Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. No (not that you should take orders from me). But it makes me sad to see them, not proud or happy. What's that supposed to mean?
  2. Kurgan theory is brand new??! Surely you jest. Brand new? It's been the "orthodoxy" until recently. And the only reason it had been so popular was basically wishful thinking and an unwillingness of the Westerners to concede that even their language came from the vicinity of Asia Minor. "The majority of scholars" are often wrong; after all that's how a field progresses. The recent Gray & Atkinson paper is the most sensible and objective way to approach the problem, and points to Anatolia as the birthplace of IE. And although they group Armenian and Greek together, it is done with a lot lower confidence level than most other groupings. And assuming that they did form a single group at some point, the time of their divergence from each other is put at ~7000 year ago (5000BC). While the total lack of evidence for "Phrygian immigrant" hypothesis could be bullied away by the academic mafia, the results of Gray and Atkinson cannot. And the faint genetic signal that has recently been found that diffuses from Anatolia westward, traced to around the same time as Gray & Atkinson's IE expansion is further proof. The Kurgan people may indeed have carried IE languages to new lands. But all indications are that they first learned it from the Anatolian farmers. Near East and Europe form one cultural unit, the former giving the latter its basic civilization. Separating the two is both artificial and conceptually un-economical. And yes, to the best of our current knowledge Armenians were basically indigenous to Asia Minor. Assimilating the occasional newcomers notwithstanding, they didn't immigrate from outside, except for the "Out-of-Africa" immigration shared by the rest of non-African humanity.
  3. Twilight Bark

    Armenian Tv

    How many billions does it take to dub foreign movies and their stupid soap operas? For a country with a big diaspora, it woudn't be an unjustifiable expense to make their TV look a bit more advanced than that of a 1970s banana republic. H1 is downright depressing to watch, except when they interview somebody interesting once in a blue moon. In addition to innumerable shorfalls in content, the sound quality is atrocious to boot. The only redeeming quality were the commercials, and now they are largely replaced by stupid ones geared for the American diaspora, when watched via satellite. Well, I know how to cheer myself up: it can only get better.
  4. I congratulate everyone on keeping your morale so high, and pretending that Armenians competing for other countries somehow contributes to "Armenian Success". When we were stateless, that was true enough. But now, it's meaningless. Except when I try to scrounge up some sort of "Armenian success" to show my little kids. But we are not little kids. Anyway, sorry for being a party-pooper. Can't avoid melancholic I guess.
  5. Phew. Glad to hear your family is alright. According to your description the guy is 100% at fault. Antsadz @lla.
  6. Yes Sasun, of course. I was just joking. In fact, I rarely read fiction, so I wouldn't be up to date on what's available, as I wouldn't be looking for it. But I am serious about the lack of translations for children's and young adults' literature, including pop-culture stuff. I think it is a pity.
  7. Forget about Armenian writers, I'll settle for Armenian translators. I would be ecstatic to find Harry Potter (or anything kids in the diaspora might think is cool) in Armenian.
  8. It's a reasonable speculation. It fits the known facts and names. That's all I can say.
  9. Here is some food for thought: * Anatolian (and Armenian) God Tarku (Tork, Torkom) * Indo-European expansion from Anatolia/Black Sea Basin --> Scythians adopt Indo-European language and elements of religion * Scythians meet and mix with proto-Turkic tribes * Armenian-Anatolian God name gets adopted by them --> Turk Full circle?
  10. Well, actually the direction in which the world culture is moving has little to do with what the governments want, "Atlantic", Eurasian, or otherwise. Governments everywhere seem content to have minimally thinking populations that are competent at linearly extrapolating in the direction that the government pushes them, but is basically too lazy or too dumb to think for themselves. However, the genie of liberalism (not in the silly sense of the American political lingo, but in the philosophical sense) is out of the bottle now, and it would take an extraordinary chain of events to put it back in. As for the existence of "different views on the human beings life in society", you seem to agree with me then that alternative views on such things can have enough legitimacy to survive and thrive alongside others. But fundamentally what I am saying has really little to do with "Western vs Russian vs Chinese" issues, even as examples. As for the practicality of the "Armenian way" in terms of evolutionary fitness, I submit that it cannot be wished away, and has to be dealt with as a given. Once one accepts that it is there to be dealt with, and cannot be dealt with by "pressure" (the country is very leaky, as everyone observes readily), the only remaining course of action is then to adapt and optimize the political system for that given. You are basically making the "wartime emergency" argument, implying that such niceties are for peace time, and Armenia being in a perpetual "wartime" footing, they are irrelevant for the forseeable future. In most general terms, the idea can be re-cast to imply that an "optimally fitting" system is bad in case of emergencies, and at wartime one needs a system that doesn't quite fit the culture of the populace. It is of course true that wartime requirements on the behavior of the people are quite different from those in peacetime. However, this does not mean that the political system needs to fit the populace any less during wartime. While conducting a war "by committee" would be disastrous, as the 1916-1920 amply demonstrated, that does not mean that a dictatorship or some other hamfisted form of pseudo-democracy is what's needed. The army itself is an inherently un-democratic institution, and it is necessarily so. In wartime, the army would hopefully be run by the most competent general (i.e. the relevant "leader" would be in charge of the relevant things), and would be a prominent figure as long as the war continues, but only about things that concern the army. "Leaders" would have a clear understanding of their sphere of authority. In any case, all this "war" talk is not really necessary because we are not in a "hot" war. Armenians are smart enough to get into the "war" mode when the writing is on the wall, and would not bicker about pension payments or Yerevan's architecture. Until then, there is no reason at all to excuse a poorly fitting form of government on the basis of "emergency". That would simply prevent the country from getting as strong as it would otherwise with better governance, leaving it ill-prepared when the "hot" war actually starts. And what I am suggesting as a better-fitting system is not "anarchy" at all. If I had to name it, it would be someting like "optimally-liberal direct-democracy", where "leaders" are leaders on the basis of their competencies rather than their self-declared or carefully-constructed image of being a super-patriotic, honest person who promises to be a most benign and lovable dictator with an equally trustworthy team of bureaucrats for the next 10 years. If one "given" is our reluctance fall in line behind a self-declared leader, the other, complementing "given" is that we make lousy leaders. Now that is not something to cherish or like, but it nevertheless needs to be "respected" (as in "face it") as a reality. There is something in our culture that prevents us from producing good leaders. Competent? Yes. "Leader type"? Yes, dime-a-dozen. True, inspiring leader? Rarely. Which perhaps explains our reluctance to follow leaders (the first "given"). After all, why follow the guy if the chances are he is not worth it? Therefore, counting on the emergence of an exceptional leader that is so good that he can overcome the traditional reluctance of the populace to trust its leaders is a poor plan. It is like counting on making a living by gambling in a casino, where you know that the odds are against you.
  11. Hi Axel, I suspect this is another case when we don't disagree as much as the surface implies, or don't disagree at all about the important aspects. In another thread having to do with "spirituality", you hit the nail on the head when you said something to the effect that any "spirituality" that focuses on "personal satisfaction" or some such is necessarily fake. And I agree with that. On a side note, I was taken aback to hear what the Pope wrote in his younger days about what life was about, and how similar it was to what I had arrived at through basically secular means and logical elimination of alternatives. There are other examples of wise and tolerant men of religion who focus on the issue self-centeredness as the main vice. Anyway, I want to make it clear that I don't differ much from you in terms of how much I like "individualism". But I like to think in logical, rather than religious terms, so bear with me. When I say we need to respect Armenian character, I mean it both pragmatically (because it is inevitable and not changeable in the short term by decree), and philosophically in the sense that it is not "bad" per se, but had the "bad" effect of preventing the formation of strong states because it was never in an environment that could be channeled properly. Empires, tyrannies, and pseudo-democracies (the mainstream of "democracy") that have "presidents" (elected kings) and a bunch of "government officials" (nobility) are not very compatible with the Armenian character, and those were the only choices until now. There is no reason not to adapt the mainstream to our character. When I regard freedom as the fundamental currency of human existence, I am not idealizing "do as you please". I am simply stating a fact. What masquarade as "wants", "needs", "benefits", "utility" etc. are nothing but various freedoms. In an old thread about good/evil that ArmenSarg had started I tried to express this thought as well. You and I wish to have the freedom to live in a society that is not composed of selfish, self-centered, superficial people. I certainly would feel claustrophobic and constrained in such an environment where people don't "get it". So my definition of freedom has little to do with "individualism" (as in advocating selfishness and self-centeredness), and is simply an acknowledgement that self-aware beings are so only to the extent that they are free to do things, and that they are not strictly predictable, even to themselves. A collection of such creatures naturally imposes a balancing act, which should allow maximum freedom compatible with order and "collective success" (or "evolutionary fitness"). Where the balance ends up depends on what those individuals value. And that value system would differ from culture to culture. There is no way not to "unleash" our nature. We can either give it the right environment designed to make it collectively productive, or we can go against it, and it shows up in myriad ugly ways among those who cannot escape the imposed restrictions (political dysfunction, corruption, insensitive and aloof government, apathy among the populace), or people simply escape it (emigration). There is nothing in what I am saying that advocates unrestrained selfishness.
  12. * The reasons for our historical lack of success in state creation may be less relevant today. Or more pointedly, our usual diagnosis as well as the oft-proposed "cures" may be wrong as well. Let's focus on the conditions and requirements of today. * Societies change very rarely by government fiat. Russian and Chinese governments are good examples of how resistant a culture is to the government "vision". Russians or other ex-soviets have not become happy-go-lucky selfless collective farmers. The entrepreneurial and materialistic Chinese culture appears remarkably intact after decades of extremely heavyhanded communist government. In any case, imposing an unnatural system of government simply forces people to emigrate (if they can; and these days they can). That happened in Ottoman times, and it is happening today. If you want to draw lessons from history, draw that lesson. * Equating coersion and state is not only tasteless. It is wrong. Or rather, there is no logical reason for it to remain true. The state shoud, and could, be the organized expression of the collective compromises individuals make in order to balance their freedoms, which form the fundamental currency of human existence. Exceeding the minimum necessary "compromise" (I guess that corresponds to the "coersion" bit in your terminology) is both evil and inefficient. I know I am not making a thorough, convincing case of the Q.E.D. kind here. But I want you to think out of the box. Your diagnosis and proposed "cure" has been proposed very often. And I question their accuracy. You simply cannot count on the emergence of "honest leaders" out of a system that does not fit the nature of Armenian culture.
  13. Good observations Boghos, above and your previous post. Reasoned and balanced as usual. Of course such traits make for boring reading; nothing to get one excited and outraged. I would like to point out, though, that we need not necessarily regard our "natural anarchism" and individualism as something to cure. The world civilization is headed in that direction, despite fits and starts, and the best efforts of governments to turn their populations into malleable automatons. I rather think it is something we need to respect. And by respect I mean having a form of democracy that allows such libertarian traits to be cultivated rather than get in the way. That is why the Armenian democracy needs to be as "direct" as possible, while minimizing "politics of personality". It would be a shame to somehow roll back the evolved Armenian psyche to conform to the stupid, personality driven (not to mention "cult of personality" kind found in banana republics) level of politics. What needs to be reformed is not how Armenians think. On the contrary, a political system that respects the national character and allows it to flourish needs to be instituted. In my opinion, the less "I am your leader" type politics, the better it will fit. And that basically means "direct democracy" of some sort, where a multitude of "leaders" (advocating alternative ways of action), depending on the subject of of discussion would emerge and fade to the background.
  14. The number 2 is obtained by assuming every couple had one ore more (including infinity) children. Any infertile couples would reduce the overall fertility rate below 2, in spite of the herculean efforts of some rare couples! Sorry.
  15. Oh, and the fertility rate would be 2 per couple on average, assuming that people can have an arbitrarily large numbers of children! But even then if we take into account non-fertile couples, the fertility rate would be less than two per couple, and the village would eventually disappear. But the last one standing would probably be female, given the longer life expectancy. So, even theoretically, the probable outcome is a devastated village, with 100% female population (of one). Probably not the intended result of the boy-loving population! There may be a more general lesson in there somewhere, and beyond the girl-boy issue.
  16. Your k is "number of girls", and my k is "number of children". In your case the sum should start from k=0 and should sum the term k/(2^(k+1)). And in my notation the girls' sum should start from k=1 and should sum the term (k-1)/(2^k). But in either case, the exponent of 2 should be one more than the factor in front of it. And both the boys' sum and girls' sum are 1, not 2. Right?
  17. I only have about a minute, so forgive me if I am off, but ... I think the sum should be of (k-1)/(2^k) rather than k/(2^k). And that would make the sum of girls 1 as well is my guess. So maybe Sasun's intuition was right. Cute problem. TB PS: Math and science is a good refuge when the "soft" issues start hurting your mind and heart.
  18. Just because language alone is insufficient does not mean that it is not a factor. It is an important factor. But it is only one of the factors, and it is neither absolutely necessary nor sufficient to push someone over the threshold of "being sufficiently Armenian".
  19. That is not true. There are two ways to "define" an Armenian, and both are alright in their domain of applicability. 1. Definition by the group If a majority of a representative sample of Armenians agree that you can be called an Armenian, you are Armenian. It doesn't matter how you feel. 2. Self-definition If you feel that you are Armenian, you are Armenian. The rest of the Armenians may not agree, but that's alright. If you are a citizen of the Republic itself, tough for "the rest". If you are not, the validity of you Armenianness is constrained into a universe of one. Tough for you, but that's alright as long as you don't mind being regarded as non-Armenian by other Armenians (whose Armenianness is subject to the same test as yours). In the context of this discussion it doesn't matter why one feels Armenian. It is sufficient to know that it is a consequence of being Armenian. I am criticizing your original linquistic conditions as well as your critique of "feeling Armenian" as a criterion. A Samoan does not wake up one fine morning and say "I am feeling Armenian today". Whatever it is that makes you "feel Armenian" most likely makes you recognizably Armenian to other Armenians (satisfying the 1st condition at the beginning of my post). Try to avoid nerdy "top-down" conditions and definitions, involving clumsy sets of rules, fractions, ifs, buts, exceptions, clauses, and a whole forest of little logical branches. Such devices should be used only as a last resort. And we are not anywhere near that in this subject.
  20. Hi Domino, I have zero time, so I'll be very brief for now, and hopefully write a bit more when I do have the time, as your "conditions" are not well thought-out. But I just want to point out that you are confusing "feeling" with "lying", "declaring", "saying", "claiming", "pretending", or some other similar action. You are not addressing this issue well at all. Perhaps you can re-start by thinking about what it would take to really feel Armenian. It is not a cause of belonging; it is the result. In any case, I do agree that keeping the language is very important. Other than that, I hope you would not get too upset if I liken the rest of your thoughts in this thread to the logical equivalent of a dadaist poem.
  21. Translated from "Historical Names in Turkey" (in Turkish) by Bilge Umar: Gergeme A village in the Bunyan borough of the Kayseri province. Its newly fabricated name is Doganlar [1]. It is at the northwest corner of Bunyan, and at the foothills of Korumaz Mountain. We see that, just as the origin of the name Korumaz is Kor-uma [3], that is Summit-people (in the period of Hellenization, the -s suffix was added to make it a masculine name, producing Korumas), the origin of the name Gergeme is Karkama, that is Kar-ka-(u)-ma [3], which means "Summit-place-people". See Kar, -ka, -uma. [3] Footnotes by TB: [1] Doganlar is pronounced Doghanlar [2] Bunyan is pronounced approximately as Biunyan [3] Luwian
  22. I shouldn't start down the road of pontificating in detail about what would or would not happen for all possible scenarios. But judging from the somewhat harrassed but physically intact Alevi population of Turkey, one could confidently say that any "acceptable" muslim sect would have escaped genocide (unless they didn't go along with the new "program"), and would have been processed by the assimilation machine set up by the republic, and made into nationalist "Turks". Glad you found them of value.
  23. To put it kindly, we are talking at different levels, and with different visions. In other words, we are talking about the same thing in different languages that are not one-to-one mappable by a simple dictionary. Now that must clarify things.
  24. Dear Domino, I think we are talking past each other. I'll leave it to the capable reader to get it.
×
×
  • Create New...