Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. Indeed, "certain personalities" do seem that way. They get resolved one way or the other however.
  2. I didn't say it was not proper to advocate on others' behalf. I said it should not be expected to do so merely to air your own grievences. I did not say "our" lobby is gaining anything. I was not addressing anything of the sort, as more perceptive readers surely must have understood. Resolution of the genocide mess would be beneficial for all affected by it emotionally or politically today, and would allow the Armenian and Turkish societies to evolve in a positive direction. I think there is a right way and a wrong way to go about it, although we may not know what that is. In any case, I doubt the dead care, or would be better or worse off one way or the other.
  3. While some of the thoughts on this thread deserve much editorializing, I'll try to be as brief and detached as possible, to save (mostly my) time. In the same spirit, I will not address most of the comments. It is disingenuous to suggest that Armenians should lobby their own or anybody else's parliament for recognizing other genocides, in order to be justified in airing their own grievences. Anyone reasonably familiar with the human species would know that it functions through "advocacy" (for oneself and self-perceived group of belonging), and "suppressed memory" of others' suffering. We couldn't go through even one day without going insane if it weren't for our capacity to ignore others' plight. If we related to each and every other person's grievances and pain as if it were our own, we could not function at all. Therefore, it is the duty of those aggrieved to make a case for their rights. While humans do not, and cannot, spontaneously volunteer to address all of the injustices inflicted on others, they nevertheless have an evolved sense of fairness and justice that obliges them to react to pleas based on those values. While there will always be exceptional individuals that defy this rule, it is for the aggrieved to make a case, and for the decent to react in a morally justified way. That's the way humans work. Offered in case it is forgotten or neglected by those too busy with more serious matters.
  4. To the best that we can deduce from what is known, Urartu was probably one of the later "components" that formed the Armenian nation. Hayasa province/client kingdom of the Hittites can be regarded as the beginning of the Armenian nation. The language of the Urartuan ruling class, or at least its scribes, was not recognizably Armenian, or even Indo-European (as far as the linguists can tell these things). However, we don't know what language or languages the common people of Urartu spoke. Any direct records of it have not survived to the best of our knowledge. While the Urartian elite did borrow from Assyrian culture, notably the script, Urartian culture was not "Assyrian dominated". Apparently by 500BC, there was no distinction between the people of Urartu and the Armenians, if there ever was any distinction. So Urartu either simply signifies the easternmost extension of the Armenian people, or it simply melted into the Armenians by 500BC. From Movses Khorenatsi's history, it is not to difficult to identify the different components, and parallel histories of component peoples that are presented as a single chronological succession of events. The special attention Urartu receives in contemporary Armenian context is probably twofold. Present Armenia is much closer to the heartland of Urartu than to the location of Hayasa-Azzi, making it easier to think of it as the "origin". And the fact that it is much more prominent and better documented than an obscure province of the Hittite empire. But the name by which Armenians call themselves, the historical precedence (1350BC vs 800BC), and Khorenaztsi's History point to Urartu as a "component", rather than as the "beginning" or "origin". So Urartu was definitely not "pre-Armenian", since it came about half a millenium after Hayasa . But an important component it no doubt is, both culturally and ancestrally.
  5. http://www.heydon.org/kevan/collection/pictures/sinclair-zx81-large.jpg It came with a whopping 1K memory, and a blazing 4.7MHz Z80 processor. Feels like yesterday.
  6. Sasun, I am characterizing his intellectual state in order to explain some basic failures. I am patient when the other side makes a good-faith effort to at least attempt to understand what is being said. But not so patient in the face of willful and unpleasant simple-mindedness. And I did point out that I was probably not any wiser at his age. Anyway, the points have been made. Some silence is needed now, that's all.
  7. Azat, it sounds like you are making a Jazz-like argument, right? That any music originating from or filtered through the American black culture is Jazz, making Rap the most recent form of "jazz". That may be. But whatever the case, while I consider the "Armenian" "wedding music" junk as cruel and unusual punishment that should be regulated by human rights, I don't mind Sayat Nova (it's been forever since I listened to it though, perhaps I should one of these days).
  8. Hi Gurgen, I appreciate the suggestion, although I would have preferred to receive it through a PM . It is highly unlikely that using private messaging will make Vigil read more attentively what is in front of him, comprehend more comprehensively what he reads, and analyze more deeply what he comprehends. However, I would like to revise what is implied buy my calling his case "obnoxious stupidity". After a quick glance through what he has written on the board about various subjects, I think his general intellectual state does qualify as "innocently stupid" (rather than toxically stupid), known also as "naive". At some point in our lives, many of us transcend the "shish-kebab philosopher" stage our intellectual development. Vigil is still young, and I am not at all sure I was any wiser at his age. I just wish he realizes that his interpretation of life and the world around him has huge room for improvement. And he should start by thinking more carefully and self-critically.
  9. Rather than erecting barriers and tests, Armenia should entice the diasporans into getting involved and getting connected to the homeland. Citizenship should guarantee almost all economic rights, but not many political rights. The latter should be gained through a demonstration of interest and opportunity to know the facts on the ground by actually residing in the country for at least a year, rather than simply visiting. And voting should be a right reserved for those with Armenian citizenship only. Dual citizens or those with "permanent residency" in another country should not vote. The country is in a bad neighborhood, and needs to have its future tightly coupled with the personal futures of its voters. It is not Holland. The idea is to attract, engage, but not to give rights that are not coupled with a strong motivation to use them responsibly. Gaining "full" citizenship by accumulating residency via visiting is a bad idea. Putting down a requirement of "at least 1/2 Armenian" is even worse. Perhaps petitions describing "qualifications" could be submitted anonymously to "panels" composed of about a dozen Armenian citizens, who would decide on a case-by-case basis. That would define Armenianness as whatever other Armenians perceive to be "Armenian enough". I think that would be the least bad solution.
  10. So smart. So subtle. So deep. I am speechless. You sure put me in my place.
  11. Citizenship should be awarded to anyone with a reasonable claim to be an Armenian. And that should include the right to purchase property or investment. I'll leave the discussion of what constitutes "a reasonable claim" for another time. And of course there are the issues of taxation and military service. But for the moment I will focus on voting rights. One must acknowledge that voting is about the future, not the past. Therefore, while it is reasonable to expect some residency before such rights are conferred, it should not be so much for the purpose of "earning" the right as it should be for familiarizing oneself with the issues and the conditions ("learning vs earning?" ). In my view, a year would be sufficient. But the important issue about voting is whether the voter has a choice to bail out of the country after a disastrous decision plays itself out. Therefore, the focus should be on how much "stake" the voter has in the responsible running of the country. If someone has dual citizenship and can simply pack and leave to a comfortable life abroad when things turn sour, should he/she be given the right to vote for the the decisions affecting the future of a country in a very difficult part of the world? While I am making my bias apparent regarding the subject, I would like to hear what others have to say.
  12. I would have preferred to say you don't know how to read, or you cannot comprehend what you do read. However, I hereby have to classify your case as "obnoxious stupidity". I would also have liked to say "show me where I have been inconsistent". But why bother, you don't seem capable of elementary logic. And how you would wish this was a "personal attack". Unfortunately for you, it is plain reality. I certainly don't wish whatever "culture" you have to be propagated.
  13. You mean "what changed as a result of it", or "what changed that caused it?"
  14. In an ideal world, Armenia would improve in time to absorb back the diaspora, and integrate their world view and culture into the Armenian society. The "Armenian" part of diasporan culture is as worthy of preservation (not for pickling, but for the purpose of contributing to the evolving culture) as the local one. However, if Boghos' optimism does not pan out and Armenia languishes for many decades, there will not be much left of the "old" diaspora (and the "new" diasporan culture would be an outdated yet westernized shadow of an earlier stage of the Republic's culture; indeed nothing special to preserve as long as Armenia stands). If we can succesfully integrate the experiences accumulated by the various diasporas into the cultural landscape of Armenia, we would obtain a more sophisticated culture (that would be natural in inclusiveness to boot) than otherwise.
  15. Particularly because we don't back it up with "gunboats". It's easy to be a "successful diplomat", when you are backed by "convincing" force.
  16. That answers my question. Thank you.
  17. And to make it ultra clear, I was not calling mx5 or axel stupid either. As I made it abundantly clear, I respect Axel. And I don't have any animosity to mx5 either. I just think he failed to understand what I was trying to get across. And he is certainly not toxic. Just for the record.
  18. Pirate, I have not called you anything other than "emotional", and "hot-headed". And anyone with a modicum of observational skill would have to agree with those adjectives. There is only one more thing I will call you, at that will be the third and hopefully the last of the adjectives I use to describe you, and that is "hypocrite". You attack and belittle everyone that shows the slightest deviation from your "vision", and then proceed to say a few superficial niceties to prove what a nice fellow you are, and finish with a martyrdom speech and more insults. Lay off it. To address the fundamental issue of "math". The two-dimensional graph is not incomplete. It's just that the extra dimensions are summed up by the "effective fertility rate". Plain more kids per household helps to offset the assimilated, and raises the effective fertility rate. So would providing an inspiration, a compelling "Point" of keeping Armenian identity, a convincing, compelling picture of why it is good to be Armenian. And as you know and point out, pop-culture, globalization (true or fake), and plain laziness reduces the effective fertility rate. Now if your idea of presenting a compelling idea is to bulldoze through a discussion forum and post encyclopedia-sized passionate appeals, hopefully unchallenged by anyone and admired by all in sight, so be it. I know there is a clientele for it. However, it is probably preaching to the converted, including me. Yes, me. So do you think you are reaching anyone that needs "conversion"? As for "individual effort". I am not saying at all that it should not be expended. It should. It's just that, in the absence of a compelling framework of concepts and "theory", individual efforts lack the coherence to move the trends. I, as an act of faith in the future of "being Armenian", do my "individual effort", even when I see that the battle is not going well. As for the "let Armenian boys hump Armenian girls" thread of your thoughts. While I understand and sympathize with your thoughts on it, I don't know what can be done about some of our cultural goofiness. I mean, if you find a graceful way of saying "On behalf of my/my neighbor's/my friend's son, may I ask for your daughter's vagina in copulation", please let us know. Still friendly believe it or not, TB
  19. Just to clarify for to other readers. The "toxic dum-dum" was a generic comment and was not directed at anyone in particular in this thread. However, considering Pirate's last post, perhaps it should have been. Pirate, I did not call you stupid. However, I reserve the right to point out stupidities as I see them. And I was not really addressing you, anyway, other than mx5's or axel's interpreations of what you wrote. And no, there is no politically correct "equivalence" between an intelligent thought and a stupid thought. And I don't need to know one's "intimate personal details" to know enough about what's relevant. What matters is what's written here, not their "intimate personal details". If someone acts like a toxic dum-dum here, that's what he is for the purposes of the public discussion. That the same person may be sweetheart in real life is irrelevant.
  20. Hi Axel, I knew that you and Boghos weren't as far apart from one another as the appearance of escalating mutual animosity suggested. As I mentioned before, "faith" (not in its usual religious sense) is the fundamental requirment, and even an end in itself when it comes to choosing to perpetuate the Armenian identity. And thanks for the passage. My interpretation of it is more along the lines of the "reality" of life, reality of human concerns as distinct from and above the "physical" mechanism underlying "everything". It affirms my position that we simply have to go along with what is in essence an elaborate illusion, collectively concocted, and nurtured. By nothing more than faith and imagination. I mumbled a few things along those lines elsewhere in the forum. Probably (I am not sure)under one of Domino(x)'s threads, as they tend to bring out such stuff. It concerns "Armenian identity" to the extent that it is a part of "life" for some of us. Anyway, good to have you here. Best, TB
  21. To Pirate, I don't know why you are hostile to me, but believe me even at this point I am not hostile to you. I appreciate that you are so motivated about keeping your heritage. While I do classify you in the "emotional" camp, there is nothing wrong with that. When I emphasize the reasoning part in my posts it's not because I am not emotional or that I don't value emotions. It's just that, solid, analytical thought is quite fragile in the face of emotional carelessness, and I try to do my part to put it back into the discourse. That's all. As for your insults about what you perceive to be my "arrogance". When I refer to me and Boghos being oldtimers, I thought it should have been obvious that I meant we have had the opportunity to understand where we stand, and that we didn't need to try extra hard to avoid misunderstandings. In other words, I don't have to write several paragraphs just in order not to offend him for pointing out something. You seem incapable of allowing earlier members to like one another when your obviously shining personality is present. Sorry. The 1500 members are largely dormant. At a given time, the active members are about 20, with perhaps as many "lurkers" that might read the stuff over a few weeks. And then there are the search-engine leads. I still don't understand why I should value each and every one's presence in exactly the same way. Somehow, in your world view, I don't have the right to express delight in seeing someone post, because, horrors of horrors, someone among the 1500 dormant users might drop by, read it, feel left out or belittled, and his/her soul would be fatally wounded. You are such a sensitive soul. When I say I don't have much time, it is true. I say it not to give an air of importance, but the opposite. I have to pick and choose what and how much I write, since I have so little disposable time. I want it to be clear that my silence or "ignoring" a comment reflects my lack of time rather than my snobbing that person (although as I said, some people definitely deserve all the snobbing they get). If you indeed have read what I have written in this forum, and you still think that I am some ego-driven, arrogant "socialite" (what a laugh), all I have to say is that you have to work on your observational skills. And also that you need to look at yourself and analyze how you come across before lecturing anyone about arrogance. From your impossibly long posts, the only take-home message I get is that there is one Armenian hot-head out there who is very enthusiastic about keeping his heritage. Good for him. The rest of your attempt at "rational analysis" is not worth the electron it's encoded in, not because it is all wrong. Just as in Ara Baliozian's case (to give an example from the other pole), 90% of what you say is already obvious, and even trivial, and the 10% that is not obvious, is almost invariably wrong. So why should I, or anyone, keep reading you, when you are not even pleasant?
  22. I am not a fan of Armenian diplomacy. However, for a Brit to make fun of the inadequecies of what has been for all practical purposes an enslaved nation for much of its history amounts to masturbation. Especially about the times of WW1. Please. Armenian diplomats had probably served the Ottoman state properly earlier. However, after the genocide, a ravaged, almost-dead nation had only a negligible chance to produce people with the proper experience and coherent "national agenda", not only because most of the elite were murdered, but also because being a "proper" nation that could stand on its own feet was something entirely new and shocking for a group of people that had stopped thinking along those lines for a long, long time, if they have ever done so. On a more general note, I think the "traditional" diplomacy you seem to be in love with is long overdue for a major overhaul. It needs to reflect the moral values of the populations it purports to represent, rather than simple realpolitik. By and large, they still look like the pompous representatives of pompous kings. Or perhaps some of those populations themselves are largely pompous, in which case they can keep their representatives just the way they are. Perhaps you are one? As for answering your question. I really don't know what the world's diplomats think when they are approached by an Armenian. However, I can guess that they generally view tham as insufferable losers who would do well to just disappear. Bullies don't like losers. But I don't know how it would excuse ridiculing those who have good reason to be inadequate. Obviously, it is the job of Armenians themselves to join the "winner's club", as others already pointed out, but that is a different discussion. And as a concluding thought, I agree with you that love for live Armenians should become much more important than that for dead Armenians. Especially in Armenian circles.
  23. Yeah, with gunboats, from the best practitioners of "gunboat diplomacy". That's the ticket. Steve, while I appreciate your enthusiasm about Armenian history, sometimes I get the feeling that the only Armenians you like are the dead ones.
×
×
  • Create New...