anatolia, and the motifs on it will be anywhere from china to greece, so is the case with the rest of our culture. this is accepted fact. as for myself, i can cite over a dozen nationalities that went into my own genetic makeup, and at least three with their pre-conversion (christian) names (anna, roxelana, mara). this doesn't make me any less turkic, since i profess to be a member of the turkic nation and none other. now as far as the uygurs are concerned, we know that they are not alone in chinese turkestan (but they form - or formed - the majority). i might differ from a good few other turks in that i am not in support of a separate state for them (if every nation got a separate state of its own, we might well end up with a thousand states, none of them viable, and also, i find it a matter of political honesty (admittedly, the two notions are frequently mutually exclusive) not to wish for another state what i don't wish for mine). the thing is that we have over here a number of uygur turks who had been horribly treated by the chinese authorities (not that they treat the han chinese any better), and these things with above-ground detonations can not by any stretch of the imagination thought to be benevolent, and their effect would clearly be genocidal. i do not know whether uygur harass or harassed other ethnic groups, i know that there have been clashes in kyrgyzstan between the uygurs and the kyrgyz, we of course could not take sides since both of them are turkic. much as i may condemn the armenian genocide and the persecution of the kurds in turkey, i cannot fail to see similar things taking place elsewhere on earth, and some of my kinsmen falling victim to them. if i can be expected to do the former, i can expect in return that the latter be taken into account and adequately condemned and taken action against by the world community. regards,
-
mj i messed it up again. my computer had had a failure and only the first half of my posting had appeared in the first post, then i clicked "reply w/ quote" and retyped the rest, it appears as another post, all in black . it is the same as the truncated one above. apologies. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear hagarag, dear thoth, 1) i do not think that the conversation has degraded into insults (at least not my contribution, i hope). rather it has been one of "strong words". given the sensitivity of the topics under discussion, and the fact that we, by the nature of things, cannot be -and cannot be expected to be - totally impartial about them, such outbreaks of passion are inevitable. i see no danger in them as long as we both can show restraint and stay above a certain level, below which it would be insults. the fact that we are agreed on a number of fundamental points (like the genocide) and that we are quoting references (well, frequently, at least), i hope, will preserve us from such deterioration. 2. turkey will eventually accept the genocide, but it cannot be expected to take place overnight. as a rule, weak nations, like weak people, are not inclined to admit to their faults, for the very practical concern that such an admission could later be used against them. now turkey is not particularly strong and stable, and has in its short history suffered from an almost 30-year long one party rule, three military coups, a hanged prime minister and two ministers, a decade long left-right civil war, the aegean and cyprus disputes with greece, an ethnic-based fifteen year long civil war in which it lost 30,000 people, yet another military intervention, a war in iraq that cost it 10% of its export revenues, and a surge in islamic fundamentalism. plus the area we live in is not a shining example of neither democracy, nor human rights, nor peace, nor political stability, nor economic prosperity. we also do not boast the most enviable set of neighbours, at least to the east (iran, iraq syria). add to this the genuine (and not unfounded) concern that her territorial integrity is not universally accepted (the eu still refuses to accept the pkk as a terrorist organisation), and turkey's rather aggressive (or defensive) behaviour would come as no surprise. we are simply never left in peace. turkey has genuine concerns that the admission of the genocide today would pave way to the reemergence of armenian territorial claims on turkish soil. the fact that we have demanded the armenian government several times to express their stance on this issue clearly, to no avail (they have declined to express cut and clear that the armenian republic had no claims on turkish territory, they rather munched their words like "how can you expect such a small nation as ours to have claims on the territory of such a big nation like yours (kocharian), which does not mean "no, we don't"). these things have to be sorted out before the genocide recognition. once this is done, there won't be any serious problem with the genocide recognition. 3. the "property tax" and the 6-7 september 1955 events are universally (well, almost) regarded as black pages in turkish history by turks. in fact, if my memory does not fail me, the 6-7 september incidents were the only case when the government officially apologised to the minorities. we think little better of the property tax horror. true, the government has not yet officially apologised to the minorities for that, but a number of non-official statements were made by high-ranking individuals to the point that it is commonly accepted as a source of shame by those turks who know it. also, the one minority community that was most seriously hurt by the property tax was the jewish one, and the jews themselves do not want the issue to surface at the moment (a most prominent member of that community, mr. ishak alaton, had said in a television programme two years ago (or was it last year?) that "its time would also come" (the programme was about the (apologies: "so-called") armenian genocide. turkey and israel are serious allies at the moment, and will likely be so for a very long time, and neither side wants to rekindle some bad old memory stuff. the time will come when it's time. 4. i do not think that liking the country's government to strike a genuine friendship with a citizen of that country is a prerequisite. otherwise, we would find it a bit hard to have chilean, argentine, chinese, russian, nigerian, israeli, iraqi, iranian, and (ugh) afghan friends, wouldn't we? if you don't like my government, well, then, that makes two of us (and i have much more valid reasons, believe me, i am living in the country they are xxxxing up). i don't expect anyone to like my govt, as i don't myself, just evaluate me as a person, for i do the same re you. regards,
-
dear hagarag, dear thoth, 1) i do not think that the conversation has degraded into insults (at least not my contribution, i hope). rather it has been one of "strong words". given the sensitivity of the topics under discussion, and the fact that we, by the nature of things, cannot be -and cannot be expected to be - totally impartial about them, such outbreaks of passion are inevitable. i see no danger in them as long as we both can show restraint and stay above a certain level, below which it would be insults. the fact that we are agreed on a number of fundamental points (like the genocide) and that we are quoting references (well, frequently, at least), i hope, will preserve us from such deterioration. 2. turkey will eventually accept the genocide, but it cannot be expected to take place overnight. as a rule, weak nations, like weak people, are not inclined to admit to their faults, for the very practical concern that such an admission could later be used against them.
-
ok everybody 1. re the burning of smyrna: as i had stated, i do not claim to know enough about the burning of smyrna to carry out a well-informed discussion about it. i'll have to go and check my sources, but at this point in time this will be a bit difficult as 1) i hva not updated the concerning parts of my library for years, and 2) my existing references may be turk-biased. i do not want to parrot unwittingly some propaganda stuff. 2. re karabekir: i'll check the references Domino gives in his "istiklal harbimiz". i happen to own the original edition, which was collected at one time for the apparently unsavoury comments he had made on some of the latter heroes of the republic (later in life he also fell apart with ataturk on the preservation of the empire versus the establishment of a republic and particularly on the alphabet issue). but (i don't have the text in front of me) what i had read of it so far tells me that 1) he was stationed elsewhere in 1915, and 2) he fought an invading army in 1919-21. again, i have to get back to the book and quote the relevant chapters. i am neither an admirer nor a condemner of karabekir, and would not actually be surprised if i found that he also engaged in the liquidation of the armenian population (the militia is another matter). let me do my homework, and then we can have an interesting discussion. regards,
-
to all, 1. yes, it was a spiced-up conversation, but given the sensitivity of the issue we were discussing, and given the fact that we both are parties to it, it is inevitable that conversation gets spiced up at times. i am not offended that it does so (though i agree with thoth that we could show some restraint), i hope no-one gets offended by me, either. 2. i think i have been misunderstood as maintaining that "armenians should be thankful to us for not having been treated quite as badly as the subjects of the europeans everywhere else". no, i do not think that they should, and i can perfectly understand - and agree with - that no-one likes their conqueror, oppressor, bully, whatever you call it - which we were. we had also been bullied in our history by a number of other peoples, and we didn't like that, either. why should we expect that of others? (but i do concede that my postings might have been read a bit to that effect, yes. 3. i do think that up to the 19th century ottoman subject peoples were treated better than european subject peoples, although i readily concede that by today's standards that leaves a lot to be desired. i also would not deny that it was just as much realpolitik as a beacon of civilised conduct on the part of the ottomans. but i think that the notion that the ottomans kept the people the way they were "just because they needed them and wanted to make use of their skills" is, while not totally inaccurate, is an over-simplification of the issue and and over-estimation of the dependence of the ottoman government on non-muslims. the ottomans were old-style imperialists: they wanted complete obedience, and would stop at nothing to get it, but once they got that, they were content: there was no notion of wanton murder unless "needed" (of course that last sentence is a hotbed of debate), and there was also no notion of the necessity to completely exterminate people because they were different. as far as the ottoman dependence on non-muslims for government purposes is concerned, the realities behind it were entirely different and had nothing to do for the alleged "inability of turks in statecraft on account of their nomadic background", as has been asserted many times. we can have an interesting discussion on such issues as the logic behind the janissary institution, the ethnicity-based labour division in the empire etc. regards,
-
thoth, on ataturk: in turkish we have a saying "you cannot found a state without shedding blood and chopping of heads". i know that this will do nothing to improve the barbaric image of the turks, but a cold, impartial look at history shows just how true it is, not confined to turkish, but all other states (armenian included). now about the darker aspects of the man: there is another saying, this time by historians, that "the hero of one is the monster of the other", and ataturk is of course no exception. but as far as the formation of the republic goes, in the aftermath of ww1, the west really did try to put an end to turkish presence in anatolia, in fact, anywhere outside central asia. what were we expected to do? sit down and wait for everyone to kill us off or send us "bag and baggage" back to central asia (in the words of gladstone)? we fought for survival, and in fights, there are winners annd losers. we won. are we to apologise because we won? now as for karabekir, he had not taken part in the genocide per se (1915), he couldn't have, as he was stationed elsewhere. he entered the scene later, in 1919 if my memory doesn't fail me, and at that time he was fighting an invading armenian army in anatolia, and not civilians (i do not rule out that civilians also died, but that was not the main aim). karabekir is also known to have made statements highly critical of the "purges" of the armenians by the CUP, so you cannot really call the man an incorrigible enemy of the armenians, nor did he set that much store to the pan-islamic or pan-turanian fantasies of enver (few ever had). in examining the independence war, one should not forget that ataturk, karabekir and others had to gather what forces had survived the great war, and it is true that many who had "something to hide" had joined the struggle for independence. hence the presence of the special organisation members in their ranks. as for the burning of smyrna, an enormous amount of debate has been going on both in turkey and abroad since the event itself. the fire had broken out in the armenian quarter and had spread to the greek, jewish and turkish quarters from there. i do not know of further details, but as far as i can recall, the fire had started after the city was won back, and sheer common sense dictates that you do not set a city ablaze that you have just conquered. you instead move in and live in it. on the other hand, the one who has lost the city and is on its way out has a far greater incentive to set it afire, for he would not want to leave an intact city to the invader. regards,
-
i think both turks and armenians are paying way too much attention to this "war-of-the-movies" business. turks have not produced much in the way of great or even watchable movies, and what little they did produce would appeal more to the subtler european viewer than to the hollywood-fed american viewer. i do not know of any armenian film or film director whose movie i have seen, either (this doesn't of course mean there isn't one). let's face it: turks and armenians have an almost century-old blood feud, but pick up any regular north american and/or european, and more likely than not they will not be able to 1) show either turkey or armenia on the map, 2) know what our conflict is about, and 3) care much. i have little doubt that "ararat" will be watched mostly by the armenians, then the turks, and the rest of the world will pay scant attention to it. the same will go for "ataturk", if it turns out to be a propaganda movie (which it will if supported by the state). i wouldn't put much store to either. meanwhile, may i repeat that the one good thing all this is doing is preparing the turkish public for an eventual recognition of the genocide. the problem with the attitude of the common folk has usually been the negation of the possibility that a genocide might have occurred in turkey, not whether or not the genocide has occurred. turks tended, and still tend, to deny that there might have been criminals among them that might have done such a thing in their name (the "our-nation-would-never-do-such-a-thing" mentality). this is the mentality that has to go since it blinds the eyes of the people to potential criminals. regards,
