Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
That is a legitimate view of life. As luck has it, it also corresponds to "genes" (read character traits) that are best left unpropagated. Too bad about other "genes" (traits) chained to them that are worth propagating.
-
Yeah, yeah. I guess the fact that it contains actual sentences does qualify as consolation. It is fair and reasonable to suggest that it still doesn't correlate all that well with reality.
-
Humph ... Boghos gets this: And I get this: <-- my new signature
-
New Turkish Penal Code & The Armenian Genocide
Twilight Bark replied to Siamanto's topic in Genocide
Yeah, probably not. But saying that is about as meaningful as saying "Turkey is a functioning democracy". The "gerekce" is not speculated by some pundit -- it is written by the lawmakers. Whatever. -
Irresponsible tax cuts, as well as reckless and hugely expensive wars are much more likely to ruin the economic future of America. According to the Cheney doctrine, "deficits don't matter", and who's Bush to argue. According to a poll conducted by The Economist (a fiscally conservative British publication that even supported Bush's war), most economists favored Kerry over Bush, although neither was regarded blemish-free. Even for ordinary Americans that are not wedded to an ideology, Kerry is the obvious choice by virtue of the fact that he is not Bush. And Bush hasn't given Armenians any reason to like him. What's there to think?
-
New Turkish Penal Code & The Armenian Genocide
Twilight Bark replied to Siamanto's topic in Genocide
It is under "Gerekce" -- "reasons/motivation". Thus the specific examples listed in "Gerekce" probably will not end up in the "Law" itself. However, it is made crystal clear for what purpose the laws are intended. It is a remarkable law even by Turkish standards. If adopted, it makes any statements or insinuations contrary to the official line by anyone remotely qualified illegal; but statements by, say, a plumber or an underwear salesman would probably be overlooked since they are not likely to "profit" from "activities against the interests of the state". On the other hand, any writer, thinker, journalist, or professor that makes offending remarks can be prosecuted because they are getting paid to do what they do. And there is not a peep from the Europeans. Apparently, defending the freedom to commit adultery ranked much higher in their list of priorities than freedom of speech. -
New Turkish Penal Code & The Armenian Genocide
Twilight Bark replied to Siamanto's topic in Genocide
Fire him. -
Welcome to the forum Gor-Gor. As you concluded, Western Armenian cannot survive in the long term without the soil from which it was plucked. The news item "The last speaker of Western Armenian died today at the age of 132" is probably about 200 years away. That doesn't mean I am not doing my best to teach it to my kids (simply because it is the one I am reasonably competent in). As for W.A. in Armenia, I think there is already a program that is designed to train teachers from the diaspora in W.A. (which is kind of strange). I don't remember any details though. I am not sure there is a point in keeping W.A. alive by life-support. It would be better if elements of it (along with Grabar [Krapar ] ) were incorporated into and reconciled with "Eastern Armenian", so that the latter becomes easier to adapt to, as well as richer.
-
You are right, that issue ties into this one. The problem is that boys are often not raised at all. They just ... grow. The values that they take to their graves are the adolescent ones that they teach one another. On the other hand, I am more disgusted when I see the vanilla American way of interacting with their kids as if they are conducting a business transaction, and their panicked obsession with making their kids "independent" so that they can kick them out of the house when they turn 18, preferably before (sappy pretense aside). They produce emotionally crippled, confused people. So I think a nudging of Armenian parental practices in the right direction (by adding certain things) is better than adopting the "western" model of parenting wholesale. Oh I think I have always been "distant" . And I am up to my eyebrows in family, thank you very much.
-
Lack of ethics? Too fond of their clan? Naah. As reasons, those don't make sense. Armenians don't like government probably because of their history with the concept. And the next level of "governance" is extended family, to which they default. We are then back to square one, where I say that you can not go to a healthy government by simply weakening family ties, as they are not the root cause. In fact they are the last line of defence that should be left alone. In this area, we need an addition (of a sense of social responsibility) into the culture, not a removal (of close-knit family). The removal of the latter does not lead to the addition of the former that is somehow waiting ro rush in, but is being stopped by family values. I agree that what has evolved as a defensive strategy (strong family), appears to be operating counterproductively among the ruling elite, who cannot break free of their programming. I disagree that a simple removal of that programming is the answer, because what can easily take its place is even less desirable (e.g. an Orwellian government or a cacophony of New Age nonsense). A "school" that is capable of producing a generation of self-centered, careerist elite groomed for government can also easily produce a generation of otherwise "normal" Armenians who have been instilled with a strong sense of ethics and priority. The cultural difference between the government elite and the rest of the population should not be in their love of family.
-
So are you saying that people in Armenia love and care about their family much more than those in less corrupt countries? Have those diasporan Armenians that are making a living ethically achieved that state of mind through weakening their family values and ties, and care less about their family members in absolute terms, compared with Armenians in Armenia proper?
-
That sounds like "vowel harmony". I didn't think that it was a universal tendency, or an evolutionary target. If so, that makes Turkish one of the most evolved languages.
-
It seems to me what you are advocating is a reduction in the relative importance of family ties. Well sure, the sense of social responsibility, trust, and cooperation should certainly be increased and strengthened. That is a self-evidently desirable goal that does not need a reduction in the absolute strength of family ties in the culture in order to be achieved. And I submit that, if the increase in relative importance of social responsibility is to have a point at all, it should not come through an erosion of family cohesion. It should instead successfully compete with that cohesion. A lot of it simply involves basic ethics and honesty.
-
Yes but you need to institute the basic rules of ethics, rather than weaken the family per se. The reason family ties is an issue is because of lack of ethics. Not because they love their family members oh-so-much.
-
Those clan members should be screwed not because they are family, or because the person in power doesn't care about family. They should be screwed because they are dishonest jerks that dishonor the family.
-
I wasn't referring to any deception by the researchers. Such dishonesty is rare enough not to worry about it until there is reason to. What I am trying to say is that it's not like a true experiment in which you are querying nature using brute force. It is a computational "experiment" that exquisitely depends on the details of the model. One can easily fool oneself about the reliability by getting back what is wired into the model to begin with. Clearly, they would be using force fields that favor beta-sheets or alpha-helices for the appropriate aminoacids, by way of their parameterizations. This would give the correct result for small proteins with simple folds. However, it could easily fail miserably for the more challenging cases. There is no doubt that such computational experiments will one day become foolproof, reliable, and feasible. However, I suspect that, the current effort is more helpful to the computational researchers in understanding and improving their methodologies than it is to pharmaceutical companies trying to find a cure for some disease. Still a valid and useful goal, but perhaps not a widely understood one.
-
We agree there, as I indicated in my earlier reply. There is a fine distinction however; it exists only as a temporary, untenable state. In the same reply, I had also indicated the dangers of that transient state.
-
No doubt. However, the whole movement and the people's attitude in general were still in "get something from Moscow" mode. In essence, at least subconsciously, they were ganging/huddling together against the perceived ultimate authority. But this is essentially equivalent to saying that we should have well-trained public servants, for whom thinking like a true public servant is second nature. They just need to do their job properly. They don't need to promise "Hey, I'll screw my family for you!". As for why the route to effective governance should not pass through weakening family ties. That's because it is always healthier to arrive at a result through competition rather than weakening your "opponent". Any government model worth its salt should be able to provide compelling reasons to well-trained public servants not to put their cousin Harut's bank account above their public duties, and not because he thinks cousin Harut, along with the rest of the family, is an insufferable bore that he has to see at every damn Christmas gathering.
-
Well, they may not be folding laundry, but they are not folding sufficiently realistic models of proteins either. It is unclear to me whether their force fields are reliable enough to almost always lead to the right geometry for all proteins. And the part where they claim that not having explicit water molecules near the protein or some critical sites (which are probably unknown before folding) is no big deal is downright scary. The project seems like a scheme to supply a particular research group with free computational resources rather than a true "grand-challenge" where one is certain to reach the desired end by applying enough brute force. I dare the computer wizards of HyeForum to come up with a generic grid-computing platform that is to be shared by Armenians worldwide. Something like "Massively Armenian Computing", where a poor graduate student or a professor would have an "unfair" advantage by virtue of being Armenian.
-
Armen, Indeed it is another chicken-or-egg problem. In many instances, a slowly-decaying, dysfunctional empire starts to exploit its subjects more and more heavily in desperation. This leads to many generations knowing nothing but an unfair and useless government before it collapses fully. The emergent cultures or nations do not start with a clean slate; they start with a populace that is deeply and justifiably suspicious of any government. Armenian history clearly fits into this category. For at least the past thousand years (in fact much more) until recently, Armenians have been governed by non-Armenians. Therefore it is not unreasonable to claim that bad (Armenian) governance came before the (Armenian) "excessive emphasis on family ties". The latter seems to be a defence mechanism against the former. Anyway, let me re-emphasize that I disagree with the statement that the Armenia of LTP was a tabula rasa to be written on. Whatever the case may be, it is unrealistic to expect a harmless reversion to altruistic collaborative model of behavior once you weaken the family ties. On the contrary, weakened family ties would lead to hyper-individualism, which would then lead to a crisis of meaning in people's lives. The emptiness then would be filled either by government (still bad at that point) propaganda (a la "1984" of Orwell) or various flavors of religious bullshit. Any variants of such an outcome are utterly undesirable. The route from tribalism to collective cohesion and trust does not, and even if it could, should not, pass from weakening family ties.
-
You might be confusing correlation with causation. Depending on the time period, all sorts of contradictory traits can be correlated with "collective success". I submit (with equal lack of proof) that the superficial appearance of excessive emphasis on family ties is a result of the vacuum left by the lack of a trustworthy government, rather than the other way around. Other cases you site have their origins in dysfunctional empires as well. Correlation vs causation. Always watch out for that confusion!
-
The Real Enemy Of Russia Is Not Islam
Twilight Bark replied to Armenian Highlander's topic in International
Turkish army was nonexistent long before that. Turkey became a player in the East mainly because the Armenian "army" lost its nerve, and the soldiers (almost entirely from the "East") felt that "this is not our war; this is not our country" about "western Armenia". They couldn't get out of there fast enough, tripping over each other. In effect they defeated themselves. The more supplies they left behind, the stronger the Turkish army became, and the higher their morale got. Sardarabad battle proved that Turks could be stopped in a major battle. However, it neither destroyed the rest of the Turkish army, nor did it have a real impact on the politics of the situation. All had been decided right before the victory. Perhaps. But the reason Turkey, instead of Armenia, became a focus of aid and support was because Armenians didn't show any strength and resolve in Eastern Anatolia when they had the chance. Sure Mustafa Kemal and Karabekir put on a fake "communist" pretense, and duped the bolsheviks. But the reason they became relevant was because Armenians let them. In any case, I keep reading on the forum "there would be no Turkey". Why is it that so many here would be happy to see no country left for the ethnic Turks of the time (whatever their origins, they wouldn't fit into any other identity). A Turkey that covered most of Anatolia except for the Aegean coast, a part of Pontus and the core Armenian provinces would have been a fair result. If you are not going to lower yourself to the depths that they lowered themselves, longing for "no Turkey" is silly. True, but probably not in the sense that you are implying. There was no real victory on the Eastern front. Only an Armenian defeat. As for a war in the future, Armenia should be prepared for it, but only to prevent it, not fight it. It doesn't take a military genius to know that it would be disastrous for all involved. If Turkey ever attacked, it would mean that they no longer fear the political consequences, which further implies that a "permanent vacation" either in neighboring countries or in the afterlife is how they would be planning to deal with Armenians in the aftermath of a war. It's crazy to contemplate a "beneficial war" for Armenia. Insane. As for preparedness, what Swiss used to do seriously (and nowadays not so seriously) would be a good model to start from as far as the human resources part. And the infrastructure should be completely decentralized and put underground whenever it is possible. Micropower (rather than one or several big power plants) for electricity, enough "strategic oil reserves", and fiber-optic communication network are a few things that come to mind. -
The brutal realpolitik of the bully nations aside, it is healthy and essential to see, recognize, and analyze past mistakes and shortcomings. We have significant blame in our being abandoned. We need to learn from the mistakes not only of the leadership, but the common people as well, whose shortcomings directly define the shortcomings of our culture. Here is the link to the said book (not an easy read because of repetitions and some tedious details, some of which actually further reveal some of our weaknesses): http://www.abrilbooks.com/Bookinfo/History...ralAndranik.htm
