Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. How disgusting one or another form of racism should be measured by its consequences. In that respect, can one really argue that "pure racism" (as you would call it) has scored more cruelty than the "lesser racism" (which it is really not)? The only reason you find the German racism more repugnant is because you still cannot free your mind from the images, empty values, and trivialities that are part and parcel of the simple-minded part of "western" mainstream. But that is a very trivial way of looking at it. Why weren't Armenians regarded as part of the new nation? Because Armenians' culture was regarded as incompatible with the Young Turks' vision of the new synthetic Turkish identity. And Armenian culture was regarded as inherently inferior, as indoctrinated by centuries of muslim-ottoman arrogance that survives in modern Turkish nationalism to this day. Armenians, with identical wealth, and identical geographical location, would not be harmed if they constituted a part of the muslim hierarchy. Pure and simple.
  2. Dear Arpa, I think using a transliteration that reflects the pronunciation by the locals (Bolis) would be more appropriate.
  3. The value of putting things in the "same bag" depends on whether the generalization is more useful than a fragmented view of the sub-classes. I cannot see why one kind of genocide is worse than the other. Some bloody-minded bullies get obsessed about one set of traits or another and decide to exterminate those carrying them. There is no good reason for the exact nature of those traits to matter. And from what you wrote, you seem to think that the denial of Armenian Genocide is more disgusting than the act itself, and mainly because the nature of the latter reminds you of what happened to Jews. If this inescapable conclusion deduced from what you wrote does not look completely warped and sick to you, you have some serious soul-searching to do.
  4. I thought addressed it as much as it needed to be addressed.
  5. I don't think so. And to make it clearer ... Whatever other adjectives you might attach to "my" definition, I would simply call it an "operational" or "functional" definition. That is, it distils what matters, and cuts out superfluous parts. It doesn't matter what the nature of the "unchangable" traits are. What matters is that they are unchangeable (i.e. the carrier is unassimilable in the relevant time-scale). In the time-scale that matters to the (potential) committers of a genocide, a hopelessly different culture is as bad as a different race. The distinction is ultimately meaningless. To lure you in, let me call it the "grand unification theory" version of racism.
  6. Stormig is right in that the islamists turned out to be not much better than the secularists in Armenian matters. One needs to make a distinction between their ideologs and grass-roots, however. The "grass-roots" of any persuasion suffers from the same, rabidly anti-Armenian indoctrination as the rest, making the words of the "islamist elite" meaningless when it comes to real action, be it the treatment of minority rights in Turkey, the relations with Armenia, or dealing with the genocide. What Kaiser is saying sounds both too optimistic and outdated. They could have been more justified before the islamists came to power and stayed for a while. But it is still true that the interests of long-suppressed islamists coincide with a more tolerant society, to the extent that it allows them to operate more freely. There is an opportunity in there somewhere for Turkey to make a forward move. Well, "Ataturkculuk" is the word, isn't it? And it is the "Allah-u-akbar" of the secularist "religion", shared by the "secularist" parties of the left, right, and center. But Kaiser is sort of abusing the term, in that there is nothing particularly anti-Armenian in it per se. It is just that the term has an unwritten implication of continuing a tradition whose roots are in the Young Turks movement. The term implies a continuation of a nationalism that is not really divergent from the Young Turk ideology. It depends on how you define "race". To the extent that "race" is "a collection of traits that are not changeable", it was a racist genocide. Armenians were viewed as culturally too alien to change and assimilate into the new, synthetic "Turk" that the Young Turks were about to create. In that sense, having a purple skin and pointy ears would have about the same effect. And at the end of the day, it is extremely important which "-ism" led to genocide. The muslim chauvinism always persecuted Armenians in a "retail" fashion, eroding their numbers and killing their spirit. But the wholesale extermination of a nation was a uniquely nationalist and yes, a racist (in the generalized sense above) act committed in the name of the new Turkism, using islamic chauvinism as an all-too-eager tool. If you don't know what caused the genocide, you don't know what to fix. Do you need to fix islam, do you need to move Turkey away from islam, or do you need to change what kind of nationalism is being shoved down Turks' throats for almost a century?
  7. Thoth, This is not about what you understand or don't understand (you have a habit of saying "Don't you think I know that too"). This is not about you at all. This is not about individuals. This is not about whether individual Kurds are just ordinary folk going about their business. And this is not about keeping old animosities. This is about whether a culture has the moral standing to demand respect. After a certain point, probably a few centuries ago, but certainly by 1900, Kurds as a collective, as a group, as a "culture", had lost any moral ground to demand respect other than by the usual means, i.e. the gun. Turkish culture belongs in the same class, but did receive the "respect" that it demanded, again by the usual means, the gun. I see no reason to grant the Kurdish culture any "respect" out of some moral argument, for the simple reason that they do not deserve any such thing by virtue of their past behavior that more or less defines their culture. If and when they earn "respect" I will grant the kind of respect that they earned. From the corner they painted themselves in, the only "respect" they can (re)earn is the kind that you show to a bandit with a gun. Armenians certainly needed to earn the same kind of respect from their neighbors, and failed at that (and therefore I believe they lack the moral right to demand territories outright; i.e. they didn't fight for it in big enough numbers by far). But that is a different story. Again, I have nothing but affection for an individual that is being harrassed unjustifiably. However, I question the necessity to cling to a cultural identity that has contributed a net negative to humanity. Therefore, I see no moral reason to feel sorry about the collective plight of that identity. However, I do see a rational reason for preserving Kurdish cultural identity for the simple reason that its assimilation into the dominant Turkish culture would likely make the latter even more arrogant than it is already.
  8. Kurds in Turkey, as a "collective", as a "culture", deserve nothing. They had been parasites feeding on the blood and flesh of Armenians, until they fully and enthusiastically conspired in finishing them off. Turkish and Kurdish cultures deserve each other. If they want to make each other miserable, let them. Any similarity between Armenians and Kurds simply indicates an earlier theft by Kurds, be it brides, culture, land, or artifacts. Spare your compassion for more deserving cultures, not vultures. And in that context, there surely were a few Kurdish tribes that were friendly and humane. If you must sympathize with Kurds, sympathize with an "ashiret" that proved itself to be more than a bunch of bullies.
  9. Google now has the Armenian language option. If you are running Windows XP, it automatically recognizes the language setting and comes up with Armenian descriptions of options and commands. Maybe some day a Mashdots spelling option will become a reality as well.
  10. As I said, it was not a utilitarian statement. There are cultures that fully deserve to be ashamed of and cannot dissolve into the "world culture" soon enough, there are cultures that are kind of pointless, and there are cultures that one can feel good to be associated with (not because you want to take credit for something others did but because by embracing it you embrace those positive values). As for what I would like to hear Turks say, I don't much care. I would like them to change what they value, what they obsess about, and what they glorify. The rest of what I care about naturally follows from that. I'll leave it at that. Bye for now.
  11. Stormig, You can't leave "pride" out of it. But let's move on. I actually disagree with Thoth's "shame" about his German or whatever ancestry. That's not what I meant at all. The "shame" is not whether "people in your clan" do or did bad things. Sure we all feel embarrassed and ashamed by what other members of our "group" does. But that's not what I am talking about. I am talking about being ashamed to embrace the contemporary Turkish identity when it has those traits of justifying genocidal acts, glorifying war and conquest, and plain longing for the lost days of empire and glory. If a Turk distances himself/herself from those traits, then that person has nothing to be ashamed of personally, but of course plenty to be embarrassed by association. The tragedy for an anlightened Turk is that, try as she may to be the perfect human being, she cannot by herself change what Turkish culture today is. Perhaps "I am embarrassed" would be a more accurate statement. In any case, I [edit: hope] am able to convey what I mean.
  12. Indeed regret is already contained in "shame". But I need to emphasize once again that the shame we should be talking about is not of the personal kind when it comes to the act of genocide itself; today's Turks did not commit it and they do not need to feel personally ashamed of it. The shame is about the traits of an ethnic identity that justified genocide, still glorifies its perpetrators, and still glorifies and longs for conquests and domination. You cannot regret your way out of that identity. To reform it, you have to be ashamed of its shameful traits first. It's "I am ashamed of those things", and not "I am ashamed of myself". Regret says "Oops what a bad thing to have done", without much further reflection or change. Being ashamed of something is indeed a stronger and more relevantly, a transforming experience. And I would like to repeat that I am reflecting philosophically and not "diplomatically" or in any "utilitarian" sense. That is, I don't expect Turks to do anything beyond a grudging "regret". But that is beside the point.
  13. A few more bits to add clarification: * Dragging individual Turks in front of Armenian audiences for "performance" would indeed be grossly unfair and in extremely poor taste, and I don't think anyone here has suggested that. I don't think that was ever the point of the discussion. * Being ashamed of one's group identity (Turkish, German, Hutu, etc.) is not the same as being ashamed of oneself. It is the first step to disassociate from what that group identity stands for (and not the "shell" of that identity itself), and to synthesize a new version of that identity. The individual shame about the evils of its collective should in fact be a source of pride, as it involves a great amount of intellectual and moral dexterity, and "cleansing" oneself of any implied support for the evil aspects of what the identity stood for. The reason such a "deep surgery" is needed lies in the fact that the glorification of conquests, wars and dominating others has become an integral part of Turkish identity. So again, the shame I talked about is not "being ashamed of oneself". And again, the ultimate purpose should be the construction of a new identity that the New Turks could be justly proud of, without reference to wars, conquests, and domination.
  14. Stormig, It is in fact quite reasonable to give "more maneuvre" to the statement by a single person than the total sum of millions of actions over a thousand years. It is called "the law of large numbers". The latter at this point should be answerable very precisely, and certainly as a "was it a net positive/negative" question, while a statement by one person does need to be treated with less dogmatism than you seem to be displaying. In any event, since I think most major nations do need to feel ashamed before they can justifiably feel clean and proud, I don't have any problem with what you describe as pathetic. I have no idea if he is indeed a pathetic person with personality problems. I also don't know if he is sincere. But the nature of the person making the statement is not really the point. We should be discussing the statement. As it stands, the statement is not out of place when you replace it with German (who did go through the shame part for the Jewish genocide) or Hutu either. Unjustified national pride has blinded enough people long enough. The path between a bully nation and justified pride passes through the painful part involving shame. They cannot go from here to there without feeling like shit first, if not for the "actions" (done by "earlier generations"), then for being willing dupes for a ridiculuous collection of tales with repugnant values (main one being the taking of pride in domination and slaughter). And the "justified pride" that would follow would have no resemblance in its nature to the pride preceding the shame. As for the rest of your argument, I think they should not be addressed to me. I have not implied anything about your stance concerning apologies, conscience etc. As a final note, a contemporary Turk cannot disassociate himself/herself from a shameful (i.e. negative) legacy to the extent of eliminating (or even diminishing) shame and simultaneously lay claim to the "positive" legacy (e.g. the ownership of the land). That would be a little too convenient to be called sincere. It would be more along the lines of "Alright I admit it. I'm sorry. Satisfied? Now get out of my hair". True evolution takes more than that.
  15. I don't know what is absolute or relative or whatever. All I can surmise from what he says can be summarized, as I said, And that is perfectly fine. There is nothing wrong with being ashamed of the collective results of one's group of belonging. And you cannot be ashamed of your group's actions without being ashamed of belonging to such a group. And such feeling of shame does not imply that he is ashamed of each and every individual of that group. In fact it doesn't even imply that he is ashamed of most of the members of his group. It means he is ashamed of the collective result of the actions taken in the name of his group of belonging. And as far as the denial goes, he would be justified to be ashamed of most of his peers, individually. Being ashamed doesn't mean he is advocating a permanent dissolution of Turkishness. It probably does mean, however, that the nature of Turkishness needs to change in order to accomodate the "new" view of it own origins. And such a drastic revision of Turkish mythology can be accomplished only with a certain degree of shame about the earlier self-view. It is perhaps a simple question, Stormig. Was the invasion of Anatolia by the Turks and the totality of their subsequent actions all the way through today a net positive or a net negative for humanity, and how does that net contribution compare with other nations? I ask this not with prejudice about the answer, but as a tool for reflection. As I said, there is plenty of shame to go around, and Turks are not the only ones due such feelings. Most major and many minor nations could do well to take a good, hard look at their history and see if they too should be ashamed before proceeding to feel clean and "proud", whatever the latter means. A little shame is long overdue in the consciousness of many of the nations.
  16. I am using a more generalized, operational definition of racism. If genes could be washed away and replaced with "approved" genes as easily, or say even more cheaply than forming concentration camps or organising death marches, it is likely that the perpetrators would simply perform it and be done with their objective. Same goes with the "cultural racism". If Young Turks were certain that they could assimilate Armenians into a muslim Turk identity in a decade or so, they probably would not have committed the monstrosities that they did. The fundamental issue in a generalized concept of racism is the getting rid of the "undesirable qualities", and the most effective way of doing so. Whether those qualities are tied to genes or culture is secondary.
  17. Oh come on. It is because it is a good conductor of heat, and more importantly it has a low heat capacity. What little "heat" it has quickly escapes the foil as soon as you take it out of the oven.
  18. Utility or lack thereof is a very poor correlator of merit, and has next to nothing to do with being pathetic or not. That is a separate discussion. That's all.
  19. Domino, One kind of racism is no better than any other kind. Just as some people were victims of their "genes" that they could not change, as far as the Young Turks were concerned, Armenians were not assimilable, and as such rather similar to having "different genes". The question in racism (regardless of whether it involves genes or culture) is whether "the others" are "redeemable" or not. Armenians were regarded both inferior ("how dare they see themselves equal to us?") and unredeemable by the Young Turks. That perception, and not the source of such perception, is the crucial issue.
  20. There is nothing wrong or pathetic with what Yalcin said. He is not saying that he is ashamed of each and every individual that belongs in his nation. He is expressing shame in the collective, overall results of his nation's actions. It is quite alright to be ashamed of one's own nation in that sense. And in fact most "major" nations fully deserve to be ashamed of in many respects. And of course there are many redeeming qualities of those "major" nations, which we can perhaps summarize as acts of "creative destruction". Many of those nations did produce something of enduring value in the evolution of human civilization. The issues of whether the Turkish civilization has contributed something substantial and positive, and where its overall balance stands perhaps belong to another discussion. But it remains true that, whatever their overall balance, it is pefectly fine to be ashamed of any one of the "major nations", and many of the "small nations" as well. Stormig and Steve are perhaps confusing "merit" with "utility". It is true that Yalcin's style or emotions cannot be expected to be adopted by most Turks. That simply means it is not something that is to be expected from most Turks, and means nothing more. We also don't expect most Turks to learn ballet dancing. On the other hand, perhaps Stormig and Steve are underestimating the fundamental goodness in most Turks, or humans in general. Now that would be shameful.
  21. Although I agree with the above statement, I am bothered by your vicious responses. Why should the debates be accompanied by personal attacks? Especially when they involve intelligent individuals with a capability on diplomacy. Those self-evident statements were not the ones in question, Anileve. These were: and were addressed by: Again, I do think there are more important priorities than genocide recognition, but that is not terribly relevant to the exchange above. Anyway, just a recap in case it wasn't clear what all the commotion was about.
  22. Defend your ideas, or go away.
  23. Against my better judgement, I will address this piece of excrement, so people would not be confused by it. Each and every statement above is wrong both literally and figuratively. Search the forum if you are interested. Yes, you would like the stupidities, particularly of your own production, to remain unchallenged, right? It's obvious that there is enough garbage collection to keep me busy, thank you very much. Show me. Are you referring to me? Whom did I blame for "my discomfort"? If you are referring to the discomfort of reading lame stupidities. Yes, I do blame their authors or at least their mentors for that. That's fair. At this point, much better than whatever your online personality appears to be.
  24. Dear Schoolyard Bully, You turn anything that contradicts your pedestrian views as personal insults. As I said earlier in response to another pathetic grunt of yours, it doesn't matter if I am a coward, a hero, have a dozen personalities or one. What does matter in this conversation are the ideas. What I try to do online is to inject a measure of reason into the conversation, and occasionally post a historical or cultural information that may be out of the beaten path. The currency of this online conversation should be rational ideas and critical analysis, not grunts. Can you defend your ideas by using reason and self-consistency? So far, you have failed that all too often, and yet display an amazing level of pompousness. You need to come down to earth.
  25. Armat, The efforts of Armenian activists should be regarded as part of the much larger and more important issue of aligning the political and diplomatic face of governments with the moral values of their own populations, which they prefer to keep as docile and malleable as possible. The current state of "diplomacy" and "international relations" is hardly any more enlightened than the time of kings and emperors, which has supposedly passed. Having said that, if it were up to me, I would channel all the energy of Armenians to address problems in Armenia rather than fix the world at this point. However, I would not disparage what others are doing, if its realistic alternative is doing not much at all about anything.
×
×
  • Create New...