Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
While I agree with you that we should get out of the pretentious and stiff habit of making up mile-long words, we should not lose nuances in trying make the langauge "cool". The first word is bribery, while the second one is "bribe". We don't want to lose the expressive power.
-
Sorry to revive an unpleasant thread, but yes, indeed you are right Armat. Recommended, no make that mandatory, reading for any Armenian that wants to go beyond the myths. For example, how important was the battle of Sardarabad in declaring independence in 1918? Where were the Armenian soldiers of the Russian army, after it started disintegrating during the revoltion? Did they head "home" to defend it? What did the Armenian army do with the enormous military supplies they found in their posession, as the Russian soldiers hurried home? Makes you want to travel back in time and slap a few faces (or worse).
-
He was probably talking about the "National Security Council", where the generals can tell the civilian administration what to do on things that really matter. The president heads the thing, but until recently the "civilian" president invariably "just happened to be" an ex-general, so there was no ambiguity about who was in charge. The current president (Ahmet Necdet Sezer) I think is really a civilian (came from the judiciary). However, I don't think that changes anything; the presidency does not wield real power. In any case, everyone knows who has the tanks and the guns. And a truly behind-the-scenes power center, if it exists, would be more inconspicuous.
-
That pretty much sums it up. Except that I would paraphrase "disintegrate". It would reverse the "ever closer integration"" drive by the "core" countries (well, France and Germany really). The thing would probably survive as a bunch of loosely associated states, willing to cooperate and harmonize on judicial and economic matters. And, as Domino said, this would fit the US just fine. Who needs a "second pole", right? On the other hand, the idea of "multiple-speed Europe" would probably gain more prominence, without formally dismantling the EU on paper. A cluster of "true" European countries, led by France and Germany, might emerge as an "inner core" that would have a freer hand in deciding whom they would like to be "integrated" with. This is not a new idea. At the outer edges, EU may go with the "oh, what the heck" philosophy and start courting Russia, to balance the odd newcomer. This has not shown up on the radar screen yet, largely because it would signify the end of EU "as we know it", even if not on paper. An EU with France and Russia in it would not please the US, so that route would be "discouraged" every step of the way by using the trojan horse, err, I mean, Britain. But then, it may not be enough. Oh, incidentally, all of the above is probably amateur nonsense But I had to procrastinate a little bit before starting to tax my brain with real work.
-
Hi Axel, Nice to see you back. As for the discussed subject, I submit that for most Armenians "nationalism" is of the "natural" kind as you put it, with the exception of the Dashnak brand, which is more reminiscent of the 19th century European kind. We have to accept neither the "19th century european" version of nationalism nor the contemporary Dashnak variety. We are a persistently un-theoretical people, and our kind of "nationalism" is in line with that. However, seemingly (but only so) paradoxically, another reason I came to regard "patriotism" as less appropriate for Armenians (other than the fact that its meaning has been hijacked) is that it refers to a land, a country, something tangible to defend. While we are fortunate to once again have a country to defend and build up, for those in the diaspora a big part of the struggle is the defence of cultural identity and continuation, and takes on an unavoidably more abstract meaning that is perhaps better described as a sort of "nationalism". I hope I am making sense here. Alright, gotta go. TB
-
Well, I remember reading stuff from the "dismal science" that didn't treat the subject so clear-cut and simple. It is a chicken-or-egg sort of problem, and you get into it because the choices that individuals make (in a kind of "game theory" sense) put the collective in a "bad" equilibrium. But it doesn't have to be that way; cultural traits could land the collective in a virtuous-cyle instead of a vicious one. Those traits are again not unrelated to Boghos's "self-confidence" thread of thought.
-
Well, I did take a look at them. http://www.hyperdictionary.com/dictionary/nationalism and http://www.thefreedictionary.com/nationalism are basically the same, treat nationalism and patriotism as synonyms, and only one out of four definitions they give has the negative connotation of "feeling superior to others". And http://www.free-definition.com/Nationalism.html says the "superiority" business is a misunderstanding of nationalism. I already wrote a blurb on Orwell, so this is it. I really shouldn't spend more time here. Grrr.
-
Or is it the other way around? Good observations from Boghos, as usual.
-
Thoth, I'll have a deeper look at the links next week when I have time. I used to think exactly the same way as Orwell's notes suggest (and not because I learned it from them, or like to parrot them). And I would still like to. However, after seeing the word patriotism abused and made to represent things that had nothing to do with it, and then seeing the whole thing represented with a positive spin, I came to regard that word as indistinguishable from nationalism, as used in the mainstream. While I agree with Orwell's definitions in 1945, I cannot agree that those definitions are properly applied today. So, today, nationalism=patriotism, and both are used to mean whatever the author wants to. And frankly, since I have seen fake "patriotism" (the word used) in a militaristic context more often than "nationalism" in recent decades, I simply gave up on the old and venerable definition of "patriotism". It seems that if I want to bully a place, I am patriotic, and if they object to it they are being nationalistic. The terms have been stripped of meaning and nuance, or simplified to a primitive level. I don't know whom to blame for that, but American culture probably has something to do with it. [Edit: In case it wasn't clear, by "Orwellian trick" I didn't mean Orwell the writer, but the language policy of the state in his novel "1984"]
-
1. I also said "there is nationalism, and then there is Dashnak nationalism". 2. Nationalism is not a magical potion that increases one's intelligence. One's ultimate goals may be admirable. That fact, however, does not prevent one from being a moron.
-
Thoth, I don't think you are a nationalist either. In fact, since you don't try to raise your kids as Armenians, and don't speak the language or make an effort to learn it, it would not be unfair to say that you are not even Armenian. And there is nothing wrong with either of those (i.e. non-nationalist, non-Armenian). But nothing you said in your post precludes you from being a nationalist. You are using the trivial, soundbite, mainstream-media version of "nationalism". Fine, in that case very few of us are "nationalists" in that sense. But English is a powerful language that allows for many shades, nuances, and implied contexts. It is an awful waste to take a perfectly fine, admirable worldview and equate with chauvinism, and then be left with no word to describe the feeling of belonging, and the affinity for ones' "group of belonging". It is an Orwellian trick. If there is no word to describe the thing, maybe people will stop thinking it, and would have a hard time advocating it. Think about it.
-
The premise of your "why" question is wrong, making the question ill-posed. There is nationalism, and then there is the Dashnak nationalism. I consider myself a nationalist at some level, but my worldview and interpretation of life and history would have little in common (outside of the most obvious, "given" facts) with any of the "parties" in general, and Dashnaks in particular. However, I am no expert on party platforms. The Dashnaks are the only sizeable and loud diasporan party (what a concept) left today, so that's why sometimes the impression is given that there is an equivalence between nationalism and Dashnak party membership. From what little I know about the early 20th century history, all I can say is that Dashnaks seem to have a "negative intelligence". What I mean is that, their actions weren't just randomly wrong or right; they had a definite anti-correlation with what turns out to be the sensible course of action in hindsight. So if a more influential, but unfortunately fictitious, party at the time simply observed their decisions and moved Armenians in exactly the opposite way, things would probably turn out to be significantly better for Armenians. One last thing. I had the displeasure of watching their satellite channel "Horizon" for a few weeks when it was freely broadcast. It would be more appropriate to call it "The Armenian Genocide Channel", because it was the main theme either directly, indirectly, or subliminally. I even caught one "bedtime story" time for kids, which, you guessed it, had the usual overtone (some lady was translating "Dr. De Soto"; an excellent, funny book that any Armenian could readily connect to the Armenian-Turkish "relationship"). Maybe it was a cosmic coincidence, and that they embrace life fully. But from what little I have seen, I cannot imagine going through life like that.
-
No. I know that everybody seems to have a different definition and understanding of that word, but it is nevertheless wrong to ascribe to nationalism, especially the Armenian kind, traits that belong to other "ism"s. Jingoism sucks. Chauvinism sucks. Nationalism doesn't have to. And Armenian nationalism has very little to answer for, and it is unfair to lump it with the virulent "nationalism" of other "nations", which often are nothing but jingoism and chauvinism. As for whether some of the "contributors" on the forum are nationalists or simply jingoistic chauvinists, readers can make up their minds. And I sure don't want to enter the Dashnak zone. In any case, please don't use the term nationalism carelessly, as the mainstream media often does and drills into the proles' heads. An enlightened and humanistic world view is not incompatible with true nationalism.
-
Ehm. That wasn't quite what had in mind.
-
"Western Armenian" spelling. But Persian Armenians also use it I think, so that wouldn't be an accurate statement (well, it wouldn't be accurate in any case). How about "classical" spelling? Edit note: Fixed spelling.
-
When the language option was selected to be Armenian [Edit: in Windows XP], the regular google site automatically switched to the armenian version. However, I later realized that it was an erratic or random thing that occurred with one computer and not another, even when they shared the same IP. It was probably still in development version when I stumbled on it. It appears now to be a standard option that doesn't need any incantations.
-
Please explain.
-
True. It may take some logistics and negotiations, but it is not by necessity a utopian dream, except that the powers of status quo make it so. Well, there is not enough "dynamic range", so to speak, to have an empire that is "much better" than another. They are all evil creations, and a collective expression of extreme arrogance and brutality. They betray, at worst a total lack of moral fiber, or at best unabashed hypocrisy on the part of the empire-builders. Ottoman empire was not a particularly "bad" empire (in a scale defined by other empires) until it started an accelerated collapse in the 19th century. Sure, it always had a massacre here, an unprovoked war there, enslavement, theft, and all such fun and glorious stuff of empires, but it was a "normal" empire, and no more evil (possibly less) than the British or French empires. And then Abdulhamid came, and the rest is, well, history.
-
It's not you per se Vava. I know you are just repeating what has become the "conventional wisdom" about the beginning of the Armenian nation. The problem is, that version has no more factual basis than what many would consider crazy or crackpot ideas, except that it struck the right chord with many "scholars". Nobody recorded "Armens" coming with the Phrygians. Furthermore, Armenians themselves don't call themselves with that name, and there is no proof that the "Armens" were the main, identity-forming component of the Armenian nation, or the most numerous. There is so little information on the Phrygian language that it is impossible to group it with any other language, other than saying that it is Indo-European and seems to have some distant relationship with Greek and Armenian. So what? Greek and Armenian already seem to have some "distant relationship" with or without Phrygian, which really doesn't bring in any new information, and certainly doesn't require an Armenian immigration from Thrace. We don't know what the ordinary people of Urartu spoke; only what the rulers or their scribes spoke or wrote. Armenians have been ruled by other groups for long periods, and many times. If we didn't have written records for the period before the Seljuks, that line of thinking could easily conclude that the Armenians arrived with the Crusaders, and formed a distinct identity after mixing with the local, indigenous Seljuk Turks, to form a new nation in Cilicia. And the ease with which the "Urartuan" people seems to have melted into one "new" people less than a century after "their state" had been overrun by non-Armenian invaders stretches reason. And all that with no record of any Armenian organized state, invasion, or anything of the sort. Poof! After Cimmerians and Scythians raze Urartu, Armenians somehow take over vast areas, assimilate the population, and basically erase the memory of the previous Urartian state and emerge as a "new nation" in a few decades, and all that without prior experience as an organized state, or a newly found zeal as invaders/plunderers? These questions need to be raised, but are often not because there are too many dumb Armenian "scholars" who are all-too-happy to classify Armenians as "European colonists", as if that elevates them to some Renaissance-making, science-creating, enlightened Europeans by virtue of "Thraco-Phrygian" genes, whose carriers by the way initiated a couple of centuries of "dark-ages" in Anatolia before absorbing what was left of the local civilization. Just a few thoughts that I wanted to get off my chest. Sorry if they are somewhat disorganized. But yes, I realize that it would take too much effort to reverse the damage done by parrot "scholars", some of whom are not guilty of stupidity but simple bias in favor of making Armenians as recent an advent as is conceivable, however unlikely or absurd it may be in a logical analysis.
-
One part to Lucifer and one part to Ahriman?
-
I give up.
-
Could you elaborate please?
-
Turkey will eventually join the EU; it's too late for Europe to say no. The process of getting ready has had some slight and superficial but perhaps ultimately helpful changes in Turkish laws and attitudes. It is highly unlikely that they will truly evolve to the European ideal (which of course hasn't been really and fully achieved by the EU members either) when they join. After they join they will have no further incentive to change and evolve in any fundamental way and will view it as a vindication of their entire history. But, it is also a possibility that by that time Russia will progress to the point that EU would not be embarassed or intimidated by its presence, and might want to woo it in order to keep the "Europeanness" of the EU at that point. In that case, the "ever-closer union" (i.e. modern empire or U.S.E.) dreams will probably have to be discarded, and EU will once again become simply an economic and judicial harmonization area. Just some late-night thoughts.
-
Such a point does not exist. Furthermore, we don't know if the bulk of the ordinary people of Urartu (as opposed to the rulers) were not close relatives of the people of Hayassa. If they were of essentially similar ancestry, there is no real fresh addition at that point. But in any case, the further addition and assimilation is an ongoing process; it never stopped. I agree with that much, as I also speculated along those lines in another thread. As for Gray & Atkinson, their work is very thoughtful and high-caliber; it is no ordinary glottochronology and can stand on its own without me defending it, and I'll leave it at that. As for the IE homeland. While one cannot be sure, it is a matter of relative confidence. It is not reasonable to arbitrarily place it somewhere far from the place where it was first assessed, especially if that place gave much of the rest of the basic civilization to the rest of Western Eurasia. In any case, it doesn't really matter. Whether Armenians spoke an IE dialect at the periphery of an original dry-Black-Sea homeland, or were right smack in the middle of its originating point is beside the point. Their main, identity-forming component did not need to come from Thrace. There is no credible evidence showing that Armenians came (or somehow had to come) with the Phrygians and became a distinct identity only by 520 BC, long after the recorded existence of a "Land of Hays".
-
Yes but he was not considered the ancestor of the UNIFIED Armenian NATION because there was no unified Armenian nation until this period. I don't know about 2492 BC, but there is no indication that "Hayk" waited until Urartu's destruction to become the "ancestor". First, let's drop the pretense that Hayk was a real person. Probably almost all those mythical "person" names refer to the names of individual peoples (i.e. tribes), and the names of Haykazian "kings" symbolize the assimilation of those tribes into Hayk. The Hayk (people) were around before anyone had heard of Urartu, but part of their kin could have fallen under the rule of the Urartuan dynasty later. In any event, there is nothing of record that justifies the assignment of the fall of Urartu as the "proper" beginning of a "unified" Hay people. And if we need to associate "Bel" with a local tribe, how about the Palaic people? It is quite reasonable to think that the Hayk had to wage some sort of a struggle against the Palaic tribes (cousins and contemporaries of Hittites) in order to gain a coherent identity. No proof for any of this one way or the other, but the evidence fits the emergence of a coherent Hay identity long before the formation of the Urartu Kingdom, probably somewhere between 2000BC and 1400BC. And we didn't even touch the linguistic analysis of Gray & Atkinson yet, which would suggest a much earlier date for the isolation of a distinct group of proto-Hay speakers, if not a self-aware tribe.
