Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
For those who are still interested in subjects other than sexual organs and shish-kebab philosophy, let me clarify one thing before I exit this topic (which is at least not a disgrace if not wholly intelligent). I see it as comically obvious that 19th century european style "nationalism" was invented in Europe in the 19th century. It is also obvious that many elements of that "nationalism" has spread to many non-European nations, including a section of Armenians. My problem is with identifying the spread of "modern" nationalism with the concept of a self-aware nation. It is not only baseless to do that, but there is ample evidence to the contrary. "Modern nationalism" in the Armenian context is basically the "Dashnak" (et al.) brand nationalism. To say that Armenians had no self-awareness before those naive adventurers is so obviously wrong in so many ways that it is wasteful to even argue about it. Armenians had a strong sense of "nationhood" (as they understood it) and collective group consciousness; just not in the "modern" sense (and should anyone but the dimmest be surprised by that?). And in the absence of an impending danger, the natural mode of Armenian collective consciousness is still the pre-modern one. Today. Please don't take my word for it; just read up a bit, and don't neglect the good old-fashioned "observation" outside the written word. Hint: European enlightenment is the wrong section of the library for the subject. And finally, I have no claims (or particular pride; quite the contrary in fact) about my intelligence or contributions; contrary to what has been claimed. We all do what we can according to the various "budgets" that we have (be it cerebral, monetary, and temporal among other things). This is not about "Oh mirror, mirror, who is the fairest". However, being shallow, vain, or pompous is not something we cannot avoid, regardless of our "budgets".
-
What I have written has been flying over your head apparently. You keep repeating the same unsubstantiated hypotheses and irrelevant factoids and examples and then pretend that regarding those burps from your cranium as anything but self-evident truth betrays an emotional block on your critic's part. It must be that you are too much in awe of your inflated self-perception to pay attention to nuanced reason. If shooting from the hip some pseudo-enlightened theory makes you feel smart and you are addicted to that emotion, there is little I can do to cure your affliction beyond what I wrote. In time you you'll probably grow up. And I don't discount the possibility that you may then contribute a properly reasoned and even brilliant thougt to Armenian intellectual life. However, that time has not come yet.
-
No, I don't think any of us would have heard of the "Armenian Paper" from family. I learned of its existence from an ad in a French magazine. The "history" section of the site claims that Auguste Ponsot saw Armenians burn "Benjoin" (Benzoin; or Stryax tonkinensis), a resin from some far eastern plant. Whatever the truth of the story, the paper is a French "invention", and the source plant is not native to Armenia. So it is fair to say that the only Armenian thing about Papier d'Armenie is that some Armenian(s) somewhere in Ottoman Armenia inspired a Frenchman (Henri Rivier) to come up with it. In any case, we'll take the credit anyway.
-
http://papierdarmenie.siteinternet.com/site/eng/
-
You are, implicitly yet clearly, by using various and sandry nations as "examples", when they invariably had incomparable histories. Perhaps you have another audience in mind. Patronizing this correspondent will not further your argument. A straw-man argument. As I said, modern european nationalism is modern and european. That has next to nothing to do with the issue. Lumping Armenians with France and Germany so effortlessly illustrates your problem. What has the genocidal tendencies of two European nations got to do with Armenian national consciousness and when it first formed coherently? Sometimes you claim that you don't know how similar we are to the original Hayk, then you sound like you actually know quantitatively how similar and dissimilar today's Armenians are to this or that group. As I explained before, to no avail, Armenians lacked the power and prestige to attract "recruits", whereas the imperial nations such as Greeks, Turks, Persians and the like acted like societal and cultural sponges. It is a simple matter of driving forces, akin to those found in thermodynamics. While the original Armenians surely intermarried with some "newcomers", there has always been little incentive for large groups of others to settle and change into the Armenian identity. Our familial link to the original "tribes" of Hayk does not become questionable when they accept brides or grooms from other groups. Yes, yes. Except that the european idea or definition of national consciousness, and whatever Marx or Hitler might have thought have no bearing on when the Armenian national consciousness, as defined by them, became coherent. Yes, 19th century european nationalism was nonexistent before 19th century, outside of Europe. A profound observation indeed. I don't know which moron you are talking about when you say "we", but you won't catch me projecting "ourselves" into 19th century European idea of anything. I don't care how Europeans (or American mainstream for that matter) prefer to define a "nation", or what kind of monstrosity they turn such a concept into. They can take their self-justifying definitions and insert it where it belongs for all I care. That Armenians used the new ideas of the time does not retroactively change when a coherent Armenian self-awareness first formed. A modern nation-state is modern. That has nothing to do with the time when the first collective self-awareness of Armenians originated. Since the Armenian language was not deposited from the heavens overnight when they got the wind of "modern" ideas, it is silly to claim linguistic discontinuity. As for pottery, dress, and other material culture, I do agree that they do not define a national consciousness. But what's the point? Just because driving a Mercedes today doesn't define national identity (wait a minute, is that true ) doesn't mean that Armenian collective consciousness does not exist today. They could be speaking Luwian for all I care. Did they call themselves Hay? Yes, since at least 1350 BC. It really comes down to what you call yourself. They did not call their collective selves "mart" or "martik". They called themselves "Hay". And I think the word for "nation", namely "azk" (with the plural "k") shouts at us in the name Hayasa-Azzi in the Hittite archives. Yeah, we should really care about European duchies, lords, and kings when deducing the the first time Armenian collective consciousness arrived. I for one am not "trying" to make the "Armenian case" anything. I simply find your thoughtless effort to fit the square of Armenians into the European circle wrong-headed. I don't know which moron you get your definitions from, but the emotions sparked by recent history, justified or unjustified, have nothing to do with when the national self-awareness of Armenians started. As you admit, Armenians rarely achieved political unity, or even full independence. Therefore, their linguistic unity must have been due to a true collective self-awareness and cultural affinity, which is the basis of "traditional" Armenian collective feeling (i.e. "Armenian traditional nationalism", and not "modern nationalism"). The linguistic unity is all the more remarkable when you consider that such mountainous terrain is used to explain the extreme variety of Caucasian languages. The Caucasus peoples diverged into little smithereens because of so-called geographical barriers whereas Armenians retained their collective name, and merely produced dialects of the same language. All that despite the lack of a central "Armenian king" demanding loyalty to the "Armenian throne", and molding the various "peoples" into an Armenian identity. The most reasonable explanation of this is a coherent collective identity of a kind that does not need a central authority. It also explains why it survived despite lack of power. Yeah, that really relates to when the first collective Armenian consciousness formed. You flatter yourself.
-
No, it's not hopeless. You can draw very well. Anybody can. What cannot be guaranteed is the creativity part. I would think that the best way to chase away your grandma's voice is to prove that you can draw. And there is no way that you cannot draw. You can. Your grandma's negative attitude is unfortunately encoutered all too often in Armenian social and family life. If there is one thing that the Armenian culture needs to borrow from the American culture is the positive, optimistic, "you can do it" attitude. As for what to read about the human brain, I don't have any suggestions. It has not been in my focus.
-
You should read this.
-
I figured as much, Vava. I am just wondering what percentage of the population is "wired" to do that. It would be interesting to know. Maybe there is an idea for a nice little research article here, but probably someone somewhere already did it.
-
Neither. But apparently you lack the proper wiring. Hey there to you too.
-
Yes Vava, but what I mean is a "true" 3D vision despite using one eye, and only when looking at a 2D picture with one eye closed. If you look at the picture with both eyes, the "backup" mechanism is not triggered. It's amazing how the brain can synthesize a pretty good "true" 3D perception by using cues such as focusing, perspective, and motion. I mean it looks 3D. Have you observed the enhancement I am talking about?
-
Close one eye, and look at the picture again. See if you'll see it more "3D". My brain apparently turns on a different mechanism to synthesize a "3D" vision from other depth cues when I close one eye. I don't know how common this is. Try it with a clear TV picture as well (which may work even better since the depth cues are more abundant due to motion). Let's see what percentage of people here can see what I mean.
-
Measure the correctness of your ideas by reason, and not by correlating it to their popularity directly or in a contrarian way. Both popularity and reverse-snobbery make lousy metrics for truth.
-
And just to demonstrate my self-evident superiority, dear anileve, I'll say that your theory has already been advanced by yours truly. I think it was in a Baliozian thread; I am not sure. Being a superior and super-important person, of course I will not take the time to find where I wrote those precious words.
-
I recently came across a book by Donald P. Hollis about the Damadian saga. He describes, in murderous detail, what Damadian has done, and has not done. It is a thoroughly convincing account, and an amusing read. After reading that well-researched book by someone close to the "action", it is hard to regard Damadian as anything more than a pathetic figure, which he apparently has been. At this point there is very little doubt in my mind that Damadian, as a scientist, was worse than mediocre, and the Nobel committee had done its homework well. Damadian's lack of a Nobel prize has nothing to do with his religious beliefs or being a jerk. He simply did not do anything scientifically or technologically significant, or even valid, as far as MRI imaging is concerned.
-
Very true. Anonymouse often says thoughtful things, as well as not-so-well-thought-out things. The idea behind this thread belongs in the second category. While rejecting the "sameness" and "equivalence" of genders in one thread of thought, he overexerts himself into accepting the sameness of all nations and their evolutionary paths in another, clearly as an article of faith and not as a result of reason.
-
Oh I am sure you are right; I agree with that. The point I am trying to make is that war is lack of peace, rather than peace is lack of war. Next, I will announce how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.
-
Good and evil can only exist in the context of self-aware beings and their aspirations. The extent of the "universality" we can assign the concept of good and evil is constrained by that. Inanimate objects on Venus should not come into the picture.
-
Perhaps. But note that I can define "good" self-consistently without reference to evil. In that system, evil is defined in reference to "good". In other words, you can start with what you know to be good (i.e. what you want), and know also that the less of that you have, the more "bad" or "evil" the causes of that reduction are.
-
The only reason I wrote about choices is because you brought it up. I simply explained how the matter of choices would be handled as a consequence of my definition. In that definition, the "good" exists independent of "evil". Absence of "evil" is a state where the optimal freedoms are enjoyed. You seem to miss the following points: maximum possible level of freedom is determined by a competition of conflicting freedoms. Individual freedoms cannot be arbitrarily maximized without reducing or eliminating other freedoms, and this has noting to do with choices or the presence of evil. The reductions in these unique, individual freedoms as a result of this balance do not constitute "evil", they constitute the "maximum possible" level of freedom. "Evil" comes into the picture when it reduces our freedom unnecessarily, say, in order to satisfy the whims of a tyrant, or in order to allow a lazy bum to be negligent of his or her responsibilities. About intution: one cannot derive a tangible definition from intuition. One can come up with examples by intuition, and it can provide guidance. Most importantly, intuition provides constraints and "reality check" on our definitions concerning human nature. Intuition summarizes our psychological and social evolution. As a fun exercise, try to redefine what you consider "good" or "evil" in terms of freedoms, and see if you are beginning to understand what I mean by my definition. Consider, for example, the need to be safe and secure, the right of privacy, and the tension between these two "needs". The need to be safe and secure can be seen as "the freedom to live one's life without being terrorized" and the right to privacy can be seen as "the freedom to keep personal information away from others". Those two freedoms cannot be maximized and enjoyed absolutely; they need to be balanced. So far so good. But if one of them is unnecessarily reduced so as to reduce the total freedom, something "bad" (or "evil" if the reduction is drastic) is introduced. Of course the freedoms need to be weighed according to the importance we assign to them. All these vary from individual to individual, so we are talking about averages so that the the total amount of freedom enjoyed by the society as a whole is optimized. Reducing that would be "bad" or "evil".
-
"Good" choices made in an "evil-free" context would keep the optimized level of freedom. "Bad" choices would lead to a reduction in the freedom level of the environment that allowed the choice to be made. Enough of these "bad" choices" could eventually make those choices themselves unavailable, or make them the "only choice" (which is of course not a choice anymore), which is a total lack of freedom. Edit: Oh, and I agree that at the time of the choice we may not know hether its is "good" or "bad". Our temporary (or sometimes eternal) ignorance on the matter is not relevant to the discussion though.
-
"Perfection" and "order" are not good correlators of what we know by intuition to be good or evil. A society with perfect order would be a nightmare, unless you make the definition of "perfect order" so plastic that it falls back to the definition I gave (i.e. everyone follows the rules, which are "just right" in order to optimize the amount of freedom individuals have). Conversely, one can easily imagine "perfect" or "perfectly ordered" societies that are thoroughly repugnant to us. The Borg of Star Trek may be extremely orderly, nearing "perfection", but they would come pretty close to what we intuitively consider pure evil. A dictatorial society in which individuals are "broken" and turned into the parts of a "perfect" collective machinery is the quintessential "evil" system. A useful definition of good and evil should be self-consistent and correlete closely with our intuition about those concepts. However, a concise, non-arbitrary and useful definition of evil (or good) cannot come from intuition or mysticism.
-
But I said "maximum possible freedom". If I float into space and suffocate I will be dead. That means I will not have the freedom to live and have the freedom to do all the other things that I want to do. For one stupid "freedom", I would be losing every other freedom I have and might have in the future. It is quite far from "maximum possible freedom", don't you think? So your example highlights the sturdiness of that definition. The choices we make are guided by what we consider good or bad. One does not need to resort to mysticism to understand good and evil. TB
-
My basic definition of evil is based on a couple of simple observations. One is the fact that we are self-aware, with (at least the illusion, if not the fact of) free-will, which compels us to do what we want. The second observation is that we have evolved as social creatures, and have integrated the requirements of a successful collective existence and survival into the nature of the individual, such as the ability to constrain one's own behavior and act altruistically, which superficially appear to reduce one's freedom (but on average it in fact maximizes). The first one defines the fundamental force defining our very existence as self-aware beings: freedom to do what we want. The second one leads to the "maximum possible freedom" argument, which means we would like to optimize our freedoms in a way that allows us to exercise as much of our free-will as possible without wrecking our social environment, whose existence itself provides a platform to exercise the vast majority of these freedoms. Our intuitive sense of good and evil is the result of this optimization process engraved into us through evolution. This also explains why freer societies tend to be more efficient and successful in the long run, if they don't get exterminated by a spurt of violence from an "evil" group first. This should be my last post for some time. Best wishes to all, and enjoy your freedoms.
-
What my definition needs is not so much refinement as thoughtful application to specific cases and circumstances. For example, while gravity severely reduces my freedom to float away to space and suffocate (not that there would be an atmosphere left without gravity), it allows me (i.e. gives me the freedom) to enjoy what earth offers me. I think you would have to try much harder than that to find inconsistencies in my definition, if there are any. Of course you have the freedom to do so.
