Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
Dear Vahan, I think you are referring to Hamshenahays that resisted islamization to begin with. Bert Vaux does say that a good number of the Hemshin Armenians fled from the region and settled elsewhere in response to forced islamization. Those must be the Hamshenahays that you have encountered. Then perhaps the turkish term Hemshinli is more appropriate for referring specifically to the islamicized Hemshin Armenians. Then I re-state my question to the forum: Do you consider the Hemshinli as Armenians, and do you think it is worthwhile to try to reach out to them? And I will add another question: Do you think you can accept them as Armenian only if they convert to Christianity, or is it OK to be a muslim Armenian as long as they acknowledge their roots and wish to be accepted as they are?
-
I have been meaning to bring up the subject of Homshentsik. I got reminded of it when Boghos quipped about them in a recent post. Here is a link to Harvard that contains very informative documents on Homshentsik (Hemshinli). They are the islamized remnants of an Armenian community on the mountains of the eastern Black Sea coast of Turkey. The unusual thing about the Hemshinli is that they have kept the Armenian language and many of the customs, but not the identity.
-
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:But what if I do not think that the intellectual is one who creates a new and self-consistent view of reality? Fine. Feel free to define an intellectual as a person that memorizes more than a certain number of books, or as one that sweeps the floors of a library, or whatever you feel is appropriate. However, if such a definition runs into trouble down the road, you are on your own. quote:Can you define what the self-consistent view is? For example, communism claimed that people are inherently so bad that they would exploit each other without mercy. And yet it also claimed that people are inherently so altruistic that they would work for the common good, and personal gain was not an appropriate motivation. I understand that there were "but"s and "if"s and various loopholes that allowed the official ideology to sound a little less ridiculuous than this, but that was the essence. In any case, I certainly don't want this discussion to turn into the finer points of communism or any other ideology. quote:Ok, then I don't know any self-consistent view of reality.Excellent. Time to start working on one, then. quote:"As for whether the Russian empire deserved its fate, why should we care? " Why we should not? /Because there is no good reason, even if it was an Angels' Collective. quote:"An empire is by definition a self-legitimizing organized crime of collosal proportions. " Wow... where did you get that definition from? Do I need to get it from somewhere? Just think about how you form an empire. If you find one that was formed without killing the innocent, destroying lives and plundering other peoples' posessions, let me know. Then I will revise my definition. quote:"An empire has no moral right to exist. " Moral right? One more definition then is needed. It has as much moral right as a person who is a cold-blooded murderer and robber that feels no remorse for his actions. Pretty low, don't you think? If you still do not see the analogy, this discussion is hereby terminated. quote:"If a group of people decide to herd the masses at gunpoint to follow a certain "new" idea, it is hardly the fault of the intellectual. And herding people at gunpoint (or the point of a sword) is hardly a new and self-consistent way of looking at reality. " You do not have to make people to take guns in order to change the way of life - creating the idea may be the first step. The onus is squarely on the person holding the gun. By the time the "new idea" trickles down to the thug holding the gun, it usually boils down to "If you are with us, and if you kill those that are or may be opposing us, you'll be rewarded handsomely" or "Enough is enough, kill al those -------s". That garbage does not belong in this discussion on what constitutes an intellectual. quote:P.S. Lets continue in another topic not to disturb Ara Baliozian.He is already somewhat disturbed. And I think this discussion is already exhausted.Regards, TB -
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Just your opinion. Naturally. Take it or leave it. It's a free market. quote:One can define the-reason-of-existence as an intellectual by himself I guess. One can just express and create ideas and not to consider that as a reason for intellectual existence.Let me simplify my point. You cannot be an intellectual without creating a new (and self-consistent) view of an aspect of reality. Whether you emotionaly care about the process, or it just happens naturally is secondary. Your intellectual self cannot exist without creation, regardless of whether you care about it or not. In other words, reading lots of books and repeating and mixing and matching their contents with style does not make one an intellectual. quote:Curiosity may be a natural thing - scientific, for example. And there may be no "standard answers" at all. There may be no answers and there may be complete answers but a man can be driven by his curiosity anyway without knowing whether or not the answers exist.Sure. And that means everything will never be perfect, and humans will keep yearning for something different, something beyond (unless they evolve/be engineered into something rather different). Those that will imagine that "beyond" before it happens will be the intellectuals of the future. quote:How can a fresh, rational look at the world destroy society and country? Bol'sheviks and komunists were fresh thinkers in Russian Empire (relatively fresh).There were intellectuals among them driving the idea and actions. Where is the Russian Empire? Did it deserve that faith? By the way, you are talking about the rational look? Wasn't that the rational look of Socrates that changed greatly the Greek Society? Fresh thinking and a new, self-consistent look at reality are not synonymous. There is a glaring inconsistency in the communist theory that only the most naive or cowed can overlook. In other words, it never was a self-consistent idea. The persons that produced it may have been intellectuals due to their other thoughts, but that particular strain of thought was a failed attempt at arriving at a new and self-consistent way to interpret reality even before the first bolshevik picked up a gun. As for whether the Russian empire deserved its fate, why should we care? An empire is by definition a self-legitimizing organized crime of collosal proportions. An empire has no moral right to exist. If a group of people decide to herd the masses at gunpoint to follow a certain "new" idea, it is hardly the fault of the intellectual. And herding people at gunpoint (or the point of a sword) is hardly a new and self-consistent way of looking at reality. [ March 20, 2002, 10:57 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] -
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Isn't it strange that in many cultures intelligencia is anti-establishment? Might it be that the reason is that intelligents are so clever and smart that they cannot get along with others? Dear Vahan, Coming up with new and interesting ways to look at reality is the reason-of-existence for intellectuals. If everything is perfect, then there is no need for intellectuals, and there won't be any intellectuals. The reason there are intellectuals in a society is because things are not perfect and there are people with enough intellect and courage to think against the establishment. Whether intellectuals have good social skills or not is irrelevant. As for the part about "decadence", I am completely lost. Maybe Mr. Baliozian knows what you are talking about. TB -
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:TB, Many musicians and artists, for example, also come up with new and very interesting ways to look at our reality. Some of them are intellectual, some not. Of course they are. quote:And if one comes up with such a beautiful idea it will not mean that he/she is an intellectual.If you can express or interpret reality in a new, interesting (and self-consistent) way, you are an intellectual regardless of whether you know it, and regardless of whether the society considers you as such. quote:Moreover, if I find a new way to look at the reality it also does not mean that it's my reason of existance no matter I am an intellectual or not.It would not be your reason of existence, but it will be your reason of existence as an intellectual. quote:What does it mean "everything is perfect"? If every person is happy or what?Yes. Obviously. quote:Lets imagine that we are living in a highly developed society with very happy individuals in a very rich country. Will we need intellectuals? In my point of view, yes we will, because there will be some people in that society with high curiousity. .But what you are describing is not self-consistent. If everyone is truly satisfied, they won't be looking for alternatives. Curiosity is driven by not being satisfied with the "standard answers". That means "everything is not perfect". Being rich and "developed" is not the same as being happy by a long shot, and "perfect" is even a longer shot. quote:And many curious people can become intellectuals simply because they will know a lot.Being an intellectual has very little to do with how much you know. You must know how to think though. quote:" The reason there are intellectuals in a society is because things are not perfect and there are people with enough intellect and courage to think against the establishment. " Good way for the anarchy. One can always find something aganist the establishment. But unfortunately in many cases great intellectuals with their anti-establishment can destroy the society and country. (or the nation, for instance) How can a fresh, rational look at the world destroy society and country? If a society is likely to be destroyed by the simple act of intellectual exercise, it certainly deserves to undergo what is sometimes termed "creative destruction". quote:"Whether intellectuals have good social skills or not is irrelevant." Do not agree. Intellectuals as well as non-intellectuals are living in a society, so, they should have "good social skills" although i do not know what you mean by "good social skill". I am not saying that it's alright for an intellectual to be an anti-social criminal. If it wasn't obvious, I hope it is now. What I am saying is that being a likeable, polite, and easy-going individual is entirely irrelevant to being an intellectual. One can be a cranky, smelly, self-centered jerk, and still be an intellectual. [ March 19, 2002, 06:40 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] -
quote:Originally posted by Arpa:As to the origins of "ereb" and "asu", almost all paper and electronic sources seem to agree that "ereb" meant "west" and "asu"- east, except that many sources leave it hanging whether "ereb" was original Assyrian or, as many assert- Phoenician. See the URL below, one of many(A simple search will reveal many). I remember reading a post in another Armenian list several years ago on this very subject, and the writer (maybe it was you?) interpreted "ereb" in Erebuni in exactly the same way as you have, suggesting that perhaps Erebuni was meant as "Gate to the West", for the people of Caucasus. Assyrian trade colonies had already spread into Anatolia at the time of Hittites, and the people of Urartu certainly borrowed liberally from the Assyrians when they formed their newly ascending culture. It is quite conceivable that Erebuni started as an Assyrian trade colony.TB P.S. Thanks for being here Arpa!
-
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian:INTELLECTUALS AND ACADEMICS ****************************************** Dear Ara,Here you rise above your usual drone, and touch upon someting interesting, and your analysis is not as off-target as usual. I know that even my praise sounds negative, but I sincerely wish that this article is an harbinger of well thought-out articles in future. quote:. . . Intellectuals are as a rule anti-establishment; by contrast, academics, especially those who are financially dependent on the establishment, are not. Very true. So true that it applies to all societies. And certain "intellectuals" (with quotes, meaning they are more like "poet-of-the-court"s) kiss up to the immediate, relevant "establishment" (let's call it "feudal lords") around them. And when they fall out with that establishment, they feel the need to glorify the alternative, much stronger establishment (let's call it "the king"), if not for material gain, then for the emotional satisfaction of being on the "winning side". They know who they are, don't they Ara? quote:Result #1: our academics,or those I call massacrists (Genocide scholars) and medievalists spend more time attacking the competition rather than defending the people’s interests by exposing the incompetence and corruption within our power structures. "Our" academics are not just genocide scholars; but that is beside the point. The job of intellectuals and academics is not to defend "their" people per se. Academics' job is to find, explore, and defend the truth; a job which often turns into finding a feeding trough, exploring "career" options, and defending the perks of that career. Again, this has nothing to do with Armenians; it is a universal fact. As for the intellctuals, their "job" is to question the dogma, and be intellectually hyperactive. quote:.. . Result #2: Our hooligans assume the role of commissars of culture, our Oriental carpet dealers wear the mantle of statesmen, and our grandmothers acquire the status of role models, Sure, when our "intellectuals" expect and demand enlightenment, support, and nurturing from the bazaar merchants and shoe-salesman-turned-kahanas, and get upset, disappointed and bitter when such are not forthcoming, why should the simpletons know any better? It is relatively easy to be an "intellectual"; it takes a lot more to be an intellectual. Lamentations (basically over a ruined career because the feudal lord didn't like what he heard) dressed as intellectual musings don't cut it. Cursing at the ethnic group to which the feudal lord belongs, and their past and future, doesn't help one to become an intellectual either. quote:as the people, left to their own devices, opt for exodus from the Homeland and assimilation in the Diaspora (a double "white" massacre), and as our leadership…strike that! What leadership? I search our national horizon and all I see is a no-man’s land of opportunists and their loyal brown-nosing midgets whose central concern is (in the words of Levon *****lian: 1868-1943) "obstructing the path of all those who wish to reform and improve our conditions and thus perpetuate a status quo whose sole aim is their own personal profit and aggrandizement." I should like to see one of our academics produce such a sentence! In other words, bad people should stop being bad. Lousy leaders should stop being lousy. Those who benefit from an evil status-quo should become altruists. Stupid people should wise up. Yeah, and I should be 16 again, and have a clean slate to avoid the mistakes I have made. -
quote:Originally posted by Arpa:I am not sure why we call Greece Hunastan except that some other Middle Esatern people call the Greek "yunan" and the country "Yunanistan". The only explanation I can think of- it may have something to do with the Huns. I still can't see the connection. Ion --> Yun or Hun As for the name Asia, I think a better explanation is Assa --> Asia. Starting with Sumerian onwards, as(s)a meant "country, land, field" in the Near East, including in the Hittite empire (e.g. Hay-asa, Land of Hays). Anatolia was regarded as the land by the Hittites, and the Greeks adopted the word used by the locals and deformed it into the modern word. The suffix -astan may also have come from "assa".
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:But from what I see the Turkish authorities really do not want Armenians there. They don't want them here, and they don't want them there. They don't want them anywhere. Maybe they should all read "Green Eggs and Ham" .
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:they are native to the place (at least have been there for the past 2,800 years or so), and still dream of their ararat mountain. They existed as a distinct, coherent entity for at least 3300 years in recorded history. We don't know how much more before then. However, if the Armenian words for lullaby and milk are common with Sumerian, an important part of their ancestors must have been in the region for ~5000 years or so, without knowing that they were Armenians quote:i was surprised to see that most armenians who answered that question in this forum said that they wouldn't return even if it were to become part of armenia.It is true that most Armenians would have a hard time justifying the move, if it involves being dropped in the middle of a dirt road and be left to tame the place with their personal means. However, things would change somewhat if the compensation is channeled into making the place acceptable for a reasonable existence. It would also help the local Turks and Kurds immensely. A win-win situation. quote: then, i ask, why so much talk about getting back the lands, if no-one is going to go live on them? not that i see it as a viable goal, anyway, but still, why no canalise your energies on areas where you can actually get something like genocide recognition, repentance, compensation, and normalisation of relations between the three countries (incl. azerbaijan)?Recognition and repentance are to the Turkish people's benefit, not the Armenians. It is an important step on the way to an enlightened existence. Compensation is meaningless for the betterment of the Armenian culture and existence, if it is to go into personal bank accounts. To make hagarag happy I do think that "proven" claims should go to the legitimate heirs. But the much larger, general compensation would be meaningful only if it were channeled to the reconstruction of Armenian communities in Eastern Anatolia (and no big loss to Turkey since the money would stay in the country and be used for something nice for a change; and this is probably the only way Turkey can afford to pay monetary damages for the Genocide). Normalization of relations are beneficial to Armenians only if Turkey becomes an enlightened country. Otherwise it simply encourages Armenian dependence on a country that is deep down hostile. And if Turkey becomes enlightened, most of the "separate" points discussed here become irrelevant (i.e. merge into the greater issue of true reconciliation). quote:i see it as a moral right of armenians to be able to live in eastern anatolia where they have done so for centuries.That is very nice of you to say. Then I assume you are also in favor of making the necessary changes in the philosophy and structure of the Turkish state. Strong local autonomy, only nominal presence of the "central government" and absolute cultural freedom are the necessary (but insufficient; lots of money is the missing ingredient) conditions for such repatriation. It is also the litmus test for the sincerity of the noble viewpoints declared. quote:(without throwing us out, for we have lived there for a good eight hundred years as well)Absolutely. The alternative is either repugnant or impractical (in many cases both). In any event, all of this is pure fantasy. I fully expect the region to keep toiling in spiritual and material misery for the forseeable future, even though the way out is in principle not so complicated, except for the inexhaustible supply of stupidity generated by chauvinism.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:now that the official turkish position is a difficult one to defend Let me try to summarize in one paragraph. "Nothing happened. Well, if something happened, it wasn't that big a deal. Well, if it was a big deal, we suffered even more. Well, even if they suffered more, they deserved it. Well, even if they didn't deserve it, they couldn't have suffered much because they hardly existed to begin with. Well, even if they existed, they didn't have an official existence. Well, even if they had an official existence, it doesn't count because they hadn't had a state for a long time. Besides, are they really a nation anyway? We doubt it. Even if they are, that was a mistake. Anyway, don't get us angry, or we will do it again; not that we did anything to begin with." P.S. It was more than half a million. [ March 11, 2002, 02:20 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
[ March 11, 2002, 07:25 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:... and the armenians did demand territory from turkey until quite recently, and there is still doubt amongst the army and conservatives that the demands can resurface, to name a few reasons. Actually, on that you and arpa apparently agree. quote:2. i don't think that territorial demands would have any future, nor are they - understandably - conducive to constructive dialogue between the two peoples.Outright territorial demands are not only unrealistic, they are also undesirable for Armenians. Administering lands that are currently inhabited by Kurds and Turks would be a ridiculous proposition. To make it managable, the areas would have to be evacuated, and the current residents compensated for the move, provided for and housed in their new location, trainded for new jobs, etc. The changes would be so inconvenient and expensive that any good will generated in aftermath of the recognition would evaporate quickly, unless truly collosal amounts of money were injected into the process by rich donor countries (fat chance). It is just plain impractical. However, if and when Turkey recognizes the genocide and apologizes for it, it should be prepared to do more than just offer a dry apology and token reparations for "proved" claims (which would form a miniscule fraction of the true loss, not counting the collosal human damage caused by the slaughter). In my view, when the Turkish nation attains the maturity to face its past, and make amends for its mistakes, it should be willing to make the Armenian ancestral homeland (Eastern Anatolia) some sort of a "cultural free enterprise zone", where those Armenians who wish can settle and form communities again on those lands. The state presence would be minimal, and the cultural autonomy for all groups would be guaranteed. This requires the state structure to be decentralized, very strong local governments, and an end to the "unitary state" dogma. I understand that these are hard to swallow for the hardliners and army types, but the ordinary Turks wouldn't care one way or the other in the abstract sense, and would benefit greatly from decentralization in general. And I think most Armenians would go along with such a "laissez-faire" arrangement. quote: the reasons for this are, apart from the fact that no-one cedes territory willingly, are i) armenians were in a minority in most of the provinces they were inhabiting by the 19th centuryThis, in a way, is circular reasoning. Armenians were reduced to minority in many of these provinces precisely because of the ongoing oppression that they experienced at the hands of the dominant groups (Kurds, Turks, etc. i.e. muslims). quote:, and ii) turks had not conquered these lands from an armenian state, but from the byzantine empire (cilicia may be a different case)This is largely irrelevant. The issue has always been about human-rights and self-determination. Just because one colonial power snatched one colony from another oppressor has never been considered as grounds for forfeiting that colony's people's inherent right to self-rule. quote:, and iii) pressing the territorial issue internationally would pave the way for similar demands elsewhere, most notably the americas and australia, but also russia, china and europe, so the turks would have many allies and armenians many adversaries. True. This is one of the most important "practical" difficulties faced by idealistic solutions. The "Solidarity of the Bullies" is an omnipresent feature in the world politics. However, a truly enlightened Turkey should not have to resort to the support of the Bullies Club in order to cope with the situation. quote:i hope that in a hundred years' time, when the genocide has been long recognised and the people of the world have broken the mental shackles of nationalism, there would be the right atmosphere for armenians to settle back in turkey and live with their turkish and kurdish neighbours in peace.While you expressed hope that the genocide will be recognized in a decade or so (I don't remember exactly, but that was the order of magnitude you had in mind), you seem to uncouple that from the more crucial issue of Armenian cultural rights in their ancestral homeland from which they were brutally torn away. If it is going to take another century for Turks to contemplate the possibility of letting Armenians into their homeland, forget it; don't recognize anything. Trust me, you would be doing Armenians a favor by not offering an empty "recognition". quote:it can happen.I agree. And I also think that it is up to Turkey to let that happen. [ March 08, 2002, 04:35 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:hi to everyone again, first, i have not been able to post for a while for I AM GETTING MARRIED THIS YEAR! i had always feared the prospect (my dad is in his 3rd marriage), but at the tender age of 34, i finally conceded, and quite easily at that! i had to travel all the way to antakya (antioch) to get her family's approval, and i did! so, sorry for the absence but it was due to force majeure (love), xqz me. Congratulations!
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Do you wish that I/we enumerate the many, many (beyond accountablity) instances of Armenians being preyed upon by Kurds, Cardassians, chettes of various types, and Turkish soldiers and government dating back.....? I personally would like to know more about the Cardassians. I think you might have meant Circassians. Hum-bug.
-
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Actually, we lump Armenians with other christians living in the Empire (at least I do it sometimes) because massacres were directed to them as well. That would be a huge mistake. I am no expert on the Balkan revolts, but I know that they were pretty vicious. The muslim refugees pouring into the remaining part of the Ottoman Empire had horrible memories to tell. The "activities" of Armenian "revolutionaries" were nowhere near the scale of the events that transpired in the Balkans (including Greece). However, the Balkan refugees viewed the Armenians as one and the same as the "Christians" that they escaped from. Their subsequent behavior towards the Armenians reflects that. We must know better than that.
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Are the studies which show that Armenians are part-Jew and part Mongol upseting you? I would like to remind you that, by the same token, sephardic Jews are part-"Armenian". In fact, all Near Eastern people are part-each-other.
-
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:It seems that this problem had no beginning. Armenians were massacring Turks in the end of 19th century and so did Turks at the same time. It is like kids game "you started first!". Was that the answer to Abdul Hamid's actions against Armenian population that Armenians themselves started to kill Turks? Or it was vice versa? Vahan Vahan,You are thinking too hard and too little simulataneously. There is no ambiguity. A population that is treated with a modicum of dignity would not react violently, as there would be nothing to react to. This is especially true for a traditionally pacific group as Armenians, who preferred to focus on making a living rather than some abstract political ideals. There is no question on "who started it first". The only way to make it ambiguous is to lump the Armenians with the other Christians, which would be unjustifiable. You give way too much credit to the apologist line of thinking.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:whether the armenians had killed the turks, may i humbly inform you that such things did indeed occur. Selam Ali Suat,Of course such things occurred. The real question is, how can any reasonable observer expect an oppressed population not to produce a few violent reactions to their plight? In fact, Armenians were by far the most pacific of the "millet"s. Only when the oppression got heavier, and their pleas for a semi-decent treatment fell on deaf ears for a long time that some (in fact remarkably few) Armenians started expressing their frustrations violently. I don't disagree with anything you say; I just wanted to put things in their proper perspective. Best, TB
-
quote:Originally posted by gen7474:I am encouraged and admire those of you who have attempted to share and provide explanations of why one may reach the observations I have. Translation: I love people that agree with me. Even more so when they try to provide justification for my thoughts. quote:To the others who simply support my thoughts and observations, it does very little to be sensitive to your needs when the automated reflex is hostility and instinctual references to "turkish souls" or "a$$" etc.Translation: I hate to be contradicted. I am a very logical person, and that means that whoever disagrees with my assertions is "instinctual" and irrational. A side note from the translator: Lumping "Turkish soul" and "a$$" together into one category is not appreciated in this enlightened forum. When I say "Turkish soul" I mean it in a neutral, dispassionate sense, and not as some sort of an insult. You have been informed. quote:You do a great disservice to those who are trying to be sensitive to understand you and help other Armenians within our local communities. I beleive that you yourself should examine your priorities and true intentions. If Armenia and Armeninans are of pride and importance than you should do whatever you can to help people understand your feelings/emotions/beleif systems rather than attempt to create and perpetuate such barriers.That is exactly each reply to your post tried to do, including the that has "a$$" in it (crude, but not without descriptive merit). You simply brush aside what you do not want to see. quote:Nevertheless, to answer some of the questions that have been raised and to form a framework of where I am coming from, I have absolutely no affiliation, heritage, direct or indirect links within that part of the world. I had only known very little about Armenia and Armenians until recently and thus had no biases or presumptions against or for Armenians. In my line of work, I deal with people from every heritage, culture and orientation. It becomes important to be sensitive to a persons past and culture. It just becomes very difficult for me to understand why certain idealogies are common, irrespective of the denial by some of the posts. My statement on "murders, killing etc" were based on the vast number of views in reference to the desire and evokable interest to kill people in one ethnic group (i.e. Kurdish, Turkish etc.) to people who may assimilate to "American" culture or those associating with Armenians.Excuse us if we do not take your word at face value. Your post indeed reflects a deep-rooted bias. Pseudo-scholarly sentences are nowhere near enough to cover it. As for the reasons for the bias, one can only speculate. quote:One does not have to look too far to view such opinions, several posts below this one is a post by Hakod titled "..To kill someone just because it is an odar ...". These types of posts are a reality and are more common than I have seen among any other culture.What are you talking about? I have not seen any such posts in this forum. As for other forums, I have seen similarly outrageous posts by hot-headed Armenians and I tried to talk some sense into them to no avail. There are some very legitimate reasons for the rage that you encounter. The way they are digested into a world view and expressed often leaves a lot to be desired. First of all try to understand why these people are so enraged and frustrated. Then tell us your opinion on how these frustrations can be channelled for the betterment of humanity and the world. You can be sure that we would all be interested. However, I have a suspicion that doing such a thing was not your intention. quote:Prejudice exists in all forms. It is a good idea to preserve heritage culture customs etc, however I personally do not beleive that such should come with the belittling of all others, such as Black, Chineese, or non-Armenians in general. There are strong views against such people expressed consistently on these sites. Congratulations on your profound discovery that the vast majority of internet sites are the garbage bins of culture. And generalizing from them is done either by the extremely naive or the garden-variety ill-intentioned. Which category do you fall in? quote:The bottom line is that culture is fine and an integral part of life. In many instances including Armenians it is a direct extension of religion. Many of the customs, traditions and even social interactions are the extension of religion. Hence, one cannot ignore what it is said in your religion and claim that the religion is irrelevant and hail the culture/customs. Afterall it is your faith that will be questioned not your culture.Religion is largely irrelevant in the sense that the Armenian brand of Christianity is quite different from the Western European tradition or even the Orthodox one. Each religious tradition cast Christianity into the pre-Christian cultural characteristics of the population involved. Thus you have the Europeans distorting the teachings of Jesus into a unqualified monstrosity for a very long time, Americans turning it into just another business that trades in souls, and Armenians practicing it with their traditional pacific and non-proselytizing fashion. Given enough time after conversion, the style of the religion reflects the culture more than the other way around. That is also why I categorically reject the notion that Armenians bear even a particle of responsibility for the barbarisms of their European (including North American) "co-religionists". quote:Nevertheless, I have kept a very open mindNo, it is rather obvious that you haven't. quote: and over the many weeks of reading, this is the first post I have written. My opinion as an outsider would be that Armenians are no worst nor any better than any other person in this world.An information-free statement. quote:One should seek humility and humbleness as they are strong moral character traits that are respected and valued.[/quote}And must brush one's teeth before goping to bed.
-
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by highflyer:In 300 [years] we will be the united earth federation. It would be nice if it were a federation. It would imply that it had distinct parts of which it is a federation. Let's hope so. quote:But then there will be no ligitamit reason for predjudice.So then there has to be a new whipping boy.I surely hope that humanity evolves to a stage where the absence of anyone significantly different from the "norm" is not required to keep the peace. A "peace" that is based on the elimination of cultural differences is fake and covers up the underlying ugliness that remains. Not much different from the age-old "peace by extermination". Only this time the exterminated are not individuals but their ancestral identity. If we arrive at a "world culture" that universally cherishes and celebrates differences, now that would be something. -
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Who knows what will happen after 300 years in the US. "Wait and see." Some of us plan to live a little shorter than that . Seriously though, in 300 years almost the entire Armenian diaspora in America will have disappeared. A sad but depressingly high probability. Unless there is a strong barrier (such as religious incompatibility with the host population) to assimilation, the Armenian-American diaspora will simply disappear as a distinct identity. Sure, the descendants of today's Armenians will be all these wonderful things, but not as "Armenians" but as "Americans". Part of the reason for it will be the shortcomings in the Armenian culture that our resident super-genius untiringly repeats. Anyway, in 300 years, the world culture may homogenize into one big blob already. My current belief is that Armenian culture deserves to remain distinct. But my belief won't tip it one way or the other . -
as i see it (cont.) - Pt. II
Twilight Bark replied to ara baliozian's topic in Ara Baliozian's Corner
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:And why do think that years of freedom could give rise to the brilliant art? I offer you two possibilities:1. He is an intellectual mouse that thinks he is a lion. In other words, he is simultaneously too simple and too arrogant to see the obvious. 2. He thinks his audience, being Armenian, is too primitive and crude to notice the silliness of his strategically inserted untruths. Sorry I broke my pact to hold my silence. I am not sure I have a "specific reason". Vahan, it's all your fault. -
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:So the Turkish authorities are busy stirring the local townspeople into a frenzy. 100+ year old Turks saying that they saw Armenian killing Turks. Is there any independent documentation of any of these allegations? Did Western journalists, diplomats or religious personnel f the era ever document anything like this? I have not heard or seen any such documentation. SO IT IS JUST A LOT OF IDLE NOISE CREATED AS A SMOKESCREEN. Since THOTH summed it up quite well, I will offer only one number as a reply and explanation: 1984 [ March 05, 2002, 01:12 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
