Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by nairi:This your speculation. I have mine. I think we shared them enough. Let's leave it at that, shall we? My whole point was the avoidance of speculation. In order to put the ancestors of a perennially indoeuropean-speaking group into a non-indoeuropean environment, you need to speculate. I, on the other hand, don't need to speculate anything, as I am not the one proposing an unproven break in the fundamental character of the Armenian language, or the language of those that later formed the nucleus of the Armenian nation. The onus is on you. quote:Did I use the words "much more special"? Nit-picking on the specific words is justified only when they make a crucial difference to the underlying meaning, or when they are particularly amusing or interesting. The quote above fails both tests. quote:And I certainly hope you'll grow out of assuming one day.Not only was this not an appropriate answer to my hopes, but it also exposes another misconception on your part. We all have to live by making assumptions. (For example, I assumed that you didn't need anybody else's protection in order to participate in a debate, regardless of the merits of your positions. Thoth assumed otherwise. ) Try going through even a small fraction of your life without making assumptions, and you'll see what I mean. However, we can always work on improving the accuracy of our assumptions, and some of us have to work harder than others. Let's leave it at that. quote:See my answer to your first comment.That is an answer that is devoid of content. To demonstrate to Thoth that I can be patient even when I think it is not warranted, let me conclude with an example. If a rock has been sitting here today, and it has been reported to be there 3500 years ago, and there is no evidence that it was moved there from somewhere else, the most reasonable working assumption would be that it has "always" (i.e. since the "creation" of the place) been there, and not moved there from some place else. The two alternatives are not of equal weight or probability. No hard feelings, and take care. TB
  2. quote:Originally posted by nairi:But what definitions are you disciplined with that many others who have studied this field forever are not? It was not self-glorification. It was a statement of prerequisite for making sense. I hope everyone that studies the field forever has disciplined thinking, although I would not bet on it. As for you, I hope you are working on it, rather than rely on somebody else's "discipline" too much. quote:... but as you said yourself, Indo-European has been acquired by Armenians. I did? Perhaps before making an attempt at disciplined thinking, you should start smaller and try to read with more "discipline". quote:Armenians did not invent Indo-European. It is not binary. Lacking the exclusive copyright to Proto-IndoEuropean does not at all mean that they had to borrow it from somewhere. Whom did we borrow Earth from? Martians? I am beginning to suspect that you actually buy the old German crap about them being the true Aryans, and by logical extension, those that don't look like them being "borrowers" or "mongrels". If you are at all influenced by such nonsense, I advise you to exercise your analytical thinking abilities as well as your apparent thirst for encyclopaedic knowledge (which is wonderful, but insufficient). quote:My point is: if after centuries, "trashvel" is still considered a foreign borrowing, then so should Indo-European words. It is irrelevant whether the first recorded Armenians spoke Indo-European or not. What is relevant however, is that Indo-European was never originally Armenian. The only truly native Armenian words are those we can trace back without doubt as purely Armenian inventions. Everything else is either a foreign borrowing or a speculation. This includes the family we chose to belong to. Almost entirely off the mark. Whatever traces of truth that still lingers in those sentences could probably be explained as random occurrences. On second thought, sireli Nairi, perhaps you should take a short break from "thinking". Best, Twilight Bark
  3. quote:Originally posted by nairi:See, I disagree with this. Yes, proto-Armenians had most probably been speaking PIE before they called themselves "Hay". However, once again, PIE was not invented by proto-Armenians. Nor were proto-Armenians the first to speak PIE. How can we know this? You plainly don't. quote:Because PIE had been spoken LONG before proto-Armenians even arrived on the scene. Proto-Armenians "arriving at the scene" is in the imaginations of some linguistic historians, and makes a cute little story. Shame there is no evidence for their arriving from anywhere. But it sticks because it makes Armenians feel European. And Armenians being relatively "unimportant", nobody cares enough to enforce a standard of evidence before parroting it. quote:Therefore, like Germanic languages, proto-Armenian borrowed PIE lexicon and grammatical structure.Really? You were there? Is there evidence showing that "proto-Armenians" (whatever that might mean, if anything) were not among the original PIE speakers? quote:Unlike Germanic languages however, Armenian managed to break away from the standard IE languages through time.Completely wrong. All IE languages "broke away" from the "standard". That is, they evolved. They diverged because of being isolated from one another. There is nothing special about Germanic languages in terms of having higher fidelity to the original "standard" (which was probably quite fuzzy to begin with). quote:This brings me back to my earlier statement that words like "kov" and "katoo", which are almost certainly IE, have been Armenianized over time, but they were not Armenian in their origin, very much like "trashvel". The two cases are entirely different. quote:This is speaking purely from a linguistic/philological point of view by the way. If it is true however, that it were the proto-Armenians who invented PIE, then I will agree with you that the origins of kov and katoo are Armenian. But until then, like you, I will unfortunately have to resume quoting other people's works.Do as you wish. I can only urge you to quote other people's work only after filtering through logic and consistency-check. You'll be amazed how much empty wishful thinking, story-telling, and plain bias there is in such subjects. In any case, if you find evidence that proto-Armenians were not among the original PIE speakers, please do let us know. It would be an interesting breakthrough. I don't have much emotional attachment to IE or PIE; so there is no risk of upsetting me.
  4. quote:Originally posted by nairi:What do you mean by this? That Indo-European lexicon should be considered "native" Armenian or not? Armenian. Becasue at the time of formation of the Armenian nation, the constituent were almost certainly speaking an indoeuropean tongue. I suspect their ancestors had been speaking proto-indoeuropean of some sort a long time before then, but that's another topic. When I have more time. quote: quote:I hope I did not upset you too much. And I certainly do not wish to discourage you. You have my best wishes in your intellectual journey. May you end up much farther than I will ever be. That is what I wish for my children, and I wish the same for you.I hope I didn't upset you too much. Thanks for your wishes though. I hope the same for your children.I also wish you to get your own phrases. TB
  5. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Okay TB jan, I'll be honest with you. Unlike yourself, I have not yet acquired enough knowledge about languages and their origins to make such determined statements as yourself. As for relying on somebody else's disciplines first before making up my own: it is merely a short-cut. You've obviously already educated yourself plenty in this field. I'm still a student of languages, so please give me some more time before I am at your level of understanding. This is not about depth of knowledge per se, age, or experience. This is about intellectual attitude and use of logic. I am not claiming general superiority on any subject. I am simply inviting you to be more logical in making sense of human history. quote:And thus they acquired Indo-European like their Hittite cousins. Or are you suggesting that Armenians were the first to speak Indo-European, and it is from them that the rest of the world acquired it?You miss my points at two levels. First, there is no evidence that neither Hittites nor Armenians had to "acquire" the indo-europeanness of their language. But that is in fact irrelevant, which brings up the second level. Even if the anthropological ancestors of Armenians did acquire their language from elsewhere, the "Hye" nation per se was formed when those people were speaking an indoeuropean language. To speak about "native Armenian" concerning times when there was no "Armenian" identity is meaningless. That would take us all the way back to the grunts and animal noises that our biological ancestors undoubtedly made. It's not helpful. Whatever the particular group of people brought with them at the time of formation of the Hye nation constitutes the most ancient "native" words, regardless of what group of languages they belong to. Some later additions would also qualify, if they came with a group of people that assimilated into Armenians in such numbers that they redefined what "Armenian" was, such as the language of Urartu (Nairi? ). For example, the word "khntsor" (apple) was perhaps not in the language at the time of Hayasa. But being an Urartuan word, it is certainly a native word. I am sure there are many instances where we would be testing our sanity trying to decide what is native and what is not. However, indo-european lexicon in the Armenian language is not among them. I hope I did not upset you too much. And I certainly do not wish to discourage you. You have my best wishes in your intellectual journey. May you end up much farther than I will ever be. That is what I wish for my children, and I wish the same for you. Over and out, Twilight Bark
  6. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Hey TB - don't be mean. I was not being mean. I was, and am still, irritated by a refusal to be receptive. I have near-infinite patience with people as long as I perceive them to be with good will. If I sense that my counterpart is motivated by "scoring points" of any sort rather than having an honest exchange of ideas, my patience evaporates, as it should. quote:A problem I have with you, MJ and occasionally some others is assuming that everyone who posts here is some kind of academic. It's a shame you base your problem with me on a misperception. quote:(and some like me don't even type with discipline and certainly can't spell right in any event). Its just the way it is. When was the last time you saw me pick on people's spelling troubles? You know this has nothing to do with typing or spelling discipline. quote:this doesn't mean that the rest of us don't have anything at all to contribute - or can't learn. When was the last time you saw me even remotely imply that? quote:Fine - correct mistakes and suggest avenues of exploration etc if you know them - but please resist putting people down. I know its less fun and perhaps more work - Yes. As I am now having to put in time that I actually don't have. Nairi got none of the points I tried to make, misrepresented what I said, and simply repeated her false perceptions about language, history, and identity. It was the combination of ignorance and arrogance that triggered my "harsh" response. I have no time to entertain someone whose main intention is to "win" an argument simply for the sake of "winning" it. quote:but your goal is not to just have a two way conversation with MJ is it? - for that you can use email. I see no need to drive away good, interested people - like Nairi - with such patronizing comments.Nairi's patronizing attitude (and the implied low probability of her walking away from the exchange better informed) is the root cause of this wasteful debate. Even the most "challenged" correspondent will get infinite patience from me as long as he or she does not display the toxic combination of ignorance and arrogance.
  7. quote:Originally posted by nairi:What is "by origin" though? Who were the first speakers of Indo-European? How did it spread? And how did Armenians acquire it? You'll agree that the answers to these questions are all mere speculations and that the theories keep changing. Even if Armenians were born into Indo-European, or voluntarily adopted it as their native language, it was still not originally theirs. Therefore, Indo-European words that sound originally Armenian (like kov and katoo), are actually Armenianized forms, very much like cow and cat in English. The "origins" are not as mysterious or murky as they are often made out to be, especially when one is disciplined with definitions. Armenians first appear as a coherent entity as a subordinate province in the Hittite Empire, by the name of Hayasa-Azzi province (the "Haykazian" period in Khorenatsi). Since Hittite was also indo-european, and Hayasa-Azzi shows itself as a coherent entity with which the Hittite center signed a treaty relatively late in the life of the Hittite empire, it is reasonable to assume that the language of this first coherently "Hye" entity was indo-european as well. As for the precise languages that their anthropological ancestors spoke, it is not all that relevant to deciding what forms a "native" Armenian word, as there was no concept of an "Armenian" at the time. If we go far back enough, our material ancestors spoke the grunts and screams of the apes, and going further back they ultimately were the silent unicellular organisms. Fascinating to be sure, but not relevant to deciding which words are "native" Armenian. Keep thinking. TB
  8. quote:Originally posted by nairi:... Besides, Mosjan, many many many words in any language were taken from another language at one time or another. That's why we have language trees. Armenian belongs in the Indo-European family. This means that words like "kov" and "katoo", are not necessarily Armenian in origin, but they have been Armenianized over time. So, if it's okay to say "kov", then it's also okay to "trashvel". Sireli Nairi, I am afraid your understanding of "language tree" is fundamentally different from mine. Armenian is an indo-european language by origin, and not by imposition or colonization. Therefore, most (almost all) "indo-european" words in Armenian are also "native". The word "trashwel" is almost certainly a "recent" (it may be centuries for all I know, but still ...) addition to the slang. I personally don't use it, and must confess never heard it in "proper" Armenian. The word "trash" also exists in Turkish, and could have found its way into Armenian via Turkish. In any case, it is not nearly as Armenian as "atsilwil". However, I have no objection to enriching the language by importing or making up words. Perhaps we can mine Grabar as well for an even richer source, and much closer to home. Got to go now ... Duty calls ... TB
  9. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:tb, why don't you just post your comments separately without reference to mine, as the two have nothing to do with one another? CompartmentalizationIt is a very useful tool. Even more so when you can compartmentalize and separate intimately related issues, and present them as separate "practical" micro-problems. Voila! Smoke, mirrors, hocus, pocus, we have nice, clear, solutions. How on earth one could fail to see an obvious connection is something beyond my meagre imaginative powers. It must take a truly gigantic mind to see how unrelated my fictional dream was to the bed-time story told by Mr. Urguplu. Being a mere mortal, I have to live with the curse of seeing how appropriate my dream was, given the warm and cosy "oror" (lullaby) sung by our eternal friend, Mr. Urguplu. [ November 01, 2002, 12:15 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  10. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:if the roa gave a clear message that they didn't have land claims from turkey and wouldn't back any by third parties, turkey would sooner or later be forced to recognise the ag Alright Armenians, time to wake up. Our friend Mr. Urguplu shows, with no trace of a doubt, that the culprit in Turkey's self-limiting view of history, Orwellian culture of governance, and the consequent cultural and economical rot is, you guessed it, The Big, Bad Armenians (insert your scariest horror-movie tune here). Of course, we should have known it all along. I mean, everybody knows that Armenians were the ultimate reason for all the bad things that happened in late Ottoman history, not to mention the straightjacket that Turkey has to wear now. Mr. Urguplu's elders say so; it must be true. Only if the Big, Bad Armenians accept that they have been the roadblock to progress and enlightenment in Asia Minor and its environs, we can all move forward. As a global power with a formidable army, an arsenal of nuclear weapons, an all-powerful political and cultural lobby in the only remaining superpower of the planet, the Big, Bad Armenians must show what a big people they are, and stop threatening the vulnerable, friendless, tiny, landlocked Turkey. Then the poor Turks and their formerly Big, Bad neighbors can start realizing their full potential. Huh!? Oh! Oh. Oh, it was just a dream. I must have dozed off.
  11. [ October 22, 2002, 10:19 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  12. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:I don't quite get your point Indeed. Perhaps you will if you read more carefully. Bye for now. TB [ October 22, 2002, 10:19 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  13. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: for instance, kurtuluş means "salvation" in turkish, and the accent is on the last syllable, but kurtuluş with the accent on the first syllable is the name of the quarter where a number of armenian families still live. taksim with stress on last syllable means "division, allotment", taksim with stress on the first is the name of the taksim square in istanbul. I understand the point about shifting the stress (as a practical means to distinguish between the ordinary usage of the word and as a proper noun). That would be necessitated by daily life in a city. However, can you provide similar examples where mountain names are involved? I am not asking rhetorically.
  14. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:The correct name in Turkish is Agri Dagi. During the 19th century (and, presumably, earlier) this was the name of the entire mountain range stretching as far west as Kagizman. Is it likely that this entire range is named after an insignificant little village on the southern slopes of Ararat? I do not think it is. In addition, "painful" is a correct description for the tortuous tracks that once crossed over these mountains when compared to the more gentle passes over other ranges in the region. During the 19th century, European travellers mention even more ridiculous names for mountain passes in Turkey, like "camel tiring pass" or "trouser ripping pass"! So, probably the current name for Ararat was derived from the old name of the entire mountain range, and the name of the mountain range is perhaps derived fom the characteristics of the routes over it. Steve Much has been said in the forum since I started my latest "silent period", and I have resisted the temptation to comment. But silly etymology for place names has a special place in my heart for some reason. While we don't really know the origin of Agri (pronounced approximately Agh-ruh), we can be pretty sure it has nothing to do with pain. The mountain does not need to be named after the village. The village could have been named after the mountain. Or both could be named after a diety or some such. Also, just because the namesake village was small in historical times does not mean that it was insignificant in prehistoric periods. If you can prove that Armenians had a good reason to name their village in ancient times after a Turkish word for pain, then you might have a case. But you don't. And lastly, the mountain name "Agri" and the word "agri" meaning pain are pronounced with the stress put on different syllables. In the mountain name the stress is on the first syllable, whereas in the word meaning "pain" it is in the second syllable. If the mountain were named after "pain", the stress would be at the end of the word. TB
  15. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Dear TB, Maybe then you should have refrained from your comment above, too? Because, after all, what you where saying above? You would think that, wouldn't you? But it so happens that I think I have thought sufficiently deeply about the subject. It is not a logical inconsistency to wish to see the same in the opinions expressed by others. quote:On the subject of violence... if I have made an impression of a pacifist on you, then it is a misperception.No you haven't. And if I gave you the impression that you gave me the impression of being a pacifist, that is a misperception. quote:Otherwise, I have only attempted to contemplate on the subject of the clarity of the relevant agenda.On which I wished you had spent more time contemplating. Best, TB [ October 07, 2002, 04:21 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  16. [DELETED] Oopsie; deleted double-post. [ October 07, 2002, 04:20 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  17. quote:Originally posted by MJ: This also leads to an enforced understanding that Turkish Ideological and Power Centers are afraid only of their own people and their primary driver is the reluctance to implement Human Right's reforms in Turkey. The Armenian Question is the best kept secret of Turkish Power Structures, it is their most hideous crime, and it is their Achilles Heal. Understood! If one wants to see any changes in the Turkish "doctrine" towards Armenia(ns), one has to opt for Human Right's reform in Turkey. However, this is a very risky proposition - in the process of an attempt to implement such reform, there are two realistic outcomes: 1. Human Right's Reform supporters will take over and the problems between Armenians and Turks would be resolved - and I would like to build on an earlier declaration of Boghos, here, but would like to go one step further, claiming that not only the problems between Armenians and Turks are simple, but also their solutions are trivial - there has to be just rational thinking on the subject. But can there be rational thinking on the subject? 2. Human Right's reform supporters would lose, which is not unrealistic to assume, and not only they will fail, but the secularist orientation of Turkey may change - Turkey is really poor country with nothing but misery for its own people and its neighbors - all neighbors – this is a consequence of their past and present imperialism. Under the known poverty, the best chances may belong to the supporters of Islamic Regime, for example. But then, “Armenians? What Armenians?” Given the second outcome, which is a very serious possibility, maybe Turkey's current Regime is the least of two evils? But then, we are back where we started... Dear MJ,Unfortunately I am entering yet another period during which I should refrain from spending much time here. I just wanted to say that I wish you had thought more thoroughly on the subject before you wrote this. TB quote:1. As far as Armenian Revolutionaries are concerned, hope they enjoy their tenure in Hell;P.S. "Armenian revolutionaries" was an almost deterministic outcome of the circumstances. It is unreasonable to expect a complete absence of violent expression of national aspirations at a time of prolonged and worsening oppression. It is irrelevant. It is like saying, "Only if you didn't scream when he was raping you. Then he got really mad." It is irrelevant not only because the scream was as impotent as the "revolutionaries", but also because it is not the actual cause of anything, by virtue of being an inevitable consequence of events and conditions preceding it. [ October 07, 2002, 03:59 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  18. Mr. Urguplu, The smugness and self-assuredness of your post animated me to reply, against my better judgement. Your post is densely packed with fallacies and traps. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:1. human rights tend to go hand in hand with increased material wealth and fair distribution of it coupled with an increased level of education. Mr. Urguplu does not even bother with posing it as a "chicken or egg" question (albeit false; the direction of causality is quite clear, and is opposite of the direction Mr. Urguplu wishes it were). He displays the wishful thinking of all cultural imperialists: you can bribe your way out of injustice and cultural rot. Not so easy, Mr. Urguplu, not so easy. Material wealth injected into a population does little to further human rights; witness Saudi Arabia for a glaring example. Even the relatively civilized and quite wealthy Singapore still has to endure a heavy-handed, authoritarian regime form many years after the enrichment of the population. On the other hand, high-quality human capital and culture almost invariably lifts a country from its temporary poverty. I cannot think of any country that remained in poverty despite having a high human-development index. Even if we assume that lots-o-money magically created respect for human rights, is that how we want to go about achieving those rights? Is that how you want to achieve enlightenment? Only if you want to build your newly rich and "oh-so-enlightened" society on the bones of the people and civilizations you crushed, to whom you may one day be willing to pay lip service from the safe distance of a century or two. I am touched. The practicality of your thoughts send shivers down my spine. quote:i) over three quarters of turks have never read a book. ii) over two thirds have never studied beyond primary school (which was until recently 5 yeas in turkey). You must mean books that are not mandated by the school. Otherwise the two statements don't make sense together. The reason why people get turned off books is the idiotic school system in Turkey, churning out people who can solve math problems like there is no tomorrow, and yet stumble at the sight of a problem requiring analytical thinking. Surprise? Not really, it reflects what the government wants in its population. quote:iii) more than half have no hobbies, no interests, no occupation beyond professional work. The rich do, and the poor are too poor to have such niceties. So what? quote:in a soccer-crazy country, 48% of the population has never been to a contest.The relevance of soccer game attendance is only by virtue of highlighting your misguided desire to bandy about statistics. When you are not quoting silly, out-of-context quotes, that is. quote:iv) turkey's population has doubled in thirty years from 35 m to 70 m, whereas newspaper circulation stayed the same or even declined, at 3-4 m/day.Considering the quality of journalism in Turkey, a total circulation of zero would in fact be a huge improvement. At least they wouldn't be doing any more harm to the already stupefied population. quote:v) over 82% of the young population would leave the country if the opportunity arose. That's nice. That must mean, among other more direct implications, that they are not rabid nationalists ready to topple the government at the first sign of its enlightenment. quote:v) over 80% live at or below subsistence level.Concerning that problem, send your complaints to the address of the state apparatus, whose mentality you are doggedly defending, your completely false professd self-image notwithstanding. quote:vi) average turkish life expectancy is 62 years (male) and 67 years (female) respectively. See my reply above. quote:anyone making comments on turkish statesmen, intellectuals, politicians soldiers, activists etc. should bear in mind that this is the raw material that they are working with. Thanks for your patronizing suggestion. May I suggest to the giver of the advice to think about why the raw material is in the shape it is? Hint: it is not for lack of riches. quote:there have been several discussions in this forum where the priorities of some members regarding morality have clashed with my priorities regarding practicality. i hope this will serve as an eye-opener to illustrate the nature of our terrain here.Mr. Urguplu apparently lacks the decency to address some individuals individually. Especially ones that expose his "system" of thought for what it exactly is. Well then. As an anonymous bloke, let me repeat what has previously fell off Mr. Urguplu's teflon-coated neurons: Without a moral basis, and logical self-consistency, there is no such thing as practicality. Without such foundations, there is only ultimatums and realpolitik, which you are trying to sugar-coat as some sort of pragmatic enlightenment. If you actually believe the poor excuse for an argument coming out of your keyboard, I can only pity you as a casualty of the Turkish educational system, which effectively lobotomizes the analytical thinking abilities of its captive audience. I will not address the rest of your self-serving and irrelevant mental debris. Happy slumber.
  19. quote:Originally posted by MJ:... this forum is a special place in some ways - this is the only more or less functional Armenian online forum. Agreed wholeheartedly. However, our attempts to explain why that has been the case might diverge somewhat. quote: Many troubled en have come here and gone, but this forum still functions - in relative terms at least. Yes. But our explanations for that success might diverge. quote:For this reason, I think it would be useful in the future too to occasionally point the troubled where do they belong to. Internet history is littered with the carcasses of forums where members tried a little too hard to shove one another off the platform. quote:As far as you disagreeing with me, however respecting my opinions is concerned, I couldn’t follow where did that one come from.The above was written in combination with my oft-expressed reservations about Hagarag's often unfortunate comments and style. It means that you have a lot more capital with me than Hagarag does. It means that, when I see an article bearing your name, I look forward to reading something thoughtful and intelligent. It means that I approach what you write with a "positive prejudice". If I am animated to mildly criticize what you wrote, it is despite my "positive prejudice", and because of my high expectations from you. That was the relevance of that little sentence. Now, Hagarag is (chronologically at least) a grown-up man. He can defend himself in any way he sees fit. And I certainly did not mean to turn this thread into a sorry saga. Anyway, I hope we can now go back to our regular programming.
  20. quote:Originally posted by MJ:Dear TB, With all due respect, I have to tell you that I resent your contention of “Hagarag and MJ having something personal going on.” Where did you get that from? What possibly you think I can have personal or cannot share with Khodja? I did not use the term "personal" to mean "private", if that's what you resent. Obviously you enjoy playing him, and he resents you intensely. Your mutual dislike is noted. Fine. Now please let's not drag it on. I will not re-elaborate on what I think of many of Hagarag's posts, or what I think they reflect about him. And you know that I respect your opinions, even when I disgree with them. All I am saying is that using this forum to torment each other is not a good idea at all. quote:If you were to say that my original comment towards him in this thread was uncalled for, you might’ve been right given that he was raising a valid issue, which I didn’t expect at the time. That too. The issue raised was not so original at this point, but such things are usually punished by indifference, and not by sarcastic posts meant to torment an already troubled man. quote:But like in the story about the boy ‘crying wolf’ repeatedly, who do you blame for it? I am not blaming anyone. And it would have no consequences if I did. In this context, my wish is that, after a certain period of getting acquainted, we let one another be.
  21. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:What a worthless thread... It is certainly not one of the most informative ones we have had. Whatever is going on between Hagarag and MJ, it is by now obviously "personal". But, despite the tongue-in-cheek tone of my post, I was dead serious in reminding Hagarag that one has to consider the morality of what they wish for (even figuratively), even if they may be rightly angry. If Hagarag truly wishes such things when he is angered, his otherwise reasonable positions (he does have a few of them every now and then) would be completely negated due to self-inconsistency (not to call it hypocrisy). Now that message is not devoid of value, is it? My friendly advice to MJ and Hagarag is to ignore each other completely. That shouldn't be too hard.
  22. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:To paraphrase Barry Goldwater, I would greatly like the United States to be cut at the Mason-Dixon line and for the US South to drift out to sea and sink in the ocean. Better yet, when Saddam sends his atomic bomb to the US I hope that he sends it to a location in the South, preferably YOUR community in Georgia. You conservative Armenians continue to make a mess out of the future of our nation and the Diaspora. As Baliozian says 85% of Armenians in the Diaspora assimilate and soon disappear. As for the ROA, it is mainly allied with rogue states. Your comments to others in this forum sometimes are as insulting as your comments to me. It is your personality flaw. Hear hear. While Hagarag's anger is (by now) expected and understandable, his apparent enthusiasm for the wholesale genocide of a region populated by "undesirables" is "surprising", considering his stated feelings about such matters. Talat would be proud; except that he wouldn't want to lose the territory. Tsk tsk.
  23. quote:Originally posted by MJ:My understanding has been that one of the alleged outcomes of Global Warming is the ozone layer. Maybe I am wrong – wouldn’t be ashamed to admit it. As far as I know they are separate problems to the first-order (Thoth in fact gave an explanation already). There may be second-order interactions as I implied in my first post in this thread. quote:However, if the relevant literature may be digested in few days, then it should mean that there is indeed not much literature on the subject, wouldn’t it? As a rule, the relevant and important literature on most subjects is usually quite brief. The rest of the published "papers" (typically in the thousands) are what I lovingly classify as "toilet paper"s. quote:However, I should admit that I disagree with your above-mentioned methodological approach to the problem, and I think the question formulated above may very well lead to misleading conclusions – maybe this is what many advocates of Global Warming hypothesis do? To be more specific, the answer to your question may be irrelevant, for example, if the ‘global’ temperature of the Earth is highly dependent/correlated (as a random process) on the solar activities, therefore the unconditional probability estimates off of that variable alone are of not much relevance, and things have to be seen in the context of the joint distribution of the above-mentioned two random processes. Ahh, but I didn't say "random", did I? You are of course right in pointing out that the temperature may not be purely random, related to many "systematic" variables from the sunspots to the intensity of cosmic rays that may depend in part on the particular angular position the solar system is at as it rotates around the galaxy. And those "natural" variations would be recorded by earth (the thick ice cover in the polar regions I think provides some information in that respect; as I said I am no expert, and not even interested enough to delve into it seriously). So looking at the natural variations (that include systematic as well as random components) one could in principle ask such questions and come up with meaningful conclusions. Good night, and have a good rest. TB
  24. quote:Originally posted by MJ: Clearly there have been a lot of studies on the subject. For some people, these studies are their sole source of income… But … There is no question that there are a lot of "scientists", some of them even "respectable", that have huge conflicts of interest, and are incapable of conducting good science on the subject. But ... quote:As far as I understand, such phenomenon has been alleged but no such evidence has been presented so far. I am afraid your understanding is out of date by a few years. If you do care about the subject, I suggest you read up on it (I, on the other hand, can't be bothered ). Your confusing the ozone-hole problem with global warming suggests that you have a long learning curve. But I am sure for an intelligent person it is a matter of a few days to digest the relevant literature. quote:One of the questions that I have never been able to find an answer to, is which law of physics contemplates that the temperature of the earth has to stay constant. Clearly, historically it has not been constant. That is a straw man argument. The first question to ask is something like "Is the current upward fluctuation explainable by the historic patterns of temperature fluctuations, with, say 95% confidence". If the answer is negative, i.e. the fluctuation is too big and fast to be characterized as "natural", then the second question would be about what we can or should do about it. quote:I disagree with you on the subject of The Economist. In particular, don’t find it particularly free-market oriented.Their idea of free-market emphasizes the "free" (as in freedom) more than a "wild" capitalist would like. But to say that they are not particulary free-market oriented is unreasonable. How would you characterize The Economist? quote:However, I estimate my children’s lives to be worth more than that.Not to take anything from your children, but I think the only individuals on the planet that are worth more than that happen to be mine . Needless to say, for most parents the value of their children is indeed infinite. The society at large has a different way of valuing a person, of course. At the other end of the spectrum, for the military types, the value of a human on the "other side" is measured by the cheapest way to exterminate them. But that's another topic. [ October 03, 2002, 01:52 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  25. quote:Originally posted by MJ:I don’t think the above mentioned excerpt attests to the existence of global warning. It merely refers to the studies. For that you would need to read his book and hunt down the references. quote:As far as I understand, such phenomenon has been alleged but no such evidence has been presented so far.The human-induced component of global warming had indeed been buried within the "noise" until recently (i.e. a case of "inconclusive evidence). However, in the past couple of years there is a growing consensus that we are indeed causing significant global warming. If The Economist, a champion of free-market thinking (and an excellent magazine overall), concedes that it exists but says it is too expensive to prevent, I think the discussion should move away from the hardliner "well, how do we know there is global warming" level to deciding what can and cannot be reasonably done about it. quote:The unit of measurement in that excerpt is unclear as well as how to interpret it and who has measured it. I don't know what you are referring to, but to find out more details I am afraid you just have to read his book. (Disclaimer: I haven't bought the book; no time ) quote:Otherwise, I am for imposing emission controls on rubber-tier manufacturing plants – within the perimeters of common sense. His argument was that it doesn't make sense to spend 20 billion dollars to save one life (in the sense that we can save a lot more lives by channeling the money elsewhere). I don't know your perimeters of common sense though. I also don't mean to suggest that your life is not worth 20 billion dollars.
×
×
  • Create New...