Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
The guy is not preserving a "Little Armenia", he is preserving a "monument" that says "we were here". He is not promoting, even indirectly, an exodus from Armenia. Can anyone seriously believe that people are leaving Armenia because some church in a faraway land has a caretaker? The two are unrelated. In fact, if every Armenian had the dogged determination of Mr. Martin to defend what belongs to their people, we would be in much better shape right now. We can be proud of Armenian traders, "explorers", and colonists. The remnants of a long-gone but noteworthy era deserve some attention and care. Certainly more so than the usual intellectual masturbation exercised in and out of this forum. More, not less, affection for all things Armenian (I don't mean "bimbo-mimbo-mall-brandname-BMW-Mercedes-Jaguar" culture) is needed. And less, yes less, rage is needed. As a closing sidenote, "a modern-day fedayee" (the self-description of the originator of the topic) would theoretically reside in Armenia and confront the powerful the corrupt and the inept. Of course he would have a life expectancy measured in weeks if not days. Regardless, that is what such a label would require.
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Tueutonic Knight, Please don't mix the quotes to which you are responding. You responded to at least three authors without indicating what is written by whom. Not much more I am afraid. First and only? That is not true. That is also an irrelevant claim to slip into this discussion. Oh, even the mother of them all, the Rus, is a Viking creation. But they acknowledge the respective periods (Turkic, Viking, or otherwise) as the time of their genesis, don't they? While the precise language spoken by Haik and Azk is not terribly relevant to the discussion of defining the time of genesis, the fact that they were in an IE-speaking empire, with Hittite and Luwian the dominant ones, makes the IE assumption more credible than a non-IE speculation. I am not rejecting the possibility of a non-IE Hayasa-Azzi language. I just don't have any evidence that it belonged to a linguistic family different from the rest of the empire. The only important thing is what one calls oneself. Here we are conversing in English, which is the only only language some on this board can speak. Just as non-hebrew speaking Jews are still Jews, non-Armenian speaking Armenians are still Armenians if they still call themselves such. No need not to apply the same criterion to the dawn of history. An irrelevant reply. The point is that the two terms are used to describe the client kingdom. And Hayasa is the more often-used and dominant one. All consistent with what I wrote, which is simply a plausible explanation and nothing more. We have precious little information on what brought Haik and Azk "further east" and south. Nothing in it says it was the Thraco-Phrygians. If it was them, it was probably because of the destruction that they wrought on their path, not unlike what the Schythians did to the Urartu. There is little doubt that the assimilation of Urartu into the Hay people was the result of a defensive pact against the intruding savages. As for Greco-Iranian split from Armenian, it would be geographically more consistent to claim that they went their separate ways to East and West, where Armenian remained at the center. Fine, then all nations are created today. And this statement will forever remain as meaningful as it is today. Remember that tomorrow morning all nations will be created anew, fresh out of the oven. Funny I don't hear anything on the news regarding such a momentous event. You would think it would make the headlines every morning. There were no "Armenians" at the time of Hayasa. There were "Hye"s. The same name we call ourselves today. And the Urartu dissolved into the already formed national consciousness. Their folk history and legends were also absorbed into the Hye nation, which is the inheritor of the Urartu civilization, despite its own earlier beginnings. The Urartu enriched the Hye nation, they did not replace it or initiate it. But I don't need to. While it is more likely than not that they were IE-speakers, that point is not essential to defining the beginning the the Hye nation. And they were not Hayasas. They were Hays. Hayasa means "Land of Hays" in Luwian. The Irish effectively replaced their language with English. That does not make them English, and does not set their time of origin at the period during which Irish was largely phased out. Probably true for the easternmost Anatolia. For the rest, that is only a speculation. Whatever the case may be, it is not relevant to the discussion on when the Hye nation began. Only after you eliminate the group of people bearing the name of the nation in question. And your "only candidate" is not even a particularly good one among the remaining "candidates" after eliminating the obvious one screaming at us. ... story, not history. You got it backwards. Obviously the newcomers assimilated into the already established Hye nation. The name "Armen" is a child of Haik in Armenian mythology, clearly assigning it a subservient/secondary importance to Haik "the father". Again, remember that those names are not really person names but the names of the tribes. "Armenak, Haik's son" means "Armens assimilated into the Haik". Not only that is not true, but your story is pure speculation and is unsubstantiated by historical and archaeological record as well as what can be distilled out of Armenian mythology (which is explained neatly by independent hiostorical record). But that is what they were. As all mythology, their stories contain grains of truth about themselves. But when they tell stories about other peoples' origins and such, as well as place names in Anatolia where hellenized Luwians etc. lived, they have zero (yes, that's right, zero) credibility. In a certain sense, Urarteans still exist. You are conversing with them online right now. As BellTheCat said, we don't know a whole lot about the ethnicity of ordinary folk in the Urartu kingdom. "Biai" or "Viai" sounds close to Hai. Who knows? In any case their folk memory is integrated into that of the Hye nation. The question of whether there was an isolated Urartean-speaking mountain village left at the time of Tigran is interesting but irrelevant. -
Sumerians were mostly Armenoid (I have read some time ago a web site claiming that a sub-group of Sumerians had Dravidian features; I don't know how credible that is). And they were most definitely NOT Nordic. They called themselves "Black-heads" apparently referring to their hair color. Their pictures and statues look quite Armenoid, and not Nordic. You seem to be trying to classify every ancient civilization around the Mediterranean and Western Asia as "Europoid". That is a kind of wishful thinking that I find tasteless. At some point you will have to gain the maturity to admit that the "Europoids" were latecomers to the civilization game. That shouldn't be that painful, as once they came to the game they created the most glorious civilization the planet has seen (in addition to some truly evil things).
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Do you have a source for this please? Well, I didn't say someone before me has deconstructed it that way. I don't know if anyone published such an interpretation or not, but it seems to me the most plausible explanation of the name. In a similar fashion, the kings' names in Armenian "mythological history" often make better sense as the names of the significant "tribes" that joined the Armenian nation in its evolution. Anyway, in the case of "Haik" and "Az", the name of the apparently dominant group, "Hay", must have become the proper name of the nation while the name of the "junior partner" tribe must have come to mean "nation". The inspiration for this line of thinking came from a little, unassuming book by Kegham Kerovpian, titled "Hayots Avantagan Badmutyun", published in Istanbul, 1968. At the end of the book the author explains the "Haikazian" kings' names in terms of tribal names, with no pretense of academic precedence (in fact he says there is nothing "new" in the book). -
Such studies would of course be very useful. But it doesn't seem like the "Armenian" way of doing things (which tend to be more "instinctive" than "scientific"), does it? Both American and Jewish cultures emphasize "rational" mode of thinking significantly more than the Armenian culture does, and such studies would appear as natural, self-evidently useful tools to them. In contrast, it is not uncommon for our "leader" types to not be very interested in other Armenians' world views or circumstances, since they already know everything that needs to be known. What's the point of choreographing with other people when they should fall in line with the one that knows the way. And if they don't, they should be dropped like a rock; they are not needed. If this mentality feels familiar, one should not look hard and far for the explanation of what's in that e-mail.
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Let me quote myself here: ... "Haikaz" can be deconstructed to "Haik" and "Az", corresponding to the Hayasa-Azzi client kingdom of the Hittites, who signed a peace pact with "the men of Hayasa-Azzi" around 1350 BC." ... Hayasa is the officially recorded beginning of the Hye nation. And it predates both Urartu and the Phrygians. It also predates the Hebrew account of the "Hittites", which, at the time Hebrews knew about them were little principalities that fancied themselves as the continuation of the glorious empire (which was no more). -
Just in time, from ArmeniaNow
-
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
A little strange becuase I don't agree with your conclusion that Armenians exist for "only" 2500 years. That is because I also don't agree with some of your reasoning and "facts". I will not be able to continue the discussion, however, for lack of time. ...please stick with facts and ideas and avoid unwinnable battles. Edit: clean up done/ Sasun -
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
It has no practical relevance. But then, normal, well-adjusted humans do care about some things that are not of immediate utilitarian concern. Something to do with "meaning", or maybe "belonging". Even peasants do that, what with their folk tales, songs, ornaments and such. Strange, huh, those Homo Sapiens folk? -
How Is Urartu The First Armenian Kingdom?
Twilight Bark replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in History
Insisting on reasonable evidence, using common sense, and requiring consistency with the way all the other nations on the planet define themselves and their genesis, one is led to identify the beginning of the Armenian nation with Hayasa, which means "Land of Hays". This is corroborated by Khorenatsi's account, which talks about the Haikazian kingdom as the first stage. "Haikaz" can be deconstructed to "Haik" and "Az", corresponding to the Hayasa-Azzi client kingdom of the Hittites, who signed a peace pact with "the men of Hayasa-Azzi" around 1350 BC. Considering that date as the time of genesis, one would arrive at ~3350 years as the minimum age of the Armenian nation. The later additions (be it Thracians or the Urartu) to the mix are simply different stages in the ever-continuing evolution of a nation. It's true, if we define the beginning of a nation as the time when it achieved its latest anthropological mix, our job would be much simpler: it begins today, for each and every nation in existence, since their mix changed from yesterday to today, as it did on each day of their recognizable existence. But such a route would also be meaningless, would it not? The beginning of the "Hay" nation did not wait for the Iranians to name them, or for Greek story-tellers to find a story that fit their world view. -
Depressing as it may be, Armenia's societal development level in many respects resembles that of Turkey in the 1970's. At two extremes of "seriousness", if you look at the military culture, and what passes as "television programming", the similarities are scary. As for self-deprecating male-bashing; it can be fun I am sure. But recent research (in the US) showed that single-mother household was much worse than a single-father household for the welfare of the child. Unsurprisingly, households where both parents are present is the best for the child. We have all observed the shortcomings of the "typical Armenian male". However, we must note that one of the items in the list of their flaws is their lack of involvement in child-rearing. This means that the children are brought up in pseudo-single-mother households. This would not only explain the shortcomings consistent with the social research, but would also somewhat circuitously place the "blame" on the mothers. Please note that I don't really mean blame when I mean "blame". It is a chicken-or-egg sort of problem. As such, the problem is self-propagating. And it cannot be solved by moving to a single-mother model, as the current situation is not much different from such a model. "Making the males accept female dominance" is the old "break the damn losers" philosophy sugar-coated with a thin layer of pseudo-enlightened modernism. The solution lies in the evolution of Armenian family, wherein the mothers would pay as much attention to nurture their sons' psyche as they do to their daughters'. Then the boys who grow up would become the second half of the environment that produces healthy minds. It is going to take time, and the "outside influences" (e.g. TV programs providing behavioral examples) will be a major factor in this evolution, not the amazon takeover of the country. Twilight Bark
-
Oh come on Domino. You know what MJ means. Perhaps he could have used a better term for what he was trying to convey, but the idea is clear: Do not give control of your thoughts, plans and future direction to the very people that you are angry at. "Forgive" is too strong a word for what he seems to be really saying. "Get on with the important stuff, and don't propagate the emotional damage". I couldn't agree more. But I think an explicit act of forgiving is entirely unnecessary. Refusal to be traumatized by it (i.e. putting a certain emotional "distance") is more like it. Perhaps what MJ is implying is that most people cannot put that "distance" without going through an act of "forgiving". That may be right. TB
-
Hi Boghos, I didn't think about labeling the vintage of my thoughts. I guess they are "my" thoughts as of August 2003. The part on "forgiveness" could be labeled "liberal", as in "let them be". The part on "land versus people", could be labeled "quintessentially Armenian" (i.e. continues to this day for most Armenians, regardless of professed priorities to the contrary). The part on "hypocrisy" could be labeled "tongue-in-cheek", with allusions to pre-1915 Istanbul and Tiflis (and wherever else) intelligentsia. But it does contain an expression of the hope that windbags (you know, people that include, among others, me) are least harmful when comfortably far away and irrelevant. And I was also serious in observing that "successful" states are almost universally founded on a pile of hypocrisy, lies, distortions, and often plain evil deeds. And the last sentence is perhaps a non-Armenian strain of thought, expressing that I do not qualify to say or do much on the subject of "statehood", or "what's good for the nation", which, as a minimum, requires a gargantuan ability to ignore intellectual and moral inconsistencies, if nowhere else then in one's own life and interactions. Not that anyone should care. Take care. Edited your quotes. /nairi
-
About "forgiveness": No need to forgive. No need to be obsessed about the crime and injustice either. But please feel free to do either (heck, both if you like). When a more compelling raw material for building an identity emerges, they'll come. Until then, whining about other people's obsessions is nothing fundamentally different from the age-old Armenian tradition of nagging "don't do this; don't do that", without providing a good alternative. About "land versus people": Only a hopeless nerd would put earth/land/tree/planet or various and sundry inanimate objects above people. There are also two cans of worms labeled "country versus people" and "grand ideas versus people", but I am not opening them right now. There is a fundamental hypocrisy in claiming patriotism and "the wisdom about what's good for the nation", without living in Armenia. My current instinct is to discard most pontifications about the subject, and look for actual deeds. Speaking of hypocrisy. My current instincts tell me that "normal" nationhood appears to require a hefty dose of it in constructing a national mythology and for maintaining collective sanity and coherence. Only a small amount of honesty is required. Self-consistency is probably counter-productive. Submitted to the attention of self-declared super-patriots and nation-builders. But why am I bothering; the aspiring "leaders" already know and practice it. Sigh. Not my cup-o-tea. In the meantime, more power to anyone who wants to move to Hawaii and start an Armenian national revival and purge (er.. I mean purification) movement. Finally, in the spirit of the above paragraph, I would advise anyone reading this to ignore what I wrote. Cheers, TB
-
I don't know enough about the subject to independently judge the claims of genocide in that particular case. However, I do know that Myanmar has one of the most brutal regimes on the planet, and that the satirical, mock article sounded like a page from You-Know-Where's government. I wonder if the writer of the article imagines that there is a place on the planet where the mock article, with names substituted appropriately, would elicit respectful nods from its audience, and used as a source for "talking points", with no hint of irony. Now that is funny. Dark, but funny.
-
http://www.theonion.com/onion3924/genocide.html
-
The Place of Truth in Journalism: An Interview with Robert F
Twilight Bark replied to Rubo's topic in Genocide
Dear friends, Poor little Night is being overwhelmed by your responses. He needs all the time he can free up to work on proving the necessity of The Genocide. In fact, I know for sure that he should be working for the rest of his life on proving that murdering a whole nation was necessary for the greater good. Leave him alone; he must be busy, I think. Or he should be if he isn't, because that's the only way he will win his "argument". TB P.S. Night, you are working on the proof, right? -
The Place of Truth in Journalism: An Interview with Robert F
Twilight Bark replied to Rubo's topic in Genocide
You implied as much. If you didn't mean to imply it, the rest of your so-called arguments become invalid. While their treason against the Turkish element of the Ottoman nation had been unintentional, their treason against the Armenian element of the Ottoman nation was very deliberate and enthusiastically bloody. You are in no position to lecture on either cold logic or compassionate morals. You lost your credibility on both counts. Unfortunately you are too thick to realize it. That's insulting. -
The Place of Truth in Journalism: An Interview with Robert F
Twilight Bark replied to Rubo's topic in Genocide
The sad truth is that Armenians foolishly responded the way you claim you would respond (which I doubt, given the extremely low moral standard you are displaying; I bet you would just say "Yeah, yeah, yeah, give me the territory, give me the territory"). In return for their passivity, Armenians were singled out as easy picking. Now, I have no intention of sinking time into this ugly discussion. I propose you do the following. Prove that the Turks were in mortal danger because of the Armenian children, mothers, fathers, elders, and the peaceful peasants that formed the vast majority of their nation, that a genocide of a whole nation was necessary, that it was absolutely necessary for some "greater good", and you can consider yourself the winner of an argument. I will not mention what you should consider yourself until you provide such proof, in order not to discourage you. If you keep working on your proof for the rest of your life, at least you couldn't do any real harm to anyone. Now that is something. -
The Place of Truth in Journalism: An Interview with Robert F
Twilight Bark replied to Rubo's topic in Genocide
"Dear" Night of Armenia, 1. There was no "treason", even in your sick world where a rapist expects loyalty. That is because the vast majority of Armenians were gullible enough to actually show the said "loyalty". Ditto for the vast majority of Armenians murdered for the fictitious "lack of loyalty". Armenian "treason" is a "speculation", if there ever was one. Imperial rule doesn't attain legitimacy when its treatment of the subjugated peoples deteriorates over time. While an elite among the Armenians of the capital Constantinople enjoyed good success in business and the arts, the Armenian heartland kept suffering at the hands of the state and its gleeful tolerance of the Kurds' parasitic behavior at their expense. Not exactly happy-go-lucky, cheek-to-cheek coexistance. More like an extended gang-rape. And I don't give a dead rat's behind whether the Ottomans took over from another oppressor, or had the honor of being the first in the gang rape. If you do, you need a shrink a lot more urgently than any "convincing". The issue for this item is "how were the Armenians being treated at the time of the genocide". And the answer is "so horribly in the Armenian provinces that, only a broken, spineless bunch could keep tolerating it". And they did largely tolerate, until they were murdered. Not a source of pride for Armenians. 2&3. You don't say? You won't find many Armenians denying that there were acts of desperatrion. The perennial pleas for reform were not about lack of luxury living. It was about not being treated like full human beings, even by the miserable standards of the place and the time. The sporadic act of desperation had no military significance. And whatever their significance, assigning the blame to the whole nation could never be justified except as a thinly veiled excuse for genocide. For example, I do not hold the entire Turkish nation collectively responsible for your apparent lack of compassion, inability to reason, and unwillingness to change. You have only yourself to blame for how you have turned out. 4. It's one thing to get the odd report from far, inaccessible provinces, and quite another to see the murder in front of you. In the former, as a diplomat, you have wiggle room to chicken out and do the "right" (i.e. morally wrong) thing. In the latter, the diplomats' need for a fig leaf is not satisfied. As far west as western Anatolia saw Armenians removed. What village do you have in mind that escaped the exile and slaughter? "Istanbul and its environs" doesn't cover it? And yeah, I am sure the Young Turk government was keeping up apearances only for the benefit of the British. Come now, you can lack a conscience and the feeling of compassion, but you lack logical reasoning as well? How about you think about "German discomfort", and "American interest" a little bit, alright? All the government needed was enough uncertainty and confusion to allow them enough time to finish the deed. Murdering the Armenian intelligentsia allowed enough silence and lack of "intelligence" (of both sorts) to do just that. 5. Oh come on. You have convinced yourself that the Abdulhamid regime and the Young Turk government were benevolent entities, deserving of loyalty and respect. And you are asking for evidence to be convinced of something? Evidence is not what it takes to convince you, Night. The real question is, have you convinced yourself that it is time to evolve? Good night, Nighty-night. I hope you enjoy the darkness. -
I'll give it a shot. Maturity: The ability to limit selfish behavior as circumstances require, with the ultimate objective of maximizing the happiness of not just oneself but one's self-defined social circle, which should include one or more individuals other than oneself. Immaturity: Lack of maturity as defined above.
-
The Place of Truth in Journalism: An Interview with Robert F
Twilight Bark replied to Rubo's topic in Genocide
1. It is impossible for a conquered nation to commit treason against an empire. 2. Armenians did not stage a militarily significant "rebellion" before the genocide. And it was too late after. 3. Virtually all the killings by Armenians were "acts of revenge" after the genocide; they cannot be used as an excuse, explanation, or extenuating circumstance. Only a sadistic scoundrel would say "I know you will be my mortal enemy after what I am about to do to you. So I will punish you for your future thoughts and actions." 4. In fact, Armenians from towns far removed from Eastern Anatolia were deported as well. Only Istanbul and its environs were spared for the simple reason that deporting and killing 100,000 Armenians from the capital city of the empire would have been, shall we say, "diplomatically challenging", with the city full of diplomats, foreign journalists and visitors. Of course, virtually the entire intellectual class of the Armenians in Istanbul were rounded up on April 24, 1915, and killed . That essentially lobotomized the Armenian nation to the point of paralysis, and they obediently walked to their deaths like sheep, save for a few remarkable acts of resistance. 5. The issue of "convincing" is more about the Turkish elite "convincing" themselves that it is time to allow the nation to evolve to the level of contemporary civilization. They have not yet done so. So you are asking the question to the wrong audience. 6. Read the archives of the forum for long and detailed discussions of all these issues. -
It seems that Armenian soldiers in Iran had a crucial role in initiating the Baha'i religion, by way of refusing to execute the founding father Bab and giving him "prophetic credibility". Interesting bit of information. http://www.upliftingwords.org/Bab.htm
-
I forgot to add a minor point. Hrant Dink writes in Agos, I think. And, I agree that it is futile to expect any profound or relevant statements (or even thoughts) to come from the Bolis "leadership". Just as the other colonies (including the "thriving" ones that represent the emptying of Armenia), it is a dying community, either suffocated by the state or outpowered by the surrounding stronger culture, and assimilating away into the society to which its members can increasingly relate. It is not much more than a guardian to the Armenian totems in Istanbul. Reasons to feel sad? Plenty. Angry? I don't think so. It's hard to get angry at orphans. Bari gisher.
-
Harkeli Arpa, I have some corrections/thoughts on what you say; I hope you don't mind. Armenian presence in Istanbul, today, is simply an artifact of history. As you know, they did not choose to be born there; they just were. The young ones are leaving in droves. However, they are not going to Yerevan. In fact, many many desperate Armenians from Armenia have gone to Istanbul to work as "undocumented laborers". The tragedy of today is not how fast the Bolsetsis are able to relocate elsewhere. It is the fact that thousands of Armenians from Armenia prefer to be illegal immigrants in Istanbul rather than live in Yerevan. Hrant Dink is not the highest caliber "intellectual" I can imagine. However, he wrote many things that no Armenian in recent history had the courage to say or write publicly. I don't think he is particularly lacking in the courage department. Mutafyan turned out to be a disappointment; but that's not surprising. Before becoming the patriarch he could afford to be bolder in his expressed views. A wrong move on his part can have very negative consequences for his "flock", so he doesn't challenge the officialdom in any way that matters. I can't blame him, ... much. As for changing places with Turks, and craving to be the victimizer. I hope you are just playing your occasional "agent-provocateur" role . Speaking only for myself, I would not want to be the victimizer under any circumstances. The moment the Armenian culture becomes a "bully" culture, and there is nothing I can do to change it, it would be time for me to declare myself as a "citizen of the world" and encourage my children to do the same. The function of our "fortresses" should be to defend, not inflict pain on others. And never mind the past; we are underdefended right now. Unfortunaltely it will remain so as long as our fundamental, cultural problems remain. And that has little to do with being peace-loving.
