axel
Members-
Posts
389 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by axel
-
It seems these "books" you mention disregarded the work of Lapide. Yes, I do disregard propaganda and no, not "just because someone contradicts it".
-
where did you get that from? http://armenians.com/forum/index.php?showt...indpost&p=22800
-
This statement is utterly false, as far as Christianity is concerned. Inasmuch as the earthly and visible Church is not the fullness and completeness of the whole Church which the Lord has appointed to appear at the final judgment of all creation, she acts and knows only within her own limits; and (according to the words of Paul the Apostle, to the Corinthians, 1 Cor. 5. 12) does not judge the rest of mankind, and only looks upon those as excluded, that is to say, not belonging to her, who exclude themselves. The rest of mankind, whether alien from the Church, or united to her by ties which God has not willed to reveal to her, she leaves to the judgment of the great day. The Church on earth judges for herself only, according to the grace of the Spirit, and the freedom granted her through Christ, inviting also the rest of mankind to the unity and adoption of God in Christ; but upon those who do not hear her appeal she pronounces no sentence, knowing the command of her Saviour and Head, not to judge another man's servant (Rom. 14. 4). (The Church is one)
-
http://www.retroweb.com/prisoner.html
-
I think this statement could safely be generalized.
-
Well Arpa, I wonder where you actually stand. In fact, your position seems quite paradoxical to me. You accuse christianity of fostering slavishness, while it doesn't, yet you seem to show some complacency towards other sectarian groups that do (evangelists, mormons, jehovah's witnesses...).
-
Btw, does anyone know of a translation of Eznik? http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/~aua/texts/ezn.../elts_aghandots
-
One has to make a distinction between the invisible Church and the visible one (which happens to be a national institution). Belonging to Orthodoxy is belonging to the former, not to the latter. Your attack with regard to the human institution is therefore irrelevant in the context of this discussion. Maybe the following text will help you see things from a non-secular viewpoint: http://www.westernorthodox.com/khomiakov (I don't endorse the site btw, I haven't looked at it) That said, what is the need for other so-called "christian" religious groups to operate in Armenia? Their very presence on our soil indicates that they do not consider the Armenian Church as truly christian or do they? If they do, what is their purpose then, sowing the seeds of further divisions? If they don't and are true christians themselves, why don't they say so and speak the truth as true followers of Christ instead of behaving hypocritically as they do? The truth is their attitude does not stem from truly christian considerations.
-
I question anonymouse's actual intents in posting these extremely manipulative texts. (Manipulation is the actual word for the reader is implicitly flattered through this "initiation" process and thereby loses all capacity of judgement, absorbing the lies that have "subtly" been inserted here and there). Is he "simply unaware of what he is really involved in" or does he belong to "the higher initiates who are known as the 'adepts' or the 'keepers of the secrets of all ages' who are aware of the real agenda"?
-
isn't the selective uncovering of the "conspiracy" itself part of the "conspiracy"?
-
Very true, as far as I am concerned, my english writing "budget" has been shrinking to a point it takes me almost ten minutes to write a single line (at 24, I do fear premature mental sclerosis) so that I am completely submerged by anonymouse's logorrheic posts
-
fungible (from fungus?) I understand it as twistable. Really imagé. I like the word.
-
You are twisting things up. When I mentionned imperialism or aggressiveness, I was refering to the expansionist character of certain nations and their attempt at subjugating others. Please spare us your francophobia My ideas are not overly popular here in France btw. as for my mentality, it doesn't have much to do with that of froggies.
-
The european union is an abstract construct which is not concerned with identities. It is just a step towards the establishement of the world state. The "new world order" rests upon the destruction of national identities and traditional cultures.
-
Could you give us a historical example? The feudal system was itself based on a form of "social contract". Peasants accepted the sovereignty of a lord in return for protection. Implicit contracts existed in early societies too.
-
Yet another example of your not reading my response! I am not saying here anarchy is not intrinsic to human activity. I do not know. But the "anarchy is natural" argument for justifying "anarchy" (and here is where you use the "fungibility" of the word to push forward a particular system ie anarcho-capitalism) is simply invalid. One may argue that everything that exists is "natural" so that the "State" itself is. My argument is metahistorical. It seems to me you mix metahistory with history which is why you do not get my point. You are too much influenced by western thought and ideas, by the very enlightenment mindset you pretend to reject. You do not understand my ideas for you judge them according to a framework they do not fit in. You made an allusion to the "nationalism" thread. Well I thought TB's counter-arguments would have convinced you of the inanity of your "treaty". I am not an ideologist btw. In fact, I've already said on this board that "the end doesn't justify the means". I am rational but I am not rationalistic. I do not have faith in "Reason". The atrocities of the twentieth centuries are not to be related with the "state" (that is too superficial an analysis) but with the triumph of ideologies based upon the belief that "Reason" should organize society. Well Man does not fit into all these systems or rational frameworks, Man is too large (I would advise you to read Dostoevsky). The pretention of reason to organize society which is the essence of enlightenment thought, this very pretention I somewhat find in your thought. I am not a partisan of the impersonal state or of democracy.I thought you would have understood from my prior posts. Or maybe you have and pretend not to, which is more likely, for you do not seem to be dumb.
-
sorry for the gallicisms ("aggressive" in french takes only one "g"), english is not my native tongue. I do agree with gamavor.
-
By virile I do not mean imperial or agressive. I mean aristocratic in opposition to bourgeois, disdainful of earthly matters. Christianism is a liberation from the slavery of ego and matter. Such liberation requires great spiritual strength, heroism, I would say. A People that has developed such force through faith is infinitely superior to others. It is resilient to all changes, to all epochs, it stays aloft above the tide of history to find its way into Eternity. PS: Russians? they survived the tatar invasions, they repelled the teutonic knights, they defeated Napoleon and Hitler. true, they fell prey to bolshevism but among the reasons why is the fact a large portion of their intelligentsia had gone away from Orthodoxy and espoused western thought. if Russians take the path of Orthodoxy, they will they resurrect. Otherwise they will vanish in the globalized cattle both anarcho-capitalism and socialism are engineered to produce.
-
I don't know what your intention was with this little off topic deviation into the realm of making things fungible with relation to the discussion of the State and Anarchy. Well I made it explicit. Maybe you should have read my post in the firstplace. I will not engage further into this debate. There is nothing new in your dissertation, you are just rehashing the same propaganda like an automaton. Having no valid counter-arguments you write a 3-page message (which is not a response to mine although it appears to be) in order to drown the reader into an ocean of sophisms. If anarchy is intrinsic to human activity as has been claimed in an early post, then why spend so much time discussing it? If it is a fact, a tautology, it is not worth debating. Do we engage in endless discussions over the fact we have two legs instead of three? The fact is you first state the obvious and then narrow the theory down and using the very "fungibility" of words, manage to substitute another reality for the one you first presented. This is precisely the way Mises proceeds. He first attempts to present his theory in the most general framework so that one may not reject and then pharisaically modifies the semantics behind the words so as to push a specific agenda and put forward specific beliefs. Why is it that this one-size-fits-all category you call "the state" exists? why did it appear? what could prevent it from appearing ore reappearing if ever it is destroyed? One might argue nothing is artificial. All proceeds from man's nature. Chaos as well as Order. The rise of "monopolies of authority and coercion" and their fall. One may say all of this is inexorable or cyclic. I wonder whether your real intent is to promote "anarcho-capitalism" in the US (this system doesn't seem to have greatly benefited Russia over the last ten years or so, has it?) or rather to confuse people with "fungible" and nonsensical ideas.
-
And the actual response was: "You, Turkish shaitan [satan], cursed devil's brother, companion and secretary of Lucifer himself; like hell you are a knight! Satan voids and your army devours. Never will you be able to subjugate the sons of Christ! We have no dread of your army and intend to fight you by land and sea. A Babylonian cook you are, a Macedonian wheelwright, a Jerusalem brewer, a goat-thrasher of Alexandria, a swineherd of Greater and Lesser Egypt, an Armenian pig, a Tatar goat. You, butcher of Kamianets and villain of Podillia [alluding to the forays by the Turks and Tatars into the Podillia region of Ukraine for captives], grandson of the devil and bafoon of the whole world and nether world ... This is how the Kozaks have answered you, the basest born of runts! Unfit are you to lord it over true Christians! The date is unknown for the lack of a calendar, the moon [month] is in the sky, the year is in a book, and the day here is the same as there and you can kiss us you know where. [signed] Kozak Kish Otaman Ivan Sirko and all the Zaporozhian Army."
-
http://www.wooop.de/Bilder/norm/mwm08348.jpg Ilya Repin. The Reply of the Zaporozhian Cossacks to Sultan Mahmoud IV. 1880-1891. Oil on canvas. The Russian Museum, St. Petersburg, Russia. Are Zaporog Cossacks to be related with Turks???!!!
