aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:The reason the elected officials must tread very carefully is not because of a backlash from the population, although it is always wise to break the news in a diplomatic fashion. The real danger is the military and the "hardliners" (i.e. the grey-wolf types, which should be regarded as a militia, rather than a true civilian group). The life expectancy of a prime minister that initiates a true enlightenment in Turkey would be reduced drastically. If lucky, he would be toppled by a bloodless coup, and spend the rest of his days under house arrest, contemplating. Under such wonderful encouragement, one's own thinking itself tends to stay, shall we say, "conservative". In many respects, Turkey is still an Orwellian society, although that has been changing slowly. Those that follow the Turkish press for a long time should remember that in the eighties there was a big hoopla in the Turkish press about some ingredient in detergents that could harm the environment. The population, which in general is as far away from being tree-hugging "Green"s as one could possibly get, got so worked up about it that all the brands phased out the offending ingredient in a relatively short amount of time. The moral of the story is that the Turkish population will follow the lead of the journalists and the establishment in general. The ones to be "convinced" are not the ordinary Turks, but their puppeteers. And they are not such a numerous group. tb, what is currently going on in turkey could possibly not have taken place without the approval (=read: informal order) of the top brass. you will be surprised to hear this from me may be (and even i am sometinmes surprised with it), but many military types are surprisingly frank and impressively objective in private discussions, but since they are the real rulers of the country, they also have to read very carefully and responsibly (the latter is a word foreign to the politicians and especially to the media). hence my daring to conduct a rather open dialogue with you guys on the net. twenty years ago i would not dare to hold such conversations with an armenian even in the confines of my own house for fear of getting taped. now i can do it online. things are changing (i bloody well hope i am not committing a dreadful and potentially very dangerous mistake here). cheers & pray for me if i disappear (just kidding).
-
quote:Originally posted by edward demian:My questin was rather straight forward. If language is the measuring stick of turkishness, than were my Grandparents not turkish? (since turkish is all they knew) Since The Gagauz of Moldova speak turkish, and are of turkish blood (but Orthodox Christian)are they turkish according to the definition of turkishness. I would like an answer from our muslim turkish friends on this pannel. Or are they still scratching their heads in disbelief. edward, sorry for the very late reply, i noticed your post only today, as i was looking for some other stuff in past discussions. your grandparents were turkicized armenians as far as i am concerned. the separating factor was the religion. in the ottoman empire, nationality (or rather ethnicity) was not much of a problem, at least at the official level (i realise this is open to suggestion). the empire was first and foemost muslim, the turkish identity coming to the fore only after nationalism hit the empire in the 19th century. for practical purposes, muslims did not differentiate between themselves much, and ethnic differences between them surfaced only early in the 20th century. the issue with the christians, however, was different: throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, muslim refugees from lost territories in the balkans came pouring into anatolia and they (and the experiences they brought with them) did much to destroy the then relatively harmonious atmosphere between the muslims and the christians. it is no coincidence that many of the top brass of the CUP who ordered the massacres, including enver, were of balkan origin (probably with little if any turkic blood, if their pictures are anything to go by). so at the end of the 19th century there was a serious rift between the two peoples (muslims and christians), and it was one where religion played a decisive role. of course you can be (and still are) called a turk if you speak turkish, are muslim, and call yourself a turk. no-one would dare question your genes without at the same time risking their own genes being questioned (who in turkey today, after all, has slanted eyes?) so my answer is that if your grandparents were turkish speaking AND muslim, they would have been called turks, even if their islam was nothing more than a veneer (nominal islam is a passport to turkish society). the fact that they were christian prevented them from being considered turks. as for the gagauz, they are turks, considered as turks, but in the ottoman empire they would have been the reaya, and bracketed together with other christians. turkish origin would not make them first-class subjects. one should, especially in the ottoman context, be aware of the way the notion "nation" (millet) has developed. this is a long issue and probably deserves another posting. cheers,
-
on a different note: i hope to be working (part-time) with a publishing house as a translator of works on the history and culture of various peoples. this house is already having redgate's book on the armenians translated into turkish. as the "ban" on things armenian is gradually being lifted, i would like to do my bit to help the process. can anyone care to give me a list of some basic books on the art, civilisation, culture and literature of the armenians, so that i can make them suggestions (preferably titles in english, as i do almost all translation from/to english). also, a few suggestions on something like "teach yourself armenian" and a decent armenian-english-english armenian dictionary please. cheers,
-
hagarag, with all due respect, a sustantial part of the world's population in the middle east and europe (and now americas) may have some jewish ancestry if you dig deep enough (this very probably includes me, and you don't have to dig that deep after all), and as far as i can tell from my observations, most of these guys couldn't care less if they had jewish blood or not. once you cease to describe yourself as a member of a certain nation/culture/religion/etnicity, it becomes a matter of ever-decreasing significance whether or not you have this or that blood in your veins. consider: what did tigran think of his jewish ancestry. when it came to choose, would he consider himself jewish or armenian? cheers,
-
dear arpa & Domino, although i disagree with your above posts (especially the tone of that of arpa), i can understand your indignation at the ongoing denial of the genocide. let me elucidate, though, the task that a turk who is trying to change the attitudes of his fellow countrymen faces: armenians 101: 1. armenians are people like us and not aliens from outer space. they are not little green men with eight eyes and tentacles and their fingertips don't glow in the dark. 2. armenians have been around since about 1,200 bc, they don't date from the battle of manzikert in 1071 ad or world war one. and their purpose in life has not uniformly been the annihilation of the turkish nation. and it is a bit far-fetched (for want of a better word) to call armenia "a dagger struck at the heart of the turkish fatherland". please guys, they have been here before us. 3. armenians have been existing in anatolia since 1,200 bc, and if this is correct, it is only logical to expect some traces of them. in fact, such traces do exist. 4. all the ancient scripts of anatolia have been deciphered, and the thing in front panel of that church is armenian. you don't have to be a scholar of obscure languages to read it, your next-door car mechanic arto can do it. 5. things armenian don't bite, sting, or otherwise cause any bodily harm. 6. you won't turn into an infidel (=christian) by entering that church. 7. reports that turks have encountered armenians and survived the event have some basis in fact. look at me. 8. no, the dolmabahçe palace wasn't built by an italian, it was built by an ottoman armenian called sarkis balyan. 9. yes, the sultan did commission him to build his palace, his tomb (=yes, tomb) and his mosque (yes, MOSQUE). and the sultan was not an armenian. 10. no, the sultan did not become an infidel (he was also the caliph for god's sake) by letting him build these (and no, he wasn't a muslim, overt or covert). and you won't lose your religion by entering that mosque. 11. the armenians say the turks killed them. we say they killed us. there are 65 million of us, and 80,000 of them, in turkey. explain. 12. peace can be made between them and us. and it won't cost us our land. 13. no, most armenians are clever enough to realise that turkey will not "give" six of its provinces to armenia to make peace. they just want the recognition of the fact of what happened to their ancestors. 14. the fact that they killed us does not undo the fact that we killed them. and if they have their criminals, that does not make us innocent. 15. not all of those armenians who died were plotting against turks. babies can't plot. see? this is where we have to start with our countrymen. given this start, i think quite a bit has been achieved already. before telling us that you don't have any hopes for changes, please read this carefully. this is the ground beneath our feet. cheers [ May 14, 2002, 09:59 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
Dear Boghos, I have heard of dadrian's book translated into Turkish with the title "jenosit". I don't have a copy yet (crisis crisis I cannot spend money on books at the moment, I have to get married first), but the book has been around for quite some time (I had heard of it about 2000). As for the cosmetic changes to appease the EU, I don't know of their motives, but the effect is going to be clear: the ugly truth will rear its head. Please understand that many clever Turks are quite, if not fully, aware of what transpired in 1915, but we have to be wary of a public opinion that lags behind us. If you are the PM of Turkey and know what really happened but have a population that has been force-fed falsified history for three generations, you have to proceed very, very carefully. This is the real problem in Turkey. And all the recent developments that have been taking place for the past two-three years reinforce my opinion that the state is current conducting a secret campaign to prepare the nation psychologically for an eventual recognition of the genocide. I think by now it has gone too far to stay as a merely cosmetic change. Cheers,
-
ok everyone, here is my motive for inquiring about the reparation business: there are x main obstacles on the turkish side for recognition of the genocide: 1. national pride. turks just don't want to be braceketed together with the nazis, serbs and the like, and the foundations of the republic were built about us being a honourable nation awfully wronged by people from within our ranks (you guys) as well as by enemies from outside (the great powers). 2. the political legacy. many of the prominent people who took part in the deportations and liquidations were later incorporated into the political and administrative structures of the republic, and their direct decendants still survive. 3. the territorial question. not much of a question at all for turks, it is nevertheless still being kept alive by hardliners on both sides, principally for domestic political purposes rather than itself. 4. the confiscated weath. a number of industrial concerns, mostly family businesses, thrived on confiscated armenian wealth, mostly immovables. any solution that incorporates reparation is likely to meet resistance from them, and these guys are strong enough to make and unmake governments in turkey. to avoid them as enemies, one has to find a solution that will satisfy the armenian side, and not unduly harm the turkish side. now about 1), there is now growing awareness that our past does contain dark pages, and the armenian question is so recent, the after effects so obvious, and has been brought to the fore so many times, that the version many turks are prepared to accept is not that different from the armenian one anymore. turks still feel their skin creep when they hear the g-word, but i reckon it is a matter of time before they get reconciled to the notion that some amongst their ranks might have planned such a thing. about 2), most of these guys are dead by now. and since the issue has reached such international proportions, especially with the coming into being of an armenian republic, that whatever political gain obtained from protecting the memory of these guys will be far outweighed by the political losses that any further attempts at burying the issue will cause, and people are well aware of it. about 3), this has always been a romantic rather than a realistic approach. i understand the net majority of armenians are aware that turks simply will not yield an inch of territory, as can be expected from any sovereign state. so it is unrealistic to bring this issue about as if it were a serious, fulfillable desire. this leaves us with 4). the wealth appropriated from the armenians - and greeks - is vast, and much of it is in private hands now. so any move at reparations will put you at loggerheads with a number of very powerful business magnates in turkey. one must understand the scale of the dispute (the amount of wealth) involved and its present whereabouts and status before one can embark on this in an intelligent manner and get results. that was the reason why i was asking this question. comments expected. cheers,
-
a documentary about nemrut dağı in eastern turkey referred to tigran the great and the armenian kingdom, mentioning that the once-powerful armenian kingdom once ruled that part of the country. the program was broadcast during the day (and not 04.00 a.m., for instance) at cnn turk, a channel with a very high rating. this is the first time i hear the word "armenian" in turkish tv outside the contexts of genocide claims, nagorno karabagh etc., and definitely the first time ever i hear "tigran the great" and "armenian kingdom" in a turkish tv channel. also, redgate's book "the armenians" is being translated into turkish. i saw the english original in a bookshop in turkey. i asked whether books concerning "the well-known issue" could also get into turkey, the shop keeper, whom i knew from before, said that there was no more any difficulty in getting that sort of stuff into turkey. it looks like attitudes are changing after all, albeit a bit slowly. comments?
-
dear everyone, i think it would help if i specified the question a bit further: for practical purposes, the wealth of the armenians could perhaps be divided into two categories: the immovables in istanbul and those in anatolia (i am exluding from the discussion movable property because it is a good deal harder to trace unless insured). as far as i know, a plot of land in a decent part of istanbul has always been vastly more valuable than a plot of similar size anywhere in anatolia (correct me if i am wrong, please). i am asking this because i want to know where reparation efforts would concentrate in case of recognition of the genocide and reparative measures taken about it. such a study would show quite clearly which segments of turkish society would oppose it most. and, as for the previous question, i would appreciate titles if there are any published works that are available, preferably over the net. i am asking all this because i do harbour some strong suspicion that the bulk of the claims filed will end up to be about plots in istanbul (which i have nothing against, but i think that that would be the case, and the value thing is an important factor in my thinking). expecting comments, cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Bulent Akarcali is trying to dismiss Genocide claims. Bottom line for all of this is fact that Turkey voided all property right to ANY survivors of the Genocide. This is the "smoking gun." Was EVERY Armenian living in Ottoman Turkey automatically an enemy of the state? How the Turkish Republic approached the SURVIVORS of the Genocide vis-a-vis property rights is a dead giveaway of the motives of the Turkish leaders. Ditto Talaat trying to get American insurance companies to pay the death benefits of massacred Armenians directly to the Turkish state, as related by Morgenthau. hagarag, is there any study of the armenian properties appropriated by the turkish state after the events? if i remember correctly, there was a law back in 1920 that stipulated that the "abandoned goods" of the armenians be returned to them or their inheritors. that law was repealed by another law in 1922, which practically confiscated that property and later on distributed it (sold?) to turkish citizens. i am asking this because even though i keep hearing of these claims (most of which are no doubt true), i have yet to see a claim that rests on either documented evidence or gives reference to a study of the subject. i would be grateful if you can clarify. thanks in advance, yours,
-
gamavor, the above passage by prof. dimitrov misses one essential point: if the turks were so barbaric and really did do the things described therein, how come the bulgarian language, ortodox christianity, bulgarian national identity, bulgarian culture etc. survived for five centuries under turkish rule? apart from that, there are few factual errors and/or selective uses of facts: for instance, church building did continue in bulgaria under the ottomans, otherwise they would not have any churches from the 14th to the 19th centuries, which they do (and the same goes for anatolia). you say that the turks are hated because they imposed their inferior culture and prevented development. i disagree. it is true that the system the ottomans imposed prevented change, but this was because the ottoman empire was essentially medieval in character, and its medieval structures were good enough to keep it going until the seventeenth century. they did not change because there was no incentive to change: they could still defeat the europeans, they were able to provide their subjects with a higher life standard (materially speaking) than the byzantine empire in its last days, which they had overtaken, the ottoman empire in its heyday was a safer place to be in than most of europe, it was cleaner (europeans got the habit of brushing their teeth from turks, and the ottoman empire was full of communal baths at a time when the notion of regular bathing did not exist in europe), and up to the 17th century istanbul life was considered to be an example of civilised living in places no less than paris and london. the europeans developed not because of some inherent superiority of their culture or race, but simply because they were exposed to challenges we were not exposed to. these were 1) us: we were at the time the greatest single power in existence in this part of the world, and consequently provided europe with one hell of a challenge. it is physical exercise that develops muscles, because it presents a challenge to them, and the challenge that we provided to europe was instrumental in three momentous developments in european history: 1) the discovery of the new world (we blocked the traditional eastern route to india and china, and european sailors decided to sail around the globe to reach india by circumventing the ottoman empire), 2) the end of feudal principalities (thanks to our introduction of the use of cannons and arquebuses to siege warfare), 3) development of a military technology that in turn gave rise to the scientific breakthroughs (for instance, the telescope owes its invention in no small part to that of the monoculars borrowed from the muslims during the crusades and later developed by europeans to spot the ottoman navy from a safe distance). we also played an important role in the development of a european identity (the notion of a common enemy plays a significant role in the formation of collective identities) and major centralised powers (there was a need to centralise europe to withstand ottoman advance. a fragmented european map could not do that). 2) themselves: europe was a fragmented continent with no central authority over a large swathe of land, and much of the technical developments that gave rise to later european superiority grew out of the challenges that the fragmented geopolitics of europe presented. this was not the case with the ottoman empire: the ottoman empire had established itself over a huge area, creating a challenge-free realm, a pax ottomanica if you like (given the relative scarcity of rebellions in the ottoman empire, you can call it a pax ottomanica after all), and, unwittingly, sealed their own fate: absence of challenge kills your muscles and numbs your brains. do not forget: it was the north wind that made the vikings vikings. 3) the new world: the new world was a source of disaster for much of europe during the first two centuries it was discovered. it posed huge challenges and out of these challenges grew a more developed and technically superior europe. turks were not subjected to such challenges. they had their challenges a few centuries before that, which had transformed them from a bunch of tribes into founders of world empires, but then that was it. the challenge was gone, the institutions were in place, life was going on, and there were no incentives to change until the end of the seventeenth century, when a series of military defeats and losses of territory brought us home the fact that either we were not what we used to be or the europeans wre not what they used to be, or both. a century of weak sultans, together with the vested interests and political power of the by then corrupt institutions held us in check, but in the next century (the nineteenth) we started with our reforms. but by then it was too late, there were too many challenges and that new explosive idea called nationalism which we had no idea how to deal with. this can be turned into a constructive and informative dialogue if the parties feel so inclined. i for my part am ready. cheers, [ May 10, 2002, 10:21 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
AMAZING: FUTURE BRITISH MONARCH WITH ARMENIAN FACE
aurguplu replied to khodja's topic in Famous Armenians
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Soon Turkish government will be claiming that heir to British throne is part Turkish, just like "Turkish" church in the middle of Lake Van and "Turkish" architect who designed the most magnificent mosque in Istambul. Turks tout about all the prominent Armenians after reforms of 1864, but never speak of what happened to these people or their progeny. hagarag, with all due respect (if you are referring to sinan), the architect in question was most probably not an armenian but a greek from ağırnas/bünyan/kayseri. that's what he wrote of himself in his "tezkiretül bünyan". true, there is popular folk memory that he was armenian, but available documents cast doubt on that (he may have been an armenian affiliated to the greek orthodox church, though). but all things aside, he was clearly an ottoman muslim and his two mosques (süleymaniye and selimiye) bear testimony to this. i live in the city, and i have seen both ayasofya and süleymaniye, and also selimiye in edirne, and they look different (at least inside). this nonsense about "turkish churches" will not be taken seriously by most turks anyway. idiocy is not a criminal offense, is it? cheers, -
hello 1. of all the peoples we have encountered in our history, jews are the only ones we have never had problems with. and we want to keep it that way. if you are short of friends like both turks and jews are, you try to keep the few you have as friends. 2. the fact that there is an israel today is chiefly due to the dismantling of the ottoman empire, in which arabs played a large part by siding with the christian british to rise up against their fellow muslim turks. the result was the creation of the numerous arab states in the arabian peninsula (syria, iraq, saudi arabia, jordan, kuwait, yemen, u.a.r, dubai) and one israel. today we have no pretensions over these lands, and if we have good relations with israel, the one nation that does not have any right to criticise this is the arab nation. you reap what you sow. 3. the israelis and jews in general tend to speak in one voice, whereas the arabs are in complete disarray, stabbing one another in the back. if they cannot have a consensus amongst themselves, how can they expect others to prefer them over other who have? 4. the israelis made a miracle out of a desert, the arabs a desert out of a miracle (the oil). one is naturally inclined to side with the smart at the expense of the dumb. 5. the arabs try to reimpose the backward lifestyle of medieval islam to secular turks. we have this behind us and want to keep it there. 6. both nations had gone quite far in peace negotiations at the time of barak, when arafat blew it all. now they will have to start back from scratch. the comments above stem largely from the religious bunch in turkey, and do not represent the viw of the majority. it is true that we as the rest of the world are highly critical of the situation in palestine, but palestinian responsibility in this cannot be ignored. the arabs must first resolve to recognise israel formally if they want to have a lasting peace and if they want to see a palestinian state formed. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Literature is one thing, state sponsored genocide is another. Peoples of the world share many similarities and a few dissimilarities. literature is a reflection of peoples' thoughts and deeds. the study of european literature (in the broad sense, not confined to belles-lettres) is instrumental in understanding the development of anti-semitism, racism and race-based world dominion ideas of the europeans (the "master race" business). the people who had not had the direct experience of genocides, slave trade, etc. can learn about these things through literature and other material remains. so literature is not irrelevant. I maintain that Turks have a special place on the Pantheon of atrocities. I do not deny all the other atrocities commited by other people, even against its own people, like the terrible situation of North Korea. But what the Turks did is only at par with what the Holocaust. so the annihilation of the native americans or the australians, with an enormous literature justifying the demise of the "inferior races" with the advent of "civilisation brought by the superior race" is not on a par with the armenian genocide, or the holocaust? the europeans had no intention of eradicating the natives in these continents, they died by accident? there was no plan to get rid of them to take their land and possessions? As to the Christian crimes against Muslims, I never denied or diminished their importance. But don´t forget that the Turks and hence the muslims were never gracious guests in those parts of the world. so by the same token if the native americans or australians rose up against their white masters and killed them off or sent them back to europe where they came from (that would include you, mind you), would you say "let's not forget that we were never gracious guests in those parts of the world to begin with"? besides, we have a far greater claim to the lands we inhabit now as we are partial descendants of the indigenous population: we all have some armenian or greek or whatever blood. few americans (the situation is admittedly different in south america) can claim that. The fact is that the Turks are essentially a warrior nation, up to this day ruled by military, and hence what they brought to the world was either the wealth of the conquered people or imperialism of a miltary nature. i largely agree, and i am not particularly proud of it. we are not the only ones, though, the romans and the aztecs were also of the same mould. Don´t be ridiculous comparing the Cherokee experience with the Armenian Genocide. Or misquoting me. i respect you but reserve the right to disagree. the cherokee were invaded, given promises in treaties, every single one of which were broken, killed in battles, and were given blankets infected with smallpox on their trail of tears to ensure maximum casualty rate. if this does not compare with the armenian genocide, then what does (and don't tell me the holocaust, there are differences)? I sense in your comments a guarded hostility towards Armenians that reappears over and over on this "you are not the only victims, blah, blah, blah". your sensors need readjusting. i don't have a guarded hostility towards armenians or guarded anything, if i had, i would not be in this forum, nor would i have used my actual name to be so open as to be identifiable (not right?). but the fact happens to be that you are neither the only, nor the first, nor the last victims of such a crime. this in no way lessens, mitigates, or justifies the crime committed against you, whether or not the turks hold the patent to genocide, or are the only ones responsible for the armenian genocide, or the numbers were half a million, a million, a million and a half, two million, or the armenians had rebelled against the ottoman government and thus provided the cup with a "justification" for genocide, all these are relevant to a point, but to a point. the main point not to be missed is that genocide against the armenians was indeed committed, and three thousand years of armenian presence in eastern anatolia was effectively brought to an end. all the rest is by the way. but that does not give you the right to push the injustice you suffered to the fore at the expense of the others, or give the perpetrators of the crime against you a special place in the pantheon (or pandemonium) of evils at the expense of the others. it would be an injustice to the other victims to say the least. If this is what you have to say about the Genocide your message has come across. well i hope what i wanted to say about the genocide is clearer by now. so rest your case. In the meantime try to sound less like an omniscient. i refrained from making comments on several issues several times, each time quoting my lack of knowledge as a reason. i did not know i was sounding like an omniscient, but i claim to know a thing or two about the things i am talking about - and still trying to learn more. Yor bluffs have been unmasked several times. which ones? examples please. boghos, i understand the indignation of the armenians over the genocide and turkey's refusal to acknowledge it. anyone who has been wronged one way or the other and the wrong not even recognised would. i also understand that it stands out from the rest of world-scale atrocities as far as you are concerned, because it concerns you directly. after all, it was your ancestors and perhaps to a certain extent even you who were directly affected by it. so it is quite understandable that you know and feel more about what happened to your people than what happened to others. it is a normal, understandable feeling common to all humanity, but like all feelings, it must be checked by reason, common sense, and a consideration for others. if you think with a calm head you will realise that we do in fact agree on far more than we realise, but the amount on emphasis we put on various things is a bit different. this should not let us allow the discussion to deteriorate into a verbal fight. we will have our differences, i do not claim to know everything, nor to be always right, and i expect the same from others. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:Ali, Boghos has a point... In fact, the Armenian massacres were very different then any massacres that happened before or during that period. One of the main difference is the destruction of the circulation permits, we can find these references still from the Turkish foreign affairs official archival releases. The Armenians had no right to leave the Ottoman, had no right to go other places then where they were sent, because their circulation right has been taken away. While the Muslim in the Balkans and the Muslims in the Russian empire were killed and expulsed, they were pulled off from these respectif frontiers... it was not the case with the Armenians, and that makes the Armenian case so unique, because this action prove without dough that there was a genocidal policy, it could only be compared with the anti-Imigration plan in NAZI Germany destinated to Isolate the Jews, by removing their right to circulate and leave the country, or the borders controled by the NAZI. The Armenians were sent in the desert, and other area's, and had no right to leave these places, then food and water supply was blocked to them, foreign help was blocked, by admitting that they wish nothing to be done that could prolong their lives... only this alone is enough prove of the extermination policy, it was unique of its kind, the extermination of the children, by fatal injection, mass drowning are well documentated cases of mass killing, the extermination of the orphans and the forced assimilation of the other part of them that are "too young to remember" are unique for the Armenian cases. Many hundreds of thousands of Muslims died and were killed in the Balkans and Russian empire, you have a point, but here again, these people were deported on the exterior, while the deportation of the Armenians was done on the interior, by isolating them. Now what I can ask you is to go at the Turkish official foreign ministry site and read the manipulated archives, all of them, and read them carefully, even if many part are hidding or many others are manipulated, some of these archives that the Turkish republic didn;t found anyhing interesting to destroy them, proves that there is something wrong in them, if you read them carefully you will find it, go and read please Ali, at least one time, and tell me what is wrong... here is where you will find the difference between any crimes of that period, something that the Turkish republic was not able to understand in order to destroy them. Regards Domino i was not denying that there are things unique to the armenian genocide. i was disagreeing with boghos' statement that the turks deserved a unique place in the pantheon of atrocities. i was against that singling-out. i know of the things you mention (but shall also point out that many, many muslims were simply killed outright, and not given the chance to leave). i also know that the treatment of the archives by the authorities is no different than the treatment of soviet archives by soviet authorities. very occasionally, some documents pop out with evidence of government involvement that the authorities have overlooked and made public. gotta dash now, more on this later. cheers,
-
dear boghos, i think i have to add one more thing re my defensive stance if i had one: when you say "the turks had a special place etc", you label a nation in its entirety. now neither me nor anyone from my family took part in, endorsed or approved of the genocide, but they are still turks. the latter generations, who were not even born at the time of the genocide, are also turks. the not so few who refused to comply with the orders, who risked life and limb to save armenians, who fought - for instance in keghi - against the incoming ottoman army not to surrender the armenians, were also turks. my grandfather, whose father was in the cup government, who was increasingly alienated by his displeasure of the treatment of armenians and eventually resigned, and who was the first person to tell me the true nature of the "events", together with the talat quote "i solved the armenian problem for fifty years", was also a turk. i, who recognise the genocide and condemn it, am also a turk. when you attack talat and enver and all the other killers i am all with you. they killed your people and stained our honour. but when you attack the entire turkish nation - and when you say turks this turks that you do, even if unintentionally -, you attack these people and me also. and when you attack me i defend myself. perhaps a little fine-tuning of language and greater consideration for the other side would suffice to solve that conflict. all the best,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, You imply that I portray the Armenian Genocide as a crime of larger importance than all other atrocities because of my emotional attachment or lack of objectivity. Nothing could be farther from the truth. It is exactly the opposite. The analysis of countless other episodes in history has convinced me of what I wrote and maintain: that Turks have a special place in the pantheon of atrocities in history. In practical terms it doesn't change anything, it is simply recognizing history. I did not grow up brainwashed by a weak state. In my family there was never mention of the Turks or Turkey in derogatory terms. I have no anti-Turkey bias. I have never felt the prejudice that Turks feel in Europe. I can understand your defensive posture and even your anti-European Middle Eastern stand. I just think that you are wrong in the way you analyze the Genocide. And that indeed you have spoken about several subjects that you seem to understand little about. I have seen that in other threads but I could mention, for example, your comment about the Jews in Germany not feeling attached to the land. I think ad hominem attacks are of course ridiculous. And I have had my share of them. I do not want this to evolve into a shouting match. Absolutely not. Nor do I want to convince you of my point of view, since I see that your answers most often distort what I write rather than focusing on its essence. Dear Ali, I very much welcome your presence here, a fellow UWC graduate of all things. Please understand that for me the Genocide is much more a Turkish problem than an Armenian one. Cheers, Boghos dear boghos, i was not implying lack of objectivity on your part, i simply thought - sincerely - that you had a special "attachment" to the armenian genocide because you are an armenian yourself. i do not think that there is anything wrong with that, by the way, who could accuse you of anything for having a special stance about things that happened to your own people? but you say that in your judgement no emotion is involved, o.k. i take your word for it. what i disagree with is the special place in the pantheon of atrocities you give my nation to. that we have a place, and probably a distinguished place, in that pantheon i do not doubt (if i did i would not be here). but if we have that special place, then the germans, the americans, the british, the spanish and the portuguese occupy equally special places in my opinion and i do cling to that opinion of mine. i have also read countless other atrocities, including ours (the armenian one is not the only one) and that reading gave me the conviction that we are not alone. please bear in mind that this "we are not alone" is not a mitigating factor, nor do i intend to use it that way: hitler was not alone, there was stalin, but that does not make him any less evil. the mongols and turks had attila the hun, genghis khan and tamerlane, amongst others, the spanish the inquisition and the conquistadores (pissarro and cortes, then diego de landa who destroyed the entire pre-columbian mayan literary heritage in a single bonfire), the americans had slave trade and the plight of the natives, the aussie the plight of the aborigines, and institutionalised racism is the collective guilt of "civilised" europe, from which the middle east can largely be claimed to have been free. we did not treat people according to the colour of their skin. we did not wonder for two hundred years whether other races were quite as human as we were. it did not take us years to realise that "the natives had souls that could be saved (catholic church). there were no cases of african pygmies being exhibited in cages in zoos because we thought they were a species of animal (the pygmy in question spoke passable english)(this in an american zoo in the 19th century). these are western crimes. we didn't have those. we had others. ours are huge, and many other crimes pale in comparison with ours, but some don't. the above is a small sample of those that don't. this is why i reject the notion that we have a "special" place in the history of atrocities. i am not quite sure that my posture regarding the genocide can be called defensive. this for the following reasons: i. i accept that what transpired was a genocide. ii. i take no justification or defense for a genocide. there cannot be a legitimate reason to kill an entire nation. period. iii. i accept that it was us who carried it out. this is important because some of those (apologists) who recognise the genocide - or, rather the killings themselves - try to shift at least some of the blame on the shoulders of the kurds because they were the ones who actually carried out the butchery. no. we are squarely to blame. but we were not the only ones. talat and enver deserve the highest possible punishment for what they did, but they were not the only ones who did. what about wangenheim? what about those german officers who assisted the turks in i) concealing it, and ii) in actually carrying it out? and if we deserve a trial (we do) we can at least get a fair one where all the suspects are lined up. this is only now taking place with the german archives being opened. as for my anti-european stance, i have been educated at european schools, studied the middle east in europe, lived both in turkey, in europe, and in the middle east, enjoy, cherish and respect certain elements in both cultures, and resent, abhor and despise others, again in both cultures. i try to keep an even balance to the best of my ability. i am not an advocate of the middle east, nor - and i think that is more to the point - that of europe, i try to point out the rights and wrongs of both. i may have spoken about certain subjects beyond my current level of expertise, i concede. it is not something that i defend, and if you recall, i had actually taken back some statements i had made re that subject and others, when i was convinced that the explanation provided by the others was more convincing. i was in no way intending to distort your posts to "prove" a certain point, in fact i was trying to get to the essence. i may have misunderstood you, but if this was the case, then it wasn't intentional. i took to mean that the essence of your last few posts was that the turks had a special place in the pantheon of atrocities, that there was something about the armenian genocide that set it apart from all other disasters like the ones i mentioned above save the holocaust, and even in the case of the holocaust, it was inspired by the armenian genocide (this last i agree with in fact). this is what i disagreed with, wit no intention to mitigate our crime: we have the genocide ok, but we have no institutionalised racism. no nation, however small, got totally extinct because of us. we never doubted that other humans were just as human as us. we hated, we tortured, we killed our enemies, but we never doubted they were people like us. i think the inability - or reluctance - of the europeans to recognise other members of their own species is the epitomy of all human crimes (and incidentally, the armenian genocide was perpetrated not by the islamic-oriented clergy but by the western-trained military and bureaucracy. the clergy tried to stop it several times, and in some small cases, they succeded). ours is of an order of magnitude just a notch (not more) below that. we knew you were people like us, and we knew that we were killing our fellow men. the europeans failed to see their fellow men in men of colour. that is the difference, and no amount of explantaion can convince me that it isn't the most significant one. dear boghos, i enjoy being here as mch as you enjoy having me here. we are of course going to have our differences of opinion and sometimes hot debates about them, but as long as the intentions are good, it will be all right. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:TB, you touched the hearth of the problem I think, justifications accusing others and saying that they have been inspired by him or them etc... is irrelevant, and many denialists do this, by accusing what happened on some sort of inspiration of the French revolution, Pan-Germanism, or even more Pan-Slavism etc... all this is irrelevent, it is not because a sick watch a film on TV and on the film someone kill his wife, that this will justify that the sick watching the film was inspired and killed his wife... could this be used on court ? Of course not... There is some other denialists that find theories such as Pan-Armenism, or the "Greater Armenia" and allege that Turks have been inspired by this, you imagine, the Young-Turks exterminating the people that they say having been inspired to commit this act... Well I will not continue and enter in some vague subject, in order to not risk a divergence with you Domino we must observe the important distinction between explanation and justification. i am trying to explain (or rather understand), not justify. if i were the type of person who would attempt to justify a genocide i would not have been in this forum. what would i be saying to you guys? "we killed you alright, but we were right in doing so, you had deserved it blah blah blah?" no. but there are facts that must be taken into account and given due weight in the discussion of the subject if we want to understand it, and not merely condemn it. it is true that some denialist or apologist is going to use the said facts to prove his point, but as we all know that the genocide did indeed happen, and that it is wrong to kill innocent people for whatever reason (i am against killing people altogether, but there seems to be no consensus in the world on that yet), what he says will say more about him than the genocide. that certain facts do not fully support our version of the events should not make us ingore, or worse still, deny them. that would put us on the same level as the denialists or apologists. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:tb, you say it should not matter by whom they were inspired. by the same logic, usama bin ladin is irrelevant. Guilt is not a "limited resource". In other words, if there is someone that inspired, aided, or facilitated a crime, that someone has commited a crime in addition to the crime being discussed. Bin Laden is irrelevant in determining the guilt (or extent thereof) of the killers. A terrorist cannot say in court "but he inspired me; so that's 10 years off my sentence, and 10 years added to his". The terrorist is fully responsible for his crime. tb you misunderstood me. of course i am not saying that the terrorist is not fully responsible (or more accurately, that he has a right to a lesser sentence because he was inspired by someone else) for his crime: after all, all mentally normal free persons have independent judgement, they can judge the morality, outcome, and consequences of their actions. this is the case with the young turk government. the entire world might have conspired to kill the armenians, but that doesn't lessen turkish culpability. but turks were not the only ones, as is becoming clearer now. i am no legal expert, but as far i i know, in a case of gang rape, the sentence is not divided by the number of the assailants, is it? the relevance of the source of inspiration is important for us if we want to understand the whys and hows of the genocide in addition to condemning it. condemning is right, but it is easy once you have the facts in front of you and a sincere conscience. it is the understanding part that is difficult: it is more akin to an investigation. and to any criminal inspector, the source of inspiration is important because it can lead to further clues regarding the case. consider a street shootout between two drug-pushing gangs with casualties. if you stop your investigation at the trigger-pullers, you will not have gotten to the root of the problem, i.e. the drug barons. what you have to do is carry it on till you get to the source of it. this is what i was trying to say, because i believe the main point in studying a genocide would be to find ways of prevention for possible future genocides. if we don't do that, we will just have condemned one criminal, and waiting for the next with folded arms. i hope this clarifies a bit. cheers,
-
dear tb, dear Domino, in the above discussion, several key issues are being overlooked as far as i can see: 1. russia. the ottoman turks were very wary of the danger that russia posed. it was known from before that the russians wanted to descend to the warmer seas (the mediterranean), and the only realistic way they could do this was through the ottoman empire. their agitation of the balkan minorities to the west, most of whom, with the exception of the albanians and the greeks, were slavic, and the armenians to the east, can - and was - seen as a two-pronged move to provide russia with direct access to the mediterranean. in the balkans, all major non-muslim communities (with the notable exception of thessaloniki jews) were orthodox christians, so were many of the armenians in the east. now it is very easy, once you get the armenian highlands in eastern anatolia, to sweep across the cilician plain, which had a substantial armenian population anyway, and wash your boots in the mediterranean. the turks were - and still are - aware of this, and therefore that territory was vital, and the armenians prior to the genocide and even prior to the hamidian massacres of the 1890s, had formed revolutionary committees, which are known to have been at some relation to the patriarchate in istanbul (to the best of my knowledge the armenians themselves do not deny this), and therefore they could not be trusted, at least in the eyes of the young turks. now of course how much weight these committees carried with the armenian public in general, and how much unity of purpose and action they showed are of course matters of debate (which i shall not engage in due to my lack of expertise), but that these trends existed and were a source of grave concern for the ottoman administration is a settled fact. this appears to me to have been one of the main reasons why the eastern territories were vital and why the armenians could not be trusted neighbours. 2. oil: armenia lies northwest of azerbaijan and iran, and north of present-day iraq (roughly), both known oil-producing regions at the time. everybody wanted these places for the oil. the armenians stood in the way of germans, russians, and the british as a small but capable nation with unreliable loyalties. you needed a pretext to get rid of the turk in these regions, and what better pretext than to create the conditions which would lead the barbaric muslim to do away with a captive christian nation (the first to accept christianity, on top of it all) in the (relative) proximity of the holy land? that would immediately turn turkey into an international pariah and would provide tremendous popular support to "throw the turk bag and baggage out of europe (gladstone)". i do not claim that the above is the truth, the only truth, and nothing but the truth, but i think it should be taken into account. i shall address a few other points in forthcoming posts. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:I entirely agree that the Kurdish question is much more an issue of Ataturk´s ideology than anything else. The reference to the Ottomans is just that the tendency to solve things by the sword has remained. that tendency is not unique to the turks, it has never been. Languages have disapeared all over the world, it is a result of what some people call "cultural genocide", but I find that quite extreme, languages will disappear, change, etc as a result of cultural imperialism, or in more neutral terms: the prevalence of a culture over another for whatever reason. All languages are full of Americanisms. Is that bad ? I don´t see why, it is foolish to fight against that. If states concentrated in giving proper education to their people, that would be enough, but you cannot stop the tide. Language is a living entity, not something confined to a glass redome. Naturally, the imposition of another language is quite different and you have mentioned the example of the Irish. boghos i was referring to the deliberate destruction of a language, together with the cultural identity, in order to break the back of a nation to ultimately assimilate them and kill the identity. this cannot be compared to americanism: we are free to choose or not to choose americanisms today, they weren't. The Cherokee trail of tears: as unfortunate as it might have been it was not done with the same intention or cruelty as the Armenian Genocide. i have known some cherokees who would disagree. Look there were no Americans rejoicing while young Cherokee girls were made to dance naked while people abused them, there were no burnt churches with the faithful inside, there were no unthinkable rapes and other forms of terrible abuse against women and children, and the list goes on. boghos in replying this i don't have to cross the atlantic, what the balkan slavs, the greeks etc. had done to the muslims in the 19th century would suffice. all of the above, plus some more perversions, such as cutting open pregnant women's bellies and chopping off the fetus in the form of a cross, boiling children alive in front of their parents, making parents copulate with their children etc., the list would go on. There has never been, by any colonial power or otherwise, an effort of the scale of the Armenian Genocide. genocide is not determined by scale. it is determined by the intent. if you have a native tribe 5,000 strong and attempt to kill all of them, but manage to kill only 2,000, it is still genocide. there were many such small-scale genocides, because the separate tribes in questin were small in numbers (but there were many of them). plus it had not been recorded for posterity to the extent that the armenian genocide was. the extent of access to graphic material in such matters can affect your point of view markedly. The holocaust comes next. This is a fact. Colonial powers were often very cruel to their subject population, but they never tried to anihilate a population on the scale of the Armenian Genocide. i disagree on that in the case of the native americans and africans, and the case of the herero in german south africa. plus read the racist literature of the time and you will see clearly "the inevitability of the extinction of the inferior races when faced with civilisation (paraphrased quote, can be found in versions in so many major western literary figures of the 18th-19th centuries that you would not want to read that period anymore). This is your heritage, I am afraid, it is not shared by all the other European countries, or America, Canada, and even latin America. this is my heritage, i am afraid, and i have to learn to live with it, and yes, it is shared by many countries: germany (as we have seen), sweden (eugenics programmes in force until the 1970s - can you imagine?) france (algeria) china (tibet, sinkiang), russia (the list is too long) england, usa, australia. too bad. note that i am not trying to deny the fact that we have that heritage, nor am i trying to "justify" or "mitigate" it in any way, i myself would be the first to oppose that (in fact i am doing this over here). but to be portrayed as the embodiment of all evil as if we were the only, or the greatest, evil on earth, and especially by evils in no way smaller and possibly much greater than ourselves, no, i cannot accept that, i am sorry. It is just not the same. Cruelty is an integral part of history, but some nations are especially good at it. all nations are equally good at it given the opportunity. look at israel today.
-
dear boghos, i think i am getting slightly misunderstood. i fear you are thinking that i) i am trying to find justifications for a genocide, and ii) i am trying to shift the burden of genocide from turkish shoulders onto german ones. both are incorrect, and i am sorry if i came across implying that sort of thing. now re the points: 1. we all know how minorities are being treated in turkey, but we would be mistaken to conclude that this attitude is a continuation of the old ottoman habits merely because it is cruel. i would concede that the oppression of the alevis in turkey harks back to the times of yavuz sultan selim (reg. 1512-1520), but in the case of the kurds, it appears to be a typically western form of oppression, a kind of cultural genocide, of the type implemented by the english on the celts, the americans on the native americans, the russians on the non-russians, the chinese on the tibetan etc. this form of cultural genocide, where the target is not people in flesh and blood, but an identity, a culture, a way of life, appears to me to be a relatively recent (last 200 years) development from the west. the turks were not quite that sophisticated. what they wanted was obedience, they couldn't care less about the language you spoke, the god you worshipped (as long as you paid the cizye) and the name by which you called yourself. you see, the ottomans regarded it as only natural that a state was composed of different nations, and they even took great pride in that: after conquering istanbul, mehmed ii gave the local greeks to stay or leave (they could retain their customs and religion if they chose to stay), and when many chose to leave, the sultan brought greeks from sinope and had them settled in istanbul!). they did cherish variety, they made quite good use of it, and they were also proud that they ruled over so many different nations and called emperor in so many different languages. the republican turks, however, are afraid of the very existence of foreign elements in turkey lest they side with enemies of turke to break the country apart, so they try to assimilate them as much as they can. this is more compatible with the notion of a nation state and ethnic lines, as opposed to religious ones, dividing peoples, itself a european idea. so the oppression of the kurds (it is coming to an end now, hopefully). is a new type of phenomenon, it would be inaccurate to compare it to pre-abdulhamid type of oppression in turkey. 2. the british organised the irish famine in the 19th century, and the americans did deport the entire cherokee nation from northeastern usa to middle america, during which trail (the famous cherokee trail) the majority of the nation perished. they did that with a good many native maerican tribes, with the result that about three quarters of the native languages spoken in the americas at the time of contact have gone extinct. the american policy with the indians have become so "successful" that it is estimated that none (NONE) of the native languages (and hence, in the long run, identities) will survive yet another century. an entire branch of humanity is slated for extinction. the same holds true for the australian aborigines. one of my english teachers was an irishman. this is what he told us about the disappearance of irish gaelic from ireland: "irish children were compelled to attend schools set up by the english, where any irish child who first spoke a word of gaelic during the day was given a belt to wear across his shoulder. the belt would then pass on to the second child who spoke a gaelic word, and so on until the end of the day. the last child to wear the belt would be flogged publicly in front of all the other children". he told us that in 1983, and he had seen it happening when he was a child. boghos, i know that what happened to your nation was a shame on humanity's record, and especially my nation's record, but you are not the only ones who suffered it, and many people whom you expect to defend your position and rights are guilt of the same type of crimes. this is of course not a pretext for us going on the way we have, but everytime i see a european or american calling us barbarians because of it, i see a pot calling a kettle black. cheers,
-
tb, you say it should not matter by whom they were inspired. by the same logic, usama bin ladin is irrelevant. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, It seems to me that your case in what concerns the Genocide was based on the accpetance of it as a historical truth, but with mitigating circumstances, such as the "decisive" influence of German ideology on carrying it on. i refuse to accept the existence of "mitigating" circumstances for a genocide. period. the german influence is a fact, not fiction, and i understand recently the germans themselves have started to talk about it. Not only that but going as far as stating that were not that to have happen, most likely the Genocide wouldn't have taken place and Armenians would have been living happily alongside Turks ever since. whether both nations would be living happily side by side everafter is doubtful, but that there would possibly not be a genocide (meaning intentional destruction of a people as a whole) is quite probable, and i cling to that opinion of mine. TB has done a good job in demistifying this theory, if we can call it that, so I won't go further than saying that this typically Middle Eastern sort of conspiracy theory mindset is removed from the truth. with all respect to tb, no, he hasn't, in my opinion, although i would not totally disagree with everything he said. briefly my main point was that he saw the genocide in a vacuum as the result of a conflict between the turks and the armenians, completely overlooking the fact that some very powerful outside players with their various and often conflicting interests were present in the game. Believeing that the Ottoman Empire was an example of tolerance and respect for human and ethnic rights is akin to believeing that the Easter Bunny will be at your doorstep shortly. this would have been correct if one were to apply today's standards to the ottoman empire. but if one applied the standards of those days, it holds water, i think (consider the treatment of the blacks, australians and native americans under the whites in the 19th century). this is of course not to say that the ottoman empire was not most cruel with its own subjects, and i would not for a moment think tha it would stand up to any serious trial in terms of human rights as we know it, but again, that concept itself is quite new and still not fully settled. Now you come up with a rehash of already tired nonsense such as "the Armenians were not loyal" (and the typical implication that they probably deserved their fate) 1. have you read boghos noubar, or others, claming how they had sided with the allied powers since the beginning of the war, and that therefore they deserved a state of their own. or, more to the point perhaps, are you not aware of the activities of the armenian patriarchate that go back to 1878 (if i remember the date correctly). or, even more to the point, would you say that the ottoman armenians in the late 19th century - before the hamidian massacres - had not harboured ideas of independence and not taken some inspiration from the greek and other balkan struggles? was the concept of an independent armenia completely new to the armenians prior to the 1890s or 1915? were there no societies that promoted the idea, no written material printed by the patriarchate and distributed across anatolia, no maps in armenian showing a dismembered ottoman state and an independent armenia emerging out of it (i saw some of these myself)? please do not get me wrong. i do not "accuse" armenians of treason. you have every moral right to rebel against a government that is not legitimately yours and treating you in a horrible fashion. you cannot "accuse" a nation for wanting to be independent, but accusing the state that governs them to attempt to protect its very existence is also tricky: imagine that you are a white american citizen. you respect human rights and deplore the plight of the native americans. at that time, one indian nation forms about ten per cent of the total american population. they have managed to keep their ethnic identity, have not forgotten what the whites had done to them, they were sophisticated, and at that time america had grown weak and was attacked by enemies who promised these natives (and all other disaffected non-whites) their own piece under the sun. the natives are inspired by the dissolution of the soviet union and how their natives got their independence. so they form societies and secretly prepare for a rebellion to ultimately throw off the white yoke and get their land back. the move gets widespread to the point that something must be done about it, and remember, the usa is not any longer what is was decades ago. you are the compassionate white american (preferably wasp) with power. what would you do, boghos? you have a moral right to prepare for a fight, but wouldn't it be naive to expect that the state in question would not take any measures? do we see that in history? is that what the french, the british, the dutch, the germans, the spanish, the portuguese, the americans are recorded to have done with their subject peoples? to see them get organised for rebellion and watch with folded arms? 2. i had hoped that it would be obvious from my past posts that i categorically refuse the notion of any nation "deserving" a genocide. i see with dejection that my message has not gotten through. a genocide is against an entire people, men women and children, with no consideration given to who is "guilty" or "innocent". and a new but completely groundless theory that oil had anything to do with the Genocide. 1. the theory is not new, it is also not fabricated by the turks (it was there when i was at oxford) 2. it is not completely groundless, especially if you look at the geology and 20th political development of the region. Do you also believe that all the Balcan nations were very happy living under Ottoman yoke and were it not for Russia they would have remained under the Ottoman's magnaminous umbrella ? no, i don't, but quite a few of them were not particularly happy with the byzantines, either (or for that matter with eachother). do not forget that the slavs are not native to the area (they invaded the balkans in the 6th-7th centuries) and the greeks do not see their presence there any more agreeable than that of the turks (remember the row over the "former yugoslav republic of macedonia"s name). Dear Ali, it is not only Turkey's recent record in human rights that is a disaster (you are still looking at the European Union through very powerful binoculars, I am afraid), it has been so from the very beginning. i know. but that is the case with every single nation. with some nations, it is covert (the swiss: they store the blood and sweat of the world in the form of bank accounts, the swedish: appearing to be doves, they are one of the largest arms producers and sellers to conflict regions), with others, it is overt and you can do nothing about it: america, israel and china, for instance. with still others, it is overt and you can do something about it (because the nation concerned is not strong enough to resist), although what you (usually the west) do is in most cases motivated by material gain and not a concern for human rights, and ultimately does not affect the victim positively. turkey falls into this category together with iraq, afghanistan and the african states. [ March 28, 2002, 03:10 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
hello there are some points that needs to be addressed in the above posting: 1. the jews are one of the very few peoples that the turks had good relations throughout history on a more-or-less consistent basis: a medieval turkic kingdom, that of khazaria, adopted judaism in 740 AD and became a shelter for many jews, and a - small - part of askenazim jews are partial descendants of this turkic nation. tukak, the father of seljuk, the founder of the seljuk sultanate, was a commander in the khazar army, and one of the first-degree relatives of seljuk (a brother/son/uncle(?)) was called israel. later on, when the spanish inquisition gave the jews a choice between conversion and expulsion in 1492 (the year columbus "discovered" america), the ottoman sultan bayezid ii gave them shelter in ottoman turkey, and our sephardic jewish community stems from that time. also, jewish pogroms, which are characteristic of european history, are generally absent from turkish history. this attitude continued throughout turkish history, for instance, the ottoman government did not oppose the settlement of jews in palestine after the start of the zionist movement in the 19th century, and saved turkish jews (and, if i remember correctly, some non-turkish ones as well) from the nazis. turkey was also the first muslim country to recognise the state of israel, and that without delay, in 1949 if i remember correctly. to this day we are the only muslim country that had consistently good relations with israel. it is something the more intelligent of us cherish and we intend to keep it that way. 2. the turks could only save turkish jews, and not non-turkish ones, because germany wanted turkey as an ally in war (which turkey carefully avoided), and so could make certain concessions to turkey, but turkey on the other hand could not ask for more than that, as that would amount to a declaration of war to germany, and turkey was in no position to militarily afford that at that time. turks did their best to save what they could, and their best was not that bad at all (this at a time when the other countries of europe, who denigrate germany freely now, either turned a blind eye to german atrocities or actually collaborated with them in the extermination of the jews). 3. the sinking of the struma was a tragedy that we could not avert, because taking them to turkish soil would mean war with germany. as stated above, we did our best to save as many jews, but we were in no position to engage in a war effort against germany at the time. a word on the hitler quote: much ink has been spilled on that, whether it was verified or not, but a point is being missed: who remembers the armenians now? well, hitler certainly did, as he was a german, and one who had fought in wwi. his nation is squarely to blame for the armenian genocide almost as much as the turks are, if ambassador morgenthau's story (which may be partly, but not totally, dismissed as wartime propaganda) is to be trusted. it is quite possible that the actual idea of genocide was a german invention, and the turks such as talat and enver, and a good many balkan muslim refugees who had flooded anatolia then, had good (!) reasons to hate christians, became unwitting collaborators in the realisation of german plans for the ultimate german aim of middle eastern (and then world) domination. i for one believe that if it weren't for the germans, the armenians would have suffered a good deal less and there would be a viable armenian population in turkey today. cheers,
