alpha Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 Has US ever had such an incompetent president? He doesn't honor agreements (Kyoto), completely ignores the problems with global warming and doesn't miss an opportunity to give a tax cut to top 1% of population. It seems like if he had his way he will put an oil refinery in every corner. In addition he is not hesitating to build a space based missle defense system which could cost up to $100 billion. It's obvious that this guy is representing the special interests of oil, energy and millitary. Very sad but true. In the US the disparity between rich and poor is the greatest amongst the industrialized nations, so instead of trying to close the gap he is widening it. The self proclaimed moronic leader of "free world" thinks that by giving meager tax cuts to middle class he will be able to subsidize the rising energy costs. What a non sense. With an increase in prices of energy the small tax breaks that the middle class will get, will go directly back to the pockets of oil and energy industry. Has anyone paid attention to net income of oil companies. The profits of the largest gasoline retailer in US is up 44%. It seems like the backward South and especially the oil producing Texas will take over the progressive states in the East and California. How sad Hayastanciner jan, heto el dzer presidentic ek boxokum. Menk el merini dzern enk krak@ @ngel. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shiner Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 Is it true that the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska has only enough fossil fuel to last the US for only 6 months? That's what I heard. By the way, yesterday I watched this show called Politically Incorrect with Bill Mahr. Among others his guests were lawyer Robert Shapiro, comedian George Carlin, and a republican official. They were all mocking the republican, and accusing George Bush of catering to oil companies and private groups. They were basically saying that the increase in gas prices is the direct result of Bush trying to make more money for the oil companies. They were also implying that the oil industry is becoming more of a monopoly. They also accused Bush/Cheney for not preaching conservation. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 No it is not true. First of all, as far as the oil goes, even if ANWR has indeed 6 months supply in order that to serve the entire US, it means a huge reserve. Primarily, because it is not supposed to serve the entire US, but the nearby areas – primarily California, Oregon and Washington. Additionally, anybody who has ever studied Equilibrium Theory in Economics, would know that when the industry is operating at the limit of its capacity, it enters an unstable mode, which implies that very slight disruption of the equilibrium between supply and demand, especially under the conditions of limited storage, transportation capacity and production, may result in huge price variations. This is called “deficit,” in layman’s terms. Even if the supply in ANWR is what they claim to be, that supply would have huge impact in tranquilizing the prices, and prevent the Marginal Refineries (or the plants or Gas Companies) from pushing the prices up. Additionally, until explorations are done, nobody can tell how much oil is there. The current proposals on ANWR are not about oil extraction but of oil exploration. This is what the left opposes too – not to the extraction, since it is not on the agenda, yet, but to the explorations. Also, the presumed area to be designated for explorations is of a size of a metropolitan area airport, while ANWR is of the size of South Carolina. Additionally, people in Alaska, Republican or Democrat alike are overwhelmingly for the exploration. But the biggest lie of all is that ANWAR is not as much about oil as it is about natural gas. States like California are in a worse shape as far as the natural gas supply is concerned than the oil supply. It is known that while the oil resources in ANWR still need to be investigated, its natural gas resources are immense. Plus, there are already oil and gas exploration stations and pipelines in place on about 150 miles distance from the location subject to disputes. Plus, everybody knows that the explorations and the extractions in modern days may be done without any harm to the environment. There is a deficit of oil, natural gas and power in the US. If this deficit is not eliminated in a short period of time, it would lead to inflation, and other devastating for the global economy events. I have always thought that Bill Mahr is a complete idiot, and have found his humor very dull. The company that you mentioned (don’t know how qualified the Republican was), has no expertise in energy, whatsoever, no expertise in economics, and all represent the ultra-left of the political spectrum – bog mouths with no content – just a lot of rhetoric. The energy companies are not the enemies of the nation. They are the providers of the much critical infrastructures and are the nerve of the entire economy. Additionally, the energy companies are primarily owned by non-energy companies, that is commercial banks. Additionally, a very substantial percentage of the pension funds are the debt and equity holders in energy industry. Traditionally, the pensioners have found a safe investment heaven financing the energy companies through purchase of their corporate debt issues. Additionally, these companies are publicly traded ones, primarily, and anybody can own their shares. I have known environmentalists in Armenia and in the US. Somehow, interestingly enough, I have found that as a rule these people are incompetents and zealots. They raise issues, which they don’t understand, and they play on the emotions of the masses “these industrialists are poisoning our environment.” No environmentalist has ever done anything constructive, but to engage in poisoning of peoples minds alleging some “vast conspiracies.” One more thing. Over the very short run, conservation, as well as the tax subsidies would be the only available alternatives. But no conservation may resolve the existing problems in the strategic domain. Those who overemphasize conservation, have no idea on the scales that they are talking about, and for them, the economy is a snapshot at the current time. They don't see the dynamics of it. While every person with basic education in economics and finance, knows that money has time value, and so that to eliminate the approaching rampant problems in a decade, investments have to be made today. We all have or will have children, and we all breath the ear, or share the joy for the surrounding nature. None of us use special filters when inhaling. But some of us try to exercise reason and common sense, others find refuge in one or another form of extremism. The environmental zealots are no any difference. Just check their backgrounds. As a rule, their profession is subsidized by the society, i.e. they are not creators of national wealth, but consumers. That’s why most frequently, those “environmental outcries” go hand-to-hand with socialistic orientation, and if you look at it, they mostly align with socialistic forces. In conclusion, much along the same lines, Armenian environmentalists were advocating the shut down of the Armenian Nuclear Plant as environmentally questionable. It was a world trend to claim that Nuclear Plants are contaminating the air with radiation, even though there was no such evidence. In fact, the Nuclear Plants are the cleanest sources of power. OK, the Armenian Nuclear Plant was shot down, though for other reasons. What was the outcome – years of darkness and total demoralization of the population. This is the level of mentality of the environmentalists, in general. [ May 17, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
alpha Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 MJ, I have never claimed to be an expert on anything. After all I am just a number cruncher not a policy maker. Yet that doesn’t take away my right to give my perspective on the policies of White House. I guess incompetence is a very subjective adjective so I won’t argue on that, but I will present my point of view on the matters discussed. Here is my perspective: First and foremost, instead of promoting conservation White House is promoting generation. A report by leading scientists, three years in the making, finds that a government led program of conservation could reduce demand anywhere from 20% to 40% (TIME magazine May 21, 2000). In addition his budget cuts federal research dollars for research into alternative fuels. Guess on whose interests in generation? They ease environmental rules on coal-burning power plants. You are an expert, unlike me, and you know that coal is the worst of fossil fuel for CO2 emissions. Our so smart president has also declared that CO2 should not be treated as a pollutant. So do you think that is a smart move? In terms of tax cuts. My economic analogy about tax cuts is the following. While the middle class may get some relief, with the rising energy costs the money saved on taxes will eventually end up in the pockets of energy barons. So what effectively is he doing, is transferring federal money to oil companies. Guess whose interest it is serving? I am sure you won’t argue that closing the gap between the rich and poor can be achieved through progressive taxing system, just like it’s done in Scandinavian countries. I am not proposing total equality, which was even not achievable in communist countries. I merely ask for measures to close the increasing gap between rich and poor. Unlike you, I don’t believe that “The mission of the government is not the elimination of this gap, but creating a climate of opportunity for everybody to materialize his/her opportunities to the fullest of his/her capacity.” Mission of government is to assure the happiness of its citizens. I think “pursuit of happiness” was in the Constitution of US. The Keynesian safety net is gradually being removed, while rich are getting richer and poor are getting poor. Government should not only create the opportunities for the talented and fortunate, it should also take care of not so fortunates. I think we have passed the stage of e economic development, where economic Darwinism is applicable. In terms of military spending. Do you think when cold war is over, and US as the only hegemon in the world it is threatened by others. Creating the missile-defense system not only significantly alters the balance of power in the world; it also unnecessarily wastes taxpayers’ money. Is this a new Star Wars Era? According to TIME, space based missile-defense system will cost $100 billion. Are we getting back to era of huge budget deficits? About Kyoto: I won’t claim that I am an expert on it too, because I am not. But I know some general facts, which I will try to reiterate. What does Kyoto protocol call for? Only for a 5 percent cut in emissions by 2010. It calls on industrial nations to cut heat-trapping emissions to below 1990 levels by 2012. The only reason EU countries are not adopting the protocol is because of US. Counselor Schroeder has said about this in one of his interviews. Bush administration argues that it’s not fair to US, without presenting any valid arguments. Since you are the expert MJ can you please educate the masses why is clean environment such a bad thing and Kyoto Protocol unfair. I guess with coming of Bush administration oil interests have taken priority over everything else. Also, I didn’t mean to argue about progressivism of South or East or California. I am sure South will rise again Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 “I have never claimed to be an expert on anything.” Well, then why are you badmouthing the experts – Dick Cheney, for example? But I have not questioned your rights, but rather the validity of your arguments. About conservation and generation. No specialist in his good mind can provide and valid arguments that one may conserve 20-40% of demand. If one can conserve 2-5% annually, it would be an overwhelming success. In any case, it is not possible this year. Therefore, the only way the Fed may help the consumers is through financial policies. It is totally impossible to conserve demand in the magnitude, you claim. Or if it would become possible, per se, it will take a dozen of years. Now, normally and historically, the demand on energy has grown at 2% per annum. The bumming economy has increased this rate. You, as a person knowing the effect of compounding of rates, can asses the pace of the growth of the demand and the rate of conservation. When you refer to alternative fuels, what do you refer you? It is such a buzz word, isn’t it? Where there are alternative fuel resources, people are rushing to build plants there. But this is a very insignificant source of energy. If this was feasible, the energy companies would’ve jumped on it. No Fed is capable to finance such research better than the energy companies themselves, and the energy companies are more interested in this then the Fed, believe me. When the possibility is feasible, the energy companies use even the hen droppings as a combusting substance to generate power (I am not joking). The alternative fuels, and the wind propelled generators are solutions of Don Kihotian era. They ease environmental rules on coal-burning power plants.You are wrong again. Being 8 years in the office, the Clinton administration had not done anything along the lines of CO2. In the last month of their tenure, they issued a whole bunch of regulations, which in Russian folklore would be characterized as “Putting a pig in one’s bed.” I am sure you know what I mean. Anything that Bush administration has reversed has been related to the package of last month initiatives of the previous administration. But I think you were confusing the arsenic related “regulations,” with the CO2 regulations. What Bush has done is to back away from his campaign promises of CO2 regulations. In fact, he hasn’t done anything on that subject yet, but has refused to take immediate actions for another six months or so, until a comprehensive package is brought together. The primary reason is that the power plants are already scrambling under the heavy burden of regulations, and under such energy crisis, one has to ease their burden, rather than to force them into bankruptcy one after another. Additionally, it was true that the old generation of coal fired power plants were not environmentally clean. But it is not true about the new generation of them. They are practically as clean as the gas fired plants. Furthermore, the biggest pollutants of the environment from the CO2 stand point of view are the people and the other animals, since we all inhale oxygen, and exhale CO2. According to the “anti-CO2” logic, we can propose to put limitations on the human reproduction, for example. I think this addresses the rhetoric question of yours about the smart presidents. About the energy barons and the middle class. There is a problem. It has been created by the previous administration. Conservation is good, and should be exercised, but it cannot produce any visual results. There cannot be increased supply – no way to generate in California, or to transport. Therefore, one or another way, the prices will be high. Since one cannot fight with the shortages of supply in the short run, the only thing that one can do is to fight with the prices hikes. It would have devastating effect on the strategic developments from the point of view of investors’ confidence to impose price caps. In fact, the fundamental analysis of the market will show that the price caps would only aggravate the problem over the long run. Therefore, the only thing that can be done is providing relief to the consumers in terms of tax cuts. It is not a solution, but there is no solution in the short run. Actually, I would vigorously argue with you on your argument of closing the gap between the rich and poor. What you are proposing is not to make the poor richer, but to make the rich poorer. Guess what, this “rich” are the hard working and creative people in the society. It is morally unjustifiable to punish the hard working for the sake of providing free ride to a generation of punks and irresponsible people, who wouldn’t aspire to become rich themselves, but would aspire to take the wealth of others and give it to them. I think that the gap has to be closed by encouraging the poor and giving them all the support so that they become rich. If they refuse to aspire, others should not be held responsible for their laziness. If rich are getting richer, it is not at the expense of the poor. In fact, quite the opposite – when the rich become richer, they invest their money in industry, which creates jobs for the “poor.” Additionally, the taxing system in the US is progressive, and it has always been so. It is known that about 90% of taxes are paid by about 2% of the population (my numbers may not be very accurate, but only in their appearance, and not in their substance – I may bee few percents off in one or another direction). There is no question that the government has to take care of the unfortunate. And the US does it through the welfare system, and the Social Security System. I think any resident of Glendale has hundreds of examples of this. As to the Scandinavians, they cannot be considered the business model for the world. First of all, they come from a totally different culture – it is a uniquely Scandinavian culture. Second, they don’t practice progressive tax system, or at least not as progressive as in the US, to the best of my knowledge. Whether the Swedish economic growth may be sustained for the long-term – we have to see it, yet. But it is evident that their system is a closed system, and they are making a substantial profit by tapping into the American markets, while keeping their markets under tight control. With all this, they bash the US. About the military. If you have followed the discussions, the current US Administration claims that he cold war is indeed over, and it is substantially cutting the military budget, which is raising an uproar from the Democrats – how funny the world has become. You might also recall that during the presidential campaign, Gore used to brag (along with Liberman) that he allocates more money for the military, then Bush does. Currently, Liberman and the other liberal democrats bash the administration as an “irresponsible” one for cutting the defense budget (when you make your allegations, I just wonder where do you take your information from). This administration has increased the, military budget in one dimension so far- giving a necessary pay raise tot eh military. As to the space program, I am not a specialist in it, but I can tell you what their arguments are. They say a real threat of international terrorism and random and non-state level missile attack by terrorists and rogue states. This is what they propose to be ready against. Additionally, they claim that they would be ready to share this system even with Russia, and their other allies. What is wrong about it? Now, if you are claiming that the $100 billion anti-missile endeavor is going to throw the US into an era of budget deficits, when the nation is floated with surpluses, and when the administration is taking the most fiscally conservative steps, by fighting with the liberal to hold the rate of growth of the federal budget at 4% (basically almost the inflation rate), I have to just wonder why are you so misinformed? Is it because you are interested only in select and incorrect information, or is it because you just don’t care to investigate, though are ready to throw around allegations.About Kyoto… The primary emissions producers in the world are the third-world countries – India, China, Indonesia, Pakistan, Russia, some Eastern European countries, etc. The USA is one of the environmentally cleanest industrial countries of the world. Imposing stringent restrictions on the US, and not having any such leverages on the real polluters of the environment puts a disproportionate burden on the US. It is unfair, and it makes no sense from the pint of view of world economy and the world pollution. Europeans always like to hide in the back of the US. There is nothing new about that – whether it is contributing military assistance or military presence even in their back yard, or providing monetary contribution to the international monetary organizations. What is unexpected of their behavior regarding Kyoto? Isn’t it convenient hiding behind the US one more time?Since you are the expert MJ can you please educate the masses why is clean environment such a bad thing and Kyoto Protocol unfair.I think anybody would agree that this statement of your is a pure demagoguery, which is another unexpected thing to hear from you. I guess with coming of Bush administration oil interests have taken priority over everything else.This is another evidence of demagoguery. Since his coming to the office, his administration has taken on the issues that the previous administration has not only not tried to resolve, but has blocked from any attempt to resolve them. This concerns to the education agenda, Medicare, social security, energy policy, restructuring of the defense to a post-Cold War era, etc. All I can do is to conclude that you are getting your information either from highly partisan sources, or for whatever reasons, this is the information that you are searching deliberately. As to the rising of the South, I would not comment on it, since it is not a remark on the merits. But I have a question for you: have you ever been outside Los Angeles? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
alpha Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 MJ, I have to admit, you provide interesting arguments, which make a lot of sense (you basically preach social Darwinism, in contrast to my humanism). One thing I don’t understand is such a negative tone from you and your personal attacks. I thought the forum is for discussions, not personal attacks. I don’t think I have personally attacked neither you nor your intelligence. I really don’t appreciate the accusations of demagoguery brought against me. I cannot make any counter arguments when the opposing side is debating not only my views, but also my personality. So unless we can agree that it won’t get personal allow me to not bring my counter arguments. By the way in terms of me being outside of Los Angeles, what can I say I just got back from Hawaii? ALOHA!!!! I might have not traveled in half the places you have, but I have been in many parts of the world. By the way do you ever take a joke, and not take things so serious. Yes, South will rise again, and that’s not based on merit just observations. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 quote:Originally posted by BTac:Is it true that the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska has only enough fossil fuel to last the US for only 6 months? That's what I heard.By the way, by some other estimates, there is enough oil in AWR to substitute the oil imports from Saudi Arabia in the next 30 years. In any case, no investor is crazy to invest in ANWR, if the volume of available oil is not substantial. Investors don't finance pipeline, refinery and storage constructions for 6 months exploitation. This argument of "6 months" is just being used by people, who would not stop at any dirty tactics to advance their extremism. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 17, 2001 Report Share Posted May 17, 2001 Dear Alpha, When you pose a rhetoric question to me “tell as why is the clean air so bad,” I think it implicitly alleges that I am advocating “dirty air,” and that’s why I have felt it is sort of demagoguery. As to the social Darwinism, and humanism. I don’t think what you advocate is called humanism. It is simply called Socialism. To the contrary, I think the US is one of the most humanistic societies and countries in the world. And, normally, I try to avoid and “isms.” Believe me, I am not negative against you. It is just my expectations are much higher for you. None of the arguments that you have made in this threat look like originating from you. And not only I have not questioned your intelligence, but to the contrary I find you to be quite intelligent. That’s why I have been puzzled while reading your arguments. I think you are not right when telling I have argued your personality. I have questioned your sources of information, or your deliberateness in studying these issues, and giving overly emotional assessments to people without studying their policies, just because you don’t like them for whatever reasons. I am glad that you have been in many parts of the world. Have you been in Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Carolinas, etc. I mean the South East USA? If you really care about the environment, then you would have such an appreciation for all these places. Besides, Georgia, for example, in particular Atlanta, is the technological center of the South-East. It is such a beauty – something in the middle of a resort and urban area, with the qualities of both, and the people are much more cultured than those in California or New York, by the way. And by the way, I do take jokes – have an unlimited capacity for it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 18, 2001 Report Share Posted May 18, 2001 Alpha, Contrary to your allegations, I have to claim that I find the current President one of the most competent and capable executives. As it relates to Kyoto, the document itself has been a demonstration of incompetence, arbitrariness, and was antiscientific. No state in the world, except Romania, has ratified that treaty. Additionally, that treaty was dead before the arrival to the US Senate, way before the latest Presidential elections. 95 out of 100 Senators have voted no on the treaty. I just cannot understand what makes you to allege the things that you have not studied. I am surprised by your the tax cut and the oil refinery assessment statements. Off all the people in this forum you, as an economist, should not make such misleading and incorrect statements. It is very easy to throw such unfounded allegations as someone representing the oil, energy and military complexes. The tranquility in energy markets and the establishment of equilibrium between the supply and demand is the most fundamental need of the entire economy of the US, and any other industrial country. It is the obligation of the president, first of all, to see that that kind of equilibrium is established. Additionally, due to the transportation constraints and the costs, no equilibrium is possible in the oil sector without new generation of refineries. Moreover, contrary to the past generation of refineries, new refineries can be environmentally much cleaner. Needless to say that, if the US economy goes does, the economy of the world does so. As to the military complex, if the President of a country doesn’t represent the military, who should do it? Could you give me one example of a responsible government, which has more than marginal role in the world affairs, that doesn’t represent the military? It is his job and the sworn duty to represent the military. I think you are taking his statements on the tax cut subsidization of the rising energy costs out of the context. For the short run, that is one of the few marginal measures to help the consumers. For the long run, the only solution is the refineries. You oppose both, which makes me wonder whether you have thought enough about the issues from the professional points of view, or are you just taking out your whatever frustrations, and no matter what, you just want to bash those who you don’t like, no matter what they would do? Your statements also show that you have no real understanding of the energy industry. Of all the industries in the US, the energy industry hearts most. The absolute majority of the energy industry participants are registering substantial loses, or no growth. It is reflected in their financials, if you would desire to check them. The few companies in the energy industry who register substantial “profits,” are in the development business and not in the marketing business, i.e. those are the companies in the business of power plant developments for example. Even those, who seemingly make huge money on the surface, are not happy with the situation. For one thing, due to the high profile defaults that you might’ve heard of, they are unable to collect their receivables. As a professional in the energy industry, as much as such statement of mine may be credible in your eyes, let me inform you that nobody benefits from the current state of the affairs in energy markets. Even those who for short while make substantial profits, would prefer lower, but steady profits, so that to have the necessary certainty when making strategic investment decisions. If the climate that is present would continue, and if the left leaning people would prevail in this argument, the future in some 10 years would be devastating, because nobody would make the decisions that need to be made today, so that to take the horrendous risks idiosyncratic to the energy markets, if the expected reward doesn’t justify it. Remember that all the energy developments are capital-intensive ventures, and their planning requires certainty in the regulatory and market domains. This is basic economics. As to the tax cut being given to the top 1%, give me a break. You are smarter than that…And of all the people, you and me know perfectly well what the outcome of the “elimination of the gap between the rich and the poor is.” We have experienced one such experience. The mission of the government is not the elimination of this gap, but creating a climate of opportunity for everybody to materialize his/her opportunities to the fullest of his/her capacity. The outcome of any attempt of “eliminating the gap” between the poor and rich has meant robbery, genocide, mass killings, exile, etc. The inequality is not created by this president, or by one or another political force. The (social) inequality is a fundamental premise of the world history. The only equality may be under Communism, that is if we believe it is morally justifiable and realistic. Additionally, in no way states like Texas are more backward than, say California. As you know, California has been once called Wild West. As much as I have explored it, and as much as I have lived in many states and cities, California is the worst place if it is to be judged outside the SF-San Jose area - both culturally and quality of lifewise, speaking. And the booming industries of the Southern States attract the best professionals in the nation, and in many ways lead its technological progress. Sorry for the tone. With all due respect, I just was taken by surprise to read such a partisan and shallow analysis from you. [ May 17, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
alpha Posted May 20, 2001 Report Share Posted May 20, 2001 MJ, thanks for your kind words. Now when I am back in town from a long and exhausting trip I can reply to you. I haven't been in South East US. The most Southern place I have been is North Virginia, close to DC (although I plan to visit Florida soon). You asked me about my sources. Usually they are TIME magazine, Wall Street Journal, Financial Times (it's my favorite newspaper, and the only one I read daily), LA Times, NY Times, Business Week, Forbes and Fortune. I think you'd agree with me that these are all credible sources. The 20%-40% conservation number I got directly from last weeks TIME (you can check it yourself). So I wouldn't question its validity. You are right about my ideas being socialist. A lot of my coworkers used to call me that (and that's not a compliment in investment banks). I am a strong advocate for cleaner environment and social justice (meaning less disparity between rich and poor). I think social Darwinism is only applicable in third world countries, where they are in desperate need for investments (this is even applicable to our motherland). the biggest pollutants of the environment from the CO2 stand point of view are the people and the other animals, since we all inhale oxygen, and exhale CO2. According to the “anti-CO2” logic, we can propose to put limitations on the human reproduction, for example. MJ I think both us know what I mean by CO2 regulation. I am glad you didn't go far enough to claim that CO2 is very healthy. I think you'd agree with me that excessive CO2 levels are responsible for global warming. And it's really sad that the leader of free world is backing away from his campaign promises of CO2 regulations. Why are you such an ardent defender of an administration who defends only the interests of small part of the population (the ones that sponsored them to finance their campaign - mainly Texas oilmen, and big business). Today when I was reading Financial Times I was surprised to find out about their idiotic plans to abolish corporate taxes, and pass them on to people. Read the article below, and you will understand what I am talking about. O’Neill lays out radical vision for taxBy Amity Shlaes in WashingtonPublished: May 18 2001 Paul O'Neill, US Treasury Secretary, has laid out a vision for a radical reform of the US tax structure, including a sweeping revision of the Social Security - or public pension - system and abolition of corporate income tax and capital gains tax on businesses. In an interview with the FT at his Treasury office, Mr O'Neill espoused changes that would reach far beyond the legislation currently before Congress. As the Senate moved ahead with the Bush administration's initial $1,350bn tax reduction plan, which Mr O'Neill expects to be signed into law next Friday, he expanded on his previous piecemeal attacks on America's tax system. The present system was "an abomination" that required changes to its "very structure". " Not only am I committed to working on this issue, the President [George W Bush] is also intrigued about the possibility of fixing this mess," said Mr O' Neill. One of the most important moves, he suggested, would be abolition of taxation on companies. Corporate income tax, the main form of tax on US businesses, accounts for 10 per cent of federal revenues and has a top rate of 35 per cent. Among other controversial ideas, Mr O'Neill questioned the the guarantees the government provides for full public subsidy of senior citizens' health care and retirement programmes. "Able-bodied adults who have the ability to earn income have an obligation not to pass part of their own responsibility on to a broader population," he said. His remarks are bound to reverberate in Washington, where speaking about reductions in elderly care programmes has been taboo. Mr O'Neill's remarks reflect growing determination in the Bush administration to show its willingness to propose radical change to try to secure growth. Abolishing corporate tax would inevitably lead to higher personal income taxes, but Mr O'Neill believes such a move would reduce the overall tax burden and promote economic growth. Current corporate tax levels - and their administrative costs - were too high, he said. The system would work better if the government "collected taxes in a more direct way from the people, who were paying the taxes in any event". Mr O'Neill said simplification of the tax code would also improve US global competitiveness. "It would certainly make us more formidable if we had a simplification of this sort." Any increase in personal income tax would undoubtedly provoke strong voter opposition. Mr O'Neill, however, says he "absolutely" wants to eliminate corporate income tax. He also wants to do away with capital gains taxes on businesses, and indicated the administration was prepared to put this on a shorter-term agenda. It is highly unlikely that other members of the Bush administration share every aspect of Mr O'Neill's reformist visions. But the fact that one of the most senior cabinet members would lay out such a detailed and radical programme is a sign that the administration has not been deterred by opposition to its initial tax-cut plan. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 20, 2001 Report Share Posted May 20, 2001 Alpha, Some of these sources may be credible, but others would hardly qualify as so – in particular the Times Magazine. Additionally, Wall Street Journal’s credibility may be frequently questioned. Additionally, neither in Forbes nor in Fortune magazines you can get the information that you have aluded to us earlier. I have to also add that I am not an advocate of what you call Social Darwinist – I am not any “ist.” Social justice requires implementation of opportunity for all. In now way expropriation of ones property, in Russian terms, “raskulachivanie” is a way of establishing social justice. Additionally, social justice doesn’t mean equal wealth for all. People are different with their abilities, the depth of their thinking, their working habits, their accomplishments, etc. The progress of the society requires adequate rewarding mechanism for adequate achievements. It is very hard not to advocate clean environment. You say again “I am glad you didn't go far enough to claim that CO2 is very healthy.” Why do you have to make such statements? Does it help you to make your case? You had eight years to demand implementation of CO2 regulations, but you didn’t do it. But this President has been in the office for just a little bit more than 100 days, and you are cornering him for not implementing his campaign promise regarding the CO2 regulations. He has not said he has not going to do it. He has said that all the regulations would be considered as a package deal, and he would revisit the issue of CO2 in six months. As to the Global Warming…. There has not been a single persuasive studies of this topic. Whether there is such phenomenon or not – it is not clear to me. This doesn’t mean that there isn’t. However, I would like to be familiarized with any serious studies that are there. From my side, I can attest to the following: Currently I have an ongoing project, which I am doing for an Energy company. The project involves full statistical analysis of maximum daily temperature in 48 cities in the US for the last 20 years. I am expecting to get similar data for 198 cities in the US. I can report you that so far, I have not seen an element of evidence suggesting “Global Warming” throughout the US in the last 20 years. I would keep you informed on the more comprehensive data, when I get it. Why are you such an ardent defender of an administration who defends only the interests of small part of the population (the ones that sponsored them to finance their campaign - mainly Texas oilmen, and big business). I think your statement above is built off of a false premise. This administration doesn’t represent the oil industry. If the oil industry has supported his candidacy – it is natural. Imagine that Gore would’ve succeeded. The energy problems of the US in the next decade would have made the US a third world country, not speaking about the compromise of the national sovereignty of the US. It is always good to have a competent administration, rather than an incompetent one. That’s why I ardently support this administration. I think never in the history of the US, the White House has had such a Five-Star Administration as it has currently. And the managerial skills of the president are obvious – he is being able to make the team work. Note that, normally, it is very difficult to have teams consisting of more than one five-star personalities function due to the multiple strong opinions. And what has been accomplished in 100 days by this administration is remarkable. He has been able to break through the deadlock in such sensitive issues as tax cuts and education. I have heard about the plan you call idiotic. First of all, it is not a plan, yet, but a thought. Your own reference claims that “It is highly unlikely that other members of the Bush administration share every aspect of Mr O'Neill's reformist visions.” Second, why is it idiotic? I think it is a very fair plan, assuming it would allow to collect enough revenues for the functioning of the Federal Government. Why should the shareholders be taxed twice? Why not to have just sales tax? Wouldn’t it be fairer? Why not to have people pay taxes based on the volume of merchandises they buy? I think the politization of the economic structure is one of the bloodiest things in the world history. And I have an impression that this is what you are proposing. P.S. As we have all learned in grade school, the best way of fighting CO2 is cultivating trees and other plants. I am cultivating about 70 trees in my front and back yards, and numerous plants. Are you doing any of this? Do you voluntere in any parks, etc, to promote any sorts of tree programs? [ May 20, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:No it is not true.Could be true. Nobody knows until they explore. I have heard the same numbers as well. The sad thing is that once they have the permission to explore the permission to extract is much easier to get.Also there are no deficits in Gas or Oil in the west as officials will lead you to believe. We have a huge increase in the price of gas because the so called "summer additives" added to burn gas much cleaner is at a shortage. In fact the price of barrel of oil is about 20% less than this time last year, yet we are paying record high prices at the pump.Gas is another monster story where few companies mostly in Texas have colluded together and have cut the supply to bring the price up.In fact we do not even have a shortage in electricity. If all our power plants worked at capacity we would have an extra supply, however they "seem" to have problems every single day and are down for repairs far more than usual. quote:Additionally, people in Alaska, Republican or Democrat alike are overwhelmingly for the exploration.What is good for Alaskans does not necessarily mean it is the best solution for the entire country. quotePlus, everybody knows that the explorations and the extractions in modern days may be done without any harm to the environment.remember Valdez? quote:There is a deficit of oil, natural gas and power in the US.There are no shortage. There are just greedy companies who give millions of dollars in bonuses to employees and management and tell the public that there is a shortage to just raise the price.If this deficit is not eliminated in a short period of time, it would lead to inflation, and other devastating for the global economy events. This exploration is NOT short term. There is nothing that Bush or any of his cronies can do that will be a "short period" solution.I find Bill Mahr to be a very funny comedian, but he is noting more than a comedian. George Carlin was hilarious on that show as well.MJ, It is my belief that Energy companies(mostly from Texas) are the enemies in this situation that we are in. Cities like Los Angeles, Glendale, Pasadena, Burbank and other who are producing their own power are over producing and selling to the state(these are the same government owned agencies that are suppose to be and inefficient and not be able to do as well a job as the private sector)(at least that is what our republican friends will tell us) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 MJ, why do you knock conservation? What has caused the so called power crisis in California? How come we have such a "shortage" of power in California this past 12 months as compare to the last 12 months prior to that. The energy use has only gone up by 4%. Yet there seems to be a HUGE shortage? If it was the 4% that conservation would work, however as I said in my previous post, I do not believe there is a shortage. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 I knock conservation? Where did you get it? All I have said is the conservation, while being necessary, is not a solution. Even 2% conservation would be an overwhelming success, and that is very hard to achieve, at least for this summer. I just say that when you make statements, you have to first study the issue. The conservation is exercised by the energy companies as much as it is possible. For example, the rolling blockouts are a way of conservation. I wonder what would’ve your attitude been if you were to reside in Northern California. How come we have such a "shortage" of power in California this past 12 months as compare to the last 12 months prior to that. The energy use has only gone up by 4%. The answer is elementary. Let’s assume that the total peak demand in California in the year 2000 was 95,000 MWH while the available supply was 100,000 MWH (my numbers are not accurate, but the qualitative picture they portray is accurate). The demand on power grows in average by 1.8-2% a year. For the sake of the ease of calculations, let’s take 2% (wouldn’t make qualitative difference). That means that in the year 2001, the peak demand would be 114,000 MWH. If no plants are built, that means that there is already 14,000 MWH shortage. And I am not taking into consideration all the required margins for the purpose of the reliability and stability of the system. Now, you can imagine what is going to happen a year later, if no plants are built – much more severe shortages. Now, let’s assume that you can conserve 2% of the demand (I am highly suspicious of it, though). But the growth of 2% is an annual growth rate, not a total growth. The conservation of 2% is a one time (or almost one time event). How are you going to deal with it. I should also say that it is very funny when you say there is no shortage of power in California. You should ask about it the residents of Bay area. Here is the projection (not mine) throughout the US: So that not to face power shortages in the US in the next 20 years, in average one new plant a week has to be brought online. Take it as written on the stone, if you have open mind for it. Otherwise the result is going to be a tremendous economic downturn. Unfortunately, the environmentalism in the US (and perhaps elsewhere) has become a religion. People claim things that they have no idea about, they just say “I believe there is no shortage.” “I believe we can conserve 40% of our demand,” etc. The question is what studies are your beliefs based on? The bottom line is – you cannot have your computers running in the future, and not have new power plants built. And by the way, the computerization of the industry accounts for the most significant share of the increased demand. I will reply to your previous material in a while – have to take care of few things, now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 Could be true. Nobody knows until they explore. I have heard the same numbers as well. The sad thing is that once they have the permission to explore the permission to extract is much easier to get. Isn’t this what one has to admit with honesty? Even if the resources are huge (to which some preliminary studies attest to), the environmentalists don’t want it to be extracted. Then why all this BS about the 6 month supply? Also there are no deficits in Gas or Oil in the west as officials will lead you to believe. We have a huge increase in the price of gas because the so called "summer additives" added to burn gas much cleaner is at a shortage. In fact the price of barrel of oil is about 20% less than this time last year, yet we are paying record high prices at the pump.Azat, why do you make such unsubstantiated statements? Because you feel that way, or because you know? The summer additives are not practiced in the west, but in Illionis. The price of the barrel of the oil being purchased in the International markets is not the entire picture. That oil is crude oil, which I am sure you know cannot be used in cars, etc. So that it becomes gasoline usable in the cars, it has to be refined. Therefore, if there are not enough refineries, even if the price of crude oil would be $10 per barrel, it is going to create deficit of gasoline, which is going to naturally push the prices up. This is elementary, I think. I live in Georgia, and I enjoy the lowest gasoline prices in the nation. You know why? For two reasons – there are a lot of refineries in South East, and the State has not imposed excessive tax burden on gasoline distributors. Think of this, if Armenia is under blockade, it would not matter that the flour is inexpensive elsewhere. The prices on bread are going to be high in Armenia. Gas is another monster story where few companies mostly in Texas have colluded together and have cut the supply to bring the price up.This is an absolute bogus, Azat. And it is a very irresponsible declaration. The gas companies have not cut production. Like any other source of energy, the demand on gas also grows annually. However, for decades, no gas storage facilities and no gas pipelines have been constructed. If you cannot transport increased amounts of gas due to the limitations of pipeline capacities, it makes zero sense to produce them? Isn’t this a very robust logic? In fact we do not even have a shortage in electricity. If all our power plants worked at capacity we would have an extra supply, however they "seem" to have problems every single day and are down for repairs far more than usual.It indeed seem like you get your information from the TV comedians. What is good for Alaskans does not necessarily mean it is the best solution for the entire country.Theoretically speaking, yes. But in this particular case it is an empty declaration. Because in this particular case, it is good for Alaska and for the US. Because Alaskans don’t experience energy shortages – it is the rest of the US that does so. remember Valdez? Yes, I do remember Valdez. And your position makes the future “Valdezes” more likely. Because due to your stance, increased amounts of oil have to be brought from oversees, thus increasing the likelihood of such catastrophes. In the mean time, the transportation of oil from the domestic sources of supply through pipelines would be much safer. There are no shortage. There are just greedy companies who give millions of dollars in bonuses to employees and management and tell the public that there is a shortage to just raise the price. I think it is obvious what my reply to this decleration of yours would be. This exploration is NOT short term. There is nothing that Bush or any of his cronies can do that will be a "short period" solution. You are right. The exploration is not short term. Neither power plant development or anything else is short term. In energy markets there are no short-term solutions. There is nothing that anybody can do in the short term. It is like five years ago you had sex with a prostitute, and you caught AIDS. For five years, not being a responsible person, you felt good about it. But five years later you come to experience the results of your irresponsible lifestyle. Now, you go around and complain that the doctors are cronies, and they refuse to do anything about your condition. I find Bill Mahr to be a very funny comedian, but he is noting more than a comedian. George Carlin was hilarious on that show as well. I don’t know Carlin as a comedian, but I saw him speak in Larry King Live, recently. I think the guy is an idiot, and an ultra-socialist zealot. As to Bill Mahr’s funnyness – sorry. Have seen his comic monologs over HBO. MJ, It is my belief that Energy companies(mostly from Texas) are the enemies in this situation that we are in.Exactly. You believe in it. You have no facts, and you have not studied the issue. And perhaps this is what you have heard from your Governer, who is trying to savve his neck in the next elections, by blaming somebidy else outside California. That’s why in my previous reply to you I said the environmentalism has become religion. It is a basic fact of life – when there is deficit, the prices go up. This was the case even in the socialistic USSR. It is your responsibility to plan consciously and in a responsible manner. Living with today’s needs only, and not thinking of the future always has consequences. You (allegoric you) have been irresponsible in your youth, have not thought of your future, now live with the consequences, and don’t blame the others. Even now, you live with declarations. You say there is no shortage, when it is out of question that there is significant shortage. So when your lights go down, you just declare that the lights are on, and feel comfrtable. And when the prices go up, you just say they are not up, they are normal. You claim French and Germans are paying much higher prices. Go ahead and believe in it. Why are your beliefs one sided? Cities of LA, etc, have been smarter/luckier for the time being. They have built adequate numbers of plants. They don’t need to transmit power from elsewhere. Moreover, the Southern California has excess power supply for the time being. Then ask the Southern Californians to sell inexpensive power to North California, and don’t go for Texas. But you cannot do it, right? Why? Because, the transmission lines (in particular the so called Path 15 connecting the Southern California grid with the Northern one) doesn’t have the capacity to allow increased transmission. The same way, there is a limited capacity to bring power to Northern California from elsewhere. Don’t blame the Texan Companies, but blame your zealot and incompetent friends for not allowing to built neither electricity transmission lines, neither gas pipelines, neither oil pipelines, neither gas storage facilities, nor power plants. Now, use candles, go to work on bikes – conserve! What do you expect from the government? It is up to you to conserve. Should the administration issue an order that you conserve your usage of energy? For example, I conserve as much as I can. If in a room of my house there is no one, we would not have the lights on. I have my air conditioning system serviced every year, so that it consumes less, and I conserve in any possible way. Do you? Additionally, one of the primary power companies who sells power and gas to California at increased prices is the Calpine Corporation, which is headquartered in San Jose. It was looking for an opportunity to do the same in Texas last summer – at that time I was spending a lot of time at their Texas office. Because of the measures that the Texan government had taken before, they couldn’t materialize such opportunities. I don’t want to make this positing a lecture on energy markets. Besides, I am a professional consultant for energy markets, and it is unprofessional of me to give such lectures for free. However, out of our friendship, if you still are interested in it, I can give you also additional explanation on the subject through private messaging. Finally, this year, we all are very lucky becasue it has been abnormally cool year, so far. Wait and see what hapens next year, if we assume that the weather pattern goes back into its normal trend. Wait and see what is going to happen in California and New York. [ May 21, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:I wonder what would’ve your attitude been if you were to reside in Northern California. If I lived in Northern California I would be pissed at my current and previous governors for getting us into this mess and the 2 companies that screwed up the whole system.The answer is elementary. Let’s assume that the total peak demand in California in the year 2000 was 95,000 MWH while the available supply was 100,000 MWH (my numbers are not accurate, but the qualitative picture they portray is accurate). The demand on power grows in average by 1.8-2% a year. For the sake of the ease of calculations, let’s take 2% (wouldn’t make qualitative difference). That means that in the year 2001, the peak demand would be 114,000 MWH.MJ, I am sorry, but how did you get the 114 figure. I understand that the umbers are inaccurate, but how did you go from 95 to 114?I should also say that it is very funny when you say there is no shortage of power in California.All I am saying is that the shortage is artificially created by the power suppliers. We did not have a single "stage 2" or "stage 3" power alerts the 12 months prior to this mess that we are in now, yet in the last 12 months we have had many. What caused this?Take it as written on the stone, if you have open mind for it. Otherwise the result is going to be a tremendous economic downturn.I have an open mind and I am all for building new and improved power plants, including one in my back yard.There are 4 new power plants that are coming online this year in california. If the power plants did NOT take all the money that they made from deregulation and send it to their parent companies and had invested some of that money back into building and improving their plants we would not be in this situation.Here is something small for you to read:~~~~~~Some of the power generators complaining loudest about California's environmental obstacle course have used the system to hold up the licensing of a competitor. According to Energy Commission documents, 22 energy companies have intervened in 12 proposals by competitors. Some become formal "interveners" simply to glean information. But others aggressively use their status to hire lawyers, file objections and cross-examine competitors in evidentiary hearings. Of the 21 power plants proposed for licensing since 1997, competing companies have intervened in 12 proposals, slowing the process in at least four situations. Six years ago, the Public Utilities Commission ordered the state's investor-owned utilities to contract with private companies that were planning to build 1,400 megawatts of new plants. Southern California Edison objected, and appealed the order to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, arguing it would "not need this power until 2005." FERC sided with Edison, and the proposed plants never were built. The following year, the state passed its deregulation legislation, and that slowed plant construction even more, said John Tiner, a professor emeritus of electrical engineering at Johns Hopkins University. "Once deregulation became a factor, the power utilities stopped building plants, with good reason. They knew they would have to divest," he said. Since 1996, the California Energy Commission has tried to speed up new generation with its "one-stop-shop" for plant permits. The result: The commission has licensed nine big power plants, totaling 6,278 megawatts, said Claudia Chandler, an assistant director of the commission. Six of those plants are under construction. Firms are formally seeking licenses for 12 others, she said. When their interests are threatened, energy companies also throw their muscle around. (Stuart Leavenworth and Chris Bowman, Sacramento Bee 1/8/01 "All kinds have foiled new plants") "Assertions that environmental regulations were holding back power production were 'absolutely false.'" - spokesman for Houston- based Reliant Energy, which operates four Southern California plants. Nor, apparently, did environmental regulations play much of a role in California's failure to build new plants in the years since deregulation. In fact, environmentalists generally favored deregulation, because they thought it would lead to the construction of new plants, which would be gas-fired and hence cleaner than the coal-fired plants that still supply much of the state's power. (Paul Krugman, New York Times January 31, 2001 "Smog and Mirrors") People think that the crisis was caused by a sudden increase in demand.The facts are that the utilities took an unusually large amount of capacity off-line for what it described as ``routine maintenance.'' At the same time, members of the power-generator cartel also began to systematically withhold power. Ostensibly, this was done because the cartel feared that any power sold to the near-bankrupt utilities on credit would be money lost. The practical effect, however, was to drive wholesale electricity rates through the roof at the same time that the now-artificial electricity shortages triggered rolling blackouts throughout the state. (Peter Navarro, Pioneer Press 1/30/ 01 Navarro is an associate professor of economics and public policy at the University of California, Irvine. Distributed by the Los Angeles Times-Washington Post News Service.)~~~~~ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 MJ, I am sorry, but how did you get the 114 figure. I understand that the umbers are inaccurate, but how did you go from 95 to 114?My apologies. Instead of 2% I had punched 20% in the numbers. But it doesn’t change the essence of the issue, given that my numbers were hypothetical, and several thousand MWH have to be allocated for reliability margin and ancillary services purposes. All I am saying is that the shortage is artificially created by the power suppliers. We did not have a single "stage 2" or "stage 3" power alerts the 12 months prior to this mess that we are in now, yet in the last 12 months we have had many. What caused this?You are wrong. The explanation is clear. 1. Growth of the Demand compared to the last year (it is not sudden – this growth is steady); 2. Law rain levels, due to which the hydropower plants could not be operated at their maximum capacities;3. Plant outages – these things happen every-now-and-then. I have an open mind and I am all for building new and improved power plants, including one in my back yard.That’s good. There are 4 new power plants that are coming online this year in california. If the power plants did NOT take all the money that they made from deregulation and send it to their parent companies and had invested some of that money back into building and improving their plants we would not be in this situation.Actually, it is not quite correct. It seems like they are behind the schedule. I think only one of them is guaranteed this summer. I would reply to the article you have pasted, later. There is some truth in it, but it is grossly exaggerated and the interpretations are not valid. Here is the short answer: if there is a price gouging or collusion, as those who would like to get clean out of the mess that they have created claim, there are anti-trust laws, and anti-profiteering laws, and the State of California can litigate them. And there have been such cases. My friend and business partner is a recognized expert providing expert testimony in the courts, when these things happen. Here is what he says: “You would be surprised at the incompetence of the politicians.” I was watching a program on C-SPAN, few months ago, where the politicians and the business executives – among them the executives of PG&E, were trying to come up with solutions (the one that failed). I was astonished at the stupidity and the incompetence of one of the senators in the commission – the senator of the Washington state. An I thought to myself that if the solution of the problems is left to this kinds of nincompoops, we would face nothing but misery. Now, I need to do some work, and when I have time, will comment on the article you have pasted. [ May 21, 2001: Message edited by: MJ ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:Azat, why do you make such unsubstantiated statements? Because you feel that way, or because you know? The summer additives are not practiced in the west, but in Illionis.This is very much so true in California. If you do not believe me ask someone on this board to drive to their local Unocal station(i only use Unocal 76, but I am sure this is true for others as well) and read the black and white sticker on the pump itself. Unocal used MTBE(I do not know what it is) to have cleaning burning fuel. This is what is in short supply.The price of the barrel of the oil being purchased in the International markets is not the entire picture. That oil is crude oil, which I am sure you know cannot be used in cars, etc. So that it becomes gasoline usable in the cars, it has to be refined. Therefore, if there are not enough refineries, even if the price of crude oil would be $10 per barrel, it is going to create deficit of gasoline, which is going to naturally push the prices up. This is elementary, I think. I live in Georgia, and I enjoy the lowest gasoline prices in the nation. You know why? For two reasons – there are a lot of refineries in South East, and the State has not imposed excessive tax burden on gasoline distributors. Think of this, if Armenia is under blockade, it would not matter that the flour is inexpensive elsewhere. The prices on bread are going to be high in Armenia.I am smarter that you make me sound to be. We had the same taxes last year the same capacity as last year, maybe a 5%(I am not sure) increase in demand, yet the price of gas is sky high. It is MOSTLY due to the shortage of the additives. I can get sources that tell you that if you want.This is an absolute bogus, Azat. And it is a very irresponsible declaration. The gas companies have not cut production.I once again never said that they cut production, they only cut the supply. It is not bogus. They have used the pipeline to send other fuels to other places thus cutting the supply of gas.Like any other source of energy, the demand on gas also grows annually. However, for decades, no gas storage facilities and no gas pipelines have been constructed. If you cannot transport increased amounts of gas due to the limitations of pipeline capacities, it makes zero sense to produce them? Isn’t this a very robust logic? MJ, it is super expensive to store natural gas because to store it they have to almost make it to liquid form and thus it becomes expensive to store in masses. And just like power, gas is almost used on the spot or is wasted. It is the size and the use of the pipeline that has increased the price.It indeed seem like you get your information from the TV comedians. That is a stupid thing to say. Unfortunately I think you have been listening to sublibibibibal messages from Mr. Bush. Yes, I do remember Valdez. And your position makes the future “Valdezes” more likely. Because due to your stance, increased amounts of oil have to be brought from oversees, thus increasing the likelihood of such catastrophes. In the mean time, the transportation of oil from the domestic sources of supply through pipelines would be much safer.What part of Valdez was a foreign company or foreign territory or anything that you said in the above statement. How does it make it less likely? Just for your information, Valdez is in Alaska(you know the state up north) and it was Exxon(you know the largest US company) that caused the problem. I think it is obvious what my reply to this decleration of yours would be. What would your answer be?You think that prices are high because of the free wholesale market of electricity I am sure.The fact is that six investigations by state and federal agencies are underway, seeking evidence of collusion or other illegal behavior. Multimillion-dollar lobbying efforts in Sacramento are intensifying. (Nancy Vogel, LA Times 12/9/00 "How State's Consumers Lost With Electricity Deregulation.")You are right. The exploration is not short term. Neither power plant development or anything else is short term. In energy markets there are no short-term solutions. There is nothing that anybody can do in the short term.I agree 100%. But there are power plants being built. My previous post shows more info about this.It is like five years ago you had sex with a prostituteI can't believe she called and told you about this. I have to have a talk with her. I don’t know Carlin as a comedian, but I saw him speak in Larry King Live, recently. I think the guy is an idiot, and an ultra-socialist zealot. As to Bill Mahr’s funnyness – sorry. Have seen his comic monologs over HBO. This is why we each have different tastes in life. I like them both. Here is a link from our humor section on some one liners from Carlin. http://armenians.com/cgi-bin/forum/ultimat...c&f=14&t=000057 Exactly. You believe in it. You have no facts, and you have not studied the issue. And perhaps this is what you have heard from your Governer, who is trying to savve his neck in the next elections, by blaming somebidy else outside California. That’s why in my previous reply to you I said the environmentalism has become religion. It is a basic fact of life – when there is deficit, the prices go up.MJ, I have facts, but my facts are not from the "Republican Gazette" or the "Bush Daily" so you would just stand here and tell me that they are not good sources. I am neither and environmentalist nor am I not for building for more plants for searching for oil, but the situation in California should not be used as an example of a shortage, but rater as an example of both corporations and government(including the current governor) screwing things up.I will not be in the dark like many in California because my little city has a public run power plant that is doing a MUCH better job than the private corporations who only care about their shareholders. Plus all 4 cities that I mentioned are selling power back to the state on the spot market. ANd it had nothing to do with them being lucky. It was smart thinkers that built enough power into their system to make sure their city did not go dark. Do you need me to get you sources that say that Glendale, Pasadena, Burbank and DWP from LA are selling power back too? But you are right in saying that we in Southern California cannot produce enough to supply all the energy needs of Northern California. And who is at fault here. The environmentalists who would not allow for new power plants. Yes partially, maybe major blame can go to them. But one cannot forget all the money that SCE and PG&E sent back to the parent companies and sat on the sideline trying to see what was going to happen with deregulation without building any new plants. That is the truth. they even blocked other companies from building plants.Don’t blame the Texan Companies, but blame your zealot and incompetent friends for not allowing to built neither electricity transmission lines, neither gas pipelines, neither oil pipelines, neither gas storage facilities, nor power plants.MJ, you are looking at this issue from only one side.I don’t want to make this positing a lecture on energy markets. Besides, I am a professional consultant for energy markets, and it is unprofessional of me to give such lectures for free. However, out of our friendship, if you still are interested in it, I can give you also additional explanation on the subject through private messaging. i don't mind getting lectured by you as long as you don't mind me taking shots at your theories. Finally, this year, we all are very lucky becasue it has been abnormally cool year, so far. Wait and see what hapens next year, if we assume that the weather pattern goes back into its normal trend. Wait and see what is going to happen in California and New York.I don't know what will happen in NY, but IF all 4 new plants come online in CA we will be fine, especially since there are 2 more coming online in 2002. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 21, 2001 Report Share Posted May 21, 2001 MJ, Should we move this conversation to be under a new topic since this has nothing to do with the current topic? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
alpha Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 I believe that you'd agree with me MJ if I said that Economist is one of the most credible magazines. The following link http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?...story_id=624258 outlines the failed policies of our imcompetent president, that he tries to implement his failed policies in Texas on Federal level. Unfortunately it doesn't mention the failures of the "energy policies". Also, why do you attack the competency of a person who makes the counter argument, or challenge the validity of his/her resources. I am ready to provide all the resources that I mentioned and stand by my numbers (TIME is also one of the most reputable magazines and 20-40% conservation number was obtained from there). Lets go back to where the whole energy debacle started. The energy deregulation was signed by notorious Republican governer Wilson, who signed the bills into a law against public outcry, but with consant lobbying of oil companies. Governer Davis just protects public from high energy prices. If you carefully follow his policies you'd notice that he was ready to bail out both energy companies from bankruptcy, but P&GE didn't want to settle for it. Albeit the result was a bankruptcy. Now I will point out one of the companies that I used to cover SCE. Southern California Edison is set up as a holding company for Edison International, which is financially well diversified company. By setting up as a subsidiary, Edison International bought the upside of Southern California Edison's profits, which sends its profit to its parent. Yet when deregulation did not go as planned all of a sudden Southern California Edison was threatening with bankruptcy, and was asking for increased prices on electricity. These corporations know how to go after public's money. There is also an investigation with oil and energy providing companies on price gauging. Duke has even secretly agreed to settle it, but when the whole deal became public state bailed out of it. That's what free reign of oilmen and energy providers does to public, when energy and oil companies are left unchecked. In one of the recent interviews Dick Cheney was advocating for less regulation of industry and no federal intervention, but as experience showed in California regulation of energy sector works for public interest. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 quote:Originally posted by alpha:I believe that you'd agree with me MJ if I said that Economist is one of the most credible magazines. The following link http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?...story_id=624258 outlines the failed policies of our imcompetent president, that he tries to implement his failed policies in Texas on Federal level. Unfortunately it doesn't mention the failures of the "energy policies".Also, why do you attack the competency of a person who makes the counter argument, or challenge the validity of his/her resources. I am ready to provide all the resources that I mentioned and stand by my numbers (TIME is also one of the most reputable magazines and 20-40% conservation number was obtained from there). Lets go back to where the whole energy debacle started. The energy deregulation was signed by notorious Republican governer Wilson, who signed the bills into a law against public outcry, but with consant lobbying of oil companies. Governer Davis just protects public from high energy prices. If you carefully follow his policies you'd notice that he was ready to bail out both energy companies from bankruptcy, but P&GE didn't want to settle for it. Albeit the result was a bankruptcy.Now I will point out one of the companies that I used to cover SCE. Southern California Edison is set up as a holding company for Edison International, which is financially well diversified company. By setting up as a subsidiary, Edison International bought the upside of Southern California Edison's profits, which sends its profit to its parent. Yet when deregulation did not go as planned all of a sudden Southern California Edison was threatening with bankruptcy, and was asking for increased prices on electricity. These corporations know how to go after public's money.There is also an investigation with oil and energy providing companies on price gauging. Duke has even secretly agreed to settle it, but when the whole deal became public state bailed out of it. That's what free reign of oilmen and energy providers does to public, when energy and oil companies are left unchecked. In one of the recent interviews Dick Cheney was advocating for less regulation of industry and no federal intervention, but as experience showed in California regulation of energy sector works for public interest.Alpha, while I agree with you on all the things that you mentioned above, I do have to disagree with you about Davis. I did vote for him and think he is doing a great job with everything but the energy crisis. I think he should have let both companies fail and others, possibly even Duke Energy would have come to save them. If not for the state to take over them.(this may still happen)And because of this crisis, I would never vote for Davis again.By the way, MJ and I did talk some more about it on the "International" part of this forum. Hope to see you there. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 No problem. Only I cannot reply until later tonight. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:1. Growth of the Demand compared to the last year (it is not sudden – this growth is steady); 2. Law rain levels, due to which the hydropower plants could not be operated at their maximum capacities;3. Plant outages – these things happen every-now-and-then. I agree with 1 and 2, but too many plants have been off line at the same time. Very interesting. Actually, it is not quite correct. It seems like they are behind the schedule. I think only one of them is guaranteed this summer.I actually never said that they are coming online this summer, but rather by the end of the year. If there are delays to that daye, than I am wrong.If there is a price gouging or collusion, as those who would like to get clean out of the mess that they have created claim, there are anti-trust laws, and anti-profiteering laws, and the State of California can litigate them.They are. Just published last week in the LA times that talked about taking those companies to court. Also they are even talking about taking over power plants under some law that go down for no reason.Here is a link from LA Times: http://www.latimes.com/news/state/20010518...t000041743.html Believe me I am not here to tell you that our Governor(current or previous) is not to be blames for this mess, but one cannot just blame the politicians and the environmentalists. The 2 companies in CA have as much blame as they do.I too have to get back to work. I have not done anything but answer your posts since I got to work. Yaiks [ May 21, 2001: Message edited by: Azat ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Alpha, I believe that you'd agree with me MJ if I said that Economist is one of the most credible magazines. The following link http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?...story_id=624258 outlines the failed policies of our imcompetent president, that he tries to implement his failed policies in Texas on Federal level. Unfortunately it doesn't mention the failures of the "energy policies". Before even I read it, let me say that just because something is published in the Economist, it doesn’t make it more credible. I will read it in the morning. And, yes, many Energy policies in the past have failed (assuming that they have existed). What does Bush have to do with them? As we go, I am growing more and more wary of your partisanship. I don’t see any arguments on the merits, but empty decorations not based neither on knowledge nor on logic. Just on hatred. Also, why do you attack the competency of a person who makes the counter argument, or challenge the validity of his/her resources. I am ready to provide all the resources that I mentioned and stand by my numbers (TIME is also one of the most reputable magazines and 20-40% conservation number was obtained from there).Let’s put it this way – I call things as I see them, and so far I would stick by that statement of mine. Those were not your numbers, as far as I understand, but of someone else. How can you stand by these numbers, if you know nothing about the subject. If you are saying that you have referenced the Time Magazine article truthfully, who has argues that? Lets go back to where the whole energy debacle started. The energy deregulation was signed by notorious Republican governer Wilson, who signed the bills into a law against public outcry, but with consant lobbying of oil companies. Governer Davis just protects public from high energy prices. If you carefully follow his policies you'd notice that he was ready to bail out both energy companies from bankruptcy, but P&GE didn't want to settle for it. Albeit the result was a bankruptcy.If Wilson is Republican it doesn’t make him more competent on energy deregulation. I have never tried to make this argument as a Republican-Democrat issue. Apparently, PG&E was smarter than your governor. You surprise me one more time as an economist. What means bailing out PG&E? Who was supposed to pay the bill? The taxpayers, right? How? What funds was your Governor supposed to use? Now, your Governor opposes having the ratepayers to pay the bill, while he proposes the taxpayer do it. Guess what – these are the same people. Only a political prostitute would like to mislead his constituents this way. And before you repeat his nonsense, just think about it a little bit. Now I will point out one of the companies that I used to cover SCE. Southern California Edison is set up as a holding company for Edison International, which is financially well diversified company. By setting up as a subsidiary, Edison International bought the upside of Southern California Edison's profits, which sends its profit to its parent. Yet when deregulation did not go as planned all of a sudden Southern California Edison was threatening with bankruptcy, and was asking for increased prices on electricity. These corporations know how to go after public's money.Can you explain how? I somehow don’t understand you. There is also an investigation with oil and energy providing companies on price gauging. Duke has even secretly agreed to settle it, but when the whole deal became public state bailed out of it. That's what free reign of oilmen and energy providers does to public, when energy and oil companies are left unchecked. In one of the recent interviews Dick Cheney was advocating for less regulation of industry and no federal intervention, but as experience showed in California regulation of energy sector works for public interest.So what that there is such an investigation. There have been multiple of them. Tell me about the findings of the court. Additionally, my argument has never been that there may not be price gauging. If there is – there are laws in the book, and it has to be settled in the court. But it is very dishonest to explain the problems with price gauging, because that’s not what the problems are about. Additionally, I can see why someone like Duke may want to settle something like that secretly, even if it has nothing to do with market manipulation, as you would like us to believe. No such publicity has positive marketing value for any company. If it has manipulated the market, it is the court’s obligation to punish Duke. But I am ready to bet that nobody is going to be able to provide evidence or proof that Duke has manipulated the market. Are you? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJ Posted May 22, 2001 Report Share Posted May 22, 2001 Alpha, I tried to read the article you have referred me to. Such a garbage. Couldn't even finish it. It is not worth my time, nor is so the commenting on it. You just surprise me more and more... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.