Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. Indeed all major issues should and could be decided by popular vote. Minor issues do need to be left to competent bureaucrats. You mean when there is low turnout. Not the end of the world. Minor, mundane decisions, no. But they should be bothered with important ones. What I said was a "strong executive branch" was undesirable. Not the existence of an executive branch. Sure, they should offer their competence in mundane, day-to-day running of things and daily decisions. And that is all they should do. But voters would not be alone. There would be stake-holders on both sides, making their case in the media. It would be the job of the issues' advocates to make them understood. And if this process displaces some mindless junk from the media, all the better. Sorry Sasun, but that is non-sequitur. That is not the function of direct democracy. Thank you for your worthwhile participation. I hope others also come in with their well-thought-out opinions. This is not, or rather should not be, an off-the-wall, wacky proposal, and deserves to be discussed.
  2. I really don't want to take part in this discussion. But I just wanted to say that I believe Anonymouse exists. In case Thoth feels left out, I believe in Thoth's existence as well.
  3. Stormig, I did not mean to discuss "internet democracy". The idea is direct democracy, with or (currently) without internet help.
  4. If you mean internet voting, that is not what I had in mind. As for frequent referenda, I don't think it would be expensive, if implemented efficiently. And the thugs would also get tired of trying to interfere with the voting, especially when it's not "my guy" against "the other guy", but rather whether a specific proposal is a good thing or bad. Many of the usual suspect would not even know which side they should be, and even when they do, they would not be as motivated as in the case of personality-driven races. And whatever its expense, it should pay for itself in vastly better governance, not only in terms of intangibles, but also in plain old economic performance.
  5. Most people are "not fit" for most decisions. Yet we allow them to marry, when they are emotionaly not fit, raise children when they are not really good parents, make investment decisions based on stupid thoughts and hearsay, manage companies or agencies when they are not fit for the job. The examples are endless. In a healthy system, all those people who really are not truly fit to make these millions of decisions every day, are and should be allowed to stumble along and find their way through trial and error and accumulated experience. We don't say "I can't give my wife orgasm, perhaps I should entrust the job to someone who can". We don't say "You know I don't really get this good parenting thing, perhaps I should give my kids to the orphanage; they are professionals and know what they are doing". The job of the "leaders" should be to convince people of the merits of a proposal, rather than convince them of their "pure hearts", "good intentions", "trustworthiness", and "presidential looks". Sorry for the flowery examples, but I have to substitute exaggerated examples for lengthy arguments, due to lack of time. And people, please give some thought to this subject and participate. Thanks.
  6. From what little I admittedly know, I think it is far superior, especially in the case of a small country that does not have any superficial excuse of unworkability of such a system. For the same reason that pressurized gas tanks do not deflate by themselves. Yes, and that is the point right? Or for cultures where everybody knows everything and does not like to be led. Currently the problem is that people are not busy enough (i.e. unemployment in many guises). And when they are, the system must have worked. Surely no more than now. Those that do would be voting for something real rather than a mirage. No which is almost never needed. Yes, in the future, but it is a luxury, not a necessity. Yes but once you start uttering "vote" and "incentives", it is a very short slippery slope before someone finds a way to manipulate the level of participation and the results without explicit fraud. I may be wrong about this (as about anything else of course). Thanks much for your participation in this discussion Sasun. It is appreciated.
  7. I would like to open a discussion on something that we all seem to take for granted, namely the form of "democracy" Armenia has. Even if it functioned ideally, a republic is a roundabout way of implementing democracy. Would it not be better if we had a system that had more elements of "direct democracy"? More decisions taken by referendum, for example. My intuition tells me that it would also be more immune to corruption. What do you think?
  8. Dear Steve, Thanks for your interest in things Armenian, and your amazing efforts in pursuit of expanding current knowledge on the subject. Redundant as it is to say it at this point, you should publish it "properly" in some form.
  9. www.sephardicstudies.org/aa.html
  10. Well Boghos, you are one of the few that tempt me to write here. Using up time that I actually don't have. I have a feeling that our "exceptions", let's call them euphemistically "Dashnakoids" , have been around 10-15%, and will remain a more-or-less permanent fixture of the Armenian landscape. So I don't really know what to call them. I can only define them by what they are not: the mainstream of Armenian identity. There must be a way to have a feeling of belonging to one's extended family, and appreciate its unique and precious traits without being chauvinistic. The best that Armenians have offered in their history were instances of transcending chauvinism and forming bridges between different peoples. Admiring this "anti-chauvinist" tradition cannot itself be chauvinism. If it is a "sinful indulgence", it is so only in the same way as feeling good about a charitable act (and then feeling embarassed about patting oneself on the back about what is supposed to be an altruistic act). Very true. Not in the sense of the European nationalist romanticism. However, the essence of Armenian identity and its "theory" needs to be formulated and discussed in Armenian intellectual life. I can barely keep up with life, so if it is done I can easily miss it. But what I am able to catch leaves a lot to be desired. I guess I am advocating a deviation from our traditional hesitation to take ourselves too seriously and put our collective wisdom into a theoretical framework that challenges the lame, traditional, "western european" nationalism and its replacement(s). So I guess I am disagreeing with your contention that we cannot get "there" by the "pen". I understand what you are trying to convey. However, there is a long tradition in non-Armenian cultures of "kna merir, egur sirem" (a phrase that we used in our family to refer to the new-found love by the aggressive cultures or individuals for their long-gone victims). The seduction of those orphans are most powerful once their people vanish, and can be "properly" romanticized. I don't want to be loved after we are gone.
  11. "Any"? I disagree. And such a pity; I hate to disagree with people that I like. Oh well.
  12. As a rare person who gets what Armenianness is about, Boghos makes thoughtful points that should not be dismissed by anyone here, even by those who may disagree. I agree. I agree. I hope you did not interpret my "white knight" argument as some sort of a Messiah. It was meant as the only "shortcut" way out of our current "malaise", and was neither promised nor suggested to wait for. I interpret what you say here as that, we are by tradition not "abstract" or "theoretical" nationalists, in the sense of "western thought". And I agree completely. That is something that I like very much about being an Armenian. Indeed. Well, I can't quite agree with that one. If the evolution of world culture had been influenced by Armenians per se (say, as much as by ancient "Greek" thought), and that we had outlived our usefulness, so to speak, I would perhaps agree with it at a certain intellectual plane. However, much of the "enlightenment" the western world has been peddling lately had been practiced by Armenians for much of their history (wrong timing?), and none of the credit goes to the Armenians, because it was apparently "invented" independently after giving one another and the rest of the world countless blood baths. The tragedy then, is for Armenians to disappear, if not into oblivion, then into obscurity right when the world has been slowly coming "their way". I refuse to be content with that outcome. Perhaps. Hmm. Not if we don't work hard and extra smart. Unless you define "winning" in such a loose way that the emergence and survival of a civilized, enlightened humanity counts as an "Armenian victory". The flag-bearers of that victory, upon reaching their target, would be standing on Armenian ashes, and wouldn't even know it. I have a hard time regarding it as a victory for the culture that would lie lifeless under their feet. Well, we are facing different challenges today, and we are not yet thriving. That would take active struggle and adaptation, rather than a redefinition of survival or confidence in past performance in a different world. I wish Armenians to remain as a distinct group of people for eternity and become the symbol of enlightenment and triumph over the bully in humanity. Yeah, just a small wish. In any case, thanks for your thoughtful comments Boghos.
  13. It is "self-inflicted" only through neglect, not by a conscious choice. And the neglect is largely due to the orphanhood itself. It is a self-perpertuating process of the chicken-or-egg kind, and which came first is unimportant today. There are two ways to break it: 1. Gradual evolution 2. An "externality", or a "white knight".
  14. When I say there is no coherent structure, I mean there is no coherent "we" or "our". It is correct that the stupid should become smart, the fools should become wise, and the idle should become active. And these "should"s can even be regarded as "could"s. However, they generally don't become "did"s without a coherent framework, a driving force. It's just the nature of things. Sorry about the flowery grammar.
  15. Speaking of orphanhood ... This is from "Geographical", March Issue, the second to last paragraph of the article on Armenia: It's a place of mixed feelings. In the local orphanage, children are encouraged to draw pictures of Ararat and Noah's Ark. These crayon drawings are stuck on the wall next to US flags. One class has obviously been taught to write, "We love George Bush".
  16. I don't know what compelled rivers and mountains to come into the conversation, but the sense of belonging Armenians have had did not originate from physical barriers. Those "barriers" had been observed much more often in the breach than in "respect", as our pathetic history of being run over countless times demonstrates. Current barriers are cable TV lines, freeways and mall aisles, which function as fairly effective barriers between an individual and her extended family. It's up to you whether you respect (i.e. defeated by) those new barriers in a new topology. What is an orphan but an individual with a barrier between herself and her parents or family, be it in space or time. Self-inflicted orphanhood is still orphanhood.
  17. You may not regard yourself culturally as an orphan. However, your last two sentences suggest strongly otherwise; something like an orphan who is forced to live on the streets and make the best of it. Yes, we all make it what we can. With 4 "my" or "I" in three short sentences, you clearly disagree with my signature. Perhaps you will change in the future.
  18. All true, Sasun. However, there is no coherent mechanism in the diaspora to guide Armenians to these laudable goals. We are orphans. Sadly, that is the case even in the Republic. Unless a white knight with very deep pockets, a big heart, and a simultaneously intelligent and inspiring vision comes along, we will have to be content to find like-minded individuals on and off the internet, talk idly, and stumble on. And accept countless casualties like Anka (if she chooses to be one).
  19. In principle, you are right. However, it is not obvious that the way she was treated moved her any farther than she is and wishes to be. On the contrary, one needs to be informed about the consequences of one's choices. If she rejects her extended family of Armenians, the consequence is that she will be, and treated as, an ordinary American peasant, with no special sympathy from those she rejected. She needs to know that she is in danger of losing something special and precious. What safer way to expose it than in a virtual, anonymous experiment?
  20. One more time. Don't waste my time. And my comments were not directed at you, any more than my comments on inanimate objects are directed at them. Now kindly get out of my face.
  21. If I may guide you in your search, I think it is about what Armenians don't do, rather than what they do.
  22. Having no disposable time these days, I feel guilty typing this hopefully short comment. And I confess that I did not read every comment in its entirety for lack of time. However, there seems to be a maddening tendency in this thread to talk past one another. And the amusing part is that almost every point of view expressed here is largely valid in its own context, often even implied by the writer. So I do not know what the excuse is for being so thick regarding one another's perspectives. Boghos is right, in that without fresh additions a disapora that does not have the benefit of claimed religious profundity (read Jews) is bound to erode and eventually disappear given enough number of generations. The only way to avoid it would be to have such a high birth rate that compensates for the ones that willingly or unwittingly assimilated away. Boghos is not advocating an abandonment of Armenianness, but a simple acceptance of this cruel reality. I disagree with him, however, that we can or should be comfortable with that fact. I will always be melancholic about lost Armenian souls, and vansihed communities that once thrived with hope and determination. A part of me will always be profoundly sad about that. Armenian Pirate is right, in that one need not take the forces of assimilation lying down. One should do what one can to maximize the number of Armenians left after each generation. Why? Well, that goes back to what Boghos said earlier; the idea that our survival should be centered around the country of Armenia. The more Armenians we have around by the time Armenia assumes its role as a magnet, as a powerhouse of human life and creativity, the better. Then they may start setting roots there with hope and happiness. I see my personal role as increasing the chances that at least some of my descendants will be Armenian enough to give that option a chance. As for Anka, I think he is rather different from Boghos, and is inconsistent in his stance. He, like many other Armenians (of all kinds, from ultra-nationalists to anti-nationalists), doesn't quite understand what makes the Armenian identity and culture, for all its many warts, precious and special. If being Armenian is of no special significance to him, he should stop wasting his time on Armenian sites. Or rather, he should start wasting it equally and equitably among all the cultures that exist on our planet, if he thinks the same of all cultures. He can of course pick a more special culture more to his liking and join the millions of ex-Armenians who have voted with their feet for millenia. That would make me sad, but I can look at that reality and accept it since it is looking at me straight in the face. As for the idea of "faith". Axel is quite justified in evoking it. It was Boghos who once talked of remaining Armenian as an act of faith. At least that is how I interpreted it at the time, and I regard it as a profound observation. It is indeed the faith in a better future, a better time when Armenia is a thriving, proud place, with a huge intellectual contribution to the world culture vastly disproportional to its size, a better time when Armenians and non-Armenians from all over the world make it a place of pilgrimage. A time when 1/64th Armenians would be digging out their Armenian ancestry and proudly proclaiming it as a sign of being blessed. Alright, it wasn't short. Best to all, Twilight Bark
×
×
  • Create New...