Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:tb, you say it should not matter by whom they were inspired. by the same logic, usama bin ladin is irrelevant. Guilt is not a "limited resource". In other words, if there is someone that inspired, aided, or facilitated a crime, that someone has commited a crime in addition to the crime being discussed. Bin Laden is irrelevant in determining the guilt (or extent thereof) of the killers. A terrorist cannot say in court "but he inspired me; so that's 10 years off my sentence, and 10 years added to his". The terrorist is fully responsible for his crime.
-
As I said earlier, we have differing definitions, and furthermore we assign different depth and breadth to those terms. I do not define pan-Turanism by its superficial manifestation of trying to actually conquer other Turkic lands and form a Turkic empire. I define it as the newly conjured up, romantic self-image of a Turkish identity distinct from the mixed, Ottoman identity. And without such a new consciousness the genocide would not occur. So I merge your "pan-Turkism" and "pan-Turanism" into one ideology. I define it as the hostile, exclusivist glorification of the Turkish element in the empire, fuelled by the romantic fantasies of Turan. We seem to have terminologies that are incompatible for a fruitful discussion. In any case, thanks for bearing with me.
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:TB, I desagree with you again Thats becoming pathological LOL. Indeed. quote: I have tried what you suggest, . . . But I didn't give any numbers. Obviously what I meant was "use the minimum solar panel power that can charge your big battery". In other words, his optimal point for solar panel power is not the typical "optimum" that allows charging the battery for daily use. It is somewhere between being able to charge it in several hours for a day's use and not being able to charge it. Your apparent assumption that I was suggesting the latter limit implies a "negative initial perspective". Many people find such a negative approach offensive and unfriendly. My friendly advice to you is to approach people with a positive attitude (at least on the outside); you'll be significantly more successful both socially and professionally. You may even feel better yourself. On the other hand, if you feel you don't need any advice, just ignore my suggestion.
-
Hi MosJan, I am no expert on the subject, but I think you can use somewhat "undersized" solar cells, and "oversized" batteries if you are going to use your cabin only a few days a year. So the battery would be "trickle-charged" all year, and when you do need it, you would still have plenty of power at hand. In other words, in your special situation, money may be better spent on "macho" batteries rather than "macho" solar cells. My apologies if I am pointing out the obvious. TB P.S. I understand you are using the cabin for hunting. I dislike the idea of "killing for fun", but that's another issue. Your choice, your values. P.P.S. I wish you a safe trip.
-
I am saying that the new, pan-Turanic self-view, was the reason why they felt the way they did. Without it, they would not view the Armenians as alien, and the genocide would not occur. Stealing something is "beneficial" only if you steal it from "someone else"; as it would be silly to steal it from yourself or a member of your family. The reason why they stole the land and wealth from the Armenians was that the Armenians became "alien" in the new pan-Turanic self-view of the Young Turks. Before then, the Armenians were viewed as part of the "Ottoman family", however dysfunctional it may have been. I agree that we are stating essentially the same facts, and yet at the very end of our arguments we are somehow coming to divergent conclusions. Strange.
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:TB, I do not understand what you are trying to say... you desagree with me, then you bring the exact arguments that proves my point, just read. The living space is tha outcome the last stage before all known genocides we know, of course many lack of some ellemts compared with the "Lebensraum" of the NAZI, and the growing German "race" but still the majority of the other ellements are present, and more the Armenian case on this term is very near to that. The nationalisation of economy was what emerged all this in the last years... the conscenquences was ----> the Living space, the Pan-Turanism was a plus, something that was not necessary for the genocide itself, but more its continuity and an argument. But you cant reject the living space, without it there could not be any genocide at all... because the Armenians being Armenians and not Turks, trying to get rid of them would without any dough directly be linked with the ----> living space because you admit there was no racism. So what can it be ? Even you argument of the Pan-Turanism being one of the centers, would lead ---> Living space... because the ideal of the Pan-Turanism is based on the Living space. No, it's the other way around. The idea of living space springs from a new, "romantic" view of past glories, and the newly developed "need" to re-capture the "purity" that was associated with those supposed "glories". The "living space" is completely meaningless without a newly developed, exclusivist self-view. "Armenians are Armenians, and Turks are Turks" becomes an issue only in the presence of the new ideology. They had been Armenians and Turks for centuries hence, but "living space" had never been an issue, until the new ideology made the presence of Armenians amongst them intolerable. Again, I am at a loss as to why you don't see the directionality of cause-and-effect here. The reason why a multi-ethnic state was discarded as an option by the Young Turks was precisely because of the new ideology. The Turkish "racism" is fundamentally different from the German one; it seeks to assimilate "lesser" elements into the identity that it wants to glorify. It subjugates other ancestries into the dominant "Turkish" one; basically saying "it is the only one that really counts" (that is why I prefer to call it "arrogance" rather than "racism"). Young Turks knew whom they could impose that charade, and who they couldn't. Armenians had to go. Again, in the German case, the Germans simply could not tolerate the Jews living amongst them. All of a sudden the Jews appeared too alien to tolerate. You feel like you can't breathe if you are stuck in a room with someone that you intensely hate. All of a sudden the room becomes "too small for the two us", not because it is really too small but because you cannot tolerate the other person. Again, "living space" is a symptom, not a cause. TB [ March 27, 2002, 11:36 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:Hardly. They "needed" that land for two reasons: 1. To maximize their territory at any cost, and have it free of "alien" elements. 2. To be geographically as close to the rest of the Turkic world as possible. You just described the definition of Living space here TB, and this from your own words. As for Tsusi genocide, well it was also about Living space... as for the Cambodgian, O.K here you may have a point, but the Cambodgian genocide is not considered a genocide by many specialists, it is some sort of autogenocide, and the Kmer Rouge ideal... that is different then other genocides. Now about the Holocaust... sorry TB, But the Living space theory was one of the center of Rosenberg ideologies and the NAZI, it was the center of Hitler ideal... the Living space was the Hearth of the Holocaust and even more then the Armenian genocide... because the "Living Space" theory was first time described with the introduction of the "Living space" By Hitler himself even in Interview he gave himself. I dont know if Thoth posted that quote about Hitler interview somewhere on the quotes... but he exposed it clearly in 1933, and it was his regime that gave this specific name and the word "Living space" you can hardly find(I never found one) work covering the Holocaust that will not dedicate at least one chapter conserning Hitlerian "Living space" Now before this the conseption pf living space was more Vague, but if we take the definitions given by the NAZI themselves, then the Living-Space would be like in the case of the Holocaust what lead to the Armenian genocide... Living space is not only about not space to live, here I am talking about the ideology of the "Living space" described by the NAZI... Its like Fascism, Fascism the word itself was first given by Mussolini, and there is definitions that goes with it, now if the definitions fit with a precious event, then we can use the word Fascism etc... What I would like you to see is that the "living space" nonsense is "needed" only when there is a substratum of a theoretical, exclusivist ideology. You are looking at the symptom and declaring it as the cause, as if it sprang into existence out of thin air. Why on earth would Armenians, Jews, or Tutsis become "alien" in the absence of such new, "romantic" ideologies? That is the question you have been avoiding to answer. If we agree on the definition of "living space" that I offered, then we would have a hard time avoiding to agree on the reason why the concept exists in the first place.
-
Turks And Jews Praising Each Other At The Gala Night Of July
Twilight Bark replied to A.R.'s topic in Genocide
quote:Originally posted by A.R.:Cause you say so? Yes quote: I know Armenians who were shocked when they heard some of the stuff I posted about the Jews and there Anti Armenian Cause. And you think those clueless Armenians will be useful in coming up with a solution? Only if you are planning on starting a pogrom in Jewish neighborhoods. quote:The internet is the best way to expose You are exposing alright. But not what you think quote:Funny when other people post articles about any other ethnic group you don`t say nothing but when its about Jews you guys turn into Jewish Spazz Monkeys.Really? Is that an assumption, or an observation? And even if you were right about us getting especially irked by your postings, our reaction is still justified. You don't deal with a very influential group as if they were some peasants that you could push around. Or you could, to your own peril. quote:Listen monkey I have no time to play your Jew Games.I understand. Sorry to interrupt your busy schedule. You must be a very important person. It is apparent from your discourse. Now where did I put my bananas? quote: You never want to debate the articles I post you just want to spazz,whine,moan and cry.I did hear a lot of whining and moaning around here. But I swear it was coming from your direction. -
quote:the Turks needed that soilYes Domino, just as a fish needs a bicycle. quote: and was considered to be their homeland, Hardly. They "needed" that land for two reasons: 1. To maximize their territory at any cost, and have it free of "alien" elements. 2. To be geographically as close to the rest of the Turkic world as possible. quote:there was no place for the Armenians, how can you disagree with this ?I don't. And the reason there was no place for Armenians was that they did not fit at all into the image of the new state being the flagbearer of the Turkic world, the new "ordu-millet". quote: Its one of the basic of known genocides... and without this ellement a genocide would have been near impossible.Really? How about the Tutsi genocide? Was it about territory? How about the Jewish genocide? Was it about territory? How about the Cambodian genocide? Was it about territory? Come on now, Domino. I appreciate your encyclopaedic knowledge, but I am afraid your your analysis could use some improvement, especially in the self-consistency area.
-
Dear Domino, I believe we are both getting tired of this discussion, not least because the terms that we use mean somewhat different things to each of us, and their breadth of generality varies crucially as well. While we do have significant differences in our interpretations, we are closer than our rhetoric implies. I define Pan-Turanism as a fuzzy ideal, and not as some immediate plans to form a territorial empire. It is a state of mind. It is saying "We come from a long line of glorious Turkic states, and we will make Turkey the last and only independent Turkic state. We are the flag-bearers of of all Turkic people on the planet. We will once again be an 'ordu-millet' (nation-army)". A multi-ethnic confederation simply did not fit into this self-image at all. Armenians were the primary spoilers. That is why they viewed Armenians as "alien". In other words, you must ask why they felt compelled to make sure that any "alien" elements did not have any serious presence in the new, synthetic nation. If they did not have that romantic, pan-Turanic state of mind in their heads, they would view the Armenians as useful allies within the system and would take advantage of their industriousness and considerable expertise in numerous areas. They wounded the Ottoman remnants fatally by committing the genocide. They inflicted overall damage to satisfy their obsession with accomplishing a culturally "pure", new nation worthy of being called the flagbearer of all of the Turkic world. That is what I mean by "pan-Turanic motivation". As for the miraculuous timidity about imposing unfair taxes. Again, if wartime provides good cover for genocide, it provides an even better cover for "funny taxes", as we all know. If they didn't care about purifying the new nation into one that is worthy of representing all of Turkic world, they would target those Armenians that had significant possessions, and would have left the Armenian peasants alone. They could have arrested all the community leaders everywhere (as they did in Istanbul), and accuse them with trumped up charges and confiscate their properties. The arrest of intelligentsia in Istanbul was enough to turn the Armenians into a headless chicken already; we all know how much resistance Armenians put up in the face of obvious oblivion. They could be made even more helpless. But the Young Turks didn't want them there, did they? The "need" for wresting economic power from the "aliens", and defining their "living space" as one that is cleansed of "aliens", and similar attitudes are hard-wired into the "romantic" pan-Turanic self-view of the Young Turks. There was no other factor that can explain the transformation of their identity from that of "Ottoman" to "the last and only representatives of Turkic glory". I am surprised that you don't see the obvious.
-
Turks And Jews Praising Each Other At The Gala Night Of July
Twilight Bark replied to A.R.'s topic in Genocide
quote:Originally posted by A.R.:Yes Armenians know about the Turkey/ Isreali alliance but what most Armenians don`t know is how deep this alliance runs counter to the Armenian Cause. Jews do everything in there power to help the Turks. Oh they have a pretty good idea about the depth. Now the real question is: What do you propose to do about it? You see, it's not good enough to take a megaphone and point out the problem and say "I am just pointing out the problem, I'll let others (supposedly uninformed simpletons) figure out the solution". If someone is so unperceptive as to be unable to see the problem, and needs your help, he is surely incapable of devising a solution for it. So again, what is your proposed solution? Making more enemies? That is all you have been accomplishing so far. -
quote:Originally posted by Domino:And another thing, if you think that Pan-Turanism alone was the central... then you believe some sort of racism... and I would desagree with you on this. Pan-turanism was a central factor, not the central one. As I said before, the Young Turk chauvinism was not "racist" in the German sense. However, they had a deep sense of who was assimilable into the soon-to-be-synthesized Turkish identity, and who was not. Armenians were not assimilable, so they had to get rid of them. And they despised them even more for daring to suggest that they should have equal rights. That is where the "arrogance" comes in. Again, the facts on the ground compels me to discard any "explanations" based on "need" of any sort. They didn't need the land, and they could get the money by other means. They ruled the country, and they could pass any necessary laws they wished. Or they could simply raise taxes and apply it selectively, as the Turkish republic did decades later. I can assure you that genocide was orders of magnitude farther outside of the Ottoman legal system formally. That did not stop it from happenning. Those people that pulled off a genocide were too timid to pass through a nationalization scheme, or some other tax scheme to be applied selectively. Right. [ March 26, 2002, 11:05 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
Dear Domino, All I request is logic, not references. Why on earth would the Armenians be allowed to get back their wealth is mysterious. They certainly would work and start building wealth once again; that is for for sure. But they didn't want them there did they? Hence the chauvinistic (pan-Turanic psychology) motive. It wasn't just the money. They just did not want them there. About "living space". Come on now, you mean those few provinces were so important that they were part of a critical "living space"? Without them the new Turkey would be crippled? That is ridiculuous. They just did not want Armenians there. I am sorry, but you haven't addressed any of the logical contradictions that I pointed out. [ March 26, 2002, 06:56 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:I agree with you...(I think its the first time ) Come on now. It's not that bad quote:You forget the real central reason of the Armenian genocide I believe... and that is the nationalisation of economy and the "living space", I tough before that Pan-Turanism was one of the two branchs and one of the two main reasons, but now I see it as a plus etc...Economic greed and living space does not explain it at all. If greed were the central reason, the slaughter would have targeted the well-off. It didn't. It was across-the-board. Also, there are politically (and otherwise) less expensive ways to confiscate property and money. For example, you "nationalize" everything, and then re-distribute it according to "national priorities". No, that wasn't it. As for "living space". That doesn't cut it either. Armenians from areas that had no chance of secession were also murdered wholesale (again, rich or poor didn't make a difference). The few eastern provinces that had at least a remote chance of one day seceding from the empire had little resources or population, and did not comprise such a big chunk as to limit the "living space" per se. Even today, the region is sparsely populated. If you cut away the territory that could have been possibly incorporated into an independent Armenia at the time from today's Turkey, its impact would be negligible in every way except "ego". Armenians were thoroughly cowed at the time, and no serious rebellion was imminent anyway. And even if it did happen, and miraculuously succeeded, its economic effect would be a big zero and its territorial effect would be minimal. Certainly nothing that justifies a genocide (as a "tool", for the supposedly panicked leaders, concerned about the future of their nation; huh!). The only remaining answer, to which we arrive by elimination, is that it must have been the arrogance and hatred produced by a pan-Turkic psychology a la Gokalp. [ March 26, 2002, 06:33 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
Turks And Jews Praising Each Other At The Gala Night Of July
Twilight Bark replied to A.R.'s topic in Genocide
A.R., Regardless of my reservations, I hope that your presence on this forum will be a positive one. While trying to "educate" others, I hope you also try to learn something from the members of this forum, as they have much to offer. Please understand that virtually every Armenian with an IQ over 70 is aware of the alliance of Jews and Turks. It's a bummer for Armenians, but hey. You cannot be so naive as to think that you are telling us something we don't already know. Now the question is, what are you going to do about it? If you think spewing what most people would consider "hate speech" all over the internet in Armenians' name is the proper way to go, I wish you a happy landing. Twilight Bark -
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:You allude to the fact that my statements about German national character amount to bigotry. I didn't say it was bigotry. I said it is hard to talk about it without crossing the line into the bigotry zone. I know what you are talking about; I have often sensed it myself. However, I have also met absolutely wonderful, humanistic people with germanic ancestry. The Germanic culture may have carried very ancient scars into the modern era. If you think about what it takes to "purify" a population with recessive genetic traits, you are forced to conclude that systematic and generations-long elimination or forcing out of individuals with "unwanted" traits must have occurred at some distant point in time. In other words, the origination of a Nordic race must have involved pretty unpleasant "events". That doesn't make their descendents evil. And I don't even know if today's people of nordic ancestry harbor xenophobic tendencies more often than others. quote:Surprisingly, the Jews whom I befriended at school never treated me poorly, in spite of the fact that I was Armenian, or even when they realized that I was part Assyrian.When I was little, I briefly made good friends with a Jewish girl in the neighborhood. Of course it was completely innocent, both in terms of "gender" and "ethnic group". When her mother saw her daughter riding in the back of my bike, I remember sensing that she was profoundly disturbed by what she saw. "Mortified" is an apt description I think. Needless to say, she was called into the house and we never talked beyond "hello" after that day. I have seen similar attitudes by Jews over the years. I have also seen attitudes completely opposite to that. So where does it leave us? Nowhere in particular, except where we started. No need to generalize.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:the germans might have been the inspirators at least to a certain degree. It should not matter by whom they were inspired. I personally don't care if they were inspired by the tooth fairy. quote:the usual ottoman response to any real or anticipated threat would be large-scale killing to "chastise" the rebellious element. this had been applied throughout ottoman history The Genocide was simply an exaggerated and extended instance of that time-tested tradition. quote:but until 1915, there was no conscious attempt to systematically eradicate an entire ethnicity. Because the simultaneous occurrence of "the perceived need" for it and the opportunity to carry it out had been lacking until it happened. quote:the germans were very much influential in the ottoman empire True. But the intellectual roots of the Young Turks can be traced not to Germany but France. quote:he is a very controversial figure, in him one sees at the same time an awareness of turkish ethnicity together with the tendency to crush any nationalist sentiment, including turkish. it is no coincidence in my opinion that the party that ultimately carried out the genocide was the one which had deposed him six years before. I tend to agree. The Ottoman Palace wished to keep the ethnicity genie in the bottle, and tried to suppress any talk of ethnicity. Since the Turks were de facto the dominant component of the empire, the Sultan thought, talking loudly about Turkishness would only irritate the oppressed and restive minorities further. With the loss of the Balkans, the Young Turks decided that there was no point in continuing the charade. For a long time they had been using the word "Ottoman" as a code word for "Turk" anyway. quote:as to the pan-turanian motives of the young turks in killing the armenians, i do not think it was the major one: the young turks appear to me to have resorted to pan-turanism only as a result of their understanding that the multi-ethnic ottoman empire was not going to last, and that it had to be replaced by something else for the sake of the turkish nation which had formed its backbone.Of course it was a replacement. That doesn't minimize its role in forming the psychology of the perpetrators. While the big-wigs (except Enver) did know that it was impossible to form a pan-Turkic empire right then and there, the ideal of Turan certainly was a central one. The Young Turks were not merely a bunch of practical, pragmatic, and ruthless men trying to salvage an empire. They had a theoretical framework through which they saw the destiny of the Turkish nation they were about to synthesize. There is no other "rational" explanation for commiting a genocide for an area whose population was less than 50% Turkish, and had practically no economic value. Do not confuse the diplomatic pragmatism of Ataturk with what the Young Turks were thinking. Not that Ataturk disliked the pan-Turanian ideal; he was just too smart to chase it before its time. He had no qualm about being expansionist when the time was right. Remember that place special to your heart, the Hatay province? And trying to erase the pathetic remnants of the "independent Armenia" from the map was also not beyond his earlier ambitions. I am sure being direct neighbors with Azerbaijan provided no motivation whatsoever . quote: here one must add that the fever of nationalism had affected the ottoman christians first, and muslims second, and turks were not the first muslims to be affected.Please do not lump the Balkan christians with the Armenians. Not even for rhetorical convenience or advantage. quote:to ascribe the genocide to racist tendencies of the turks appears to me as an over-simplificationIt was undiluted arrogance, not "racist tendencies". The scary thing is that the same arrogance persists to this day. quote:it looks after all that germans might well be responsible for the two major genocides of 20th centuryNot so fast. While the Germans gleefully watched Armenians get murdered and are accomplices by way of inaction, they are not "responsible" for the Genocide. "Bearing responsibility" and "being responsible" are slightly but importantly different. However, I do agree that a German chancellor, on his knees, begging for forgiveness (once again) is probably justified. And their supplying some of the funds needed to re-settle willing Armenians in their ancestral lands is also probably justified. Not that any of this is going to happen; how do you say "fat chance" in German . As for the discussion about German national character, it perhaps belongs in a different thread. It is hard for one to make such generalizations without being a bigot oneself.
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Just look to this forum and you will see the problem very clearly. A new mmeber here, who has his own website (A.R.) has a lengthy post about me where he calls my great-grandfather "filth." I think this is a forum where A.R. would be eaten alive if he were to repeat his previous performance. I for one am not sure I want to waste my time on him. Even in the absence of anyone wasting bits and bytes on him, I am sure the moderators are fully capable of handling him if he crosses the line too many times. On a side note related to the earlier discussion, I hope you understand my point that being "hagarag" is nowhere near enough.
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:SELF-FLAGELLATION is what our Armenian leadership should be FOCUSING upon. True. As for the rest of us, we should focus on why we do not produce good leaders. There are cultural reasons for this, starting from the crib. We should also focus on why the few that have the right character and talents do not find (or seek) their way to the top. The trail of ancient and recent history is littered with cultures that became roadkill due to incompetent or corrupt leadership. For too long the Armenians have lived on the line separating the Darwinian winners and losers. Having said all this, I must emphasize that while realizing there is something wrong is a useful start, hastily attacking any and all things Armenian is counterproductive. The patient needs all the support and nourishment it can get. And the "cure" must make the patient better, not worse. And constantly nagging the patient about his bad health is also not very helpful. In more concrete terms, saying that conservatives should become liberals, that the liberals should get real, that the semi-literate merchants should become intellectuals, that "intellectuals" should get rid of their quotation marks, that bad leaders should become good leaders, that the corrupt bureaucracy should become true civil cervants, that self-serving community leaders should become wiser and more altruistic has a net benefit of zero, including the "benefit" that they make the utterer of those words feel better about himself. Unless the utterer analyzes the reasons behind the said diseases. Even better if one can come up with rational ways to tackle them. Saying that "I just point out the problems, and let others figure it out" is both lazy and disingenuous: someone incapable of spotting the problem is surely not up to the task of analyzing its causes, let alone coming up with a way to fix it.
-
quote:Originally posted by highflyer:Hense her famous song ,Half Breed.Isnt it strange Armenians dont believe we are capable of such things as abandoning our children.And we are taught we are the perfect people. I personally haven't met any Armenian who believed Armenians were "incapable of doing such things". However, it is true that the behavior of Cher's father is not at all typical of an Armenian father. I would be the first to say that Armenian parenting has some serious flaws (in addition to wonderful, wonderful overall strengths), but such behavior is simply not a widespread problem; in fact it is quite rare. You are focussing on the wrong problem. Self-flagellation can be put to better use.
-
quote:Helping bringing back those that are on the verge of leaving or have already done so is beyond the realm of what could be deemed reasonable.While I agree with virtually everything that has been said in this thread, the reason why it is "beyond reasonable" is also the reason why we don't have Armenians that climb the highest mountains before others, explore the scary and unknown places before the rest, and why in general we have a hyper-realist (not to call it "pessimistic") outlook on life ("never mind, it would never work"). And I am not saying that I am any better. On the other hand, if a few big-wig Armenians made some serious noise about the Hemshinli, it would lead to a serious reaction in Turkey (naturally indignant and negative). That is all you need to at least put the issue into the consciousness of the Hemshinli. I would find any effort at religious "conversion" thoroughly tasteless. It is high time to free the Armenian identity from the church. If they like what they see, they can convert; or if they don't care about religion, that should be fine. Is it truly so impossible to let the Hemshinli know that we would eagerly accept them? I am not 100% sure. I am not talking about immigration to poor Armenia or imposing a now-alien religion. Re-connecting to one's ancestors and ancestral culture may be a strong enough motivation for many Hemshinli. After all, there is no advantage (and indeed plenty of heartbreak) in viewing oneself as a Kurd in Turkey; yet many do it anyway. Anyway, I do agree that "it would never work", not because it wouldn't but because we are the way we are. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by Nvard:Huynastan is still an Enigma for me You mean you disagree with the explanation I offered? Why?
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:My answer to TB´s question is very simple: whoever has any reasonable ground to claim he is Armenian, is an Armenian. In other words: if you consider yourself Armenian, than you are an Armenian. This is a decision that should be left to the individual in our case. We have a large and complex diaspora, nobody has the right to say who is Armenian or not, except for his own case. I fully agree with you. In this case, however, the individuals in question (the Hemshinlis) would in general not want to be considered Armenians. Therefore, to nudge their current self-view toward acknowledging and embracing their Armenian ancestry requires a very sympathetic approach by those who do call themselves Armenian. Such sympathy and caring would only be generated if a big enough number of Armenians consider the Hemshinli as proper Armenians to embrace and cherish. That is why the views of Armenians other than the Hemshinli individuals are important in this particular context.
-
quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:They may have not kept an Armenian identity, but they have kept THEIR identity, which is more important I think. I respectfully disagree. They are preserving a garbled, severely lobotomized "identity". Sort of like an accident victim with partial amnesia: The ability of the victim to remember and realize that he is a distinct individual is certainly a good thing compared with an inability to do so. But it is only the first step in the chain of "good" things to happen to the patient, who still cannot remember where or who his family is. quote:However, except for some specific cultural or geographical words they seem to no longer speak Armenian.That is a shame, but not surprising I am afraid. Then time is running out for Armenians to make a connection with these people. I wonder how the people on this forum feel about the Hemshinli. Alright people, do you think the Homshentsik are Armenians? Do you think it is worthwhile to reach out to them? TB P.S. Bellthecat, please give us more first-hand information about the Hemshinli. Do you have Hemshinli friends or relatives? Your perspective would be a very valuable contribution.
