Azat Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 MJ,Why do you think that the article is garbage. I just read the article and found it to be very interesting. Is there any fact in it that is not true? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Azat, I cannot commit all my time interpretting nonsense, right? That would take all my time. I think you can read the bullet points in the mentioned article, compare them with the conclusions of the same article, and then make your own judgments if you know anything about the subject. I don't know if their facts are true or not. But I can read their conclusions and think about how do they relate to the evidence. At the and, I would have one question to the author: "What were you trying to convey in this article?" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:I cannot commit all my time interpretting nonsense, right?"From your perspective it is nonsense, but there are millions of us who believe it is not. Don't make is sound like your perspective of things, facts, ideas are the only correct ones. We are all here to share our opinions and nothing more.The thing that upset me was the way you insulted alpha. I think of you as a very intelligent person, however your method of discrediting "things" is to attack the messenger and not the "things" in question.If you believe that the article is all wrong and can prove that it is, write a letter to the Economist and I am sure they will retract their article and publish a thank you note to you. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 It is very funny. Why should I care about this article, and why should I write Economist? Why should I care about it? What kind of nonsense is this? Additionally, I have neither attacked the messenger nor Alpha or you. I am yet to see one single argument on the merits from the either one of you. All you keep saying is "I believe... Many people believe..." So what that you believe? Does it constitute a meaningful argument? I am out of this dispute. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
alpha Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 MJ, I appreciate the fact that you took time to read parts from such a credible magazine as Economist. You keep saying that my facts are not right, but I’d like to point out that these are not my facts. They come from very reputable sources. I’d be more than happy to read publications that you find credible, which show your point of view. The reason I posted the link and tried to make a reasonable argument by pointing my sources, was to show my perspective of how current administration works. One thing I don’t understand is your ardent desire to close your eyes on their mistakes, and to justify their shortcomings. I might not have the academic credentials like you do, but I’d recommend you to have an open up your mind on other sources, and not discredit them without giving any reasons. Also, you said that some numbers that I provide (mainly 20-40%) are not my numbers. As an analyst I can attest you that using numbers provided by reputable sources is an acceptable practice in investment community. Guess what, as an economist I can point out that taxation is progressive, and by raising taxes to pay for rate increases helps common people who are in financial difficulty. That’s the only way state can shield its people from money grabbing of energy companies. It’s an indirect way of redistribution of income. The gap between haves and have-nots is increasing at a rapid pace. Something must be done to stop it. On the one last note, why do I surprise you. Can we stop name calling. We are here to have reasonable arguments. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Just as I mentioned in a previous post. You keep attacking individuals when you cannot prove your point. And about my intellect. Well I hold an MBA. Do very well in life and business. And have an IQ of a genius. Thank you very much. I am not interested in talking to you on this or any other subject. Just think about it for a second. I am not the first person that you have annoyed around here. It could be you and not all the others that have been annoyed by you. Consider this as my last post to you. At this rate, Garo could soon change the name of this forum to "MJ Forum". Good bye, and take care of your self. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Azat, You are too insignificant of an outcast for me to go after you. You are not worth my time. Alpha, just out of personal curtesy, I will respond to your last posting, however, I have to say that I have really no interest in the argument. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Alpha, This is not about the credentials, but not claiming things that we have never studied or thought about. I pay significant amount of money on a monthly basis to buy the materials from the professional sources. And I get significantly compensated for the analysis that I provide. So let’s leave it there. However, I can refer you to one valuable, in my view, public online material, which true, is not about California, but the events of the summer of 1998 in MidWest. The magnitude of the problems in California is nowhere close to the magnitude of the problems in MidWest that has faded away in the result of the measures taken subsequently. However, the problems are very similar, and the market forces are the same. It is a Report written by a special investigative commission of FERC – Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, whether there was market manipulations in Electricity Markets in the MidWest in the Summer of 1998. Here it is: http://www.ferc.fed.us/electric/mastback.pdf . It is an 87 page report, however. As to the sources, it is very difficult for me to accept a projection published in Time Magazine as a credible source. The only credible source on conservation may come from the energy specialists, who have had considerable experience in the retail side of the market, and who understand the physical fundamentals of the process of generating energy commodities. And on that capacity, no professional would claim that we can conserve 20-40% of the energy demand. It is just nuts. I can assure you that I have open mind, but I have zero tolerance for non-professionalism and partisanship. As to the subject of the progressive taxation, as we know the taxation in the US is progressive, and it is proposed to remain so. Additionally there are a few systems of financial aid in place for law income people. The most significant contributors of these programs are the so-called “rich.” I am not aware of any declarations regarding abolishing the national and state financial aid programs. To the contrary, it is the position of the current administration that the states have to have the discretion of determining the way to help the less fortunate people, and the Faith Based Organizations have to be encouraged and supported to organize support on a local level. On a Federal level, the current Administration has demonstrated the initiative of strengthening the Social Security System – something that the former administration has not only refused to do, but has blocked any bi-partisan attempt to do so. The same concerns the MediCare system. In the previous 8 years, the administration has not only avoided these issues, and has demagogued them, but has blocked any initiative that the Republican and Democrat Senators have tried to bring together for the purpose of providing solutions for these much important programs. Now, this Administration, being in the office for less than 120 days, has taken on these issues. I presume you have never attacked the previous administration in eight years, but you do so the current one after 120 days. And the very things you accuse them of failing are the things that have been failed in the last administration, while this administration is trying to fix.About raising taxes to help for paying for the increase of the rates, and it being the only shield against the energy industry. To be honest, with all due respect, this is not an argument of an economist, but a left-leaning partisan. First of all, I hope you would agree that you don’t know much about the physical underlyings of the energy markets, nor you do so about their market structure and the interaction of different forces. The taxpayers and the ratepayers are the same people – you and me. It doesn’t make much difference whether we pay for energy consumption from our left pocket or from the right pocket. Both pockets are ours. If the taxes are going to be raised, we are going to pay for it. If the energy rates are going to be raised (and this is where Grey has manipulated the public opinion) – still we are going to pay for it. However, it makes huge difference in terms of facilitating investments, without which, in the next 30 years, the US Energy Markets would be in disarray. As I have mentioned earlier, the Federal Energy Administration has estimated that in the next 30 years, so that to satisfy only the electricity needs in the nation, we need in average one new plant a week to go online. Where is this money going to come from? You may be tempted to say from the taxes. However, I don’t think that you would understand the magnitude of the presumed tax hikes you might propose. That would basically imply a fundamental change of the social, political and economical structure of the US, which I can assure you that even the most ardent liberals would not advocate. As evident, the absolute majority of the US population if supportive of the opposite – tax cuts. And it is supportive of the Bush Tax cut, otherwise it would’ve not had a chance for passage in a 50-50 Senate. As the energy markets are concerned, the very deregulation has been initiated so that to promote infusion of capital into the energy markets, since the fed was not able to facilitated the investments in the regulated markets, when no matter what kind of risks you take, you are guaranteed fixed margins. Additionally, it was expected that the energy prices would come down after the deregulation. It has not happened. Why? For a variety of reasons. One reason being the implementation of wrong models. But this is similar to the deregulation of telecommunications industry. If you might remember, right after the deregulation of that industry, the long-distance call prices went up for quite some time. However, the competition from all the small companies forced the AT&T, MCI and Sprint to lower the prices. It took few years. The same is the case in energy industry. The prices are high because the deregulation process has been hampered by the regulators, states, the Fed, and those old day energy companies, which do everything to preserve the status quo. This is a subject that can be discussed for very long time, and I don’t believe that the Hye Forum is the right place for it. To address your question on why you surprise me, let me just say because you are much smarter than your latest arguments. Let’s go to the article in the Economist, now. ”• On May 11th, Rick Perry, the new governor, signed into law the “James Byrd Hate Crimes Act”, named after a black man chained to a truck and dragged to his death. The law specifies harsh punishments for crimes committed against particular groups of people. Mr Bush opposed it as governor and on the campaign trail.” There have been three perpetrators of the mentioned crime. Two of them have been sentenced to death, and the third one has been sentenced to life-in-prison. Seems like it is hard to think of something harsher. Additionally, the logic of the proposed crime is to have special category of sentencing for the crimes when they are committed against the blacks, for example. I think it constitutes reverse racism. I share Bushes stance in this regard – no matter what race of people or what minorities the crimes are committed against, they should be categorized equally, and be punished equally by the law. Can you tell me what is wrong with this logic? Do you feel that killing a white man is less of a crime then killing a black man, and there should be a special law against killing black men? “• The state’s House of Representatives has passed a bill that would set a two-year moratorium on new charter schools (privately managed public schools, a Bush favourite), and voted to postpone by a year Mr Bush’s planned abolition of social promotion.”So what that is has been postponed. Bush has been recognized primarily for his success in the area of education in Texas. I don’t know what is going on in Texas currently, but I know the following – he has been able to receive the support of the democrats and the republicans alike (including the Ed Kennedy types) to implement his education agenda nationwide. This is characterized even by the left leaning media as an overwhelming victory by Bush. “• The legislature is working on several bills to moderate death-penalty laws. One would provide better legal defence for indigents (a bill Mr Bush had earlier vetoed). Another would extend the use of life imprisonment. A third would stop the execution of mentally retarded murderers.”This bullets say that there are efforts underway. We’ll see what the result would be. (Personally, I am not much supportive of the death penalty, however I don’t have a strong stance on it from the opposite point of view, either.) The absolute majority of the US population is supportive of the death penalty. The population of Texas is even more overwhelmingly supportive of it. The death penalty is not introduced by Bush. It was there during all previous administrations, even when the legislature and the executive branch of the Texas government all were Democrat. No attempts were made then to change it. Why is this Bushes legacy, I cannot understand. Additionally, Bush, Clinton, Gore and Liberman alike have been supportive of the death penalty. This is not a partisan issue. It is a cultural issue. As frequently quoted, there is no evidence that anybody in Texas has been executed without having full access to the courts, and the ability to appeal. On of the lately executed, in fact, has had the ability to appeal it almost 30 times in the last 12 years, if my memory doesn’t betray me. The governor of Texas, by the constitution of the state has no discretion in making decision with respect to the executions. Unless the independent commission established for this purpose makes a recommendation, the governor (no matter who he is) cannot do anything by the law. What Bush claims that no one under his watch has been executed without being proven beyond reasonable doubt that he/she has been guilty of the charges, and he has made sure that everybody has had full and fair access to the courts. Nobody has provided any other evidence. ‘• Both houses have voted to streamline Medicaid, helping poor children to get it (another proposal Mr Bush had opposed).’No details are provided on the scope and the character of the initiative, and no explanations what Bush has opposed to. No poor child has ever been denied medical help in Texas. In this sense, the Texas system has one of the best systems. True, not every one has Medicaid, but in Texas there are special rules that when people not having any coverage appeal to a Hospital or a clinic, they have no right not to treat them. Additionally, this system has been in Texas since ancient times. It is not Bushes invention. However, Bush has dumped significant funds into the system, so that no one in need of medical help is returned. • The House has voted against the state’s practice of allowing 700 ageing factories to volunteer to cut their pollution (only one has done so, surprise, surprise).In Bushes watch, the environment in Texas has been cleaned at much higher rates then during any other administration or in any other state. True, Texas (primarily Houston) is not the cleanest state. But it is a major industrial state, and a huge chunk of oil refineries are located around Huston. This is not Bushes legacy, either. It has always been like this. ‘• A proposal has appeared to repeal a property-tax cut that Mr Bush pushed through in 1997. This is going nowhere, but the fact that it was even considered is a gauge of the broader implications of the Texas debate. ‘Hundreds of proposals are appearing on the floor of legislature every year. Few of them pass, the absolute majority don’t In what way does this undo Bushes legacy – I don’t see. For Democrats, there is an obvious lesson to be drawn from all this. If Mr Bush’s agenda of tax cuts, education reform and business-friendly deregulation has proved too much even in a conservative bastion such as Texas, surely his attempt to reproduce those policies on a national scale is doomed? In fact, Mr Bush’s Texan legacy is more complicated. In terms of specific policy issues, the current rebellion says very little about his national agenda. But, in terms of fiscal shortsightedness, the message is much more worrying. I don’t see where does this conclusion come from. The evidence the author demonstrates in the 6 bullet points above is a sloppy, inconclusive evidence. Things which have nothing to do with Bush are being attributed to him. When there is no evidence that something is being undone, it is being characterized as “Bushes legacy is being undone.” Very peculiar standards I should say. This is why I have called this material garbage. In the schools that I have gone, these people (I mean of the type of this journalist) would’ve not graduated and received degrees. At most, the attempt to roll back the Bush legacy is a limited one. As Mr Perry Just what is this journalist trying to say? What is his claim? Both the attempt to keep social promotion for an extra year, and the moratorium on charter schools, are being held up in the Senate by one of Mr Bush’s fervent supporters, who has the power to kill them. Many of the criminal-justice provisions will get through, but probably not the environmental toughening.Any details? What is the reason of holding the promotion for a year? Financial reasons? Questioning the merits of the promotions? What is it? Moreover, even if the education bills were to become law, it is an open question whether they should be considered ideological reversals. The reason for keeping social promotion for an extra year is not really to do with the underlying debate about whether abolition would penalise poor pupils.Tell me what is this journalist trying to convey? Which side of the issue is he in? The school year when social promotion is due to end, 2002-03, is also the year when new school tests (tied to a new curriculum) will be introduced. Supporters of a moratorium worry that teething problems with the tests may undermine support for another Bush hobby-horse, accountability.Does this give some explanations to the previous statements? So, what is being held here against Bush? Something similar is afoot with charter schools. The original bill was pushed through in a fit of enthusiasm, with very little supervision of the people setting them up (for which Mr Bush must share the blame). Although a few charter schools have been educationally outstanding, far more have been egregious organisational failures. Schools have closed in the middle of term for lack of cash. Examples of embezzlement and incompetent financial control abound. The Texas Education Agency says that almost a quarter of the 100-odd charter schools it has studied were inadequate. So should there be accountability as promoted by Bush (his main thesis) or not? In a sense, this example, and that of the death penalty, suggest, in Mr Sadler’s words, that “it’s not about dismantling the Bush legacy. It’s just part of the natural progression of government.” Texas was at the forefront of some of the experiments in local government in the 1990s, and it is unsurprising that it is in Texas that problems have cropped up early. As Bruce Buchanan, a professor at the University of Texas at Austin, points out, the state is changing fast. The huge influx of Latinos, largely from Mexico, as well as the growing number of technology firms, has made Texas more urban than it used to be, and less unique in terms of its political culture. Does this paragraph need a comment? Normally, such gradual changes would make policy reversals gradual as well. The swiftness largely reflects two other changes. The first was the national spotlight beamed on Texas by the presidential campaign. Al Gore spent around $300,000 advertising Texas’s failures to the rest of America. This had its impact back home. “We thought of ourselves as a mega-state,” says Mr Buchanan. “But Texas was embarrassed to become the poster child of industrial pollution and a butt of criticism because of our system of criminal justice.” How about spending $300,000 during a presidential campaign to advertise California’s or New York’s failures? How about the Arkansas failures in the Clinton era. Do you know that Arkansas has the fame of the most corrupt State in the US? The other change was personal. The current legislative session is the first to take place since the departure of Mr Bush and the death of Bob Bullock, his Democratic lieutenant-governor. Mr Bullock was legendary for his strong-arm politics. Mr Bush had a public-approval rating in his latter years as governor of more than 80%. When the two men co-operated (and they co-operated a lot), they could exert a far greater hold over the political process than the indistinct and hapless Mr Perry.Do we need comments here to understand the processes? To the extent that the legislature is delivering a rebuff to Mr Bush, it is reverting to a norm, having been absurdly generous in the 1999 session. As Scott Hochberg, a Democrat in the House, puts it, “Two years ago, when we sneezed, the question was did it help or hurt Bush. Now that pressure’s off.” The 1999 session saw the passage of a tax cut and several new spending programmes (such as a pay rise for teachers) in an atmosphere in which lawmakers were doing their very best to help Mr Bush. Rosy fiscal forecasts, which everybody knew to be bogus, were also accepted with barely a murmur. (Washington politicians, of course, are behaving much more responsibly with Mr Bush’s current tax cut.)So to what extend is it being delivered as a rebuff? Should one also praise Bush for the pay rise for the teachers? How about praising him for being able to bring along the Democratic legislature of the State, and sympathizing the current Governeor for not being as successful. Additionally, during Bushes watch, the State Budget of Texas has had in excess of $1 billon of surplus. Part of it has been returned to the tax payers, part of it has been used on spending priorities. Which part of it has been “rosy?” It is at this point that the main charge against Mr Bush emerges. He failed to prepare Texas for the long-term task of reforming state finances, and thus left the main items of state spending—education, health and welfare—in a bind.What is precisely the allegation here? He hasn’t done everything that Texas needs? So? What are the successive governments for? After all, he didn’t even finish his term… The most dramatic example is welfare. The largest single source of money for welfare payments is a block grant from the federal government. In the name of flexibility, Mr Bush used about a sixth of this grant as a windfall to pay for programmes only tangentially related to welfare, such as family planning and the protection of abused children. This also made it easier for Texas to afford the tax cut Mr Bush pushed through in 1997.It is very interesting to hear that “family planning and the protection of abused children” are tangentially related to the welfare. Does this paragraphs provide information what was the other part of the grant used on? If it was Federal Grant, as the author claims, it couldn’t be used for tax cuts. This is bogus. Additionally, how about the State funds for welfare? Any information about it? Now, after five years of decline, welfare rolls are starting to rise again. Patrick Bresette, of an Austin-based think-tank called the Centre for Public Policy Priorities (CPPP), says that the block grant is already failing to keep pace with the increase in welfare demands and will fall into deficit if the rolls rise further. The money cannot simply be reclaimed from child-care programmes, where the relevant agency now depends on that federal grant for a third of its budget. And the tax cut has eroded the surplus in the general account.What is the logic here? The welfare rolls are rising, and the prior allocated money is not adequate? The first question is why in a state like Texas, where the economy is booming, the welfare is rising? Might it have something to do to the fact that Texas is a border state, and it gets disproportionately large influx of Mexican illegals? Might it be that this is also the reason why in Texas the number of people without medical coverage is higher than elsewhere? How about Arizona? California? Has this issue been studied on a comparative basis? The problem stretches well beyond welfare. Demand for social services of all sorts is rising faster than revenues, partly because Texas has one of the highest proportions of school-age children in the United States.So, after all, there are some idiosyncratic for Texas problems, are there? Since the state must by law run a balanced budget, the contrast between lagging revenues and rising spending cannot show up as a deficit. Instead, it produces fiscal chicanery to balance the books. In its 1999-2001 budget, the state financed only 23 of the 24 months of Medicaid and other social services.This is the only serious argument in this article so far. However, it doesn’t provide an explanation what means financing the Medicade only for 23 months out of the 24. Does it mean that during the 24th month those dependent on Medicare have not been able to receive medical services? Do you think it is possible? So they have reshuffled the funds, perhaps, in the books. It is not desirable, but is it something demonstrating the “failure” of Bushes legacy?To keep programmes at current levels for the next two years, the CPPP reckons, would need $300m more than expected revenues (which themselves would be revised downwards if growth were flat). And that excludes several spending measures that are hard to put off. These include increasing Medicaid payments (most such services have not seen a rise for ten years and some doctors are refusing to offer them); the provision of health insurance for teachers (a few get it now through their school districts, but not all); and a pay rise for state employees. Texas is at or near the bottom of state and local government spending per head. There is a limit to how much more it can be squeezed.Do you know anything about CPPP? Who is this organization? Who is it financed by? How credible are its projections? Do you know anything about them? Has this author, if he is an unbiased journalist, spoken to anybody in the government, or the opposite side of the fence. Is there one instance in the entire article, that both sides are questions, or both arguments are investigated? Isn’t it a primary responsibility of a professional journalist? I am not a budget specialist. I can’t neither refute nor support these allegations. However, it is evident that they are based on a single source, the character of which is not clear to us. Whether this is financed by the opposition party or by Ralph Nadar, per se, we don’t know. In any case, even if it is financed by Nadar, that doesn’t mean automatically it is non-credible, however, as I said, the credibility of such projections requires checking them with other sources. This is something that is absent in the entire article. The underlying problem is the lopsided structure of the tax system. Over half the state’s revenues come from a sales tax on goods, which has not kept pace with Texas’s shift to a service-based economy. The CPPP’s budget expert, Dick Lavine, calculates that tax revenues as a share of personal income have declined from over 9.5% in 1994 to about 8.7% this year, and are still falling (see chart).Yes. Texas has no State income Taxes. It has been the case for very long time. This state has always had booming economy, and the sales-tax has sufficed. If it is not adequate anymore, the Tecans would revisit it, however, I am not going to take the projection of a single (and unknown to us) source as an evidence. The school-finance system is particularly skewed. It depends on local property taxes. There is a cap on these taxes; 20% of school districts are at the limit, and most others are near it. But school enrolment is soaring. Mr Bush promised to increase the state’s share of education spending to 60%; instead it has fallen to 44%.Yes. It is the case everywhere. The school funding primarily comes from the local taxes. If there are problems, that means they require further effort to fix them. As the article says – the school enrolment is soaring. I bet it is also due to the illegal emigration. I don’t know about the education spending. However, as we know, for every $1 spend on education in the US, about 10% of it is reaching the classrooms or the local schools. This is a failed system in general – not just in Texas, and this is the primary reason beyond some attempts to eliminate the Department of Education, the plutocracy of which eats most of the funds. This is a complex issue, and without knowing the particulars, which this article doesn’t provide I cannot comment on them. It may seem unfair to blame Mr Bush for the mess. Underfunding and financial chicanery long pre-date his governorship. And, to his credit, he tried to solve the structural problem by proposing to shift some of the burden of revenue-raising from property taxes to business taxes. Alas, he failed to persuade his own party, which vetoed the plan in the state Senate.Do you have any comments on this? Because I don’t feel I have to comment. The real accusation is that Mr Bush’s later campaigns for tax cuts fed an illusion of fiscal prosperity that Texas is only starting to wake up to. In their next few sessions, the lawmakers will almost certainly have to cut tax exemptions, widen the tax base where they can, and even consider, horror of horrors, an income tax. And a tax rise in Texas really would hurt Mr Bush, as much in Washington as in Austin.Now, this is his opinion. He has the right. What is it based on, however? Does his evidence support it? What are his sources? CPPP? What budgetary committee have expressed this opinion? What projections of state revenues and liabilities is this based on? Is this something that the author “just believes on?” Doesn’t the integrity of this material raise your eyebrows? Look, Alpha. I am a professional man. When I read these kinds of articles – I call them garbage. To write more systematic analysis of this article, I have to spend more time on it. I see no point in doing that. As I have said, it is not my duty to rebottle every single idiot. It is evident that the analysis is shallow, the internal logic of the article is flawed, the declarations made in the beginning of the article don’t correspond to their own evidence and conclusions, the some of the accusations are based on a single source, which is a violation of journalistic norms, etc. It is not clear what is this author claiming here, other than “I don’t like Bush.” This is what I call garbage, and I call a material not worth my time. If you would have more questions on the energy markets and the deregulation process, you can send me a private message, and I would reply to you as my time allows. [ May 23, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 23, 2001 Report Share Posted May 23, 2001 Look , I do not give a rats ass what you do and what you do not do. I think if you go back to all my posts you will notice that I listed hard facts with date and sources. You called them bogus and garbage and everything else you wanted. But I am sure other members of this forum would find my arguments and sources to be more legit than the so called MJ professional sources. There was not a single argument that you made that you did back up with any kind of document. All the stuff you wrote you said it was written in "Stone" but noting was presented to us in writing. You called your opinions "facts", yet not a single source was provided. Oh yes, I forgot, you have your professional sources. Show me the facts. Don't just talk. If you take your head out of your ass and think for a second you will realize that you are being a pompous ass in this case. [ May 22, 2001: Message edited by: Azat ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 23, 2001 Report Share Posted May 23, 2001 I think your posting speaks volumes on your intellectual capacity and on your integrity. I'll keep it undeleted for you come back every-now-and-ten and enjot it. It is not my obligation to educate every pretentious immitator of a thinking person, who cannot hold a simple streight line in his own argumemts, who would trhough things around wihtout even understanding of the words and concepts he uses. Is it my duty to correct everyone? I don't think so. Live with your illusions, but go back to school to learn some elementary manners, and learn the difference between your mouth and your "ass," becasue it seems like they both perform an equivalent function. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 23, 2001 Report Share Posted May 23, 2001 Tehran TimesMay 23 2001 A New Energy Triangle Emerges: Iran-Armenia-Ukraine Armenia has suffered severe energy shortages since 1991 and has longbeen looking to Iran to relieve its energy needs. Last year theEuropean Commission decided to back a project for construction of apipeline from Iran into Armenia. Discussions have now begun withUkraine concerning the possibility of Iranian natural gas transitingArmenia and Georgia, then traveling either overland through Russia orunder the Black Sea into Ukraine and onward to European markets.Turkmenistan's President Niyazov must now face Russia and Iran aspotential competitors for the European market. Unless Niyazov decidesto build the trans-Caspian gas pipeline, both Russia and Iran willhave a stranglehold on Turkmenistan's gas and oil exports. BACKGROUND: Iran and Armenia signed an intergovernmental agreement in1992 (amended in 1995) to construct a 140-kilometer pipeline with avolume of one billion cubic meters (bcm) per year. This pipelinewould straddle the two countries' short common border, crossing theMegri corridor that separates Azerbaijan proper from its exclaveNakhichevan. In mid-1999, Iran's foreign minister Kamal Kharrazisuggested constructing a gas pipeline to Ukraine via Armenia. TheUkrainian ambassador replied by proposing to connect the Iran-Armeniapipeline with a Turkmenistan-Ukraine pipeline. Ukraine's newestformer Deputy Prime Minister Yuliya Tymoshenko, who was recentlyforced to resign, had long propounded the idea for the trans-Caspiangas pipeline (TCGP) to carry Ashkhabad's gas westward into Ukraine.Such a pipeline, after going under the Caspian Sea and throughAzerbaijan, would continue westward under the Black Sea to join thepipeline system in Ukraine at Fedosiya. Ukraine has indicated itswillingness to take gas from Turkmenistan piped through Iran viaArmenia. Financing even for the short pipeline from Iran to Armenia has beendifficult to find under any plan. Gazprom expressed an interest inmid-1999 but then withdrew at about the same time that Gaz de Francedanced a similar hesitation-waltz. The joint venture Armrosgazpromheld discussions with the National Iranian Gas Company (NIGC) inmid-February 2000 and agreed on a price of U.S.$ 90 per thousandcubic meters, but that is over a quarter again as expensive as thesame quantity from Russia. The World Bank nevertheless expressedinterest in the project and construction began only to be halted inmid-March once more for lack of funding. In April, the World Bankexplicitly refused to subsidize the excessively high interest ratethat China demanded for the U.S.$ 80 million loan it had offered toArmenia for the project. In mid-July, after the project consortiumwas restructured to include Armrosgazprom, NIGC, the National GasCorporation of Greece (DEPA) as well as Gazprom, a significanttrilateral meeting occurred in Yerevan among the European Commission,Iran and Armenia. The European interest in the pipeline from Iran to Armenia stemmedoriginally from its nuclear safety program for the new post-Sovietstates. It desired to shut down Armenia's Medzamor Nuclear PowerPlant, but Armenia refused to do this until an alternative source ofenergy was identified and made available. Iranian natural gas wouldsatisfy that requirement. At the Yerevan meeting, however, theEuropean Commission decided to sponsor the Iran-Armenia pipelineproject under its INOGATE program. INOGATE, an important andcomprehensive if little-known initiative to address questions ofmulti-modal transportation throughout the former Soviet area, standsfor interstate oil and gas transportation to Europe. Iran, oddly, isthe only participating country or observer country at INOGATE thathas not signed the European Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) that formsthe basis, in all of Europe and beyond the Urals, fornon-discriminatory harmonization of national energy sectors. Thecurrent practices in the Iranian oil industry make Ukraine look likesparking spring water. IMPLICATIONS: Contacts among the European Commission's PresidentRomano Prodi, Germany's Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder and Russia'sPresident Vladimir Putin at the end of September 2000 initiatedstrategic discussions of the possibilities for long-term Europeanparticipation in the development of the Russian energy industry,especially the natural gas sector. The EU intends to increase theproportion of natural gas in its fuel consumption mix over the longterm, for environmental reasons. The European move on Iran is fromone standpoint just a maneuver to pressure Russia on price. YetEurope has declared itself willing to take from Iran whatever amountsof gas Russia is unable to sell. There are some problems with theidea of piping Iran's natural gas to Europe via Ukraine, whether theroute goes overland through Russia or under the Black Sea. If thepipeline goes across Russian territory to Ukraine rather than underthe Black Sea, then this would give Russia a still greater potentialstranglehold upon the EU's natural gas supplies. Ukraine and Russiahave long been at odds over the question of Ukraine's allegedpilfering of natural gas exported across its territory from Russia toEurope. Such problems may be expected to continue so long as theUkrainian energy sector remains fundamentally unreformed, and wouldcertainly affect Iranian gas transiting the country as well. Indeed,in early 2000 Tymoshenko had accused the state oil and gas concernNaftogaz Ukrainy of siphoning gas out of Russian pipeline, anddeclared that the country's net debt for gas was U.S.$ 1.7 billion,or twice what Naftogaz Ukrainy had claimed. Later that year, inmid-August, after continued denials of the pilfering, PresidentLeonid Kuchma created a sensation when he told the German magazine**** Der Spiegel **** that gas thefts were being carried out on theorder of Ukraine's government. The Russian side thereupon claimedUkraine was more than U.S.$2 billion in arrears, including fines forlate payments. The same vested interests in the Ukrainian energy sector that did notfavor Tymoshenko's policy of monetizing resource flows also oppose aTCGP to Ukraine, because this might mean leverage in favor of demandsfor greater transparency in accounting and business methods. One ofthe reasons for Tymoshenko's recent ouster was her insistence onimplementing fundamental reform in Ukraine's energy sector. As farback as last August, Ukraine's Prime Minister Viktor Yushchenkosuggested that parts of Ukraine's gas transportation network might besold off or given to Russia as payment for the Ukrainian gas debt.Tymoshenko's recent forced departure may easily make it more likelythat Gazprom and Itera will come to control, if not own outright,parts of Ukraine's gas transportation network. CONCLUSION: The INOGATE program was originally established to promotecooperation between the EU and the newly independent states. Apipeline in the INOGATE framework has also been suggested from Turkeyto Greece, channeling gas from the Caspian Basin, and Iran inparticular, to Europe. Turkey is moving slowly on this idea becauseit still believes in the TCGP from Turkmenistan under the CaspianSea. The disadvantage to Turkmenistan of going through Iran isprecisely the same as going through Russia: The transit country withcontrol over the taps is a competing gas supplier to the ultimateconsumer. It is noteworthy that the definite moves by the EuropeanCommission to back the Iran-Armenia pipeline came only after the TCGPnegotiations all but collapsed early last year. In November last year, Turkmenistan's acting oil and gas industryminister stated that his country still gave priority to the TCGPproject over the Iranian route for Ashkhabad's gas to Europe. Delaysin the Blue Stream project for Russian natural gas to go under theBlack Sea to Turkey, and in the Shah-Deniz project for Azerbaijanigas to enter Turkey through Georgia, have both recently encountereddelays for complicated technical and engineering reasons. This givesNiyazov an unexpected window, which was on the verge of closing, tomake a deal for the TCGP. The Iranian option to Europe has to impressNiyazov even more forcefully that if he does not build a TCGP tosomewhere, then he will be left with only one buyer, Gazprom, whichwould then be in a position to dictate the price. Niyazov's onlychoice is to bite the bullet and agree to build the TCGP with minimalfurther delay. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Berj Posted June 2, 2001 Report Share Posted June 2, 2001 http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg32811.html Jane's: New directions in Caspian politics Jane's Intelligence Review May 1, 2001 Tamara Makarenko The recent discovery of substantial oil reserves in Kazakhstan hasadded a new urgency to discussions on establishing pipeline routes toexport oil and gas reserves. Tamara Makarenko examines the politicaland economic implications of the 'new' Caspian game. The importance ofresolving the legal status of the Caspian Sea and finalising pipelineroutes for the export of Caspian oil and gas reserves has taken on asense of heightened urgency from both littoral states and externalactors. Renewed interest in prioritising Caspian issues follows theannouncements made by the Offshore Kazakhstan International OilConsortium (OKIOC) in mid- March, confirming that it had hit oil inthe second of two wells drilled in the Kashagan oil field. Preliminaryestimates suggest that the second well alone may be capable ofproducing 2 million barrels of oil a day in 15 years, making it thefifth largest oil field in the world, and the largest discovery in 30years. The Kashagan finds, combined with significant deposits inTengiz and Karachaganak, have ensured that Kazakhstan now representsan important key to future Caspian development. Renewed Russian and US attempts to win Kazakh loyalty can beattributed to the influential position enjoyed by Kazakhstan, which isrecognised by all of the Caspian players. The 'new' Caspian game,however, also includes a string of additional players, whichtransforms regional politics into an intricate web of complex choicescarrying political and security repercussions. In an environment wherenothing is certain and alliances can change overnight, a constantanalysis of the actions and policies of the most powerful actors isthe only way to gauge whether or not the Caspian will ever represent astable oil and gas producing region capable of supplying the worldmarket. Moscow has two primary objectives in the Caspian region: first, toconvince all littoral states to divide the Caspian seabed along amodified median line while keeping the surface water a common area;and second, to ensure that export pipelines continue to transitRussian territory. Since President Vladimir Putin came to power in May 2000, Russia hasattempted to fulfil these goals through a change in official policytowards the Caspian littoral states. Moving away from former PresidentBoris Yeltsin's undeclared policy of winning influence by regainingterritorial control, Putin appears to be following a strategy whichfocuses on exploiting Russian economic influence via its traderelations. In many respects this strategy has already worked withAzerbaijan and Kazakhstan, and has the potential to influence thedecisions Iran ultimately makes regarding Caspian Sea issues. Over the past few months the Russian-Azeri relationship has improvedas a result of actions taken by both states. Azerbaijan significantlyaltered the environment in which bilateral relations were conducted byextraditing two Chechen rebels to Moscow earlier in the year. Russiahas reciprocated by entering into official discussions about energyand security issues. However, despite the fact that Baku officially confirmed its decisionto back Moscow's modified median line approach on Caspian divisionduring Putin's visit to Azerbaijan in January, Russia has been unableto influence Azerbaijan's pipeline preferences. On this issue,President Heydar Aliyev, for obvious reasons, firmly supports theconstruction of a pipeline from Baku to Ceyhan (Turkey). Thispreference places an overarching strain on Russian-Azeri relationsbecause the Baku-Ceyhan pipeline, bypassing Russian and Iranianterritory, is favoured by the USA. For this reason Azerbaijan isalways primarily regarded as a US ally and is therefore accordedcareful treatment by the other Caspian states. Russian-Kazakh relations, on the other hand, remain considerably morecomplex. President Nursultan Nazarbayev and the government ofKazakhstan are continuously reminded of their economic dependence onRussia. Not only is Russia a leading trade partner but Kazakhstandepends on Russia to export the majority of its oil. These economicties, however, are not entered into blindly - on the contrary, Astanaopenly favours increasing economic co-operation with Moscow.Furthermore, Kazakh officials have noted that they consider Russia anincreasingly important partner in terms of maintaining regionalsecurity. These important links have thus made it somewhatunsurprising that Kazakh authorities tacitly agree with Russia'sapproach on dividing the Caspian Sea. Unlike Azerbaijan, thisagreement also appears to spill over into Kazakhstan's choice ofexport pipelines. Viktor Kalyuzhny, the Caspian envoy to Russia, was recently quoted assaying, "Where to export oil is Kazakhstan's right. Russia must justdo everything so Kazakh oil goes through Russia. And for that Russiamust establish all economic and political conditions and create a'green channel' for Kazakh crude." Despite officially voicing an interest in diversifying its exportroutes to bring Kazakh oil to the international market, actions takenby Astana suggest it continues to prioritise its relationship withRussia. This loyalty to Russia is highlighted by Nazarbayev's decisionto support the construction of a pipeline from the Tengiz oil field tothe Russian port of Novorossiysk. Although the Tengiz-Novorossiyskpipeline was the only viable option in 1998 capable of offering alarge-scale export option for increasing Kazakh oil production, italso showed Astana's deference to Russian priorities. Inaugurated atthe end of March 2001, the Tengiz- Novorossiysk pipeline is the firstinternational pipeline dedicated to taking Caspian oil to theinternational market. Not only does it promise to bring Russiasignificant revenues as a transit country but it also gives Moscowadditional political leverage in terms of influencing future Kazakhpipeline decisions. Given that the Tengiz-Novorossiysk line is not sufficient to export aprojected 67 million tones of Kazakh oil per year, it is recognisedthat Kazakhstan must seek additional export routes. Astana has twoviable options: the first is to support Baku-Ceyhan (with an estimatedprice-tag ranging between US$2.4 and $3.7 billion), the second is toback the construction of a pipeline from Kashagan to Kharg, Iran (withan estimated cost of $1.2 to 1.5 billion). Taking into account economic, political and security considerations,the latter option appears to be Kazakhstan's clear, if unstated,choice. The fact that Agip of Italy was chosen as the officialoperator at the Kashagan structure, to the distaste of the USA whichpreferred ExxonMobil, suggests it is becoming increasingly likely thatAstana will eventually choose a route through Iran. Agip is known toprefer the Iranian option, and unlike the US company ExxonMobil, whichcannot operate in Iran because of the Iran-Libya Sanctions Act, Agipfaces no operational restrictions. Furthermore, in light of recentdevelopments in Russian-Iranian relations, the Kashagan-Kharg pipelinewould represent continued Kazakh deference to Moscow at a time whenAstana is reassessing the importance of its Russian relations. Iran and Russia draw closer Despite disagreeing about many issues, Iran and Russia have found anumber of interests in common, drawing the two states closer togetherover the past few months. The most notable being their mutual distrustof US influence in the region, and mutual frustration overWashington's attempts to dictate Russian and Iranian policy. Irantherefore views Russia as a path leading away from internationalisolation, and Moscow has realised the potential benefits associatedwith supporting a regional power outside the US sphere ofinfluence. Thus the landmark meeting held between Putin and PresidentMohammad Khatami in March may be seen as an important turning point inCaspian and international politics. Although the two countries did not agree on how the Caspian should bedivided, both parties concurred on three basic points: - that the construction of pipelines under the Caspian should beblocked for environmental reasons; - the status of the Caspian would not be finalised until all fivelittoral states are in unanimous agreement; and - that the non-littoral states should be forbidden from using theCaspian Sea to deploy their naval forces. Many analysts have suggested that Russia and Iran's failure to agreeon the division of the Caspian is a ploy to sabotage the Baku-Ceyhanpipeline. In order to make Baku-Ceyhan feasible, the large oilreserves in Kazakhstan would have to be used to fill the pipelinebecause Azerbaijan does not have enough reserves of its own. In theabsence of a legal status it is unlikely that investors would agree tobuild the required trans-Caspian pipeline connecting Kazakh reservesin the north-east of the Caspian to Baku in the south-west. Thiswould inevitably result in reserves having to continue to go norththrough Russia, and south through Iran, guaranteeing both statestransit fees and the accompanying regional influence associated withdependence on these countries to export Caspian oil and gas reservesinternationally. The most important aspect, however, arising from the meeting heldbetween Putin and Khatami in March, was Moscow's agreement to resumesales of conventional arms to Iran, in addition to suggesting that itwould help complete the Iranian nuclear power plant at Bushehr. Instead of directly focusing on Caspian issues, the arms trade hasbecome the cornerstone of future Russian-Iranian relations. Estimatessuggest that within the next few years Iran will become Russia's thirdlargest arms buyer, after China and India. This move initiated byRussia is not as erratic as the West would like to believe. On thecontrary, it appears to be a well thought out policy by Putin todemonstrate Russian influence in the region at the beginning of thenewly elected Bush administration, and to gain more influencevis-a-vis Iran, which may eventually be used to persuade Khatami tocompromise on the Caspian. Despite being adamant about receiving an equal 20% share of theCaspian, as opposed to 14% it would receive by agreeing to Russia'smedian line approach, Iran may increasingly feel obliged to compromiseits position on the Caspian as a result of expanding political andmilitary co-operation with Russia. Given that Moscow appears willingto give Tehran the option of accepting the median line approach, plusone or two per cent, it is difficult to envisage Iran continuing todisagree with Russia over the legal status of the Caspian. For thesake of building on current relations Iran may see greater benefitassociated with following Russia. As French analyst Olivier Roy hasstated on numerous occasions, Iran would prefer that Russia dominatethe region, as opposed to the USA or any of its allies. A statement made by Sergei Blagovodin, deputy director of the RussianAcademy of Sciences Institute of International Relations and the WorldEconomy, exemplifies the newly accorded importance of Iranianrelations for Russia. "It would be strange for Russia to ignore acountry such as Iran, with its growing economic potential, and whichplays such an important role in the Caspian," he argued. However, itwill not be long before Russia expects Iran to show signs ofgratitude. US responses Since the election of President George W Bush, US policy towards theCaspian has seemingly been driven by reactions to Russianinitiatives. As Russia placed greater efforts on addressing thesecurity and economic concerns of the region, US officials closelyfollowed by initiating parallel efforts. For example, as Russiaentered into military co-operation agreements with Azerbaijan andKazakhstan, the USA showed a renewed interest in resolving theNagorno-Artsax conflict, ultimately inviting the leadership ofArmenia and Azerbaijan to peace talks in Florida in early April. Asfar as US interests are concerned, the resolution of Nagorno- Artsaxis essential to ensure the future security of pipelines required toconnect Caspian oil to refineries in Europe and ultimately in the USA. The Florida peace talks may also partially be seen as a US response tothe opening of the Tengiz-Novorossiysk pipeline. Losing influence toRussia as a result of the successful opening of Tengiz- Novorossiysk,the USA is now placing greater efforts in pushing for construction tobegin on the Baku-Ceyhan pipeline. Ensuring pipeline security is an important factor in pre- constructiondecisions. As it currently stands, despite praising Baku-Ceyhan, USaction has merely proven that this pipeline is primarily supported forpolitical reasons. Instead of going forward and investing asignificant amount of money in the project, the USA is trying toinvolve Kazakhstan in the pipeline. Given the large oil finds on Kazakh territory, US officials havesuggested that Washington could find the required credits to financethe construction of Baku-Ceyhan if Kazakhstan guaranteed it would usethe line. Regardless of signing an agreement suggesting it would useBaku-Ceyhan were it to be built, it is unlikely that Kazakhstan willbe willing to spend its oil profits on a project that wouldimmediately alienate Russia and damage its relations with Iran. Forthese reasons the project will never be economically viable and willtherefore remain a political enterprise. Washington's unease over developments in the Caspian can be partlyattributed to Moscow's decision to renege on the secret agreementsigned between vice-presidents Chernomyrdin and Gore in 1995, blockingRussia from exporting conventional weapons to Iran. US Secretary ofDefense Donald Rumsfeld was quoted by UK newspaper the SundayTelegraph as stating that Russia has become a "chief distributor ofweapons of mass destruction to rogue-states". In response to theseattacks, Russian officials have focused on what they regard as UShypocrisy by questioning Washington's military contacts with Pakistanand the large amount of weapons it supplies to Saudi Arabia. Inattempting to promote itself as a moral alternative to Russia, the USAis merely damaging its own reputation in the region. Instead of easing sanctions and allowing US companies to become partof Iranian pipeline projects - thereby regaining a degree of theinfluence it has lost in the region - the Bush administration iscaught up in replaying Cold War politics, forever attempting to proveits superpower status. The historic statement made by former USSecretary of Energy Bill Richardson in 1998 during an interview withthe New York Times continues to shed light on US priorities in theCaspian: "This is about America's energy security; which depends ondiversifying our sources of oil and gas worldwide. It's also aboutpreventing strategic inroads by those who don't share ourvalues. We're trying to move these newly independent countries towardsthe West. We would like to see them reliant on western commercial andpolitical interests rather than going another way. We've made asubstantial political investment in the Caspian, and it's veryimportant to us that both the pipeline map and the politics comes outright." The USA's strategy in the Caspian is not very different from Russia's- both states are attempting to gain control over lucrative Caspiandevelopments. However, the difference between the two states lies inthe fact that the Caspian is in Russia's neighbourhood, whereas theUSA is only a guest. Considering this very important distinction,Washington needs to come to terms with the fact that there is aninherent danger in trying to sideline Iran and Russia. Furthermore,the view that Caspian states will turn to the USA as a buffer againstRussia is no longer entirely viable because Washington is losinginfluence in its relations with most littoral states. Even Azerbaijan, known to be a staunch US ally, appears to berethinking its relations with the other Caspian states. In addition tothe noticeable improvement in relations with Russia, the relationshipbetween Baku and Tehran has thawed since the beginning of the year. Inlate January Iran agreed to restore electricity supplies toNakhichevan, an enclave and autonomous republic of Azerbaijan. InFebruary Iran sent aid packages to Azerbaijan's poor. Security considerations In light of recent Caspian Sea developments, a number of securityconsiderations have received significant attention from analysts andmedia observers. The most dire have focused on the repercussions ofRussian initiatives. However, it is equally important to note thesecurity implications of US pressures on Caspian states and foreigninvestors. The most serious concern suggests Russia will engage in gunboatdiplomacy should it make inroads in the Caspian. It has been arguedthat the primary reason why Russia wants the surface waters of theCaspian Sea to be treated as common territory is because it wouldbenefit militarily. According to this argument Russian naval controlof the Caspian would significantly alter the development of Caspianresources and would threaten western investment in the region. The notion of Russian gunboat diplomacy in the Caspian isoverstated. Russia is interested in gaining influence over Caspianresources but Putin appears to have realised that the most effectiveway in which this can be done is through less threatening bilateraleconomic and security co-operation arrangements. The Putin government is also aware of the need for western investmentto exploit Caspian resources. More practically, Russia knows it cannotafford to become a Caspian naval power. Most damaging in terms of short-term regional security are thepriorities the USA is following. The fact that the Baku-Ceyhanpipeline would pass by or through the unstable areas of Dagestan,Chechnya, South Ossetia, Abkhazia, Adjaria and Kurdish territory,places Baku-Ceyhan on par with proposed pipelines that travel throughAfghanistan. Should Baku-Ceyhan be built, it will cost foreigninvestors a considerable amount of money to ensure pipeline securityfrom bands of armed militias and gangs. Foreign investors, however, would not be the only actors to lose fromUS Caspian policy. Washington's determination to act in ways whichalienate Russia and Iran is likely to backfire in two ways. First, byforcing Russia to take more decisive steps to secure its influence inits own backyard - Moscow's decision to engage in arms sales to Tehrancould therefore be seen as the beginning of a more forceful andconfident Russia - and second, by fostering tensions in the CentralAsian states with an interest in Caspian development throughpreventing them from gaining economic incentives associated with themost economically viable pipeline options. Attempting to persuadeKazakhstan to choose Baku-Ceyhan over an Iranian alternative, forexample, would eliminate significant transit revenues for Turkmenistanand Uzbekistan - profits which could be used to alleviate internaltensions caused by deteriorating socio- economic conditions. Tamara Makarenko is an independent political and security consultantspecialising in the Russian Federation and Central Asia. GRAPHIC:Photograph 1, A worker passes by a section of the pipeline opened on26 March 2001 set to carry crude oil from the Tengiz oil field inKazakhstan to the Russian Black Sea port of Novorossiysk. (Source: PANews); Photograph 2, Iranian navy cadets march during a graduationceremony in the northern city of Now Shahr on the Caspian coast. Iranand Russia are developing a military and economic relationship whichtakes into account Caspian oil issues and aims to minimise theinfluence of the USA in the region. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted June 4, 2001 Report Share Posted June 4, 2001 U.S. NATIONAL ENERGY POLICYReport of the National Energy Policy Development Group[Headed by Vice President Dick Cheney] CHAPTER EIGHT [. . .] The Caspian Proven oil reserves in Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan are about 20 billionbarrels, a little more than the North Sea and slightly less than theUnited States. Exploration, however, is continuing, and provenreserves are expected to increase significantly. For example, initialresults of the exploration well at Kazakhstan's Kashagan fieldindicate the find is one of the most important in thirty years, and iscomparable to Prudhoe Bay in size. Current exports from the region areonly about 800,000 bar-rels of oil per day, in part due to limitedex-port route options. However, potential exports could increase by1.8 million barrels of oil per day by 2005, as the United States worksclosely with private companies and countries in the region to developcommercially viable export routes, such as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan(BTC) and Caspian Pipeline Consortium oil pipelines (Figure8-10). Moreover, there is considerable optimism that exports couldgrow even more substantially in subsequent years because of positiveprospects for new oil and gas finds as additional geologic structuresundergo exploration, and the development of new export routes. Foreign investors and technology are critical to rapid development ofnew commercially viable export routes. Such development will ensurethat rising Caspian oil production is effectively integrated intoworld oil trade. U.S.-supported East-West pipeline routes will addsubstantial new oil transportation capacity to allow continuedexpansion of production and exports. Over-land routes via pipeline,such as the planned BTC oil pipeline, will also help mitigate maritimerisks in the crowded Bosporus Straits. To help countries prepare forincreased oil production within the region the United States isworking with Black Sea and Caspian Sea border states to ensure thatthey develop adequate oil spill response capabilities. Recommendations:-- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof State, Commerce, and Energy to support the BTC oil pipeline as itdemonstrates its commercial viability. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof Commerce, State, and Energy to continue working with relevantcompanies and countries to establish the commercial conditions thatwill allow oil companies operating in Kazakhstan the option ofexporting their oil via the BTC pipeline. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof State, Commerce, and Energy to support the efforts of privateinvestors and regional governments to develop the Shah Deniz gaspipeline as a way to help Turkey and Georgia diversify their naturalgas supplies and help Azerbaijan export its gas via a pipeline thatwill continue diversification of se-cure energy supply routes. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct appropriatefederal agencies to complete the current cycle of oil spill responsereadiness workshops and to consider further appropriate steps toensure the implementation of the workshops' recommendations. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretaryof State to encourage Greece and Turkey to link their gas pipelinesystems to al-low European consumers to diversify their gas suppliesby purchasing Caspian gas. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof Commerce, Energy, and State to deepen their commercial dialoguewith Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, and other Caspian states to provide astrong, transparent, and stable business climate for energy andrelated infrastructure projects. Russia Russia has about 5 percent of the world's proven oil reserves. In2000, Russia produced an average of 6.7 million barrels of oil andnatural gas liquids per day, making it both the world's third largestproducer and second largest exporter at 4.2 million barrels of oil perday. Russia's oil production in 2000 represented an increase of 7percent over 1999, the first increase since the dissolution of theSoviet Union. A similar rate of increase is projected for 2001. Newfields are being developed, including those with U.S. and otherforeign investors. Nevertheless, substantial infrastructure investment is still needed,as well as legislation and a stable and reliable regime of contractingto finalize the Production Sharing Agreement (PSA) (Schtj) mechanismfor private-sector participation and actions to improve the generalinvestment climate. Russian oil firms are increasingly active on a global scale, withupstream and down-stream investments in the Caspian, the UnitedStates, Africa, South Asia, and Europe, enhancing Russia's ability todevelop its own and international oil reserves. Russia holds 33percent of the world's natural gas reserves, exporting a full 35per-cent of its production to Europe and Central Asia in 1999. Russiannatural gas exports can increase regional fuel diversification andadvance environmental goals. With production declines now evident inexisting fields, development of new reserves that re-quire substantialnew investments will be necessary. Recommendations: -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof State, Commerce, and Energy to deepen the focus of the discussionswith Russia on energy and the investment climate. -- The NEPD Group recommends that the President direct the Secretariesof Commerce, State, and Energy to assist U.S. companies in theirdialogue on the investment and trade climate with Russian officials,to encourage reform of the PSA law and other regulations and relatedtax provisions, as well as general improvements in the overallinvestment climate. This will help expand private investmentopportunities in Russia and will increase the inter-national role ofRussian firms. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mike77 Posted June 4, 2001 Report Share Posted June 4, 2001 Those were some great articles. Keep up the nice work you guys. This is my first post here. I have been making the rounds. Visiting other forums as well. You guys must be scholars or something. I am just a simple person. Keep up the nice work. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted June 4, 2001 Report Share Posted June 4, 2001 No scholars, here, Mike. Just people like you. Welcome to the Forum. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted June 25, 2001 Report Share Posted June 25, 2001 http://www.ftenergyusa.com/images/fte_logo.gif Energy EconomistJune 25, 2001 For the recordIraq has announced it is holding talks with Turkey on a gas pipeline from Northern Iraq to the Turkish Mediterranean port of Çeyhan. Baghdad's al-Rafideen weekly newspaper quoted Oil Ministry senior undersecretary Taha Humud Musa as saying the talks were "promising" and that "this strategic project will have great economic benefit to the two countries". In 1996, Turkey's then Islamist Refah Party-led government signed a memorandum of understanding for development of a 10 bcm/y gasline. The Foreign Ministry (which did not come under Refah auspices), discovered subsequently that the agreement did not include the usual clause that such a line would only be built once sanctions were lifted, although, during subsequent non-Islamist governments, Turkish officials have told FT Energy that they would only pursue the project after sanctions were lifted - or if they secured the necessary changes in the sanctions regime to permit such a project. Copyright © 2000 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted November 11, 2001 Report Share Posted November 11, 2001 The Wall Street Journal November 7, 2001 Commentary A Caspian Alternative to OPECBy Brenda Shaffer. Ms. Shaffer, research director of the Caspian Studies Program at Harvard University, is author of "Borders and Brethren: Iran and the Challenge of Azerbaijani Identity" (MIT Press).BAKU, Azerbaijan -- As the U.S. struggles to maintain its global coalition against terrorism, it finds itself bending over backwards to not offend the Saudis. Although Saudi Arabia bears some responsibility for the rise of Islamist radicalism, and is only offering lukewarm support for the anti-terror campaign, it appears to be immune from criticism because of American dependence on its oil and gas. The U.S., it is believed, can't afford to get tough with its main energy supplier. Or can it? One way to help diminish dependence on Saudi Arabia is to focus on oil from the Caspian Sea.Diversity of sources is one of the most important factors in energy security. Saudi Arabian officials and Saudi-sponsored think tanks are constantly producing low estimates for the amount of Caspian oil and dismissing its importance. The reason? Caspian oil makes Saudi Arabia and the OPEC cartel nervous. Not because of the size of the Caspian volumes, which are roughly equivalent to those of the North Sea. Rather, because the main oil producers in the Caspian region -- Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan -- are not members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and do not coordinate their policies with the cartel.Flows of large volumes of Caspian oil through non-OPEC countries would erode the power of OPEC, as well as its ability to maintain high oil prices and to use oil as a mode of political blackmail. In order to contribute to world energy security, the previous and current U.S. administrations have been pressed for the construction of an oil pipeline on an east-west route -- known, by its coordinates, as "Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan." This would bypass Iran and Russia, and ensure a major oil source far from OPEC tentacles. http://interactive.wsj.com/public/resources/images/ed_azerbaij11062001223926.gif The U.S. administrations have demanded that this route prove its commercial viability beyond its contribution to diversity of world energy sources. British Petroleum has now thrown its weight behind the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan plan, reflecting the project's commercial value, and it seems that significant amounts of Caspian oil will flow from Azerbaijan to the Turkish Mediterranean port of Ceyhan in 2005.The U.S. should deal with Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan because, although they are predominately Muslim states, they maintain complete separation of religion and state. The overwhelming majority of the populations of these states are secular and their foreign policies, especially in Azerbaijan, are staunchly pro-American. While both countries need to make significant progress to strengthen democracy and the rule of law, the human rights situation there is a liberal dream compared with Saudi Arabia and the neighboring Gulf states, which do not even pay lip service to the popular will. Even Russia has, in the last year, dropped its active opposition to the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline and appears to have accepted the project as inevitable.So, Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan are pro-American states, awash with oil, non-coordinated with OPEC, and begging to have their oil flow westward. Does this sound too good to be true? It is. One glitch is the continuing Nagorno-Karabagh conflict.On the eve of the Soviet breakup, a conflict emerged between neighboring Armenia and Azerbaijan over the Nagorno-Karabagh region. This district was in the internationally recognized boundaries of Azerbaijan, but had a majority Armenian population. In 1992, despite the defeat of Azerbaijan, Congress -- at the urging of the Armenian-American community -- slapped sanctions on Baku, barring government-to-government assistance in many fields of cooperation. Despite this punitive move, Baku has cooperated with Washington throughout the decade on non-proliferation and anti-terror operations.Congress has renewed the sanctions, despite the previous and present administrations' opposition, which complicates Washington's ability to cooperate with Azerbaijan. Under the guise of mobilizing support for the anti-terror campaign, and at the urging of Secretary of State Colin Powell, Congress endorsed last week a temporary presidential waiver of the sanctions.While this is a step in the right direction, voices in Azerbaijan are expressing disappointment that while this interim waiver will allow the U.S. to use its bases and airspace, Azerbaijan is still among the group of pariah states including Iran, Iraq and Cuba that have U.S. sanctions placed on them. Azerbaijan also finds it ironic that it is the target of Iranian and Islamist extremist destabilization due to its pro-American policies, even as Washington keeps its sanctions.Caspian oil cannot replace the volumes from Saudi Arabia and the other Persian Gulf states. However, its contribution to the world oil market can weaken OPEC's price and political manipulation. A dramatic change of regime in Saudi Arabia could bring an interim slowdown in oil production and delivery, but even radical states of any type like to sell their oil and gas. In the event of a temporary reduction of Gulf oil flow, the Caspian contribution could soften the blow to the oil market. Diversification of oil sources and energy forms should remain a constant policy, and quick development Caspian oil contributes to that goal. http://interactive.wsj.com/fr/emailthis/re...36416722840.djm [ November 11, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted November 23, 2001 Report Share Posted November 23, 2001 CONGRESSMAN CROWLEY'S AMENDMENT URGES ARMENIA'S INCLUSION IN BAKU-CEYHAN PIPELINEAmendment Not Approved, House Legislation Not Affected WASHINGTON - During a House Financial Services Committee meeting today, Congressman Joseph Crowley (D-NY) and several colleagues offered an amendment to prohibit Export-Import Bank funding for the Baku-Ceyhan pipeline if it does not transit Armenia. The Crowley amendment, which was co-sponsored by Michael Capuano (D-MA), Barbara Lee (D-CA), Carolyn Maloney (D-NY), Michael Rogers (R-MI) and Brad Sherman (D-CA), reads: "The Bank shall not guarantee, insure, or extend credit, or participate in an extension of credit in connection with the export of any good or service that is to be used in the planning, development, construction, or maintenance of a pipeline from Baku, Azerbaijan, to Ceyhan, Turkey, that will not pass through Armenia." While the amendment had strong support, it lost by a vote of 20 (yes) - 24 (no). The amendment has no impact on separate legislation - H. Con. Res. 162 - introduced earlier this session by Congressional Caucus on Armenian Issues Co-Chairs Congressmen Joe Knollenberg (R-MI) and Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and fellow Caucus members Congressmen Crowley and John Sweeney (R-NY). H. Con. Res. 162, which has over 40 co-sponsors, discourages the use of American taxpayers' funds for energy transportation projects in the Caucasus if they exclude consideration of trans-Armenia routes. The resolution also recommends that the Trade Development Agency fund a feasibility study to determine the cost savings of a trans-Armenia Baku-Ceyhan pipeline. During today's hearing, it was estimated that a trans-Armenia pipeline would save some $600 million. "We commend Congressman Crowley for his strong initiative and thank his colleagues that co-sponsored the amendment and those who voted for it," said Bryan Ardouny, Armenian Assembly Director of Government Relations. "Although Armenia has successfully implemented economic reform measures, as long as it remains blockaded on its eastern and western borders and is isolated from regional development projects at Azerbaijan's insistence, Armenia will not be able to reach its full economic potential. Winners and losers in the Caucasus will not promote regional stability and is not in the long-term interests of the United States," he added. In the Assembly's letter to Committee members in support of the amendment, which Congresswoman Barbara Lee asked to be included in the record, the Assembly noted that "The U.S. should make it clear that Armenia must be included in regional and trans-regional economic development projects." Assembly staff and several New York activists met with Congressman Crowley in his Queens district office in late August to thank him for his initiatives and continued support. The Export-Import Bank helps American exporters meet government-supported financing competition from other countries, so that U.S. exports can compete for overseas business on the basis of price, performance and service. http://www.aaainc.org/press/10-31-01.htm Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.