Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
Thoth, You are quite wrong. For all his "lack of accomplishment" and self-professed confusion etc., Azat has the right idea about life, if by "accomplishment" he means something other than becoming a rich snob. Viewing life as a pleasure source to be mined as much as possible misses the point of life altogether. Even if you are permanently exhilarated and overjoyed at orgasmic levels for every moment of your life, accumulating every possible pleasurable sensation, you eventually die, and it doesn't matter whether you had a miserable life, or spent it in constant pleasure. Admittedly, this line of thinking is not something that a suitably deep 7-year old couldn't think up, but it's true all the same. We are right to lament when we look back and panic upon seeing that we did not create beauty and depth in others' minds. And I don't mean to say you haven't. You probably have. Azat, I know you are hard on yourself, but leaving behind something worthwhile is not reserved for people you read and see in the news. If you could brighten one child's future, your life would be already worthwhile. If you could make the world better for two people, you are more than even. On the other hand, countless "accomplished" people are nothing but self-centered jerks, whose net contribution to the illusion we call humanity is often either neutral (because there would be a long line of others, jerks or otherwise, equally "capable" and willing to take their place, given the absence of the first one), or plain negative. Of course countless people that are recognizably "accomplished" have immense contributions to humanity. But do something nice and beautiful that you know will remain undone if you don't, and you are already ahead of many an "accomplished" snoberati. TB P.S. I hope the soppiness of the above does not detract the reader from its message. I don't feel like expressing those thoughts in a dour, over-intellectualized way.
-
This topic should be filed under the "Dark Humor" section. And in that spirit ... I propose that we come up with a list of unnecessary body parts with the view to correct what the evolution forgot to delete. I mean, most people use either the right or left part of their brains. I can see an oportunity to reduce brain cancer by a whopping 50% by a widescale targeted lobotomy campaign. Do we really need two lungs? Take one out, and voila, you just reduced the probability of anything going wrong with your lung(s) by 50%. Men that are uninterested in sex, due to old age for example, should have all the now-irrelevant gear taken out as a preventative measure. Oh the possibilities. One of the kidneys? Ear lobes? Do we really need two eyes? Can't we have a normal life with one eye? Having two instead of one just doubles your chances that something may go wrong with your eye(s). And I didn't even begin to enumarate the implications for weight loss. How about heart health? Less organs to feed, less blood to pump. Surely a longer, healthier, and more enjoyable life. This evolution thing sure has left a lot of baggage around. Yeah, it's obvious that we are smarter than nature. It's time to take action.
-
Dear TimeForChange, I think you imply that those of us that do not see their future in Armenia can still be useful, and be good Armenians. I see several problems with it. First, we are nowhere near Jews in terms of overall success, intellectual sophistication, and drive. It is not a matter of time. There are profound cultural differences, into which I will not go at the moment. This relative lack of horsepower seriously compromises the "reason for existence" of an extensive diaspora. Losing 95% of more than half of Armenians in a couple of generations is not a good price to pay to have a "strong lobby" that will at best be a distant second to the Jewish lobby. And for what? So we can keep irritating the Turks? Hardly worth the price, when the price is the cultural identity of my descendants. Second, the choice to remove Armenia from your family's future "in order to do greater good as a member of the diasporan lobby" is simply a useful narcotic. It has a heavy dose of pretense. Armenian culture does not have the strength to keep successive generations in orbit. It is equivalent to giving away your progeny to the host culture. You may or may not live to see the final act of handing over; but it is a virtual certainty. And the third problem is my personal objection to the idea of making another country Armenians' puppet (not that there is any chance of that). I don't want any other country to become my puppet. I don't want to fool innocent hillbilies into fighting my wars. I don't want to "control" other nations. But that's just me. Before you start feeling that I am being hostile, let me say that I do understand where you are coming from very well, and I do sympathize. It's just that I refuse to come to your conclusion. I cannot provide a nice and neat solution; but I also cannot fool myself. Apparently I am too smart for myself . All the same, whatever we may think theoretically, we may end up doing essentially the same thing, namely giving away our descendants to our respective host cultures, after leading relatively painless and pointless lives. Best wishes in your soul searching, TB ---------- minor edit done: I inserted an "I" where it was missing.
-
That is indeed a nice change in attitude. While a depressing number of his critics are indeed nothing but "hooligans", for a long time Mr. Baliozian had taken the same sort of attitude to any critique of his own thoughts. I for one appreciate his increased willingness to engage in a two-way conversation, even though I never experienced it myself. It is still a pity that Mr. Baliozian stands out as a rarity, rather than a small part of a wide spectrum of intelligent thought (or attempts thereof). It is a sad reminder of the mediocrity of Armenian intellectual life.
-
For the "Western Armenians", and increasingly for second and third-generation "Eastern Armenians" as well, Armenia cannot be a past, a "dznuntavair", or a nostalgic memory. A huge section of the disapora does not have memories of Ararat from the Yerevan side. They cannot nostalgically think back to good old Yerevan, and it is silly to force themselves or pretend that they have such feelings. For the said Armenians, Armenia can only be a FUTURE. I personally care much more about Armenia becoming that future than how good an advocate it is for a pet issue. When it suceeds in becoming a vibrant, dynamic center of Armenian existence (which we will know happened when diasporans start settling in Armenia in large numbers, reversing the current trend), all issues of relevance could automatically be "trusted" to it. Obsessing about the genocide, when you don't give Armenia at least a probabilistic place in your future is no different from singing at her grave. Nice gesture, but she won't appreciate the song of lamentation from her grave. If there is any take-home message I want to give here, it is: don't be disappointed if you cannot find today's Armenia in your past. Try to make it your future. Failing that, try to make it your grandchildren's future. That future will arrive when going to Armenia evokes emotions akin to going to Disneyland rather than attending an obligatory church service. And until that future arrives, good old-fashioned "preservation" is all most of us can do. Back to square-one?
-
What Is The Good Of Armenian Church Anyway?
Twilight Bark replied to Armen's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
It is a matter of defining the ideals for different institutions. We all have a pretty good idea of the ugly reality. But that should not detract us from demanding the ideal. The ideal is a pretense. But it is a useful one, providing a reference point. At this point in time, the church is just another private institution, vying for more power, more influence, more perks, more money, bigger, better, and all the nonsense that drives "private enterprise". And it's not necessarily a bad thing. You can't blame the individuals or institutions for asking, but you can blame the government for giving. Let me give an example from a different kind of "priesthood". It is perfectly acceptable, and indeed almost universally viewed as desirable that science departments do "outreach" in order to recruit young minds into science. Of course, the science establishment often sucks their blood and chews out what's left after grad school, but that fact would not be a part of their "proselytizing". Microsoft would have a much harder time going into schools with the explicit intention of producing future Microsoft programmers, even though they may be offering a more prosperous or even more meaningful future. The history and the perception of one of the two "institutions" allows it to get away with something that others cannot. The church milks its perceived image and "national" position for all its worth. And why wouldn't they, when everyone else is? In an ideal situation, they come and ask, the government raises its middle finger, and the case is closed. As for the misdirection of diasporan funds. Like all funds, they are being wasted and channeled in breathtakingly inefficient directions. Who has the organizational level and clout to do something about it? Certainly not the Twilight Barks or ArmenSargs of HyeForum, or a few dozen readers. Only the government has the ability to mold and guide. The church could be a formidable moral force, even for non-believers. But forget it; we know it's not going to happen. And we can go door to door preaching to diasporans that they should stop supporting the church. What will it accomplish? Needless to say we would be dismissed (or worse) by most of the "friends of the church". And from the few that agreed, we would have taken away the only national totem that was near and "tangible" to them. Most likely they will proceed to view being Armenian as a pointless exercise in masochism, and assimilate away. Most will not turn into vigorous reformers of anything, not even the neighborhood grocery store. Just as the church should compete with other denominations by offering higher spirituality and self-consistency rather than bullying them out of Armenia, the non-church entities should offer sensible alternatives for the souls and funds of Armenians everywhere. The keyword is competition. The regular disaporan is the "client", and any entity with national or nationalistic pretenses is competing for their "business". Have we learned the basic tenets of free-enterprise yet? -
What Is The Good Of Armenian Church Anyway?
Twilight Bark replied to Armen's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Dear ArmenSarg It's not that I don't agree broadly agree with your sentiments. I do. It's just that I think there is a qualitative difference between an institution that is supposed to have no ego of its own (the government) and those "Private" institutions, such as the church. I agree completely with you about the "qualities" of the church. The cars, the perks, etc. It disgusts me. However, the church has always been a self-centered, and often selfish institution, Armenian or otherwise. I just don't expect much from them. On the other hand, if they are having even a limited success in competing for the "souls" of stupid rich people, it says to me more about what the government is NOT doing than what the church IS doing. As for people being "smart", "educated", etc. All I can say is that intelligence and sophistication is often highly compartmentalized. "Soft" matters that do not lend themselves to "left-brain" kind of analysis leaves many a "smart professional" looking like a deer staring at a bright headlight. Armenians are still orphans as far as I am concerned. I hope I clarified what I meant a bit more. Again, I would like to stress that I agree with your sentiments very much, in most ways. TB -
What Is The Good Of Armenian Church Anyway?
Twilight Bark replied to Armen's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Individuals can define their priorities as their background and intellectual abilities allow and guide them. We, as individuals, should be assumed to be stupid and in need of guidance. I am not bothered much by other Armenians' priorities, even when I might find them ridiculous. I also think we should not be bothered when the church acts in a way that it thinks furthers its self-interest. I may (and do) disagree with its pursuit of self-interest, but I understand it. However, I am bothered very much when the government of Armenia gets its list of priorities upside down. I am also bothered when the "problem" involves a greedy "state church" and a hopelessly stupid government, and the discussion immediately starts revolving around the hapless, unguided diasporans doing what they think is a good deed (which, incidentally, has nothing to do with the content of the article that started this discussion). This particular problem has nothing to do with the instinctive support of the church by the "old" diaspora. Please keep your focus where it should be. Belittling the traditional diasporans for their instincts, when they are receiving no (or bad) guidance from the motherland is another instance of that "m" word. Only the state has the means to lift itself and the nation (in and out of Armenia) up from our bootsraps, above and beyond our "natural" rate of evolution. The buck stops at the gate of the government. -
Well, at least in Turkey the name "Isa" (meaning Jesus) is used. So there.
-
So many good points made here. Indeed, academia is like a cult with plenty of unwritten rules about how to conduct oneself. It's not that academia is any less "vulgar" than the corporate world in terms of money, power, and all that. But there is a theatrical role-play that has to be accepted by the "priests" (err ..., I mean academics). Having said that, a lot of eccentric behavior will be tolerated if the fellow cleric (sorry, "professor") brings in a lot of cash and fame to the institution. The day the money dries up, so will the supply of tolerance and good will towards the brash eccentric (or anyone else for that matter). Another aspect of the cult system is the indispensibility of forming one's own "mafia" (sorry, I mean "network"). If outside of academia, one needs to either belong to quasi-academic "campuses" (like the research arms of Bell Labs of yesteryear, IBM, and the like), or cultivate excellent relations with the "church" (darn, my tongue is slipping so often today; I mean "academia"), by paying tribute to the proper gods and donating generously. Damadian apparently did not follow any of those rules all that well. As for Hagarag's comment of Armenians being un-pragmatic ideologues. My feeling is that Armenians are typically hyper-realist hyper-pragmatists, but cannot shake off one cultural trait: they are also hyper-individualists that still run, in their mind's eye, a "small business" or a "shop" in the village or neighborhood. While there are many Armenians thriving in "collective" settings such as academia and corporations, a disproportionate number of Armenians prefer to be running the show in a small operation rather than melt into a big hierarchy, perennially remaining "outsiders". As a gross generalization, we make lousy leaders, and at the same time do not like to be led either. TB
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Dear ArmenSarq, First, let me say a belated "welcome to HyeForum". There is a problem with your timeline, which is cited often. It equates the beginning of the Hye nation to when the foreign powers named us, instead of the time when we named ourselves. This is understandable since the preceding Urartu state dominating Eastern Anatolia and the territory of the modern Republic of Armenia was non-Armenian. So our historians wait until the devastated Urartu people assimilate into the Hye nation spreading eastward and "meet" the Persians as a "new" people. That is understandable, but inaccurate. There is plenty of circumstantial evidence that points to the Hittite client-kingdom of Hayasa-Azzi as the proper beginning of a coherent "Hye Azq". And they existed at least as early as 1350 BC, making our real beginnings at least 800 years earlier than the usually recited date. If, by some historical accident, the little piece of historical Armenia we have left today were situated in northeastern Anatolia, closer to the Hittite heartland instead of south Caucasus, our historians would probably take Hayasa more seriously and put it in its rightful place as our proper starting point. Today's reality seems to shape our "past" retroactively. Twilight Bark -
Computer related puzzles and questions
Twilight Bark replied to Sip's topic in Science and Technology
1 & 2 cross first (2 min.) 1 goes back with the flashlight (3 min.) 3 & 4 cross (13 min.) 2 goes back with the flashlight (15 min.) 1 & 2 cross (17 min.) -
http://www.narek.com
-
Here is a link that explains some of the controversy that most will consider now resolved: http://www.opinionjournal.com/taste/?id=110001844
-
The Nobel Assembly at Karolinska Institutet on Monday awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for 2003 jointly to Paul C Lauterbur and Peter Mansfield for their discoveries concerning magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Thus, Raymond Damadian received what is in technical jargon called "the middle finger". It would be mildly interesting to know the politics involved.
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
A few very quick comments: * My interest is in defining when the Armenian enterprise started, and not so much the anthropological origins of today's Armenians, which is largely a Near Eastern mix. I am referring to the mix, not a particular anthropological type. As I said before, just taking a look at Armenians suffices to conclude that they are ancestrally more Near Eastern than "European", whatever the latter means. * Mainstream Europeans, Americans, Turks, or Jews couldn't care less about Armenian origins. * The "specialist" Turks whose motivation is to prove that Armenians are just another "intruder/invader" group that is fundamentally no different from them, would gleefully approve your speculations. And for the few dozen Jews that care about the subject, your views are just fine and dandy as it conforms to the official Turkish line, and makes Armenians appear much less ancient than they are. Your views are essentially aligned with their wishes, to the extent that they care, which is little. -
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Teutonic Knight, I really do not have the time to entertain this interesting discussion. And I don't anticipate having more time in the near future. I never claimed to possess the ultimate truth. I simply gave my interpretation of what's known. I would let the reader make her/his own synthesis of those competing ideas and considerations rather than us getting stuck in an endless loop in any case. However, I would urge you or anyone else interested in making pronouncements about Armenian origins to actually take a good look at real, live Armenians and do a reality-check before going off in the wrong direction for too long. Sometimes you don't need to bury yourself under a ton of dusty books to see the obvious. Armenians are mostly (and as far as I am concerned, proudly) Near Eastern , with a significant dose of "European" ancestry. And whether being such a mix is particularly unique in the Asia Minor/Caucasus area can be debated. I think it is the norm. To me, the most interesting aspect is not the precise truth about origins, but the way in which one's background, prejudices, aspirations, and place of birth shapes the preferred "story". The choice of the story (or not being interested in the story at all) reveals something about the person or the nation. Twilight Bark -
i heard this name only here in US. but i would guess it means what it means, talar (dalar if pronouced in EA). dalar means fresh, flexible (as refered to a young tree or 'jyugh') but i'm not sure if it's Armenian or not. Talar can mean "fresh" or "green" (as in fresh greenery).
-
Doesn't "asum em vor ..." mean "I say that ..." rather than "I am saying"?
-
While I avoid using "gor" like the plague, and my kids have practically not heard of it (except of course when my "untamed" relatives speak to them ), I do think that the Armenian language needs a proper "present continuous" tense. I would actually use "gor" (or something, anything!) if it were declared a part of the "standard"; I don't care where it comes from. It is a flaw that would be nice to fix.
-
I will spare you the nerdy, long-winded definitions. Armenian: What others call us, but we never called ourselves that. Armen: A "theoretically constructed" tribe, whose historical existence was never directly recorded. From our Greek misnomer Armenoi, and the mythological king Armenak (most Haykazian king names actually stand for tribe names), it is reasonable to assume that they assimiliated into Haik. Armenoid: Upon observing that Armenians represented a typical example of Near Eastern peoples, German anthropologists came up with the name indicating "Armenian-like". One of the noteworthy features of Armenoids is a broad skull (brachycephalic). Not all Armenians are Armenoids, but it is probably true that most are (I don't have any statistics about it, nor do I care). Having to talk about this arcane stuff in embarrassing enough. It is utterly irrelevant to anything practical, except to correct misinformation spread by people with an agenda that has nothing to do with the welfare of the Armenians (such as the ridiculuous notion that we are supposed to be good vikings, and if we are not, we should at least be viking-wannabes). Get real people! This will be all for a while.
-
A new BMW, the latest fashion, the need to show off to their fellow show-offs usually outrank such trifle issues as preservation. There is more than enough money. There just isn't enough intellect. And there isn't enough affection. Money, intellect and heart seem to follow some sort of an "exclusion principle" when it comes to Armenians. Hard to find all three possessed by the same individual. While I don't think the preservation of that church is a priority, I don't see why we should be hostile to those who do want to preserve it. Let them do their thing. I can't see how it would harm the "Yerevan province" a bit. Somehow, doing nothing at all does not attract hostility, but doing something that is not immediately utilitarian does. There is something wrong with that.
-
Two points Gamavor. 1. There isn't much to talk about. Armens hardly exist in the historical record. Their historical existence is deduced by back-propagation from our Greek name and the name of the mythological king Armenak. That's it. 2. Our Europeanness should come from our cultural traits, and not from a relatively small (but certainly not negligible) "European" ancestry. Have you been showing much "Europeanness" lately?
-
This discussion is hereby terminated. Best of enjoyment to you in reading your fairy tales. TB P.S. You are addressing things that I never said or implied. I have no interest in engaging fanatics that start a verbal diarrhea at the slightest hint of an affront to their racial gods. As for Sumerians being Nordic, the kindest thing I can call that is "crap".
