-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
Efkere.com History of Armenian Village
bellthecat replied to Jonathan Varjabedian's topic in History
Here is a similar site on a town in the same area: Gurun. http://perso.club-internet.fr/ddersark/index.html -
quote:Originally posted by Harut: from left to right: Raffi Michael Nalbandian Peshiktashlian Artsruni Ghevond Alishan Khrimian Hayrik Raphael Patkanian Nazarian Khachatur Abovian i hope you know who they are. Thank's Harut I have seen most of the names before, and know a little about a few of them. However, not one seems to have been mentioned in "Famous Armenians" before. So maybe someone who knows something about them in detail might post something. Another question - is the scene entirely imaginary? Are those depicted from different time periods, or countries? Could they all have been gathered together like this or is it an entirely symbolic painting? Note the symbolic "mother Armenia" figure to the left of the door and what looks like an idealised scene from Ani to the right. And Ararat at the top right.
-
Could you put names to the faces, lets say working left to right, numbering them 1 to 9. I was bidding for the card on ebay - it started at 10 dollars, but I had to drop out once it went above 30 dollars, 30 dollars just for a postcard is a bit much, no matter how important the Armenians are!
-
This is from an old postcard - I don't have a better scan to read the writing, but can anyone recognise the Armenians depicted (eg.: the guy at the right looks a bit like H. Abovian). Also, it is a painting rather than a photograph - has anyone seen the actual painting, or know anything about it? Steve http://virtualani.homestead.com/files/armenian_personalities.jpg
-
anti-Armenian propaganda that is being carried out in Azerba
bellthecat replied to MosJan's topic in Artsakh
quote:Originally posted by Juggernaut: Mind you, Russia has a rich history of forsaking its former allies to the wolves. Not as rich as America though - I think American embassies must all be designed with rooftop helicopter pads in preparation for the enevitable day that they will pack up, fold their flag and get on that final flight out. And look at Iraq and Afghanistan - both regimes set up with US support! First they build them up - then they bomb them flat (is it all a massive plot to provide the US army with combat training situations :-) ). -
Efkere.com History of Armenian Village
bellthecat replied to Jonathan Varjabedian's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Efkere: No, I went on my own. A little scarry, but I got to spend a fair amount of time looking for the villages I am most interested in. Thanks. I was just wondering, because he was there with a group in June '98. They did not get into the church (if I am remembering the video correctly) because the entrance was walled up or something. Did you? -
Efkere.com History of Armenian Village
bellthecat replied to Jonathan Varjabedian's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Efkere: Dear Vart: When I was in Efkere in 1998, I could not find it. Were you with Armen's 1998 tour of eastern Turkey? -
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Aaaaah. yeah, there are stories about ani. Lots. And also passages by Aram raffi if U want me to I can type them. Yes I want you to! Pleeeeze!!
-
quote:Originally posted by edward demian: Ancient Sassoon is on the Black Sea south of Georgia. You have some sort of unusual mental disorder, edward, one that affect your geographical orientation (and possibly your common sense as well).
-
London - Centre for Armenian Information & Advice - 15th
bellthecat replied to bellthecat's topic in Diaspora
I'm happy this was useful to you Kazza. I think the membership fee is something small - like £6 or £7. Although the letter began "dear member" I actually assumed that anyone who was interested could attend! So it's a good thing you phoned them to check. Hey - if you get to see their new library, tell me what sort of books they have there. -
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: I had also read the story on the Artist who built the castle for the daughter of the Arian King. She said he had to do it then she would marry him, than she married someone else So sad! And what happened to the Artist afterwards. In most of these type of stories it usually ends in his death, probably plunging from the building he created. The only happy ending story I have heard is one about the young architect of a palace in Isfahan, who built a secret entrance to the ruler's harem so that he could secretly visit his lover there. Unfortunately they were discovered eventually, and he ran up the stairs of the minaret, intending to throw himself off the top rather than suffer the tortures that the king would certainly inflict on him. But when falling from the minaret God took pity on him and gave him wings with which he flew to the Elbruz nountains, the land of his birth. Are there any stories about Ani (the city) in that book?
-
US Library of Congress - History of Armenia: Last Decade
bellthecat replied to MJ's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: It's that they didn't need to have an official border change. Just an "understanding" between the two countries that the Turkish military may get into the area for anti-rebel purposes. I don't think the Turkish military has EVER been able to have an "understanding" with any of its neighbours. Shoot (or invade) first - think about the consequences later. -
quote:Originally posted by edward demian: No turks in Sasoon? Well,go to Page 274(Part of Asiatic Turkey, Distribution of peoples" [Frontiers of Language and Nationality in Europe by Leon Dominian published by the American Geografical Society of New York by Holt and Company, 1917] and look at the foldout map following. Also, I'm speaking of the province of Sassoon not just the city. No water? Have you heard of the Black Sea? Sassoon borders on the Black Sea. If you examine the map, you will notice small Armenian areas hugging the seashore from the 32 parallel, 33.4, 35 to 36 parallels,(just northewst of Sassoon.)again at the 40th parrallel. Lets see you challenge that. ] What sort of crazy map are you looking at Edward? Sassoun (both town and district) is to the south of Moush, over the hills. It is many hundreds of miles from the Black sea. There were almost no Turks living in Sassoun in 1915, only a mixture of Armenian and Kurdish villages, and a large number of nomadic Kurds that lived almost like bandits.
-
Centre for Armenian Information & Advice (CAIA) Hayashen, 105a Mill Hill Road Acton, London W3 8JF Telephone 020 8992 4621 Fax 020 8993 8953 e-mail info@caia.org.uk website www.caia.org.uk Dear Member We are pleased to invite you to celebrate the 15th birthday of the CAIA in Hayashen on Sunday November 25th,2001 at 3pm. During the afternoon we will also be launching the new UK Armenian Directory and provide you with a progress report on the planned refurbishment of Hayashen. The Mayor of Ealing will be guest of honour and there will be free refreshments and buffet food. We look forward to seeing you. Misak Ohanian General Secretary - CAIA
-
quote:Originally posted by edward demian: Afterthe Turks collected and killed most of the adult Armenians and chilldren they found, they movedon. Soon,the crying of chilldren could be heard everywhere. The Turkish farmers collected these surviving chilldren but soon found themselves with thousands. They wrote a letter asking what to do with the chilldren. The authorities responded with clear instructions. The surviving chilldren of Sasoon were taken out in boats, their throats slit and dumped overboard for the sharks. Edward - what utter crap! Firstly there were no Turks in Sassoun. Secondly there are no lakes (or boats) there for children to be taken out in. Thirdly, be there lakes or no lakes, there are certainly no sharks in Anatolia (discounting the human variety). quote:Originally posted by edward demian: So I cannot but compare the accidental killing of a few Afghan chilldren to the purposeful killing of chilldren by Muslim fishermen If ever a few American children are "accidentally kiled" then I hope that one of them will be your child - maybe you will get some humanity and be able to feel what many parents in Afghanistan (or in the countless other places bombed by the USA) are now feeling.
-
US Library of Congress - History of Armenia: Last Decade
bellthecat replied to MJ's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: I am not an expert on the subject by any means. However, as far as I know, the area involved in the "swap" was tiny. A militarily meaningful area would have to be larger. I don't doubt that such a pretext was given by the Turkish government. After all, you don't say "We would like to have a pan-Turanic sphere of influence, so we can act like a superpower. Could you please get out of the way?". Moreover, an official annexation is not necessary for military operations against rebels. Turkey has been getting in and out of norhern Iraq for a long time for te same reason. There must have been more than military convenience involved. I propose that it was explicitly for obtaining a real border with Azerbaijan, as an investemnet into the future. Undoubtedly, declaring such an intent/context would not go over well with the Soviets. However, I concede that my perception of that strategic move may be wrong. The are involved might be small - but it was not unimportant. Saying that it was not militarily meaningful area is totally incorrect - why else would Turkey want a desolate hillside if it was not to their militery advantage. As for the border with Nakhijevan - although I do not have a 1920s map to hand to confirm it - I am reasonably certain that there already WAS a land border before the annexation of Iranian territory. The reason for the annexation (to secure the border against the uncontrolled entry/exit of Kurdish rebels) was specifically stated in the source I originally got this information from (an old issue of Asiatic Review, sorry - I forget the exact volume). -
US Library of Congress - History of Armenia: Last Decade
bellthecat replied to MJ's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: I am not an expert on the subject by any means. However, as far as I know, the area involved in the "swap" was tiny. A militarily meaningful area would have to be larger. I don't doubt that such a pretext was given by the Turkish government. After all, you don't say "We would like to have a pan-Turanic sphere of influence, so we can act like a superpower. Could you please get out of the way?". Moreover, an official annexation is not necessary for military operations against rebels. Turkey has been getting in and out of norhern Iraq for a long time for te same reason. There must have been more than military convenience involved. I propose that it was explicitly for obtaining a real border with Azerbaijan, as an investemnet into the future. Undoubtedly, declaring such an intent/context would not go over well with the Soviets. However, I concede that my perception of that strategic move may be wrong. -
US Library of Congress - History of Armenia: Last Decade
bellthecat replied to MJ's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: The little territorial swap between Turkey and Iran (during the republican era, I forget exactly when; but certainly before the Iranian revolution) allowed Turkey to have a short but important land border with the Nakhijevan part of Azerbaijan. At the time, it was a completely meaningless swap, because the Soviet border was the important entity, and not which so-called "republic" lied on the other side. [ November 19, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] This "land swap" was not meaningless and had nothing to do with Armenia or the USSR. It happened during the 1930s. Turkey was having trouble putting down a Kurdish rebellion in eastern Turkey, centered on the Ararat region. Turkish soldiers found it imposible to capture the Kurdish rebels because they would simply move to the upper levels of mount Ararat and then easily travel eastwards into Iran (since the mountainous countryside was too wild and remote to guard). To plug the gap Turkey demanded that all the base of little Ararat be incorporated into Turkey, Iran agreed simply because the country was too weak to resist. I was not aware that Iran got anything in return - so the word "swap" might not be an accurate word to use! -
A sham - "something that is not what it purports to be". 100% true in this case. However Pilger's definition of it is a fraud is a little more accurate: "a deliberate deception, trickery, or cheat, intended to gain an advantage". But what advantage? I think Bush and Blair have been reading their history books. The events since september 11th mirror very closely the events in Berlin during 1933, The burning of the Reichstag building (as symbolic to Germany as the twin Towers were to America) in 1933 by Communist "fundamentalists" was used by Hitler as an excuse to massively increase his dictatorial powers and to introduce repressive laws that marked the end of Germany as a democracy. Bush and Blair are now doing the same. Who knows what horrors they are planning for the future. Have you heard that the US government is buying up the rights to images of the aftermath of US bombing raids in Afgahnistan. This is to prevent their publication in America - a deviously elegant way of using the free-market to introduce state censorship into a country that in theory does not permit it. I wonder if the likes of MJ have seen in American media pictures like that row dead children in the cited news report? (Or do Americans get off on looking at pictures of children they have murdered).
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: [QB]
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: And no that's not her real hair! How d'ya know? (Maybe the next question should be - is that her real voice on her latest song? To be honest, with all the electronic distortion, it could be anybodys!) Thanks for the comments about the website.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: you do not live in a country where you experience everyday terror. i do. if in my country you stop buses, ask for "visas" to kurdistan, kill turkish civilians, poison city water mains, explode bombs in shopping malls, kill teachers in front of their wives, scalp the heads of my soldiers and PUT THEM ON and take pictures with them (have you seen these pictures? i have, and not in govt propaganda channels), kill two year old kurdish babies in their cradles, then i chase you to the ends of the earth, and when i get you (there is no if, i will get you), i do as i please with your head. and if people cannot accept this, they should first turn around and look at themselves and not support such organisations in the first place. the pkk had semi-official status in almost all of the eu until it turned around to shooting germans. if i am going to be called a barbarian for that, so be it. i couldn't care less. Ali - you do not live in a city where you experience everyday terror - you live in Istanbul. If you want to experience everyday terror I think you should be living is Bingol or Mus or similar places! You seem to be saying that just because one side commits atrocities it is OK for "your" side to do it. But all you are doing is pouring more fuel on the fire. I suspect a lot of people here will see direct parallels with this photo and similar photos taken during the Armenian genocide. I wonder - would you like to live next to those soldiers, would you like your daughter to marry one? Your views are not barbarian - they are just rather thoughtless.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: The restoration of the Pagan Temple of Garni was rumored to be influenced by some "powerful circles," who wanted to restore a Pagan Temple in the heart of Armenia. I don't know who these "circles" where (allegedly). At the risk of contradicting myself, I think the case of Garni's reconstruction was probably OK - or at least the good equalled the harm, because it was (before reconstruction) just like a huge jigsaw puzzle. Most of the bits were there and it was just a matter of rebuilding them in the right places. But I suspect a lot of the atmosphere of the place was lost - remember the character in Egoyan's film "Calendar" describing it as looking like a bank!
-
PRESS RELEASE Art Poster Campaign for the recognition of Arm
bellthecat replied to 15levels's topic in News Feed
quote: According to UNESCO information for 1974, 464 of 913 Armenian buildings were wipe off the earth, 252 - ruined, 197 needs general repair. This "information" comes (I think) from a book published in 1974 from the self-styled "Permanent Peoples Tribunal". Exactly what their connection to UNESCO was is never made clear. In the book, where they got these figures from is also unclear, however the figures given ARE just pulled from the air - nobody had visited any of the allegedly destroyed or allegedly still surviving monuments. quote: As for Azerbaijan, 21 Armenian buildings, among which churches, monasteries, chapels, Armenian cemeteries were destroyed and burned since 1998. Why "since 1998". do they actually mean "since 1988"? And if they do the figure seems surprisingly small. In Nakhichevan destruction of 800 khachkars (stone crosses) and 250 monasteries was prevented. quote: Oh really? And how do they know destruction was prevented - again, no-one has gone to see! I would not be surprised to learn that every one has been destroyed. And has anyone ever seen credible documentation about the alleged Khatchkar destruction (I presune they are talking about the Julfa cemetery). Are Armenians incapable of using cameras, or not understanding the concept of "before and after" pictures. The whole graveyard is clearly visible from Iran. It all backs up my belief that they are not seriously interested in preserving anything - but are just using the subject as one more thing to attack the Turks/Azeris with. -
Here are some pictures of the palace, just after the "restoration" - taken last year. I do not have overall views because it started to rain. An ugly roof was put over the surviving part of the palace (which is not even the original upper floor level). To support this roof most of the original upper sections of the walls were demolished and rebuilt using new stone - the photos show the two huge piles of demolished masonry that were part of the original walls until the restoration - notice all the sculptural fragments. Maybe Thornt will know if these piles of stone are still there (I doubt it - they are probably underneath a new road, or buried in a hole somewhere). http://virtualani.homestead.com/files/db1.jpg http://virtualani.homestead.com/files/db2.jpg http://virtualani.homestead.com/files/db3.jpg http://virtualani.homestead.com/files/db4.jpg
