Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. In early Ottoman history, the name "Ermeni Derbendi" is encountered often, and corresponds to a mountain pass on the way to Bursa. Yes, Bursa, the city in Western Turkey! The name comes from the Byzantine name for the castle in the pass, "Armenocastron" (Armenian castle). Of course, the "modern" name has no trace of the Armenian connection. The current name of the closest village is Pazarcik (little Bazaar), conveniently shortened from "Ermeni Pazarcik". The mountain near the mountainpass used to be known as the Ermenek mountain. Source: "Place Names in Anatolia" by Bilge Umar (in Turkish)
  2. At the risk of elongating this dismal thread, I would like to make a clarification to those that are not well-versed in Sumerology. Sumer had nothing to do with Kuwait; not when it existed in the 3rd millenium BC, and not today. Sumerian civilization was confined to Mesopotamia, that is today's Iraq. The only reason to erase Iraq from a discussion of Sumerians and subsitute Kuwait as the "location" of Sumerians would be to score brownie points with a certain well-known, well-endowed ethnic group that colludes in another case of historical revisionism. And calling Sumerians "quasi-African" is probably best interpreted as a first step in a pathetic attempt at connecting Sumerians with the Hebrews of ancient Egypt. If there was a "settler-newcomer" element in the Sumerian civilization, it was probably from the North, the wishful thinking in certain quarters notwithstanding. If you are tempted to think that this subject is boring or irrelevant, please suspend that temptation. Now back to our regular programming ...
  3. The take-home message for the bystanders is that Armenians can count among their ancestors the ancient "Armenoid" peoples of the Near East, some of whose descendants created the Sumerian civilization. For a playful discussion of the linguistic evidence of this ancestral connection go to /cgi-bin/forum/ultim...ic;f=7;t=000071 Now, this point could have been made perfectly well without bringing Kuwait, quasi-africans, or others into the discussion, but it would have been too reasonable. [ May 30, 2002, 06:03 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  4. As promised, I will not engage in a first-person discussion with individuals that lack the basic faculties for comprehension. However, the innocent bystanders deserve not to be misinformed. Hence my persistence in correcting what is at best ignorant nonsense, and at worst a deliberate attempt at misinformation. During the time of Sumer, the silt from Euphrates and Tigris had not filled up the southern part of Mesopotomia to its current extent. In other words, the shoreline was significantly farther north, leaving present-day Kuwait completely outside of the Sumerian heartland. Even if one professes ignorance of this historic geography, it is inexcusable to deny the common knowledge that Sumerian heartland was between the two rivers and their vicinities, and certainly not in the desert to the south. I submit the above to the attention of those interested in truth, however boring and irrelevant it may seem. For others, I suggest further concentration in fabricating fantasies about imaginary "accusations" (as if it would be a sin) about being a Jew, assorted other identities, and the unfairness of those imaginary accusations, thus staying safely out of discussions for which they are so obviously unqualified.
  5. quote:Originally posted by Domino:TB Many other attempts were made to link the Sumerians with the Turks. ... which need not be dignified by a serious discussion or rebuttal. A shaking of the head is sufficient.
  6. Dear Garo or MosJan, Could you move the out-of-topic discussion to its own topic? Sorry for the nuiscance. Thanks. TB [ May 29, 2002, 02:13 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  7. quote:Originally posted by Lindsay:oh i have no trouble being comfortable...two years in a row i attened the marchs in little armenia (north hollywood) and most of my friends are armenian...i was just wondering if the familys would like not want me there or something. oh and twightlight bark im sorry about the "white" thing...im german...my family has been here since ww2...but i just said white cause thats what im considered...thats the box i check when i register for school and such...there is no german-american box to answer someone elses question...they are from actual armenia...they moved to glendale a few years ago im thinking like 6 or 7 maybe If someone is going to be uncomfortable, don't let it be you As for checking boxes, in the absence of a specific "Armenian" entry in the questionaire, an Armenian would have to mark "white" unless he/she has a parent from another explicitly listed "group" ("pacific islander" sounds cool to me ; what the heck mark that anyway ) and chooses to mark that instead. Otherwise, Armenians are as "white" as Germans are "white", whatever that means.
  8. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: but we should not fight a losing battle (even though we seem to like it) Ahh.. The glory of going down fighting Or... Let's just fix RofA so we can move there (or establish a foothold, as the case may be). First, we have to make them want us I guess. How do you do that?
  9. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:I am starting to "GET IT." Those of us who are the descendants of Armenians who arrived upon US shores circa 1920 or earlier are NOT considered TRULY Armenian. No one mentions us at all. We are TOO American for some of you here. All right, I get it. Let me summarize my take on the subject then. Arabized Armenians often have Arabized weddings, Turkified Armenians often have Turkified weddings, Armenians from Armenia proper often show a melange of influences including Russian, and last but certainly, definitely, categorically not the least, Americanized Armenians often have Americanized weddings. And I don't even know if these are the exceptions or the rules. Now this was enlightening, wasn't it? There.
  10. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:I am starting to "GET IT." Those of us who are the descendants of Armenians who arrived upon US shores circa 1920 or earlier are NOT considered TRULY Armenian. No one mentions us at all. We are TOO American for some of you here. Dear Hagarag,What do you mean?
  11. quote:Originally posted by BTac:How much respect do individual Armenian clergy deserve? What exactly do individual Armenian clergy do for Armenia and the nation? And by Armenian clergy I don't mean the Armenian church as an institution. I'm talking about individual men. Poor BTac is still waiting for answers to his real question. The individual clergy's function, as Boghos said, is "to be there". For many of us, the clergy's function is to perform the ceremonies when we get married, baptize our children, and get buried. I don't attach particularly "Christian" value to those; I value them because it is something that has been done by Armenians for 1700 years, even though those ceremonies replaced our long-forgotten "true" Armenian customs. In other words, I wouldn't bother baptizing my child if I cannot do it in an Armenian church, by an Armenian priest. I wouldn't bother marrying in a church if it is not an Armenian church. In other words, the Armenian clergy are vehicles for carrying on a ceremonial tradition. Even though I hardly buy the biblical story, I am "home" in an Armenian church. I cannot say that for a church of the vanilla variety. An Armenian priest receives the kind of respect from me that I accord anyone fulfilling a perceived need, in a professional manner. Whether he is well-versed in biblical philosophizing is almost irrelevant for me. I think such a "secular" attitude is not uncommon among Armenians, although the non-stop "industrial evangelism" in the US might have changed that somewhat.
  12. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:The leadership position of the AC in the diaspora has deteriorated significantly. It is now much more interested in aligning itself with the powers in Armenia proper. That alignment with the "powers in Armenia proper" is not the sort of alignment we need. In fact, it is downright harmful if it acquires the character of "state religion"; and it is not too far from that. The church must align itself with the interests of the people, not the powers. The current cosy relationship between the Church and the state raises questions about freedom of faith, and does nothing to push the country out of cleptocracy. Such an "alignment" with the powers-that-be is not even in the interest of the church itself.
  13. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: I think the Armenian Church is a spent institution that should withdraw from a "leadership" position. I think that should happen even if there is a danger of leaving a "power vacuum" in the diaspora. The existence of the vacuum perhaps would provide a motivation for qualified leaders to appear. Hello TB, The leadership position of the AC in the diaspora has deteriorated significantly. It is now much more interested in aligning itself with the powers in Armenia proper. The Church failed to create cadres of a quality that would help maintaining its position in the diaspora. It has very little to offer to most diasporans except maybe for celebrating ritual acts. I think there is no vacuum at all, and there will never be. But that is a doctrinary position. We will not see any leaders arise simply because Armenians in the diaspora are not looking for a leader. Even if there was such a high caliber person that would make a "leader" he would probably do much better in an odar environment. Finally, a leader for what ? I think what we need is to have well established "processes": make sure that we are close to the people we need to be in a professional manner and help Armenian in any way we can. I think Armenia will improve very quickly once the perception that it is cleaning up its act prevails. We are not very close to that, but perhaps closer than in the past. The Armenian Church will always be there. Churches in many countries have played an important role in protecting democracy and human rights, this is not the nature of our church. Most of our churchmen see themselves as the guardians of "hayootion" and should be treated accordingly. Public servants without a real mission...But if there is a recommendation to them: "Do not disturb". As usual, I agree with your general idea. I would like to highlight, though, the fact that I said "leaders", and not "leader". As you correctly point out, there is no need for a single leader in the diaspora; that would in fact be absurd given that the diaspora is spread over numerous countries. What I mean is that the church should step aside and encourage non-religious institutions to grow and acquire enough legitimacy to represent a community. The trend everywhere is increased secularization. For someone living in one's own country and culture the secularization poses no risk of loss of cultural identity and alienation form ancestral roots. The same secularization has a devastating effect on a church-centered Armenian community. I am sure you have observed the gradual but unstoppable distancing of the Sao Paulo "kaghut" from the Armenian church as the old generation passed away. Is there an organization that filled the "void"? Can you have such an organization without the "leader" types?
  14. quote:Originally posted by Lindsay:i was invited to an armenian wedding on july 6th and i was planning on going. i don't know the bride and groom..i was invited by the bestman's family. anyway i wanted to know how i should act and how to be proper and what to do, considering im white and not armenian. my friend told me i was going to be the only white person there. i dont feel wierd at all. but do you think they'll be all like what the heck is she doing here and stuff? oh and my friend said i needed to learn to dance. i dunno...any input would be wonderful thank you. Dear Lindsay,This may be nitpicking, but Armenians are white; just not Northern European sort of white. If you narrow the definition of white to the Nordics, you would also have to surrender all the accomplishments of the Near Eastern and Mediterannean civilizations to non-whites, and define it as an extreme latecomer to the adventure of "civilization". There is no need to do that, is there? As for your question, there is no standard answer. The customs vary quite a bit depending on the country the particular Armenian families come from. I know for fact an Istanbul Armenian wedding (in North America) where not a single Armenian song was played; 95% of the songs were Turkish, and the crowd sang along with those songs only to lose its "energy" when the rare non-Turkish song came every now and then. On the other hand, such a scene may be considered justifiable grounds for aggravated assault by a "nationalist" family from Lebanon . The Western-Armenian (i.e. those not directly from the Armenian Republic) families expect their guests to show up for the church ceremony. On the other hand, those from Armenia may be pleasantly surprised that you bothered to show up for the church ceremony rather than directly going to the party. They also apparently expect you to drink a bottle of vodka or Armenian brandy to wash down a whole lamb's worth of meat, as well as the matching amounts of other dishes. As for the "dances", I find the whole "belly dance" routine in poor taste, but I would be in a small minority. I think you should just relax and be yourself. And remember that what you see at Armenian weddings has next to nothing with the traditional Armenian culture, and is a manifestation of what happens to a small and weak culture when it is surrounded by the cultures of power.
  15. quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian: quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ara, talking of honesty everywhere... we should ask. Are you a honest man ? Can you once admit that you have been mistaken ? I told you what you have done is a caracter assassination... now I am waiting that you answer me that I was wrong, and prove me I was wrong... I also saw the critics from the BBC etc... These same sources have also cricised Egoyans film and a lots, one one of these same film that they criticised won the first prize in Cannes festival. Have you read on the other side French critics ? Would you want that I post them for you here ? We all know how English critics are, they bark and bark, when a film is a little complicated for them, while the French critics generally more mature see what is a masterpieces. Now if you were a honest man like you claim, you would admit your mistake and eradicate your caracter assissination of Egoyan from your collection of writtings, and more particulary for a film that you even haven't seen. You attack Egoyan by saying that he also grow up by seing the Turks as monsters ? Then be glad to explain me why the repsentents of Istanbul festival at Cannes, suggested to present Egoyan film at the opening of their festivale. The worst enemy of a film is bunch og yellers like you, that critic a film based on few things you have read about on critics, without having seen the film yourself... we all know how it is easy to kill a film.. and the proof that Egoyans film has achieved what was expected is that its the film that from my knowledge that the critics are the most opposed for the past years... Some call it a genious work(from French critics) and other call it a flop, but again, if they can not understand a film and have been educated to critic "Hollywoodian" films, its their problem. Now shut the ... off... and wait untill you see the movie, before deciding if you will assassinate Egoyan. Have a nice day. i have at no time maintained to be infallible. It doesn't take honesty to admit this, only common sense. Writing as if you were infallible is not much better. What upset Domino is not your claim to infallibility (although one would be forgiven for surmising such self-assessment on your part), but your shooting from the hip, without any regard to factuality or fairness. Any claim of infallibility would indeed be met with ridicule, given the fact that a good portion of your un-borrowed output is seriously flawed if they are meant to be social commentaries. However, if they were meant as the manifestations of a long and public mental masturbation, they are excellent specimens.
  16. quote:Originally posted by MJ:..narrations in the Armenian hectograph ... P.S. My apologies for the misspelled word, above. Meant "historiography." Perhaps the word "hekiat" (as in "badmutiun") got mixed in?
  17. Hi MJ, Good to "see" you again. Yes, the Armenian Church, as the churches virtually everywhere, was largely motivated by self-interest and self-perpetuation. We see this not only in the traditional religions, but academic disciplines as well. Fortunate societies benefit from an alignment of their interests with the powerful institutions within them. And unfortunate societies suffer and eventually disappear because of a misalignment. As damaging as it was to the indigenous Armenian culture, the national church of Armenia did have the consequence of providing a focal point and a distinctive identity based on the grandiose notions of God, eternity and afterlife. I suspect that, had Armenians not converted to Christianity and developed a national church, they would have dissolved into the muslim masses and lost their identity completely. Having said that, I think the Armenian Church is a spent institution that should withdraw from a "leadership" position. I think that should happen even if there is a danger of leaving a "power vacuum" in the diaspora. The existence of the vacuum perhaps would provide a motivation for qualified leaders to appear. [ May 26, 2002, 06:20 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  18. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:TB, Thank you for clarifying your belly remarks. If you could call it that.
  19. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:I still have the belly of a 25 year old, in my old age. It is not time upon which the size of the belly depends, but lifestyle. N.B. the big belly must be accompanied by the proverbial cigar. I am glad to once again hear about your excellent health and fitness level. However, I would like to draw your attention to the fact that I disclosed neither the time profile of the phenomenon nor its general trend, if any. Of course, you may have been commenting in a completely orthogonal sense. Time, though, is a legitimate variable, at least in the sense of being a "parametric variable" (isn't that always the case anyway?). That is, it represents everything else that is changing in your body as you age, as well as the changes in lifestyle. TB P.S. A few more posts in this direction, and we'll need to ask MosJan to move the belly-size posts to their own little topic.
  20. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Ok. But how about the belly ? Well, that is a time-dependent phenomenon
  21. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:But bear in mind that Zoryan is just a collection of New England Armenian fat-belly intellectuals, not a really professionally run place. PS: TB, I am sorry if you are one of them... You are trying to flatter me, aren't you? Nah, I fall comfortably in the "nobody" category. Sorry to dispel any mystique surrounding me. I am as "well-read" as any of them I suppose. And as for being an "intellectual", I would call that my part-time occupation only to the extent that I have sculpted a self-consistent view of reality, and that I enjoy thinking (the first criterion is susceptible to debate, but the second one is a certainty ).
  22. quote:Originally posted by Rouben Malayan:When I was in Yerevan this winter I heard a rumor that the government is about to dismantle the tram rails (for which purpose i wonder). I thought it was a brute joke, one cannot think of more ecological and quiet transport than trams (here in Amsterdam it gives a perfect solution to the noise reduction and ecology problems). I understand the bloody fools in the governement have a short vision and since they make no clean profit- hell with it- dismantle it and sell the steel to the japanese... OK, I understand it makes loses because of the electricity but then don't use trams until situation improves- why in heaven sake do the tracks have to be dismantled? Now, see, that wasn't a rumor I heard and it wasnt a brute joke- its real. ArmenPress News Agency May 16 2002 TRAM RAILWAYS DISMANTLED IN YEREVAN YEREVAN, MAY 16, ARMENPRESS: A senior official of the Yerevan city council downplayed today an estimate, made by a team of volunteers of Yerevan electrical transport department in a bid to prove that exploitation of trams in the capital would be profitable if fares reduced from current 40 drams to 20 (less than 5 US cents). The move came after the city hall has decided to dismantle tram rails in several central streets in Yerevan. Electrical department employees claimed that in case of reducing fares the annual profits would be some 100 million drams, a sizable sum, if compared to loss-making electrical transport, as claimed by city hall officials. Areg Barseghian, chief of the city department dealing with public transport said at today's news conference that the estimate was made wrongly. Barseghian also said that the majority of tram carriages were more than 20 years old being unable to secure comfortable commuting, whereas people appreciate comfortable and speedy transport. According to some estimates, about 80 percent of passengers in Yerevan are transported by vans. Maybe I am being a bit too cynical, but it sounds like someone "well-connected" wishes to sell a few dozen smelly buses to the government.
  23. quote:Originally posted by Sip: quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:... He says that money spent on a silly museum in Armenia is money wasted.... Well, maybe he is right. Maybe the money should be spent on a serious museum rather than on a silly one I'm sorry, I just couldn't resist. Please ignore Dear #646, I think the general idea is that any new museum at this point is by definition a silly one. That would be correct if we were certain that the same resources would still enter the country for a more "practical" purpose. Boghos and I are doubting it aloud I suppose. TB
  24. quote:Originally posted by Harut:forgive me, but i didn't really understand what was the standing of Hughes. can someone clerify please? His position is well-intentioned, but not necessarily realistic or wise economically. He says that money spent on a silly museum in Armenia is money wasted. Many of us, including me, would feel the same way as a knee-jerk reaction. A cool-headed analysis, however, would probably show that such sentiments, although well-intentioned and noble, are not justified.
  25. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Armenia, itself, our people living there will have to bear the burden of forming a country. It is not just money (look at many of the oil rich Arab countries, Nigeria), it is being able to create a functioning society that benefits everybody, even if in different ways. Indeed. It is extremely important for Armenia to eliminate widespread corruption, and build up a very efficient and independent judicial system. These are rock-bottom, absolutely basic requirements for investment to materialize, not just from the diaspora but from any foreign investor. The diaspora, or anyone else, cannot do it for them. quote:If someone wants to build a museum, so be it. It will also benefit Armenia economically. I don't think Armenian needs hand outs. It needs time and constructive help from each of us, however we can do it. Not whinning and complaining all the time.Right again. The money will go directly to the local economic activity, helping a few more people to make a living in a dignified way, and indirectly by creating another "tourist trap" to help generate income in the long term. If and when Armenia becomes a "normal" country and start entering the radar screens of the tourists of the world, it would be nice to have "off-the-wall" places in addition to the more "traditional" attractions. In any case, if you dare not establish a business because of the hostile environment, and do not want to send yet more handouts (with ultimately little lasting value), you build someting, anything, that will keep the locals busy. Why not.
×
×
  • Create New...