aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
thoth i think there are grounds to think that i) the hamidian massacres and the 1915 genocide are linked, and ii) the germans might have been the inspirators at least to a certain degree. the usual ottoman response to any real or anticipated threat would be large-scale killing to "chastise" the rebellious element. this had been applied throughout ottoman history to a number of different peoples, ironically most commonly to fellow turks (consider the treatment of the kızılbash (alevis) by yavuz sultan selim (selim the grim, regebat 1512-1520) and later instances when entire turkish tribes were deported from anatolia to the balkans). but usually these were applications of a "heavy hand" to chastise people and break their back so that they would see the error of their ways and not attempt to rebel again. as for the innocent being killed together with the "guilty", the "justification" can be found in the turkish proverb "kurunun yanında yaş da yanar" (next to the dry one, the wet one also burns). but until 1915, there was no conscious attempt to systematically eradicate an entire ethnicity. the germans were very much influential in the ottoman empire starting with the reformation (tanzimat) and kaiser wilhelm had formed better relations with sultan abdulhamid than either the british or the french. the sultan himself had no respect for human life, be it turk or armenian or anything else. he is a very controversial figure, in him one sees at the same time an awareness of turkish ethnicity together with the tendency to crush any nationalist sentiment, including turkish. it is no coincidence in my opinion that the party that ultimately carried out the genocide was the one which had deposed him six years before. as to the pan-turanian motives of the young turks in killing the armenians, i do not think it was the major one: the young turks appear to me to have resorted to pan-turanism only as a result of their understanding that the multi-ethnic ottoman empire was not going to last, and that it had to be replaced by something else for the sake of the turkish nation which had formed its backbone. here one must add that the fever of nationalism had affected the ottoman christians first, and muslims second, and turks were not the first muslims to be affected. so to ascribe the genocide to racist tendencies of the turks appears to me as an over-simplification, and runs the danger of overlooking other factors. also, german culture was quite influential with the turks, especially among military ranks, from the time of abdulhamid and actually a good deal before that. most of the founders of turkish nationalism were german-influenced, some had even had their education in germany. enver was trained in germany as an officer. the germans produced some of the strongest scholars in the field of turkic studies in the 19th century, and many of our nationalists were their pupils. on a different note, ziya gökalp, chief ideologue of the c.u.p., is most noteworthy for his introduction of durkheim into turkish philosophy. so one should by no means underestimate german influence in turkey, and there are at any rate works (such as dadrian's) that study german responsibility in the genocide. it looks after all that germans might well be responsible for the two major genocides of 20th century that inspired later ones such as those in cambodia, rwanda, bosnia, and tibet. it must be difficult for conscious german to sleep in that. cheers,
-
hello i was reading some on-line stuff by ara baliozian, where he mentioned casually that elisabeth taylor was of armenian heritage and that her real name was yeghishapet terzakian (the surname sounds like the turkish for tailor, terzi). could anyone post more info on that please? regards,
-
dear everyone, in turkey, the term "hemşinli" exclusively refers to the hemşin armenians (please note that there are two hemşins in the black sea region: hemşin proper and çamlıhemşin. if i remember correctly hemşin proper must be further southwest of çamlıhemşin). "hemşinli" is used almost as a "euphemism" by both hemşinlis and non-hemşinlis while alluding to their armenian roots. in the recent past, people would say thaht the hemşinlis spoke armenian but did not know that their language was armenian, and would only realise that it was when they would come to istanbul and open up restaurants, and hear the armenian clientele speak armenian and understand them (someone who is very knowledgeable in these matters - a turk who speaks armenian - once told me that the hemşinlis know very well their armenian origins but prefer to hide it for obvious reasons). the hemşin region is traditionally left-wing i understand, and they have been on very bad terms with their laz neighbours who call them "kalın kaburgalı ermeni" (thick-ribbed armenian) (armenians in turkey have a physical type that tends to differ slightly from neighbouring non-armenian populations, except in areas where there has been extensive conversion and intermarriage). they appear to have converted to islam in the last two or three centuries because they were buckling under the heavy "belief tax (cizye)", but many people, especially those from the region (like the laz) suspect that they secretly keep to their old religion and therefore do not intermarry with them much. of course, like with everything, attitudes are esaing up, albeit slowly. i have no idea how many hemşinlis there are in turkey, but i guess the number is nowhere near the "millions" once claimed by a contributor to this forum about a year ago. most of the info above comes from sevan nişanyan's book "herkesin bilmediği olağanüstü yerler" (extraordinary places few know about). cheers,
-
that is precisely the reason why so many people prefer to avoid the question. 80 years is not yet history. moreover, the armenian question is not an isolated issue in a vacuum, but tied to an enormous number of other issues, both turkish and international. the genocide, no matter how tragic and horrible, was only the tip of the iceberg of greater undercurrents, and once you unlock the secrets about it, a number of other skeletons in the cupboard will come out into the light. that's what people don't want to happen, at least until the issue becomes "history". regards,
-
thoth, turkey has really become a large-volume wine producer of the world, and you might be surprised to learn that a substantial part of french bordeaux (of cabernet sauvignon variety) actually is obtained from turkey (no-name of course). the french use it to augment their volumes. i understand most of it goes to the vin de table, vin de pays and vin délimité de qualité superieure classes, but some of it indeed finds its way to appellation bordeaux controlée class as well. so some french bordeaux that you enjoy about 10-30 USD/bottle may indeed contain something from your "old country", so to speak! turkish wine was simply undrinkable up until the 1980s, then things improved a bit, and a lot in the last few years, to the point that turkey now has wines good enough to challenge the coopération (not chateau) AOC wines of bordeaux in quality, if not always in price/quality (we have a something like 400% excise tax on imported alcohol in this country). next time you come around, drop in, and i can offer you some really memorable turkish wine! cheers, [ March 18, 2002, 06:11 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
quote:Originally posted by bellthecat: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:i wonder what would happen if i got assimilated into the christian community inside turkey, with all my aristocratic turkish background and strong turkish identity Ali, I didn't think Turkey ever had an aristocracy along European lines. Position was, at the start of the empire, attained mostly through ability and luck, and at the end, mostly by bribes. And everything could be lost at the whim of the sultan. Very little was to do with the "natural" inheritance of power and position over others as if it were a god-given right, which is the essence of aristocracy. Or have I got it wrong?bellthecat, no, you haven't got it wrong, but there are a very few (about a dozen) turkish families that approach the european notion of aristocracy (i mean they are not the statesmen, clergy, or military). i tend to keep my family history to myself (and that remark about aristocratic background was a bit of a slip of the pen); and i would appreciate if we moved on to other subjects. no offence intended. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Ali - you are truly an enlightened individual. (And I can agree with everything you have said in your post). It is so very refreshing for me to meet persons of your disposition and attitude - truly a sign of some hope.... Whenever I am in Turkey again I must look you up. We could enjoy a nice bottle of Raki together and see who drink the most of it... dear thoth, thanks a lot. when you think of coming over, drop here a note, and let's have that bottle of raki. cheers,
-
dear boghos, excuse me my ignorance, but who is viceroy muhammad ali al k'bir? cheers,
-
dear boghos, o.k. you are right. at any rate sweeping generalisations like "the jews, the armenians, the turks...." are bound to be wrong since no group of humans is composed of individuals who don't differ. but in the case of the jews, the idea that there was a holy land, that one day jews were going to live there iwthout the oppression of gentiles, and that their stay in the lands of the gentiles was ultimately temporary was a fairly strong one, wasn't it? at any rate the jews are a far too diverse group to make any kind of generalisations. they have lived in so many different countries, absorbed and were absorbed by so many different cultures, produced figures of eminence with so many diverse views and opinions, that one would be hard put to find an opinion common to all jews. but i think i was right when saying that jews had never contended to any piece of land in europe, especially germany. cheers,
-
Domino, thanks for defending me (or admonishing sen vahan about his style). vahan, i am not greatly offended by your style, but Domino is right when he says that you won't get very far in establishing dialogue with it. i read as much western stuff as turkish stuff on the armenian question, probably more western stuff than turkish, actually. it is true we have been fed garbage by our educational system in turkey, but i had started questioning that garbage way back when i had started secondary school. it is also equally true that there is also armenian, western and russian garbage concerning this particular issue. but i have learned that even though turks are on the whole on the wrong side of this rift, some of the things they say are true. there is nothing strange about this: in all human conflicts, there are two sides, and even the side that is generally regarded wrong can get a few things right. moreover, the armenian question was almost never approached by a dispassionate and disinterested individual: most of the writers on this issue are either armenian or turkish, or belong to one of the "camps" or have vested interests defending this or that position for their own nations, not for turks or armenians. for instance, it would be naive to expect a serbian or greek to be totally impartial on a subject which presents wonderful opportunities of turk-bashing, wouldn't it? the russians, on the other hand i) have rarely if ever have been allowed to express their own individual (as opposed to official) opinion, the english and the french were the enemies of turkey during the time that particular conflict took place, and the germans are at least partially motivated by the desire to "prove" that the idea of genocide is not teir gift to the world (and they will not know where to look when their archives concerning this issue gets opened soon - it has started to already. by the way, really, how seriously have the armenians examined german complicity in the armenian genocide?) as for the land issue, i had previously stated in a discussion with mj that this was out of question as far as i was concerned, and i am pretty sure the same goes for any turkish government and the nation as a whole. there is nothing particularly turkish about this attitude: no-one gets out of the territories their ancestors conquered except by force. you might of course mention exceptions like finland after the establishment of the soviet union, but these are, as i have stated, exceptions. does france get out of corsica, brittany, euskara (basque country) or alsace? does spain get out of catalania or euskara? do the english get out of england and go back to northern germany and southern denmark where they originally came from? do the russians get out of east of the urals? do the americans sail back to the old world? do the australians do it? then why should we? besides, we have much more of a right to be in these countries as we are largely the descendants of the original inhabitants of anatolia. the whites that have been strewn around the world cannot say the same thing: the american whites have little if any native blood, and the same goes for the australians. they still have their european culture, language and physical makeup. whereas in our case we are for the most part indistinguishable from the greeks, armenians, kurds and other peoples physically or culturally. the chief differences are that of language and religion. so any move to throw the turks out and replace them by other natives would be injustice to say the least. at this point i have to address a few observations made about me by the members of this forum (i think it was tb who wrote the longest one). basically i was viewed as a turkish patriot who wanted the best for his country and saw reconciliation of the two peoples as a step toward this. i was also described as a rational player and a good opponent to have. i commend the contributors, but let me state my position myself: i am a turkish patriot, but with a difference: my patriotism is characterised by the omission of "my country, right or wrong". this is probably due to my familiarity with history, especially the example of germany in wwii, even though i am by no means an expert on this particular area or period. my patriotism also is - or tries to be - based on i) rational facts, ii) long-term vision, iii) containment of national pride, iv) a determination to find practicable solutions to existing problems that can turn a lose-lose situation to a win-win situation for both sides of the conflict, and v) a fundamental sense of justice common to humanity. i love my nation, language, culture and country, but that does not mean that i have to hate other nations, languages, cultures and countries. this is especially true in the case of turks, whose nation, language, culture and country has so many foreign elements in it, but still retains its distinct turkish identity. it is in this respect that i differ most profoundly from the narrow-minded republican or boz kurt type nationalists who are exclusivists in their outlook. the bozkurts are out there to purge all non-turkic elements out of the turkish identity, be they linguistic, cultural, artistic or other elements, or more dangerously, people. as far as the fundamental sense of justice is concerned, it is based on the twin pillars of integrity and common sense (you know what they say about it: it just isn't common): integrity: is it just to lament the plight of the mayan indians in guatemala and to deny, or try to justify, the plight of the kurds and armenians in turkey? common sense: how can you expect that the world recognise the plight of the uighur turks in china, the one million displaced azeri turks in regions outlying nagorno-karabagh, the 14 million strong azeri community in iran, the iraqi turkmens massacred by the iraqi kurds and saddam, when you still deny the armenian genocide and denied until very recently the very existence of kurds in turkey? give no justice, get no justice. long term vision: in a hundred years time, there will very probably be very few borders left on this world. this has already happened in europe, and it is a growing trend. it is up to us to ensure that our two countries aren't two of the very few losers left that still have border checks in 2100. just look at the map, remove the conflicts, the borders etc. and see what a wonderful, prosperous place can be made out of it if peace prevails. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:hi "love kills, but hate perpetuates a minority population". i beg to differ. sibel (my wife-to-be) is an orthodox christian (not religious, though), and i happen to be a sunni muslim (not religious, though), and no-one is trying to assimilate the other. i wonder what would happen if i got assimilated into the christian community inside turkey, with all my aristocratic turkish background and strong turkish identity (i do have a strongly turkish identity, believe it or not, just it is not a barrier between me and the rest of the world)? curious. cheers, First off, Ali, hayirli ve bereketli olsun!You mean your future half is of Armenian extraction? She may not know this but Antioch was an Armenian town during the Cilician times. The Patriarch was there recently to reopen the church. Although most were exiled when the French handed it to Turkey, some stayed, most live on the Syrian side in towns like Kessab etc. The majority of them are in Ainjar in Lebanon. As to your "aristocratic" ancestry, it is a known fact that Christianity was first adopted by the royalty, primarily the women, both in the case of Rome and Armenia. It may seem so on the surface, but my opinion is that the common folk had already converted but until the aristocracy (Constatin's mother and Trdat's Sister Sandoukht), the king would not relent and continued to persecute. When their own loved ones presented the dilemma... it is fabled that Trdat lost his mind...and the rest is history. arpa, thanks a lot. i understand your turkish is pretty good! did you learn it in the family? no, my future half is of christian arab extraction, actually, but as orthodox christians intermarried, she may well have armenian blood (so might i, in fact, like most central and eastern anatolian turks), though to the best of my knowledge she doesn't know much about that sort of thing. she has family in syria and lebanon, and some in brazil (they chose to leave when antioch was repatriated to turkey in 1939). we have visited some of the important sites in antioch, including the museum (wonderful graeco-roman mosaics) and some of the churches. i have not seen anything armenian there, though we met a family of neighbours who had an armenian grandfather originally from malatya. i found the last paragraph very interesting (the one about the adoption of christianity, trdat etc) but i couldn't really see how it relates to my "aristocratic" ancestry. could you please clarify? cheers [ March 13, 2002, 02:14 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:now that the official turkish position is a difficult one to defend Let me try to summarize in one paragraph. "Nothing happened. Well, if something happened, it wasn't that big a deal. Well, if it was a big deal, we suffered even more. Well, even if they suffered more, they deserved it. Well, even if they didn't deserve it, they couldn't have suffered much because they hardly existed to begin with. Well, even if they existed, they didn't have an official existence. Well, even if they had an official existence, it doesn't count because they hadn't had a state for a long time. Besides, are they really a nation anyway? We doubt it. Even if they are, that was a mistake. Anyway, don't get us angry, or we will do it again; not that we did anything to begin with." P.S. It was more than half a million. yepp this is more or less the turkish position, and of course the turks have to be reminded of three of their own proverbs: "you cannot smear the sun with mud", "the candle of the liar burns until night sets in", and "he who has an wound, let him itch". i know it was more than half a million, i was just quoting the official stuff. cheers,
-
hi "love kills, but hate perpetuates a minority population". i beg to differ. sibel (my wife-to-be) is an orthodox christian (not religious, though), and i happen to be a sunni muslim (not religious, though), and no-one is trying to assimilate the other. i wonder what would happen if i got assimilated into the christian community inside turkey, with all my aristocratic turkish background and strong turkish identity (i do have a strongly turkish identity, believe it or not, just it is not a barrier between me and the rest of the world)? curious. cheers,
-
hagarag, i agree with you to a certain extent, but the jews were not native to germany (in a sense), they never considered themselves to be, and they always wanted to go back to the holy land, and indeed zionism and extensive jewish resettlement in israel actually predates the holocaust (theodor herzl etc.). this is not the case with the armenians. they are native to the place (at least have been there for the past 2,800 years or so), and still dream of their ararat mountain. this is why i was surprised to see that most armenians who answered that question in this forum said that they wouldn't return even if it were to become part of armenia. then, i ask, why so much talk about getting back the lands, if no-one is going to go live on them? not that i see it as a viable goal, anyway, but still, why no canalise your energies on areas where you can actually get something like genocide recognition, repentance, compensation, and normalisation of relations between the three countries (incl. azerbaijan)? i see it as a moral right of armenians to be able to live in eastern anatolia where they have done so for centuries (without throwing us out, for we have lived there for a good eight hundred years as well). of course, whether or not they would actually want to do so is entirely their business. i can understand that people who have lived in the west for three generations would already have been assimilated to a certain extent into the surrounding population and not want to come back and start everything from scratch in eastern anatolia (which is a tough place to start anything from scratch, anyway), but i can't really see much f another reason (this, of course, provided that the rift between the two peoples have healed). cheers,
-
arpa, 1. kamuran gurun is an ex-turkish diplomat, so a mouthpiece for the turkish government. it is only natural that he writes stuff to defend the turkish position. now that the official turkish position is a difficult one to defend (=there was no genocide. half a million people died by accident.) the stuff he is going to write is going to sound a bit incoherent here and there. i have read his "armenian file: the myth of innocence exposed" and must say that i have seen few books so badly written and easy to trash academically. the chapter on armenian origins especially makes you puke. it sounds like 19th century racist colonialist british-american stuff about the natives. so i would be less than flattered to say the least being compared to gurun, although i have to concede that he may have a few good points for the 19th century (don't have the book with me, so examples will probably follow later on). 2. menderes' surname has got nothing to do with non-turkish ethnic origins. the river meander (the original name is either greek or pre-greek) is called "menderes" in turkish, and his family was from there, so he was called menderes. he got hanged (which was a tragedy) ostensibly because he violated the constitution, but actually because he said things like "i can run this army with non-commissioned officers", and the famous "if i threw a piece of wood, it would be elected an mp (this one a public statement)". in turkish we have a saying: the dog about to die pisses at the mosque wall (eceli gelen köpek cami duvarına işer). two other ministers were hanged with him, with impeccably turkic origins (not that that was an issue those days. believe it or not, if you are a muslim, native turkish speaker, and declare yourself a turk, you don't get molested in this country, at least not on ethnic grounds). i hope this clarifies a bit. cheers,
-
hello i have checked anger.net, and found there are quite a few posts about most groups/nations, including us turks (why is ours the only one with the name in capitals?). i wouldn't set much store to it, but the way armenians are described in the post very closely resembles the way turks are (and can be) described by german and other euro racists, especially the languge ability, cultural adaptation, hair dyes and cologne bits. they could have added garlic smell, beating wives and wearing garish-colured shirts which leaves a most hairy chest exposed with fake gold jewelry (even in the case of men) etc. unfortunately there are such types amongst the turks. we call them "kıro" or "maganda" for those who know turkish. cheers,
-
dear arpa, tb, Domino, sen vahan, i shall answer the points raised to the best of my ability: 1. i do nothing to evade the mit. i use my real name as my user name, my surname is pretty famous in this country, i myself have appeared in the press several times (in totally different contexts), and if someone wants to find my whereabouts, it would take them a day if they were morons, and less if they had an iq over 90. if they haven't got me with all that by now, the only explanation i have for this is that they are not interested in doing so. 2. i wasn't advocating recognising the genocide without doing anything about it. as far as i am concerned, the genocide has to be recognised, compensation has to be paid for loss of life, limb & property, and the former armenian population of anatolia, who were ottoman subjects and therefore ought to have the same rights as today's turkish population, should be restored to their ancestral lands. now i had raised that issue in a previous discussion, and the replies i got from most armenian members who cared to reply were negative on the issue of returning to these lands. as far as i can recall mj even said something to the effect of "no armenian is ever going to return to eastern anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of armenia" (sorry mj if i am misquoting), and i got the impression that the armenians on the whole were more interested in getting the genocide recognised, repented for, compensations paid etc. than an actual return to the lands (on the other hand, i myself favour their return). secondly, you will already have enough in your hands trying to get the turks recognise the genocide and agree to pay compensation for it, and it will be met with greatest resistance on the part of the reactionary and nationalist factions, and it will give a card into their hands, something which no-one favours, i guess. thirdly, there are over ten million people currently residing in these regions, both turkish and kurdish, and their displacement will be out of question as far as the turkish government and nation are concerned. fourthly, any recognition, compensation and resettlement will automatically - and rightfully - bring similar demands both from the turkish and azeri sides about the plight of the over one million internally displaced azeris in azerbaijan, both from the nagorno-karabagh region and the territory outside it that is currently being occupied by nagorno-karabagh forces, and armenian republic's attempts to distance itself from that problem will be as successful as turkey's attempts to distance itself from a similar question in cyprus has been - not very. in brief, we have to find a solution that will work for both sides, and not harm either party. added to this is the fact that most of the diaspora is by now pretty well settled in countries a good deal more prosperous than both turkey and armenia, and that most of those who returned to armenia have left the country or are still leaving, and the azeri/turkish blockade is neither the only nor the most important reason for this, as we all very well know: they are disgusted with the way the country is being run (corruption, nepotism etc). 3. re the percentage of armenians in the empire prior to the genocide and/or 1891: i do not know that topic in depth, obviously, the further back in time you go, the greater that percentage would be, but as things stand, by the third quarter of the 19th century, they were a minority in every province by the figures available to me. 4. re the right of self-determination of peoples: somehow the plight of some people in this issue gets more attention than others: you do not hear much about that in the case of the tibetans or the uighurs in china, or the bosnians in former yugoslavia (they are the only nation that did not get its own state after the break-up, they ended up in a bosnian-croat federation. could it be because they were muslims?). in the case of iraq, for instance, you hear a lot about the kurds, but a good deal less (or nothing, in fact) about the turkmens who are currently being liquidated by the kurds of talabani and barzani. you hear about the plight of the kurds everywhere, including iran, but you don't hear about the plight of azeris in iran, for instance (now there are some fifteen million turks in iran, a third of the population, and they cannot even get education in their own language. how about that?). i am not against the right of self-determination per se, but only if it is applied everywhere equally. if everyone else will get theirs and we turks are not going to get anything save by force, then we cannot be expected to respect anyone else's right of self determination, can we? may i conclude by adding that the most fruitful way to approach the problems between our two peoples would be to discuss them directly without intermediaries as we are doing here. we have all seen how reliable third parties are when defending our rights. regards,
-
hagarag, i completely agree and symphatise with you. of course, someone who has gone through what your family has gone through would want to have his revenge, and one cannot blame him for that, even though revenge in my opinion is not a healthy feeling (strong vinegar damages its own jar, as we say in turkish). i also agree that pre-1915 reports of armenians massacring turks can be greatly exaggerated, but there were several such instances. the turkish thesis is that these were intended 1) to incite armenians to rebel, and 2) to provoke turks to retaliate against the armenians, and thus create a pretext for the western powers and russia to intervene. i believe there is some truth in this as the same plan was implemented in the balkans and had succeeded, there was every reason to believe that it would have succeeded in eastern anatolia as well. moreover, eastern anatolia being in close proximity to the oil-rich regions of iran and southern mesopotamia, they would have the incentive to do that, too. in addition, russians have traditionally striven - and still strive - to descend to the warmer seas (their afghan invasion in 1980 was ultimately a try to get down to the indian ocean as their mediterranean prospects had largely failed). so only thinking in historical terms of realpolitik, there are grounds to believe that some armenian factions carried out terrorist activities (these are actually documented and i do not know of armenians denying them, esp. those in istanbul), incited the population to rebel - with mixed success, as the bulk remained loyal to the Porte - and carried out atrocities to incite the turks to seek revenge. this is a very common pattern that can be seen in such onflicts throughout the world. of course, the motives and machinations of the CUP were entirely different: they wanted to get rid of the non-muslims in the empire, and confiscate their wealth. and of course, whatever some armenians may have done, there can be no justification whatsoever for what followed. cheers & thanks on congrats, i'll extend them to my wife-to-be.
-
arpa, i agree with your points to a significant degree but mine differ slightly from yours in the following respects: 1. post-ottoman turkey would not that gladly oblige to accept the genocide, for i) mustafa kemal had to enlist some of those murderers amongst the ranks of the fighters of the independence war, and these guys consequently became listed among the heroes of independence, and later on, the founders of the republic; ii) these very guys had swallowed armenian wealth, you would not expect to cough it up from their newly-gained position of power, would you?, iii) much of the industrial wealth (especially in terms of real estate) was based on confiscated armenian, greek, and jewish property, iv) turkey had a hard time making the world accept its existence (western countries refused to move their embassies from istanbul to ankara for nine years, counting that the new republic would not survive) and the armenians did demand territory from turkey until quite recently, and there is still doubt amongst the army and conservatives that the demands can resurface, to name a few reasons. 2. i don't think that territorial demands would have any future, nor are they - understandably - conducive to constructive dialogue between the two peoples. the reasons for this are, apart from the fact that no-one cedes territory willingly, are i) armenians were in a minority in most of the provinces they were inhabiting by the 19th century, and ii) turks had not conquered these lands from an armenian state, but from the byzantine empire (cilicia may be a different case), and iii) pressing the territorial issue internationally would pave the way for similar demands elsewhere, most notably the americas and australia, but also russia, china and europe, so the turks would have many allies and armenians many adversaries. i hope that in a hundred years' time, when the genocide has been long recognised and the people of the world have broken the mental shackles of nationalism, there would be the right atmosphere for armenians to settle back in turkey and live with their turkish and kurdish neighbours in peace. there were such times once. why can't there be again, after the wounds of the past have healed at long last? i believe in this sincerely when i look at europe: these people have been fighting one another since time began, they slaughtered a significant portion of eachother as recently as fifty years ago, and now there are no borders to speak of between them. it can happen. cheers,
-
thoth, thanks for the remarks. i agree with you that one shouldn't let the common turks off the hook as easily. i do believe that even many of the killers had little if any idea of the genocide, though that does not make them any more innocent: they were basically killing innocent people. thanks for the congrats on my upcoming marriage. i fear we are not going to do much in the way of muslim stuff for the marriage ceremony for 1) my family, including myself, are not religious a bit (in fact my dad is not even particularly sympathetic to islam), muslim marriage ceremonies are pretty sombre things where the bride and groom (i.e. men and women) celebrate it separately, and we don't believe that celebrating separately the start of a common life is a clever thing to do, and 4) my wife (i so much got used to the word) is a christian, and a muslim marriage ceremony might well less than please her, and suit us two. cheers,
-
hello hope this can help a bit: "al" is also turkish for "deep, dark red". "gul" comes from proto-indo-european "bhlomen" from which the german blume, english bloom, latin flos, (french fleur) also come. as for "vart" it looks like the arabic "ward" which means "flower", but i do not know which comes from which. by the way, where did roses originally come from? i mean, plants were moved around by people in the past a lot. maybe that would help. cheers,
-
hey guys i guess this particular topic is none of my business, but after having read the postings, i couldn't resist the temptation to contribute. i find it so shocking that artur's (and to a certain degree jugs') postings and the attitudes they reflect are so similar to those of the grey wolves, the islamic fundamentalists and in general the more conservative folks in our society. i wish i could find a website where our folks were discussing that type of stuff in english, i would love to direct artur there. artur, i do not mean to offend you, but if we had found a way to bring some of the folks i mentioned above and you together (concealing your turkish and armenian identities and perhaps your religions) you would be the best pals, and probably even congregate to establish a common society (how you would propagate given your views on sex i leave it to you to figure out)! the folks here who criticise folks like me (and thoth, for instance) utter exactly the same sort of four x (since i guess i am the only turk left on this forum i don't want to get banned) as you have been spouting. the same views on how "real" turks should behave, whether women should be allowed to drive cars, how children should show respect to their parents, how everyone in the west is engaged in sex, child abuse, drugs etc., and how it would damage our society to associate too much - or at all - with the west, how the women of all other nations are prostitutes and only the turkish women chaste (of course, by men's standards, not women's), how liberals are hypocrites, etc. and do you know? they accuse the greeks, armenians, jews and other "gavurs" (do you know the term?) for having "corrupted" the turkish society this way. man, who did you pick up this attitude from? an ottoman fossil or what? wake up, go have some sex, and then you'll think in a a much more balanced manner. loving your culture, your way of life does not mean you have to hate everthing that doesn't fit it. all the best & hope i have not offended you, for that was not the intention. cheers,
-
manukyan, are you a turk or an armenian being sarcastic about the turkish attitude? i would appreciate if you clarified. regards,
-
hagarag, i sincerely wish you and all the armenians the best of success in your efforts to get justice by legal means. of course, the chief reason why turkey has evaded recognition is precisely that: the looted properties of the armenians. we suspect in this country that some of this wealth ended up in the ittihadists's hands, but much of it was grabbed by the chetes. there is also the question of real estate. i think that you guys would have a greater chance of getting compensation for real estate than movables, except if the movables in question were recorded in banks and if these records were still extant. i do not know the extent to which legal material pertaining to this question has survived until now. can you tell me, if you know, of how this question was addressed in the case of the jewish holocaust? thanks for the congrats, by the way. we still have a long way to go (we think the date will be september), but this weekend we will sort out the first round of the rings. cheers,
-
Gallup Poll Exposes the Myth Of Turkish-American Friendship
aurguplu replied to hyecory's topic in International
thoth, maybe my posting needs a readjustment a bit: the common turk does not hate the common american. turks are largely - not totally - free of hating persons of a nation. what they hate is us involvement in the middle east, especially iraq (because it hurts us financially) and palestine (because israeli excesses by now even revolt many jews). when you listen to a turk criticising the usa, you don't much hear of "americans this, americans that", rather, "america this, america that". they - and i - see a difference there. after all, we also get exposed to the fact that many americans are highly critical of us foreign policy. as far as the aid is concerned, it may be true that the sums are huge, but what is it good for if it doesn't make a difference in our lives? of course this is very largely ou own fault: somehow we cannot come up with 550 honest people to fill the parliament. one major boost for us image over here was us aid after the earthquake. and also, our relationship with the us is a love/hate relationship of the type many developing countries exhibit: they hate us arrogance and their perceived right to meddle everywhere and dictate their own terms, but given a choice, few if any would refuse a green card. i gotta dash now, my future wife is waiting for me at home. cheers,
