Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by Azat:If you need to research something, do you fall in the trap of these so called "mainstream culture" and use modern tools or do you just use the library with the old fashion card catalog system to find your books. You assume too much. And if you think creating a straw-man argument by pretending that I am equating the rational use of useful new technologies as mindless surrender to the mainstream culture is a legitimate tool in debating a subject, I must say we are off to an unpromising start.Disappointed, TB
  2. quote:Originally posted by Azat:Dear Twilight Bark, >>Can you read your monitor in the bathroom? Yes. >>Can you carry your monitor around? Yes, I do it all the time. >>Can you scribble on your TV? Yes, I can and do all the time. >>Can you spill coffee on your laptop or drop it into the water and say "Oh well, I'll just get another copy?" I can, But I do not want to because it costs alot. >>Does the word "ergonomics" ring the bell? Yes it does. In fact my monitor is much more ergonomic than any book you can show me. Allow me to ask you few questions. Can you read your book in pitch dark? Can you increase the font size, or change the font on the books you are reading just in case the font is not compatible with you? ("ergonomics" remember?) Can you get additional information on the Author or anything in the book within that book? Can your book remind you that you have meetings, or allow you to listen to music, or lookup a phone number, or lookup a phone number and act as your navigation device, or even allow you to play challenging games with it? Do you want me to list more things that you dream of doing that you can't with your book? Oh just in case you want to come out of the 1980s, my "monitor" is a Sony Clie 760C with a 56K wireless modem, 64K color screen and 142 Megs of RAM. BTW - If you need to research something, do you fall in the trap of these so called "mainstream culture" and use modern tools or do you just use the library with the old fashion card catalog system to find your books. Dear Azat,I am so impressed by your technological prowess. I am also so glad that you take your gadgets to the bathroom with you. However, one still cannot escape the simple observation that the electronic books have some way to go to match the user-friendliness of a simple book. If you care to read a bit more attentively, I am anticipating the replacement of paper books by digital gadgets in the future. All I am saying is that the future is not here yet, except for those enthusiasts who are willing to ignore the limitations of a clumsy gadget with whiz-bang features but lacking some of the basics. And I am not dreading that future either; I am looking forward to it. As for the rest of your comments answering points that I never made, allow me to agree with you that search capabilities offered by digital media are certainly very valuable in the "search" mode of reading. I for one, find what internet allows me to do perfectly compatible with my way of doing things. However, having an attention span longer than the clock cycle of a processor, I can enjoy reading my book and digest the points made in it before dashing off to check the life story of the author, or what color socks he prefers wearing, or for that matter, what Azat thinks about it. Regards, TB
  3. quote:Originally posted by Nvard:As for the Redheads in Armenia, they existed long long before the Celtic crusaders..lol... The Celtic invaders came a lot earlier than the crusaders. They eventually melted in the indigenous population. quote:(BTW,it's a proven fact that the Celts actually come from Middle Asia),Hm. Can you point me to the proof? Sounds interesting. quote:the Urartians used to worship all the people that had "Sunlike" hair.All the Kings used to dye their hair and beards RED, to be more like the pagan god Vahagn.Perhaps they learned their fighting skills from one odd "barbarian" from the north where they lived to fight. Worshipping red haired persons would get really old really fast if there were an appreciable number of them among the Urartians I imagine. So it is safe to say that red hair was rather rare (vanishingly so?) among them. quote:As for the dumb "We were blondes before the Turks came" theory, I HATE IT!!!!!!!!and all the Armenians repeat it day by day, just like Hayr mer!It's like we're cripples or something! Unlike what one certain "sage" seems to believe, Armenians are anything but smug and self-satisfied. Anyway, its always nice to read your contributions and perspective. TB
  4. quote:Originally posted by highflyer:TBI will most certianly find this book.I am sorry but I still see the tribal mind set and behaviour of the people of the stans most the same as when Kippling was writing of his experiances of being there.I also have spent a VERY LITTLE time there and found it to be much as he wrote.It is not what you know but who you know and are affiliated with.Very tribal.But I will most certianly find this book and read it and then give a reply. A small correction: The author's name is Jared Diamond (not Jarod Diamond; I can't think why I misspelled it that way). The book does not address the state of "stan" countries per se. When he goes into details, it is usually about his "pet" places that tend to be more exotic and obscure than the near-east/central asia, such as New Guinea, Pacific islands, etc. It is an excellent summary of the important factors shaping human history; and they are rarely what many of us would immediately think. And he doesn't just pontificate; his conclusions are convincing because they are based on facts and solid reasoning. One caution: he tends to repeat some of the points, almost like a teacher who is worried that his pupils might forget them. But it is a must-read.
  5. quote:Originally posted by Azat:The thing that I do not understand is why you feel that my ""whiz-bang gadget" is not as simple as your book when it comes to performing that function. And I would say that the future is not here yet because people like you do not want to convert over to the digital format this making it much more expansive to create e-books thus not enough e-books out there for people who have converted over. You get the picture. It is a bad cycle. It is not as simple because it still feels wooden compared with leafing through a book. It takes longer to do many of the things you take for granted in a book, and that is a non-starter regardless of other nifty features. People adopt something when they see the value. The reason electronic books have been slow to take off is not because people are dumb. It is because they know value when they see it, and it's not there yet in current technology. I have no doubt that the technology will advance to the point where paper books will become marginalized. At that point, our discussion will be completely meaningless, because we will have a new object that will be able to function as a paper book, and be able to do much more if and when we want it to.
  6. quote:Originally posted by Azat:Dear TB, my point, which I am sure you understood very well, or else you would have not commented, Really? You mean you really believe in your straw-man argument? To the contrary, if I understood what you meant I would feel no need to address it. All I could deduce is that it was a rethorical device called "straw-man argument". quote: was that you are no better than any one in the mainstream culture.I don't remember saying or thinking I was "better" than anybody. I do, however, think that we sould all make an effort to step back and be skeptical about where the "mainstream" is taking us, and evaluate it for ourselves analytically. When I say "mainstream", I am basically referring to "peer-pressure". Thus the "mainstream" in the editorial room of an "out of mainstream" publication is entirely different from the "mainstream" in a big-circulation daily. My basic point is to avoid the herd mentality, that is all. I hope I am clarifying my terminology, which is often not all that clear at the outset. quote: You are one of the many who make the so called "mainstream culture". No better, no worse.I can only take that as a compliment, as I often feel more inadequate than superior. In any case, I probably don't deserve the compliment, as I am not really in a position to contribute to the "mainstream culture" appreciably. If I could, I would. And I would still hope that the consumers of my contribution take it with the appropriate reflection and tought.
  7. quote:Originally posted by Azat:Can you read your book in pitch dark? Why would I want to do that? Unless I am 10 years old and enjoy reading my books under my blankie, or a soldier trying to read a darn manual to operate that darn gadget that somebody named Azat invented. quote:Can you increase the font sizeYes, it's called a magnifying glass, and has been around for centuries Ditto for a pair of glasses. Or contacts, which have been around only for decades. quote:, or change the font on the books you are reading just in case the font is not compatible with you?If the publisher was silly enough to publish the book with ancient gothic fonts, I am smart enough to deduce that the contents are probably not worth reading. quote:Can you get additional information on the Author or anything in the book within that book?Refer to my previous comment about attention spans. We don't constantly interrupt people during conversations whenever something pops into our minds, not only because it is rude (which is irrelevant in this context) but also because we want to get the whole picture of what he/she is saying, want to digest the ideas, and see if the whole packege put together makes sense. A book is much denser with (hopefully) well thought-out arguments, and we do well to focus on what's written and give it a chance rather than hyperactively jump from place to place in a futile attempt at cross-referencing everything. The frantic "discussions" on some TV "news" shows how superficial and dangerously misleading their "conclusions" can be. quote:Can your book remind you that you have meetings, or allow you to listen to music, or lookup a phone number, or lookup a phone number and act as your navigation device, or even allow you to play challenging games with it? When the digital gadgets become a lot more like ordinary paper books in the way they "interact" with people, I will be the first in line to buy them, and my book (I will be able to call it that) will be able to do that and much more hopefully.
  8. Dear Sip, Can you read your monitor in the bathroom? Can you carry your monitor around? Can you scribble on your TV? Can you spill coffee on your laptop or drop it into the water and say "Oh well, I'll just get another copy?" Does the word "ergonomics" ring the bell? If and when the digital media become as friendly as an old-fashioned book, there will be no reason to stick with paper. Until then ... As for TV as substitue for books, that's laughable. As highflier said, it may be good in sparking curiosity about a subject, but if you want to really learn about it you need to read a book (or its digital equivalent when it becomes convenient enough to throw around). Sip, you have allowed to be babysat by the mainstream culture too much and for too long. Wake up and start reading books that interest you, not those that "respectable" people say should interest you. Then see where it takes you. If you still cannot gather enough patience to read through a book on a subject that otherwise interests you, perhaps the problem lies elsewhere. Good luck on your adventures. Twilight Bark
  9. quote:Originally posted by highflyer:Kippling(the man who would be king) will give you a insite of the mentality of the people of the Stans.They have not changed much since his times. Dear Highflier,It is sterile to judge and pretend to analyze the traits of the people of "stans". It is important not to forget that up until 500 years ago, the flow of technology, wisdom, and "civilization" in general was from the "stans" to Europe. That wasn't because the easterners were particularly bright, and today's difference is also not because the people of Western civilization are smarter. There are major pressures generated by the scenarios created by an interplay between environmental factors and the history of the place up until that point. I know this sounds cryptic, but a good place to start is Jarod Diamond's "Guns, Germs and Steel". We tend to observe behaviors in isolation from their context, and proceed to judge the "losers" in extremely unfair terms. Mr. Baliozian positively enjoys it, and I have little patience with third-rate analysis or downright vicious untruths. Anyway, I recommend "Guns, Germs and Steel" to anyone that hasn't read it yet. Twilight Bark
  10. quote:Originally posted by Nvard:Actually it was the Greeks that invented the Armen- name of us.I guess they used to call lots of nations with -men ending wich means LIKE (Nman).So considering that the AR thing comes from a Uratian word for Sun(Arev)...so.... Armen actually means LIKE-the-SUN It looks very valid, considering that there were lots of redhead (Sunlike) Armenians.And this was very unusual for the Greeks, I guess. Dear Nvard,Your "like sun" theory is not very convincing I am afraid. The name "Armenoi" basically appears out of thin air in the Greek sources, with no discernible meaning in Greek. It is impossible for the Greeks to come up with an Urartuan-Greek compound word. However, it is quite possible that Armenoi is a corrupted form of a name used by earlier cultures of Anatolia, namely the Luwians and Hittites. "Arma" is the moon god in ancient Anatolia, and the suffix -wanda was used to denote "people", the literal meaning being "of the kind" (the usual w-->k(g) tranformation also explains the origin of the -kan, -gan suffix in Armenian). Armawanda would mean "Moon People", indicating that the "Armenoi" were Moon worshippers. Armawanda --> Armanda --> Armana --> Armenoi is a natural progression of distortions. So a good case can be made for explaining the origin of the name "Armenian" by using Hittite-Luwian languages, witout resorting to the extremely unlikely mixture of Urartu+Greek. As for the red-head Armenians, a red or blond haired Armenian of today is much more likely to have got these traits from the Galatian (Celts) invaders of antiquity and the European crusaders of the middle ages rather than some mythical red-haired Armens marching across Anatolia . If the motivation is to find the bearers of the indo-european Armenian language, no need for that. There is zero evidence that the red or blond haired populations formed the bulk of the indo-european speakers at the time of proto-indoeuropean (childish fantasies of self-absorbed German pseudo-scientists of late 19th and early 20th centuries nothwithstanding). In fact, it is likely that the nordic people adopted the indo-european languages along with the wave of innovations coming from their southeast. Regards, Twilight Bark [ April 12, 2002, 12:27 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  11. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:I don't think money is the problem at all. It is priorities and organization. They are in the wrong order and in short suplly, respectively. By the way have you tried www.radiohay.com ? It should be near the top of priorities. The diaspora needs an organic connection to the homeland. In contemporary culture, broadcast media are the threads weaving the culture and identity together. As for radiohay.com, yes, I did listen to it for quite some time. It has been silent lately. It had a random mix of music genres. I wish they had more conversation (which was almost completely absent) though. Anyway, it seems to have evaporated.
  12. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:I share your views but, as you know, regretfully most Armenians in Armenia proper and many elsewhere are still concerned with making a living at the most basic level.[/qb] Count me in that category. But the financial requirements are probably not so huge (i.e. more than a few million dollars) that the state budget cannot accomodate it. Heck, it may even be obtained as some sort of a "grant". All I know is, there is enough money sloshing around in foreign bank accounts and Mercedes Benzes to make the excuse of "no money" invalid. Forget that; even the current pathetic state budget probably can squeeze out enough money for internet broadcasting. Despite what our traditional hyper-realists may think, this is not a "luxury item" at all. It is part of the basic survival as Armenians, when the dust settles. quote:After reading a few of the most recent posts by some illustrious members, I came to the conclusion that there is one cause for all our maladies. Hint: it is not US. Thanks for being one of the voices of reason.
  13. Dear Arpa, Vahan, and others, At the risk of moving the discussion further away from its official subject (which probably wasn't meant to be a discussion), I would like to add a few points. The Armenian government and what is left of its intelligentsia must show strong leadership in the cultural arena. They have shown none. None. In an ideal world, the standard language would merge elements from the Eastern and Western dialects. The "new standard" would be based on the Eastern dialect (for obvious reasons) but would be more readily intelligible to Western Armenian ears. This becomes more relevant when we pay attention to another glaring lack of leadership on part of the Armenian "establishment": We have no widespread beaming of Armenian TV and radio into the diaspora. One can get a channel via sattelite in the middle east and Europe, but not elsewhere (unless I am mistaken). No internet TV broadcasting, and the mainstream "normal" radio stations are either absent from the internet broadcasting or are under my radar screen. Armenia is too aloof; and that is inexcusable. It should have been beaming multiple channels of TV and radio to the distant corners of the diaspora in a "special" east-west-fusion dialect that would in time form the nucleus of a united language. Similar arguments can also be made for unifying the syntax and vocabulary. It is not that hard; we make it hard. "Hyper-realist", "pessimist", "oh, it would never work", start echoing in my head as soon as I dare think of anything remotely resembling "initiative". Pity. TB
  14. quote:Originally posted by Shirag:I hope you help to inlarge this word's list. Thank you. arm.: Stooik, spanish: estóico. arm.: Gantegh, lat.: candelle; italian: candelle (candle); I guess this word came too, "iugh" oil oleum; .... to be continued... Dear Shirag,Do you have any evidence that these words came from Latin (or other languages that you posted about earlier). While it is unlikely that the Romans would borrow many words from Armenians, in the absence of evidence, it is much more appropriate to talk about common roots rather than directionality. As Arpa pointed out, extreme laziness is pervasive in ordinary dictionaries that purport to give the "source" of the word. When lucky, they usually give (at best) only the immediate source from which it was borrowed or descended. Very often, they show extreme bias in favor of the following two classes of languages: "Famous and prestigious" languages such as Latin, Greek, French or Arabic, and "Early languages that captured their imagination" such as Sanskrit or Pahlavi (but not Sumerian, Hittite, Luwian or Hurrian). It is as if the languages of "weaker" or "forgotten" nations or languages that have been attested later than the "classics" could not possibly have those words in common by way of linguistic ancestry, or by way of both languages having borrowed from a third (but not "favorite") language. I am not saying that "water" comes from Hittite "wata". But I am saying that the "water" and "wata" have the same root, and both come from some sort of proto-indoeuropean. Being a late contemporary of the Hittites, the language of Armenians surely contains numerous "native" words that are shared by other languages. Borrowing has to be proved. Otherwise, in the absence of convincing evidence, it is much more appropriate to use the term "common with", or "has the same root as", rather than the silly "from". [ April 05, 2002, 11:48 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  15. quote:Originally posted by Sip:The current CD which is in my truck's CD player has 4 songs by Harout Pamboukjian, 3 songs by Garth Brooks (very famous US Country singer for those who don't know), several Euro/techno tracks, a couple of German Rock songs (RAMSTEIN), and a few SOAD tracks (I just love that CD). So you pick and choose what the mainstream culture throws at you. Better than some other alternatives, but nothing to do with being individualistic, unless one's reference is North Korea. quote:I go to many offroading trips with some of these people that are extremely nice individuals. Some of the people there are probably the most friendly, enlightened, and knowledgable people I have ever met. Good. However, I do not see anything particularly individualistic there. quote:Some of my "Armenian" friends, would never consider hanging out with those people ... calling them rednecks, outsiders, whatever. They make fun of me for listening to country music and enjoying off-roading. But I also hang out with my Armenian friends going to different trips because I also find a lot of value in spending my time that way. Sorry to hear that your Armenian friends have such close minds. What you described, Sip, is entirely within Armenian cultural traditions of befriending neighboring peoples and adopting new ideas from "outside". In fact it is much more in line with the historic Armenian norm than the close-mindedness your friends apparently display. quote:So what collective am I a part of (or in danger of becoming a part of)? The way I see it, I am defining my "individuality" as I go on, without trying to fit in a certain mold passed down from my supposed ancestors who lived in a completely different time than I. Yes, I agree that I am in danger of losing my "Armenian" identity. But as I said above, I don't think I will lose my individuality or become a member of the "Borg" as you claim. So far, no one has been able to explain it to me, why is it important to keep that specific identity ... why is it so wrong to change, adapt, and go on with the times? Keeping the identity is part of cherishing your ancestors. The reason for cherishing your ancestors is the same reason you care about the future. You may be preoccupied with writing a piece of "really neat" code, or publishing a scholarly article. But in a few short years, the code will be obsolete and forgotten (if it ever becomes relevant to begin with), the published papers will become less worthy than a roll of toilet paper, the people that praised and flattered you in social or professional contexts will disappear, and there will be silence. Unless you leave behind in your offsprings something worthwhile, such as the ability to love, to make others happy, to be deep and sensitive individuals. And unless you fulfill your role in the chain of love we call "family" or "ancestry". In the absence of such sensibilities, the only time that matters is today, the only thing that matters is to have a jolly good time when you are alive, and that is the end of it. No need to care about the past or the future. There are individuals that fall in that latter category and yet display some sort of "nationalism". That sort of "belonging" is more akin to "our football team is better than yours" sort of feeling, which has nothing to do with what I am discussing. I do understand that many people will not even know what I am talking about. Then again, some others will immediately recognize the profoundness of cherishing those that came before us, and giving the best that we can to those that will follow us. When family is no longer the vehicle to do that we will have become the Borg. What has this got to do with Armenian identity? Armenians are esentially a tribe; we are all relatives; we are an extended family. When I say "azkagan", I mean "relatives", and when I say "azk" I mean nation. Some people will snub that notion as primitive. I, for one, view it as the only worthwhile reason for a distinct "national identity" to exist.
  16. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:certainly language being a major piece of this Ah yes, the language. Each one of us should try really hard to keep it alive. I mean tooth-and-nails kind of try. The sound of Armenian in the household is in the same class with the sweet fragrance of the pastries, and the warm hug of your parents. However, in the end, if you lose that battle (i.e. your children don't speak it and can't write it), it must not mean accepting total defeat; just a "strategic withdrawal".
  17. quote:Originally posted by Sip:It is not so much of a collective I want to join as it is having "my own" values, culture (As Vahan pointed out), etc etc. I am not saying I want to abandon individuality (completely the opposite). I am just saying that I don't personally care much for roots, tribal identity, history, where I come from, what happened hundreds of years ago, etc. I only care about what is ahead. Once you are stripped of your ancestral, familial connection, you are always one push away from becoming a drone in "the collective". I would like to invite you to observe your "individuality" and see how much of it is really "yours", and how much of it is actually worthwhile. At this stage, resisting assimilation is the "individualistic" route, not the other way around. There is much more analysis to be done on this subject, but I already sank much more time in this discussion than I am entitled to.Best, TB
  18. quote:Originally posted by Sip:Have I become too Americanized, or computerized? Both. How do you say "hook, line and sinkers" in C++ ?
  19. Twilight Bark

    Gini/Wine

    Dear Arpa, You just lit a spark in my mind. It appears that wine was invented around 5000BC, about the same time as the indo-european languages started spreading away from the "indo-european homeland". Unless the cold Russian steppes (that are the favorite "homeland" of European linguists) was the place where wine originated, it gets eliminated as a candidate. That basically narrows the field of candidates for "indoeuropean homeland" down to one: Asia Minor. Of course, now I should go back to my books to see how the "traditionalists" weaseled out of this inconsistency. I don't remember reading anything about this point. TB [ April 02, 2002, 05:01 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  20. quote:Originally posted by Sip:I think there should be a universal language used purely for communication. Yes, Sip, it is called "lingua franca". The idea is as old as history. Sumerian, Hittite, Roman, Swahili, Arabic, French, Spanish, Russian, and of course English have served as lingua franca. English is now destined to become the widest-ever lingua franca of the planet. I am fully supportive of the idea. The "problem" of finding a worldwide lingua franca has already been solved: it is English. That does not mean that one cannot nurture one's ancestral language in addition to being able to use the planet's lingua franca. quote:So basically, I don't think Diaspora is where Armenian "culture" (language, etc etc) should be preserved. Armenian (and the associated ways of life) should be (and will be )preserved in Armenia."Should" is too strong a word. You preserve your language and the elements of the culture relevant and important to you, wherever you are. If you don't care, you don't. I want to hand over the most beautiful aspects of my ancestral culture to my offsprings. If you don't have such a desire, you don't need to. Please feel free to join the Borg collective. After all, "resistance is futile; you will be assimilated". TB
  21. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Guys, do you think we should open a special topic in this forum for learning (or probably "learning") the language? That is an excellent idea. However, being a mediocre speaker of Western Armenian, I cannot offer good help in Eastern Armenian. And at this point in time, those starting from scratch should probably learn the "official", Eastern Armenian, rather than the Western variety that is on its way to a slow, painful death, cut off from its soil. Or we can start synthesizing a hybrid Armenian, and use the unsuspecting students as lab subjects. I hope your idea takes off.
  22. quote:Originally posted by Sip:About the language thing: I know this is a very unpopular stance but I really think the whole world should just pick a single universal language and stick with it. I mean enough with all the different stuff. I don't care which language it is. I even think it should be a completely new language so no one thinks they were cheated! But never-the-less, I think it's about time to start ... (I know how much trouble it was to get the Euro going ... but we have to start at some point!) oh, and it better be an easy language to learn and remember. No more strange spellings, strange grammar rules, strange words. A very simple language ... maybe even a subset of English. Well, in that case I suggest Turkish for you. It is a very structured, predictable language, almost mathematical in its structure. To really make you ecstatic, I would say that it is modular, and with a little effort can be made object oriented To make your life completely self-consistent, I think we should pick one political party and stick with it, should exterminate all that confusing jumble of flora and fauna on the planet except for one animal and one plant (to be decided by a worldwide referendum) and stick with them. Not to mention one make of car and one software company and stick with them. And we should demand such simplicity for all aspects of our lives that have become so bewilderingly and unnecessarily complex and fragmented. I also propose to invest the necessary sums to develop the technology to network our brains together for the most efficient mode of communication, and eliminate the absurd archaism we call language altogether. Imagine how efficient and united we will become. Oh, I can go on about making our lives more efficient and simple, but I am getting too excited. quote:it should be up to me to decide which language, culture, style (or lack there-of ) I want to have in life ... but of course subject to the contraints (rules, regulations, and customs) of the country I live in.It always is up to you, Sip. TB P.S. Warning: Being immersed in computers for too long can put the right side of your brain into a comfortable slumber.
  23. quote:Originally posted by Harut:i would listen to music regardless of its origin, i would dress the way i liked, think the way i liked, and so on... . . . but, then, this nostalgie of Armenianess came to me. . . . but, then, i saw that i was falling behind life. living in Armenian way in US didn't work. and now i have all this mess in my head that i can't make sense of. I think our sense of affecttion and pride in our ancestors, which forms the backbone of our national consciousness, rests on two main themes: their peace-loving nature (as opposed to being empire-builders), and their unique sense of inventiveness that allowed an "old-fashioned" sense of cohesion to live side by side with an enthusiasm for embracing new "things". Conversely, I would not be pleased to see (if I could) my great-great grandchildren unable to go beyond my "inventions" or my "system of thought". I would, however, be pleased to see them remember, study and respect their ancestors. What matters is the preservation of our tribal identity, not "our ways" as defined at a certain time in history. One of the strong forces in contemporary world culture is to isolate one from one's family, ancestors, and "tribe". There are many, many "tribe"s that are better dismantled and dissolved into the Big Blob. The question that you must answer convincingly is whether you think the Armenian identity is one of them. For me, keeping my Armenian identity is my most effective way of thumbing my nose at all the "bully" cultures of the world. Twilight Bark
  24. The link below is an attempted interpretation of an ancient Hurrian tablet (~1500 BC) containing a musical score. From what I understand, it is not at all guaranteed to sound as the original composer intended, because they don't really know the "system" the notes correspond to. Anyway, given the ancestral ties with the Hurrians (via Urartu), I thought it might be interesting for the people on this forum. http://members.aol.com/ricdum/arrangement.mid
  25. quote:Originally posted by Edita:Dear TB, Are trying to say you don't like to be Armenian? If yes,then I feel really sorry for you but if you just wanted to discuss this topic,then I may say it's a really good topic to discuss. Sorry for my poor English,I am an exchange student:) Dear Edita,While being an Armenian is a pretty hard full-time job by itself, and often a pain-in-the-neck, I would not want to be anything else. Even if you gave me all the niceties of "being an Armenian" except for the identity, I would still want to keep my Armenian identity. If you kindly go through the trouble of reading the posts and the threads in which they are written in their entirety, you can perhaps get at the meaning of what's being said. If you still cannot make out the meaning clearly, then perhaps you could try to read posts by the person (inthis case, me) in other threads in order to put a context to otherwise ambiguous statements. I want to believe that you had not yet gone through these avenues when you came to your conclusion about my potentially sorry state. After you show the proper "due diligence", I would be happy to entertain your informed questions. Best wishes, Twilight Bark
×
×
  • Create New...