Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. Dear Boghos, I agree with you entirely. When I said "the point", I did not mean it in the "rational" sense, although one can take the viewpoint that our emotional and spiritual needs are just as real as any "physical" needs, and therefore compatible with "rational" choices. For example, if one's primary emotional need is "fitting in" assimilation into the larger society is the "rational" choice. On the other hand, the desire for a deeper spiritual life may dictate another "rational" choice. I am simply attempting to construct the menu of choices that "remaining Armenian" provides. The final goal is to be able to say "if you want x, y or z, preserving your Armenian identity will do that best". Such a "rational" approach to such matters is itself rather uncharacteristic for the "instinctive" Armenian psyche, but we evolve As for relocation to Armenia. I think it should be highlighted, underlined, and printed in large, bold fonts on a constant basis . If preserving the Armenianness of your children and grandchildren (and son on ..) is of paramount importance, settling in Armenia is the only way to accomplish that. However, it is usually more complicated than simply buying a one-way plane ticket . Such a move should stop being equivalent to professional suicide and the extinguishing of any other dreams one may entertain, or to plain physical hardship. And unless we somehow get a big jolt of economic development it looks set to remain that way for some time. Anyway, we seem to be starting a new thread here. [ December 05, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  2. quote What did I say to deserve that? I know about Cher's circumstances, and I thought I made it clear that I appreciated her trying to connect with her homeland. Knowing her circumstances, no one would be surprised to see that she felt a bit out of place. But she did it anyway. Good for her. quote My perspective may be limited. But that has nothing to do with my perception of Cher, which happens to coincide with yours. I don't know what the problem is. As an aside, you know next to nothing about me; so it is futile at best and counterproductive in general to pontificate about my perspective and its limits. quote I didn't say I expected her to feel comfortable. Relax Hagarag, we actually agree.
  3. I was hoping to get some opinions before I posted mine, which is just a speculation. There is a w <--> ch transformation in Armenian, which explains the indo-european origin of some words. For example, water in English, wata in Hittite, but the almost unrecognizable chur in Armenian. Work back from chut- to wut- in Old English (Norse etc.), and you get wood-. As for -ag, it is a common suffix in Armenian nouns, (e.g. navag, bnag, kntag) often describing objects with curved contours (I don't off-hand know how strongly they are correlated though). Anyway, it seems to me chutag in its early days must have meant something like "wooden, curved thingy" I would be delighted to hear different takes on it.
  4. Go to www.troy.am/dictionary You can translate anything to your heart's content It will give you the Armenian word with Armenian fonts. For heart, pick the first word from the list that it returns.
  5. quote:Originally posted by nellie: One thing I forgot to mention, Twilight Bark, in answer for your question about positive armenian traits, is family in the Armenian household. The biggest reason why i'm proud to be an armenian, is becuase of the strong connection and attachment I have not only to my immediate family, but also to extended family. Grandpas and grandmas, aunts and uncles, all take part in my everyday life. this is surprising to non-armenians, who are used to being kicked out of the house at age 18, remembering their family only during the holidays, if even this. This connectedness to our families and to each other, is what keeps us unique. The warmth of family life. That is probably the most compelling one. Even the warmest, most caring parents of Northern/Western European background tend to value "independence" (both theirs and their offsprings' after the latter turned 18 or so) much more than the emotional interdependence traditional Armenian culture cherishes. So we don't produce many adventurers. We are not driven to climb Mount Everest. We don't try to reach the South Pole for the heck of it. But we don't use psychiatrists as our main human contact and outlet either. I'll take the warm, big family.
  6. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Twilight Bark, In 1993 a famous Academy Award-winning American actress went to Armenia during a time that there was no heat. She did not visit in the warmer months as many of us did. She froze with the other there to show her solidarity. We flock to a Greek-American, Diamanda Galas, who has many similar traits ot the aforementioned actress. Yet the first actress mentioned is just "too cool" to be an Armenian. Problem is, she is 1/2 Armenian and was there when she was needed most. Our culture is just too "sick" to understand this. Yes I remember clearly Cher's trip to Armenia. What I recollect though is that she somehow felt that she had to go there, and yet was standoffish in terms of interacting with the people there; sort of "afraid to touch" kind of feeling. Anyway, it was definitely a much more active recognition of her roots than many other famous "Armenians". Armenian identity is akin to being a close-knit family, with all the positive and negative implications. Armenian culture values ancestral connectedness, and rejects nation-building by indoctrination. The "indoctrinated" jingoism you may hear from some Armenians is not the glue holding Armenians together; it's just a nuiscance. I don't agree that Cher would be regarded as "too cool" by Armenians. I suspect if she settled into Armenia, she would be revered as a demi-goddess.
  7. quote:Originally posted by Harut: TB jan, we are not theorists here. we are just simple people. Yes Harut jan, we are. And that is better. "Theorists" would be a bad audience to direct such questions, as they would not be representative. For example, Armenians have pluralistic and individualistic instincts. Often they are attracted to libertarian schools of thought. But they would usually not bother defining their collective and coherent intellectual traits coherently, or theorize about them. In fact, Armenians are generally by nature not "theorists". How about that for a "theory". But we can observe ourselves and come up with abstractions of how we feel, how we think, and how we act. I would not want to name our traits necessarily, as I think they are probably distinct enough to resist being described by off-the-shelf vocabulary of western thought. Let me continue along the lines of the example I gave above. I think Armenians do not make good "leader"s, but they do not like being led either. And they do best in small operations. I don't know what to call this, but I think it's there. The specific flavor of this thread though is: which of these distinct cultural traits make their preservation worthwhile, on their own merits, independent of whether we are used to them or not? Any thoughts anyone?
  8. Any opinions on the etymology of the word "chutag" or "jutak"?
  9. Let me give a few possibilities; please pick one (or more) or add a new one to the list of possible perspectives. 1. Being an Armenian is like being a member of an extended family. One should not and cannot deny one's family. 2. Armenian culture is a singularly beautiful and peaceful one. We need to preserve it because it deserves to. 3. Armenians are just superior to others, so why give up membership in such an elite club? 4. Remaining Armenian? Who says I've been trying? Give me a new identity and I'll take it gladly; preferably North American or Western European please.
  10. From Harut And Nellie I get the opinion that the only way for a child to learn being an Armenian is by "learning by doing". I agree. However, I also want to see if there are theoretical reasons for wanting to stay Armenian. Compelling traits that are luring, regardless of whether the environment is Armenian. Can we come up with an abstraction of Armenian traits that are unique and positive (I don't mind discussing the negative ones, but that is a different thread ) ? Hagarag thinks that the Armenian culture is uncool. I do not think that it is uncool. However, I can see that many people would perceive it as such. Perceived "cool"ness is very much correleated with the perceived strength. Make Armenia and Armenians strong (or at least look strong), and it will be "cool". It is a bit more complicated than that; but not by much. In any case, it would be very useful to probe into Hagarag's reasons without being judgemental. There may valuable lessons there. [ December 03, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  11. Dear Harut and Nellie, You provide good answers that I can relate to. But how do you explain it to a young child born in the diaspora? There is a choice to be made by him/her at some point, regarding the "dominant" identity. Should one regard oneself as American/French/Whatever first, and say "oh yeah, my parents are Armenian", or say "I am Armenian, and I am a good citizen of Whateveria"? It is easy for someone born "Armenian". Not so obvious for a child growing in a powerful, "cool" culture, such as the United States or France. So, how do you explain it to a child? Or can you? That is, is there more to it than being a collection of the things we are used to as we grow up? [ December 03, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  12. What is the point of being/remaining Armenian? It would be interesting to have a cross-section of perspectives. And, how would you explain your perspective to a young child? To a non-Armenian?
  13. quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian: The Israeli-Palestinian conflict exposes an aspect of our Genocide that so far may have escaped notice. ... and was waiting to be noticed by a super-genius equipped with infinite wisdom and piercing vision. quote:When Ambassador Morgenthau pointed out to Talaat that not all Armenians were guilty, Talaat is said to have replied: "They may not be guilty today but after what we have done to them we cannot count on their innocence forever," or words to that effect. In other words: If you don't exterminate the whole tribe today, you may end up prolonging the conflict ad infinitum and ad nauseam. If the Israeli-Palestinian conflict continues indefinitely, as tribal feuds tend to do in the Middle East, the number of casualties may reach, perhaps even exceed, the number of victims of World War I in the Ottoman Empire. To put it differently: our children and grandchildren would be busy pelting stones and being shot at in Istanbul, Izmir and Van, we would be making headlines in the international press every day (to the annoyance, perhaps even disgust, of the entire world) and an international array of pundits would pontificate and say: "The Armeno-Turkish problem has no solution." Thus spake our sage. Now you simpletons know that we are supposed to be grateful for the "Final Solution". You see, we wouldn't want to be a nuiscance to the nice civilized people who'd rather be shopping. Aren't you happy that we are now much less of a nuiscance than what would happen if the Final Solution was not implemented? Pheew, that was a close one.
  14. Twilight Bark

    Yes/No

    quote:Originally posted by edward demian: ha is slang.Probably turkish. Actually you haveha in English slang. Ha? Ha! In Enlish is virtually identical in usage. "Ha", just like ma, mama, pa, ba, papa, baba, tata, dada, is one of the "universal words" that exist in many unrelated languages. It was probably being used by Armenians before the arrival of the Turks in Anatolia. Ditto for many/most of the other words mentioned above.
  15. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Eureka, so Armenians are no different than any other nationality!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!So all that I was "fed" at Armenian school and family was a bunch of bunk. So we are as mixed gentically as most other nationalities from the British to the Chinese. Thank you for your confirmation. Armenians are of course different from other nations, just as other nations are generally different from one another. Armenians collectively have certain characteristics that they can be proud of, and certain characteristics that they should work on improving or eliminating. Just like other nations. That does not mean they are indistinguishable. And Armenians are "special". To whom? Only to other Armenians and their friends and enemies. But in general, they are an insignificant little speck in the huge cultural landscape of the planet. Should we care? No. My family is special to me, and that is the end of that. And whenever someone refers to ancestry by the sterile, technical term genetics, I know that there is a serious problem of perspective. It is not the homogeneity of a few stupid genes that makes a group of people an extended family. We all share common ancestry to some extent, and that is a warm feeling, and the only justification for bothering to define a nation; call it tribalism or whatever you like. Having shared ancestry does not mean genetically identical clones. Our ancestors were from many little groups, and we cherish that. But the particular mixture that came together and formed the "Hye" nation defines our ancestry for the large part. We are not some synthetic nation (as many "modern" nations are, or are supposed to be we are often told) whose identity needed to be drilled into its individuals by a central education system. But none of that has anything to do with genetics. Please think in more human and familial terms.
  16. quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian: quote:1. If we, who have nothing to defend and protect except our insignificant egos, cannot come to terms, what are we to think of our bosses and bishops with their long history of partisans rivalries and feuds? Once tribal, always tribal: is that our collective destiny? Mr. Baliozian supposedly wants to see Armenians to become a monolithic army-nation. Nazi Germany and Mongolian Empire come to mind, not to mention the self-image of Turkey. His superficial mind cannot understand that divisions, "feuds", and partisanship are part and parcel of pluralistic, individualist societies. Armenians have practiced it for a long time without giving them such fancy names. For all its "shortcomings", the world has been evolving toward such societies. quote:2. It has been said that empires behave like gangsters and oppressed nations like pimps: yes, but pimps whose secret ambition is to be gangsters. It has been said only by self-serving members of the powerful nations, or intellectual and moral simpletons. Such a view is disgustingly pessimistic. It equalizes the murderer with the victim by saying "Oh shut up! You would have done the same if you had the chance". Believe it or not, there are significant differences in the collective behaviors of cultures. Some are aggressive, and some are not. In Mr. Baliozian's sick mind, the oppressed nations and the empires are morally equivalent, except that the oppressed are actually worse because they are "losers" who cannot get their act together for a good old fashioned invasion, theft and slaughter. And all cultures lust after these wonderful activities with varying degrees of success. I will stick with my view of humanity. I stand in awe of the Neanderthal (wo)men that placed flowers in the burial site of their family members. I refuse to believe that we are an evolutionary step backward, when we are as capable of love. quote:3. It has also been said that hate binds us to our adversaries as surely as love does to our beloved. Which is why it is healthier to loathe. To loathe is like hating without strings attached. Try loving your extended family of Armenians some time. It will be a new, refreshing feeling for you. quote:5. Misery likes company, they say. That may well be one reason why I would like to convert fanatics. I can't stand their smug self-satisfaction, their misplaced self-esteem, their infatuation with their own intellectual prowess, and their arrogant dogmatism based on the totally absurd assumption that they have all the answers. Call it envy! I hope you are able to recognize yourself in that description. quote:6. You want to convince your adversary? Pretend to be detached. Nothing damages an argument as much as emotional involvement. Try the following experiment: scream 2+2=4 and whisper 2+2=22 and see which makes more sense. What can I say? Tools of the trade; from the toolbox of a third-rate "thinker".
  17. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: I agree with Martin. The Turkish right was by far the most important objector. Moreover bear in mind that Trabzon is a very sensitive area for the Turks: it is not in the best economic condition and also heavily populated by Kurds. Well, OK. But the same Turkish right that MJ credits with killing the immediately relevant Trabzon project is somehow powerless when it comes to determining long-range "pie-in-the sky" ideals of the Turkish elite, according to MJ. It seems inconsistent. But I'll buy it; I'm easy. As for Trabzon being populated with Kurds. Isn't it supposed to be a Laz town? Has the demographics changed so dramatically?
  18. quote:Originally posted by MJ: As simple as not being able to buy the pan-Turkism as a geopoliticaly viable and desirable for Turkey (outside some small groups) political doctrine. Additionally, I don't think that Turkey would've ever expected (until the mid 1980s perhaps) the collapse of the USSR. That's not good enough. Turkey has done many things that are not beneficial to it. Turkey has believed and enforced ideologies that are not beneficial to it. Such rational arguments are not terribly useful in analyzing the ideals of the Turkish establishment. As for expecting an imminent collapse, of course not. However, note that Turkey bothered, at the time, to become a "co-guarantor" of Nakhijevan. That is, technically nobody could unilaterally mess with Nakhijevan's status without automatically invoking Turkey's response. Surely, Turkey did not expect to be in a position to challenge the Soviets; but they bothered to thrust themselves to be a guarantor of the place nonetheless. Please correct me if my memory about Turkey being a "guarantor" of Nakhijevan is inaccurate. You seem to have a reasonably intimate knowledge of these things.
  19. quote:Originally posted by MJ: The possibility was killed by the Turkish side as something going against the Turkish interests. Trabizon would have had strategic value for Armenia (don't want to exaggerate it due to potential availability of Batumi and Poti ports of Georgia). The project died due to Azeri objections. However, it would give Turkey an immense leverage over Armenia. Once Armenia got used to the easy access to the sea, it would be as dependent on Turkey as it once was on Azerbaijan/Georgia/Russia. The biggest strategic beneficiary would be Turkey, but it had to respect the Azeri opinion. There is no doubt that it would have been economically hugely beneficial to Armenia, though. Whether increased wealth and stopping of the outward migration would have translated into a strategic net positive is unknown. However, there is little doubt that Armenia would be a more pleasant place to live today. And that may be much more relevant to many of us.
  20. quote:Originally posted by MJ: Maybe. For example, I still cannot buy it. OK, no hard feelings However, it would be useful and educational for me if you could elaborate a bit more on the reasons for your inability to buy it.
  21. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: This "land swap" was not meaningless and had nothing to do with Armenia or the USSR. It happened during the 1930s. Turkey was having trouble putting down a Kurdish rebellion in eastern Turkey, centered on the Ararat region. Turkish soldiers found it imposible to capture the Kurdish rebels because they would simply move to the upper levels of mount Ararat and then easily travel eastwards into Iran (since the mountainous countryside was too wild and remote to guard). To plug the gap Turkey demanded that all the base of little Ararat be incorporated into Turkey, Iran agreed simply because the country was too weak to resist. I was not aware that Iran got anything in return - so the word "swap" might not be an accurate word to use! I am not an expert on the subject by any means. However, as far as I know, the area involved in the "swap" was tiny. A militarily meaningful area would have to be larger. I don't doubt that such a pretext was given by the Turkish government. After all, you don't say "We would like to have a pan-Turanic sphere of influence, so we can act like a superpower. Could you please get out of the way?". Moreover, an official annexation is not necessary for military operations against rebels. Turkey has been getting in and out of norhern Iraq for a long time for te same reason. There must have been more than military convenience involved. I propose that it was explicitly for obtaining a real border with Azerbaijan, as an investemnet into the future. Undoubtedly, declaring such an intent/context would not go over well with the Soviets. However, I concede that my perception of that strategic move may be wrong.
  22. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: The are involved might be small - but it was not unimportant. Saying that it was not militarily meaningful area is totally incorrect - why else would Turkey want a desolate hillside if it was not to their militery advantage. I thought I provided one possible explanation. It's not that it was not to their "military advantage", however small it might be. It's that they didn't need to have an official border change. Just an "understanding" between the two countries that the Turkish military may get into the area for anti-rebel purposes.
  23. quote:Originally posted by MJ: I think with the exception of the Armenian Genocide, Turkey has been most rational and brilliantly strategically thinking state of the region. Granted. But that's not saying much!
  24. quote:Originally posted by MJ: And they felt threatened, but threatened of what? Part of all that was their brutality, part of it was their arrogance (this can be traced all the way to our days), part of it was their desire to poses the Armenian property (to partially compensate the displaced Turks from Balkans, and perhaps to “bribe” Kurds to buy their loyalty in the WWI), etc. However, contrary to TB’s opinion, I think pan-Turkism was a very minor factor in the Genocide, though some highest profile Ittehat members cherished such hopes/concepts. Armenians on the territory of Ottoman Empire, and even the Armenian Statehood on the territory of its Eastern provinces where not an obstacle for pan-Turkist aspirations. If any obstacle, it would’ve been the Armenians on the territory of Eastern (Russian) Armenia, but primarily the Russian forces, which until 1917 where in a pretty good shape and victorious in WWI. About bribing the Kurds, I suspect the state could probably "nationalize" anything it wanted, and redistribute it. It's not as if Kurds had not plundered the Armenian villages for anything they wished, including "bride"s for a very long time. Armenians would keep on complaining, and the complaints would fall on deaf ears as usual. I probably should have emphasized that pan-Turkic dreams were only one of the central motivations. I agree with your analysis regarding arrogance, plain old hatred, and "how dare they even think of equal rights?" mentality. I have to agree that the irrational part of their thinking was probably a (or maybe even "the") major factor. I was analyzing the "rational" (if you could call it that) part of their motivations. The pan-Turkic dream remained alive in the state ideology of Turkey to this day. The dreams have been expressed often enough by various Turkish leaders over the years. The little territorial swap between Turkey and Iran (during the republican era, I forget exactly when; but certainly before the Iranian revolution) allowed Turkey to have a short but important land border with the Nakhijevan part of Azerbaijan. At the time, it was a completely meaningless swap, because the Soviet border was the important entity, and not which so-called "republic" lied on the other side. But Turkey was taking a very long-term view of things. And it paid off. The fact that Turkish officials repeatedly present the silly idea of a territorial swap between Armenia and Azerbaijan (where Azerbaijan gets the Zangezur area, and becomes connected to Nakhijevan and Turkey, in exchange for recognizing Karabagh's independence) is consistent with this persistently pursued dream. It is a very long term project. [ November 19, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  25. quote:Originally posted by MJ: I am aware of Enver and some others of comparable profile being stunt pan-Turkists at the time. However, I don’t see in what way Armenians of Ottoman Empire where obstacle to such alleged plans. I would argue that [Western] Armenians where not obstacle to any such plans – merely didn’t have the capacity to become obstacle in any sense. Dear MJ, The wily Young Turks knew that once the dust had settled, the Armenian-populated provinces would prevent them from having a "unitary" state. It would also make it harder to implement heavy-handed assimilation programs. Note that the muslim refugees saw themselves as "Ottoman" or "muslim" and not "Turkish" yet. A big Armenian presence in the country would spoil the homogeneity not only by its own numbers, but also making it more difficult to proclaim with a straight face that everyone in "Turkey" are Turks. So it's not any "active" ability of Armenians that was the problem. Their mere existence was a great nuiscance. The pan-Turanic longings are a continuation of this vision. Pan-turanic aspirations of Turkey has been mostly about influence, rather than territory; that is true. Sure, Turkey had no immediate plans to conquer Central Asia. But you can be sure that it wanted to be ready when/if the opportunity arose. And you don't act as a proper Turkic center when you are a federation of a hodge-podge of Ottoman remains. As for the more recent developments, Turkey did try to make a foray into the Central Asian republics. It has been kindly but firmly rejected by those republics for many reasons including the ones aptly described by you. Their failure was not due to a lack of enthusiasm on Turkey's part. Azerbaijan is a lot closer to Turkey than the other republics, both geographically and "emotionally". However, as you said, its leadership is too corrupt to share the proceeds from oil. And Azerbaijan has come to be viewed by the Turks as the good-for-nothing, incompetent cousin, not least because of their losing the Karabagh war. Finally, believe it or not, entering the EU and establishing a pan-Turanic sphere of influence are not contradictory; at least in the minds of the Turkish establishment. On the contrary, a "European" Turkey would be in a much better position to be the "big brother" in their opinion. And they may be right. TB P.S. Thanks for your positive assessment of my other thoughts. Your agreement is a meaningful confirmation.
×
×
  • Create New...