Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. quote:Originally posted by MJ:I am not even sure that in Armenian language there is an equivalent of the word "pilgrim" the way it is perceived in English. Since the Arab conquest, I think, the word "gharib" has been put into circulation in Armenian society, and it is reflected in the poetry of the time, as well as in the pages of the poetry of the early 20th century. That is the closest that I can think of, which comes closest to the word “pilgrim” in Armenia. ( Would like to stand corrected if I am wrong. ) And the word “gharib” has more of a meaning of “immigrant” then a “pilgrim,” the way we understand it in English. Which is much the same as the English word "pilgrim", which (according to my dictionary) comes from the Latin "peregrinus" (meaning someone who is "beyond ones own land"). So it seems that it is not correct for us to assume (which I was) that a pilgrimage has to have a religious context, though religion does seem to have taken over its use. Looking in my thesaurus for an alternative, less religious, word for pilgrimage led to nothing. All the alternative words for travel seem just to be connected with frivilous, aimless, or pointless travel. This is the exact opposite of the original concept of travel - until maybe 200 years ago nobody travelled just for the sake of travelling. Actually, nowadays the modern mind seems incapable of considering any travel other than the pointless variety: customs ask "is your travel for business or pleasure" - I have never travelled for either. Steve PS: Strange thing, the word "holiday" (holy day) has gone exactly the oppposite way - originally 100% religious, now 100% secular (although Americans seem to go about wishing each other a "happy holiday" at Christmas, a practice that now seems decidedly strange to Britons, but which must result from the original usage being preserved in America and lost in Britain.
  2. quote:Originally posted by Stormy:Dunno, I've noticed mention of pilgrims at least once on this site: http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/khtz...nk/khtzkonk.htm In 1878, after the Russian conquest of the Kars region, Khtzkonk was returned to the Armenian Church. The buildings were renovated and religious life resumed within the monastery. New accommodation was erected for monks and pilgrims - these were built along the edge of the main spur, beside the river in the gorge below, and also to the north-west of the Saint Sargis church. Wouldn't you agree that those sites in such remote, desolate places were too beautiful to be left unvisited and just for the purpose of keeping the monks busy? There is a drawing by Martiros Saryan, from 1929, titled "Pilgrimage", showing a large crowd of people picknicking and camping in front of this monastery. The specific scene is definately imaginary because there is no flat ground near the monastery for such a gathering, but it might have been based on a real event but depicted with some artistic licence. Steve
  3. quote:Originally posted by MJ:I meant that there is no precedent in Armenian History of people organizing "pilgrimages to holly sites." I am not aware of declaration of any holy sites in Armenia history. I understand your argument that the word pilgrimage is indeed used in a lose manner in our days. As I said above, my comment was of a tangential character. Do you mean that the organization of "pilgrimages" at times that do not follow the traditional dates of pilgrimages set by the Armenian church, and going to places that do not traditionally have pilgimages has no precident? That might be true, but to say anything more than that has to be wrong - there are loads of old accounts of Armenians going on pilgrimages to religious sites (not always even to churches - pointing to possible pre-Christian origins). Some were strictly local in character, others of national importance - and as for the lack of "holy sites" - come on, there are plenty examples - the Etchmiadzin churches are built upon the sites of the graves of Hripsime and her virgins, Zvartnots was built on the spot where Trdat the great meat St. Gregory, there is a church near Erzincan that contained the grave of St. Gregory, and many other minor saints had churches built over their supposed burial places. Steve
  4. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:I watched it and, if I have the time, I'll give some comments on it in a day or so once I rewatch it and make notes. Steve Sorry, it won't be in a day or so, I have rewatched it and made notes but I don't just now have the time to write anything, and I will be travelling for the next 2 weeks. But, rewatching it has reinforced my bad opinions of it - the title "Betrayed" is certainly an apt one: since this "documentary" has betrayed almost every good aspect of historical research. It is a piece of junk TV - produced only to fill a gap in Blair's contemptable "Holocaust Memorial Day" and make it less like a "Zionist Propaganda Day". Steve
  5. Anyone got any background information about what has happened at the charity "Centre For Armenian Information and Advice" (CAIA) and "Hayashen", their Armenian community centre in London?
  6. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Anyway - I am waiting for this documentary to be aired in the US. Eventually I assume... Here are the comments I just submitted: Er, but how can you justify posting comments about a TV program you have not seen? Although, I bet I would be justified in asking the same question to probably most of the Turks and Armenians who have sent their comments - barely 1 in 100 will have actually seen the documentary. Are they all wanabe Pavlov dogs? They just have to hear of the existance of a program about the Armenian Genocide and, depending on their ethnicity, they automatically reach for the keyboard and drool with pleasure or howl madly with anger. Sometimes it is best to say nothing. That's what I feel anyway, and the comments accepted so far do make pretty dismal reading. Steve Sorry, I just re-read what I had written, so I should make it clear that I wasn't actually saying your comments were just drool! Your comments make sense, but they are not specifically about the TV program in question, not could they be since you have not seen it.
  7. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Anyway - I am waiting for this documentary to be aired in the US. Eventually I assume... Here are the comments I just submitted: Er, but how can you justify posting comments about a TV program you have not seen? Although, I bet I would be justified in asking the same question to probably most of the Turks and Armenians who have sent their comments - barely 1 in 100 will have actually seen the documentary. Are they all wanabe Pavlov dogs? They just have to hear of the existance of a program about the Armenian Genocide and, depending on their ethnicity, they automatically reach for the keyboard and drool with pleasure or howl madly with anger. Sometimes it is best to say nothing. That's what I feel anyway, and the comments accepted so far do make pretty dismal reading. Steve
  8. quote:Originally posted by gamavor:Welcome back Bellthecat! Thanks, There was a period when I was too busy, then there was a period when there was nothing worth posting or replying to, then there was a period when I had lost my password, then there was now.
  9. I watched it and, if I have the time, I'll give some comments on it in a day or so once I rewatch it and make notes. But, basically, for a short, one-off TV documentary it was just about as good as I expected it to be: it was not particularly original, said nothing new, had the usual gross simplifications and generalisations you get with such things, plus the occasional glaring falsehood, plus the feeling that the persons making it don't know that much about the subject. And (no surprises here) all Armenians will praise it, most Turks will crudely attack it, the rest of us will just ignore it. Steve
  10. quote:Originally posted by MosJan: ....Menush, a specialist who is reconstructing Tsitsernavank and who has reconstructed several churches and was conferred with the Order of Ananya Shirakatsi. ...Tsitsernavank dates to the 4th or 5th century (construction made in accordance with the project of extended rectangle and it is one of the main types of the early Christian temples). The church and its bakery were reconstructed in 2001-2002 with the help of Armenian benefactors from Diaspora. This is what I was talking about here: Another Armenian church destroyed? Rather than giving him an award, he should be arrested for cultural vandalisim. (The url for the photo has changed it is now here.)
  11. Steve can comment My primary observation on reading that the "restoration" was delayed was the thought "well, at least the church will survive intact for another year!" Nobody that is involved in "restorations" in Turkey or Armenia should be allowed near Aght'amar - they are all incompetant, lacking in even the most basic understanding of how an historic monument should be conserved. Their concept of "restoration" is a century behind accepted conservation practices in western Europe, but even a hundred years ago such things were not done! They will not "restore" it, they will destroy it as an historic monument, just like they have effectively destroyed every other historic building in Turkey and in Armenia that has been "restored" during the last 10 years. We can see the real reason for their interest in "restorations" by looking at the proposed budget. 2 million dollars is a ludicrously high sum. The Aght'amar church could be consolidated and preserved for less than 10 percent of that sum, probably for as little as 1 percent of it. But there is no money to be made from that - no politicians pockets will be lined, no contractors will retire to Istanbul, no "academics" will see their salaries trebled for a few years. If anybody involved had the slightest real interest in conserving the church they would advocate the permanent employment of a skilled local mason to make the small amount of repairs that are necessary, and have that person visit the church regularly to attend to the regular maintenance of the structure. But there is no money to be skimmed off that sort of project. Other false statements in that article include: The dome is in no danger of collapse. There is no rainwater seeping through the dome. There is no "dirt or moss" on the roof of the dome. Shepherds never used the reliefs for target practice - there were no shepherds on the island becasue Aght'amar is too small to support sheep. The damage was done by bored soldiers from the army post that was on the island until the 1950s.
  12. As a cheaper alternative to spending several million - why not get a fake Gorky, a snip at 1800 dollars! Painting signed ARSHILE GORKY The small "a" and the lack of a date are the signs it's a fake.
  13. I just saw for sale on ebay: "original pristine soul" THIS AGREEMENT made in Pleasant Grove, Utah County, in the state of Utah, United States of America this ------- day of --------- Two Thousand and Two. Between: Not Disclosed until sale, of Pleasant Grove, Utah County, in the state of Utah. (hereinafter called the "Seller") THE ONE PART AND: ------------- (hereinafter called the "Buyer") OF THE OTHER PART The parties hereto mutually agree one with the other as follows: 1. For and in the consideration of the sum of $-------------------- ($o.oo) hereinafter called the "Purchase Price" paid by the Buyer to the Seller on or before the execution of this agreement the Seller hereby sells to the Buyer, Subject to the terms and conditions herein contained, a soul of the following potential, detail and description, Namely: Sex: MALE Name of the soul: ------ Date of Birth: ------ Race: Caucasian It shall be understood that at the time of sale this soul is NOT considered to be of show or breeding quality, but is representative of its breed and is structurally and temperamentally suited as a companion. 2. THE SELLER COVENANTS AND AGREES WITH THE BUYER AS FOLLOWS: 2.1 THAT the Seller is the lawful owner of the soul and that the soul is free of all claims of any other person or body, except as hereinafter specified. 2.2 THAT the soul is, at the time of this agreement, in good health and of sound body and constitution. 3. THE BUYER COVENANTS AND AGREES WITH THE SELLER AS FOLLOWS: 3.1 THAT the Buyer will pay all shipment costs related to the delivery of the soul. 3.2 THAT the Buyer will maintain and keep control of the soul, and adequately provide, house and care for the soul. 3.3 THAT if at any time there is a reason that the buyer cannot keep the soul, he/she will notify the Seller and bring the soul back for direction in placement. 3.4 THAT if at any time the Buyer decides to sell the soul or the Buyer receives an offer, which he/she is willing to accept, for the purchase of the soul, he/she shall not sell the soul without first granting to the Seller a prior right to acquire the soul at a price not higher than the original Purchase Price. The offer to the Seller shall be in writing and the Seller shall have thirty (30) days from the receipt of the offer to accept same. 3.5 THAT should the Seller fail to exercise the right referred to in clause 3.4 hereof, and the Buyer not accept the offer made to him/her as aforesaid, the Buyer shall nonetheless be responsible to comply with clause 3.4 for any and all subsequent offers. 3.6 THAT this soul shall not be sold by, to or through any commercial wholesale establishment, any chain store, catalogue sales house or commercial breeding establishment, nor shall it be offered as a prize in any raffle, draw, contest or lottery of any nature or kind whatsoever. Failure to observe this clause will entitle the Seller to take the soul back under their care, control, and ownership, and ownership will be transferred to the Seller. 4. IT IS HEREBY MUTUALLY AGREED TO AND UNDERSTOOD THAT: 4.1 The Seller assumes no responsibility for any disorder acquired by the soul through injury, nutritional, infectious or para-natural disorder, or by disease. 5. This agreement and all rights and duties of either party hereunder shall devolve on, ensure the benefit of, and be binding upon the respective personal representatives, heirs, successors and assigns of the parties hereto and in the event the Buyer shall sell to any other person other than the Seller herein, the person to whom the sou is sold shall, prior to the completion of the sale of the soul, execute an Agreement identical to this one with the Seller herein. 6. This agreement may only be canceled by the mutual consent of the parties hereto. 7. This Agreement shall constitute the entire Agreement between the parties hereto and neither party is bound to any representation, warranty, undertaking, promise, covenant, condition, term, agreement or inducement not embodied or contained herein. 8. The validity and interpretation of this Agreement and each clause and part therefor, shall be governed by the Law of the State of Utah, and if any provision of this agreement shall be found to be deemed to be illegal or invalid, the remainder of the agreement shall not be affected thereby. IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have hereunto their hands and seals subscribed and set on the day and year first before written. SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED) SIGNATURE OF WITNESS Legal Seal Affixed Here SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED) SIGNATURE OF WITNESS
  14. Yeuch - what is the point of remaking perfection. The remake's url shouldn't be "solarisTHEmovie.com" but solaristhecheapandnastycopy.com But, actually, I wasn't aware one of the characters was Armenian - so that's why there was a picture of an Armenian church on one of the room walls!
  15. They were Greeks, and they were not "early Christians". The documentary probably used that phrase simply to avoid explaining why there are no Christians left there (i.e. the genocide and expulsion of the Greek inhabitants in 1922).
  16. quote:Originally posted by Rouben Malayan:Thanks everyone for your inputs, yes, the catch here is of course the game with Absolut. I removed any reference to the actual trademark from the poster, therefore the connection is purely symbolic. But the word "Absolut" is a trademark! And since you are also copying the general design concept of the original advert I think you are probably also infringing the copyright of that. Regardless of that, it is a catching design but (if the earlier responses are anything to go by) is over the heads of a lot of people, or, at least, it needs the viewer to have an awareness of current advertising design, or to have to stand at bus stops for ages, with nothing but an advertising panel to look at!
  17. Yawn ....finally seeing Macs consigned to the oblivion of technological obsolesence will be a good thing if only to see the end of MAC vs PC arguments.
  18. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:by the way, this thread was about turkey's eu membership, we seem to have lost the thread, don't we? Before we return to it, Ali, could you answer my question about where you found those "signs of improvement" showing that the plight of Armenian buildings in Turkey is improving?
  19. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:Ali, your knowledge is nothing to boast about on this subject. I am curious as to where you get your information. There is barely a single Armenian church that is protected from destruction and, far from diminshing, the rate of destruction is increasing. With maybe a dozen exceptions, I expect that there will be almost nothing left within a decade. Steve i live in this country, travel around, and revisit places i first visited years ago. i have not been able to do so much for the past four years, but until then, i kept seeing some signs of improvement here and there. i don't deny that some destruction may still be going on, but there is some reversal as well. Ali, I am certain that I have travelled much more widely in your county than you have. For Armenian churches in Turkey there has, is, and always will be, nothing but destruction, destruction, destruction. Year after year after year of it. There is no reversal. The total destruction of all recognisable Armenian monuments in Turkey is an inevitable consequence of and integral part of the Armenian Genocide. It is not reversable, any more than the Genocide is reversable. Even if the Turkish government were to change its policy regarding the Genocide the monuments still would not be saved. A few, like Ani or Aght'amar, would be destroyed by Turkish-style "restoration", the rest would still be left to the pickaxes and shovels of treasure hunters, to the bulldozers of property developers, to the dynamite of religious or Turanic fanatics, or to the simple effects of 90 years of dereliction. As far as I am aware, to date, not one lira has been spent by the Turkish state towards preserving any Armenian church. So, give us some examples of your signs of improvement!
  20. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: On a global scale, I don't think Turkey is threatening everyone with an intention to start a world war. Nor do I think that Turkey is threatening the very existence of human civilisation with its selfish enviromental destruction. On a domestic scale, far from moving towards European ideals, America seems to be hell-bent on running away from them. It is a teeny bit ridiculous for you to complain about "homoginized European Union standards". Hasn't your odious president just been jackbooting his way up and down electoral platforms all over America proclaiming that he is engaged in a worldwide war to protect US "standards" which he thinks should be the world's standards. Our standards are (I hope!) based on a complex and sometimes difficult to balance range of humanist ethics and the experience gained (over the last few hundreds of years) of sometimes trying to live through difficult times when those standards have been lost sight of. Your country's standards seem to be mostly based on nothing more than "I'm always right, I say so, God says so, even when everyone else says I'm wrong, and even when I secretly know I'm wrong". The relevance to all this on an Armenian board is that it is ridiculous for Armenian organisations to be going around saying that Turkey should not be a member of the EU because of Turkey's past or present relationship with Armenia and Armenians. Firstly, nobody who is in the position of saying "yes" or "no" to Turkey's membership is going give even a second of consideration to such reasoning. Secondly, given the number of far more disagreeable problem countries that Europe has to deal with (USA being No. 1 at the moment), it is useless to be constantly attacking Turkey. I don't think you will ever see 500,000 people marching through an Italian city protesting at Turkish policies! Thirdly, the Turkish state's disagreeable disregard of European standards like democracy and truth will have to change if it enters the EU, and the standards of the average Turk will also have to change once Turkey actually becomes a member. Rather than opposing Turkish membership, Armenians should actually be encouraging it (and maybe it would even lead to EU membership for Armenia since it would mean it would be bordering an EU country!). But, as I said before, I don't think Turkey will be a member, and the reason for it will be economic. Steve
  21. quote:Originally posted by HOVSEP KASHISHIAN:To all nations of the world: 1) unvail your women 2) take the faze off your mens head 3) put on europian clothes 4) adopt europian alphabets 5) have some kined elections 6) ally your country with the U S A Walla you got it, now you can join the EU Mebership regardless of your human wrights violations or miss treatment of your minorities . WHAT A JOKE . Your words are the joke here, and I'm not referring to the spelling. Ultimately the only criteria for Turkey's EU membership will be economic, and that is why Turkey will not be allowed to join the EU. There is only a fixed ammount of EU money available for development grants and agricultural subsidy. A country like Turkey would take such a big slice of those funds that it would affect all the other parts of Europe. This would have huge implications for the electorial support that many EU politicians have. While their natural instinct is (like the leaders of all empires) to expand - they have (just) enough sense of their own self preservation to know when to stop and say "enough". One further note, however imperfect the Turkish state currently is in relation to European political ideals, Turkey passes far more of those ideals than a country like, say, America, which, with its gross abuses of human rights, use of capital punishment, political control of its judiciary, and its widespread flouting of international laws and treaties, would have no chance of joining, EVER! Steve
  22. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: To the best of my knowledge, no armenian church is being destroyed today. the bulk of the destruction took place between 1915-1923, and continued until about the 1970s. since the 1980s, actual destruction more or less stopped and as far as i know in the 1990s some reversal has begun. Ali, your knowledge is nothing to boast about on this subject. I am curious as to where you get your information. There is barely a single Armenian church that is protected from destruction and, far from diminshing, the rate of destruction is increasing. With maybe a dozen exceptions, I expect that there will be almost nothing left within a decade. Steve
  23. Huh! I thought it was the 3 million dollar Arshile Gorky painting you had spotted! It's also on ebay. http://cgi.liveauctions.ebay.com/ws/eBayIS...item=1579922731 There are others at a mere snip of $300,000
  24. quote:Originally posted by MJ:[Hmm… Not a single Armenian name… - MJ] Hmmmm.... it should be worth reading then! Steve
  25. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan: Don't even try to make parallels btw Armenian case and chechens in Russia, it's absolutely irrelevant. As I responded to Thoth's post, there is no genocide, no extermination of the nation in Chechnya, russian soldiers do not enter chechen's houses and kill children and women, did not you know that? Moreover, there is a chechen opposition in Chechnya which works on the side of federals and has the same attitude to the terrorists - they REALLY worry about the nation and its living conditions. Do you know something similar in the case of armenians in the Ottoman Empire? Such blind arrogance!! You have never bothered to read anything about the long series of wars during the 19th century the Russian empire fought to conquer Circssia. Wars that were fought with a scorched earth policy and mass reprisals against civilians that mirror Russian activities in Chechenia today. And after the Russians had won, from the 1860s onward hundreds of thousands of Muslim Circassians were forced to leave their homes and given the choice of either move to resettlement camps in Ukraine or to migrate to Turkey - most chose Turkey. They were from the western Caucasus (Abkhazia and Abassia). There was not a forced mass expulsion on the same scale from the eastern Caucasus (Chechenia and Ingushetia) but many chose to leave anyway, again migrating to Turkey. This is why the Circassian diaspora in Turkey has exact parallels with the Armenian diasora in Europe and North America, Both are made up from the descendents of genocide survivors with a recent influx of immigrants from the post-soviet period. And both have the same legitimate concerns for the survival of their original homeland. So, if Eduard Markosyan really believes there is any justification for his words "the main topic here is INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM AND THE SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS GET FROM THE TURKS AND THEIR AZERI BROTHERS." then he should start another topic titled "INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM AND THE SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS GET FROM ARMENIA AND THE ARMENIAN DIASPORA". He cannot be so selective with his deceits. Steve
×
×
  • Create New...