Jump to content

Arpa

Members
  • Posts

    9,923
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    41

Everything posted by Arpa

  1. GorGor, you say your family had had a Turkish surname for a whole century. WOW! That is a loooong time compared to the fact that we have been Armenisn for at least 50 centuries? What would your srname have been before that "century"? b Let me repeat one thing. Why is it that when we live in an English/French....bl-bla empire and we adapt our names to that empire it is called assimilation/alienation but when we adopt Turkish names it is known as wetsern Armenian/ trkahayeren. What a f**** oxymoron!! Americahayeren is something to laugh at, russahayeren is disdained, parskahayeren sounds funny but trkahayeren???!!! I will not accept any excuses like it has been in our family for a hundred years. What were our names before the Turk ever set foot on our homeland? Did the Mamikonians and Suny's have ugly insulting and insultful Turkish names? Drop the damn ugly, insulting and insultful names. No Turk will be caught dead with a name like Cholakian, Topalian and the winner of them all-Chirkinian (all real surnames). Who is "chirkin"? Those sonofabitches!
  2. Arpa

    ԱՆԱԼԻ

    #Stormig May 16 2004, 09:10 AM Post #1   Why is salty, աղի (aghi), and the opposite, lacking salt, անալի (anali)? Shouldn't it have been անաղի (anaghi)?  -------------------- Խոսողին լսող է պետք: At that time I did not participate in this debate. Let me address the issue this way. Us western Armenians say “anli” not “anali”, probably a contraction and corruption. Recently when I was reading Paruyr Sevak’s article Mer Qnarergoutyan Vahagn@ about Petros Tourian, this item caught my attention. Of course, Sevak thinks the word of Bedros Dourian, he thinks Bedros created a whole world rather than repeating all the platitudes of mountain, sea and heaven etc. The reason why he calls him The Vahakn of our Lyricism. Among others of Bedros’ inventions he mentions that line fro ՏրտունջքTrtunjq/Protestations where we read; “Ելնել աստղերու սանդուղք անալի”. He says people , even linguists were so confused at that word that they finally decided that it may be a typographical error, so much so that they finally thought to settle the issue by substituting it with “ahali” (filled with awe). In fact my book of Tourian does have it as “ahali”. That is until, 50 years later it took another genius, Daniel Varuzhan to correctly interpret the word to mean “anali/ with no ali”, “ali/wave” being the singular of “aliq”, hence what Bedros meant was “a stairway with no rungs(waves)”, smooth. Here is that poem. Here also it reads “ahali”. http://armenianpoetry.com/arm/1656.html
  3. Անահիտը բաղնիք գնալու ընթացքին CVS կամ Walgreen կանք կ’առներ եւ Loreal Golden Harvest hair dye կը գներ Վահագնը որ հուր հեր* ունէր եւ մորուս Flaming Red hair dye կը վերցնէր Իսկ դուն որ մի քիչ ալէխառն ես դարձեր արդէն աթթարի խանութէն մի հատ հեննա վերցուր Why "chastvatsouhi" and not atvatsouhi( you wrote it with a capital Cha), are you afraid that Aramazt may strike you with a bolt of lightning, or Vahakn may run you over with his chariot? In no other language one finds an equivalent of "chastvats", like "un-god"? The most common distinction is either to capiltalize or not, like God v god or Astuats v astuats. Armenians are such lying cowards! *Hour her=hair of fire. I'm sure you know that we use "her" to mean hair as in aleher/white haired.
  4. Arpa

    ԹՐՔԱՀԱՅ

    Don't believe everything I say. Sometimes I pull peoples' leg and at other times I make up deliberate inaccuracies to test peoples' attention. "Zuluhay" is a total invention of mine. There is no such thing, but as I said to run the gamut of the Alphabet the roster of nations begins with Afghanistan and Zululand if there were such a country would be the last.
  5. Arpa

    Caucasus Women

    Armat, may be you should go to Amazonia or Masai-land in Kenya where the women are tall and statuesque. :)
  6. Իմ անունըս Արփա է, Արփի չէ, ես արու տղայ եմ . Not that it matters. No harm done. I have explaineդ why. Mostly because I am such a lazy slouch I chose a "four letter word" . The reason, even if I may be a pasta-head, I did not choose երկայնակլորախմորածակ. It is easy to sign on, plus it is a take-off on the River Arpa, which those SOB's have all but commandeered renaming it "Arpa-Chay" to make it sound Turkish. "arpa" has no meaning in Turkish except for to mean "barley/գարի". How much sense does that make? Like in "գարեջուր"? Those who know Armenian grammar the declension-հոլովում is; Սեռական -Արփ Դրական- Արփի Բացառական- Արփա Գործիական- Արփով Arpa means "from the Sun". Please search and find my post with he subject topic "Arpa" why I chose that nickname. Here is that post I was referring to Jan 18 2002, 01:38 PM Post #1 Movses, you asked; Inch e nshanakum Arpa? On the surface Arpa is a river, no, two rivers. One, also lnown as Arevelyan Arpa originates at the highlands of Artsakh, flows south west through Armenia, enters Naxijevan and pours into the Arax. At the present there is a project ro combine it with Vorotan creating the Arpa-Vorotan canal/tunnel diverting it towards Lake Sevan. The other, better known as Akhourian in Armenian originates at Lake Arpi, flows southward along the Turkish Armenian border, also eventually joing Arax. This latter river is known as Arpa Chay (ArpaCay)by the Turks.Their contention is to make it Turkish based on the fact that "arpa" is in fact a Turkish word meaning barley (gari). This cannot be further from reality. "Arpa" is the batsarakan holov (ablative case) of arp, among the other holovs- arp, arpi, arpa, arpov. It is all derived from "arp" which originally meant "ether", the vacuum between the earth and the sun, stratosphere. In time the root word fell into disuse and the more common derivative "arpi" survived but this time to exclusively mean the sun. Why were these rivers named Arpa. i.e. "from the sun"? I personally witnessed a scene that made it clear as the (light)Sun. I was looking up a small creek next to Geghart. It was midmorning, as I looked up to see where it came from I was almost blinded, the sun was so huge and bright and as I looked up it seemed like the the stream was trickling right from the sun as if it was being squeezed out of it. No wonder the natives called it Arpa Get and held it to be sacred as in those days the sun was the source of all life, just as it is today, and it is sacred. There are many variations of "arp", the most common being Arpi, a popular feminine and name. There seem to be no masculine counterpart except maybe Arpiar ??. Even more popular is Arpine(h) which brings us to the question why many Armenian feminine nouns and names end in "e" or "eh", as in Nane, Hermine etc. Yes, the "e" is a feminizing suffix, although not officially defined, it is not unique to Armenian. Many languages, including European as well as Oriental (Semitic) use the "e/ "a" ending to feminize. There may be numerous examples but suffice it to consider names like Robert and Roberta, Francisco and Francesca, Eugene and Eugenia (Evkineh) just as in the Arabic "amir" means prince and "amira"- princess. Ibn means "son" and "ibna"... well, I'll let others to comment on that. Of course, this all happened when the rest of m party were aaah-ing and oooh-ng at the wonders of Geghart/spear, I, the "pagan-cynical-agnostic" that I am was out admiring nature. What? You did not know that "geghart" means spear? The "spear" that eventually became a pain in our v*r*k..... side. Based on that idiotic legend that the "spear" that pierced Jesus' side on the cross was brought to Armenia and it became our exclusive property?
  7. Arpa

    ԹՐՔԱՀԱՅ

    Yes indeed! Let us see WTH it all means. You will notice that the very nickname was an Armenian creation. The Turks had no equivalent to it, neither did the Persians or the Russians have equivalents to Parskahay or Russahay in their respective languages. And while w're at it, let us see how many more "hays" there are. You fill in the blanks. I will run the gamut of the alphabet with "Afghanahay....to.....Zuluhay".
  8. Arpa

    ԹՐՔԱՀԱՅ

    You will notice my signature below, which is a quote from Sevak's Anlreli Zangakakatun. It refers to the time when Komitas who, salvaged from Trkahayastan was brought to Ejmiatsin. And when he sang, in Turkish, it brought tears to Khrimyan Hayrik's eyes. "Երեւի այդօր- քանի դար հետո- Երկինք ու երկիր հաշտվէցին նորից... Երեւի այտօր քանի դար հետո- Հայաստան բառից պոկվեցին ընկան Ռուսա-ն ու Տաճկա-ն" "It seems from that day on, after so many centuries, "Trka" and "Russa" were forever severed and fell from "-Hayastan"." It refers to how from that day on Armenians became one. Not Turkish Armenians or Russian Armenians anymore. This subject has been discussed to the ground in reference to Eastern and Western Armenian ("dialects").
  9. Arpa

    ԹՐՔԱՀԱՅ

    ԹՐՔԱՀԱՅ??? TRKAHAY?? WTH does it mean?? What an oxymoron!! Does it mean a Turk that is Armenian? Or an Armenian that is a Turk? I will leave it here to subsequently further develop and embellish.
  10. I know many similar cases. I will not go into specificս as some may wish to noտ have their identities revealed. I will only reveal this. There is an extended faily in our neighborhood whom I had always known as the Karian's. It turns out that their Turk-Armenan surname had been Kara-oghlan-ian (black boy, those SOB SSO so and so's! Who is a "black boy"?). When they arrived in America from Syria, hey deemed it opportune to shed heir Turkish yoke and.... As I said, there are many similar cases. Only if we had a smidgeon of Armenian pride we would find a way. I will not delve into the subject here as you can see this thread is about "benefactors". See you at Թրքահայ. However, you may be dsmayed to know that those ugly and insultful nicknames were not coined by the Turks themselves but by Armenians, as even then as now Armenians lived in their own enclaves, albeit many speaking Turkish, and lableled each other with those "sh*ty" names. I will explain under another thread.
  11. Sireli GorGor, I am not sure whether your meant "I did" or "did not" understand that Armenian paragraph. We can blame our ancestors all we want yet, now that we so much more sophisticated and know better and we are FREE we still pass the buck and declare impotence to do something about it. But above all; Who placing a noose around our necks to not dare shed our yokes of Ottoman culture? Is there a law that says Armenians CANNOT deturkify their names etc.? This is not the place to go into details. I will start a thread under the topic of Թրքահայ/Trkahay an oxymoron of all times.
  12. =========== Sireli MosJan Will you allow me to claim credit for your conversion? I cannot find that post of yours where you finally succumbed and relented promising to never use "karmir-kapuyt-narnjaguyn" again. May be you can remember. However the following may suffice. And please forgive me as this may not be the proper thread to bring this up. ===========
  13. Arpa

    Weird names

    The following is from here, Thanks MosJan; http://armenian.name/index.php?a=term&d=1&t=309 ARSEN From Greek arsen which means "strong', "manly"(Latin Arsenius, French Arsene, Russian Arseniy etc.). It is in use now as well as the corresponding surname Arsenyan. No matter where one looks it points to Greek. Many entries of Arsenius, St. Arsenius etc. Some will direct us to Arsenic, that highly poisonous metal. My dictionary says it is from the Greek word “arsenikus” meaning strong, masculine. And when I looked up “arsenal” which is explained as a storage of weapons. Even if the source attributes it to Greek it stops there, yet one can see the connection of “strong” as an arsenal is a fortified stronghold. I was also pleasantly surprised where the dictionary says the word is used by the Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, English etc. it also includes Armenian. Who can tell if the Greeks took it from Persian or visa versa?? It is all “Greek to me” anyway! :) BTW. The Arm. Encycl. has Arsen simply as an entry for Arsenic., and it does say that it is derived from the Geek to mean "arnakan, ouzhegh". Here is a bonus for you the Armenian word for Asenic is "mkndegh"/մկնդեղ i.e. mouse drug/poison.
  14. C'mon Hovsep (Karakashian)! Give us a break! Are you imitating Khoja/Hagarag/AmericaHye/Phantom22? First off, de-turkify your suranme of kara-kash(you may know what "khara" means in Arabic). You may already know that "sev" is the Armenian for black and "ounq" is the word for (eye)brow. Have you ever thought about renaming yourself Sevunkian?
  15. ԿորԿոր, Ինչ կը’սես կոր քա/ծո? Ակա լան, վալլահի մէկ բառ պիլեմ անկլամըշ չեմ ըներ կոր: Հայտէ, յալլա, իշտէ այսպէս: Տոլմա սարմա սարմըշ կընես կոր? The above is Armenian. Can you tell? Why are you so celebratory about a building at CSUN being after a Turk. Turk you say? Would you be celebrating if that building were named HAMID-ian, or for that matter-Kamal/Kemal-ian (a real Armenian?) surname? Hamid is not an Armenian (sur)name yoy say? When did BAYRAM(ian) become Armenian.? Do we call our holidays like Christmas and Eatser “bayram”? And, people have the nerve to talk about assimilation an alienation! Oh! I see! When Ohanessian adopts a name like Johnson it is assimilation but when we have Catholicoi with names Sikbashian it is totally Armenian and sacred !!?? Not to worry though. Armenians will never be assimilated . We have such a powerful OTTOMAN/TURKISH culture that no American, French or Bangladeshi culture can supersede. For now, good night, good morning. Wake me up when that CSUN building is named Tigranian/Vardanian, Mamikonean or Amatuni. Until then bayram-ogles and the bokhju-oglus will get zero lumas from me. Not even Catholicoses with names like Balji-oglu or Kazanji-oglu. Not to forget that lovely and loving grandmotherly matriarch- Khatun -Khanum Goetu-boeyik-ian.* The above means “large vorik-ian”. Maybe we don’t have that as a surname. But how many “goezu-boeyuk-ian do you know? Or, for that matter, how many Karagoexians do you know.? Do you know any Sevak-ian? Look her kids! As long as we maintain and insist to preserve such Turkish surnames lie Bayram-ian, Demirji-ian, and insist and maintain on having sirnames lkie Kakvorikian (my invention) you will all ridicule, and no sympathy or respect from me. Count me out as an assimilated American. Signed , Johnny Johnson Johnson beats kater-ji-ian or eshek-ji-ian anytime.. Don’t forget that Sports Complex in Yerevan that will be named for Demirji-oglu, Karen. Of course , as I said before, it is only fair that the Sports Complex in Ankara will be named for Haik Ermeni-ian. Is this the Bayramoglu we are talking about? ====  http://www.armtown.com/news/en/azg/20050827/2005082702/  Published since January 24, 2001 original article © AzgPublished on August 27, 2005 POSTPONED 'OTTOMAN ARMENIANS AT DECLINE OF THE EMPIRE' WORKSHOP TO BE HELD IN SEPTEMBER On September 23-25, Bosphorus University of Istanbul will hold the "Ottoman Armenians at Decline of the Empire. Scientific Responsibility and Issues of Democracy" workshop that was postponed 4 months ago owing to fierce opposition in Turkey. The Preparatory Committee announced about the workshop on August 21, and Turkish central newspapers caught it up. The postponed workshop, that was to take place on May 25-27, was initiated by Sabanj, Bilgi and Bosphorus universities of Turkey and had in its Preparatory Committee such scholars as Murad Belge, Halil Berktay, Selim Deringil, Ethem Eldem, Zaglar Keyder, Haqan Erdem, Aksin Somel and Jalil Kocak who reject Turkish denialist stance on Armenian Genocide issue and define the events of 1915 as genocide. As participants of discussions the Preparatory Committee invited Taner Akcam and Fatma Myuge Gyocek and other Turkish scientists from Yale, Harvard, Michigan and Minnesota universities as well as Turkish-Armenian editor of Akos newspaper, Hrant Dink, and Zaman newspaper columnist, Etienne Mahtchupian. A day before the workshop was to start, two oppositional deputies of Turkey's parliament condemned the organization of the workshop with participation of "pro-Armenian" Turkish scholars. The fact that it was to take place at the state-fund Bosphorus University made the matter even worse. Justice minister of Turkey, Jemil Cicek, labeled the initiative a "manifestation of irresponsibility" and stated that it is a "stab at Turkish people's back". After the minister's statements the Bosphorus University could do nothing but inform Turkish public of its decision to postpone the conference. But the postponement could not curb speculations that raged over the workshop in Turkey. Not to give room for the West to accuse Turkey of crackdown on freedom of speech, chairman of the Turkish parliament, Byulent Arinc, declared, "Dissent should not be impeded in the country. It was certainly permissible to hold the conference within the frames of freedom of speech". Turkish prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan joined him. Reminding that the workshop was the initiative of the country's higher educational establishments and scientists, Erdogan said it was meaningless to prescribe the postponement to justice minister's speech and added, "Let everyone speak. We'll learn at least what they think". It's noteworthy that those circles that most fiercely responded to the initiative of the workshop, displayed the same opposition to the Preparatory Committee's announcement about the September 23-25 conference. The Union of Civil Society Organizations of Turkey appeared to be the most aggressive one as it expressed resolution to make the organizers put off the workshop once again, Terjuman paper informed August 23. A member of the Union, Ramazan Kerek, threatened to spare no efforts to do that and added, "No one living in this country can betray Turkey." Meanwhile, justice minister Cicek gave an elusive answer to Milliyet newspaper saying, "They did not ask me while organizing the workshop nor did while postponing it. We'll see what they think at the conference". Those siding with the workshop answered the question of Hurriyet paper. Hrant Dink greeted the Preparatory Committee's decision to held the workshop, called for the Turkish government political circles to contribute to its holding and pointed out to the interested world community, saying another postponement will damage Turkey's reputation. Etienne Mahtchupian also welcomed the revival of the conference and a columnist of pro-government Yeni Safak, Ali Bayramoglu, added, "It is a profoundly positive and not less important workshop. Fierce opposition within the Turkish society of this unrealized workshop speaks well for holding it". Bayramoglu thinks that the workshop was politicized but it does not mean further politicizing will occur once launched. The latter informed Hurriyet about their invitation to take part in the conference. If their agreement was predictable, foreign minister Abdullah Gul's readiness to take part in the conference came as a surprise. Yeni Safak paper thinks that Gul's participation will mark the beginning of the process of reconciliation with history and will help acknowledge the fact of the Armenian Issue in Turkey. By Hakob Chakrian
  16. I don't know anything about them, except that they may be what is known in Arnenian cirles as Եղբայրութիւն, "brotherhood". They are an ultra-evangelical/literalist branch of the Protestant denomination, best described as Armenian fundamentalists, similar to those idiots like of Pat Robertson. I have seen (I will not say "met") Vahram Tatigian in person when I was very young, on an extremely cold, snowy and frosty Christmas eve, when the carolers stopped at our house and Vahram, freshly arrived from Istanbul was accompanying the carolers with his viloin with his frozen fingers. Biography of Vahram Tatikyan Vahram's devoted service to God and man, first in Istanbul, then in Anatolia and finally in different countries around the world reads like a spiritual epic. How was it that this man, who knew neither school nor university, was yet able to speak to hundreds of thousands of people, change the direction of their hearts' affections and be used as an effective instrument in bringing countless people to find peace with God? more... Nothing more ridiculous than those who may have discovered Jesus some 1699 years too late. Jesus is everywhere! All one has to do is look in one's heart.
  17. What business do those SSO's have in Australia? WE are where we are because of them. What is their excuse? Why are they invading the civilized world? Why did they rape our mothers, murdered our fathers, conficated our homes and land if they had no intention of living there? Those SOB's/kopoglu's!!! They can go to Europe, Australia, America and.... HELL! Let them! Every one of them!! Every Christian country should send them back where they came from, i.e their "mother bitch's'.... ..womb"!! We will go back to OUR HOME LAND.
  18. Miss Merkel seems to have won the chancellorship and according to recent reports France's Nicolas Sarkozy is still the most likely contender.
  19. I know the meaning and the intricacies of both words. You said "expunge" =abort, I said "expand"=elaborate. I may not have made my point clear. Again, before we go any further, if you have anything to say about the subject please do it in a separate thread. Isuspect tha you may have an opinion about "paganism" in our culture, that you wish were "expunged", and what I said was "expand", elabotrate, cite specifics and give reasons why they should be expunged. Let me repeat, if and when yiu decide to elaborate and cite spsifics about the subject, don't do it here since, after you and others have read this post I will EXPUNGE it. PS. We may have spoken about some aspects of the subject, such as "superstitions" etc. but never specifically about "paganism" in the presnet day Armenian culture(religion, if you will).
  20. Expunged? Don't you mean "expanded"? Don't respond to this debate here. To expand on your suggestion you may choose to start a separate thread under another topic in another category.
  21. Verjin, Arajin, whatever, you are sounding like a broken record. Դդումի համ ես տալիս,. You taste more and more like squash. Tasteless!! By now you may have realized that this is HyeForum, not Hrya Forum. .If you have anything to say about Hryas then you may consider to take your comments there. Lantos voted the way he did because he was pissed at the turks. Not because he got his a.ss kissed by any Armenians chor klooch. "Rep. Tom Lantos, D-Calif., the panel's top Democrat, said he was reversing his own position in supporting the resolution. He said though Turkey was a good friend, it needed to show more solidarity with the United States on important matters, noting the issue of U.S. troops, among others." Asbarez Even if I will not retract what I said about “Lantos the Mimos” above. Look at the reason and the reasoning he gave for his vote. The flip-flop artist that he may be , does that mean that the next time the US, intent to take out the ANPP , the Soviet inspired and Russian engineered (Armenian Nuclear Power Plant) at Metsamor, and Turkey opens its air space for the adventure then will Tom the Mimos/Lantos once again flip-flop and reverse his vote? Let us be practical and pragmatic. Yes, Lantos, the flip-flopper may prescribe to the Jewish faith, consider that our newfound sweetheart/hero Adam Schiff also prescribes to the same faith. What is the reason for his inclination? Is it because his electoral district(Glendale) is heavily Armenian? Would he stick to his guns if his district were heavily Turkish/Azeri? I doubt it. Some people, regardless of their denominational persuasion, unlike that Lantos the Mimos, who still does nor know where his ass is, some may still have the decency to speak the truth. Which brings us to what Henry Hyde said; In paraphrase. “This bill will not harm the US Turkish friendship”. In other words, “It is time that the ‘tail stop wagging the dog’”. That the donee may not pull the strings of the donor. That the recipient of welfare may not dictate the terms. Where would Turkey be without the huge infusion of American dollars? Would they be sustained by the Russian Ruble, or the Pakistani Ruplee? The Chinese Yuan? It may be time that Americans realize who the “dog” is and which the “tail”.
  22. Is Armenia reverting back to the Garden of Eden? Look who are promoting it. Adam and Eve. Yup! You heard it right. http://schiff.house.gov/HoR/CA29/Biography/ Adam Schiff, born June 22, 1960, is a graduate of Stanford University and Harvard Law School. Adam and his wife, Eve (yes, it's true), have two children, a daughter, Alexa Marion, born in July 1998, and a son, Elijah Harris, born in July 2002.
  23. No! I just wish that idiots of his kind go to HELL, a cocnept that hiis ilk inculcated in us in the beginning. "In the beignning was the word"' ? Whatever the hell, that may mean? Word of who? Mine or you'rs/their's?
  24. Lantos the “mimos”. What an idiot/clown! He has no idea where his "oss" is. He struggles with the English laguage, using such highfluting terms to cover his Hungarian ass. Who elects such idiots to the US Congress anyway??! Baring the bankrolling from TelAviv! The term is often used to mean “clown”. It is obvious that it is just an armenianized version of “mime”, i.e imitator, a mimic. He may be best described as a “manklavik/clown”, based on “manklav=slapstick”, a court jester. “Why did the chicken cross the street?” Har-di-har-har! Slap, slap!! Lantos the Mimos, the Jewngarian who pretends to be the best Yankee since the “Clipper”, Joe DiMaggio, yet he fails miserably He may pretend to be an all American protagonist, promoting our “staunchest ally”, yet he fails to realize that our “staunchest ally” had total hegemony and absolute control over the Middle East, including Israel/Palestine but chose to prohibit his ilk from settling there, as those lands were designated for the people of the Koran. Don’t forget the Mehmet is not Jewish. They may write volumes how the Ottomans welcomed the remnants of the Spanish Inquisitions, yet it begs for an explanation why those remnants were not allowed proceed further south , past Istanbul, to the “promised land”. Is it because they had to wait until the British Mandate would take over the Ottoman hegemony to establish a “homeland”? And now! Turkish/Jewrkish brotherhood!!!
  25. Sorry I couldn't resist. You can shoot me when you catch me. :) Armat, that is one of the most categorically cataclysmic catastrophes ever, is that guy is pulling our cat-paws.? Besides, it is mewingly hilarious. One wonders how much cat-calls he will receive. What does the Catholic cathechism have to say about it! :) Speaking of which , i.e. using animal and human remains I recently read an article about mad cow disease. India has been all but commandeering the world of hi-tech of late, yet see what goes on in the belly of the country. What do they care? They don’t eat beef/meat anyway. See below. Note the highlights by me. =====  Theory: Mad Cow May Have Come From Humans By EMMA ROSS, AP Medical WriterThu Sep 1, 7:07 PM ET A new theory proposes that mad cow disease may have come from feeding British cattle meal contaminated with human remains infected with a variation of the disease. The hypothesis, outlined this week in The Lancet medical journal, suggests the infected cattle feed came from the Indian subcontinent, where bodies sometimes are ceremonially thrown into the Ganges River. Indian experts not connected with the research pointed out weaknesses in the theory but agreed it should be investigated. The cause of the original case or cases of mad cow disease, or bovine spongiform encephalopathy, is unknown, but it belongs to a class of illnesses called transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, or TSEs. Such illnesses exist in several species. Scrapie is a TSE that affects sheep and goats, while chronic wasting disease afflicts elk and deer. A handful of TSEs are found in humans, including Kuru, Alper's disease and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, or CJD. All TSEs are fatal, untreatable and undiagnosable until after death. They are called spongiform encephalopathies because the diseases involve spongy degeneration of the brain. The disease was not known to infect cows until 1986, when the first cases were noticed in Britain. About a decade later, a new permutation of CJD, which scientists dubbed variant CJD, started showing up in people there. Experts believe this new variant came from eating beef products infected with mad cow disease. But where the cows got the disease remains a mystery. The most popular theory is that cattle, which are vegetarian, were fed meal containing sheep remains, passing scrapie from sheep to cows, where it eventually evolved into a cow-specific disease. Another theory is that cows just developed the disease spontaneously, without catching it from another species. However, a pair of British scientists now proposes the origin may be the bones of people infected with classical CJD, which they theorize ended up in cattle feed imported from South Asia. Britain imported hundreds of thousands of tons of whole bones, crushed bones and carcass parts to be used for fertilizer and animal feed during the 1960s and 1970s. Nearly half of that came from Bangladesh, India and Pakistan, said the scientists, led by Alan Colchester, a professor of neuroscience at the University of Kent in England. "In India and Pakistan, gathering large bones and carcasses from the land and from rivers has long been an important local trade for peasants," the scientists wrote. "Collectors encounter considerable quantities of human as well as animal remains as a result of religious customs." Hindus believe remains should be disposed of in a river, preferably the Ganges. "The ideal is for the body to be burned, but most people cannot afford enough wood for a full cremation. ... Many complete corpses are thrown into the river," the scientists said, adding that the inclusion of human remains in animal bone material exported from the Indian subcontinent has been documented. Britain was the main recipient of animal byproducts exported from India and Pakistan during the relevant period and was also a leader in feeding meat and bone meal to calves, they noted. Finally, the similarities between the strains — mad cow disease, classical CJD and variant CJD — are sufficiently close to support the theory of a link among them, the authors argued. "We do not claim that our theory is proved, but it unquestionably warrants further investigation," the scientists wrote. Indian neuroscientists Susarla Shankar and P. Satishchandra of the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences in Bangalore, India, agreed the theory needs to be followed up, but urged caution. "Scientists must proceed cautiously when hypothesizing about a disease that has such wide geographical, cultural and religious implications," they wrote in a critique published in the journal. Relatives of people who die of suspected CJD are persuaded to bury their dead or cremate them, the two said. In most hospital-related deaths, bodies are not taken to Varanasi, the holy city on the banks of the Ganges, but cremated or buried nearer to home. "Even in Varanasi, most Hindus do not put half-burnt bodies into the river," they wrote, adding that if bodies found in the Ganges did have CJD, there should have been a major epidemic of the disease in north India. "Facts to support or refute their hypothesis now need to be gathered with urgency and great care," the Indian scientists said. Copyright © 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. The information contained in the AP News report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press. Copyright © 2005 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
×
×
  • Create New...