Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:what is currently going on in turkey could possibly not have taken place without the approval (=read: informal order) of the top brass. . . . hence my daring to conduct a rather open dialogue with you guys on the net. twenty years ago i would not dare to hold such conversations with an armenian even in the confines of my own house for fear of getting taped. . . . (i bloody well hope i am not committing a dreadful and potentially very dangerous mistake here). cheers & pray for me if i disappear (just kidding). Dear Ali Suat,Our dialogue here serves to demonstrate possible scenarios for the eventual reconciliation. It serves to fly trial balloons to see what seems acceptable to moderates, and where even the moderates draw the line. It is valuable "intelligence". And we are happy to provide it. I hope someone well-connected and intelligent actually utilizes it. TB
  2. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:11. the armenians say the turks killed them. we say they killed us. there are 65 million of us, and 80,000 of them, in turkey. explain. . . . 14. the fact that they killed us does not undo the fact that we killed them. and if they have their criminals, that does not make us innocent. 15. not all of those armenians who died were plotting against turks. babies can't plot. Next semester; Armenians 102, first week: 16. The killing was entirely lopsided. Almost complete annihilation of Armenians first, on the order of a million innocents, and revenge killings (mostly innocents, must be presumed) by Armenians later, possibly in a few tens of thousands. 17. Not every Armenian was an enemy is a drastic understatement. The percentage of Armenians posing any threat to anyone was pitifully small, probably a few percent. The unavoidable existence of fed-up radicals was used as a cover for wholesale murder and plunder. [ May 14, 2002, 10:24 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:2. armenians have been around since about 1,200 bc, they don't date from the battle of manzikert in 1071 ad or world war one. and their purpose in life has not uniformly been the annihilation of the turkish nation. and it is a bit far-fetched (for want of a better word) to call armenia "a dagger struck at the heart of the turkish fatherland". please guys, they have been here before us. Very nice. Except that the start date would have to be somewhat earlier, slightly predating the Phrygians. The dealings of Mursili II with the "Hayasa-Azzi" people took place around 1330 B.C. or so. It is beyond any doubt that the Hayasa-Azzi province was the first amalgamation of the Armenian people. quote: 8. no, the dolmabahçe palace wasn't built by an italian, it was built by an ottoman armenian called sarkis balyan. You mean the famous architect Baliani did not exist? Darn. quote:11. the armenians say the turks killed them. we say they killed us. there are 65 million of us, and 80,000 of them, in turkey. explain.That's easy. They simply emigrated. You know, looking for better jobs, material gain, and blonde girls, being the materialistic scum we all know they are (to paraphrase another esteemed contributor). As for the "land" issue. It is impractical and undesirable for all involved, simply because it is currently populated by Kurds and Turks. The usual story of "two wrongs don't make right". However, civilized countries do let go of "their" territory when people on that territory state unambiguously that they want to secede. Czechoslovakia is a good example. Canada is also a good example, since it has all the mechanisms for it to take place in a peaceful and orderly fashion. Even Russia, not known to be at the cutting edge of political liberalism, has allowed its "empire" to contract significantly without bloodshed or much quarrel (the case of Chechnya being where they apparently draw the line).
  4. The reason the elected officials must tread very carefully is not because of a backlash from the population, although it is always wise to break the news in a diplomatic fashion. The real danger is the military and the "hardliners" (i.e. the grey-wolf types, which should be regarded as a militia, rather than a true civilian group). The life expectancy of a prime minister that initiates a true enlightenment in Turkey would be reduced drastically. If lucky, he would be toppled by a bloodless coup, and spend the rest of his days under house arrest, contemplating. Under such wonderful encouragement, one's own thinking itself tends to stay, shall we say, "conservative". In many respects, Turkey is still an Orwellian society, although that has been changing slowly. Those that follow the Turkish press for a long time should remember that in the eighties there was a big hoopla in the Turkish press about some ingredient in detergents that could harm the environment. The population, which in general is as far away from being tree-hugging "Green"s as one could possibly get, got so worked up about it that all the brands phased out the offending ingredient in a relatively short amount of time. The moral of the story is that the Turkish population will follow the lead of the journalists and the establishment in general. The ones to be "convinced" are not the ordinary Turks, but their puppeteers. And they are not such a numerous group.
  5. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Twilight Bark, Hilmar Kaiser would disagree with you. He feels that pursuing the restoration of Armenian properties is critical to Genocide Recognition. If a robber kills his victim and steals from his victim, why is it in poor taste for the victim's family to expect that property returned? Hagarag,As you know, I have said many times that the provable claims must be paid. With the proper interest at that. However, I suspect the vast majority of the descendants of the survivors do not have the proper documentation. Then it becomes impossible to give the heirs specifically their due. Even proper documentation leads to awkward results. A large plot of relatively cheap land in the Ottoman times might have become a huge industrial park, or a business district with a current value running into billions of dollars. It would be problematic to decide what to pay. The distasteful way to address the reparations would be to give every living Armenian lacking documented property rights a check of an "average" amount. If the amounts are going to be meaningful, it would put a huge burden on Turkey, and would start brewing a new wave of resentment. And "finishing the job" might start looking like a good way out to many. In the ever-elusive event of recognition and reparation, I would say paying provable claims and channeling "development funds" towards re-settling willing Armenians in their ancestral homeland (with very broad cultural rights) would be the decent thing to do. Not that very many Armenians would be queing up to take up the offer.
  6. quote:Originally posted by Domino:TB, you accused me first of giving to much importance to Ara, but by answering him like this, you just are doing this yourself... you take him to much seriously. I am not accusing you of anything. The amount of my "discussion/debate" time I devote to him is a small fraction of my total budget. He is after all a persistent and loud voice, backed up by some sort of a "reputation". A modicum of "attention" is justified. [ May 11, 2002, 12:32 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  7. Dear Domino and Steve, you are both making points that are worthwhile to consider. I wish those points were made with less offense. Steve is correct in saying that vast numbers of Armenian peasants didn't have much wealth. Domino is also correct that many Armenians did indeed have sizeable wealth. However, putting great emphasis on personal, monetary compensation is both in poor taste and is impractical to the degree of being counterproductive. Pragmatic approaches are called for. Domino, trying to explain the genocide in terms of large-scale robbery is too simplistic. Lust for wealth explains nothing without the underlying chauvinism. It was not a class revolution.
  8. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:However, I consider this emphasis on property rights to be very distasteful. True. See, Steve, we are on the same page. While I do think that provable claims must be compensated for, they are a near-irrelevance to any true reparation. The true loss was the eradication of an indigenous culture in a most ruthless manner. As I said earlier, the only rational way to address the issue of material reparation is to direct it towards re-settling the descendants of the survivors in their ancestors homeland. Those that would pass up such an offer are then by definition too far removed from the original crime to be paid "reparations". The pragmatic side of this is that it would keep the resources going to reparation inside the Turkish economy, and make it economically affordable and even beneficial.
  9. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:[Hmmmm... you really have not a clue what he is talking about! - but maybe you are at the dawn rather than the twilight of your understanding. Hmmm... Maybe you should think and reflect a little bit more. Your presumption of ignorance of higher concepts on my part is unbecoming of you. quote:He is saying that a country (ANY country) that has the foresight to consider the pursuit of knowledge for knowledge's sake to be worthwhile is for THAT REASON a country and culture which is worth defending (by its own population). And he used the word DEFENDING, not the word DEFENDED.Thanks for the hand-holding. See, I was not capable of understanding such sophisticated concepts on my own. Much appreciated. Dear trigger-happy friend, of course that is what he is talking about. He is reflecting a widespread value system in which the "sophisticated" individuals are worth more than "unsophisticated" ones. And whether we like to acknowledge it or not, each one us subscribes to a version of such a system of valuation. I was not implying that he was talking about defending other countries in the past or present. But I am implying that his statement implicitly reflects a world view that sorts people's value by their intellectual sophistication. quote:Given that many Armenians on this board have abandoned their homeland for the pursuit of short term, individual, material gain it is inadvisable to be attacking those that have the wisdom to think of higher things.I, for one, have done no such thing. And what other Armenians do or do not for whatever reason has no bearing on my analysis of the statement in question. And if you read and think more carefully, you will realize that I am not attacking the person that uttered the quote. As for your belittling the poor, hopeless people throwing themselves out of Armenia. While it is partly a result of Armenian "hyper-realism", it is unfair to characterize their emigration as simply motivated by "short term, individual, material gain". While staying in their wretched country for the abstract notion of nationalistic sentiments may seem "noble" to some, caring about their children's future seems more noble to many Armenians. I think I wouldn't be terribly wrong when I state that in the traditional Armenian value system, caring for your family and loving your children are what makes your existence worthwhile, and not how sophisticated a thinker you are. Anyway, we can take this discussion into many intersting directions. And it would be even pleasurable to do so if you stop assuming that your counterpart is a simpleton. Twilight Bark [ May 10, 2002, 05:36 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  10. quote:Originally posted by Domino: but he is a talented writer, and we can't deny this, Bah. Perhaps he could have become one, but his apparent level of talent is no better than a mediocre journalist. His level of thinking also appears to be at that level. That is still more than many ordinary people; just not enough to justify all the pomposity. In any case, all this is quite irrelevant. If he had the intellectual and spiritual depth, I would admire him even if he had zero "talent". quote: maybe its for him better to increase his "Ironic" skills by reading a little of Voltaire...He already does more copying than is good for anyone. quote: How many of you, just ONE DAY, after remarking that Ara has new post didnt opened his threat to read what he has just writen ? Be honnest. I raise my hand. I only occasionally glance through his "output". I usually comment on it only as a response to some poor soul that appears to buy his half-baked ideas becase of the borrowed, "enlightened", sugary fluff that surrounds them.
  11. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Reading Baliozian is like reading Baronian. I am not quite sure the intended purpose is the same, and I do sense a more "end of the world prophet" atmosphere in Baliozian. He probably couldn´t find his place among Armenians, as a Balakian did for example. But Ara Baliozian is someone I respect, if not for his message which is a bit repetitive and a bit extreme, but for his implied sense of humour. Now, the self-loathing and even self-hatred is symptomatic. I won´t get into it. Suffices to say that unless it is written with a dose of irony, it becomes quite boring. I agree that having respectable social critics with literary talent would indeed be a wonderful blessing for the Armenians. And I wish I could share your respect for Mr. Baliozian. The workings of his mind, and what he tries to pull off in his writings are all too easy to see, and I don't like what I see. You mention irony. He doesn't see the irony when he behaves in exactly the same way as the people he supposedly loathes. That is, the irony is there, but just horribly and apparently unwittingly misplaced. And when I see someone rising to his usual bait of "oh-so-noble" sermons about how the bad guys are bad, and the good guys are good, and the bad guys should become good guys, I have to convince myself once again that the poor reader will probably be alright in the end. I sincerely wish that he were better; but he is not. His calling is at best a career as a second-rate shock-jock columnist. I sincerely wish to be wrong, and wish to believe that we do have a high-caliber intellectual that is energetically trying to illuminate the Armenian masses; but I cannot suspend my disbelief. Anyway, enough about my pet-villain . Welcome back.
  12. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:If ... what we all discuss here will amount to zero, it is better to get lost Perhaps. But we can't seem to unglue ourselves from here can we? I, for one, am using this forum to sharpen and clarify my thinking, especially on my cultural identity and its place in the world. I am not in a position to charge ahead and change the world. However, perhaps I can introduce a spark in someone else's mind. Just maybe. And maybe by the time I am in a position of more leverage, I will have honed my thought system so that the resources that I plunge into a "cause" will not be wasted. Just maybe. And that "just maybe" makes it worthwhile. Twilight Bark
  13. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:As sad as this is, I have come to the conclusion that the best thing is to let go of the Armenianness. Perhaps Dikran Kouyoumjian, the grandfather of Gregory Peck, Malachi Martin, my prominent relatives and many others had the right idea. If no one will listen to Baliozian, and what we all discuss here will amount to zero, it is better to get lost. Armenians are a lost cause. What a bunch of self-defeating nincompoops. The enemy isw not only the Turkish establishment, the enemy is within our community psyche. Dear Hagarag, First of all, I don't buy your manifesto. Your attitude towards being an Armenian is that of the "traditional" Armenian bride: "Goulam, payts gertam" You know that there is something good about keeping your Armenian identity, even when you cannot tell what on earth it is. You'll stay. You'll stay in the margins, but you'll stay. Second, listening to Baliozian has nothing to do with reforming anything. If you want to let go of something, let go of him and use your own intellect to figure out things. He introduces more confusion than clarification. Third, sure we are a lost cause and self-defeating nicompoops . Of course I prefer to characterize our attitudes as "hyper-realist" The funny thing is that almost each one us think more or less the same about the rest of the Armenians, except for the one exception, us (as in first person singular), the pearl stuck in the mud. If you think you have something valuable to say (and I am not implying at all that you do not), or write, do it. What use would it be if the Armenian culture was in excellent condition? The real challenge is to say something so clever and profound that the self-defeating nincompoops will listen and change. I think one needs to start with oneself, and then try to work his way to the people that seem like such losers to you. In that journey, one would hope to learn as well as teach. In any case, if some of my words hurt you, please don't take it as a lack of sympathy towards you. In fact, almost all the people on this forum, including the ones that are having fun at your expense, are your anonymous friends. They disagree with almost everything you say, but they are friends. You know why they are friends? Because at the core level, they are also family. Best, Twilight Bark
  14. From "The Economist": IN 1969 Robert Wilson, the first director of Fermilab, a big American particle-physics facility, was asked by Congress what his new laboratory would contribute to America's defence. He replied: “This new knowledge has all to do with honour and country, but it has nothing to do directly with defending our country, except to help make it worth defending.” A harmless enough statement, you would think. Scientifically oriented among us may find it uplifting. But it immediately made me think "So if a society does not ponder such questions in the mentally disciplined way that high-energy particle physics or modern cosmology employs, they may be regarded as less worthy of defending?". Or for that matter, less worthy of caring about after they are decimated and gone. Next time you encounter "why should I care about your tragedies?" attitude from otherwise "enlightened" members of the Western civilization, think of how the Armenians and the other Near Easterners seem to them, and the above statement might shed some light on the situation.
  15. We need critics, thinkers, as well as doers. This obvious fact has been abused countless times by untalented pundits to justify their verbal diarrhea. While we need our thinkers, it does not mean we need any and all "thinkers". In the case of Baliozian, we need a full-time "devotee" cleaning up his mess after him. The combination may indeed resemble something valuable. Without a critic's critic, Baliozian's output is a net negative. Not terribly consequential perhaps, but a negative one nonetheless. We have as much use for insincere charlatans wrapping themselves in the flag of international enlightenment, but only out to score against their former paymasters, as we need flag-waving hate-monger chauvinists. As for Hagarag, he may often be preoccupied with himself, and say silly things more often than he probably should. But he at least seems to care about the individual Armenian even if it shows mostly as some sort of snobbery. His net message cannot be summarized as "If you know what's good for you, shed your backward identity and assimilate. That will piss off the big-wigs that didn't let me criticise them, so now I can take my revenge", unlike our sage Saint Ara. Anyway, I would say that Hagarag's net contribution is probably zero. The same goes for the vast majority of us. And I don't hesitate to include myself in that category. Twilight Bark P.S. The more "cerebral" parts of this thread brobably belong in a separate topic.
  16. quote:Originally posted by Domino:Why TB hate him so much is simply because, I don't hate him. quote: TB seem to understand Ara with a cartesian way...That is not true. I am being as "wholistic" about understanding him as is reasonable. Have a nice weekend everyone!
  17. quote:Originally posted by Boghos: I don't disagree. But there is always a distribution of people, with a range of susceptibilities. I guess I just want to put my objection on the record, to indicate that our general silence does not necessarily mean tacit or wholesale approval. You are probably right that it is much ado about nothing. By the way, bon voyage. quote:Dear TOTH, I have meant to say that a long while ago: my deep appreciation for your always polite and balanced intervetions, but more than anything for your humble (in the best of senses) attitude always. Ditto.
  18. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:do you really think he is harmful? (In some real way - as some do - for pointing out "our" alleged failings - giving ammo to our "enemies" and such)? I don't - I find the debate itself worthwhile and educational - whether or not I agree... Dear Thoth,As you know, I have done my share of our collective and public self-critique. It is not the self-assessment and self-critique I dislike. Quite the contrary, it is one my favorite pastimes . However, I do think that self-critique must be done with the proper introspection and compassion. In a way it is like surgery. If it not going to be done carefully and competently, it may be better not done. Thus, the bliss of ignorance may be preferable to a misdirected self-flagellation done for the wrong reasons and with no therapeutic value. For each Thoth or Domino there are dozens of individuals out there, who know that there are some problems in the Armenian culture, that things are far from perfect, but have just started their intellectual journey. The two loudest messages they get on the internet is the chauvinist nonsense that they would probably be repelled by (being the ones that sense that things are not nearly so perfect and black-and-white), and Mr. Baliozian's megaphone. There are enough poison pills and misdirected road signs in his writings to throw them off-course and force them to a long detour on their trek to intellectual maturity, if they ever finish the lengthened journey. Or if they ever finish the trip as Armenians, and not ex-Armenians grateful to be rid of such disease. In short, sloppy thinking and persistent superficiality are the main "intellectual" reasons behind my irritation. At a more emotional level (which is never completely divorced from reason), I sense in Mr. Baliozian a repugnant lack of compassion of a bitter old man. A bitter old man, to whom I would otherwise give all the compassion, sympathy, and respect. Despite my irritation, I still see in Mr. Baliozian an intelligent young boy, aware of his gift, ready to face the world and make a difference. A boy asking "when will my time come?". A boy that "knows" that he is special, and that he has something to give to the world. A boy that craves being flattered by his elders. And it breaks my heart to see that promising young boy turned into a bitter old man pouring his venom daily on his extended family. Twilight Bark
  19. quote:Originally posted by Domino:still he achieve what he wants, that is attention, like him or hate him, this is what an artist want, what ever you think of him, just give him attention, indifference is the worst enemy of an artist. He is not a novelist. He is not a satirist. He is not a painter. He is not a poet. He is a self-styled "pundit". That hardly qualifies as an artist. He does crave attention, particularly of those that agree with everything he says, and those that disagree with him but don't know exactly why and lack the wherewithal to properly dissect his nonsense (so he can proceed to prove his "righteousness" by trampling on the poor slob that insulted him). A young child craves attention, and has every right to. But for an artist, the attention is usually secondary. An artist does her art because she feels compelled to, and not because she is after the attention of strangers. In any case, Mr. Baliozian qualifies as an artist as much as any of us does. Enough attention for today.
  20. quote:Originally posted by Domino:you are to much hard with him Then perhaps you should give me as much benefit of the doubt as you do to Mr. Baliozian below. quote: there is many artists that do not believe what they write, they forge a style for their own... what prove you have that Ara is not doing just that ? That he is not just writing to shock, and in fact he even don't believe the majority of what he write ? I do not; I cannot; and I scarcely care. As a public writer, he is judged by what he writes. quote:I find his writings like satiresIf satire is his intention, he fails miserably for this "reader".
  21. True to form, Mr. Baliozian's essays lack depth, human compassion, and logical self-consistency whenever he tries to incorporate something of his own, rather than parroting the thoughts of better men (though apparently without fully grasping what they mean). In other words, both the "left-brain" and the "right-brain" aspects are irreperably flawed. The only significant value in Mr. Baliozian's "essays" is the fraction of his quotations that happen to come from worthwhile thinkers. As for his earth-shattering recommendation that we should learn from the "winners", and we cannot learn anything from the "losers", not surprisingly, it is wrong. Both in personal and collective contexts, the success is more a result of avoiding the mistakes that the much more numerous "losers" made, and the specific circumstances (otherwise called "luck"). If you interview successful individuals, you do not get some precious secret that will open the gates of success to anyone that "learned" them. Almost invariably, you get some platitudes that the "losers" already knew of. And the adoption of "innovations" leading to success is very much dependent on the environment and circumstances of the "losers". The reason for the astonishing difference in "civilization" between a western european scientist and a Tasmanian hunter-gatherer with stone-age tools has nothing to do with the inherent character of their groups, but their environment and its history. Jews have a lot to be admired for. In general they are hard-working, intellectually oriented, and driven by a desire for success (not money, or even power per se). But these are only the "proximate", superficial reasons. One has to ask what led to the adoption of these values. Arabs have a lot of problems, which we do not need to enumerate. Is that because of something inherently wrong in their genetics or culture? That is very unlikely, given their cultural supremacy in the Midle Ages. One has to ask what caused it to fall behind, and learn both the circumstances and the possible mistakes made. Mr. Baliozian observes the world as it is today, and pontificates trivialities. The trivialities could still be forgiven had they contained an ounce of compassion; but they don't. And I loathe such nasty superficiality. Yes, Mr. Baliozian, I don't hate it; I simply loathe it.
  22. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Twilight Bark, were you born with your gentle wisdom or did your parents instill it within you?I must say it is a honor to be able to savor your wisdom in this anonymous forum. Thanks for your kind words. We all have our insights to contribute; we have been showing one another alternative ways to look at things, all the while maintaining a good level of cordiality. We have developed an unusually mature and intelligent culture in this forum, and credit is due to many of the participants. We are all helping each other become wiser.
  23. quote:Originally posted by Sip:First about the "mainstream" thing: I am under the impression that the "mainstream" advocates the reading of books as the thing to do! Actually, here I am going against the mainstream ... if you don't believe me, just read all the replies and you'll see I am alone in my thinking about books Your "mainstream" is the geekdom in which you spend your "professional" part of your life Your "mainstream" and, say, highflier's "mainstream", although intersecting, are significantly different in many areas. quote:About books: I am talking about the 1-dimensionality of it. You start on page 1, you work your way to page n, moving your eyes over word k-1 before going to work k. Word after word, page after page, until you're done. I just get extremely bored with that. My mind typically wonders around and I can't focus since the process is sooooo sloooooooow (maybe I need speed-reading practice?) Books are anyting but 1-dimensional. You can very quickly jump to any page or paragraph. A good table of contents and a good index makes it even easier. Nothing prevents you from reading the concluding chapter first, to see what the whole thing is about (something I often do ). quote:On a computer however, I can do 5 things at the same time, switch back and forth, jump forwards and backwards, search (yes, it is VERY important to me and I do it all the time while reading), lookup words/concepts I don't know, and even get side-tracked and follow a different tangent than where the flow of the text is trying to taking me.But one can do the same while holding a book in one's hands. There are no proximity alarms going off when a book approaches a digital device quote:About TV: I think it is a fantastic medium. Unfortunately, it is not being used the way it should. Most "mainstream" programs SUCK. BUT, a huge book can be efficiently condensed into a short 1 or 2 hour program since instead of spending 30 pages describing the scence, they just show it to you in 1 frame!!!! The 3 paragraphs used to describe a sound ... you just hear it! Example: How long does it take to describe an elephant, how it moves, how it behaves, how it eats ... in a book? How long does it take to do the same on TV? Which one is really better? I think the difference is obvious.As I agreed earlier, TV and radio have their place. I enjoy learning a lot from both of these sources. However, there is a level of depth and proficiency that is simply impractical to achieve regardless of how excellent the program is. quote:Another example: I always hated "History" in school. It was torture for me to read about history. But I actually love the History channel we have here. I have learned A TON of stuff about ancient egypt, Word War II, US History, European History, etc etc just by watching that channel. I would have to spend hours and hours reading books to get the same info. Here, I just have the TV on while I am working on my PC. I pick up an amazing amount of info that way. The beauty of it is that I don't even really have to pay attention (as opposed to a book where you have to read each paragraph carefully). I just glance over every few seconds and I can immediately reconstruct what happened in between because things are so visual and auditory (as opposed to plain text). "Hatred" of history is of course very common because it is taught extremely poorly all around the planet. Only very few people survive the active dicouragement they receive in their formative years. There is another component in your case though . Yes, that "mainstream" thing again. "History is bunk" summarizes the North American attitude. The mainstream culture in the US implicitly carries the message that we should forget the past and look to the future. It is of course self-serving for two reasons. Having a very short history, Americans feel left out when discussing anything that goes further back than the period in which their country ascended to be a world-power (and eventually the only superpower). It is therefore convenient to brush aside much of history as "irrelevant". A related but distinct second reason is the still prevalent "manifest destiny" attitude. That is, America has a God-given right and duty to lead the world into the future, and that such leadership is the most important aspect of current human existence. Some even go so far as sincerely (but not necessarily consciously) believing that what is good for America is by definition good for the whole humanity. As a silly example avoiding history, observe that the American mainstream culture encourages children to be fascinated by dinosaurs and other prehistoric curiosities, as a substitute for real history. Medieval history would be a distant second as far as "past stuff" goes, and forget about anything older. As the American culture spills over to other parts of the planet, its idiosyncratic features also get adopted. It is amusing to watch. quote:All I can conclude right now is that clear and organized thinking leads to clear and organized communication abilities. Do reading books help? Maybe ... are they necessary? I'd say no. A more crucial point to consider is what one has to communicate. I'd rather listen to a stuttering man that sprinkles his torturous and tortuous speech with lots of "ums" and "aaa"s but has deep insight, than a smooth talking "communicator" whose discourse has perfect "left-brain" logical connections and perfect internal consistency but is based on a completely false or fatally superficial view of reality.
  24. Dear Sip, That picture is hilarious. I laughed out loud at the sight (which I rarely do in front of my computer). As you tickle us with "baits" to promote interesting discussions, I tickle you by accusing you of bowing to the "mainstream". Thanks for taking it in good humor, as it was intended. Twilight Bark
  25. While I agree that celibacy is counterproductive, I also agree with Sip that it has little or nothing to do with child molestation. Armenian church has married priests ("der-hair" or "kahana"). Therefore, those that think church is their calling but also want to have a family can do so in a perfectly dignified manner. As for the "celibate" Armenian priests that have a change of heart, I am sure many of us have heard of comical folk tales about bishops with mistresses. Child abuse does not, and should not, come into the discussion as some sort of a natural result of celibacy gone bad. However, it has been theorized that men from conservative backgrounds but with "deviant" urges often hope to suppress those tendencies by becoming celibate priests. This hope is very often in vain, and the Catholic Church ended up with a disproportionate number of child molesters in the celibate priest population. So far the Armenian Church has been "immaculate" in that respect as far as I know. Eliminating the celibacy requirement would solve many problems for the church. It would make priesthood available to many devout people who do not agree with the celibacy requirement, thus solving the problem of dwindling numbers of priests. It would eliminate celibacy as a false refuge for people suffering from deviant urges; they need therapy not temporary celibacy. In the end, the priest population would have a much smaller percentage of child molesters than the overall population; the exact opposite of the current state. In any case, we can be proud that the Armenian Church has been untouched by such scandals. Fingers crossed.
×
×
  • Create New...