Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
quote:Originally posted by nellie: nowadays, I do consider the strongest as the fittest. In a limited time frame, strongest does indeed look like the fittest. In longer time frames though, the relevance of strength vanishes. quote: Strong, however, isn't only meant physically. Indeed. But does a bully have the right kind of strength in greater abundance than the bullied?
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: OK, let's address the curiosity. In the earlier postings I did not claim the ny ancestry was overwhelmingly Anatolian (if I did, then I was wrong). What I cliamed was that my ancestry had a significant Anatolian component, in addition to the Turkic and other components. After all, I speak Turkish as native language and claim TUrkish ethnicity. This must have come from somewhere. Therefore, I do not think I have made an about-face. Curiosity addressed? No, it has not been addressed. You previously implied that you were essentially of the same stock as the ancient population of Urgup. You just can't have it both ways, that's all. quote Having one "valid" personality as the front of a group does not exclude the possibilty that a group exists. However, I take your word for it. quote I did; right in the post you are replying to. Anyway, the important thing is all of us should make a conscious effort to eliminate hypocrisy and jingoism from our world views. I try, in my humble and small way, to encourage Armenians to do the same. quote:in the friendliest and most humanistic sense. really? Really. That shouldn't be so hard to believe. Friendly and firm are not mutually exclusive. [ January 11, 2002: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: ... to speak related languages, you must at least share part of your ancestry. Absolutely not. Many a Jamaican would attest to that Seriously, in many cases the language is simply imposed, and whole regions adopt it out of "convenience" (in its most general sense). That's not to say a Bangladeshi does not share any ancestry with a Swede. However, it is unlikely that the extent of it is higher than with, say, Ethiopians. And take any Tamil (Dravidian) from the region, and their shared ancestry with a garden variety Bangladeshi would be much, much higher. It would be entirely silly for the poor Bangladeshi (behind whose back we have been talking ) to identify with a Swede more than with a southern Indian. quote: 3. the turks were not formed by detonating nuclear bombs in anatolia to eliminate the native population. the turks were alive and kicking long before they came to turkey, stayed in anatolia as turks for almost a millenium, and until the last quarter of the 19th century there were no mass killings of the native (or, more accurately, earlier) anatolians, otherwise the armenians, greeks and kurds together would not have made up about a third of the anatolian population, nor would the turks be physically indistinguishable from whatever earlier anatolian population they lived in the vicinity of. My point was that the modern Turkish identity is largely a product of "forced" assimilation. By "forced" I don't necessarily mean "at gun-point". When a typical "Turkish" person from modern Turkey glorifies (or even symapthizes/identifies with) the "ancient Turkish", he is doing nothing other than glorifying the group that bullied (most of) his ancestors and changed their cultural identity, language, and religion, in other words the essence of their being. Therefore, I am disappointed to see an otherwise enlightened Turk do that. However, I have absolutely no problem with a Turk being proud of the achievements of the republican Turkey, whatever they may be. The shameful parts, we don't have to touch in this thread. quote Slighting the plight of Uighurs was not my intention. Believe me, I sympathize with the Uighurs for the very reasons that you mentioned. quote: ali suat (a single person and not a group, and ny name not a moniker) It's obviously OK by me even if it is a moniker, since mine obviously is. Regards, Twilight Bark (a moniker)
-
quote:Originally posted by highflyer: It is indeed a interesting question.But the problem is there are no abslutes in parenting. I try to raise my son as neither a bullie or sissy.Its easyer to raise your child to be strong but kind.If a fight is brought to you finish it and if you see someone who has been treated badly be a comfort to them. I agree with you. However, if you absolutely had to choose one of the choices, and the wizard will turn your child into either a "bully" or "bullied", which one would you choose. Let us also assume that the "bullyness" trait is an inherent one, a part of your offspring that he will carry into his adulthood and possibly to his progeny. What would you choose? In other words, would you rather begin with a "bullied" child and teach him how to stand up to the bullies, or start with a "bully" child and teach him to be kind?
-
quote:Originally posted by nellie: 1)survival of the fittest, or in other words, of the strongest. Dear Nellie, Thanks for your thoughtful reply. Without touching on the rest of the issue yet, let me point out that fittest and strongest are very distinct concepts. We don't see Tyrannosaurus Rex around anymore
-
If you absolutely had to choose one of the following two choices: 1. Your child bullies weaker kids and steals their lunch money 2. Your child is the bullied one Which one would you choose?
-
quote:Originally posted by highflyer: I would choose the intelligant every time as many intelects can not do simple daily tasks. I would take the intellect specialized in business, and then use the money to hire the intelligent for doing the daily tasks for me. And I would take special care not to abuse my power over the intelligent
-
quote:Originally posted by highflyer: #1-I agree as absolute power corrupts absolutly Also to mistake intelect for intelligance is a common acurrance,I would choose the intelligant every time as many intelects can not do simple daily tasks. A example is Albert Ienstien who had trouble counting change for a purchase in a store. But Mr. Baliozian didn't say absolute power. He said any power. Since it is physically impossible for two people(s) to have precisely, exactly the same level of "power", the logical conclusion is that everyone will abuse everyone else whenever they get the slightest chance, which would be absurdly often. He also thinks that the only difference between the persecutors and the persecuted is that the former are better in grabbing power. Even if we assume that Mr. Baliozian had a magical threshold in mind for the power difference, the implication that the persecuters/executioners/thieves are thus overall "better" than the victims is a central aspect of Baliozianism. Baliozianism also avoids any mention of the observation that some cultures simply do not pursue domination over others while others pursue it with utmost arrogance and violence.
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: So, let us say they are native Armenian words and pass the onus on them to prove otherwise. Exactly. Bravo Arpa! Without any bias, one can make the argument that since the indo-european language spread from the Armenian direction (regardless of whether Armenia was the "ground-zero" of the indo-european language) towards Persia, it is entirely reasonable that the speakers of "proto-Armenian" used the precursors of those words before Pahlavi and Persian diverged into distinct languages.
-
Yikes! quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:and the Chinese throughout history referred to Turks and other “northern barbarians” as “fire-haired monkeys”. From the beginnings of the Turkish Republic, there was a constant desire to identify with the "superior blond-eyed, fair-haired people". You parrot the same strain of thought (I am beginning to think that you sympathize with Grey Wolves but that's another topic; many left-wing Turks have amazingly right-wing ideas about language, nation, culture and history). The fire-haired "monkeys" were most probably the "Saka", or the Scythians. The Scythians were one of the most bloodthirsty and barbaric of the "Indo-European" tribes, and formed natural alliances with the Mongolian/proto-Turkic tribes. One theory about the name "Turk" is that it comes from "Tarkhun", an diety that Scythians worshipped and passed onto the tribes that became later the "Turks". However, the thought that the "original" Turks were blond-haired and blue-eyed is a fantasy encouraged by the German pseudo-scholarship that was very popular among the elite of the early Turkish Republic. Get rid of it already. quote Such derogatory descriptions are very common in "culture clashes". Arians and Dravidians called each other similar names when they first interacted. While I completely disagree with "all cultures are equally violent and bloodthirsty" suggestion usually made by the "winners" of history, making fun of "foreign" cultures and races is nearly universal. No big deal. quote:“Our race incorporated many different nationalities and it is still continuing this process today.” In a process called forced assimilation and, at times, genocide. Your race is currently conducting above-ground nuclear tests in the vicinity of Uighur cities in Sinkiang to make sure that all the Uighurs get radiated and are unable to reproduce viable offspring. Come on now, Ali Suat. Really. What do you think the modern "Turk" is a result of? You base your argument on the premise that those living in glass houses should not throw stones. Heed your own premise. quote Absolutely not. Linguistic relationship alone does not imply such ancestral commonality. Thanks to empire builders that you appear to admire, the linguistic relationships are buried too deep under the noise to provide much guidance one way or the other. quote:“It is also hard to imagine how Koreans can claim kinship with the Turks of Turkey. They are both completely different; believe me.” The Swedes and Bangladeshis are kinsmen even though they are completely different from one another. Ridiculuous. They obviously have totally different ancestry. They probably diverged not long after Homo-Sapiens walked out of Africa. quote
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route. While I also have little patience with the jingoistic attitude exemplified by "chinese scholar", you also demonstrate appalling deficiencies in your overall outlook on history, nation and culture. You have to work much harder to cleanse yourself from the silliness otherwise known as the "Official Turkish History". While the "pan banditica" established by the organized crime structures otherwise known as "empires" may have provided temporary stability over a wide area, their (I mean the empire builders', not their subjects') contribution to human culture are grossly exaggerated by their cultural heirs, be it post-Romans (Europeans) or post-Ottomans ("Turk"s). quote:if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. It might have taken a little longer. But their inventions would most definitely leak out eventually. A bloodthirsty empire was not necessary to leak out the inventions of the Near Easterners. And one was not necessary for the Chinese. Knowledge cannot be contained in one area forever. It is just a matter of timescale; and don't worry, it would not be a geological time scale As members of a "tribe" that suffered too much under a variety of empires, while having aspired to establish no such thing for ourselves, it is Armenians' morally defensible duty to expose the stupidity represented by empire-worshipping strains in modern culture and scholarship.
-
The original nucleus of Ordu turms out to be a small town that had an Armenian community. Their church was named "Asdwadz Orti" (meaning Christ). The long name was shortened to Orti by the locals, and eventually deformed to Ordu; a word that has a meaning in Turkish.
-
Armenian GDP increased by 9.6% in January-October 2001
Twilight Bark replied to Azat's topic in Economy
quote:Originally posted by Juggernaut: I dont think impeachment is a good idea, whoever becomes president is going to 'eat'. It is my belief that after a certain period of time Armenian politicians have enough to 'eat' and actually start contributing, after all they cant 'eat' forever. An impeachment will make things worse and only add to the confusion and insecurity. Note: I am not a supporter of Khocharian, in fact I think it is a bad idea of having someone from Artsakh running Armenia. I agree that disrupting the government would not be productive at all. I also think that Kocharian has turned out to be a disappointment in many ways. However, I don't think his being from Artsakh has anything to do with it. We saw what happened with the "native" politicians such as Ter Petrossian. Yuck. Where is the alternative? Who is the knight in shining armour? Let's face it; Armenia currently lacks the societal dynamics to "snap out of it". So we'll wait until they slowly stumble out of their current rot. If the rest of the society has too much inertia the individual in the president's office hardly matters unless he is someone with a small mind but an inflated ego. Now that would be a disaster; and Armenia had that before in her first president. Unless we get the equivalent of Ataturk, which is an unlikely, freak event that occurs very rarely anywhere. And we haven't had much "luck" since Katch Nazar . -
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: We may know what you may have had in mind. Amot!!! If by "crowd" it is meant to mean "horda" tis is used in the Armenian, as "Mongolakan hordaner" etc.)then I hate to rain on your parade. "horda" does mean crowd, it is from the English "horde" a word usually applied to ragtag collection of invading people often applied to Asian invaders. There is a reason for its Asian (Mongolian) application since the word "horde" is from the Turkish "ordu" which in general means "army" but it seems it originally was used to describe invading... HORDES. I did understand the connection between "ordu" or "horda" and "crowd", although I did not think it was part of "official" Armenian lexicon (don't have my dictionary with me ). However, as you pointed out, it is a word borrowed from Turkic languages. That hardly counts as Armenian, especially when we are talking about a city in Turkey! According to Bilge Umar, the present name of Ordu is the result of deforming an Armenian name of unrelated meaning, so as to make it sound sensible in Turkish. And he makes a reasonable case for it. Last chance everyone!
-
quote:Originally posted by dragon: Ordu in armenian means pazmutiun, tsegh, dohm. In English may be crowd. oh pardon me my English is very poor, so I have no right to give any explanation in English I am not aware of "ordu" meaning "crowd" in Armenian. And that is not the origin I had in mind. Hmm.
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Twilight Bark, I believe that if we met, we could come to an understanding. I think that I could even develop a better relationship with MJ. Armenians in general do too much shouting and not enough soul-sharing. We have a lot more in common that the differences that we can see. I hope you stopped seeing me as some sort of "adversary" by now. I for one try to avoid "shouting", and share the part of my "soul" that I think may be worthy of sharing.
-
quote:Originally posted by Harut: i just want to say that you can't put the way Armenian parents behave in one category. not much here in US, but in Armenia you can see so much different approches to this. you would see parents who absolutly don't care about their kids. you would see parents who don't let their kids do anything without their approval. you would see parents who care but leave everything to their kids. "mi khoskov", you would see all kinds of parents. and i think that's true for not only Armenians. True. Any statement made about groups of people involves a distribution. So we indeed find a whole range of styles in every culture group. However, this does not prevent one from making observations about the "average" behaviour. For example, you cannot say that smoking does not cause cancer because you had a chain-smoking uncle that lived to 95. Also, we should emphasize that we are discussing the "traditional" Armenian families that still identify themselves as culturally Armenian. How the parenting traditions propagate in assimilated families is another interesting topic, but that's another topic.
-
quote:Originally posted by Juggernaut: Twilight, You summed it up preatty well, but even though I live in a country (Australia) dominated by Anglo culture, I am not aware of any 'better aspects in their parenting'. Encouraging independence. Teaching leadership and initiative. Showing restraint in hitting/spanking them. Basically letting them do more exploration and flourishing than "traditional" Armenian parents, and giving them more self-confidence. I am not touching on the shortcomings of Anglo-Saxon parenting, as they are irrelevant.
-
Ordu is a city on the Black Sea coast of Turkey. Can you guess what Armenian word its name comes from?
-
quote:Originally posted by Harut: the point is that no metter what you are, Armenian or non-Armenian, no metter how long you live, 20 years or 89, no metter who you are, a good guy or bad, you and your entire life are just a tiny fruction of history. Yes, that's what is scary. So it's not enough to take care of things here and now. It's important to set up a path so that we have a reasonable level of confidence in the general direction that our descendents are likely to take. Even though we are repeatedly told that a good and civilized nation is not based on ancestry, I still feel that that is the only reason for a nation to exist. Absent ancestral ties, I'd rather directly belong to the larger hodge-podge of a mess known collectively as "humanity", without any intermediate level of "belonging". Even if you gave me all the "niceties" of being an Armenian, but made me into, say, a southern Italian, I would still want to be an Armenian. The only "rational" explanation I have for this is the emotional ties one has to an extended family; because I know that I would never feel that way toward a group defined by the "modern" definition of a "nation" (i.e. common ancestry is optional, and preferably irrelevant; everyone that happens to fall within a boundary formed by historical/military forces are supposed to be a "nation). The term "extended family" crops up whenever I think of my relationship to the larger community of Armenians. Call me tribal.
-
Hagarag touched on a complex subject. Armenian parenting in general probably could use a lot of improvement. I have been critical of certain aspects of it for quite a while. However, the "overbearing parents" come as a package. Their interference in their children's lives usually stems form the fact that they care. They care in a profoundly more emotional and personal way about their children than is characteristic of western/northern European cultures. With such a group, you are bound to find parents who go too far. If I absolutely had to make a choice, I'll take the overbearing parents over a pair that celebrates the departure of their children so that they can finally start having fun. In the end, the for all its shortcomings, the Armenian parenting produces a healthier soul than the northern alternative. The optimum is somewhere in between. Think of what one could achieve if we combine the best aspects of Anglo-Saxon and Armenian parenting! Hagarag, thanks for bringing up such a topic; it's fertile ground for further exploration and soul-searching. On an unrelated note, I agree with your description of academia. Snake pit indeed. [ December 10, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by wh00t: Mos Jan, they are lyrics to a song written around 1915 relating to the Genocide.. sorry about that but I hope you'll leave it for the time being, I'd like Thorny to see. I think it is a lamentation on the fallen Turkish soldiers in distant corners of the Empire, Yemen to be specific. It is tangentially relevant to the Genocide in that such military (as well as civilian Muslim and possibly Christian as well) casualties during WW1 are lumped into a big number by the apologists and utilized in saying "Well, 2.5 million Ottoman subjects died too", implying that Armenians somehow bore responsibility for those deaths. By the way, I do feel for the poor fallen soldiers sent to battle as cannon fodder, courtesy of the Ittihadist rulers of the time, whose "core competence" was the slaughter of civilians.
-
quote:Originally posted by nellie: Not true, Boghos, I disagree. Perfect example is of that Iranian Armenians, who have been living in Iran for over 5 centuries. I have friends that recently moved to the U.S. from Iran, they speak fluent Armenian, and believe it or not have held on to their roots, unfortunately even more so (sometimes) then the rest of my friends that I left behind in Armenia. If your dedicated to holding on to your heritage, it can be accomplished. No body said, however, that it would be an easy task. Dear Nellie, I think what Boghos is saying is not that we shouldn't try. The point he is raising is that over the long term it is not realistic to expect that our descendants (say, five generations down the road) to be recognizably Armenian when they are raised generation after generation in an environment that constantly erodes their Armenianness. And that prospect makes me uncomfortable (on the other hand, your optimism gives me some hope.) Wait long enough, and a diasporan community disappears unless there are special circumstances. It is not clear that most diasporan communities have those "special circumstances". If "Armenianness" were a "religion", it would have an advantage, but it is not; at least not in the usual sense. Anybody volunteering for the role of a prophet?
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos: I do not want to make this an immigrate not-immigrate type discussion. First of because it is boring, and second because usually it develops into who is a better Armenian shouting match (of course the "better" Armenians will never immigrate). You won't get a shouting match from me . I would characterize the issue as being boring by way of being depressing. Anyway, you are right in implying that we all know pretty much what the issues and the challenges involved are, and that there is no compelling need to re-iterate.
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: [QB]The violin is a relatively modern instrument, according to one source it was introduced to Europe by the Arabs during the X-XII c. It may be recent in Europe. But it is entirely possible that an instrument similar to it has existed (and been named) from very early times in the area where Armenians lived.
