Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: My initial posting stated that the restoration of the Armenian nobility would be good for tourism. I inferred that it should be for ceremonial purposes only. For ceremonial purposes only. Thanks for being merciful. The only way such a thing would promote tourism is by a slogan like "Visit the silliest country on earth! You haven't seen real bufoons if you haven't seen this country!". Or how about "Yeah, they had to invent a monarchy to look interesting, but the beaches of Lake Sevan ain't bad either!". Don't worry everyone, I am not joining the Ministry of Tourism; I'll keep my day job for now . quote I did not twist your comments. Your whole proposal is the "interesting" one.
  2. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Twilight Bark, Interesting that you resurrect this thread at this precise time. I suspect that it has something to do with my recent posts, which have NOTHING to do with this topic. You are being an enforcer to propel Armenian group-think. Huh? quote Delusions of grandeur have nothing to do with clinging to the past, or nostalgy. The latter, I respect and sympathize. The former is laughable at best, repugnant at worst. quote: If you think that you can shut me up, TB, you are sadly mistaken. Huh? quote:The more progressive Armenians will not be shut-up anymore. Since we have gained a voice, it has greatly helped the Armenian cause. If you beat back the recent gains of the Armenian Democrats in the US, you will hurt the cause. Long live Eshoo, Harpootlian, and Armenian Democrat officeholders in California, Massachusetts and New England. Also,thank God that not all Armenian-Americans are working within the Republican Party to drive it right-ward. What has this got to do with anything I said? I couldn't care less about either party (or any party for that matter) even if I tried. quote You are laughably wrong. [ February 11, 2002: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by khodja: Restoration of the Armenian monarchy will bring stability and an interesting tourist draw to Armenia. To those of us who are geneologists, it will be a boom for our business. Personally, I wish to have my title restored by the new monarch, as a member of the Cilician nobility. LONG LIVE THE ROUPENIANS AND THE HETHUMIANS!!!!!!!!! Hagarag, I am disappointed. Unless you were joking, in which case you may be disappointed that I am so dense. For the moment, I will assume that you meant what you wrote. Nobility is initially gained almost invariably by an act of bullying or worse, combined with a huge dose of arrogance and a "leader" character. The last trait (a character that craves to lead) is nowadays an even greater asset than it used to be, even though I dislike the "side-effects" of such a personality. So, other than the "leadership" bit, all the ingredients in the character of the initiator of a line of nobility are unquestionably negative. I, for one, would not be proud of such a lineage. On the other hand, considering that the initial bully accounts only for an infinitesimal portion of the proud would-be noble's ancestry today, I wouldn't care one way or the other. Your longing for a supposedly large family fortune (which you did not earn, and seems to be the dominant component in your motivation to correct the results of the Genocide), and now a stated desire for a title of nobility leads me to think that you are suffering from a delusion of grandeur. MJ was onto something.
  4. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: TB - I disagree with your assertion that Thorny is meerly being contentious on this and or other forums. Sure - she has tusseled with some folks here - folks that IMHO have deserved being put into their place (don't you think?). But you ignore her very many purely positive and informative posts - ranging from descriptions (& sometimes pictures) of trips she has taken (to Ani and such) to commentary concerning her family and its roots, social/political commentary from inside Turkey, comments on movies, TV programs, lectures, newspaper articles and the like relevent to Armenian & Genocide issues. Please consider all of these before you jump to conclusions regarding her motivations and contributions. You are correct however in your ascribing to her as being courageous. In fact, I beleive that her stand on (and actions concerning)the Armenian Genocide (and elements of Turkish history & current politics) goes beyond even this. I take some amount of pride to being a catalyst (along with Domino)for her enlightenment on this issue. She does more - in intelligently confronting other Turks - then most any Armenian has done. Her pointed commentary was the reason for ATAA shutting down their guestbook - she embarrased them into such - a real achievement (no Armenian was able to pull off) IMO. I did not say that she is "merely" being a contrarian. Obviously there are myriad different ways of being a contrarian, and she chose a noble one. However, it is hard not to observe that she enjoys contradicting the "establishment". And "establishment"s usually fully deserve to be contradicted, so it's a perfectly good activity. Of course it would take a Turk to change other Turks' behavior; no surprise in that. That is why it is important to help Turks educate themselves about their history, their identity, and their neighbors. But it is they that will effect the change, not Armenians. I hope you realize that we basically agree on Thorny Rose. To quote (or paraphrase) another Turkish guest, Ali Suat, "people on this forum agree on more things than they realize". quote I agree that banning Thorny Rose was uncalled for, and betrays a certain degree of chauvinism. I did not agree with what was going on at the time, but felt that I was too new in the forum to intervene with any consequence. For what it's worth, I do think that she should be welcomed to this forum.
  5. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Gunduz Aktan editorial today in Turkish Daily News. While I do not agree with all his points, his referral to "father" and "child" is appropriate. Armenians trusted their father, the Ottoman leaders. When some of the children mis-behaved the father punished all the children in a most brutal way. I have know parents who do this all the time. They are not the best of parents and create many pschological problems in their children. Heh. What they called "misbehavior" was the simple request to be given a modicum of dignity. The response to those wishes by the Armenian subjects was more oppression and slaughter. This in turn did produce a few "revolutionaries" that indeed "misbehaved" in the sense that you are implying. But then, it would take a super-human level of patience from a community not to produce any violent reaction to such oppression. The "father" in question was a very, very abusive one to begin with. If one insists on making a father-child analogy, a more appropriate one would be: Most of the abusive father's kids punch him and leave the house. The enraged brute then turns his fury on the few children that still stayed in the house and starts beating them, again, even more brutally than before. Upon hearing their cries for help, he decides that those ungrateful bastards are just too much trouble and stabs them. I suspect Turkish Daily News did not have such an analogy in mind.
  6. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: Arpa - agreed...though i fail to see how Turkey has suffred whatsover regarding its stance on the Genocide.Their strategy has largely succeeded (in the macro sense) and any negative effects are perhaps to subtle to distinguish from overall/general Turkish mouth foaming nationalism... Not being able to confront their history properly keeps the Turkish nation in a perpetual state of identity crisis. It hinders the general societal development. The powers-that-be have the awkward task of making Turkey a "modern" nation, while preventing them from analyzing themselves and the world properly. It is obviously impossible, and it is an impediment to Turkey's true progress. That is the "negative effect". Otherwise, you are absolutely correct that Turkey has been superficially "successful" (brilliantly, in fact) in its Orwellian sleight of hand.
  7. quote:Originally posted by Domino: Where did I assumed anything conserning you ? I just made important distinctions, generals one without pointing anyone. Well it sounded like that Sorry, it must have been one of my crankier moments That's what happens when you are in a hurry. quote I used the term "idealist" loosely, to indicate that she does not appear to have any alterior motives in voicing her opinion, other than the apparent pleasure she derives from being perceived as "difficult". There are many ways in which she can be difficult, but she chose one that has moral merit. Of course, she also chose to irritate and insult the forum's moderators. I never claimed that she is wise. As for her past as a "denialist", so what? Every Turk is socialized and brainwashed into firmly believeing a fictitious version of history. When confronted with a version of history that offends their belief system, it is understandable that they are outraged and try to defend their honor. Very few of them take the courageous step of confronting the truth, though. She deserves to be appreciated for her courage. quote:As for Ali, I don't know him much, so I can't judge him. In the virtual world of the web, we judge each other by what each of us writes. Being a frequent contributor to this forum, Ali Suat is in a good position to be characterized and "judged". In my opinion, the overall "judgement" is positive.
  8. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: TB - I have really liked your posts of late...but I don't think you have hit the mark at all on Thorny...additionally I do not view Ali Suat in any way as an adversary...in fact he is a better ally (in the cause of genocide recognition & related...Turkish/Armenian friendship etc) then most Armenians - particualrly those whose posts (and views) reflect ignorance & intolerance - etc. IMO - both Ali & Thorny represent the great hope for Turks & Armenians. Sure we will always see things differently...but isn't accepting this part of an understandable (and necessary) Armenian consession? Turks such as Ali & Thorny shoudl be applauded and encouraged by Armenians. If we cannot do so then their is no hope for us or our cause of Genocide recognition. (IMO) Actually, we agree basically on all points. It's the terminology that is getting in the way of clarifiying positions and thoughts. About Ali Suat: I already expressd my appreciation for his rational and enlightened positions numerous times. When I classify him as an "opponent", I mean it in the gentlemanly sense. He is, first of all, a Turkish patriot looking for ways to improve the condition of his country. Being at peace with their history is one important step in that direction. Ali Suat is an ally not because he supports Armenian positions, but because he is a "rational player". I fully agree with you that one would rather have a rational "opponent" than a foolish friend making a mess of things. And Armenians do have their share of fools among them. In the final analysis however, it is more useful to view Ali Suat and Turks like him as good, gentlemanly "opponents" in a strategic game. Ali Suat, for example, realizes that it is foolish to view the game as zero-sum. It is clear to rational thinkers that it is much better to look for win-win solutions. The importance of viewing rational, pleasant Turks such as Ali Suat as "opponents" is that at the point where the relative sizes of the "win"s are decided they will try to maximize Turkey's benefits, often at the expense of Armenians', even though they let Armenians win something as well. In an ideal world, both Turks and Armenians would negotiate an optimal solution to the whole genocide mess by employing negotiators of Ali Suat's kind: simultaneously rational, modern and patriotic. About Thorny Rose: I don't know what you disagree on. Please elaborate.
  9. quote:Originally posted by Domino: Twilight Bark if a Turk and Armenian, that have no real knowledge of the event, one say it happened and the other say the contrary. What makes ones believe not a believe but a historical fact ? Someone could believe in Aliens, if one group of people find undeniable evidences on this subject, then for the one that study the evidences, for him it will not be a believe anymore, he will not believe it, but he will know it, the other that will still believe to the Aliens and that he will not find this evidence, for him the aliens will be only believes. Now you can believe that you know, and in fact you don't know. For example, someone in Turkey that will study Turkish files, will believe that he know that a genocide never happened, on the other side, an Armenian studying biased documents will believe to know it happened. Only the one that will study both, and remark without any resonable dought that a genocide happened and will take conscience of it will know it happened. It is true that humans have to operate with assumptions and beliefs. And I also agree that "knowledge" is a fancier form of belief in the most general sense. Now a few words about the specific subject. Please don't assume that I have not read Turkish sources. As for the "primary" material, lack of a stupid, self-incriminating sentence saying "Yeah, let's murder them all. They are innocent, and we know it, but let's commit a genocide" does not in any way contribute to finding the facts. It simply shows what we all know: that the Turks were not nearly as self-confident and arrogant when commiting their deeds as the Germans were. Germans basically thought they were doing humanity a favor, as gruesome and stupid that sounds. Turks were aware of how repugnant and gruesome their scheme was, and did not feel the need to proudly document it. quote Everybody agrees that if we asked for the presence of a "letter of intent" to convince ourselves of a murderer's guilt in the courts, society would be in big trouble. An overwhelming amount of documentation by third parties is available to draw a reliable conclusion about the nature of the Genocide. It is true that the average Armenian "believes" and does not "know" in the formal sense. However, being a practical lot, they know that if their case did not have the merit of being true, it would have been discarded long ago by the non-Armenian historians, as there is no "penalty" in doing so. In some cases the opposite is true. To make a fiction live on, you need the complicity of the establishment, of which Armenians are not a part anywhere in the world except Armenia. quote Thorny is an idealistic, hot-headed individual who enjoys being a contrarian. Her contrarian-ness in this case is well-thought and appropriate. Ali Suat is basically an enlightened patriot with a more sophisticated understanding of what is good for his nation than the garden-variety patriot. He is driven more by improving the condition of his country than by his conscience. Make no mistake, he is still in the "opponent" (note that I am not using the word "enemy") camp; but one that you can fully respect.
  10. quote:Originally posted by Anshnork: Most people now acknowledge that an Armenian Genocide did occur. I too believe that it has. However, I cannot understand why the Armienian Government is wasting SO much time and energy trying to get it "recognized." The Turks have made it very clear that they refuse to accept it, and I don't think any amount of budging will get them to, RIGHT NOW. So considering that there are MUCH more pressing issues in Armenia today, why do we continue to pursue "recognition." Why is it so important to most Armenians today? It is not a matter of "I believe". It is not a theological matter. It is a historical fact that has had an enormous impact on the Armenian psyche. As for the efforts of the Armenian government, they are truly modest. They are not expending that much effort on it. The diaspora is understandably leading doing most of the work in pursuit of recognition. And that is clever anyway, for diplomatic and other practical reasons. Recognition, in itself, is actually most beneficial to the Turkish society. Being a Turkish patriot of the enlightened sort, Ali Suat understands this. I suspect he prefers to minimize the estimated extent of it and wishes that the "practical consequences" of the recognition not go beyond an apology and token reparations, but that is another sub-topic. In contrast, whether the recognition would have any actual (including psychological) benefits to the Armenians is an open question. I think it will result in a case of "now what?". A sort of pschological low after the euphoria of the recognition passes. I suspect it will result in increased assimilation. So, in a perverted way, the lack of recognition, i.e. the "hardship" is more beneficial to the Armenian Diaspora! A true "reparation" would entail a lot more than a dry apology. It would involve a fundamental change in the state ideology of Turkey, as well as its long-standing dogma of a "unitary state". That is, of course, a tall order. A true reconciliation would involve granting Armenians wide cultural and settlement rights in Eastern Anatolia, which would be some sort of a "cultural free-enterprise zone". That is also a tall order. Short of a recognition and reparation of that sort, Genocide recognition would mostly benefit Turkey, with Armenia getting some bread crumbs by having normalized diplomatic relations with Turkey and access to to its roads. In return, Armenia would be increasingly dependent on Turkey for its welfare, and become integrated into the Turkish economy. It is important that Turks be educated and convinced, rather than arm-twisted into grudgingly accepting it. Once the intelligentsia and the elite makes the evolutionary step, it is a matter of a few short years to have the population follow. Just some quick toughts. [ February 01, 2002: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  11. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Twilight Bark, Why do you refer to the Armenian community leaders in Istambul as "undesirable?" Please explain your comment. I thought it was fairly obvious. Any Armenian "community leader" that was not liked by the authorities for any reason would be "undesirable". The reason could be political, or could be as mundane as their properties being to yummy to pass up. How dare "they" have so much wealth in "Turkey for the Turks". I hope that clarifies the adjective.
  12. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: hi elchin, according to ottoman sources, there were 1,295,000 armenians in turkey in 1914. in the 1927 republican census, there were about 300,000 of them. today there are 65,000-80,000. what happened to them? regards, Dear Ali Suat, While I truly appreciate your sticking your neck out on the subject and defending the general truth of the Genocide, I would like to point out that the number maintained by the Armenian Patriarchate was just above the 2 million mark. The Patriarchate's numbers, essentially coming from the records of baptisms, should be regarded as more reliable. The Ottoman census counted households, not people. The Ottoman number is at best an estimation from the number of households. It does not take into account different average household size in different communities. I will not get into the "motivation" to distort numbers on both "sides". In any case, I think we would be in agreement that the exact numbers are not crucially important. What is more important is the qualitative devastation. The 300,000 you are referring to were almost entirely in Istanbul and its environs, where the ordinary Armenians (but not their intellectuals and the "undesirable" community leaders) were spared due to the huge presence of foreign media and diplomats. The percentage annihilation/cleansing in the provinces was a lot closer to 100% than the 300,000/1,300,000 would suggest. Best Regards, Twilight Bark
  13. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear twilight bark, 2. re the anatolian turks and armenians being closer kinsmen than the anatolian turks and the uygurs: on a genetic level this is true, as it is on a number of cultural traits, but two important points should not be overlooked: 1) on some important cultural points, most notably language, the two turkic peoples are obviously closer than they are to armenians and the chinese (to whom the uygurs would be more closely related genetically). now language is a very crucial factor, being far more than a means of communication, it is also the framework for a mindset, a way of looking at the world, and also, a repository of culture. It is true that a language is a repository of culture. However, it cannot propagate or dictate a way of looking at the world. At an emotional level, it can be argued that ancestry is much more fundamental than language. After all, language can be imposed, or forgotten. Ancestry cannot be changed. I have come to intensely dislike the term genetics. When I think about ancestry I think about how my umpteenth grandparents lived, and how they would have wished their descendants to be, their wisdom, the little things in their universe, the things dear to them, and things of that nature. I think it is horribly misguided to reduce ancestry into a set of genes, genetics, and the science and pseudo-science that goes with those images. It is also misguided to even contaminate a discussion of ancestry with genetics. Ancestry is about a chain of love from parents to offsprings, and not our cellular hardware. And we do make choices when we think or fantasize about our ancestry, and in that sense reflect something very cultural. I, for example, prefer to focus on the Anatolian peasants with simple and peaceful outlooks onlife, and mostly ignore those ancestors that were, say the result of rapes by Scythian invaders. You can say that I have a fundamental antipathy for warlike tribes, whether they form a part of my ancestry or not. Others have different preferences, which reflect their tastes and cultural values. quote: 3. re the origin of the armenians and the phrygian component: now the phrygians did exist, and they spoke an indo-european language that is scantily recorded. armenian is also an indo-european language, although one strongly affected by caucasian languages. armenian forms an independent branch of the indo-european family tree, with no known close relatives. phrygian was written, although as a dead language (much like latin in the 15th century) up to the 3rd century ad, i.e. a century before armenian was written down for the first time. the two languages do not appear to be closely related, although the phrygian language is perhaps too poorly attested to allow for a comprehensive comparison. both languages show a closer similarity to greek than to the other indo-european languages, though. there is abundant evidence for the phrygians having migrated from the balkans (moesia), and to have first spent some time in western anatolia (mysia), and being known to the caucasians and the hittites by another name (sa-mekhi, muski). the phrygian king midas was very likely the mita of muski in the hittite records, i.e. a historical figure. the name "phrygian" comes from the same root as the english "brigand" and means the same thing. the ethnonym appears to have been something like musi, muski. this also appears to have been the name by which the georgians call the armenians (sa-mekhi). in brief, i would not treat the armeno-phrygian hypothesis outright as a fable, there appears to be a serious case for it. perhaps the most likely explanation is that the early armenian speaker were phrygian colonists (or some close cousin) who mixed with the indigenous anatolians. after all, the language must have come from somewhere! The Phrygian hypothesis is a "case" of something, but it sure is not history. Hayasa predates the Phrygians, and its nature was radically different from the Phrygians. The Phrygians were extremely warlike, and to the best of our understanding brought even the lowest forms of cultural expression in Anatolia to a standstill for a couple of centuries. Now, the people of Hayasa were probably viewed by the Hittite center as little more than irritating country bumpkins, but they were nothing like the Phrygians. That argues against hypothesizing that the Hay were at the leading edge of the Phrygian invasion to come. One could speculate that the Hay were displaced from Balkans as the Phrygians entered there from who knows where. But of course the evidence supporting such speculation is nonexistent. As for the indo-europeanness of the Armenian language, do not forget that Hittite itself is an indo-european language. Therefore, there is no need to bring the Phrygians into the picture to explain the fact that Armenian is indo-european. The Hayasa-Azzi province was a part of Hittite confederation. Furthermore, there is simply no good evidence that shows that Hittites and Luwian languages are "newcomers" to Anatolia. Europeans certainly like to bring them from somewhere else, but they have to use a good dose of fantasy and wishful thinking in order to make that case. In the absence of proof to the contrary, it is more reasonable to assume that Hittite and Luwian (and Armenian) in fact did originate in or near Anatolia. And if they came from outside, we really have no clue about whether they came from the east or the west. Since all humanity sprang from Africa, the whole point becomes moot once you try going back too far. Therefore, for the purposes of discussing Anatolian cultures and languages, the most reasonable stance would be to regard Armenian as native to the land, unless proven otherwise.
  14. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Twilight Bark, I do not limit the Armenian ancestry to the four peoples that I listed. The largest portion of our gene-pool is from the indigenous Urarteans who populated the region since ancient times. Another large portion comes from the Balkan Armens. Dear hagarag, If by "Balkan Armens" you mean the infamous "Phrygian colonists" hypothesis, I have not found any real indication of their existence, other than in the imagination of Greek history-tellers that were more often story-tellers. Of course it has been picked up and lovingly preserved and embellished by those overly eager to have European ancestry. We don't find "Armens" as a well defined people in the history books. In fact, they are not a proper historical entity at all. For all we know, the word may have been a corrupted form of "Aram's people", referring to the first "king" of Urarteans. After all, the only glaring omission in the "code-names" given by Khorenatsi is the Urartu, although we find Aram's name prominently playing a role. I can come up with different speculations until cows come home. So unless proven otherwise, it is much more reasonable to regard the genesis of the Armenian nation as the client kingdom of "Hayasa-Azzi" in the Hittite confederation/empire. Again, there is no indication that the people of Hayasa-Azzi were anything but "indigenous" (whatever that means). The emergence of Hayasa into history predates the invasions by Phrygians, so they cannot be Phrygian colonists. There is little doubt that over time the people of Hayasa-Azzi merged with the devastated (from Scythian and Kimmerian invasions) people of Urartu, and together represent the bulk of our ancestry. There is no real evidence of a big Balkan component. I am sure it exists, but I suspect it is small compared with the Hayasa/Urartu components. It is time to wean ourselves off Eurocentric "creation myths".
  15. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Yepiskoposyan found the Georgians to be very homogenious genetically, but the Armenians very diverse. This points toward a unique religion (Armenian Christianity) taking in a large number of converts. I think it has little to do with religion. One could ask why the Georgian Christianity did not attract members from other groups. It's not as if Armenians are known for proselytizing. It reflects more the xenophillic nature of Armenians, even more so because they usually do not conquer, bully and assimilate other peoples. If they are diverse despite their lack of appetite for such "adventures", that should say something about how friendly and accepting the traditional Armenian culture is. It is quite obvious that by 500 BC, Armenians were already very "diverse". [ January 24, 2002: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  16. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Interesting how Armenians get into discussions of the "mixed" Turkish genetics, culture and ancestry yet walk around with blinders concerning the mixtures of the Armenians. We are part Jew, part-French, part-Assyrian, and part-Mongol/Chinese. A new book emanating from the ROA is a biography of the Queens of Armenia. The mix of our queens is duplicated in the mix of the Armenian people. The chauvinists among us will deny the glaring documentation of this fact. Hagarag, You must have been talking to the most rabid of the chauvinists. Even the ultranationalist Armenians define Armenians as a mixture. Not the same mixture as you have in mind perhaps, but a mixture nonetheless. Whatever the case may be, taking the ancestry of the queens and kings as representative of the population in general is ridiculously simple minded, and is meritless unless supported by information about population movements.
  17. Dear Ali, I respectfully have to make a few adjustments to the spin of your article. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:what few people realise is that we are perfectly happy wit the fact that we are central asians+anatolians+iranians+slavs+greeks+armenians+anyone else we came across. A classic case of "yes, but ...". Turks accept the obvious, and try to forget it as soon as they can. The overbearing presence in Turkish cultural consciousness is the glorification of the central asian component far, far above all others. Viewing the vast majority of one's ancestors as subservient to the identity of a warlike tribe is not exactly honest or desirable. When Turks understand and cherish the fact that they are "Turks" and not Turks, they will have evolved to a much higher cultural plane. quote: of course, if you have been mixing with people, your culture is also going to be mixed. i can pick you any carpet from central anatolia, and the motifs on it will be anywhere from china to greece, so is the case with the rest of our culture. this is accepted fact. case in point quote Yes, the real incentive is to avoid hypocricy. Of course, one can equally easily avoid hypocricy by advocating a world where every nation that wishes to have the trappings and privileges of a state receives them as a natural right. The usual bogus argument advanced against this right by the current states (i.e. defenders of the status-quo) is that small states are not viable. That is nonsense. It assumes that all these states and the states they separated from will be so hostile as to reject trade and cooperation with each other. A perfect example of self-fulfilling prophecy. "You can't secede without an ugly and long fight, and if you do we will make your life miserable". On the other hand, in an enlightened world, the purpose of a state would be cultural preservation and not much else. As such, the economic activities that decide whether a state is viable or not can continue unhindered. quote:the thing is that we have over here a number of uygur turks who had been horribly treated by the chinese authorities (not that they treat the han chinese any better), and these things with above-ground detonations can not by any stretch of the imagination thought to be benevolent, and their effect would clearly be genocidal. i do not know whether uygur harass or harassed other ethnic groups, i know that there have been clashes in kyrgyzstan between the uygurs and the kyrgyz, we of course could not take sides since both of them are turkic. much as i may condemn the armenian genocide and the persecution of the kurds in turkey, i cannot fail to see similar things taking place elsewhere on earth, and some of my kinsmen falling victim to them. if i can be expected to do the former, i can expect in return that the latter be taken into account and adequately condemned and taken action against by the world community. Much as sympathize with the Uigurs, the scale of their plight is nowhere near that experienced by the Armenians. Close to Kurds' perhaps, but nowhere near the Armenians'. As for Uigurs being your kins, they are much less your kin than the Armenians you are conversing with on this forum. Best wishes from one of your closer kins , Twilight Bark
  18. Twilight Bark

    Weird names

    quote:Originally posted by Arpa: Nvard, is "nvard" a purely native Armenian name? No and yes. I am sure you have researched it and can give us a thorough analysis. On the surface it seem like it it is composed of nu=new and vard=rose(red) from a neighboring language. Whoa, hold your horses! There is no proof that vard is not a native Armenian word. I remember reading western, non-Armenian articles where the etymology of rose was connected to vard, and it was explicitly mentioned that the name probably came from the east of Greeks, and that it was not obvious whether Parthians borrowed from Armenians or vice versa. I also remember at least one non-Armenian article where the etymology was claimed to originate in Armenian. Perhaps more interestingly, the Persian name for rose is gul, and, believe it or not, it has decended from vard or some form of it. Does anyone know what the steps were in this incredible tranformation? I sure would like to find out. If anyone finds out, could you please post it (preferably under the Language forum where it probably belongs) ?
  19. Twilight Bark

    Friendship

    As an aside, most men appear to be uncomfortable with analyzing friendships, to the point of considering it a faux-pas to explicitly discuss it. In contrast, I think most women would find the subject a fine one to discuss. It would be most interesting to collect some opinions on that sub-topic as well.
  20. Twilight Bark

    Friendship

    quote:Originally posted by Harut: i would like to open a discusion on friendship. what is a friendship? who are "best friends"? what do they serve for? friendship between man and woman? lifetime friends? what are the most occuring problems between friends? i'm looking forward for an interesting discusion. thank you Best friends are made when young. Especially when the two are facing an intimidating world together, and there are no "rational" considerations other than a primal compatibility of characters. Friendships made in elementary school, or maybe early days of high school may have a chance of becoming life-long friendships immune to the silly filtering process that we learn in later stages of life. If you don't have a good friend by the time you are 18, forget about truly altrustic, true friendship. However, you can always find a person with compatible outlook on life, and have a sort of "rational" friendship. It will never be the same as a friend from childhood, though.
  21. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: we guys do not look like the central asians a bit, rather, we are indistinguishable from the local greeks, and more tellingly, from the ancient ones (their remanis have been found), so there must be a strong local component. Make that the main component. quote Tracing your ancestry to one particular family 50 generations ago is certainly interesting and amusing. However, do not lose sight of the fact that the number 2 raised to the power of 50 is a very, very small number representing the fraction of "you" that are coming from "them". The political power of the "newcomers" far exceeded their actual numbers. For the vast majority of Turks, the Central Asian component is miniscule compared with the Anatolian one. Picking the Central Asian component (that may not even exist in many cases) as the one that really matters is the central dogma in contemporary Turkish chauvinism. quote:and to those who are aware of this, this "clash of cultures and civilisations" business, which pits our paternal cousins against our maternal ones, is sheer nonsense. as an individual i can accomodate both the asian and anatolian aspects of my heritage without problems, in fact with pleasure, to me one enriches the other, but i realise i differ from many turks (and not a few armenian and greek diaspora members) In fact, the cultural outlooks of Greeks and Turks are more similar to each other than to Armenians. To me, Greeks and Turks form one cultural unit; they just have to realize it yet Armenians have their share of chauvinists as well. However, Armenians have embraced and cherished their "mixture" without any complexes. The mainstream Armenian thought consistently defines Armenians as a mixture. There may be discussions about the make-up of the mixture, or how to define the beginning of a proper "Hye" nation, but elevating and glorifying one warlike (to put it kindly) component over others is just not a part of mainstream Armenian self-image.
  22. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: i would describe ecevit as a crypto-fascist in a socialist's (formerly communist's) clothing, many so-called "socialists" in turkey were or are. Agreed. The term national-socialist comes to mind. However, even extreme nationalism and chauvinism in Turkey is more "practical" than "theoretical". Turkish chauvinism is essentially cultural, not racial. I say "essentially", because an Armenian ancestry is still regarded as a big no-no. All others are OK as long as the person declares himself as a Turk, and accepts the official mythology that the original Turkish invaders are part of all "Turk"s ancestry and that the only component that matters is that last one. quote Ecevit may not be a racist, but he is a strong advocate of the official myth, what with his (and his co-ideologists') obsession with "purifying" the Turkish language. quote There are a pitifully small number of intellectuals in Turkey worthy of the description (the state of Armenian intellectual tradition is also not cheerful, but that's another topic). There are many pseudo-intellectuals. Waiting for the subject to be politically correct in Turkey is for the ordinary persons, who would rightly fear for their safety. Being a true intellectual is a much riskier and adventurous proposition that demands to tell the truth now, before it becomes mainstream. Strong connections with powers-that-be would probably be required to express taboo opinions. Perhaps we can discuss what makes one an intellectual in another thread. It is an interesting topic. As for the etymology of the -vit suffix, I am interested in alternative etymologies that you may have in mind. I don't mind a bit if it turns out to be non-Armenian. Bilge Umar himself states openly and honestly that his work may contain many inaccuracies. However, his work is orders of magnitude better than the chauvinistic crap that many Turkish "linguists" have produced over the years.
  23. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: Poor Ecevit, he looks more like a comic character in a 60s Hollywood imitation Turkish comedy. But in all fairness he has never, to my knowledge at least, expressed ll feelings towards Armenians. By the way ,most Turks did not have surnames until the beginning of the century. Yes, his level of hostility is indistinguishable from the background noise (on Armenians) in Turkey. How you characterize that level is up to you. My feeling is that he would prefer that Armenians forever remained under the radar screen so he wouldn't have to think about them. As for surnames, you are right of course. Many people adopted the name of their (or their close ancestors') birthplace, such as Ecevit, as their surname. As for appearances, his nose may point to some Armenian heritage.
  24. Turkish researcher Bilge Umar states that place names in Anatolia that end with -vit usually come from Armenian, -vit being a distortion/shortening of hovit. He decomposes Ecevit (pronounced edge-evitt) edis-hovit, meaning something like "the rear plain". The esteemed prime minister probably would not be amused.
  25. quote:Originally posted by highflyer: If it is a absolute I would want my child passive first.If you poke at the passive little rabbit enough you will pay by being bitten and scratched. Good insight. Self-defense is a universal mechanism. Its activation and proper use is probably easier than turning off a violent and hostile nature. I agree with you that the preferable starting point would be the "bullied" instead of the bully. But now we are bending the "rules" a little bit by introducing the hope that the bullied will one day rise and start defending himself. However, I find myself much less sure if the choices were between "eternal bully" and "eternal sissy". Such a pair of choices is probably too far from being realistic.
×
×
  • Create New...